KRISHANU DECEASED THROUGH LR'S GEETA AND OTHERS vs ROOP DEV DECEASED THROUGH LR JAMNA DEVI AND OTHERS I
- Court
- High Court of Himachal Pradesh
2026:HHC:42216
High Court of H.P.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF HIMACHAL PRADESH, SHIMLA
RSA No. : 508 of 2004
Reserved on : 14.08.2026
Decided on : 30.09.2026
Uploaded on : 30.09.2026
Krishnu @ Krishan Chand (deceased) through LRs.
…Appellants
Versus
Roop Dev (deceased) through LRs.
…Respondents
Coram
The Hon’ble Mr. Justice Virender Singh, Judge.
1
Whether approved for reporting? Yes.
For the appellants : Mr. Sanjeev Kuthiala, Senior
Advocate, with Ms. Tamanna
Sharma and Ms. Preeti Thakur,
Advocates.
For the respondents : Mr. Jai Lal Thakur, Advocate, vice
Mr. G.R. Palsra, Advocate.
__________________________________________________________
Virender Singh, Judge
Appellants have preferred the present Regular
Second Appeal, under Section 100 of the Code of Civil
1
Whether Reporters of local papers may be allowed to see the judgment? Yes.
::: Downloaded on - 30/09/2026 16:33:19 :::CIS
2 2026:HHC:42216
High Court of H.P.
Procedure (hereinafter referred to as the ‘CPC’), against the
judgment and decree dated 01.10.2004, passed by the
Court of learned Presiding Officer, Fast Track Court,
Mandi, District Mandi, H.P. (hereinafter referred to as the
‘learned First Appellate Court’), in Civil Appeal No.
112/2002, 77/2004, titled as ‘Roop Dev & Anr. Vs
Krishanu’.
2. By way of judgment and decree dated
01.10.2004, the learned First Appellate Court has allowed
the appeal preferred by the respondents. The respondents
had filed the above first appeal against the judgment and
decree dated 29.06.2002, passed by the Court of learned
Sub Judge First Class, Court No. 3 Mandi, District Mandi,
H.P. (hereinafter referred to as the ‘learned trial Court’) in
Civil Suit No. 161/2000 (93), titled as ‘Krishanu Vs Rup
Dev & Anr.’.
3. Vide judgment and decree dated 29.06.2002,
the learned trial Court has decreed the suit of the
predecessorininterest of the present appellants, by
granting the following relief:
::: Downloaded on - 30/09/2026 16:33:19 :::CIS
3 2026:HHC:42216
High Court of H.P.
“32. In view of my discussions made above while
determining Issues No. 1 to 8 since issue No. 8 has been
decided against the defendant and issue No. 1 and 2
have been decided in favour of the plaintiff, suit of the
plaintiff is decreed and defendants are restrained through
decree of permanent prohibitory injunction to cause any
sort of interference over the suit land. However, in the
peculiar facts and circumstances of the case the parties to
the suit are left to bear cost of the suit on their own.
Decree sheet be prepared accordingly. File after
completion be consigned to the record room.”
4. For the sake of convenience, the parties to the
present lis are, hereinafter referred to, in the same manner,
as were, referred to, by the learned trial Court.
5. Brief facts, leading to the filing of the present
appeal before this Court, as borne out from the record,
may be summed up, as under:
5.1. PlaintiffKrishanu has filed a suit for permanent
prohibitory injunction against the defendants, on the
ground that the land bearing Khata Khatauni No.
3min/4min, Khasra No. 243, measuring 031808 bighas,
situated in Mauja Fatewahan, Illaqua Tungal, Tehsil Sadar,
District Mandi, H.P. (hereinafter referred to as the ‘suit
land’), is owned and possessed by him. In this regard, he
has relied upon the copy of jamabandi for the year 1990
91.
::: Downloaded on - 30/09/2026 16:33:19 :::CIS
4 2026:HHC:42216
High Court of H.P.
5.2 It is the case of the plaintiff that the defendants
without any right, title or interest, started causing
interference over the suit land and also tried to tresspass
the suit land. Despite repeated requests of the plaintiff,
defendants have not resisted and finally refused to accept
the prayer of the plaintiff on 24.06.1993.
5.3 On the basis of above facts, the relief of
injunction has been sought.
6. When put to notice, suit has been contested by
the defendants by filing the written statement, in which,
they have taken the preliminary objections that the suit is
not maintainable and the plaintiff is estopped by his acts
and conduct from filing the present suit.
6.1 The claim of the plaintiff, qua ownership and
possession over the suit land, has been admitted. However,
according to the defendants, they have not committed
tresspass over the suit land and they are also not
destroying the crops, as alleged. According to them,
Khasra No. 243 was part of old Khasra No. 347 measuring
091110 bighas. Land was in the joint ownership and
::: Downloaded on - 30/09/2026 16:33:19 :::CIS
5 2026:HHC:42216
High Court of H.P.
possession of the parties to the lis. In this regard, they
had relied upon the copy of jamabandi for the year 1985
86. During the consolidation proceedings, the land in
question along with other land of the parties, has been
partitioned and the land comprising Khasra No. 243 (suit
land) was allotted to the plaintiff. However, there was a
path on Khasra No. 243, which is 4 feet wide and is
existing on the spot for the last more than 60 years. This
path starts from the house of the defendants, after passing
through Khasra No. 244 and thereafter the path is existing
over Khasra No. 243 (suit land), and then, the same
connects the house of the plaintiff with main road i.e.
MandiKotli road. In this regard, the spot map prepared by
them, has also been relied upon by them. The said path is
stated to be the only ingress and outgress for the house of
the defendants and they are using this path continuously
for last more than 30 years, as a matter of right. Without
this path, the defendants could not approach their house
and other property. According to them, there is easement
of necessity in their favour.
::: Downloaded on - 30/09/2026 16:33:19 :::CIS
6 2026:HHC:42216
High Court of H.P.
6.2 It is the further case of the defendants that it is
the plaintiff, who had started causing obstruction in the
user of the path, in the month of June, 1993. Thereafter,
the application was moved to the police on 22.06.1993.
Matter was compromised in the presence of respectable
persons of the locality, in which, the plaintiff has admitted
the right of the defendants and agreed not to obstruct the
path in future. On the basis of said undertaking, the
police proceedings were dropped. Thereafter, the plaintiff
had filed the present suit.
6.3 As such, a prayer has been made to dismiss the
suit.
7. Plaintiff filed the replication, denying the
preliminary objections, as well as, the contents qua
existence of any path through Khasra No. 243, as alleged.
In addition to this, the stand taken by the defendants qua
easementary right of path over the suit land has also been
disputed. According to them, there is a main path, which
is nearby to the suit land and this path is used by the
defendants, as well as, the other villagers, whose houses
::: Downloaded on - 30/09/2026 16:33:19 :::CIS
7 2026:HHC:42216
High Court of H.P.
are situated nearby the house of the defendants and the
Panchayat has also repaired the said path, but the
defendants with a malafide intention and just to destroy
and damage the crops of the plaintiff, want to create the
path through the land of the plaintiff.
8. From the pleadings of the parties, following
issues were framed, by the learned trial Court, vide order
dated 12.01.1995:
“1. Whether there exists a path over the suit
land and the path is being enjoyed by the
defendants since long, as alleged, if so, its
effect? OPP
2. Relief.
9. After framing of the issues, parties to the
lis
were directed to adduce evidence.
10. Thereafter, the suit of the plaintiff was decreed,
vide judgment and decree dated 01.07.1996. However, the
case was remanded back by the learned District Judge,
and following issues were framed on 31.07.2000:
1. Whether the defendants are causing interference
in the ownership and possession of the plaintiff
over the suit land, as alleged? OPP
::: Downloaded on - 30/09/2026 16:33:19 :::CIS
8 2026:HHC:42216
High Court of H.P.
2. If issue No. 1 is proved, whether the plaintiff is
entitled for decree of permanent prohibitory
injunction, as prayed for? OPP
3. Whether the suit is not maintainable and
sustainable in the present form? OPD
4. Whether the plaintiff is estopped by his act and
conduct from filing the present suit? OPD
5. Whether no cause of action has accrued to the
plaintiff to file the present suit? OPD
6. Whether the court has no jurisdiction to try the
suit? OPD
7. Whether the suit is not properly valued for the
purpose of court fee and jurisdiction? OPD
8. Whether defendants are enjoying path through
Khasra No. 243 as a matter of right and as an
easement of necessity, as alleged? OPD
9. Relief.
11. Thereafter, the parties were directed to adduce
evidence.
12. After closure of the evidence and upon hearing
learned counsel for the parties, the learned trial Court has
decreed the suit of the plaintiff, vide judgment and decree
dated 29.06.2002.
13. Said findings have been assailed by the
defendants, by way of first appeal before the learned first
appellate Court. The learned first appellate Court, vide
::: Downloaded on - 30/09/2026 16:33:19 :::CIS
9 2026:HHC:42216
High Court of H.P.
judgment and decree dated 01.10.2004, set aside the
judgment and decree dated 29.06.2002, passed by the
learned trial Court and the suit of the plaintiff has been
ordered to be dismissed.
14. Feeling aggrieved from the said judgment and
decree, present Regular Second Appeal has been filed by
the plaintiff, before this Court, on the ground that the
learned first appellate Court has misread and
misappreciated the pleadings and evidence. The
documents Ext. PW3/A and Ext. DA, have been misread.
15. Findings of the learned first appellate Court
have been assailed on the ground that the learned first
appellate Court has wrongly discarded the findings of
learned trial Court qua the fact that it has been proved
that there is alternative path maintained by the Panchayat.
16. While allowing the appeal, according to the
appellants, learned first appellate Court has not considered
the provisions of Sections 13, 15 and 47 to 51 of the
Easement Act.
::: Downloaded on - 30/09/2026 16:33:19 :::CIS
10 2026:HHC:42216
High Court of H.P.
17. According to the appellants, the alleged
compromise has wrongly been relied upon by the learned
first appellate Court.
18. On the basis of above facts, Mr. Sanjeev
Kuthiala, Senior Advocate, assisted by Ms. Tamanna
Sharma and Ms. Preeti Thakur, Advocates, has prayed that
the appeal may kindly be allowed by setting aside the
judgment and decree passed by the learned first appellate
Court and suit may kindly be decreed, by restoring the
judgment and decree passed by learned trial Court.
19. Per contra, Mr. Jai Lal Thakur, Advocate, vice
Mr. G.R. Palsra, Advocate, for the respondents, has prayed
that the learned first appellate Court has rightly
appreciated the documentary, as well as, the oral evidence
and rightly dismissed the suit of the plaintiffs. As such, a
prayer has been made to dismiss the present appeal.
20. The present appeal has been admitted, by this
Court, on 02.12.2004, on the following substantial
questions of law:
“1. Whether the findings of the learned first
Appellate Court, holding that the defendant
::: Downloaded on - 30/09/2026 16:33:19 :::CIS
11 2026:HHC:42216
High Court of H.P.
has right of passage over the land of the
plaintiff as of necessity, is dehors the
pleadings and evidence on record?
2. Whether the learned first Appellate Court
could have based his findings regarding the
right of passage by the defendant over the
land of the plaintiff on a compromise by the
police?”
21. In order to decide the above substantial
questions of law, it would be just and appropriate for this
Court to discuss the oral, as well as, the documentary
evidence led by the parties, before the learned trial Court.
22. After framing of the issues, the plaintiff
appeared in the witnesses as PW1 and deposed on the
lines of his pleadings, as contained in the plaint. In the
crossexamination, he has admitted that earlier the
holdings of plaintiff and defendants were joint. Till the
holdings were joint, defendants were forcibly using the
passage, in order to reach their home, whereas, they are
having the passage upto their home. Well was also there
on the said passage. The Well was dug by the villagers and
the father of the defendants had also done voluntary
contribution of physical labour. He has denied the
suggestion that defendants were using the passage for the
::: Downloaded on - 30/09/2026 16:33:19 :::CIS
12 2026:HHC:42216
High Court of H.P.
last 3040 years. He denied that in the month of June,
1993, when he has raised the obstruction, the matter was
reported to the police, where he was called to the Police
Station. According to him, his signature over Ext. DA,
were obtained by putting force upon him. He has denied
that in the document Ext. DA, he has given undertaking
that he will not interfere with the passage. Rest, he has
denied all the suggestions, which, were put to him, by
learned counsel for the defendants.
23. PW2 Damodar, has deposed that there is no
passage over the suit land. Defendants are having the
passage, leading to their home from the main road. The
said passage is in the government land. This person is
having 9½ bighas holding in the village. His ancestors had
purchased 35 bighas, about 50 years ago. His house is
constructed half kilometer away from the land in dispute.
He purchased 9½ bigha in the year 198081. Near the
house of the defendants, there is a waterbouri, which is
being used by the villagers for fetching the water. He
::: Downloaded on - 30/09/2026 16:33:19 :::CIS
13 2026:HHC:42216
High Court of H.P.
denied all the suggestions that the plaintiff has raised
obstruction in the said passage.
24. The plaintiff has examined the Local
Commissioner, Lalit Kumar, Advocate as PW3, who
deposed that he visited the spot on 01.08.1993, in the
presence of parties, as well as, their respective counsel and
thereafter, submitted his report Ext. PW3/A. He has
specifically deposed in the crossexamination that from the
road, there are two passages existing on the spot, one is
motorable and other is pedestrian path. Rest of the
suggestions, he has denied.
25. To rebut this evidence, the defendants have
examined, as many as, six witnesses. DW1 is defendant
No. 1Roop Dev, who has deposed that consolidation
proceedings had taken place in their village in the year
199091 and land was partitioned between the parties to
the lis. The passage leading to his house is situated in the
suit land and they are also using the said passage for
fetching the water. According to him, except the said
passage, there is no passage for leading to their house.
::: Downloaded on - 30/09/2026 16:33:19 :::CIS
14 2026:HHC:42216
High Court of H.P.
Width of the passage is 4 ft., as shown in the spot map,
which he has prepared. In the month of June, 1993, the
plaintiff has started obstruction in the said passage, who
visited the spot and thereafter, the passage was restored.
In this regard, he has relied upon the compromise Mark X.
This witness is having the water connection in his resident,
but according to him, there is obstruction in water supply,
in case, any damage caused to the pumping machine or in
the failure of the power. The distance between the houses
of the parties to the lis is about 1km. The road is situated
at a distance of about 1km, from his house. The passage
has been built by Panchayat. The compromise had taken
place in the presence of the police.
26. DW3 Bhup Singh, also supported the case of
the defendants, by asserting on the stand as taken by the
defendant. In addition to this, he deposed that when
dispute arose between the parties, police visited the spot,
however, when the police left the spot, the plaintiff has
agreed to provide the passage, vide compromise Ext. DA,
which bears his signature. In the crossexamination, he
::: Downloaded on - 30/09/2026 16:33:19 :::CIS
15 2026:HHC:42216
High Court of H.P.
has admitted that the police had also apprised the plaintiff
to compromise the matter, as the same would be in his
favour. However, the plaintiff was not threatened to face
the future course of action, if he fails to compromise the
matter. He has admitted the existence of the main road,
which, is being maintained by the Panchayat, but
voluntarily stated that the said passage is only up to the
house of the plaintiff. Distance between the house of the
plaintiff from the house of defendants is about 250 meters.
He has also admitted that between the two houses, there is
a passage, which, is being used by pet animals. He has
also admitted that he has seen the denfendant using the
passage, built/maintained by Panchayat.
27. DW4 Padam Singh, also supported the case of
the defendants, but admitted the existence of the main
passage from the bus stoppage on the main road, but
stated that the same is not up to the house of the
defendants, but up to the house of the plaintiff. Existence
of said passage is not disputed and he also admitted that
said passage was being maintained by Panchayat.
::: Downloaded on - 30/09/2026 16:33:19 :::CIS
16 2026:HHC:42216
High Court of H.P.
28. DW5 Hukam Chand, also deposed in his
examinationinchief as per the stand taken by the
defendants, in the written statement. He has also deposed
that except the said passage, there is no other passage.
However, he could not disclose about the Khasra number
of the said land, but, admitted that a link road is there
from main road to the house of Brij Lal. The said road has
been constructed by the Panchayat.
29. DW6 Dharam Chand also deposed on the
similar lines.
30. Apart from this evidence, the learned trial
Court, in the present case, has also appointed a Local
Commissioner. The report of Local Commissioner is Ext.
PW3/A.
31. The learned trial Court has decreed the suit,
whereas, the learned first appellate Court has set aside the
said judgment, on the basis of the compromise Ext. DA.
This document is a vague document, as the same does not
contain any description of the land or passage, about
which, the dispute has arisen, between the parties.
::: Downloaded on - 30/09/2026 16:33:19 :::CIS
17 2026:HHC:42216
High Court of H.P.
32. Moreover, the defendants are claiming the
passage on the ground of their easementary right based
upon the fact that he was having no other passage,
whereas, the essential ingredients of seeking the relief on
the basis of easement of necessity are not there in the
pleadings. The spot map relied upon by the defendants
does not depict the true picture of the said document, as
well as, the evidence of defendants is too short to hold that
the defendants are not having any other passage except the
same, which is allegedly existing over the suit land. No
counter claim seeking the declaration of the passage on the
easement of necessity has been filed by the defendants and
when from the report of Local Commissioner, it has been
probablized that there are two passages, one is motorable
and other is pedestrian, then, the plea of the defendants
that they are having only one passage, is not sustainable in
the eyes of law. The learned first appellate Court has given
undue weightage to the compromise Ext. DA, which is too
short to connect the said document with the passage,
::: Downloaded on - 30/09/2026 16:33:19 :::CIS
18 2026:HHC:42216
High Court of H.P.
which is admittedly existing over the land owned and
possessed by the plaintiff.
33. The well reasoned judgment passed by the
learned trial Court has wrongly been interfered with, by the
learned first appellate Court, as despite lengthy cross
examination, nothing material could be elicited from the
crossexamination of Local Commissioner, who has
categorically stated about the existence of two passages on
the spot. The learned first appellate Court has also ignored
the admission made by the defendants’ witnesses, in
which, they have admitted that the motorable passage was
being maintained by the Panchayat. When, the defendants
are not able to plead and prove the essentials of
easementary right over the suit land, then, the learned first
appellate Court has fallen into error by interfering with the
well reasoned judgment passed by the learned trial Court.
34. Consequently, both the substantial questions of
law are decided in favour of the plaintiff by setting aside
the judgment and decree passed by the learned first
appellate Court. The judgment and decree passed by
::: Downloaded on - 30/09/2026 16:33:19 :::CIS
19 2026:HHC:42216
High Court of H.P.
learned trial Court is ordered to be restored, by decreeing
the suit, as prayed for.
35. Accordingly, the appeal is allowed, in the above
said terms. Decree sheet be prepared.
36. Pending application(s), if any, shall also stands
disposed of.
37. Record be sent back.
( Virender Singh )
Judge
th
30 September, 2026
(Pramod Kumar)
::: Downloaded on - 30/09/2026 16:33:19 :::CIS