The Chandigarh State Coop. Bank Ltd. vs Satish Kumar
- Court
- Punjab and Haryana High Court
IN THE HIGH COURT OF PUNJAB AND HARYANA AT CHANDIGARH
RSA No.5605 of 2014 (O&M)
The Chandigarh State Coop. Bank Ltd. and others . . . Appellants
vs.
Sa 0sh Kumar . . . Respondent
Reserved on: November 17, 2026
Pronounced on: November 19, 2026
Pronounced fully/opera0ve part : Fully
CORAM: HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE DEEPAK GUPTA
Argued By:- Mr. K.K. Gupta, Advocate for the appellants.
Mr. Jagdish Manchanda, Sr. Advocate (through V.C.) with
Mr. Shivam Gupta, Advocate for the respondent.
DEEPAK GUPTA, J.
The present regular second appeal, filed under Sec $on 100 of
the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 (hereina*er referred to as 'CPC'), is di-
rected against the judgment & decree dated 04.07.2014 passed by the
learned Addi$onal District Judge, Chandigarh, whereby the appeal preferred
by the defendants was dismissed, and the judgment & decree dated
19.10.2011 passed by the learned Civil Judge (Senior Division), Chandigarh,
decreeing the suit for possession by way of ejectment and mesne profits, was
affirmed.
2. The dispute pertains to a por$on of the building known as Durga
A7a Chakki, situated in village Dhanas, Union Territory, Chandigarh. The
respondent-plain$ff, claiming himself to be the owner of the premises,
inducted appellant-defendant No.1, Chandigarh State Coopera$ve Bank
SARITA RANI
2026.11.19 16:43
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
Chandigarh
RSA No.5605 of 2014 (O&M) 2026:PHHC: 203709
Limited, as a tenant in a por $on thereof on a monthly rent of ₹7,500/-. The
rent was being adjusted against the interest payable by the respondent on
the loan facility availed by him from the appellant-Bank.
3. The respondent terminated the tenancy by serving a no$ce
dated 21.05.2008 under Sec$on 106 of the Transfer of Property Act, 1882,
calling upon the appellants to vacate the premises. As possession was not
delivered, the respondent ins$tuted a civil suit seeking ejectment and
damages for use and occupa$on/mesne profits at the rate of ₹25,000/- per
month.
4. The appellants contested the suit primarily on the ground that
the demised premises were governed by the East Punjab Urban Rent
Restric$on Act, 1949, as extended to Chandigarh by the East Punjab Urban
Rent Restric$on (Extension to Chandigarh) Act, 1974. According to them, the
civil court lacked jurisdic$on to entertain the suit and the respondent could
seek evic$on only before the Rent Controller on the grounds prescribed
under Sec$on 13 of the 1949 Act. It was addi$onally pleaded that adjustment
of rent against the interest payable on the loan, even a*er issuance of the
no$ce termina$ng the tenancy, amounted to waiver of the no$ce.
5. The learned trial Court, on apprecia$on of the evidence, held
that village Dhanas was not shown to be an urban area covered by the rent
legisla$on. Consequently, the suit before the civil court was held
maintainable. The tenancy having been validly terminated, a decree for
possession was passed, besides mesne profits at the rate of ₹7,500/- per
month with effect from October 2011 un$l delivery of possession.
6. The learned First Appellate Court, a*er examining the statutory
provisions, par$cularly the East Punjab Urban Rent Restric$on (Extension to
Chandigarh) Act, 1974, the Capital of Punjab (Development and Regula$on)
Act, 1952, and the Punjab Reorganisa$on Act, 1966, affirmed the findings of
the trial Court.
SARITA RANI
2026.11.19 16:43
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
Chandigarh
Page 2 of 13
RSA No.5605 of 2014 (O&M) 2026:PHHC: 203709
7. Assailing the above said concurrent findings of the courts below,
Learned counsel for the appellants has confined his submissions before this
Court to the ques $on of jurisdic$on of the civil court. It is contended that
village Dhanas admi7edly forms part of the Union Territory of Chandigarh by
virtue of Sec$on 4 read with the Second Schedule of the Punjab
Reorganisa$on Act, 1966. Once the provisions of the East Punjab Urban Rent
Restric$on Act, 1949, stood extended to Chandigarh by the Act of 1974, the
demised premises necessarily came within the protec$ve ambit of the rent
legisla$on. It is thus urged that the courts below erred in trea$ng village
Dhanas as excluded merely because no separate no$fica$on declaring it to
be an urban area was produced.
8. Per contra , learned counsel for the respondent submits that the
expression 'Union Territory of Chandigarh' cannot be equated with the
expression 'urban area' as defined under the applicable rent legisla $on. It is
argued that the statutory defini$on specifically refers to the area comprising
the City of Chandigarh under the Capital of Punjab (Development and
Regula$on) Act, 1952, and such other areas as may be no$fied by the Central
Government. In the absence of any no$fica$on bringing village Dhanas within
the prescribed urban area, the provisions of the rent legisla$on are
inapplicable. The respondent accordingly supports the concurrent judgments.
9. In view of the limited controversy, the following substan$al
ques$on of law arises for considera$on:
Whether the mere inclusion of village Dhanas within the territorial limits
of the Union Territory of Chandigarh, under Sec $on 4 read with the
Second Schedule of the Punjab Reorganisa$on Act, 1966, renders the East
Punjab Urban Rent Restric$on Act, 1949, as extended by the Act of 1974,
applicable to the demised premises, thereby excluding the jurisdic$on of
the civil court?
10. Sec $on 9 CPC confers jurisdic$on upon civil courts to try all suits
of a civil nature except those of which cognizance is expressly or impliedly
SARITA RANI
2026.11.19 16:43
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
Chandigarh
Page 3 of 13
RSA No.5605 of 2014 (O&M) 2026:PHHC: 203709
barred. The exclusion of jurisdic $on is not to be readily inferred and must
follow from the language and scheme of the special enactment.
11. The East Punjab Urban Rent Restric$on Act, 1949, regulates the
rela$onship between landlords and tenants in the urban areas to which it
applies. Sec$on 2(j), as applicable to Chandigarh by virtue of the
modifica$ons introduced by the Act of 1974, defines 'urban area' as follows:
“"Urban area" means the area comprised in Chandigarh as defined in
clause (d) of Sec $on 2 of the Capital of Punjab (Development and
Regula$on) Act, 1952 (Punjab Act XXVII of 1952) and includes such other
area, comprised in the Union Territory of Chandigarh as the Central
Government may, having regard to the density of the popula$on and the
nature and extent of the accommoda$on available therein and other
relevant factors, declare by no$fica$on to be urban for the purposes of
this Act.”
12. Sec $on 2 of the East Punjab Urban Rent Restric$on (Extension to
Chandigarh) Act, 1974, defines the Act of 1949 by reference to its applica$on
in the specified areas of the erstwhile State of Punjab immediately before
01.11.1966.
13. Sec$on 3 of the Act of 1974 provides:
"Notwithstanding anything contained in any judgment, decree or order of
any Court, the Act shall, subject to the modifica $ons specified in the
Schedule, be in force in, and be deemed to have been in force with effect
from the 4th day of November, 1972 in the Union Territory of Chandigarh
as if the provisions of the Act as so modified had been included in and
formed part of this sec$on and as if this sec$on had been in force at all
material $mes."
14. The above provision is required to be read together with the
modified defini $on of 'urban area'. Although Sec$on 3 extends the
enactment to the Union Territory of Chandigarh, its opera$ve applica$on to
SARITA RANI
2026.11.19 16:43
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
Chandigarh
Page 4 of 13
RSA No.5605 of 2014 (O&M) 2026:PHHC: 203709
par $cular premises remains governed by the defini$ons and other provisions
of the Act as modified.
15. Sec$on 1(2) of the Capital of Punjab (Development and
Regula$on) Act, 1952, provides:
"It extends to the City of Chandigarh which shall comprise the areas of
the site of the Capital of Punjab as no $fied by the Government of Punjab
before the 1st November, 1966 and to such areas as may be no$fied by
the Central Government from $me to $me."
Sec $on 2(d) thereof defines ' ' to mean the area to which the said
Chandigarh
Act extends.
16. Sec $on 4 of the Punjab Reorganisa$on Act, 1966, reads as
under:
"On and from the appointed day, there shall be formed a new Union
Territory to be known as the Union Territory of Chandigarh comprising
such of the territories of Manimajra and Manauli Kanungo circles of
Kharar tehsil of Ambala district in the exis $ng State of Punjab as are
specified in the Second Schedule and thereupon the territories so
specified shall cease to form part of the exis$ng State of Punjab."
17. The Second Schedule to the Punjab Reorganisa $on Act, 1966,
specifically includes village Dhanas amongst the villages of the Manimajra
Kanungo circle transferred to the newly cons$tuted Union Territory of
Chandigarh.
18. A conjoint reading of the aforesaid statutory provisions makes it
evident that the territorial limits of the Union Territory of Chandigarh, as
cons$tuted under the Punjab Reorganisa$on Act, 1966, are not necessarily
co-extensive with the 'urban area' contemplated under the East Punjab
Urban Rent Restric$on Act, 1949, as extended to Chandigarh by the Act of
1974. While Sec$on 4 read with the Second Schedule of the Punjab
Reorganisa$on Act, 1966, determines the territories forming part of the
Union Territory, the applicability of the rent legisla$on to any par$cular area
SARITA RANI
2026.11.19 16:43
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
Chandigarh
Page 5 of 13
RSA No.5605 of 2014 (O&M) 2026:PHHC: 203709
is governed by the defini $on of ' urban area ' contained in Sec $on 2(j) of the
Act of 1949, as modified by the Act of 1974.
19. Consequently, the mere inclusion of village Dhanas within the
Union Territory of Chandigarh does not, by itself, establish that the demised
premises are governed by the rent legisla$on. For a7rac$ng its applicability,
it must further be established that village Dhanas either falls within the area
comprising the City of Chandigarh as defined under Sec$on 2(d) read with
Sec$on 1(2) of the Capital of Punjab (Development and Regula$on) Act,
1952, or has been separately declared an urban area by the Central
Government in exercise of the powers contemplated under the modified
Sec$on 2(j) of the Act of 1949. It is in this statutory context that the objec$on
regarding jurisdic$on of the civil court is required to be examined.
20. Undoubtedly, village Dhanas forms part of the Union Territory of
Chandigarh under Sec$on 4 read with the Second Schedule of the Punjab
Reorganisa$on Act, 1966. However, the said enactment was intended to
reorganise the erstwhile State of Punjab and cons$tute the successor States
and Union Territory. It does not, by itself, declare every village included
within the Union Territory to be an urban area for the purposes of every
other enactment.
21. The legislature, while extending the East Punjab Urban Rent
Restric$on Act, 1949 to Chandigarh, consciously adopted a specific defini$on
of 'urban area'. The defini$on comprises two dis$nct categories: firstly, the
area cons$tu$ng Chandigarh within the meaning of Sec$on 2(d) of the
Capital of Punjab (Development and Regula$on) Act, 1952; and secondly,
other areas situated within the Union Territory which may be declared urban
by no$fica$on of the Central Government.
22. The use of the expression " such other area " in the modified
defini $on is important. It indicates that the legislature did not intend
automa$cally to treat the en$re territory of Chandigarh as an urban area.
Otherwise, the provision authorising the Central Government to declare
SARITA RANI
2026.11.19 16:43
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
Chandigarh
Page 6 of 13
RSA No.5605 of 2014 (O&M) 2026:PHHC: 203709
addi $onal areas urban, a*er considering popula$on density, availability of
accommoda$on and other relevant factors, would become redundant.
23. Thus, the mere fact that a village was included in the Union
Territory under the Punjab Reorganisa$on Act, 1966, cannot dispense with
the requirement of establishing that it falls either within the no$fied area of
the City of Chandigarh under the 1952 Act or within an addi$onal area
declared urban for the purposes of the rent legisla$on.
24. In the present case, the courts below have concurrently
recorded that neither no$fica$on issued under Sec$on 1(2) of the Capital of
Punjab (Development and Regula$on) Act, 1952, bringing village Dhanas
within the City of Chandigarh, nor any no$fica$on issued under the modified
Sec$on 2(j) of the rent legisla$on declaring village Dhanas an urban area, was
produced.
25. The appellants have relied upon the Second Schedule to the
Punjab Reorganisa$on Act, 1966. However, that Schedule establishes the
territorial inclusion of village Dhanas in the Union Territory but does not
establish its inclusion within the separately defined urban area. The two
statutory concepts cannot be treated as interchangeable.
26. The conten$on that Sec$on 3 of the Act of 1974 extends the
rent legisla$on to the en$re Union Territory, irrespec$ve of the modified
defini$on of urban area, cannot be accepted. Such an interpreta$on would
render the statutory modifica$on defining urban area substan$ally o$ose.
The extension provision and the modified defini$on must be construed
harmoniously, giving effect to both.
27. It is well se7led that the exclusion of the jurisdic$on of the civil
court is not to be presumed. In Dhulabhai v. State of Madhya Pradesh, AIR
1969 SC 78 , the Hon'ble Supreme Court laid down the principles governing
exclusion of civil court jurisdic $on. Unless the dispute is shown to fall within
the field exclusively assigned to a special forum, the ordinary jurisdic$on
under Sec$on 9 CPC remains available.
SARITA RANI
2026.11.19 16:43
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
Chandigarh
Page 7 of 13
RSA No.5605 of 2014 (O&M) 2026:PHHC: 203709
28. Applying the aforesaid principles, it is evident that the appellants
have failed to establish the founda $onal fact necessary to a7ract the
statutory bar, namely, that the demised premises are situated within an
urban area to which the rent legisla$on applies. The mere existence of a
landlord-tenant rela$onship does not, by itself, a7ract the jurisdic$on of the
Rent Controller. Such jurisdic$on depends upon the applicability of the
special statute to the premises concerned.
29. The learned First Appellate Court has, therefore, rightly
dis$nguished between the geographical extent of the Union Territory and the
urban area contemplated by the rent legisla$on. Its conclusion that the suit
was maintainable before the civil court is founded upon a harmonious
interpreta$on of the relevant enactments and does not suffer from any legal
infirmity.
30. Once the applicability of the special rent legisla$on is excluded,
the rela$onship between the par$es is governed by the Transfer of Property
Act, 1882. The tenancy was terminated by no$ce dated 21.05.2008 under
Sec$on 106 thereof. The no$ce was admi7edly received and replied to by the
appellants. The courts below have found that the subsequent adjustment of
rent against the interest payable on the loan did not establish an inten$on on
the part of the respondent to treat the tenancy as subsis$ng. The ins$tu$on
of the suit for possession shortly therea*er was inconsistent with any such
inten$on.
31. Mere acceptance or adjustment of rent a*er issuance of a no$ce
to quit does not automa$cally cons$tute waiver within the meaning of
Sec$on 113 of the Transfer of Property Act. Waiver requires conduct
evidencing an inten$on to treat the lease as subsis$ng, with the consent of
the person to whom the no$ce was given. No such inten$on stands
established in the present case.
32. Since no other finding has been challenged before this Court, the
concurrent findings concerning the landlord-tenant rela$onship, termina$on
of tenancy and en$tlement to possession do not call for further examina$on.
SARITA RANI
2026.11.19 16:43
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
Chandigarh
Page 8 of 13
RSA No.5605 of 2014 (O&M) 2026:PHHC: 203709
33. Accordingly, the substan $al ques$on of law framed above is
answered against the appellants and in favour of the respondent, holding
that the inclusion of village Dhanas within the Union Territory of Chandigarh
does not, by itself, establish applicability of the East Punjab Urban Rent
Restric$on Act, 1949, as extended by the Act of 1974, and consequently does
not oust the jurisdic$on of the civil court.
Applica "on for mesne profits
34. During pendency of the present appeal, the respondent-landlord
has filed CM No.3650-C of 2015 under Sec $on 151 CPC, seeking a direc$on to
the appellant-Bank to pay mesne profits at the prevailing market rate of
₹70,000/- per month from the date of decree dated 19.10.2011 un$l delivery
of vacant possession.
35. The applica$on has been contested by the appellants by filing a
detailed reply.
36. Learned counsel for the respondent submits that
notwithstanding the concurrent decrees for possession, the appellants have
con$nued to occupy the premises under the protec$on of the interim order
dated 01.12.2014 passed by this Court. It is argued that the premises are
being u$lised for commercial banking ac$vi$es and that comparable
accommoda$on commands rent between ₹70,000/- and ₹1,00,000/- per
month. Reliance is placed upon Atma Ram Proper "es (P) Ltd. v. Federal
Motors (P) Ltd., (2005) 1 SCC 705; State of Maharashtra v. Super Max
Interna"onal (P) Ltd., (2009) 9 SCC 772; and R.K. Bansal v. Jag Pravesh
Sharma, 2012 (2) RCR (Rent) 203 .
37. Learned counsel for the appellants opposes the applica $on,
submiSng that the very jurisdic$on of the civil court is under challenge. It is
further argued that the respondent had earlier accepted the arrangement for
adjustment of rent against interest payable on the loan account and had
even sought enhancement of rent by correspondence. It is contended that
the trial Court, a*er apprecia$ng the evidence, had already assessed mesne
profits at ₹7,500/- per month, which determina$on was not challenged by
SARITA RANI
2026.11.19 16:43
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
Chandigarh
Page 9 of 13
RSA No.5605 of 2014 (O&M) 2026:PHHC: 203709
the respondent. Consequently, enhancement to ₹70,000/- per month,
without independent evidence of the prevailing market rent, is stated to be
impermissible.
38. The rival submissions require examina $on in the light of the
dis$nc$on between mesne profits awarded under a decree and
compensa$on which an appellate court may direct an unsuccessful tenant to
pay as a condi$on for enjoying the benefit of stay of execu$on.
39. Sec$on 2(12) CPC defines ‘mesne profits’ as those profits, which
the person in wrongful possession of property actually received or might,
with ordinary diligence, have received therefrom, together with interest on
such profits, excluding profits a7ributable to improvements made by the
person in wrongful possession.
40. Order XX Rule 12 CPC empowers the civil court, in a suit for
recovery of possession and mesne profits, to pass a decree for possession
and to determine rent or mesne profits, including by direc$ng an inquiry
where necessary, subject to the limita$ons contained in that provision.
41. Order XLI Rule 5 CPC provides that an appeal shall not operate as
a stay of proceedings under the decree appealed from unless the appellate
court so orders. Sub-rule (3) thereof prescribes the condi$ons relevant to
grant of stay of execu$on. The power to impose appropriate condi$ons while
gran$ng or con$nuing stay is exercisable to protect the successful decree-
holder from prejudice arising from postponement of execu$on.
42. In Atma Ram Proper "es (P) Ltd. (supra), the Hon'ble Supreme
Court recognised that, a *er an evic$on decree, an appellate court may, while
staying execu$on, direct the tenant to pay compensa$on for use and
occupa$on at a rate reasonably reflec$ng the prevailing market rent. The
purpose is to ensure that the decree-holder is not deprived of the fruits of
the decree without appropriate compensa$on merely because the tenant
has pursued an appellate remedy.
SARITA RANI
2026.11.19 16:43
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
Chandigarh
Page 10 of 13
RSA No.5605 of 2014 (O&M) 2026:PHHC: 203709
43. In Super Max Interna "onal (P) Ltd. (supra), the Hon'ble
Supreme Court reiterated that an appellate court may impose reasonable
condi $ons for con$nua$on of stay, including payment of compensa$on at a
rate higher than the contractual rent. However, the amount fixed must be
reasonable and must not be excessive, oppressive or puni$ve.
44. Thus, the power to impose market-rate occupa$on charges as a
condi$on of stay is dis$nct from the adjudica$on of mesne profits under
Order XX Rule 12 CPC. The former is incidental to the exercise of appellate
jurisdic$on and is intended to balance the equi$es during the period for
which execu$on remains stayed.
45. In the present case, the trial Court awarded mesne profits at the
rate of ₹7,500/- per month with effect from October 2011 un$l delivery of
possession. The said determina$on was made in the year 2011. However, the
appellant-Bank has con$nued to occupy the demised premises during
pendency of the present appeal under the protec$on of the interim order
dated 01.12.2014 passed by this Court.
46. The ques$on, therefore, is whether the respondent-landlord
should be confined to the rate determined in 2011 notwithstanding the
prolonged occupa$on of the premises by the appellants under the protec$on
of an interim order.
47. The answer must be in the nega$ve insofar as the condi$ons
governing con$nua$on of stay are concerned. The compensa$on payable by
a tenant for con$nuing in possession under the protec$on of an interim
order staying execu$on of an evic$on decree stands on a foo$ng dis$nct
from the mesne profits determined under the decree itself. As already
no$ced hereinabove, the appellate court is empowered to impose
reasonable condi$ons for protec$ng the interests of the successful landlord
during pendency of the appeal. Such compensa$on is intended to prevent
the tenant from deriving an undue advantage from the interim protec$on
granted by the Court and to ensure that the decree-holder is not unfairly
deprived of the fruits of the decree during pendency of the appeal.
SARITA RANI
2026.11.19 16:43
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
Chandigarh
Page 11 of 13
RSA No.5605 of 2014 (O&M) 2026:PHHC: 203709
48. It cannot be overlooked that the appellant is a coopera $ve bank
carrying on commercial ac$vi$es from the demised premises. The contractual
rent of ₹7,500/- per month, which also formed the basis of the decree passed
in 2011, cannot reasonably be regarded as an adequate measure of
compensa$on for the con$nued occupa$on of such premises over the
prolonged period during which execu$on of the decree remained stayed. To
permit the appellants to retain possession throughout this period without
paying any amount beyond the rate determined in 2011 would confer upon
them a substan$al advantage arising from the interim protec$on granted by
this Court.
49. At the same $me, the respondent's claim for occupa$on charges
at ₹70,000/- per month is not supported by comparable lease deeds or other
sa$sfactory evidence establishing the prevailing market rental value of
similarly situated premises. The amount claimed, therefore, cannot be
accepted in its en$rety.
50. Nevertheless, considering the commercial character of the
premises, the nature of their use by the appellant-Bank, the considerable
passage of $me since the decree and the fact that possession has con$nued
under the protec$on of this Court, an appropriate and reasonable amount
deserves to be fixed.
51. Having regard to the totality of these circumstances, this Court
considers ₹25,000/- per month to be a reasonable amount towards use and
occupa$on charges for the period during which the appellants enjoyed the
benefit of the interim order.
52. Accordingly, in exercise of the powers under Order XLI Rule 5
read with Sec$on 151 CPC, the appellant-Bank is directed to pay to the
respondent-landlord occupa$on charges at the rate of ₹25,000/- per month
with effect from 01.12.2014 un$l delivery of vacant possession of the
demised premises. The amount so determined is in subs$tu$on for, and not
in addi$on to, the mesne profits of ₹7,500/- per month awarded under the
decree for the corresponding period. All amounts already paid or deposited
SARITA RANI
2026.11.19 16:43
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
Chandigarh
Page 12 of 13
RSA No.5605 of 2014 (O&M) 2026:PHHC: 203709
towards rent, mesne profits or occupa $on charges for the said period shall be
duly adjusted. For the period preceding 01.12.2014, the mesne profits
awarded under the decree shall remain payable in accordance with its terms.
53. The aforesaid direc$on is intended to balance the equi$es
between the par$es and to compensate the respondent for the con$nued
occupa$on of the premises under the protec$on of the interim order passed
by this Court. It shall not be construed as a modifica$on of the decree
regarding mesne profits, but as an independent direc$on concerning
occupa$on charges for the period of stay. CM No.3650-C of 2015 is
accordingly partly allowed.
Conclusion
54. In view of the discussion made hereinabove, this Court finds no
illegality or perversity in the concurrent judgments and decrees passed by the
courts below. The interpreta $on placed by the learned First Appellate Court
upon the relevant statutory provisions is legally sustainable. No ground for
interference under Sec$on 100 CPC is made out.
55. Consequently, the present regular second appeal is dismissed,
and the judgment and decree dated 04.07.2014 passed by the learned First
Appellate Court, affirming the judgment and decree dated 19.10.2011 of the
trial Court, are upheld.
56. The interim order dated 01.12.2014 stands vacated. The
respondent-decree-holder shall be at liberty to execute the decree in
accordance with law. The appellant-Bank shall also be liable to pay
occupa$on charges in terms of paragraphs 51 and 52 above, a*er adjustment
of amounts already paid or deposited.
57. All other pending miscellaneous applica$ons, if any, stand
disposed of.
November 19, 2026
Sarita
(DEEPAK GUPTA)
JUDGE
Whether speaking/reasoned? : Yes/No
Whether reportable? : Yes/No
Uploaded on: November 19, 2026
SARITA RANI
2026.11.19 16:43
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
Chandigarh
Page 13 of 13