Rinku Singh vs State Of Haryana
- Court
- Punjab and Haryana High Court
CRM-M-55540-2026 1
IN THE HIGH COURT OF PUNJAB AND HARYANA AT
CHANDIGARH
246 CRM-M-55540-2026
Rinku Singh
....Petitioner
V/s
State of Haryana
....Respondent
Date of decision: 17.11.2026
Date of Uploading : 18.11.2026
CORAM: HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE SUMEET GOEL
Present: Mr. D.S. Matya, Advocate for the petitioner.
Mr. Aditya Pal Singla, AAG Haryana.
*
SUMEET GOEL , J. (Oral)
1. The present petition is the second attempt under Section 483 of
Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita, 2023 (hereinafter to be referred as ‘the
BNSS’) for grant of regular bail to the petitioner in FIR No.354 dated
26.08.2021 registered under Sections 148, 149, 323, 325, 452, 307, 302 and
506 of IPC at Police Station Sadar Nuh, District Nuh.
2. For the sake of convenience, the relevant factual milieu has
been drawn from the order dated 10.09.2026 passed by passed by the
learned Additional Sessions Judge, Nuh (whereby regular bail plea of the
petitioner was rejected) which reads thus:
“2. Brief facts of the case are that on 25.8.2021, telephonic
information was received in Police Station Sadar Nuh that injured Arun,
Raj Kumar, Suresh Kumar, Satish and Mahesh, resident of village Ujina
are admitted in SHKM Hospital Nalhar, on account of assault injuries.
Vipin son of Naresh Singh resident of village Ujina has expired on
account of assault injuries and dead body is kept in mortuary of SHKM
Hospital, Nalhar. On receiving the information, police party went to the
AJAY KUMAR
2026.11.18 17:18
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
CRM-M-55540-2026 2
Hospital and received medical records of the injured and dead body and
rukka of deceased Vipin. After receiving opinion of the doctor the
statement of injured Suresh was recorded. He submitted that he had got
registered a complaint in Police Station Nuh on 18.8.2021, against some
unsocial elements of village Ujina. On account of the same, on that day
i.e. 25.8.2021, at 6.00 PM the accused were coming towards his shop to
attack him. His nephew Vipin was coming to the shop to meet him. When
he reached near the shop, accused Naresh etc. 8 persons armed with rods,
hockeys, lathis and pistol, assaulted Vipin, in a brutal manner and
absconded. When Vipin was taken to the Hospital, he was declared
brought dead. Subsequently, the above-said 8 accused alongwith 20 other
accused assaulted Arun, Suresh, Satish, Mahesh, Raj Kumar with rods,
lathis and dandas in order to kill them. Appropriate proceedings be
initiated against the accused persons. On the basis of the complaint and
the medical records, FIR was registered under Section 148, 149, 452,
323, 307, 302 and 506 of Indian Penal Code, 1860, Investiganon was set
into motion. Inquest proceedings were conducted and post-mortem of the
dead body was conducted. The clothes of deceased and viscera were sent
to RFSL. Bhandai for examination. Statements of witnesses under Section
161 of CrPC were recorded. Site-plan was prepared. Accused Naresh,
Pawan and Gagan were arrested on 27.8.2021. They got recovered 2
cars, lathis, and iron rod used in the offence. Eyewitness Deepak gave the
video-film of the incident alongwith certificate under Section 65-B of The
Indian Evidence Act, 1872. Accused Madan, Rajinder and Ombir
surrendered in the Court on 16.9.2021 their custodial interrogation done.
During interrogation accused Naresh got recovered an iron rod and
accused Madan got recovered a Sariya used in the offence. Accused Om
Prakash son of Balkishan was arrested on 10.1.2022 and he got
recovered an iron rod. Offence under Section 325 and 120-B IPC were
added. Accused Rinku, Vinod and Lokesh were arrested on 13.1.2022 and
they got recovered the lathis used in the offence. Accused Om Prakash
son of Bhanwar Singh was arrested on 18.1.2022 and he got recovered a
lathi. Accused Jitender was arrested on 14.2.2022 and he got recovered a
lathi and an Eco car bearing registration No. HR-27H-5003. On
completion of investigation final report was submitted.”
3. The petitioner had earlier applied for grant of regular bail
before this Court which was dismissed on merits vide a detailed order on
03.07.2025. The present petition is, thus, the second attempt for grant of
AJAY KUMAR regular bail, which has been preferred on and around 19.09.2026.
2026.11.18 17:18
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
CRM-M-55540-2026 3
4. Learned counsel for the petitioner has iterated that the
petitioner has nothing to do with the alleged occurrence and the prosecution
has levelled vague allegations in order to implicate the petitioner in the
instant case. Learned counsel has further iterated that a bare perusal of the
FIR would reflect that no definite/individual role has been assigned to the
petitioner. According to learned counsel, the allegations against the
petitioner are omnibus in nature and the FIR does not attribute any specific
overt act or injury to the petitioner. It has been further contended that the
complainant has neither disclosed the nature of weapon allegedly used by
the petitioner nor specified any particular injury caused by the petitioner.
Learned counsel has emphasized that the petitioner was alleged to be
carrying a pointed iron rod as per the FIR whereas no such weapon was
recovered from him which casts serious doubt regarding the prosecution
version. Furthermore, the cause of death, as reflected in the post-mortem
report, was the head injury, which was not attributed to the petitioner in the
FIR. It has been further contended that the specific allegation of petitioner
having inflicted a stick (lathi) blow on the head of deceased Vipin surfaced
during the deposition of the prosecution witnesses and did not form part of
the original version in the FIR. According to learned counsel, this amounts
to a material improvement in the prosecution case. It has been further
pointed out that several co-accused, including persons who have allegedly
been assigned specific roles in causing injuries to the deceased, have already
been granted the concession of regular bail and, therefore, the petitioner
deserves the same relief on the ground of parity.
4.1. It has been further contended that the first petition seeking
grant of regular bail was dismissed by this Court on merits vide order dated
AJAY KUMAR
03.07.2025 passed in CRM-M-6861-2025 and the challenge thereto before
2026.11.18 17:18
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
CRM-M-55540-2026 4
the Hon’ble Supreme Court by way of Special Leave Petition was also
dismissed vide order dated 08.10.2025. According to learned counsel, the
petitioner has been in custody since 13.01.2022 and the trial is progressing
at a snail’s pace with only 09 witnesses have been examined and 02 have
been given up out of 66 witnesses cited by the prosecution. It has, thus,
been submitted that the continued incarceration of the petitioner particularly
in the absence of any substantive or direct evidence linking him to the
alleged offence would serve no useful purpose. Furthermore, the petitioner
has clean antecedents and there is no likelihood of his absconding or
tampering with the prosecution evidence. Moreover, the petitioner
undertakes to abide by all/any condition(s) that may be imposed by this
Court, including not tampering with the prosecution evidence or influencing
witnesses and not leaving the country without prior permission of the Court.
On the strength of aforesaid submissions, the grant of petition in hand is
entreated for.
5. In oppugnation, learned State counsel has vehemently opposed
the grant of bail to the petitioner by arguing that the petitioner is the main
accused who has actively participated in the commission of offence in
question. According to learned State counsel, the petitioner was a member
of the unlawful assembly and his role was not merely that of being present
at the spot. Furthermore, during the course of trial, the prosecution
witnesses have specifically alleged that the petitioner inflicted a stick (lathi)
blow on the head of deceased Vipin. Learned State counsel has pointed out
that the earlier petition of the petitioner for grant of regular bail has already
been dismissed and there is no substantial change in circumstances.
Considering the gravity of the offence and the specific role attributed to the
AJAY KUMAR
2026.11.18 17:18
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
CRM-M-55540-2026 5
petitioner, learned State counsel has prayed for the dismissal of the instant
petition.
6. I have heard learned counsel for the rival parties and have
perused the available record.
7. It would be apposite to refer herein to a judgment passed by
this Court in Rafiq Khan vs. State of Haryana and another: 2024:
PHHC:054064 ; relevant whereof reads as under:-
9. The paramount issue, in any plea for grant of regular bail,
is the liberty of an individual. Indubitably, within our society and
jurisprudence, liberty is a cherished foundational principle and has
fundamental ascendency over all other attributes of social order. Even
within the framework of Constitution, this principle is made
conspicuous, inter alia, in Article 21 of our Constitution that no person
shall be deprived of his personal liberty except according to procedure
established by law. The Cr.P.C., 1973 is one such procedural law
which permits curtailment of liberty of anti-social and anti-national
elements. Yet, liberty of an individual, the accused, must not transgress
the rights of another individual, the victim, in terms of right to dignified
everyday life without any imminent fear or threat. Additionally, the
rights of the collective of individuals viz. the State/Society at large, also
cannot be neglected. Therefore, while countenancing the facts for
considering the bail, the rights of the triad of accused, victim and the
State (Society at large) ought to be entailed. Ergo, while considering a
bail plea, the Court ought to take into account this core concept(s).
9.1 An analytical perusal of Cr.P.C. explicates that this statute
does not contain any provision relatable to maintainability or
otherwise of second/successive bail petitions, including one(s) seeking
regular bail. Once there is no statutory prohibition provided for in law,
a Court is not logically empowered to import into it such prohibitions,
especially in case of codified and legislated law. It is trite law that
Courts ought not to read a provision in codified law which has not
been specifically provided for by the legislature especially when such
reading results into deprivation of rights. The bar contained in Section
362 of Cr.P.C. can, by no stretch of legal imagination, be said to be
barring the filing of second/successive regular bail petition.
9.2 The Hon’ble Supreme Court in case of Babu Singh case
AJAY KUMAR (supra) has held that rejection of a bail petition does not, by itself,
2026.11.18 17:18
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
CRM-M-55540-2026 6
forbid a Court from considering another one, later in point of time.
Similar is the ratio decidendi of the judgment of Hon’ble Supreme
Court in Kalyan Chandra Sarkar (supra). Ergo, it can be safely
inferred that the decision of a Court qua regular bail petition is
essentially an interlocutory order and hence the postulation of res
judicata does not apply to its realm.
9.3 The issue that next craves attention is as to what are the
factors/parameters for consideration of second/successive regular bail
petition(s).
9.4. The concordant legal position is that the essential pre-
requisite for consideration of second/successive regular petition is the
material/substantial change in circumstances and factors of alike
nature. Indubitably, the further period of incarceration suffered by the
petitioner-accused after rejection/withdrawal of first/earlier plea for
bail, pace of trial, the witnesses turning hostile or not supporting
prosecution case and changed medical condition(s) of accused would
be pertinent factor(s). It goes without saying that these factors are only
illustrative in nature and cannot by any means be said to be exhaustive.
9.5 No rigid or universal criterion can possibly be delineated
to conclusively govern the exercise of judicial discretion, in
determining, as to what would constitute as the above stated
substantial change in circumstances. Factual flexibility, one additional
or different fact, may cause a sea of difference. There is no gainsaying
that each case has its own distinct and unique facts and, hence,
exercise of such judicial power is best left to the judicial discretion of a
Court, in accordance with the settled norms of our jurisprudence.
10. As an epilogue to the above discussion, the following
principles emerge:
I Second/successive regular bail petition(s) filed is maintainable in
law & hence such petition ought not to be rejected solely on the ground
of maintainability thereof.
II. Such second/successive regular bail petition(s) is maintainable
whether earlier petition was dismissed as withdrawn/dismissed as not
pressed/dismissed for non-prosecution or earlier petition was
dismissed on merits.
III For the second/successive regular bail petition(s) to succeed, the
petitioner/applicant shall be essentially/pertinently required to show
substantial change in circumstances and showing of a mere superficial
or ostensible change would not suffice. The metaphoric expression of
seeking second/successive bail plea(s) ought not be abstracted into
AJAY KUMAR
2026.11.18 17:18
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
CRM-M-55540-2026 7
literal iterations of petition(s) without substantial, effective and
consequential change in circumstances.
IV No exhaustive guidelines can possibly be laid down as to what
would constitute substantial change in circumstances as every case has
its own unique facts/circumstance. Making such an attempt is nothing
but an utopian endeavour. Ergo, this issue is best left to the judicial
wisdom and discretion of the Court dealing with such
second/successive regular bail petition(s).
V In case a Court chooses to grant second/successive regular bail
petition(s), cogent and lucid reasons are pertinently required to be
recorded for granting such plea despite such a plea being
second/successive petition(s). In other words, the cause for a Court
having successfully countenanced/entertained such second/successive
petition(s) ought to be readily and clearly decipherable from the said
order passed.”
8. The present petition is a second petition for grant of regular
bail by the petitioner. A second regular bail petition is indeed maintainable
under law; however, it requires the demonstration of a substantial change in
circumstances since the dismissal of the earlier petition. It is a settled
proposition of law that such a change must be significant and not merely
superficial or technical so as to warrant reconsideration. This standard
ensures that the remedy of successive bail petitions is not misused through
repeated filings but is available only when new and material factors arise
that alter the initial assessment of the case. The first regular bail filed by the
petitioner was dismissed on merits on 03.07.2025. The instant petition i.e.
second petition for grant of regular bail has been filed thereafter on
19.09.2026.
9. The grant of bail falls within the discretionary domain of the
Court; however, such discretion must be exercised in a judicious and
principled manner, ensuring it aligns with established legal precedents and
the interests of justice. While considering a bail application, the Court must
AJAY KUMAR
evaluate factors such as the existence of prima facie evidence implicating
2026.11.18 17:18
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
CRM-M-55540-2026 8
the accused, the nature and gravity of the alleged offence, and the severity
of the likely to be imposed upon conviction. The Court must also assess the
likelihood of the accused absconding or evading the due process of law, the
probability of the offence being repeated and any reasonable apprehension
of the accused tampering with evidence or influencing witnesses.
Additionally, the character, antecedents, financial means, societal standing,
and overall conduct of the accused play a crucial role. Furthermore, the
Court must weigh the potential danger of bail undermining the
administration of justice or thwarting its due course. A profitable reference
in this regard is made to the judgment passed by the Hon’ble Supreme Court
titled as State through C.B.I. vs. Amaramani Tripathi, 2005 AIR Supreme
Court 3490, relevant whereof reads as under:
“14. It is well settled that the matters to be considered in an application
for bail are (i)whether there is any prima facie or reasonable ground to
believe that the accused had committed the offence; (ii) nature and
gravity of the charge; (iii) severity of the punishment in the event of
conviction; (iv) danger of accused absconding or fleeing if released on
bail; (v) character, behaviour, means, position and standing of the
accused;(vi) likelihood of the offence being repeated; (vii) reasonable
apprehension of the witnesses being tampered with; and (viii) danger, of
course, of justice being thwarted bygrant of bail (see Prahlad Singh
Bhati v. NCT, Delhi, 2001(2) RCR (Criminal) 377 (SC) :2001(4) SCC
280 and Gurcharan Singh v. State (Delhi Administration), AIR 1978
Supreme Court 179 ). While a vague allegation that accused may tamper
with the evidence or witnesses may not be a ground to refuse bail, if the
accused is of such character that his mere presence at large would
intimidate the witnesses or if there is material to show that he will use his
liberty to subvert justice or tamper with the evidence, then bail will be
refused. We may also refer to the following principles relating to grant or
refusal of bail stated in Kalyan Chandra Sarkar v. Rajesh Ranjan,
2004(2) RCR (Criminal) 254 (SC) :2004(7) SCC 528 :"The law in regard
to grant or refusal of bail is very well settled. The court granting bail
should exercise its discretion in a judicious manner and not as a matter of
course. Though at the stage of granting bail a detailed examination of
AJAY KUMAR
2026.11.18 17:18 evidence and elaborate documentation of the merit of the case need not be
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
CRM-M-55540-2026 9
undertaken, there is a need to indicate in such orders reasons for prima
facie concluding why bail was being granted particularly where the
accused is charged of having committed a serious offence. Any order
devoid of such reasons would suffer from non-application of mind. It is
also necessary for the court granting bail to consider among other
circumstances, the following factors also before granting bail; they are:
a. The nature of accusation and the severity of punishment in case of
conviction and the nature of supporting evidence.
b. Reasonable apprehension of tampering with the witness or
apprehension ofthreat to the complainant.
c. Prima facie satisfaction of the court in support of the charge. (see Ram
GovindUpadhyay v. Sudarshan Singh, 2002(2) RCR (Criminal) 250
(SC) : 2002(3) SCC 598 andPuran v. Ram Bilas, 2001(2) RCR
(Criminal) 801 (SC) : 2001(6) SCC 338. ”
This Court also in specific terms held that :
“the condition laid down under section 437(1)(i) is sine qua non for
granting bail even under section 439 of the Code. In the impugned order
it is noticed that the High Court has given the period of incarceration
already undergone by the accused and the unlikelihood of trial
concluding in the near future as grounds sufficient to enlarge the accused
on bail, in spite of the fact that the accused stands charged of offences
punishable with life imprisonment or even death penalty. In such cases, in
our opinion, the mere fact that the accused has undergone certain period
of incarceration (three years in this case) by itself would not entitle the
accused to being enlarged on bail, nor the fact that the trial is not likely
to be concluded in the near future either by itself or coupled with the
period of incarceration would be sufficient for enlarging the appellant on
bail when the gravity of the offence alleged is severe and there are
allegations of tampering with the witnesses by the accused during the
period he was on bail."
In Panchanan Mishra v. Digambar Mishra, 2005(1) Apex Criminal 319
: 2005(1) RCR(Criminal) 712 (SC) : 2005(3) SCC 143, this Court
observed :
“The object underlying the cancellation of bail is to protect the
fair trial and secure justice being done to the society by preventing
the accused who is set at liberty by the bail order from tampering
with the evidence in the heinous crime..... It hardly requires to be
stated that once a person is released on bail in serious criminal
cases where the punishment is quite stringent and deterrent, the
accused in order to get away from the clutches of the same indulge
in various activities like tampering with the prosecution witnesses,
AJAY KUMAR
2026.11.18 17:18
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
CRM-M-55540-2026 10
threatening the family members of the deceased victim and also
create problems of law and order situation.”
10. Indubitably, the allegations against the petitioner are grave in
nature. The material which has come on record, at this stage, prima facie
suggests that the petitioner has specially been attributed an active role in the
alleged incident. The main ground(s) urged by learned counsel for the
petitioner are with regard to alleged inconsistency regarding the weapon, the
nature of the injuries, the alleged improvement in the statements of the
prosecution witnesses, parity with the co-accused and prolonged
incarceration. In the considered opinion of this Court, these grounds
essentially relate to the evidence collected during the course of
investigation. Such grounds, in the absence of any significant subsequent
development, do not constitute an accentuating circumstance warranting a
different view from the view taken while dismissing the first bail petition on
merits.
11. The plea that the petitioner was not specifically assigned the
injury which proved fatal does not, at this stage, dilute the specific role
attributed to him, as the prosecution has attributed a specific role to him in
the occurrence of inflicting a stick (lathi) blow on the head of deceased
Vipin. The nature and gravity of allegations as well as the role assigned to
the petitioner cannot be lightly brushed aside at this stage. The question as
to whether the injury caused by the petitioner was sufficient to cause death
is a matter that can only be ratiocinated upon during the course of trial and
cannot be conclusively determined at the stage of consideration of plea for
grant of regular bail. The seriousness of the allegations, coupled with the
specific role attributed to the petitioner, weighs heavily against the grant of
bail. At this stage, the petitioner cannot seek regular bail merely on the
AJAY KUMAR
2026.11.18 17:18
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
CRM-M-55540-2026 11
ground that the prosecution has attributed other injuries to different accused
persons as well.
12. The plea of parity raised by the petitioner is also misconceived
and does not merit acceptance, as the case of the petitioner stands on a
different footing inasmuch as a specific and active role, particularly of firing
the gunshot, has been attributed to him. It is well settled that the principle
of parity is not absolute and is subject to the individual role and
circumstances of each accused. Therefore, the petitioner cannot claim the
benefit of parity in the factual milieu of the case in hand.
13. At this stage, no accentuating circumstances have been made
which may prima facie constitute a compelling ground for the grant of
regular bail to the petitioner, especially in light of the gravity of the
allegations and the evidence on record. It is also to be borne in mind that
offences of this nature strike at the very root of public order and societal
conscience. Granting bail in such cases would not only undermine the
gravity of the offence but may also embolden the accused. Further, there
exists a strong likelihood that if enlarged on bail the petitioner may abscond
to evade trial or attempt to influence, threaten, or intimidate prosecution
witnesses. Furthermore, the petitioner has also sought bail on the ground of
prolonged custody and snail pace of the trial. Though it is true that the
petitioner has been in custody for a considerable period but the seriousness
of the allegations weigh heavily against him. The material which has been
placed on record does not show that the delay in trial is solely attributable to
the prosecution. In such circumstances, prolonged incarceration, by itself,
cannot be treated as a ground for grant of bail. The period of custody has to
be considered along with the nature and gravity of the allegations, the role
AJAY KUMAR
attributed to the accused, the stage of trial and the overall facts of the case.
2026.11.18 17:18
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
CRM-M-55540-2026 12
14. Considering the gravity of the offence, the stage of the trial and
the overall facts and circumstances emerging from the record, this Court
finds no merit in the present petition. Accordingly, this Court is of the
considered opinion that the petitioner does not deserve the concession of
regular bail in the factual milieu of the case in hand.
15. In view of the prevenient ratiocination, it is ordained thus:
(i) The petition in hand is devoid of merits and is hereby
dismissed.
(ii) Any observations made and/or submissions noted hereinabove
shall not have any effect on merits of the case and the investigating agency
as also the trial Court shall proceed further, in accordance with law, without
being influenced with this order.
(iii) Pending application(s), if any, shall also stand disposed of.
(SUMEET GOEL)
JUDGE
November 17, 2026
Ajay
Whether speaking/reasoned: Yes/No
Whether reportable: Yes/No
AJAY KUMAR
2026.11.18 17:18
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document