Mahinder Singh Since Deceased Through Lrs vs Pratap Singh
- Court
- Delhi High Court
$~
* IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
st
Reserved on: 21 August, 2026
th
Pronounced on: 20 November, 2026
# CNR No. DLHC011879242014
+ RFA 488/2014 & CM APPL.17876/2026
SH. MAHINDER SINGH SINCE DECEASED THROUGH LR’S
.....Appellant
Through: Mr. Arvind K. Nigam & Mr. Rajesh
Yadav, Sr. Advs. with Mr. Neeraj
Yadav & Mr. Dhananjay Mehlawat,
Advs.
Versus
SH. PRATAP SINGH .....Respondent
Through: Mr. Uttam Datt & Ms. Malvika
Trivedi, Sr. Advs. with Mr. Charan S.
Verma, Mr. Bharat Deepak, Mr.
Shailendra Slaria, Ms. Sonakshi Singh,
Mr. Ajay Avinashi & Mr. Naman
Kumar, Advs.
# CNR No. DLHC012119262014
+ RFA 615/2014, CM APPL. 3196/2026 & CM APPL. 4366/2026
MR. PRATAP SINGH .....Appellant
Through: Mr. Uttam Datt & Ms. Malvika
Trivedi, Sr. Advs. with Mr. Charan S.
Verma, Mr. Bharat Deepak, Mr.
Shailendra Slaria, Ms. Sonakshi Singh,
Mr. Ajay Avinashi & Mr. Naman
Kumar, Advs.
Signature Not Verified
Digitally Signed By:BHASKAR
SINGH RAWAT
Signing Date:21.11.2026
14:09:04
RFA 488/2014 & conn. Page 1 of 74
versus
MR. MAHINDER SINGH THR LRS .....Respondent
Through: Mr. Arvind K. Nigam & Mr. Rajesh
Yadav, Sr. Advs. with Mr. Neeraj
Yadav & Mr. Dhananjay Mehlawat,
Advs.
CORAM:
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE AMIT SHARMA
JUDGMENT
AMIT SHARMA, J.
1. The present cross-appeals arise out of the judgment and decree dated
1
11.09.2014 , passed by the learned ADJ-12, Central District, Tis Hazari
2
Courts, Delhi , in CS No. 53/11/98, titled as “Pratap Singh v. Mahinder Singh
3
and Ors.” , whereby the suit instituted by the original Plaintiff, i.e. , Mr. Pratap
4 5
Singh , against the original Defendants, i.e. , late Mr. Mahinder Singh , was
partly decreed with costs. Aggrieved by the impugned judgment, both the
parties have preferred the present appeals. RFA No. 488/2014 has been
preferred by the original Defendant, whereas RFA No. 615/2014 has been
preferred by the original Plaintiff.
2. The Plaintiff had initially instituted a suit seeking a decree of
permanent injunction in respect of property bearing Municipal No. RZ-33B/1,
1
Impugned Judgment
2
Learned ADJ/Learned Trial Court
3
Subject Suit
4
Plaintiff
5
Defendant
Signature Not Verified
Digitally Signed By:BHASKAR
SINGH RAWAT
Signing Date:21.11.2026
14:09:04
RFA 488/2014 & conn. Page 2 of 74
6
Kishangarh, Mehrauli, Delhi . The case of the Plaintiff was that he was the
owner and in possession of the suit property, and that the Defendant was
interfering with his possession and obstructing the construction being carried
out by him. The Defendant had contested the subject suit and, inter alia ,
disputed the Plaintiff’s claim with respect to the suit property, asserting that
the suit property was in his possession and it was bearing Municipal No. RZ-
33B/7 and not RZ-33B/1, and that the same had fallen to the Defendant’s
share pursuant to a family arrangement/partition amongst the four sons of late
Shri Prabhu, i.e. , father of the parties.
3. During the pendency of the subject suit, a Local Commissioner was
appointed by the learned ADJ, who inspected the suit property on 03.06.1998.
The report of the Local Commissioner dated 03.06.1998 recorded that while
conducting the commission, the gates of the suit property were opened by the
Defendant and that no electricity meter was found installed at the suit
property. Subsequently, the plaint was amended by the Plaintiff on
13.03.2006 and a claim for possession was incorporated, alleging that the
Plaintiff had been forcibly dispossessed from the property by the Defendant
on 14.02.2006. The Plaintiff had also pleaded ownership of the suit property
by contending that the said property was transferred to him out of love and
affection by late Shri Hari Singh, i.e. , the younger brother of his grandfather.
4. The learned ADJ, after considering the pleadings and evidence led by
the parties, had framed the following issues for consideration: -
6
Suit Property
Signature Not Verified
Digitally Signed By:BHASKAR
SINGH RAWAT
Signing Date:21.11.2026
14:09:04
RFA 488/2014 & conn. Page 3 of 74
“1) Whether the suit is bad for non-joinder of necessary party? OPP
2) Whether the plaintiff is owner and in possession of suit property? OPP
3) Whether the plaintiff is entitled for relief as claimed? OPP
4) Whether the suit has not been properly valued for the purposes of
court fee and jurisdiction? OPP
5) Whether the plaintiff has been dispossessed forcibly by the defendant
during the pendency of case on 14.02.2006? OPP
6) Whether the plaintiff is entitled for recovery of possession, as
claimed? OPP
7) Relief.”
Vide the impugned judgment and decree dated 11.09.2014, the subject
suit was partly decreed by the learned ADJ while holding that the suit
property would be deemed to be jointly held by the Plaintiff, the Defendant
and other family members of late Shri Prabhu. Hence, the present cross-
appeals.
S UBMISSIONS ON BEHALF OF THE DEFENDANT
5. At the outset, learned Senior Counsels for the Defendant submitted that
the learned ADJ had passed the impugned judgment in the nature of a
declaration, when neither the relief sought by the Plaintiff, nor the foundation
for entitlement to such relief had been sought in the pleading by the Plaintiff,
or in the evidence. In support of the said submission, learned Senior Counsels
placed reliance upon the judgment passed by the Hon’ble Supreme Court in
Signature Not Verified
Digitally Signed By:BHASKAR
SINGH RAWAT
Signing Date:21.11.2026
14:09:04
RFA 488/2014 & conn. Page 4 of 74
7
Bachhaj Nahar v. Nilima Mandan & Anr. and particularly upon
paragraphs 10, 11, 12 & 13 thereof.
6. Learned Senior Counsels had further submitted that the relief granted
by the learned ADJ vide the impugned judgment was never pleaded in the
pleadings by the Plaintiff, and rather a suo moto relief was granted. It was
further submitted that the Plaintiff had set up an independent claim qua the
suit property on the basis of a right derived from late Shri Hari Singh, i.e. ,
younger brother of his grandfather, and the said fact could not be proved by
the Plaintiff. In support of the said contention, reliance was placed on the
judgment passed by the Hon’ble Supreme Court in Kalyan Singh Chouhan
8
v. C.P. Joshi and particularly upon paragraph 19.
7. Learned Senior Counsels had further submitted that the Plaintiff failed
to prove his title and previous possession of the suit property, and the learned
ADJ, while rendering the impugned judgment had observed that the parties
could not prove their respective claims qua the suit property.
8. Learned Senior Counsels for the Defendant drew attention of this Court
to the Report of the Local Commissioner dated 03.06.1998 to contend that the
said report made it abundantly clear that the Plaintiff was not in possession of
the suit property as on 03.06.1998. It was further submitted that on account of
the same, the relief of injunction, as claimed by the Plaintiff in the subject
suit, was not maintainable.
7
(2008) 17 SCC 491
8
(2011) 11 SCC 786
Signature Not Verified
Digitally Signed By:BHASKAR
SINGH RAWAT
Signing Date:21.11.2026
14:09:04
RFA 488/2014 & conn. Page 5 of 74
9. Learned Senior Counsels had further submitted that finding of the
learned ADJ that the suit property constituted a joint holding and that there
had been no partition between the parties was erroneous and the same was
arrived at under the influence of an incorrect Memo of Parties filed by the
Plaintiff. It was further submitted that the material on record demonstrated
that the father of the parties, during his lifetime, had orally partitioned his
properties amongst his four sons, and the said partition was equitable and was
acted upon by the parties, and subsequently, the same was reduced into
writing through various registered documents.
10. Learned Senior Counsels had further submitted that the learned ADJ
had wrongly discarded the documents relied upon by the Defendant, merely
because the said documents were disputed by the Plaintiff. It was further
submitted that the documents in question were registered documents, and the
same were duly proved in accordance with law. Learned Senior Counsels had
further submitted that the relevant records had been summoned from the
Office of the Sub-Registrar, and the attesting witness had also been examined
during the course of trial, thereby satisfying the requirements of Section 68 of
the Indian Evidence Act, 1872. It was further contended that once the
documents have been duly proved, the evidentiary burden shifted upon the
Plaintiff to disprove the said documents, which burden the Plaintiff failed to
discharge. In support of the same, learned Senior Counsels placed reliance
upon the judgment passed by the Hon’ble Supreme Court in Prem Singh &
9
Ors. v. Birbal & Ors.
9
(2006) 5 SCC 353
Signature Not Verified
Digitally Signed By:BHASKAR
SINGH RAWAT
Signing Date:21.11.2026
14:09:04
RFA 488/2014 & conn. Page 6 of 74
11. Learned Senior Counsels had further submitted that the learned ADJ
had failed to appreciate the fact that the Plaintiff had been beneficiary of the
family arrangement/partition relied upon by the Defendant. It was further
contended that the Plaintiff, after having derived benefits from the said
partition, could not turn around and challenge the same for the purposes of
maintaining the subject suit.
12. Learned Senior Counsels further drew attention of this Court to
Criminal Writ Petition No. 892/1998, filed by the Plaintiff before this Court,
aggrieved by the alleged removal of the electricity meter from the suit
property by the Defendant. It was submitted by the learned Senior Counsels
that the reply affidavit filed in the said proceedings by Mr. P.K. Bharadwaj,
Deputy Commissioner of Police, South-West District, Delhi, materially
contradicted the case set up by the Plaintiff before the learned ADJ. It was
further contended that the contents of the said affidavit demonstrated falsity
and inconsistency in the Plaintiff’s claim qua his possession and entitlement
in respect of the suit property.
13. Learned Senior Counsels had further submitted that in view of the
reply affidavit filed by the DCP, the Criminal Writ Petition filed by the
Plaintiff was dismissed vide order dated 20.07.1999, which had attained
finality, as the said order was never challenged by the Plaintiff.
14. Learned Senior Counsels had further submitted that the Plaintiff was
required to succeed on the strength of his own case, and he could not derive
any advantage merely from an alleged weakness in the Defendant’s case. It
Signature Not Verified
Digitally Signed By:BHASKAR
SINGH RAWAT
Signing Date:21.11.2026
14:09:04
RFA 488/2014 & conn. Page 7 of 74
was further contended that the suit had been instituted by the Plaintiff on the
basis of an alleged title to the suit property, and therefore, the primary burden
was upon him to establish the same by placing sufficient evidence on record.
It was further contended that the learned ADJ, having itself observed that the
parties had not been able to establish their respective claims, could not have
proceeded to partly decree the subject suit, merely on the basis of the alleged
failure of the Defendant to establish the title set up by him. In support of the
same, reliance was placed upon the judgment passed by the Hon’ble Supreme
Court in Ramchandra Sakharam Mahajan v. Damodar Trimbak
10
Tanksale (Dead) & Ors. , particularly upon paragraph 13, and the judgment
11
passed by this Court in Harish Mansukhani v. Ashok Jain , particularly
upon paragraphs 18, 22 & 23.
15. Learned Senior Counsels for the Defendant had further submitted that
there was a cloud over the Plaintiff’s title over the suit property on account of
the competing claim raised by the Defendant, and therefore, the Plaintiff
could not have maintained a suit for possession/injunction without seeking
declaration of title. In this regard, learned Senior Counsels had placed reliance
upon the judgment passed by the Hon’ble Supreme Court in Anathula
12
Sudhakar v. P. Buchi Reddy (D) By LRs & Ors. , and particularly upon
paragraphs 13.3, 14, 21 & 29.
16. Learned Senior Counsels had further submitted that the learned ADJ
had failed to appreciate the legal effect of the family arrangement relied upon
10
(2007) 6 SCC 737
11
2009 (2) AD (Delhi) 30 Lawpack
12
(2008) 4 SCC 594
Signature Not Verified
Digitally Signed By:BHASKAR
SINGH RAWAT
Signing Date:21.11.2026
14:09:04
RFA 488/2014 & conn. Page 8 of 74
by the Defendant. It was further submitted that a family arrangement could be
entered into orally and in support of the same, reliance was placed upon the
judgment passed by the Hon’ble Supreme Court in Kale v. Dy. Director of
13
Consolidation , and particularly upon paragraph 10.
17. Learned Senior Counsels had further submitted that family
arrangements are governed by a special equity principle and it is the duty of
Courts to uphold and give full effect to a family agreement. In this regard,
reliance was placed on the judgment passed by the Hon’ble Supreme Court in
14
Hari Shankar Singhania v. Gaur Hari Singhania , and particularly upon
paragraphs 42 to 58. It was further submitted that the said judgment was not
taken into consideration by the learned ADJ while passing the impugned
judgment.
18. Learned Senior Counsels for the Defendant had further submitted that
the Plaintiff had taken inconsistent and contradictory pleas at different stages
of the proceedings. It was further contended that there were material
variations between the case set up in the original plaint, the amended plaint,
the affidavits of evidence filed by the Plaintiff and his deposition during the
cross-examination. It was further submitted that the Plaintiff had repeatedly
shifted his stand qua the source of his alleged title, his possession over the
suit property and the circumstances in which he claimed entitlement thereto.
13
(1976) 3 SCC 119
14
(2006) 4 SCC 658
Signature Not Verified
Digitally Signed By:BHASKAR
SINGH RAWAT
Signing Date:21.11.2026
14:09:04
RFA 488/2014 & conn. Page 9 of 74
19. Learned Senior Counsels had further submitted that the Plaintiff could
not be permitted to approbate and reprobate by taking inconsistent stands
according to the stage of the suit proceedings. In support of the same, reliance
was placed upon the judgments passed by the Hon’ble Supreme Court in
15
Garre Mallikharjuna Rao & Ors. v. Nalabothu Punniah , and particularly
upon paragraphs 6, 9 & 15 and Devasahayam (dead) by LRs v. P.
16
Savithramma & Ors. , and particularly upon paragraphs 29 and 33 .
20. Learned Senior Counsels for the Defendant further submitted that the
amended plaint, as filed by the Plaintiff, was a suit for possession based on
title, with relief of permanent injunction. Attention of this Court was drawn to
Issue No. 2 framed in the subject suit. The said issue reads as under: -
“Whether the plaintiff is owner and in possession of suit property? OPP”
In view of the above, learned Senior Counsels submitted that the
Plaintiff led evidence on the issue as framed without seeking any amendment
and striking out the said issue. It was further submitted that it was imperative
for the Plaintiff to prove his ownership/title in respect of the suit property, in
order to succeed, as the burden of proof was on him by virtue of Sections 104,
105 & 109 of the Indian Evidence Act, 1872.
21. Learned Senior Counsels had further submitted that during the course
of oral hearing in the subject suit, the Plaintiff had laid stress on the fact that
an electricity meter was installed in the suit property and to buttress the said
15
(2013) 4 SCC 546
16
(2005) 7 SCC 653
Signature Not Verified
Digitally Signed By:BHASKAR
SINGH RAWAT
Signing Date:21.11.2026
14:09:04
RFA 488/2014 & conn. Page 10 of 74
plea, the Plaintiff had sought to rely upon a certificate issued by DESU,
photograph of the electricity meter and electricity bills pertaining to the
months of January and March, 1998. It was further submitted that the said
documents were not proved as per law, since no witness from the erstwhile
DESU, DVB or BSES Rajdhani was examined by the Plaintiff. It was further
submitted that if the witnesses were not appearing despite summons, as was
contended by the Plaintiff, then recourse ought to have been taken to Order
XVI Rule 12 of the CPC, to compel appearance of the said witnesses. It was
further submitted by the learned Senior Counsels that the said documents, do
not, in any manner, demonstrate that an electricity meter was installed in the
property bearing No. RZ-33B/7.
22. Learned Senior Counsels further drew attention to the Report of the
Local Commissioner dated 03.06.1998, to contend that even the said report
found that no electricity meter was installed at the suit property. It was further
submitted that mere observation of the Local Commissioner to the effect that
there was a board and an electrical wire hanging in the air in no manner
proves that there existed an electricity meter belonging to the Plaintiff.
23. Learned Senior Counsels further drew attention of the Court to the
affidavit filed by the Mr. P.K. Bharadwaj, Deputy Commissioner of Police,
South-West District, Delhi, wherein it was clearly stated that the place of
occurrence of the incident was RZ-33B/7, and as per the report received and
inquiries made by the DESU authorities, no electricity meter was installed at
the said premises, and therefore, the question of its theft did not and could not
arise. It was further submitted that the said affidavit stated that when the
Signature Not Verified
Digitally Signed By:BHASKAR
SINGH RAWAT
Signing Date:21.11.2026
14:09:04
RFA 488/2014 & conn. Page 11 of 74
police officers arrived at the suit property, the Defendant opened the door and
stated that he was in possession and occupation of the said house and no
incident of breaking of locks or any quarrel took place there. It was further
stated in the said affidavit that the Plaintiff was asked to accompany the
Police Officer to the place of occurrence, but he refused to do so by stating
that he wanted to lodge the report, which he had lodged. It was further stated
in the said affidavit that the Plaintiff did not co-operate with the Police and no
cognizable offence was found to have been committed, and thus, the DD was
filed. Learned Senior Counsels had contended that the only intention of the
Plaintiff was to create false evidence and cause of action to file the present
suit, and no rejoinder to the reply affidavit of the DCP was filed by the
Plaintiff, and therefore, the facts stated in the said affidavit were admitted by
the Plaintiff.
24. Learned Senior Counsels had further submitted that the reliance placed
by the Plaintiff upon an Inspection Report for property tax of the year 1983,
assessment order dated 01.04.1997 and payment of House Tax receipts of the
years 1996, 1997 and 1998, issued in respect of property bearing No. RZ-
33B/1, is misplaced, as the same do not pertain to the suit property. Learned
Senior Counsels had submitted that the suit property bears the Municipal No.
RZ-33B/7. It was further submitted that PW1/2A, Shri Bhagwan, UDC from
MCD, Najafgarh had brought the summoned records pertaining to the House
Tax Assessment file in respect of House Nos. 33B/1, 33B/3 to 33B/11. It was
further submitted that in his cross-examination, the said witness had stated
that he does not personally know about which property the assessment record
of EX.PW2A/1 to PW2A/20 pertain to. It was further submitted that the said
Signature Not Verified
Digitally Signed By:BHASKAR
SINGH RAWAT
Signing Date:21.11.2026
14:09:04
RFA 488/2014 & conn. Page 12 of 74
witness admitted that there were no ownership documents in the mentioned
files of EX.PW2A/1 to PW2A/20. It was further submitted that the said
witness had deposed that he cannot say as to who was the owner and who was
in possession of the mentioned properties, as he was deposing on the basis of
record.
25. Learned Senior Counsels further drew attention of this Court to
EX.PW2A/16, i.e. , the inspection form of property No. RZ-33B/7,
Kishangarh, and the name of the assessee therein had been mentioned as
“Mohinder Singh son of Prabhu”, i.e. , the Defendant. It was submitted that
the date of inspection in the said form was mentioned as 27.03.1986, and the
said document was duly proved by the Plaintiff. It was, therefore, submitted
that the suit property was bearing No. RZ-33B/7 and the same belonged to the
Defendant, and the said fact demolishes the case of the Plaintiff.
26. Learned Senior Counsels had further submitted that the Defendant had
also proved the House Tax Records of the suit property, i.e. , Municipal No.
RZ-33B/7, as EX.DW1/5 (Colly), which are dated 27.03.1986, 30.03.1986
and 10.11.2003, and thus, it was evident that the Defendant had deposited the
property tax of the suit property, even after the year 1998. It was further
submitted that the property tax documents pertaining to property No. RZ-
33B/1, which the Plaintiff allegedly claims to be the suit property, were of the
period prior to March, 1998.
27. Learned Senior Counsels had further submitted that EX. PW2/A had
been wrongly described by the Plaintiff to be an Assessment Report dated
Signature Not Verified
Digitally Signed By:BHASKAR
SINGH RAWAT
Signing Date:21.11.2026
14:09:04
RFA 488/2014 & conn. Page 13 of 74
16.03.2006; however, the date 16.03.2006, appearing on top of EX. PW-2A/1
to EX. PW-2A/6, is the date on which these documents were provided under
the RTI Act, and not the date of the documents. In view of the same, it was
contended that it is clear that after March 1998, no property tax was
paid/deposited by the Plaintiff, even in respect of property No. RZ-33B/1.
28. Learned Senior Counsels had submitted that it is settled law that
municipal revenue records, electricity bills, house tax receipts etc. do not
establish title over a property. In support of the said contention, reliance was
placed upon the following judgments: -
17
i. Neelam Kapoor & Ors. v. Bhag Chand & Ors. , paragraph 10 (i);
18
ii. Jai Singh Thr. Lrs. V. Harbans Singh Thr. Lrs. , paragraph 29;
19
iii. Re-M/s. JVG Finance Ltd. , paragraph 14.
29. Learned Senior Counsels had further submitted that the Plaintiff had
relied upon the complaints filed on 14.02.2006, and the said complaints are
self-serving, as the same were filed with a view to create a false cause of
action for amending the plaint. It was further submitted that the Defendant
had always been in possession of the suit property, and the said fact had been
duly noted by the Local Commissioner in his Report, as well as by the Deputy
Commissioner of Police in his affidavit in the year 1998. It was further
submitted that the Plaintiff in his cross-examination dated 01.03.2005, had
himself admitted that at the time of visit of the Local Commissioner, the lock
of the Defendant was in the suit property, and the same was opened by the
17
2017 SCC OnLine Del 10262
18
2016 SCC OnLine Del 3898
19
2016 SCC OnLine Del 3898
Signature Not Verified
Digitally Signed By:BHASKAR
SINGH RAWAT
Signing Date:21.11.2026
14:09:04
RFA 488/2014 & conn. Page 14 of 74
Defendant, which fact proves possession of the Defendant over the suit
premises, and therefore, the contention of the Plaintiff that he was
dispossessed from the suit property on 14.02.2006 is misconceived.
30. Qua the testimony of Mr. B.P. Singh, Civil Engineer, PW-3, it was
submitted by the learned Senior Counsels that the said witness failed to
produce any engagement letter or proof of payment by the Plaintiff. It was
further submitted that the said witness failed to show any documentary
evidence that he had raised any construction on the suit property. It was
further argued that the said witness failed to identify the suit property from
the photographs exhibited by the Plaintiff as EX.PW1/72 to EX.PW1/88, as it
was deposed by him that he had not constructed anything in property No.
RZ33-B9/7, Kishan Garh Mehrauli. It was further submitted that the said
witness had stated that neither will he see the photographs nor he will speak
anything about the said photographs.
31. Qua the testimony of Mr. Dharmendra Singh, PW-2 and Mr. Sunil
Kumar, PW-3, it was submitted by the learned Senior Counsels that both the
said witnesses had filed verbatim similar affidavits, and both the witnesses
admitted having been present at the time of the visit of the Local
Commissioner in the year 1998, and have further admitted that locks of the
suit property were opened by the Defendant, yet they have falsely deposed
that the possession of the suit property was taken by the Defendant forcibly in
the year 2006.
Signature Not Verified
Digitally Signed By:BHASKAR
SINGH RAWAT
Signing Date:21.11.2026
14:09:04
RFA 488/2014 & conn. Page 15 of 74
32. Learned Senior Counsels had further submitted that the argument of the
Plaintiff that since the Defendant could not show a better title than the
Plaintiff, the learned Trial Court ought to have decreed the suit in the
Plaintiff’s favour is misconceived, as the present suit for possession was
based on title and the onus was on the Plaintiff to prove his title and not vice-
versa . It was further submitted that the Plaintiff had failed to prove his prior
possession of the suit property and had failed to place on record any cogent
evidence to establish the same.
33. Learned Senior Counsels further drew attention of this Court to the
following portion of the impugned judgment, and the same is reproduced as
under: -
“ 13 Issue No. 2. Whether the plaintiff is owner and in possession of
suit property? OPP and Issue No. 3. Whether the plaintiff is entitled
for relief as claimed? OPP and Issue No. 5. Whether the plaintiff has
been dispossessed forcibly by the defendant during the pendency of
case on 14.02.2006? OPP and Issue No. 6 Whether the plaintiff is
entitled for recovery of possession, as claimed? OPP:- All these issues
are taken up together as they are inter-connected. Under these issues, the
plaintiff was required to prove that he is owner and was in possession of
suit property at the time of filing of suit and thereafter was dispossessed
and was entitled to the relief of possession and injunction. The plaintiff
has averred that he was in possession of suit property on the date of filing
the suit which is denied by defendant on the strength of' various
documents filed on record. Defendant No. 1 is mainly contesting the suit
and has taken the stand that plaintiff has not been able to prove the
ownership but simultaneously has taken the plea that father of the
plaintiff and defendant has been given their separate share alongwith the
other brothers and plaintiff is enjoying said share in property as per site
plan and GPA etc. executed by father of parties. He has further taken
members stand that property of plaintiff bears no. C, C-1 and C-2 and
property of other family members bears other no. Though plaintiff has
firstly put the claim on the basis of plea that suit land was part of
property of Sh. Hari Singh who is brother of Prabhu but said chunk of
Signature Not Verified
Digitally Signed By:BHASKAR
SINGH RAWAT
Signing Date:21.11.2026
14:09:04
RFA 488/2014 & conn. Page 16 of 74
property is sought to be proved by defendant as part of property of Late
Prabhu father of parties. Daughter of Sh. Hari Singh rather stated that
suit land belongs to Late Prabhu. In a way if defendant No. 1 has
admitted that property belonged to father of parties and was orally
partitioned and later on reduced to writing then the onus shifts upon
defendant and if he is not able to prove the same then property would be
deemed to be joint property and all the Lrs of Prabhu will be co-sharer in
the same. The main thrust is that as to whether defendant has been able
to prove the partition or not and if not then what are consequences.
Number of documents produced are placed on record. Ex, PW-1/D2, Ex.
PW-l/Dl and Ex. DW-1/2 main documents put forward by defendant
have not been proved as per Indian Evidence Act. The plaintiff has
denied the signatures on all the documents and in these circumstances,
the defendant should have proved the same. Though documents were
sought to be sent to CFSL but more signatures and admitted signatures
were sought by CFSL so it cannot be stated that CFSL report is
favourable to anybody and rather it is inconclusive. No other evidence
has come on record which can prove that signatures of plaintiff are
available on these documents. Wife of late Prabhu and another son
Gajinder are witness to Will, undertaking and GPA but wife of late
Prabhu has died and otherwise also being defendant the other signatories
are interested parties. No independent witness has signed the same.
Another witness B. S. Chauhan could have been produced by defendant
to prove the document but he has also not come to depose so in these
circumstances, these documents have not been proved as per Indian
Evidence Act and self-serving statement of defendants have no
relevancy. Once these documents have not been proved, facts contained
in these documents stands discarded and cannot be taken into account.
The partition as per undertaking is of no value for want of prove. The
will in these circumstances, once taken as defence also stands discarded.
Both the parties have not been able to prove their contention as stated
aforesaid and rather joint holding of Late Prabhu and Hari Singh will be-
deemed to be existing in the wake of absence of clear cut partition of the
property between predecessor in interest of the parties. The same is
fortified by the evidence on record. DW-1 has stated that he has no
knowledge regarding areas of khasra No. He has no knowledge as to how
much share his grand-father individually owned. He has rather stated that
DDA has acquired the land but possession has not been taken, so the suit
property in question has already been acquired as admitted but
possession is still either with plaintiff or with defendant which will be
adjudicated upon in the later part of reasoning. This witness has also
Signature Not Verified
Digitally Signed By:BHASKAR
SINGH RAWAT
Signing Date:21.11.2026
14:09:04
RFA 488/2014 & conn. Page 17 of 74
admitted that no municipal no. has been given to the suit land. On asking
whether any electricity meter is installed in the name of his father or
family member, to which he has stated that he is not aware. From the
evidence produced on record, it has not been even made out that how
much area was inherited by father of plaintiff and defendant No. 1 and 2
and in what manner. It is also not made out that khewat is still shamlat
not and whether any partition has been taken place between father of the
plaintiff and defendant No. 1 and 2 and his other brothers, pw-2 Smt.
Premwati has stated that suit land belonged to late Prabhu and both the
plaintiff and defendants are son of Late Prabhu and it was in possession
of late Prabhu. She nowhere has also talked about the partition between
parties. DW-3 Gajender in his chief examination has stated that late
Prabhu father of plaintiff and defendants was having ownership of many
properties and it was transferred by way of registered deeds to avoid any
dispute and the properties were amicably partitioned by all the parties.
On the contrary, the defendant has based his claim only on the basis of
GPA, undertaking and Will stated above and there are no separate
registered deeds. He has stated that fadier of parties has mutually
partitioned the said land even prior to execution of above said documents
but as stated above, same, are not proved as these documents can be
created when plaintiff has denied his signatures. Statement of DW-2
Gajender otherwise cannot be taken into consideration as he has denied
his signatures in some other court though they were signed in open court
so extra care has to be applied while reading his statement. In totality of
the circumstances, it is crystal clear that there is no dispute regarding
holding of property once upon time by Late' Prabhu (which even may be
as co-shares alongwith his other siblings) but subsequent transfer by oral
partition to different LRs was to be proved by defendants which they
have failed, it is also crystal clear that plaintiff has also not come to the
court with clean hands and both the parties are lying after coming to the
court. But crux of the above observation is that when defendant has
failed to prove the oral partition, the land is deemed to be joint and all the
persons i.e. plaintiff and defendants No. 1 and 2 and other LRs of Late
Prabhu are deemed to be co-sharers in equal shares and it cannot be held
that property was exclusively hold by defendant. It cannot be held that
property solely owned by plaintiff and being cosharer, both the parties
are deemed to be owner and in possession till partition by metes and
bounds. In these circumstances, the question of exclusive possession
either with plaintiff and defendant losses its significance because one
party will be deemed to be having possession with other co-sharer also,
though otherwise defendants have failed to prove their exclusive
Signature Not Verified
Digitally Signed By:BHASKAR
SINGH RAWAT
Signing Date:21.11.2026
14:09:04
RFA 488/2014 & conn. Page 18 of 74
possession thus in these circumstances, issue No. 2 is decided
accordingly and plaintiff is deemed to be co-sharers of the suit property
and issue No, 5 becomes redundant. As far as issue no. 6 is concerned,
exclusive possession cannot be given to any of the party and suit for
partition by metes and bounds is required to be filed by parties. The issue
No. 6 is answered accordingly. As far as issue No. 3 is concerned, it is
clear that when all the parties are co-sharers then every co-sharer can use
every piece of land and then defendant cannot restrain the plaintiff from
using any part and parcel of land, The plea of exclusive possession of
defendant is not accepted and so the plaintiff has every right to enter into
the suit land and all of them will hold the possession or will do whatever
they want in whole of the suit land subject to condition that same will be
equally for the benefit of all the parties and no specific share can be
given to any of the parties and all the share holders shall enjoy the
property jointly accordingly All the issues are decided accordingly in
above terms.
14. Relief:- In view of the above finding, the suit of the plaintiff stands
partly decreed with costs as aforesaid. Decree sheet be prepared
accordingly and file be consigned to Record Room.”
It was submitted that the said portion pertained to findings on Issues
Nos. 2, 3, 5 and 6, and it was observed by the learned ADJ that under the said
issues, the Plaintiff was required to prove that he was the owner and was in
possession of the suit property at the time of filing the suit, and thereafter, he
was dispossessed and was entitled to the relief of possession and injunction;
however, while rendering the impugned judgment, the said observation was
completely ignored by the learned ADJ.
34. It was further submitted by the learned Senior Counsels that the
Plaintiff had further contended that the documents, i.e. , Will and GPA have
not been proved by the Defendant as per law. In view of the same it was
submitted that the Defendant had produced the attesting witness Mr. Gajender
Singh, DW-3, who had not only deposed in his affidavit of evidence, that he
Signature Not Verified
Digitally Signed By:BHASKAR
SINGH RAWAT
Signing Date:21.11.2026
14:09:04
RFA 488/2014 & conn. Page 19 of 74
can identify the signatures of his brothers, but also the fact that they had
signed in each other’s presence. It was further stated that the said witness in
his cross-examination had stated that his father had affixed his thumb
impression on all the documents in his presence, and therefore, the execution
and registration of the said documents were duly proved in accordance with
the law.
35. Learned Senior Counsels had further submitted that the contention of
the Plaintiff that the Will of late Shri Prabhu had not been proved as per the
provisions of Section 63(c) of the Indian Succession Act, 1925, and Section
68 of the Indian Evidence Act, 1872, is baseless, inasmuch as not only one of
the attesting witnesses, Mr. Gajender Singh was examined to prove the
execution of documents, but also the witness from the Office of the Registrar,
i.e. , DW-7, was examined to prove the registration.
36. Learned Senior Counsels for the Defendant had further submitted that
the argument of the Plaintiff that the statement of Smt. Prem Wati, DW-2, in
her cross-examination dated 07.02.2014 was self-serving, was misconceived.
It was further submitted that Smt. Prem Wati being the daughter of late Shri
Hari Singh was the most important witness who demolished the whole basis
of the case of the Plaintiff. It was further submitted that Smt. Prem Wati had
clearly stated in her cross-examination that late Shri Hari Singh was not the
owner of the suit property, rather the same was owned by late Shri Prabhu. It
was further submitted that Smt. Prem Wati had produced and proved the Will
of her father, which proved that he had bequeathed his entire estate in favour
of his daughters, and not even an inch of land had been given to the Plaintiff.
Signature Not Verified
Digitally Signed By:BHASKAR
SINGH RAWAT
Signing Date:21.11.2026
14:09:04
RFA 488/2014 & conn. Page 20 of 74
Relevant portion of the cross-examination dated 07.02.2014 is reproduced as
under: -
“Q. I put it to you that the possession of suit land was given by Hari
Singh to Pratap Singh?
Ans. The land belonged to Prabhu and both the plaintiff and defendant
are son of Prabhu.
It is incorrect to suggest that the suit property was in possession of Sh.
Hari Singh. (Vol. It was always in possession of Prabhu).
I do not know regarding khasra girdawari i.e. Mark B to D. (Vol. Any
land belonging to Hari Singh is owned by us).
It is incorrect to suggest that the suit property was not in possession of
Mahender Singh. I am not a summoned witness.
Q. On whose instance are you deposing?
Ans. I was asked by Atul Gandas to depose. (Vol. He informed me that
his uncle Sh. Pratap Singh had filed a false case on the basis of the fact
that Sh. Hari Singh my father had given some land to him). I told him
that no immovable or movable property had been given to Pratap Singh
by my father.
It is correct that I attend marriages and functions hosted by Atul Gandas.
I am not on visiting terms with Pratap Singh. It is incorrect to suggest
that we have no visiting terms with Pratap Singh as my father had given
possession of suit property to him. (Vol. My father has not given
possession of any property either to Pratap Singh or to Mahender Singh.
It is incorrect to suggest that I am deposing falsely at the instance of Atul
Gandas. It is incorrect to suggest that I am deposing falsely.”
37. Learned Senior Counsels for the Defendant had further submitted that
the reliance as placed by the Plaintiff on Section 3 of the Delhi Lands
(Restriction on Transfer) Act, 1972, in order to contend that since the land in
dispute had been acquired, then late Shri. Prabhu could not have executed the
GPA or Will, is misplaced, as the same did not constitute any transfer which
would have been prohibited under Section 4 of the said Act. It was further
submitted that it was not a transfer of property within the meaning of Section
5 of the Transfer of Property Act, 1882. Learned Senior Counsels had further
Signature Not Verified
Digitally Signed By:BHASKAR
SINGH RAWAT
Signing Date:21.11.2026
14:09:04
RFA 488/2014 & conn. Page 21 of 74
stated that admittedly, the possession of land was not taken by the
Government.
38. Learned Senior Counsels for the Defendant had further submitted that
the separate GPAs executed and registered by late Shri Prabhu in favour of
his four sons were in the nature of reducing the oral family
settlement/partition into writing, and therefore, the contention of the Plaintiff
that the GPA came to an end with the death of late Shri Prabhu was
erroneous. It was submitted that late Shri Prabhu, during his lifetime, had
mutually partitioned the subject land amongst his sons, even prior to the
execution of the Powers of Attorney and Wills in their favour, in respect of
their respective portions, and the respective sons had been in possession of
their shares pursuant to the said oral partition. It was further submitted that the
registered Powers of Attorney and Wills were executed in favour of the sons
in respect of their respective shares to obviate any dispute regarding the
division of the land. Learned Senior Counsels further submitted that the
undertaking and site plan were also signed by the brothers and the site plan
was duly registered. The aforesaid position, according to the learned Senior
Counsels, was duly affirmed by Mr. Gajender Singh and Mr. Manjeet Singh,
who had stated that they had been in possession of their respective shares
even prior to the execution of the said documents.
39. Learned Senior Counsels had further submitted that the documents
executed by late Shri Prabhu in favour of the four sons also included
documents in favour of the Plaintiff and his two other brothers, namely, Mr.
Ishwar Singh and Mr. Gajender Singh. It was submitted that the Plaintiff had
Signature Not Verified
Digitally Signed By:BHASKAR
SINGH RAWAT
Signing Date:21.11.2026
14:09:04
RFA 488/2014 & conn. Page 22 of 74
received the property which had fallen to his share pursuant to the oral
partition, which was subsequently recorded in the aforesaid documents. It was
further contended that the Plaintiff had not only received and enjoyed the
property which had fallen to his share under the said arrangement, but had
also dealt with the same without any objection from any of his brothers.
40. Learned Senior Counsels had further submitted that all the documents
executed in favour of the four brothers had been produced and proved in the
subject suit and had been duly acted upon. It was contended that the objection
of the Plaintiff that the documents, including the GPAs, Wills, site plan and
undertaking, merely bore internal numbers such as A, A-1, B, B-1, C, C-1 and
D, D-1, instead of municipal numbers, was misconceived. It was submitted
that the relevant Khasra numbers had been duly mentioned in the said
documents, and therefore, the non-mentioning of municipal numbers could
not, in any manner, invalidate the said documents. Learned Senior Counsels
further submitted that, having taken benefit under the said documents, it did
not lie in the mouth of the Plaintiff to dispute the documents executed in
favour of the Defendant.
41. Learned Senior Counsels further drew attention of this Court to
paragraph 13(b) of the amended plaint filed by the Plaintiff, wherein the
Plaintiff had specifically pleaded that he was the actual owner of the suit
property, having obtained the same from late Shri Hari Singh, who was stated
to be the real younger brother of the grandfather of the Plaintiff. It was
submitted that the said pleading was directly contrary to the submission
advanced on behalf of the Plaintiff that ownership of the suit property had not
Signature Not Verified
Digitally Signed By:BHASKAR
SINGH RAWAT
Signing Date:21.11.2026
14:09:04
RFA 488/2014 & conn. Page 23 of 74
been claimed by him. Learned Senior Counsels further submitted that the
contention that late Shri Hari Singh had put the Plaintiff in possession of the
land was also contrary to the case pleaded by the Plaintiff himself.
42. Learned Senior Counsels had further submitted that the reliance placed
by the Plaintiff upon the judgment dated 28.10.2025, whereby the suit filed by
the Defendant seeking declaration in respect of the undertaking, GPA and site
plan was dismissed under Order VII Rules 11(a) and (d) of the CPC, was
misplaced. It was submitted that the Defendant had already preferred RFA
Nos.1053/2025 and 1054/2025, titled Shri Mahinder Singh (since deceased)
through his Legal Heirs v. Shri Partap Singh & Ors. , against the said
judgment. It was further submitted that this Court, vide order dated
19.11.2025, had issued notice in the said appeals, and in the meantime, had
stayed the effect and operation of the judgment and decree dated 28.10.2025.
Learned Senior Counsels therefore submitted that reliance placed by the
Plaintiff upon the said judgment was misplaced, particularly when the interim
order passed by this Court was continuing.
43. Learned Senior Counsels had further submitted that the contention
advanced on behalf of the Plaintiff that, since the impugned judgment had
been assailed by both parties, the matter ought to be remanded to the learned
Trial Court for fresh adjudication, was also misconceived. It was submitted
that the power of remand under Order XLI Rules 23, 23-A and 25 of the CPC
was circumscribed and the present case did not fall within the parameters
thereof.
Signature Not Verified
Digitally Signed By:BHASKAR
SINGH RAWAT
Signing Date:21.11.2026
14:09:04
RFA 488/2014 & conn. Page 24 of 74
44. Learned Senior Counsels further submitted that there was no allegation
on behalf of the Plaintiff that the trial before the learned ADJ had been
conducted in an unsatisfactory manner. It was contended that the appeals
could effectively be decided on the basis of the material already available on
record, and therefore, no occasion arose for remanding the matter to the
learned Trial Court. Learned Senior Counsels further submitted that the
Plaintiff had failed to bring his case within the ambit of Order XLI Rules 23,
23-A or 25 of the CPC. In support of the said contention reliance was placed
upon the judgment of the Hon'ble Supreme Court in Sirajudheen v. Zeenath
20
& Ors . , and particularly upon paragraphs 16, 17, 23, 24 and 28 to 32.
45. In view of the aforesaid submissions, learned Senior Counsels for the
Defendant prayed that RFA No.488/2014, preferred by the Defendant, be
allowed and RFA No.615/2014, preferred by the Plaintiff, be dismissed. It
was further prayed that the impugned judgment and decree dated 11.09.2014
passed by the learned ADJ be set aside and the suit instituted by the
Respondent/Plaintiff be dismissed.
S UBMISSIONS ON BEHALF OF THE PLAINTIFF
46. Per contra, learned Senior Counsels for the Plaintiff had submitted that
the appeal filed by the Defendant is liable to be dismissed. It was further
submitted that the Plaintiff had initially filed a suit for permanent injunction
qua the property bearing municipal No. RZ-33 B/1, Kishangarh, Mehrauli,
New Delhi, and had specifically pleaded that he was in possession of the said
property since 1983. It was further submitted that the Plaintiff had proved his
20
2023 SCC OnLine SC 196
Signature Not Verified
Digitally Signed By:BHASKAR
SINGH RAWAT
Signing Date:21.11.2026
14:09:04
RFA 488/2014 & conn. Page 25 of 74
possession through MCD assessment records, electricity connection and bills,
and the oral evidence led by him.
47. Learned Senior Counsels for the Plaintiff had submitted that in the
subject suit, the Plaintiff had claimed that there existed tin sheds at the suit
property in the year 1983, as well as the remaining vacant land was being
used for agricultural purposes. It was further submitted that the MCD had
inspected the site during their survey for the assessment of house tax, and it
was found that the suit property fell in Mehrauli. It was further submitted that
post assessment, the suit property was assessed to property tax in the name of
the Plaintiff and the said fact had been duly proved by the Plaintiff in his
evidence as PW-1, and through the officials of MCD.
48. Learned Senior Counsels had further submitted that in the year 1985,
the Plaintiff had applied for an electricity meter connection with DESU, and
an electricity meter bearing No. 3149577 was installed at the suit property in
his name. It was further submitted that the said fact stood duly proved through
the original certificate issued by DESU, as well as through the electricity bills
placed in record during the course of trial.
49. Learned Senior Counsels had further submitted that in the year 1997,
the Plaintiff had undertaken a large-scale renovation and alteration in the suit
property through a civil engineer, Mr. B.P. Singh, and the existing tin sheds
were replaced by pucca structures. It was further submitted that although the
construction could not be completed on account of financial constraints, the
said renovation resulted in proceedings before the MCD and revision of the
rateable value of the suit property. In support of the same, learned Senior
Signature Not Verified
Digitally Signed By:BHASKAR
SINGH RAWAT
Signing Date:21.11.2026
14:09:04
RFA 488/2014 & conn. Page 26 of 74
Counsels had placed reliance upon the following documents: -
i. MCD assessment order, i.e. , EX. PW2A/11(1);
ii. Hearing Proceedings before MCD, i.e. , EX. PW2A/11(2),
iii. Letter addressed to the Assistant Assessor and Collector, Najafgarh,
New Delhi dated 11.03.1998;
iv. Cross-examination dated 02.09.2009 of PW3, Mr. B.P. Singh, who had
deposed that he had undertaken the construction work as a contract appointed
by the Plaintiff.
50. Learned Senior Counsels had further submitted that on 18.05.1998,
when the Plaintiff visited the suit property along with his workmen to
complete the unfinished construction, he was confronted by the Defendant
and was prevented from allowing his workmen to commence the construction.
In support of the same, reliance was placed upon the Report of the Local
Commissioner dated 03.06.1998.
51. Learned Senior Counsels had further submitted that the Local
Commissioner, in his Report, had recorded that force was used for breaking
the locks and the electricity meter was also removed from the suit property
and photographs of the suit property had also been placed on record during
the course of trial. It was further submitted that the said report of the Local
Commissioner constituted legal evidence under Order XXVI Rule 10(2) of
the CPC. In support of the same, reliance was placed upon the judgment
passed by this Court in New Multan Timber Store & Ors. v. Rattan Chand
21
Sood .
21
MANU/DE/1253/1997
Signature Not Verified
Digitally Signed By:BHASKAR
SINGH RAWAT
Signing Date:21.11.2026
14:09:04
RFA 488/2014 & conn. Page 27 of 74
52. Learned Senior Counsels had further placed reliance upon the cross
examination dated 03.04.2010 of PW4, Mr. Bal Kishan to submit that the said
witness had proved the site plan of the suit property and he had further
deposed that he had visited the spot on 19.05.1998 and found that the Plaintiff
was in possession of the suit property. It was further submitted that the said
deposition further establishes the Plaintiff’s possession over the suit property
prior to the dispossession by the Defendant.
53. Learned Senior Counsels had further submitted that during the
pendency of the subject suit, on the night of 14.02.2006, the Defendant had
broken the lock placed by the Plaintiff on the suit property and illegally
dispossessed him from the suit property. It was further submitted that
thereafter, the Defendant stacked building material at the suit property and
demolished a portion thereof, and raised construction. It was further submitted
that the Plaintiff had called the PCR and also lodged a written compliance
with the Police on the following morning, and in view of the same, the
amendment was carried out in the plaint, seeking a relief of possession.
54. Learned Senior Counsels had further placed reliance upon the evidence
by way of affidavit of Mr. Dharmender and Mr. Sunil Kumar to submit that
the case of the Plaintiff regarding his possession prior to 14.02.2006 and his
subsequent dispossession by the Defendant was supported by the said
witnesses. It was further submitted that both the said witnesses had deposed
that the Plaintiff was retaining possession and occupying the suit property
prior to 14.02.2006, and thereafter, the Defendant had demolished a portion of
Signature Not Verified
Digitally Signed By:BHASKAR
SINGH RAWAT
Signing Date:21.11.2026
14:09:04
RFA 488/2014 & conn. Page 28 of 74
the suit property and raised construction thereon. It was further submitted that
the said witnesses had also deposed that after the Defendant took forcible
possession of the suit property, the same was subsequently demolished by the
Government Authorities for removal of the illegal construction.
55. Learned Senior Counsels had further submitted that the Defendant had
claimed ownership and possession of a different property bearing Municipal
No. RZ-33 B/7, and had based his claim upon a GPA executed by his father,
and an undertaking bearing the signature of the Plaintiff. It was submitted that
the Defendant had specifically pleaded that he came into possession of the
suit property in the year 1996, i.e. , pursuant to an oral partition amongst the
brothers. It was further submitted that the case of the Defendant was itself that
he came into possession only in the year 1995-1996, whereas, the Plaintiff
had established his possession since the year 1983.
56. Learned Senior Counsels had further submitted that the Defendant had
never pleaded or set up the Will in his written statement, and the said Will
was only introduced for the first time during the course of evidence. It was
further submitted that none of the attesting witnesses to the said Will had been
examined, and therefore, the Will had not been proved in accordance with the
law. In support of the said submission, reliance was placed by the learned
Senior Counsels upon the judgment passed by the Hon’ble Supreme Court in
22
Bachhaj Nahar v. Nilima Mandal & Ors . Reliance was further placed by
the learned Senior Counsels upon the judgment passed by this Court in Shri
22
AIR 2009 SC 1103
Signature Not Verified
Digitally Signed By:BHASKAR
SINGH RAWAT
Signing Date:21.11.2026
14:09:04
RFA 488/2014 & conn. Page 29 of 74
23
Bharat Gupta v. State & Ors. , to contend that the said Will had not been
proved in terms of Section 63 of the Succession Act, 1925 and Section 68 of
the Indian Evidence Act, 1872.
57. Learned Senior Counsels for the Plaintiff had further submitted that the
map, as relied upon by the Defendant, in support of the oral partition did not
bear the dimensions of the plots and the same had not been proved by its
maker, i.e. , Mr. V.K. Sangwan. Learned Senior Counsels had further
submitted that the said witness had not appeared in the witness box, and
therefore, an adverse inference ought to be drawn against the Defendant under
Section 114(g) of the Indian Evidence Act, 1872. It was further submitted that
the said map does not reflect the Khasra numbers mentioned in the Will and
the GPA, and that DW1, Mr. Atul Singh Gandas, i.e. , son of the Defendant,
was unable to identify the spot bearing Municipal No. RZ-33-B/1 from the
said map.
58. Learned Senior Counsels had further submitted that the Defendant had
also failed to prove the GPA executed by his father in accordance with the
law. It was further submitted that the Plaintiff had denied execution of the
said GPA in his presence, and had also denied the alleged signature appearing
thereon. It was further submitted that the matter had been sent to the FSL for
verification, but no authentic result had been produced. Learned Senior
Counsels had further submitted that since late Shri Prabhu had expired in the
year 2000, the GPA, being without consideration, came to an end, and in any
event, the Defendant had failed to prove the Will in terms of Section 68 of the
23
2023 LawPack (Del) 92558
Signature Not Verified
Digitally Signed By:BHASKAR
SINGH RAWAT
Signing Date:21.11.2026
14:09:04
RFA 488/2014 & conn. Page 30 of 74
Indian Evidence Act, 1872 and Section 63 of the Indian Succession Act,
1925.
59. It was further submitted by the learned Senior Counsels for the Plaintiff
that in view of the provisions of Section 81 of the Indian Evidence Act, 1872,
a presumption ought to be raised in respect of the original electricity bills
placed on record. It was further submitted that the said document was
required to be taken into consideration while adjudicating the Plaintiff’s claim
with respect to the suit property.
60. Learned Senior Counsels had further submitted that the Defendant had
taken false and inconsistent pleas qua the electricity connection existing at the
suit property. It was submitted that the Defendant had claimed to have an
electricity connection in the suit property through his old house property
bearing No. 25/2, Kishangarh, Mehrauli; however, the Defendant had deposed
that the said property was 300 meters away from the suit property, with many
buildings in between. It was further submitted that the Defendant had shown
ignorance when asked if there was an electricity meter installed at property
No. 25/2, as he had denied the existence of property No. 25/2, and thereafter,
replaced the same with property No. 25/9, and while doing so, the Defendant
had failed to produce any material to substantiate the existence of an
electricity meter at either property. It was further submitted that DW-1 had
admitted in his cross-examination dated 20.01.2014 that the suit property
bearing No. RZ-33 B/7 formed part of Khasra No. 1240, whereas, the said
Khasra number was not mentioned in the GPA, and the Khatoni placed on
record pertained to the Central Government land in possession of the DDA.
Signature Not Verified
Digitally Signed By:BHASKAR
SINGH RAWAT
Signing Date:21.11.2026
14:09:04
RFA 488/2014 & conn. Page 31 of 74
61. Learned Senior Counsels had further submitted that the Plaintiff had
been in possession of property bearing No. RZ-33 B/1 since the year 1983,
whereas, the Defendant had claimed to have come into possession only in
1995-1996, pursuant to the alleged partition. It was, therefore, submitted that
the Plaintiff was admittedly in prior possession of the suit property.
62. Learned Senior Counsels had further submitted that the testimony of
DW-3, Mr. Gajender Singh, materially contradicted the case set up by the
Defendant as the said witness had categorically stated that late Shri Prabhu
did not have any right or title in the suit property, in respect of which he had
executed the GPA and the Will in favour of his sons. Learned Senior
Counsels had further submitted that the said statement was contrary to the
very root of the Defendant’s case, as the same was based upon the document
allegedly executed by late Shri Prabhu, and therefore, the testimony of DW-3
could not be relied upon.
63. Learned Senior Counsels further drew attention of this Court to the
assessment record qua the properties, with effect from 01.04.1983 to submit
that all four brothers were having different properties, bearing Nos. RZ-33
B/1, RZ-33 B/2, RZ-33 B/3, RZ-33 B/4, RZ-33 B/9, RZ-33 B/10 and RZ-33
B/11, and the said properties were distinct, separate and independent, and
were assessed to property tax right from 01.04.1983. It was further submitted
that the Defendant had two properties, i.e. , RZ-33 B/2 and RZ-33 B/7,
whereas, the Plaintiff also owned and possessed two properties, i.e. , RZ-33
B/1 and RZ-33 B/11.
Signature Not Verified
Digitally Signed By:BHASKAR
SINGH RAWAT
Signing Date:21.11.2026
14:09:04
RFA 488/2014 & conn. Page 32 of 74
64. Learned Senior Counsels had submitted that the claim of the Defendant
relates to a different property, other than the suit property. It was further
submitted that the plot numbers mentioned in the alleged partition did not
match with the official records, and the Defendant had failed to explain as to
why different plot numbers were mentioned in the alleged oral partition in the
year 1995-1996, when the properties had already been identified in the
municipal records.
65. Learned Senior Counsels had further submitted that the witnesses
produced by the Defendant during the course of trial were related to him, and
had admitted their inimical relationship with the Plaintiff, and therefore, the
deposition of such witnesses cannot be relied upon.
66. Learned Senior Counsels had further relied upon the judgment passed
by the Hon’ble Supreme Court in Shivshankar & Anr. v. H.P. Vedavyasa
24
Char , to contend that when both the parties fail to establish their title, the
question of who had prior possession becomes crucial. It was further
submitted that in the said case, the Hon’ble Supreme Court had noted that the
right to possession is based on actual possession, and the party who could
prove prior possession would be entitled to remain in possession of the
property.
24
2023 (5) SCALE 218
Signature Not Verified
Digitally Signed By:BHASKAR
SINGH RAWAT
Signing Date:21.11.2026
14:09:04
RFA 488/2014 & conn. Page 33 of 74
67. Reliance was further placed on the judgment passed by this Court in
25
Saleem & Ors. v. Wahid Malik , to contend that in a suit for possession or
a suit for injunction against dispossession, the Plaintiff is not required to
establish title or ownership, but a better right to remain in possession of the
suit property, as compared to the right of the defendant.
68. Learned Senior Counsels had further placed reliance upon the judgment
passed by the Hon’ble Supreme Court in Rame Gowda (Dead) by LRs v. M.
26
Varadappa Naidu (Dead) by LRs & Anr. , to contend that in the absence
of proof of better title, possession or prior peaceful settled possession is itself
evidence of title, and when the Defendant failed to prove his title to the suit
and land, the Plaintiff can succeed in securing a decree for possession on the
basis of his prior possession against the Defendant who dispossessed him.
69. Learned Senior Counsels had further submitted that the reliance placed
by the Defendant upon the judgment in Anathula ( Supra ) was misplaced, as
the said judgment itself recognised that in a suit for injunction, the question of
title would ordinarily not be directly and substantially in issue, and the relief
would be decided with reference to possession. It was further submitted that
the said judgment was distinguishable on facts, as in the said case, the
Defendant was able to establish a better title over the property, whereas in the
present case the Defendant had failed to establish better title over the suit
property.
25
2022 (295) DLT 8
26
2004 1 SCC 769
Signature Not Verified
Digitally Signed By:BHASKAR
SINGH RAWAT
Signing Date:21.11.2026
14:09:04
RFA 488/2014 & conn. Page 34 of 74
70. Learned Senior Counsels for the Plaintiff had further submitted that the
suit property had admittedly been acquired by the DDA, and consequently,
late Shri Prabhu had no authority to execute the GPA and Will qua the suit
property. It was further submitted that the execution of the said documents
was in violation of Section 3 of the Delhi Lands (Restriction on Transfer) Act,
1972. In support of the said submission, reliance was placed upon the
27
judgments in AD Overseas v. Sneh Lata Sharma & Anr. and Meera
28
Sahni & Anr. v. Lt. Governor of Delhi & Ors .
71. Learned Senior Counsels had further submitted that the learned ADJ
had failed to adjudicate the material dispute regarding the identification of the
suit property. It was submitted that while the Plaintiff had consistently
identified the suit property as bearing Municipal No. RZ-33 B/1, the
Defendant had claimed the suit property to be bearing Municipal No. RZ-33
B/7. It was further submitted that the Local Commissioner had identified the
venue of the site as property bearing No. RZ-33-B/1. Learned Senior
Counsels therefore submitted that despite noticing the rival submissions of the
parties on the issue of identification, the learned ADJ had failed to return any
finding thereon.
72. On the basis of the aforesaid submissions, learned Senior Counsels for
the Plaintiff had submitted that the latter had established his settled possession
over the suit property, whereas the Defendant had failed to establish any title,
whatsoever, over the same, and thus, the present appeal preferred by the
27
2012 SCC OnLine Del 5256
28
(2008) 9 SCC 177
Signature Not Verified
Digitally Signed By:BHASKAR
SINGH RAWAT
Signing Date:21.11.2026
14:09:04
RFA 488/2014 & conn. Page 35 of 74
Defendant is liable to be dismissed and the appeal filed by the Plaintiff be
allowed.
A NALYSIS AND FINDING
73. Heard the learned Senior Counsels for the parties, and perused the
record.
74. Learned Senior Counsels for the Defendant had submitted that the
learned ADJ, after holding that the Defendant had failed to prove the oral
family partition, proceeded to hold that the suit property was jointly held by
the Plaintiff, the Defendant and the other legal representatives of late Shri
Prabhu, and that they were co-sharers in the same, despite neither party
having set up such a case. It was further submitted that in a suit for possession
and injunction, the learned Trial Court could not have granted a relief of
declaration with respect to the ownership of the suit property, when no such
relief had been sought by the Plaintiff. In support of the said submission,
reliance was placed upon the judgments passed by the Hon’ble Supreme
Court in Bachhaj Nahar ( Supra ) and Kalyan Singh Chouhan ( Supra ) .
Reliance was further placed upon the judgment in Anathula Sudhakar
( Supra ) , to contend that in the presence of a cloud over the Plaintiff’s title, the
Plaintiff could not have maintained a suit for possession and injunction
without seeking a declaration of the title. Per contra , learned Senior Counsels
for the Plaintiff had submitted that the Plaintiff had established his prior
possession over the suit property and that the Defendant had failed to
establish better title thereto. It was further submitted that the judgment in
Signature Not Verified
Digitally Signed By:BHASKAR
SINGH RAWAT
Signing Date:21.11.2026
14:09:04
RFA 488/2014 & conn. Page 36 of 74
Anathula Sudhakar ( Supra ) was distinguishable on facts. Reliance was
placed upon the judgments in Shivshankar & Anr. ( Supra ) , Saleem & Ors.
( Supra ) and Rame Gowda (Dead) by LRs ( Supra ) , to contend that where
neither party establishes title, prior possession assumes significance in
determining the entitlement to possession. Learned Senior Counsels for the
Plaintiff had also relied upon Bachhaj Nahar ( Supra ) to contend that any
evidence beyond pleading is impermissible to be looked into.
75. In the backdrop of the said position, this Court will now examine the
material on record with regard to the title and possession of the Plaintiff in the
suit property.
76. The Plaintiff, in the suit filed before the learned Trial Court, had stated
that he is the owner of the suit property, bearing No. RZ-33 B/1, and he was
carrying large scale alterations and additions in the suit property. It was
further stated that on 18.05.1998, the Plaintiff along with the workmen had
entered the suit property and was confronted by the Defendant and that the
Defendant had asked the Plaintiff to stop the construction work. It was further
stated that the Defendant had no right in the suit property and the Plaintiff was
the absolute owner of the same, and in view thereof, the Plaintiff had filed the
original plaint seeking the following reliefs: -
“(i) a decree for permanent injunction restraining the defendant, his
associates and other family members not to interfere in the peaceful
possession, enjoyment, occupation and user of the plaintiff over his
house bearing No. RZ-33B/1, Kishan Garh, Mehrauli, New Delhi, in any
manner whatsoever.
Signature Not Verified
Digitally Signed By:BHASKAR
SINGH RAWAT
Signing Date:21.11.2026
14:09:04
RFA 488/2014 & conn. Page 37 of 74
(ii) restraining the defendant from obstructing the plaintiff and creating
hurdle of any type whatsoever in raising construction for completion of
his semi-finished house bearing municipal No. RZ 33B/1 (Mehrauli)
Kishan Garh, New Delhi which has teen shown more clearly in the site
plan annexed with the plaint.
Cost at the suit or any other relief that this Hon. Court deems fit and
proper in the circumstances of the case be also granted.”
77. Thereafter, on 02.06.1998, the Plaintiff had made a PCR call stating
that the Defendant is breaking open the locks in the suit property. Further, on
the said date, an application under Order XXVI Rule 9 of the CPC for
appointment of a Local Commissioner was also moved by the Plaintiff before
the learned Trial Court, and the said application was allowed, and
accordingly, a Local Commissioner was appointed by the learned Trial Court.
The Local Commissioner was asked to prepare a report on the following
queries: -
“(1) Whether site plan filed by the plaintiff is correct as per site?
(2) The details and extent of construction raised at the spot be given.
(3) Whether there is electricity metre installed in the suit property, if
so the details of its number and other particulars be given?
(4) Weather building is complete or not?”
78. Subsequently, on 03.06.1998, the Local Commissioner had visited the
suit property to carry out the commission in accordance with the order dated
02.06.1998 passed by the learned Trial Court. The report of the Local
Commissioner reads as under: -
Signature Not Verified
Digitally Signed By:BHASKAR
SINGH RAWAT
Signing Date:21.11.2026
14:09:04
RFA 488/2014 & conn. Page 38 of 74
Signature Not Verified
Digitally Signed By:BHASKAR
SINGH RAWAT
Signing Date:21.11.2026
14:09:04
RFA 488/2014 & conn. Page 39 of 74
Signature Not Verified
Digitally Signed By:BHASKAR
SINGH RAWAT
Signing Date:21.11.2026
14:09:04
RFA 488/2014 & conn. Page 40 of 74
Signature Not Verified
Digitally Signed By:BHASKAR
SINGH RAWAT
Signing Date:21.11.2026
14:09:04
RFA 488/2014 & conn. Page 41 of 74
Signature Not Verified
Digitally Signed By:BHASKAR
SINGH RAWAT
Signing Date:21.11.2026
14:09:04
RFA 488/2014 & conn. Page 42 of 74
Signature Not Verified
Digitally Signed By:BHASKAR
SINGH RAWAT
Signing Date:21.11.2026
14:09:04
RFA 488/2014 & conn. Page 43 of 74
Signature Not Verified
Digitally Signed By:BHASKAR
SINGH RAWAT
Signing Date:21.11.2026
14:09:04
RFA 488/2014 & conn. Page 44 of 74
Signature Not Verified
Digitally Signed By:BHASKAR
SINGH RAWAT
Signing Date:21.11.2026
14:09:04
RFA 488/2014 & conn. Page 45 of 74
79. It is further pertinent to note that the Plaintiff had filed a Criminal Writ
Petition before this Court being Criminal Writ Petition No. 892/1998,
aggrieved by the breaking open of locks and alleged removal of the electricity
meter from the suit property by the Defendant. The said writ petition was
dismissed by the learned Division Bench of this Court vide order dated
Signature Not Verified
Digitally Signed By:BHASKAR
SINGH RAWAT
Signing Date:21.11.2026
14:09:04
RFA 488/2014 & conn. Page 46 of 74
20.07.1999, basis the affidavit filed by the DCP. The said order of dismissal
dated 20.07.1999 and the affidavit filed by the DCP are reproduced as under:
-
Signature Not Verified
Digitally Signed By:BHASKAR
SINGH RAWAT
Signing Date:21.11.2026
14:09:04
RFA 488/2014 & conn. Page 47 of 74
Signature Not Verified
Digitally Signed By:BHASKAR
SINGH RAWAT
Signing Date:21.11.2026
14:09:04
RFA 488/2014 & conn. Page 48 of 74
Signature Not Verified
Digitally Signed By:BHASKAR
SINGH RAWAT
Signing Date:21.11.2026
14:09:04
RFA 488/2014 & conn. Page 49 of 74
It is further pertinent to note that the aforesaid order dated 20.07.1999
passed in Criminal Writ Petition No. 892/1998, as well as the affidavit filed
by the DCP had been proved by Mr. Mukesh Batra, Judicial Assistant,
Criminal Branch, Delhi High Court, in his cross examination dated
05.03.2014.
80. The affidavit filed by the DCP clearly records that the place of
occurrence was property bearing No. RZ-33B/7. It was further stated that, as
per the report received from DESU, no electricity meter was installed at the
said property, and therefore, the question of theft of any such meter did not
arise. The affidavit further records that when the Police Officer reached the
said property, the Defendant opened the door and stated that he was in
possession and occupation thereof. No incident of breaking open of locks or
any quarrel was found to have taken place. It was also stated that the Plaintiff
was asked to accompany the Police Officer to the place of occurrence;
however, he refused to do so, by stating that he only wished to lodge a report.
The Plaintiff did not cooperate with the Police Officer, and as no cognizable
offence was found to have been committed, the DD entry was filed.
81. It is further pertinent to note that the trial of the subject suit was kept
pending for the purposes of evidence from the institution of the suit in the
year 1998 till the year 2006. Thereafter, on the night of 14.02.2006, the
Plaintiff had again called the PCR stating that the Defendant had broken the
lock of the suit property and had forcibly dispossessed the Plaintiff therefrom,
and after breaking open the locks, the Defendant had dumped building
material over the suit property and had stocked several truckloads of bricks,
Signature Not Verified
Digitally Signed By:BHASKAR
SINGH RAWAT
Signing Date:21.11.2026
14:09:04
RFA 488/2014 & conn. Page 50 of 74
stone dust, steel bars and marble stones, in order to change the nature of the
suit property. A written complaint with respect to the alleged incident had
also been lodged by the Plaintiff with the Police in the morning of
15.02.2006. In view of the same, the Plaintiff had sought to move an
application under Order VI Rule 17 of the CPC, seeking amendment of the
Plaint. The said application was also allowed by the learned Trial Court vide
order dated 13.03.2006, and thereafter, the Plaint was amended by the
Plaintiff.
82. The following issues were framed by the learned Trial Court before the
amendment of the plaint: -
“1) Whether the suit is bad for non-joinder of necessary party? OPP
2) Whether the plaintiff is owner and in possession of suit property? OPP
3) Whether the plaintiff is entitled for relief as claimed? OPP
4) Whether the suit has not been properly valued for the purposes of
court fee and jurisdiction? OPP”
83. In view of the amendment in the plaint, the learned Trial Court vide
order dated 18.04.2007 had framed the following fresh issues for
consideration: -
“1. Whether the plaintiff has been dispossessed forcibly by the
defendant during the pendency of the case on 14.02.2006? OPP.
2. Whether the plaintiff is entitled for recovery of possession, as
claimed? OPP.”
84. It is pertinent to note that the Plaintiff had initially sought the relief of
Signature Not Verified
Digitally Signed By:BHASKAR
SINGH RAWAT
Signing Date:21.11.2026
14:09:04
RFA 488/2014 & conn. Page 51 of 74
injunction on the basis of claim of ownership over the suit property; however,
subsequent to the alleged dispossession of the Plaintiff on 14.02.2006, the
plaint was amended to incorporate the relief of recovery of possession.
Therefore, the Plaintiff was required to establish his entitlement to the reliefs
claimed on the basis of the pleadings and the evidence led by him.
85. The claim of the Plaintiff was that the suit property was given to him
by late Shri Hari Singh, i.e. , uncle of his grandfather, out of love and
affection; however, no document was placed on record qua the alleged
transfer of the suit property, nor was any other supporting evidence produced
to substantiate the said claim. The Plaintiff, in the plaint, had relied upon
certain documents to show his possession and right over the suit property. The
said documents are as under: -
i. Copy of the inspection report carried out by the Deputy Assessor and
Collector, MCD dated 01.04.1983;
ii. House tax payment receipts for the year 1996, 1997 and 1998, Ex. PW-
1/2, PW-1/3 and PW-1/4;
iii. Original bills for the year 1996, 1997 and 1998, Ex/ PW-1/5, PW-1/6
and PW-1/7;
iv. Original certificate issued by DESU, bearing Serial No. 535133, Ex.
PW-1/8;
v. Electricity bills for January 1998 and March 1998, Ex. PW-1/9 and
PW-1/10;
vi. Certificate dated 09.09.1997 issued by Mr. BP Singh, Civil Engineer,
Mark-A;
vii. Site plan, Ex. PW-1/11;
Signature Not Verified
Digitally Signed By:BHASKAR
SINGH RAWAT
Signing Date:21.11.2026
14:09:04
RFA 488/2014 & conn. Page 52 of 74
viii. Original assessment order dated 16.03.1998, Ex. PW-1/12;
ix. Photographs and Negatives as Ex. PW-1/13 to PW-1/16.
The aforesaid documents relate to property bearing No. RZ-33B/1;
however, whether the same was the suit property or not, was not an issue
framed by the learned Trial Court, nor any finding had been given thereupon.
86. The Plaintiff, apart from the above, had also relied upon the testimony
of Mr. B.P. Singh, Civil Engineer, PW-3, who had deposed in his cross
examination dated 02.09.2009 that he constructed the suit property in the year
1997, having been engaged by the Plaintiff; however, in the said cross-
examination he had further stated that he had not seen the documents of
ownership pertaining to the suit property. Relevant portion of the said cross
examination reads as under: -
“I constructed the building for Sh. Pratap Singh, plaintiff. In the year
1997 the construction were continued for about 5-6 months. There was
no written contract between myself and the plaintiff. I work as a
contractor and engineer for the plaintiff. I visited tile spot personally at
that time however cannot tell how many times I visited the property of
the plaintiff. I have not seen the documents of ownership of the
property, as I have no concerned with the documents .”
Further, Mr. B.P. Singh, in his cross examination dated 03.11.2009 had
deposed that he had carried out construction in property bearing No. RZ 33-
B/1, Kishan Garh, Mehrauli, and he had not carried out any construction in
property bearing No. RZ 33B-9/7, Kishan Garh, Meharauli. The relevant
portion of the said cross examination is reproduced as under: -
“ I have construed the property bearing no. RZ 33B/1 Kishan Garh
Signature Not Verified
Digitally Signed By:BHASKAR
SINGH RAWAT
Signing Date:21.11.2026
14:09:04
RFA 488/2014 & conn. Page 53 of 74
Mehaurli, Delhi. It is correct to suggest that I have not constructed
or had any construction with regard to the property bearing no. RZ
33B-9/7 Kishan Garh, Mehaurali, i.e. the property of Sh. Mahinder
Singh . I have never visited the property which I got constructed in the
year 1997 i.e. from March to September 1997 since the day of its
completion.”
Mr. B.P. Singh, in his cross examination dated 31.10.2013 had deposed
that he had not been provided any record to show that the suit property bears
No. RZ 33B/1, Kishan Garh, Mehrauli. The relevant portion of the said cross
examination reads as under: -
“I cannot tell now as to whose property is situated at west, north, east,
south sides of suit property. I have not been provided with any record
to show that property bears No. RZ-33B/1, Kishan Garh, New
Delhi .”
In view of the aforesaid, while Mr. B.P. Singh claimed to have carried
out construction at the instance of the Plaintiff, his testimony does not
establish that the said construction was carried out on the very property which
forms the subject matter of the present suit. Further, he had not produced any
record to establish the municipal number of the property where the
construction was carried out by him. In view of the discrepancy in the
description of the properties, the testimony of Mr. B.P. Singh does not
establish the Plaintiff’s claim with respect to the suit property.
87. Similarly, PW-4, Mr. Bal Kishan had also deposed in his cross-
examination dated 03.04.2010 that he had prepared the site plan after visiting
the suit property, and it was the Plaintiff who was in possession of the suit
property, as the locks were opened by him. He had further deposed that he did
Signature Not Verified
Digitally Signed By:BHASKAR
SINGH RAWAT
Signing Date:21.11.2026
14:09:04
RFA 488/2014 & conn. Page 54 of 74
not see any title documents pertaining to the suit property, but only an
electricity bill was shown to him. Relevant portion of the said cross
examination reads as under: -
“I cannot tell as to how many rooms and other construction were existing
when I visited the suit property in 1998. It is incorrect to suggest that in
the property Sh. Mahender Singh residing at the time of my visit. Vol. It
was Pratap Singh who was residing therein. I ascertain from the fact
that Pratap Singh had opened the lock of the gate in my presence
however nobody was residing as the property was under
construction at that time. It is wrong to suggest that the suit
property was in possession of Sh. Mahender Singh. The Municipal
number of the suit property is RZ33B/1, Kishan Garh, Delhi. It is
correct to suggest that I have not visited the property RZ33B-9/7
Kishan Garh Mehrauli Delhi nor I have drawn the site plan of the
said property. I had enquired from 2/3 persons who were present at
that time as to who was the owner of the property shown in the site
plan. They had disclosed to me that the property belonged to Sh.
Pratap Singh. I did not see any title documents of the property but
an electricity bill was shown to me. I cannot show the said electricity
bill nor the same has been placed on record by me. It is wrong to
suggest that no electricity bill was seen by me .”
Further, Mr. Bal Kishan, in his cross-examination dated 31.10.2013,
had clarified that the electricity bill shown to him did not mention the site of
the property. The relevant portion of his cross-examination is reproduced as
under: -
“The site plan bears the property number. I do not remember whether
property number was written anywhere. (Vol. I have seen the
electricity bill with regard to suit property). I do not have the copy of
said electricity bill. It is correct that there is no mention of site of
property in electricity bill. I myself of my own do not see the
electricity bill while preparing the site plan but I see the same if it is
shown to me. I do not mention about the electricity bill etc. while
preparing the site plan. ”
Signature Not Verified
Digitally Signed By:BHASKAR
SINGH RAWAT
Signing Date:21.11.2026
14:09:04
RFA 488/2014 & conn. Page 55 of 74
The aforesaid testimony of Mr. Bal Kishan does not establish the
Plaintiff’s possession over the suit property. While it was stated that the
Plaintiff had opened the lock of the property in his presence, he also admitted
that he had not seen any title documents pertaining to the suit property and
that the electricity bill shown to him did not mention the site of the property.
Further, the site plan was prepared on the basis of his visit to the property and
the information provided by persons present at the spot. In view of the same,
the testimony of Mr. Bal Kishan does not establish that the property inspected
by him was the same property which forms the subject matter of the present
suit or that the Plaintiff was in possession thereof.
88. The Plaintiff had also relied upon the evidence of Mr. Dharmendra
Singh, PW-2, resident of Village Kishan Garh, Mehrauli, who had stated in
his cross examination dated 18.08.2012 that the Plaintiff was in possession of
the suit property. However, Mr. Dharmendra Singh, in his cross examination
dated 15.02.2013 had deposed that he has not seen any documents showing
that the Plaintiff was the owner of the suit property, as was pleaded by him in
his evidence by way of affidavit, and he had only seen the house tax receipts
of the suit property. The relevant portion of the cross examination dated
15.02.2013 is reproduced as under: -
“ I have not seen any document to show that plaintiff is owner in
pleaded by me in para 2 of my affidavit. (Vol. I have seen him in
possession). I have seen house tax receipt in favour of plaintiff with
regard to suit property. I have not seen any other document except
house tax receipt. I do not know how the property is assessed to MCD. I
have no document to show that construction was carried out in 1997 by
Signature Not Verified
Digitally Signed By:BHASKAR
SINGH RAWAT
Signing Date:21.11.2026
14:09:04
RFA 488/2014 & conn. Page 56 of 74
plaintiff but I used to see that. I am not in position to show the
demolition and construction. I have been brought to give evidence on
behalf of plaintiff.”
The aforesaid testimony of Mr. Dharmendra Singh shows that he had
not seen any document establishing the Plaintiff’s ownership over the suit
property, except for the house tax receipts. Further, although he had claimed
that the Plaintiff was in possession of the suit property, he admitted that he
had no document to show that the construction therein had been carried out by
the Plaintiff in the year 1997. Therefore, the testimony of Mr. Dharmendra
Singh, while supporting the Plaintiff’s claim of possession, does not establish
his ownership over the suit property.
89. The Plaintiff, had further relied upon the testimony of Mr. Sunil
Kumar, PW-3, i.e. , who was residing in Mehrauli, Delhi, and in his cross-
examination dated 15.02.2015 he had stated that he had seen the Plaintiff in
possession of the suit property. The relevant portion of the said cross-
examination reads as under: -
“ I have not seen any document to show that plaintiff is owner in
pleaded by me in para 2 of my affidavit (Vol. I have seen him in
possession). I have seen house tax receipt in favour of plaintiff with
regard to suit property. I have not seen any other document except
house tax receipt. I do not know how the property is assessed to MCD. I
have no document to show that the construction was carried out in 1997
by plaintiff but I used to see that. I am not in position to show the
demolition and construction. I have been brought to give evidence on
behalf of plaintiff. ”
A perusal of the aforesaid testimony would demonstrate that it is
identical to that of PW-2, Mr. Dharmendra Singh, and therefore, as discussed
Signature Not Verified
Digitally Signed By:BHASKAR
SINGH RAWAT
Signing Date:21.11.2026
14:09:04
RFA 488/2014 & conn. Page 57 of 74
hereinbefore, it could not be of any assistance to prove the Plaintiff’s case.
90. Learned Senior Counsels for the Plaintiff had submitted that the Local
Commissioner, in his report dated 04.06.1998 had identified the suit property
as RZ-33 B/1, and therefore, the claim of the Defendant that the suit property
bears a different municipal number is devoid of merit. However, it would be
apposite to refer to the cross-examination dated 05.11.2008 of Mr. Anupam
Dhingra, PW-2, i.e. , Local Commissioner, wherein he had deposed as under: -
“ I cannot tell whether the number on the property is RZ-33-B/7,
Ward No. 9, Kishan Garh, Delhi as there was no number plate on
any part in the property but the same was identified by both the
parties …
…I was not supposed to ascertain the ownership of the suit property
including the building material or the goods lying in the suit property.”
In view of the said testimony, it is evident that the Local Commissioner
had not verified the municipal number of the suit property and had identified
the same on the basis of the identification of the suit property by the parties,
and therefore, the report of the Local Commissioner, by itself, does not
establish that the suit property was bearing Municipal No. RZ-33 B/1.
91. On the other hand, the Defendant had claimed ownership over the suit
property on the basis of an alleged oral family partition amongst the sons of
late Shri Prabhu, and had relied upon the following documents in support of
his claim: -
i. Undertaking executed by the Plaintiff, Defendant and two of their
brothers, namely Mr. Gajender Singh and Mr. Ishwar Singh, i.e. , sons of late
Signature Not Verified
Digitally Signed By:BHASKAR
SINGH RAWAT
Signing Date:21.11.2026
14:09:04
RFA 488/2014 & conn. Page 58 of 74
Shri Prabhu, Ex. PW-1/D1;
ii. General Power of Attorney executed by late Shri Prabhi in favour of
the Defendant, dated 11.09.1995, Ex. PW-1/D2;
iii. Will dated 30.08.1995 executed by late Shri Prabhu in favour of the
Defendant, Ex. DW-1/2;
iv. Site plan depicting the portions of land allegedly allotted to the
respective brothers pursuant to the said partition, Ex. DW-1/4;
v. General Power of Attorney executed by late Shri Prabhu in favour of
Mr. Ishwar Singh, i.e. , brother of parties, Mark D2/1;
vi. Will dated 30.08.1995, registered on 09.11.1995 executed by late Shri
Prabhu in favour of Mr. Ishwar Singh, Ex. DW-7/1;
vii. Will of late Shri Hari Singh, Mark A;
viii. General Power of Attorney dated 11.09.1995 registered on 09.11.1995,
in favour of Mr. Gajender Singh, with site plan, Ex. DW-3/1;
ix. Will dated 30.08.1995, registered on 09.11.1995 in favour of Gajender
Singh, Ex. DW-3/2;
x. General Power of Attorney in favour of the Plaintiff, Ex. DW-7/2;
xi. Will in favour of the Plaintiff, Ex. DW-7/3;
xii. Orders passed in Criminal Writ Petition No. 892/1998, Ex. DW-4/1;
and
xiii. Affidavit filed by the DCP in Criminal Writ Petition No. 892/1998;
Mark A.
92. Learned Trial Court, while adjudicating the aforementioned issues, had
given a completely contrary finding, and the same reads as under: -
Signature Not Verified
Digitally Signed By:BHASKAR
SINGH RAWAT
Signing Date:21.11.2026
14:09:04
RFA 488/2014 & conn. Page 59 of 74
“13. …In totality of the circumstances, it is crystal clear that there is
no dispute regarding holding of property once upon time by Late Prabhu
(which even may be as co-shares alongwith his other siblings) but
subsequent transfer by oral partition to different LRs was to be proved by
defendants which they have failed, it is also crystal clear that plaintiff has
also not come to the court with clean hands and both the parties are lying
after coming to the court. But crux of the above observation is that when
defendant has failed to prove the oral partition, the land is deemed to be
joint and all the persons i.e. plaintiff and defendants No. 1 and 2 and
other LRs of Late Prabhu are deemed to be co-sharers in equal shares
and it cannot be held that property was exclusively hold by defendant. It
cannot be held that property solely owned by plaintiff and being
cosharer, both the parties are deemed to be owner and in possession till
partition by metes and bounds. In these circumstances, the question of
exclusive possession either with plaintiff and defendant losses its
significance because one party will be deemed to be having possession
with other co-sharer also, though otherwise defendants have failed to
prove their exclusive possession thus in these circumstances, issue No. 2
is decided accordingly and plaintiff is deemed to be co-sharers of the suit
property and issue No. 5 becomes redundant. As far as issue no. 6 is
concerned, exclusive possession cannot be given to any of the party and
suit for partition by metes and bounds is required to be filed by parties.
The issue No. 6 is answered accordingly. As far as issue No. 3 is
concerned, it is clear that when all the parties are co-sharers then every
co-sharer can use every piece of land and then defendant cannot restrain
the plaintiff from using any part and parcel of land. The plea of exclusive
possession of defendant is not accepted and so the plaintiff has every
right to enter into the suit land and all of them will hold the possession or
will do whatever they want in whole of the suit land subject to condition
that same will be equally for the benefit of all the parties and no specific
share can be given to any of the parties and all the share holders shall
enjoy the property jointly accordingly All the issues are decided
accordingly in above terms.
14. Relief:- In view of the above finding, the suit of the plaintiff stands
partly decreed with costs as aforesaid. Decree sheet be prepared
accordingly and file be consigned to Record Room.”
Thus, the learned Trial Court, while disbelieving the documents placed
on record by the Defendant qua the oral partition, concluded that although
Signature Not Verified
Digitally Signed By:BHASKAR
SINGH RAWAT
Signing Date:21.11.2026
14:09:04
RFA 488/2014 & conn. Page 60 of 74
there was no dispute with regard to the property having been held by late Shri
Prabhu, i.e. , the father of the parties, the subsequent partition of the property
amongst his legal representatives had not been proved by the Defendant. The
learned Trial Court had further observed that even the Plaintiff had not
approached the Court with clean hands. However, on the basis of the
Defendant's failure to prove the alleged partition, the learned Trial Court
proceeded to hold that the suit property would be deemed to be jointly held by
the Plaintiff, the Defendants and the other legal representatives of late Shri
Prabhu, who were consequently treated as co-sharers therein. The learned
Trial Court concluded that the suit property could not be held to be in the
exclusive possession of the Defendant. The aforesaid finding rendered by the
learned Trial Court is contrary to the pleadings of the parties. Neither the
Plaintiff nor the Defendant had set up a case that the suit property was jointly
held by the Plaintiff, the Defendant and the other legal representatives of late
Shri Prabhu. Rather, both the parties had asserted their respective claims over
the suit property. Therefore, the learned Trial Court, merely on account of the
Defendant's failure to prove the oral partition, could not have proceeded to
hold that the suit property was jointly held by the parties and the other legal
representatives of late Shri Prabhu, thereby treating them as co-sharers in the
suit property.
93. Even otherwise, the impugned judgment passed by learned ADJ suffers
from a fundamental error, as no issue was framed qua the aforesaid findings.
It is pertinent to note that the aforesaid finding has been challenged by both
the Plaintiff and the Defendant by way of the present appeals, as this was not
the case pleaded or step-up by either of them. Once the learned ADJ had
Signature Not Verified
Digitally Signed By:BHASKAR
SINGH RAWAT
Signing Date:21.11.2026
14:09:04
RFA 488/2014 & conn. Page 61 of 74
come to the conclusion that the land was jointly owned by both Plaintiff and
Defendant along with other members of the family, he ought to have decided
as to who was in possession of the same at the time of the institution of suit in
the year 1998. It has been rightly argued by learned Senior Counsels for the
Defendant that serious infirmity had crept in the judgment while relying upon
the wrong memo of parties of some other suit. The learned Trial Court,
therefore, erred while returning the aforesaid finding.
94. Be that as it may, this Court will now proceed to examine the Plaintiff's
claim for the relief of injunction and possession on the basis of his alleged
prior possession in suit property.
95. So far as the question of ownership is concerned, no document has been
placed on record by the Plaintiff to substantiate his claim of ownership over
the suit property. On the contrary, Smt. Premwati, i.e. , daughter of late Shri
Hari Singh, had deposed before the learned Trial Court that no land had been
transferred to the Plaintiff by late Shri Hari Singh. The relevant portion of her
cross examination dated 07.02.2014 is reproduced as under: -
“…My father had bequeathed his entire movable and immovable
property to me and my sister. My father had never gifted any property or
portion thereof to Pratap Singh. He had no occasion to deal with Pratap
Singh and as such to give any property or any portion thereof to him.”
96. There are two factors in favour of the Defendant being in possession of
the suit property, i.e. , report of the Local Commissioner, wherein he had
stated that the gates were opened by the Defendant and the affidavit filed by
the DCP, as noted hereinabove. So far as the address of the suit property is
Signature Not Verified
Digitally Signed By:BHASKAR
SINGH RAWAT
Signing Date:21.11.2026
14:09:04
RFA 488/2014 & conn. Page 62 of 74
concerned, the affidavit filed by the DCP before this Court had clearly
identified the property as RZ-33B-7/9. It is further pertinent to note that the
Defendant, in his written statement, had specifically disputed the description
of the suit property as stated by the Plaintiff in the plaint; however, the
learned Trial Court had not framed any issue qua the same. The criminal writ
petition filed by the Plaintiff was also dismissed by the learned Division
Bench of this Court on the basis of the said affidavit of the DCP. It is further
pertinent to note that the affidavit filed by the DCP, as well as the order
dismissing the writ petition, had never been challenged by the Plaintiff. In
view of the same, the discrepancy in the description of the suit property
assumes significance while examining the Plaintiff's claim of possession over
the suit property. Learned Senior Counsels for the Plaintiff had relied upon
the report of Local Commissioner wherein it has been stated that the suit
property was RZ-33-B/1. The said reliance is misplaced, inasmuch as the
report of the Local Commissioner itself further records that there was no
address plate or number on the suit property. It is further noted that this
objection with regard to the description of the property had been taken by the
Defendant at the very first instance in the written statement filed before the
learned Trial Court. However, no such issue was framed by the learned Trial
Court nor any finding was given thereupon.
97. It is further pertinent to note that even if the electricity meter had been
forcibly removed by the Defendant in the year 1998, nothing has been placed
on record to demonstrate that any attempts were made on behalf of the
Plaintiff to reinstall the said meter, till his alleged dispossession on
14.02.2006.
Signature Not Verified
Digitally Signed By:BHASKAR
SINGH RAWAT
Signing Date:21.11.2026
14:09:04
RFA 488/2014 & conn. Page 63 of 74
98. The Plaintiff was required to establish his actual possession over the
suit property on the basis of the evidence led by him. However, the
documents relied upon by the Plaintiff, including the house tax receipts and
the electricity bills, do not, in themselves, establish that the Plaintiff was in
actual possession of the suit property. It is further pertinent to note that no
official from the electricity department was examined to prove the electricity
bills as relied upon by the Plaintiff. Further, the affidavit filed by the DCP in
Criminal Writ Petition No. 892/1998 refers to the property as RZ-33B/7 and it
further records that no electricity meter had been installed therein. The
aforesaid circumstances, create a doubt as to whether the documents relied
upon by the Plaintiff pertain to the very property in respect of which he has
claimed possession in the subject suit. In view of the same, this Court is of the
considered opinion that the Plaintiff has failed to establish his possession over
the suit property.
99. So far as the issue with regard to the alleged forcible dispossession of
the Plaintiff on 14.02.2006 is concerned, it is pertinent to note that the said
allegation formed the basis for the subsequent amendment of the plaint,
whereby the Plaintiff sought the relief of recovery of possession. Therefore,
the Plaintiff was required to establish not only his prior possession over the
suit property but also his dispossession by the Defendant. However, in view
of the material discussed hereinabove, particularly the discrepancy with
regard to the description of the suit property and the failure of the Plaintiff to
establish his possession over the property in question, the Plaintiff has failed
to establish his entitlement to the relief of recovery of possession.
Signature Not Verified
Digitally Signed By:BHASKAR
SINGH RAWAT
Signing Date:21.11.2026
14:09:04
RFA 488/2014 & conn. Page 64 of 74
100. Reliance was also placed by the learned Senior Counsels for the
Plaintiff on Section 81 of the Indian Evidence Act, 1872, to contend that a
presumption ought to be raised in respect of the original electricity bill placed
on record. However, the said provision would be of no assistance to the
Plaintiff, inasmuch as the foundational facts necessary for raising such
presumption have not been established. No witness from the Electricity
Department was examined to establish whether the said bill had been issued
in respect of the suit property. Further, no evidence was led to establish that
an electricity meter had ever been installed at the suit property. It is further
pertinent to note that the affidavit filed by the DCP records that no electricity
meter had been sanctioned for property bearing No. RZ-33B/1, and that the
disputed property was identified as RZ-33B/7, in respect of which no
electricity meter had been installed.
101. Learned Senior Counsels for the Plaintiff had placed reliance upon the
judgment dated 28.10.2025 titled as “ Sh. Mahender Singh (Since Deceased)
through LRs vs. Shri Pratap Singh and Ors. ” rendered in CS DJ-612992-
16 wherein the suit for declaration filed on behalf of the Defendant on the
basis of documents produced on record in the present suit was dismissed. It is
further submitted that the aforesaid finding with regard to title documents of
the Defendant would have a bearing in the present case. It was further pointed
out by learned Senior Counsels for the Defendant that the aforesaid judgment
had been challenged before this Court in RFA 1053/2025 and connected
matter, and the learned Single Judge of this Court vide order dated 19.11.2025
had stayed the effect and operation of the judgment dated 28.10.2025. Be that
as it may, as noted hereinabove, this Court has examined the issue of
Signature Not Verified
Digitally Signed By:BHASKAR
SINGH RAWAT
Signing Date:21.11.2026
14:09:04
RFA 488/2014 & conn. Page 65 of 74
possession and is not examining the documents claiming ownership produced
by the Defendant. As noted hereinabove, the suit of the Plaintiff for injunction
would necessarily be maintainable if it is proved on record that the Plaintiff
was in possession of suit property.
102. In a suit for injunction, the Plaintiff must establish his right over the
suit property and demonstrate that the Defendant has interfered with such
rights. Moreover, where the Plaintiff had also sought recovery of possession,
he must establish that he was in prior possession of the suit property, and was
subsequently dispossessed by the Defendant. However, in the present case,
the Plaintiff had failed to establish his ownership over the suit property, or
that he was dispossessed by the Defendant. Reliance has been placed by
learned Senior Counsels for the Defendant on Anathula Sudhakar ( Supra )
and particularly on the following paragraphs: -
“13.3. Where the plaintiff is in possession, but his title to the property is
in dispute, or under a cloud, or where the defendant asserts title thereto
and there is also a threat of dispossession from the defendant, the
plaintiff will have to sue for declaration of title and the consequential
relief of injunction. Where the title of the plaintiff is under a cloud or in
dispute and he is not in possession or not able to establish possession,
necessarily the plaintiff will have to file a suit for declaration, possession
and injunction.
14. We may, however, clarify that a prayer for declaration will be
necessary only if the denial of title by the defendant or challenge to the
plaintiff's title raises a cloud on the title of the plaintiff to the property. A
cloud is said to raise over a person's title, when some apparent defect in
his title to a property, or when some prima facie right of a third party
over it, is made out or shown. An action for declaration, is the remedy to
remove the cloud on the title to the property. On the other hand, where
the plaintiff has clear title supported by documents, if a trespasser
Signature Not Verified
Digitally Signed By:BHASKAR
SINGH RAWAT
Signing Date:21.11.2026
14:09:04
RFA 488/2014 & conn. Page 66 of 74
without any claim to title or an interloper without any apparent title,
merely denies the plaintiff's title, it does not amount to raising a cloud
over the title of the plaintiff and it will not be necessary for the plaintiff
to sue for declaration and a suit for injunction may be sufficient. Where
the plaintiff, believing that the defendant is only a trespasser or a
wrongful claimant without title, files a mere suit for injunction, and in
such a suit, the defendant discloses in his defence the details of the right
or title claimed by him, which raise a serious dispute or cloud over the
plaintiff's title, then there is a need for the plaintiff, to amend the plaint
and convert the suit into one for declaration. Alternatively, he may
withdraw the suit for bare injunction, with permission of the court to file
a comprehensive suit for declaration and injunction. He may file the suit
for declaration with consequential relief, even after the suit for injunction
is dismissed, where the suit raised only the issue of possession and not
any issue of title.
21. To summarise, the position in regard to suits for prohibitory
injunction relating to immovable property, is as under:
( a ) Where a cloud is raised over the plaintiff's title and he does not have
possession, a suit for declaration and possession, with or without a
consequential injunction, is the remedy. Where the plaintiff's title is not
in dispute or under a cloud, but he is out of possession, he has to sue for
possession with a consequential injunction. Where there is merely an
interference with the plaintiff's lawful possession or threat of
dispossession, it is sufficient to sue for an injunction simpliciter.
( b ) As a suit for injunction simpliciter is concerned only with possession,
normally the issue of title will not be directly and substantially in issue.
The prayer for injunction will be decided with reference to the finding on
possession. But in cases where de jure possession has to be established
on the basis of title to the property, as in the case of vacant sites, the
issue of title may directly and substantially arise for consideration, as
without a finding thereon, it will not be possible to decide the issue of
possession.
( c ) But a finding on title cannot be recorded in a suit for injunction,
unless there are necessary pleadings and appropriate issue regarding title
(either specific, or implied as noticed in Annaimuthu Thevar
[ Annaimuthu Thevar v. Alagammal , (2005) 6 SCC 202] ). Where the
Signature Not Verified
Digitally Signed By:BHASKAR
SINGH RAWAT
Signing Date:21.11.2026
14:09:04
RFA 488/2014 & conn. Page 67 of 74
averments regarding title are absent in a plaint and where there is no
issue relating to title, the court will not investigate or examine or render a
finding on a question of title, in a suit for injunction. Even where there
are necessary pleadings and issue, if the matter involves complicated
questions of fact and law relating to title, the court will relegate the
parties to the remedy by way of comprehensive suit for declaration of
title, instead of deciding the issue in a suit for mere injunction.
( d ) Where there are necessary pleadings regarding title, and appropriate
issue relating to title on which parties lead evidence, if the matter
involved is simple and straightforward, the court may decide upon the
issue regarding title, even in a suit for injunction. But such cases, are the
exception to the normal rule that question of title will not be decided in
suits for injunction. But persons having clear title and possession suing
for injunction, should not be driven to the costlier and more cumbersome
remedy of a suit for declaration, merely because some meddler
vexatiously or wrongfully makes a claim or tries to encroach upon his
property. The court should use its discretion carefully to identify cases
where it will enquire into title and cases where it will refer to the plaintiff
to a more comprehensive declaratory suit, depending upon the facts of
the case.
29. The High Court, in the absence of pleadings and issues, formulated in
a second appeal arising from a suit for bare injunction, questions of law
unrelated to the pleadings and issues, presumably because some evidence
was led and some arguments were advanced on those aspects. The only
averment in the plaint that the plaintiffs were the owners of the suit
property having purchased the same under sale deeds dated 9-12-1968,
did not enable the court, much less a High Court in second appeal, to
hold a roving enquiry into an oral gift and its validity or validation of
ostensible title under Section 41 of the TP Act. No amount of evidence
or arguments can be looked into or considered in the absence of
pleadings and issues, is a proposition that is too well settled.”
Learned Senior Counsels for the Plaintiff had tried to distinguish the
aforesaid judgment by submitting that in the said case the Defendant therein
was able to show a better title than the Plaintiff, as shown in paragraphs 6 and
7, which are reproduced as under: -
Signature Not Verified
Digitally Signed By:BHASKAR
SINGH RAWAT
Signing Date:21.11.2026
14:09:04
RFA 488/2014 & conn. Page 68 of 74
“ 6. There was no dispute that the site purchased by the defendant from
Damodar Rao under deed dated 7-11-1977 is the same as the two sites
purchased by the plaintiffs from Rukminibai under sale deeds dated 9-
12-1968. There is also no dispute that the suit property is a vacant plot
and it was originally portion of the backyard of the property bearing Nos.
13/775 and 13/776, belonging to Damodar Rao, and that he was shown
as registered owner of the said Properties Nos. 13/775 and 13/776 in the
municipal records.
7. The plaintiffs led evidence to the effect that Damadar Rao orally gifted
the backyard portion of Nos. 13/775 and 13/776 (separated from the
main building by a dividing wall) to his sister Rukminibai in the year
1961, by way of “pasupu kumkumam” (a gift made to a daughter or
sister, conferring absolute title, out of love and affection, with a view to
provide for her); that Rukminibai sold three portions of the gifted site to
PW 3, Plaintiff 1, Plaintiff 2 in the year 1968 and they were in
possession ever since 1968; and that an agreement of sale was also
entered in regard to another portion with PW 5 as per Ext. X-2. On the
other hand, the defendant led evidence denying that the suit property was
given to Rukminibai by way of “pasupu kumkumam”. His vendor
Damodar Rao gave evidence that he was the owner of the suit property
and he sold it to the defendant under deed dated 7-11-1977 and put him
in possession thereof. While the plaintiffs alleged that plots were mutated
in their names after their purchase, the defendant alleged that the suit
property purchased by him was a part of Plot No. 13/776 which stood in
the name of Damodar Rao in the municipal records. Neither party
produced the order of mutation or any certificate from the municipal
authorities, certifying or showing mutation to their names. They only
produced tax receipts. The tax receipts produced by the plaintiffs showed
that they had paid taxes from 1978 onwards, that is, for a period
subsequent to the sale by Damodar Rao in favour of the defendant. The
plaintiffs did not produce any tax-paid receipt to show that the property
stood in the name of Rukminibai. Nor did they produce any tax receipt
for the period 9-12-1968 (date of purchase by the plaintiffs) to 7-11-1977
(date of purchase by the defendant). The defendant produced tax receipts
to show that the suit property stood in the name of his vendor Damodar
Rao till the date of sale in his favour.”
However, in the present case the fact remains that the Plaintiff has not
Signature Not Verified
Digitally Signed By:BHASKAR
SINGH RAWAT
Signing Date:21.11.2026
14:09:04
RFA 488/2014 & conn. Page 69 of 74
been able to show any clear title to the suit property, nor the possession was
proved in accordance with law, despite the fact that the issue no. 2 was with
regard to the ownership and the onus was upon the Plaintiff to prove the
same. Although, there is no finding with regard to the same, as noted
hereinabove, no documents or sufficient/credible evidence has been placed on
record to establish the ownership of the Plaintiff.
103. Learned Senior Counsels for the Plaintiff had further relied upon on
Rame Gowda (Dead) by LRs ( Supra ) to contend that in the absence of proof
of better title, possession or prior peaceful settled possession itself becomes
evidence of title. Relevant portion of the said judgment reads as under: -
“7. The thought has prevailed incessantly, till date, the last and latest one
in the chain of decisions being Ramesh Chand Ardawatiya v. Anil
Panjwani [(2003) 7 SCC 350] . In between, to quote a few out of several,
in Lallu Yeshwant Singh v. Rao Jagdish Singh [AIR 1968 SC 620 :
(1968) 2 SCR 203] this Court has held that a landlord did commit
trespass when he forcibly entered his own land in the possession of a
tenant whose tenancy has expired. The Court turned down the
submission that under the general law applicable to a lessor and a lessee
there was no rule or principle which made it obligatory for the lessor to
resort to court and obtain an order for possession before he could eject
the lessee. The Court quoted with approval the law as stated by a Full
Bench of the Allahabad High Court in Yar Mohd. v. Lakshmi Das [AIR
1959 All 1 : 1958 All LJ 628 (FB)] (AIR at p. 4):
“Law respects possession even if there is no title to support it. It will not
permit any person to take the law in his own hands and to dispossess a
person in actual possession without having recourse to a court. No
person can be allowed to become a judge in his own cause.” (AIR p. 5,
para 13)
In the oft-quoted case of Nair Service Society Ltd. v. K.C. Alexander
[AIR 1968 SC 1165 : (1968) 3 SCR 163] this Court held that a person in
Signature Not Verified
Digitally Signed By:BHASKAR
SINGH RAWAT
Signing Date:21.11.2026
14:09:04
RFA 488/2014 & conn. Page 70 of 74
possession of land in assumed character of owner and exercising
peaceably the ordinary rights of ownership has a perfectly good title
against all the world but the rightful owner. When the facts disclose no
title in either party, possession alone decides . The Court quoted Loft's
maxim — “ Possessio contra omnes valet praeter eur cui ius sit
possessionis (he that hath possession hath right against all but him that
hath the very right)” and said: (AIR p. 1175, para 20)
“A defendant in such a case must show in himself or his predecessor a
valid legal title, or probably a possession prior to the plaintiff's and thus
be able to raise a presumption prior in time.”
In M.C. Chockalingam v. V. Manickavasagam [(1974) 1 SCC 48] this
Court held that the law forbids forcible dispossession, even with the best
of title. In Krishna Ram Mahale v. Shobha Venkat Rao [(1989) 4 SCC
131] it was held that where a person is in settled possession of property,
even on the assumption that he had no right to remain on the property, he
cannot be dispossessed by the owner of the property except by recourse
to law. In Nagar Palika, Jind v. Jagat Singh [(1995) 3 SCC 426] this
Court held that disputed questions of title are to be decided by due
process of law, but the peaceful possession is to be protected from the
trespasser without regard to the question of the origin of the possession.
When the defendant fails in proving his title to the suit land the plaintiff
can succeed in securing a decree for possession on the basis of his prior
possession against the defendant who has dispossessed him. Such a suit
will be founded on the averment of previous possession of the plaintiff
and dispossession by the defendant.
8. It is thus clear that so far as the Indian law is concerned, the person in
peaceful possession is entitled to retain his possession and in order to
protect such possession he may even use reasonable force to keep out a
trespasser. A rightful owner who has been wrongfully dispossessed of
land may retake possession if he can do so peacefully and without the
use of unreasonable force. If the trespasser is in settled possession of the
property belonging to the rightful owner, the rightful owner shall have to
take recourse to law; he cannot take the law in his own hands and evict
the trespasser or interfere with his possession. The law will come to the
aid of a person in peaceful and settled possession by injuncting even a
rightful owner from using force or taking the law in his own hands, and
also by restoring him in possession even from the rightful owner (of
course subject to the law of limitation), if the latter has dispossessed the
prior possessor by use of force. In the absence of proof of better title,
Signature Not Verified
Digitally Signed By:BHASKAR
SINGH RAWAT
Signing Date:21.11.2026
14:09:04
RFA 488/2014 & conn. Page 71 of 74
possession or prior peaceful settled possession is itself evidence of title.
Law presumes the possession to go with the title unless rebutted. The
owner of any property may prevent even by using reasonable force a
trespasser from an attempted trespass, when it is in the process of being
committed, or is of a flimsy character, or recurring, intermittent, stray or
casual in nature, or has just been committed, while the rightful owner did
not have enough time to have recourse to law. In the last of the cases, the
possession of the trespasser, just entered into would not be called as one
acquiesced to by the true owner.”
104. Learned Senior Counsels for the Plaintiff had further relied upon
Shivshankar & Anr. ( Supra ) to contend that when both the parties fail to
establish their title, the question of who had prior possession becomes crucial.
The relevant portion of the said judgment reads as under: -
“30. It is evident that on a careful consideration of the available
pleadings of the defendants, the High Court held that they did not
disclose their defence in their written statement and at the same time did
not even contend therein that they are in possession of the suit property.
According to us, in such circumstances, when the facts disclose no title
in either party, at the relevant time, prior possession alone decides the
right to possession of land in the assumed character of owner against all
the world except against the rightful owner. In that context, it is worthy
to refer to the maxim ‘Possessio contra omnes valet praeter eur cui ius sit
possessionis’ (he that hath possession hath right against all but him that
hath the very right)”.”
105. There is no dispute with the proposition of law laid down in the
aforesaid judgments. However, in order to seek protection of possession or
recovery of possession on the basis of prior possession, the Plaintiff was
required to establish that he was in actual possession of the suit property and
that the Defendant had interfered with such possession or had dispossessed
him therefrom. In the present case, as discussed hereinabove, the Plaintiff has
failed to establish that he was in possession of the suit property. Further, the
Signature Not Verified
Digitally Signed By:BHASKAR
SINGH RAWAT
Signing Date:21.11.2026
14:09:04
RFA 488/2014 & conn. Page 72 of 74
evidence led by the Plaintiff does not sufficiently establish that the property in
respect of which the documents were relied upon was the same property
forming the subject matter of the present suit. In view of the same, the
aforesaid judgments do not support the case of the Plaintiff.
106. In view of the aforesaid discussion, this Court is of the considered
opinion that the findings returned by the learned ADJ, resulting in a partial
decree, cannot be sustained. The Plaintiff has failed to establish his
entitlement to the reliefs as claimed in the suit. Accordingly, the impugned
judgment and decree dated 11.09.2014 is liable to be set aside.
107. In view of the aforesaid findings, this Court finds merit in the appeal
preferred by the Defendant, i.e. , RFA 488/2014 . Accordingly, the appeal
preferred by the Defendant is allowed and disposed of and the impugned
judgment and decree dated 11.09.2014 is hereby set aside. The subject suit
filed by the Plaintiff, i.e., CS No. 53/11/98, stands dismissed.
108. So far as the appeal preferred by the Plaintiff, i.e. , RFA 615/2014 , is
concerned, in view of the failure of the Plaintiff to establish his entitlement to
the reliefs claimed in the suit, this Court finds no ground to grant any further
relief to the Plaintiff. Accordingly, the appeal preferred by the Plaintiff is
hereby disposed of in the aforesaid terms.
109. The interim order dated 01.10.2014 passed by the learned Predecessor
Bench of this Court, directing the parties to maintain status quo with respect
to the suit property, stands vacated.
Signature Not Verified
Digitally Signed By:BHASKAR
SINGH RAWAT
Signing Date:21.11.2026
14:09:04
RFA 488/2014 & conn. Page 73 of 74
110. Pending application(s), if any, also stands disposed of.
111. Judgment be uploaded on the website of this Court, forthwith .
AMIT SHARMA
(JUDGE)
NOVEMBER 20 ,2026 /sn/db
Signature Not Verified
Digitally Signed By:BHASKAR
SINGH RAWAT
Signing Date:21.11.2026
14:09:04
RFA 488/2014 & conn. Page 74 of 74