Zaki Ullah Khan vs State Of U.P.And Ors.

Court
Supreme Court

1
2026 INSC 827
(REPORTABLE)
IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA
CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION
CIVIL APPEAL No.2412/2011
ZAKI ULLAH KHAN Appellant(s)
VERSUS
STATE OF U.P. AND ORS. Respondent(s)
O R D E R
1. The issue raised in this Appeal is
whether the deed in question by which,
fishing rights were settled in favour of
the appellant for rearing fishes from the
Sharda Sagar Jalashya for the period from
05.09.1998 to 30.06.2001, was a lease of
immovable property and was therefore,
chargeable to stamp duty as such.
2. The Collector, Pilibhit, Uttar
Pradesh (hereinafter, ‘the Collector’) by
its order dated 23.03.2006, directed the
appellant to pay the deficit stamp fee of
Signature Not Verified
Digitally signed by
NISHA KHULBEY
Date: 2026.08.11
14:53:28 IST
Reason:
Rs.15,72,525/- and in the absence of non-
deposit of the charged amount/ deficit
stamp fee, the same shall be recovered as

2
arrears of land revenue.
3. The above order passed by the
Collector was affirmed by the Chief
Controlling Authority U.P. at Allahabad
(hereinafter, ‘the CCA’) by its order
dated 06.10.2006 which, in turn, was
called in question before the High Court
and has been duly affirmed under the
impugned order.
4. The Collector and the CCA, passed
the orders imposing the liability on the
appellant to pay the deficit stamp duty of
Rs.15,72,525/- mainly on the ground that
the subject deed though referred as
licence, is in fact a lease requiring
registration under Section 17(1)(d) of the
Registration Act, 1908 if the value of the
document is more than Rs.100/-, and the
same would attract stamp duty as a
‘lease’. The reasoning given by the
Collector was found in favour with the CCA
and the High Court.
5. Mr. Abhishek Swarup, learned
counsel appearing for the appellant, would

3
seek parity by referring to a two Judge
Bench order passed by this Court on
12.02.2025 in the case of Farookh Ahmad
vs. State of Uttar Pradesh seeking parity
on the ground that in a similar matter
wherein also, a licence of the same nature
was in issue, this Court has set aside the
order passed by the High Court wherein the
appellant, Farookh Ahmad, was held
responsible for payment of the stamp duty
as a lease.
6. It is also argued that the
appellant was not granted permission to
conduct fishing activities for the entire
year, much less three consecutive years,
inasmuch as by a permission granted by the
Uttar Pradesh Matsya Vikas Nigam Ltd.
fishing activities were allowed only for
10 months in a year and thus, the
‘licence’ cannot be treated to have been
issued for more than a year or more.
7. Per contra , learned counsel, Mr.
Shaurya Sahay, appearing for the
respondent-State would refer to the law

4
laid down by this Court in;
a. Anand Behera & Anr. V
State of Orissa & Anr., (1955) 2
SCC 303
b. Bihar Eastern Gangetic
Fisherman Co-operative Society
Ltd. V. Sipahi Singh & Ors.,
(1977) 4 SCC 145.
c. Godwin Construction Pvt.
Ltd. v. Commissioner, Meerut
Division and Anr., 2025 INSC
1207.
d. Santosh Jayaswal & Anr. V.
State of M.P. & Ors. (1995) 6 SCC
520 and
e. A full Bench judgment of
the Allahabad High Court in the
case of Guddi wife of Keshav Das
v. State of U.P. & Ors., AIR 1997
AII 396,
to argue that the rights to rear fishes
from the pond by executing a deed, amounts
to transfer of immovable property, as the
same amounts to profit à prendre. Thus, it
is compulsorily registrable and would
attract stamp duty as a lease deed in view
of Section 17(1)(d) of the Registration
Act, 1908 read with Section 2(16) of the

5
Stamp Act, 1899.
8. It is also argued that this Court’s
order in Farookh Ahmad (supra) is clearly
distinguishable and would in fact, not
assist the appellant for the reason that
this Court has observed that reading the
document as a whole is required.
9. We have heard learned counsel for
the parties at length and have perused the
appeal papers.
10. The subject deed titled as “licence
for fishing” was granted consequent to the
appellant being successful in an auction
of the Sharda Sagar Jalashya, Pilibhit,
Uttar Pradesh conducted by the Uttar
Pradesh Matsya Vikas Nigam Ltd.
11. Admittedly, the licence was granted
for a period of three years on payment of
auction amount of Rs.38.01 Lakhs for the
period 01.09.1998 to 30.6.1999; 41.81
lakhs for the period 01.09.1999 to
30.6.2000 and Rs.45.99 lakhs for the
period ending on 01.09.2001. Thus, the
‘licence’ was issued for a total period of

6
three years. Permission for carrying out
‘fishing activities’ is altogether
different than ‘licence to carry on
fishing activities’. Such permission is
granted only on the basis of licence,
inasmuch as fishing activity is not
allowed to be carried out throughout the
year.
12. Under Section 6(4) and (5) of the
Fisheries Act, 1897 read with the Rules
framed thereunder, fishing activity is not
permissible during the breeding season,
i.e. during the rainy season and
therefore, the fishing activity is always
restricted to be carried out for a period
excluding the breeding season, the same
being in the nature of a regulatory
suspension. However, this would not amount
to reduction of the period of licence.
13. The subject fishing tank, namely
Sharda Sagar Jalashya is situated in
District Pilibhit, Uttar Pradesh. The
fishing and allied activities in the State
of Uttar Pradesh are governed under the

7
U.P. Fisheries Act, 1948 (hereinafter
‘1948 Act’). Section 3 of the 1948 Act
makes provision regarding prohibition and
licensing of fishing in selected waters by
rules. Under clause (d) of Section 3(3)
of the 1948 Act, the State Government can
frame rules to prohibit fishing, except
under licence, or regulate the granting of
such licences, the charges of fees
therefor and the conditions to be inserted
therein. Further, clauses (e) and (g)
enable the State Government to frame rules
to prescribe seasons in which the killing
or catching or sale of any spawn, young or
adult fish, of any prescribed species
shall be prohibited or prohibit fishing in
any specified water for specified period.
In exercise of the above powers, the
State of Uttar Pradesh has framed rules
known as U.P. Fisheries (Development and
Control) Rules, 1954 (hereinafter ‘1954
Rules’). Rule 3 thereof provides that no
person shall be allowed to catch, destroy
or sell fry and fingerlings (2”-10”) from

8
July 15 to September 30 and breeding fish
from June 15 to July 30 in the prohibited
areas for fishing, except under a licence
issued by the Director of Animal
Husbandry, Uttar Pradesh.
14. Thus, restricting fishing
activities in the subject Jalashya to 10
months in a year upon grant of permission
from the Uttar Pradesh Matsya Vikas Nigam
Ltd. is in accord with the provisions of
the 1948 Act and the 1954 Rules.
Prohibition of fishing for a particular
period has thus statutory backing.
However, that by itself would not convert
the licence for a period less than one
year.
15. In the licence itself, it is
clearly mentioned in Clause 6 that the
same is granted for specific rights of
conduct of fishing and for taking away
fish cot from the Jalashay. Thus, the
licence was exclusively granted for
carrying out fishing activity.

9
16. In the matter of Anand Behera
(supra), a five Judge Bench of this Court
held that the right to catch and carry
away fish in specific sections of the lake
over a specific future period is a right
to take some profit of the soil for the
use of the owner of the right and in
India, it is regarded as a benefit that
arises out of the land and as such, is
immovable property. This Court, proceeded
to observe thus;
“ ...8. The facts disclosed in
Para 3 of the petition make it
clear that what was sold was the
right to catch and carry away fish
in specific sections of the lake
over a specified future period.
That amounts to a licence to enter
on the land coupled with a grant
to catch and carry away the fish,
that is to say, it is a profit a
prendre: see 11 Halsbury's Laws of
England (Hailsham Edn.) pp. 382
and 383. In England this is
regarded as an interest in land
(11 Halsbury's Laws of England, p.
387) because it is a right to take
some profit of the soil for the

10
use of the owner of the right (p.
382). In India it is regarded as a
benefit that arises out of the
land and as such is immovable
property.
9. Section 3(26) of the General
Clauses Act, 1897 defines
“immovable property” as including
benefits that arise out of the
land. The Transfer of Property Act
does not define the term except to
say that immovable property does
not include standing timber,
growing crops or grass. As fish do
not come under that category the
definition in the General Clauses
Act applies and as a profit a
prendre is regarded as a benefit
arising out of land it follows
that it is immovable property
within the meaning of the Transfer
of Property Act.
10. Now a “sale” is defined as a
transfer of ownership in exchange
for a price paid or promised. As a
profit a prendre is immovable
property and as in this case it
was purchased for a price that was
paid it requires writing and
registration because of Section 54

11
of the Transfer of Property Act.
If a profit a prendre is regarded
as tangible immovable property,
then the “property” in this case
was over Rs 100 in value. If it is
intangible, then a registered
instrument would be necessary
whatever the value. The “sales” in
this case were oral: there was
neither writing nor registration.
That being the case, the
transactions passed no title or
interest and accordingly the
petitioners have no fundamental
right that they can enforce.
17. Thereafter, in the matter of
Santosh Jayaswal (supra), a similar issue
came for consideration and this Court
clearly held in paragraph nos. 5 to 8
which is reproduced hereunder for ready
reference;
“….5. Section 17(1) of the Indian
Registration Act provides that
certain documents shall be
registered, if the property to
which they relate is situate in a
district in which, and if they have
been executed on or after the
specified date. By virtue of
Section 17(1)(d) leases of
immovable property from year to
year, or for any term exceeding one

12
year, or reserving a yearly rent is
compulsorily registrable
instrument. This Court considered
the controversy in Bihar Eastern
Gangetic Fishermen Coop. Society
Ltd. v. Sipahi Singh [(1977) 4 SCC
145] and held that if the profit a
prendre is a tangible immovable
property, its sale has to be by
means of a registered instrument in
case its value exceeds Rs 100. If
it is intangible, the sale is
required by Section 54 of the
Transfer of Property Act, 1882, to
be effected by a registered
instrument, whatever its value.
Therefore, in either situation the
grant of the profit a prendre has
to be by means of a registered
instrument.
6. Since the definition of
“immovable property” in M.P.
General Clauses Act includes
benefits to arise out of land and
things attached to the earth, the
question is whether the right to
catch fish is a benefit to arise
out of the land. It cannot be
controverted that catching fish
from the tank would be a benefit
arising out of the land. Therefore,

13
it is an immovable property. Even
though it is profit a prendre,
since it is a benefit to arise from
the land, it is an immovable
property. If its value is more than
Rs 100 or the lease is on year to
year basis, it is a compulsorily
registrable instrument under
Section 17(1)(c) of the Indian
Registration Act. It is an
instrument under Article 35(a) of
Schedule 1-A clauses (1) to (3) of
the Stamp Act. Therefore, it
requires to be engrossed with
required stamp duty and registered
under Section 17(1)(d) of the
Indian Registration Act.
7. Though Shri Pramod Swarup,
learned counsel for the appellant,
sought reliance on the judgment of
this Court in Ananda Behera v.State
of Orissa [(1955) 2 SCR 919 : AIR
1956 SC 17], State of
W.B.v.Shebaits of Iswar Sri Saradia
Thakurani [(1972) 4 SCC 158] ,
Board of Revenue v. A.M. Ansari
[(1976) 3 SCC 512 : 1976 SCC (Tax)
350] and State of Orissa v.
Titaghur Paper Mills Co. Ltd. [1985
Supp SCC 280 : 1985 SCC (Tax) 538]
they render little assistance to
the facts in these cases. Therein

14
the question was whether the right
to catch fish is a lease or a
licence. In view of the language of
documents in those cases, this
Court considered that it would be a
licence but not a lease. Since the
document has not been placed before
us, we cannot decipher whether it
is a licence or a lease. Since the
controversy was not put in issue
before the Division Bench, we
proceeded on the premise that it is
a lease. Under these circumstances,
we are of the considered view that
the Division Bench of the High
Court is right in its conclusion
that it is a lease and being of the
value of more than Rs 100 and
upwards, it is compulsorily
registrable under Section 17(1)(d)
of the Indian Registration Act.
8. Under Section 17 of the
Registration Act, read with Section
2(16) of the Indian Stamp Act,
‘lease’ means a lease of immovable
property and includes a patta, a
kabuliyat or other undertaking in
writing, not being a counterpart of
a lease to cultivate, occupy, or
pay or deliver rent for immovable
property etc. Right to catch fish
is profit a prendre and benefit to

15
arise out of land is an immovable
property for the purpose of stamp
duty. It would, therefore, be clear
that since it is a right given to
the appellants to catch fish in the
tank, it is a profit a prendre
attached to or benefit to arise out
of the land. Therefore, it is an
instrument for the purpose of stamp
duty. Since the duration of lease
in LPA No. 21 of 1994 is only nine
months, it is not a compulsorily
registrable instrument by operation
of Section 17(1)(c) of the Act. The
civil appeal arising out of LPA No.
21 of 1994 relating to Santosh
Jaiswal is, therefore, partly
allowed. It is an instrument which
requires to bear the appropriate
stamp duty but is not a
compulsorily registrable
instrument. In appeal arising out
of LPA No. 22 of 1994 of Surendra
Shukla, since the duration of lease
is more than a year, it is an
instrument and compulsorily
registrable by operation of Section
17(1)(c) of the Registration Act
and liable to stamp duty under the
Indian Stamp Act. Therefore, it
cannot be acted upon unless it is
duly engrossed with stamp duty and

16
registered .
18. The law settled by this Court that
when the right is given to a person to
catch fish in the tank, it is profit à
prendre attached to, or a benefit to arise
out of the land. Therefore, it is an
instrument for the purpose of stamp duty
and since the duration of the licence
which is in fact a lease, is for more than
a year, it is compulsory registrable and
liable to stamp duty as an instrument of
lease.
19. In our considered view, the law
being fairly well settled and having not
being diluted by this Court’s judgment in
Farookh Ahmad (supra), the document in
question, the terms of which we have
referred to in the preceding paragraphs,
would be an ‘instrument’ akin to a lease
deed. Therefore, the orders passed by the
Collector, the CCA and the High Court does
not call for any interference.

17
20. The order passed by this Court in
Farookh Ahmad (supra), relied by the
appellant, is clearly distinguishable
inasmuch as this Court has set aside the
order passed by the High Court because in
the said matter, the High Court had not
adverted to the terms and conditions of
the licence for deciding whether a
document is a lease instrument or not.
Whereas, in the present case, the
Collector and the CCA, have discussed the
terms of the document to record a
categorical finding that the document is
an ‘instrument’ requiring to be
mandatorily registered being for a value
more than Rs.100/- and for a period more
than a year.
21. For all the above stated reasons,
we are not inclined to interfere with the
impugned order.
22. The appeal fails and is hereby,
dismissed.

18
23. Pending application(s), if any,
shall stand disposed of.
......................J.
(PRASHANT KUMAR MISHRA)
.....................J.
(SHREE CHANDRASHEKHAR)
New Delhi
15-07-2026

19
ITEM NO.103 COURT NO.13 SECTION III-A
S U P R E M E C O U R T O F I N D I A
RECORD OF PROCEEDINGS
Civil Appeal No(s). 2412/2011
ZAKI ULLAH KHAN Appellant(s)
VERSUS
STATE OF U.P.AND ORS. Respondent(s)

Date : 15-07-2026 This appeal was called on for hearing today.
CORAM :
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE PRASHANT KUMAR MISHRA
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE SHREE CHANDRASHEKHAR
For Appellant(s) :
Mr. Abhishek Swarup, Adv.*
Mr. Chetan Sharma, Adv.
M/S. Manoj Swarup And Co., AOR

For Respondent(s) :
Mr. Shaurya Sahay, AOR
Mr. Aman Jaiswal, Adv.
Ms. Sharvi Sharma, Adv.

UPON hearing the counsel the Court made the following
O R D E R
1. The appeal is dismissed in terms of the
signed reportable order.
2. Pending application(s), if any, shall
stand disposed of.
(NISHA KHULBEY) (AKSHAY KUMAR BHORIA)
COURT MASTER(SH) COURT MASTER(NSH)
(signed reportable order is placed on the file)