M. Nallathambi vs The State of Tamilnadu, Rep. by its Secretary to Government,

Court
Madras High Court

W.P (Crl.) (MD).No.5282 of 2026
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT MADRAS
DATED : 13.11.2026
CORAM :
THE HON’BLE MR.JUSTICE D.BHARATHA CHAKRAVARTHY
W.P (Crl.) (MD).No.5282 of 2026
and W.P.M.P (Crl.) (MD).Nos.1201 and 1202 of 2026
M.Nallathambi .. Petitioner
Versus
1. State of Tamilnadu,
Rep. by its Secretary to Government,
Department of Home (Court-II-A),
Secretariat,
Fort St. George,
Chennai – 600 009.
2. The Competent Authority cum
District Revenue Officer,
Madurai District,
Madurai.
3. The Superintendent of Police,
Economic Offences Wing,
South Zone,
Ashok Nagar,
Chennai.
4. The Inspector of Police,
Economic Offences Wing,
Park Town,
Madurai.
1/11
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
( Uploaded on: 19/11/2026 01:03:38 pm )

W.P (Crl.) (MD).No.5282 of 2026
5. M/s.Martin Realty Pvt. Ltd.,
75-A, Sri Vidhya Garden,
Mettupalayam Road,
Coimbatore.
6. M/s.Adventas Global Properties
Private Limited,
th
No.239, 7 Cross Street,
Morias City,
Near Airport,
Chempattu,
Trichy District.
7. M/s.Livsmart Properties Private Limited,
st
No.1-3, Muthu Nagar 1 Street,
Trichy Road,
Dindigul Town,
Dindigul District. .. Respondents

Prayer : Writ Petition filed under Article 226 of the Constitution of India
seeking a Writ of Certiorarified Mandamus, calling for the records relating
to the impugned sale notice, dated 09.08.2026 with regard to item No.11 in
respect of Ilanthaikulam village, Madurai district in respect of S.Nos.19/2,
19/3A, 19/3B, 19/35A and 19/35B and patta No.866 to the extent of 10
acres 26 cents and quash the same as illegal and unconstitutional and
consequently direct respondents 2 to 4 not to confirm the auction and sale
of the properties above mentioned.
For Petitioner : Ms.D.Bharathy
For Respondents : Mr.C.R.Malarvannan,
Additional Public Prosecutor, for RR-1 to 4
2/11
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
( Uploaded on: 19/11/2026 01:03:38 pm )

W.P (Crl.) (MD).No.5282 of 2026
ORDER
The property in the village of Ulaganeri, Kalikappan, Bit – I,
Ilanthaikulam village at Madurai, is totally, admeasuring to 38 acres. In
this regard, this Writ Petition is filed by one Nallathambi for a Writ of
Certiorarified Mandamus challenging the earlier sale notice, dated
09.08.2026 issued in respect of the said property. The claim made by the
petitioner is that the petitioner and his brother inherited the property vide
registered Will, bearing Doct.No.26 of 1981 executed by his father
namely, S.Muthu , who was the former Mayor of Madurai and his mother,
Ranjitham . It is stated that the Will contains A and B schedule properties
in Ilanthaikulam village and the property in S.Nos.19/2, 19/3A, 19/3B,
19/35A and 19/35B nanjaland to the extent of Ac.10.26 cents falls under
Schedule - A properties and as such, it is covered under the Will.
Therefore, he and his brother, being the owners of the property, bringing of
the property by way of auction by the competent authorities, is erroneous
in law.
2. The Writ Petition is resisted by the competent authority by
filing a detailed status report.
3/11
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
( Uploaded on: 19/11/2026 01:03:38 pm )

W.P (Crl.) (MD).No.5282 of 2026
3. It is seen that even as per the Will, the entire extent of 38
acres is not mentioned. It is only 4 acres that is mentioned in the Will.
Even with reference to the same, it is stated that to the extent that is owned
in respect of the relevant survey numbers, the parents of the petitioner
namely Muthu and Ranjitham had executed several documents even during
their lifetime and the property stood alienated and ultimately, vested with
the accused Company. Therefore, the property is now attached and is
brought for sale. As a matter of fact, the details are given in respect of the
said transactions in paragraph No.7 of the status report and the same is
extracted hereunder for ready reference:-
Tr. Muthu (Father of Petitioner T.Nallathambi)
Sl.
No.
Date Document
Survey
Extension Seller Buyer
No.
No.
1. 06.08.1980 3919/1980 19/2 4.11 Acre Sankaramoorthy
Muthu
Mudaliyar and 12
others
2. 06.08.1981 Will Deed
19/2 4.11 Acre Muthu and
Nallathambi and
Ranjitham
Karunanithi
26/1981
(Minor)
3. 18.05.1983 2759/1983 19/2 2 Acre Muthu Susila w/o
Karuppanan
4. 22.07.1983 3329/1983 19/2 2.11 Acre Muthu Karuppanan
5. 20.11.1990 2485/1990 19/2B 2 Acre Susila w/o
Karuppanan
Valarmathi (Gu)
S.Ravi (Mi)
6. 20.11.1990 2487/1990 19/2B 2.11 Acre Karuppanan Valarmathi (Gu)
4/11
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
( Uploaded on: 19/11/2026 01:03:38 pm )

W.P (Crl.) (MD).No.5282 of 2026
S.Devi (Mi)
7. 03.09.2009 2884/2009 19/2B 4.11 Acre S.Ravi, S.Uma,
S.Devi, S.Rani,
M/s. Martin
Reality Pvt. Ltd.,
(M.Sivaprakash -
Purchase Manager)
B.John Britto
(Confirming
Party)
8. 14.06.2019 2543/2019 19/2B1 2 Acre M/s. Martin
Reality Pvt. Ltd.,
M/s. Adventa
Global Properties
Pvt. Ltd., (Neomax
(Vedamuthu-
Group)
(D.Veerasakthi-
Authorised
signatory)
Authorised
signatory)
9. 14.06.2019 2544/2019 19/2B2 2.11 Acre M/s. Martin
Reality Pvt. Ltd.,
M/s. Livsmart
Properties Pvt.
Ltd., (Neomax
(Vedamuthu-
Authorised
Group)
(R.N.Jeyachandran
signatory)
- Authorised
signatory)
Tmt.Ranjitham, W/o.Tr.Muthu (Mother of Petitioner T.Nallathambi)
Sl.
No.
Date Document
Survey
Extension Seller Buyer
No.
No.
1. 26.02.1981 811/1981 19/3A,
4.15 Acre Malaichamy
Ranjitham
35B,
3A, 3B
Thevar
2. 06.08.1981 Will Deed
19/3A 1.99 Acre Muthu and
Nallathambi and
Karunanithi (Mi)
19/3B 0.99 Acre
26/1981
Ranjitham
19/35A 0.17 Acre
19/35B 1 Acre
3. 24.04.1983 1851/1983 19/3B,
1.99 Acre Ranjitham Karuppanan s/o
KaruppanaKonar
35A,
35B
5/11
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
( Uploaded on: 19/11/2026 01:03:38 pm )

W.P (Crl.) (MD).No.5282 of 2026
4. 24.04.1983 1852/1983 19/3A 2.16 Acre Ranjitham (1) Karuppanan @
Ravi (M) s/o
K.V.K.Krishnan
(2) Thiruppathi @
Selvam (Mi)
(3) Kannan (Mi)
(4) Kaliammal
(Gu)
5. 20.11.1990 2488/1990 19/3B,
1.99 Acre Karuppanan s/o
Valarmathi (Gu)
35A,
Karuppana Konar
S.Rani (Mi)
35B
6. 20.11.1990 2489/1990 19/3A 2.16 Acre (1) Karuppanan
Valarmathi (Gu)
@ Ravi (M) s/o
K.V.K.Krishnan
S.Latha (Mi)
(2) Thiruppathi
@ Selvam (Mi)
(3) Kannan (Mi)
(4) Kaliammal
(Gu)
7. 03.09.2009 2884/2009 19/3B,
1.99 Acre S.Ravi, S.Uma,
M/s Martin Reality
35A,
S.Devi, S.Rani
and B.John Britto
Pvt. Ltd.,
(M.Sivaprakash-
Purchase Manager)
35B
(Confirming
Party)
8. 06.09.2010 3368/2010 19/3A,
2.16 Acre (1)
S.LathaS.V.Rani-
M/s. Martin
Reality Pvt. Ltd.,
3B,
35A,
35B
Power Agent
(Power Doc. No.
(M.Sivaprakash-
Purchase Manager)
4440/2008)
(2) John Britto -
Confirming Party
9. 14.06.2019 2544/2019 19/3A 4.15 Acre M/s Martin
Reality Pvt. Ltd.,
M/s Livsmart
Properties Pvt.
Ltd., (Neomax
(Vedamuthu-
Authorised
Group)
(R.N.Jeyachandran
signatory)
- Authorised
6/11
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
( Uploaded on: 19/11/2026 01:03:38 pm )

W.P (Crl.) (MD).No.5282 of 2026
signatory)
Petitioner Tr.Nallathambi and his brother Tr.Karunanithi
Sl.
No.
Date Document
Survey
Extension Seller Buyer
No.
No.
1. 06.08.1980 3918/1980 19/2 2 Acre Sankaramoorthy
Mudaliyar and 12
Malaimani
Ammal w/o
Packiyaraman
others
2. 07.12.1980 6326/1980 19/2 1 Acre Malaimani Ammal
Nallathambi
w/o Packiyaraman
3. 07.12.1980 6327/1980 19/2 1 Acre Malaimani Ammal
Karunanithi (Mi)
w/o Packiyaraman
(Age: 15/1980)
Ranjitham (Gu)
4. 06.07.1983 2985/1983 19/2 1 Acre Nallathambi Vijayakumar (Mi)
s/o
KaruppanaKonar
5. 06.07.1983 2986/1983 19/2 1 Acre Karunanithi Venkatachalam @
Vijayakumar (Mi)
s/o
KaruppanaKonar
6. 19.11.1990 2486/1990 19/2 2 Acre Kumar (School
Valarmathi (Gu)
Name) @
Vijayakumar @
S.Uma (Mi)
Venkatachalam
(Mi) s/o
KaruppanaKonar
7. 03.09.2009 2884/2009 19/2C,
2 Acre S.Ravi, S.Uma,
S.Devi, S.Rani,
M/s. Martin
Reality Pvt. Ltd.,
2D
B.John Britto
(M.Sivaprakash-
(Confirming
Purchase
Manager)
Party)
8. 14.06.2019 2543/2019 19/2C,
2 Acre M/s. Martin
Reality Pvt. Ltd.,
M/s. Adventa
Global Properties
2D
(Vedamuthu-
Pvt. Ltd.,
7/11
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
( Uploaded on: 19/11/2026 01:03:38 pm )

W.P (Crl.) (MD).No.5282 of 2026
Authorised
(Neomax Group)
signatory)
(D.Veerasakthi-
Authorised
signatory)
4. Learned Counsel for the petitioner would submit that of the 38
acres, 10 acres finds place in the schedule. Immediately, upon coming to
know of the entries, the petitioner has already filed O.S.No.102 of 2026 on
the file of the District Munsif, Madurai. The documents which are
mentioned by the learned Additional Public Prosecutor are all bogus.
When the petitioner is only the owner of the property, they need not file
any suit for declaration and that is why they have filed a simple suit for
permanent injunction.
5. Though a rejoinder was filed disputing the transactions, the
learned Counsel did not substantiate the same the allegations.
6. I have considered the rival submissions made on either side
and perused the material records of the case.
7. Firstly, it must be seen that the petitioner’s parents namely,
Muthu and Ranjitham though executed the Will on 06.08.1981, even
8/11
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
( Uploaded on: 19/11/2026 01:03:38 pm )

W.P (Crl.) (MD).No.5282 of 2026
during their lifetime, by documents bearing Nos.2759/1983, 3329/1983,
1851/1983, 1852/1983 have alienated the property in favour of third
parties, from whom the property ultimately came to be vested with the
accused companies. As a matter of fact, at the same point in time, the
petitioner and his brother had also sold the extents vested in them by
document Nos. 2985/1983 and 2986/1983 in favour of third parties. Thus,
43 years later, it is too late in the day for the petitioner to contend that the
documents are forged.
8. It must be seen that till date, not even a complaint has been
lodged by the petitioner or his brother with reference to the alleged
offences. Even in the Civil Suit in O.S.No.102 of 2026, no prayer of
declaration is made and it is for a bare injunction. The entire extent is
already attached. For the purpose of auction, already by orders of Court,
the bushes and vegetations were cleared and all the authorities have also
inspected the entire extent and the properties have now been divided and
earmarked into smaller parcels of land so as to fetch maximum price in the
auction. There is absolutely no documentary proof whatsoever even with
reference to the alleged possession. On the other hand, the title documents
and the revenue documents prove the title and possession of the accused.
9/11
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
( Uploaded on: 19/11/2026 01:03:38 pm )

W.P (Crl.) (MD).No.5282 of 2026
Admittedly, the lands were purchased from and out of the proceeds of the
Crime. Accordingly, when the very claim is based on the Will and if the
testators have sold the property even before the Will came into the force,
the petitioner cannot make any claim. Further at this point of time, any
claim is hopelessly barred by limitation.
9. Accordingly, finding no merits, this Writ Petition stands
dismissed. There shall be no order as to Costs. Consequently, connected
miscellaneous petitions stand closed.
13.11.2026
Neutral Citation : no
grs
To
1. The Chairman,
O/o.TANGEDCO,
N.P.K.R.R. Maaligai,
144 Anna Salai,
Chennai – 600 002.
2. The Chief Engineer/Distribution,
O/o. TANGEDCO,
Trichy Region,
Thennur,
Trichy District.
3. The Superintending Engineer,
O/o. TANGEDCO,
Perambalur Electricity Distribution Circle,
Perambalur District.
10/11
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
( Uploaded on: 19/11/2026 01:03:38 pm )

W.P (Crl.) (MD).No.5282 of 2026
D.BHARATHA CHAKRAVARTHY, J.
grs
W.P (Crl.) (MD).No.5282 of 2026
13.11.2026
11/11
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
( Uploaded on: 19/11/2026 01:03:38 pm )