Union Of India And Another vs Satya Narayan And Another
- Court
- Punjab and Haryana High Court
IN THE HIGH COURT OF PUNJAB AND HARYANA
AT CHANDIGARH
112
CM-8045-LPA-2026 in/and
LPA-3302-2026 (O&M)
Date of Decision: 16.11.2026
UNION OF INDIA AND ANR
...Appellants
Versus
SATYA NARAYAN AND ANR
...Respondents
CORAM: HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE HARSIMRAN SINGH SETHI
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE MINDERJEET YADAV
Present: Mr. Sandeep Bhatia, Advocate for the appellants.
HARSIMRAN SINGH SETHI , J. (ORAL)
CM-8045-LPA-2026
Present application has been filed seeking condonation of delay
of 198 days in filing the appeal.
Keeping in view the averments made in the application, which
are duly supported by an affidavit, the application is allowed. Delay of 198
days in filing the appeal is condoned.
LPA-3302-2026 (O&M)
1. In the present Letters Patent Appeal, the challenge is to the
impugned order dated 24.03.2026 passed by the learned Single Judge in
CWP No.14372 of 2018, titled as Satya Narayan and others vs. Union of
India and others, whereby a direction has been issued to notionally
promote the respondents to the post of Assistant Commandant (GD),
NISHA
2026.11.20 13.31
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
CM-8045-LPA-2026 in/and -2-
LPA-3302-2026 (O&M)
before their retirement, for which promotions they had been found suitable
by the Departmental Promotion Committee against the vacancies arising out
in the 2013-2014.
2. Certain facts need to be mentioned for the correct appreciation
of the issue involved. The respondents were eligible for promotion to the
post of Assistant Commandant (GD) against the vacancies arising out in
2013-2014. The Departmental Promotion Committee (DPC) meeting was
held on 26.07.2017 for considering the claims of eligible candidates against
the said vacancies. The claims of the respondents were also considered by
the Committee, and they were ultimately found fit for promotion to the post
of Assistant Commandant (GD) against the vacancies for the year 2013-
2014.
3. It may be noticed that, due to pendency of certain litigations
before the Delhi High Court at the instance of officers belonging to the
General Duty Cadre (Group 'A'), Telecom Cadre, Transport Cadre and Tailor
Specialist Cadre, challenging the combined seniority list for promotion to
the post in question, the promotions on the said post could not be effected. In
the meantime, the respondents retired from the service.
4. Thereafter, keeping in view the fact that the litigation had
attained finality, promotions were made to the post of Assistant
Commandant (GD) on the basis of the same recommendations made by the
Departmental Promotion Committee in its meeting dated 26.07.2017.
However, the benefit of promotion was not extended to the respondents by
placing reliance upon the Office Memorandum dated 14.11.2014 issued by
the Department of Personnel and Training, Government of India, which
NISHA
2026.11.20 13.31
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
CM-8045-LPA-2026 in/and -3-
LPA-3302-2026 (O&M)
provides that, in case an employee retires after the recommendations of the
Departmental Promotion Committee but before the issuance of the
promotion order, such an employee cannot claim a right to be granted
promotion.
5. Keeping in view the aforesaid grievance, the respondents filed
the writ petition, which has been allowed by the learned Single Judge. The
learned Single Judge held that, once there was no impediment in promoting
the respondents on the date when they were found fit by the Departmental
Promotion Committee, and there was no restraint order passed by any
competent Court of Law, the Government could not have withheld their
promotions merely on account of the pendency of the litigation. Ultimately,
after the litigation attained finality, the same recommendations of the
Departmental Promotion Committee were acted upon in respect of other
employees who had also been found fit for promotion, hence, denying the
benefit of promotion to the respondents merely on the ground that they had
retired in the meantime, despite having been found fit for promotion, was
held to be unjustified. Accordingly, a direction was issued to notionally
promote the respondents from the date on which they were found eligible, so
that they could be granted the designation as well as the pay scale of the post
in question on a notional basis, for the purpose of refixation of their retiral
benefits. The said order dated 24.03.2026 passed by the learned Single Judge
is under challenge in the present appeal.
6. Learned counsel for the appellant, has not been able to rebut the
facts narrated hereinbefore. The only argument raised is that, keeping in
view the Office Memorandum dated 14.11.2014 issued by the Government
NISHA
2026.11.20 13.31
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
CM-8045-LPA-2026 in/and -4-
LPA-3302-2026 (O&M)
of India, the benefit of promotion could not have been granted to the
respondents and, in the absence of any challenge to the said Office
Memorandum dated 14.11.2014, the grant of such benefit is not justified. It
is further contended that the learned Single Judge has exceeded the
jurisdiction vested in the writ Court.
7. We have heard learned counsel for the appellants and have gone
through the record with his able assistance.
8. It may be noticed that, while exercising jurisdiction under
Article 226 of the Constitution of India, the writ Court is required to
consider the merits of the matter as well as the equities involved, before
passing an appropriate order. The learned Single Judge has rightly found
equity in favour of the respondents by holding that, once they had been
found fit for promotion to the post of Assistant Commandant (GD) while
they were still in service, and the promotions could not be effected only on
account of the pendency of litigation, the respondents could not be denied
the benefit when, ultimately, after the litigation attained finality, especially
when the same recommendations of the Departmental Promotion Committee
were acted upon in respect of other employees against the vacancies for the
year 2013-2014. The respondents cannot be made to suffer prejudice on
account of the delay on the part of the authorities in acting upon the
recommendations of the Departmental Promotion Committee.
9. The aforesaid view is also supported by the judgment of the
Hon'ble Supreme Court of India in Major General H.M. Singh, VSM vs.
Union of India and another, 2014 (1) SCC (L&S) 649, wherein, in somewhat
similar circumstances, an officer who had been found fit for promotion by
NISHA
2026.11.20 13.31
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
CM-8045-LPA-2026 in/and -5-
LPA-3302-2026 (O&M)
the Departmental Promotion Committee could not be promoted before his
retirement. The Hon'ble Supreme Court, while considering the said
circumstances, issued directions for extending the benefit of promotion to
the officer by giving effect to the recommendations of the Departmental
Promotion Committee.
2
“ 2. The question that arises for consideration is, whether the non-
consideration of the claim of the appellant would violate the
fundamental rights vested in him under Articles 14 and 16 of the
Constitution of India. The answer to the aforesaid query would be in
the affirmative, subject to the condition, that the respondents were
desirous of filling the vacancy of Lieutenant General, when it
became available on 1.1.2007. The factual position depicted in the
counter affidavit reveals, that the respondents indeed were desirous
of filling up the said vacancy. In the above view of the matter, if the
appellant was the senior most serving Major General eligible for
consideration (which he undoubtedly was), he most definitely had
the fundamental right of being considered against the above
vacancy, and also the fundamental right of being promoted if he was
adjudged suitable. Failing which, he would be deprived of his
fundamental right of equality before the law, and equal protection of
the laws, extended by Article 14 of the Constitution of India. We are
of the view, that it was in order to extend the benefit of the
fundamental right enshrined under Article 14 of the Constitution of
India, that he was allowed extension in service on two occasions,
firstly by the Presidential order dated 29.2.2008, and thereafter, by a
further Presidential order dated 30.5.2008. The above orders clearly
depict, that the aforesaid extension in service was granted to the
appellant for a period of three months (and for a further period of
one month), or till the approval of the ACC, whichever is earlier. By
the aforesaid orders, the respondents desired to treat the appellant
justly, so as to enable him to acquire the honour of promotion to the
rank of Lieutenant General, (in case the recommendation made in
his favour by the Selection Board was approved by the Appointments
Committee of the Cabinet), stands affirmed. The action of the
authorities in depriving the appellant due consideration for
promotion to the rank of the Lieutenant General, would have
resulted in violation of his fundamental right under Article 14 of the
Constitution of India. Such an action at the hands of the respondents
would unquestionably have been arbitrary. We are therefore of the
view, firstly, that the order allowing extension in service of the
appellant for a period of three months, dated 29.2.2008, and the
order allowing further extension in service by one month to the
appellant, dated 30.5.2008, so as to enable his claim to be
considered for onward promotion to the rank of Lieutenant General,
cannot be held to be in violation of the statutory provisions. Rule
16A of the Army Rules, postulates extension in service, if the
exigencies of service so require. The said parameter must have been
duly taken into consideration when the Presidential Orders dated
29.2.2008 and 30.5.2008 were passed. The respondents have neither
NISHA
2026.11.20 13.31
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
CM-8045-LPA-2026 in/and -6-
LPA-3302-2026 (O&M)
revoked, nor sought revocation of the above orders. Therefore, it
does not lie in the mouth of the respondents to question the veracity
of the above orders. The above orders were passed to ensure due
consideration of the appellant’s claim for promotion to the rank of
Lieutenant General. Without rejecting the above claim on merits, the
appellant was deprived of promotion to the rank of Lieutenant
General. Besides the above, we are also of the considered view, that
consideration of the promotional claim of the senior most eligible
officer, would also fall in the parameters of the rule providing for
extension, if the exigencies of service so require. It would be a sad
day if the armed forces decline to give effect to the legitimate
expectations of the highest ranked armed forces personnel. Specially
when, blame for delay in such consideration, rests squarely on the
shoulders of the authorities themselves. This would lead to
individual resentment, bitterness, displeasure and indignation. This
could also undoubtedly lead to, outrage at the highest level of the
armed forces. Surely, extension of service, for the purpose granted to
the appellant, would most definitely fall within the realm of Rule 16A
of the Army Rules, unless of course, individual resentment,
bitterness, displeasure and indignation, of army personnel at the
highest level is of no concern to the authorities. Or alternatively, the
authorities would like to risk outrage at the highest level, rather than
doing justice to a deserving officer. Reliance on Rule 16A, to deprive
the appellant of promotion, to our mind, is just a lame excuse.
Accordingly, extension in service granted to the appellant, for all
intents and purposes, in our considered view, will be deemed to
satisfy the parameters of exigency of service, stipulated in Rule 16A
of the Army Rules.
23. While dealing with the issue of consideration of the appellant’s
claim for onward promotion to the rank of Lieutenant General, it is
necessary for us to also conclude by observing, that had the claim of
the appellant not been duly considered against the vacancy for the
post of Lieutenant General, which became available with effect from
1.1.2007, we would have had to hold, that the action was
discriminatory. This because, of denial of due consideration to the
appellant, who was the senior most eligible serving Major General,
as against the claim of others who were junior to him. And specially
when, the respondents desired to fill up the said vacancy, and also
because, the vacancy had arisen when the appellant still had 14
months of remaining Army service. Surely it cannot be over looked,
that the Selection Board had singularly recommended the name of
the appellant for promotion, out of a panel of four names. In such an
eventuality, we would have no other alternative but to strike down
the action of the authorities as being discriminatory and violative of
Article 16 of the Constitution of India.
24. The deliberations recorded by us hereinabove are incomplete,
inasmuch as, we have not answered the pointed objection raised by
the learned senior counsel for the respondent nos. 1 and 2, namely,
that an officer is not entitled to promotion during the period of
extension in service. For the instant objection raised at the hands of
the respondents, it is necessary to refer to the deliberations of the
Appointments Committee of the Cabinet, and specially paragraphs 8
and 9 thereof. A collective reading of the paragraphs 8 and 9 reveals
an extremely relevant objective, namely, situations wherein an
NISHA
2026.11.20 13.31
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
CM-8045-LPA-2026 in/and -7-
LPA-3302-2026 (O&M)
officer attains the age of retirement without there being a vacancy
for his consideration to a higher rank, even though he is eligible for
the same. Such an officer who is granted extension in service, cannot
claim consideration for promotion, against a vacancy which has
become available during the period of his extension in service. The
above conclusion drawn by us is clearly apparent from the
paragraph 9 of the proceedings of the Appointments Committee of
the Cabinet. In fact in the operative part of the proceedings recorded
in paragraph 11, it has been noticed, that .”…extensions motivated
by a promotion in the offing during the extension period cannot be
allowed…” We can derive only one meaning from the above
observations, namely, extension being granted for promotion against
a vacancy in the offing. That is to say, retention in service, so as to
consider an officer for a vacancy which has not become available
prior to his retirement, but is in the offing. The above reason
recorded in the operative part of the proceedings of the
Appointments Committee of the Cabinet, is laudible and legal.
Insofar as the present controversy is concerned, there is no doubt
whatsoever, that a clear vacancy against the rank of Lieutenant
General became available with effect from 1.1.2007. At that
juncture, the appellant had 14 months of service remaining. It is not
as if the vacancy came into existence after the appellant had reached
the age of retirement on superannuation. The present case is
therefore, not covered by the technical plea canvassed at the hands
of the learned senior counsel for the respondents. The denial of
promotion to the appellant mainly for the reason, that the appellant
was on extension in service, to our mind, is unsustainable besides
being arbitrary, specially in the light of the fact, that the vacancy for
which the appellant was clamouring consideration, became
available, well before the date of his retirement on superannuation.
We have, therefore, no hesitation in rejecting the basis on which the
claim of the appellant for onward promotion to the rank of
Lieutenant General was declined, by the Appointments Committee of
the Cabinet.
25. In view of the fact, that we have found the order of rejection of
the appellant’s claim for promotion to the rank of Lieutenant
General, on the ground that he was on extended service to be
invalid, we hereby set aside the operative part of the order of the
Appointments Committee of the Cabinet. It is also apparent, that the
Selection Board had recommended the promotion of the appellant on
the basis of his record of service, past performance, qualities of
leadership, as well as, vision, out of a panel of four names. In its
deliberations the Appointments Committee of the Cabinet, did not
record any reason to negate the aforesaid interference, relating to
the merit and suitability of the appellant. We are therefore of the
view, that the appellant deserves promotion to the rank of Lieutenant
General, from the date due to him. Ordered accordingly. On account
of his promotion to the post of Lieutenant General, the appellant
would also be entitled to continuation in service till the age of
retirement on superannuation stipulated for Lieutenant Generals,
i.e., till his having attained the age of 60 years. As such, the
appellant shall be deemed to have been in service against the rank of
Lieutenant General till 28.2.2009. Needless to mention, that the
appellant would be entitled to all monetary benefits which would
NISHA
2026.11.20 13.31
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
CM-8045-LPA-2026 in/and -8-
LPA-3302-2026 (O&M)
have been due to him, on account of his promotion to the rank of
Lieutenant General till his retirement on superannuation, as also, to
revised retiral benefits which would have accrued to him on account
of such promotion. The above monetary benefits shall be released to
the appellant within three months from the date a certified copy of
this order becomes available with the respondents. ”
10. The directions issued by the learned Single Judge, keeping in
view the facts and circumstances of the present case, are in consonance with
the settled principles of law laid down by the Hon'ble Supreme Court of
India in Major General H.M. Singh's case (supra). The aforesaid judgment
has not been distinguished by learned counsel for the appellant, nor has any
contrary legal position been brought to the notice of this Court.
11. The order is dictated in the open Court in the presence of
learned counsel for the parties. No further arguments have been raised.
12. Keeping in view the above, no ground is made out for
interference by this Court in the facts and circumstances of the present case.
Accordingly, the present appeal is dismissed.
13. Pending application(s), if any, stand disposed of.
(HARSIMRAN SINGH SETHI)
JUDGE
(MINDERJEET YADAV)
JUDGE
November 16, 2026
Nisha-1
Whether speaking/reasoned Yes
Whether reportable No
NISHA
2026.11.20 13.31
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document