SRI.ASWATHA NARAYANA REDDY vs THE STATE OF KARNATAKA

Court
Karnataka High Court

®
- 1 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:61808
WP No. 29514 of 2026
C/W WP No. 28317 of 2026

CNR: KAHC010642392026





IN THE HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA AT BENGALURU


TH
DATED THIS THE 6 DAY OF NOVEMBER, 2026

BEFORE

THE HON'BLE SMT. JUSTICE LALITHA KANNEGANTI

WRIT PETITION NO. 29514 OF 2026 (EXCISE)

C/W

WRIT PETITION NO. 28317 OF 2026 (EXCISE)


IN WP No. 29514/2026

BETWEEN:

1. SRI.ASWATHA NARAYANA REDDY
S/O LATE VENKATA SWAMY REDDY
AGED ABOUT 64 YEARS,
R/AT OPP. MANVI CONVENTION HALL
ST
1 SECTOR, HSR LAYOUT
BENGALURU,
KARNATAKA-560 102

2. SRI. KARTHIK A
S/O ASWATHA NARAYAN REDDY
AGED ABOUT 35 YEARS,
R/AT OPP MANVI CONVENTION HALL
ST
1 SECTOR, HSR LAYOUT
BENGALURU,
KARNATAKA-560 102
…PETITIONERS
(BY SRI. PRASHANTH S., ADVOCATE)

AND:

1. THE STATE OF KARNATAKA
DEPARTMENT OF REVENUE,
REPRESENTED BY ITS SECRETARY,
VIDHANA SOUDHA,









Digitally
signed by
SUVARNA T
Location:
HIGH COURT
OF
KARNATAKA

- 2 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:61808
WP No. 29514 of 2026
C/W WP No. 28317 of 2026

CNR: KAHC010642392026



BENGALURU -560 001

2. THE COMMISSIONER OF EXCISE
OFFICE OF THE EXCISE COMMISSIONER,
2ND FLOOR, TTMC 'A' BLOCK,
BMTC BUILDING, SHANTINAGAR,
BENGALURU -560 027
3. THE DEPUTY COMMISSIONER
OF EXCISE (BUD-5)
BENGALURU URBAN DISTRICT,
BENGALURU-560 027

4. THE INSPECTOR OF EXCISE
RANGE 30, MAHADEVAPURA,
(BUD-5) BENGALURU-560 048

5. SRI.HARI PRASAD B.G.,
S/O GOPAL REDDY
AGED ABOUT 36 YEARS
R/AT HOUSE NO.120
SRINIDHI, GOPALA REDDY COMPOUND
NEAR KADUBEESANAHALLI
BENGALURU-560 103
…RESPONDENTS
(BY SMT.PRATHIMA HONNAPUR, AAG A/W
SRI.MANJUNATH K., HCGP FOR R1 TO R4
SRI.MAHESHKIRAN SHETTY S., ADVOCATE FOR R5)

THIS WRIT PETITION IS FILED UNDER ARTICLES 226
AND 227 OF THE CONSTITUTION OF INDIA, PRAYING TO
QUASHING THE IMPUGNED ENDORSEMENT/ORDER DATED
03.09.2026 BEARING NO. EXE/BUD-5/V30/CL-9
R.VB/17A/40/2025-2026, ISSUED BY RESPONDENT NO.3, VIDE
ANNEXURE F.

- 3 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:61808
WP No. 29514 of 2026
C/W WP No. 28317 of 2026

CNR: KAHC010642392026



IN WP NO. 28317/2026

BETWEEN:

SRI HARI PRASAD B.G.,
S/O GOPAL REDDY
AGED ABOUT 36 YEARS
R/AT. HOUSE NO. 120,
SRINIDHI, GOPALA REDDY COMPOUND,
NEAR KADUBEESANAHALLI,
BENGALURU -560 103
...PETITIONER
(BY SRI. MAHESHKIRAN SHETTY S., ADVOCATE)

AND:

1. THE STATE OF KARNATAKA
DEPARTMENT OF REVENUE,
REPRESENTED BY ITS SECRETARY,
VIDHANA SOUDHA,
BENGALURU -560 001

2. THE COMMISSIONER OF EXCISE
OFFICE OF THE EXCISE COMMISSIONER,
ND
2 FLOOR, TTMC A BLOCK,
BMTC BUILDING, SHANTINAGAR,
BENGALURU -560 027

3. THE DEPUTY COMMISSIONER
OF EXCISE (BUD-5)
BENGALURU URBAN DISTRICT,
BENGALURU -560 027

4. THE INSPECTOR OF EXCISE
RANGE 30, MAHADEVAPURA, (BUD-5)
BENGALURU- 560 048

5. SRI. ASWATHA NARAYANA REDDY
S/O LATE VENKATA SWAMY REDDY
AGED ABOUT 64 YEARS
R/AT. OPP. MANVI CONVENTION HALL,

- 4 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:61808
WP No. 29514 of 2026
C/W WP No. 28317 of 2026

CNR: KAHC010642392026



ST
1 SECTOR, HSR LAYOUT,
BENGALURU – 560 102
...RESPONDENTS
(BY SMT.PRATHIMA HONNAPUR, AAG A/W
SRI.MANJUNATH K., HCGP FOR R1 TO R4
SRI.PRASHANTH S., ADVOCATE FOR R5)

THIS WRIT PETITION IS FILED UNDER ARTICLES 226 AND
227 OF THE CONSTITUTION OF INDIA, PRAYING TO ISSUE A
WRIT IN THE NATURE OF CERTIORARI OR ANY OTHER
APPROPRIATE WRIT OR DIRECTION TO QUASH THE ORDER
BEARING NO. EXE/BUD-5/VA-30/CL-9PLUSR.V.B./17-
A/40/2025-26, DATED 27.08.2026 PASSED BY THE
RESPONDENT NO. 3 VIDE ANNEXURE-Y.
THESE WRIT PETITIONS HAVING BEEN HEARD AND
RESERVED ON 02.11.2026, COMING ON FOR
PRONOUNCEMENT OF ORDER THIS DAY, THE COURT
PRONOUNCED THE FOLLOWING:

CORAM: HON'BLE SMT. JUSTICE LALITHA KANNEGANTI
CAV ORDER
Both the writ petitions are filed questioning the order
dated 03.09.2026 passed in No.EXE/BUD-5/VA30/CL-9 +
R.V.B/17-A/40/2025-26 by the Deputy Commissioner, Excise,
Bengaluru. Hence, both the writ petitions are disposed of by
way of a common order.

BRIEF FACTS IN WP NO.28317/2026:

2. It is the case of the petitioner that one late Smt.
Premamma V, being the aunt of the petitioner was holding

- 5 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:61808
WP No. 29514 of 2026
C/W WP No. 28317 of 2026

CNR: KAHC010642392026



Form CL-9 license for the sale of Indian Liquor or Foreign
Liquor to sell the liquor at premises bearing Site No.1576, New
th
EPID No.2682407496, Khata No.1552/1520/1576/1552, 4
Main Road, E-Block, AECS Layout, Marathahalli, Bangalore,
which she acquired from her husband. Respondent No.3 had
issued the licence and had renewed the licence of Form No.CL-
9 for the Excise Year 2025-2026, after receiving the prescribed
license fee on 23.07.2025. On 13.08.2025 Premamma expired
leaving behind her legal heirs. The family of the petitioner i.e.
husband decided to transfer the CL-9 licence in the name of the
petitioner. All other family members had given no objection for
transferring the CL-9 licence in the name of the petitioner. The
petitioner filed application along with no objection of the other
legal heirs before respondent No.3 requesting to transfer the
CL-9 licence in his favour under Rule 17A of the Karnataka
Excise Licences (General Conditions) Rules, 1967 (hereinafter
referred to as ‘the Rules, 1967). The respondent No.3 refused
to transfer the CL-9 licence in the name of the petitioner. It is
the case that in spite of the petitioner providing all the
necessary documents substantiating his claim, seeking transfer
of the CL-9 licence under Rule 17A of the Rules, 1967.

- 6 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:61808
WP No. 29514 of 2026
C/W WP No. 28317 of 2026

CNR: KAHC010642392026



Respondent No.3 kept the application pending and orally
refused to transfer the CL-9 license. Aggrieved by the said
inaction of respondent No.3, the petitioner earlier had filed WP
No.29599/2025 before this Court. This Court had directed
respondent No.3 not to precipitate or take any coercive
measure to either restrict the petitioner or close down the
licenced premises. On 21.07.2026 the writ petition came up for
hearing and the Court disposed of the writ petition with a
direction to the respondent to consider the representation given
by the petitioner and also the request of the petitioner for
transfer of the licence in accordance with law within two days
from the receipt of the order.
3. It is stated that the petitioner received the notice
from respondent No.3 on 23.07.2026 indicating the date as
24.07.2026 even without referring to the judgment of this
Court. The petitioner has also given a representation to
respondent No.3. On 24.07.2026 the petitioner along with his
advocate submitted all the documents and put forth their case
and the matter at the request of one Ashwath Narayana Reddy
was adjourned to 28.07.2026. The petitioner was issued an
enquiry notice to appear on 28.07.2026 at 03:00 p.m. and the

- 7 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:61808
WP No. 29514 of 2026
C/W WP No. 28317 of 2026

CNR: KAHC010642392026



said Ashwath Narayana Reddy was called upon to appear at
04:00 p.m. in the very same proceedings. The petitioner along
with his advocate appeared before respondent No.3 and gave
statement of all other legal heirs who gave no objection for
transfer of licence in favour of the petitioner. Further
arguments were canvassed. The petitioner was present all
along till 05:15 p.m. and the proceedings were closed and the
said Ashwath Narayana Reddy never appeared. However, the
order impugned indicates that the said Ashwath Narayana
Reddy came after completion of the proceedings and submitted
his documents. None of the copies of the documents were given
to the petitioner. Respondent No.3 passed the impugned order
holding that the transfer under Rule 17A of the Rules 1967
cannot be made in the absence of the Succession Certificate.
4. Being aggrieved by the order passed by respondent
No.3, the petitioner preferred WP No.24645/2026 with a prayer
to quash the order passed by respondent No.3. The writ
petition was allowed by setting aside the order passed by
respondent No.3 and further remanded the matter back to
respondent No.3. After the matter was remanded back to
respondent No.3, said respondent No.3 once again asked the

- 8 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:61808
WP No. 29514 of 2026
C/W WP No. 28317 of 2026

CNR: KAHC010642392026



petitioner and respondent No.5 to appear and put forth their
case. After hearing the arguments canvassed by both the sides,
respondent No.3 had passed a similar order observing that
since the applicants have not produced the succession
certificate, the transfer of the license cannot be carried out as
per Rule 17A of the Rules 1967. Therefore, ordered that the
stock of liquor and beer held by Smt. Premamma shall continue
to be taken into custody by the Department as per the Rules. It
is further observed that one Sri Hari Prasad, S/o Ashwath
Narayana Reddy had separately obtained pedigree certificate as
legal heir of the deceased license holder and submitted it to
their office. It has been found that two different persons related
to the deceased license holder have obtained separate pedigree
certificates and are claiming to be the legal heirs. Who are the
legal heirs as per Rule 17A of the Rules 1967, it is not possible
to determine from the documents submitted to the respondents
and they have no authority to decide who are the legal heirs
and since the proceedings are going on in the civil courts and
succession certificate has not been filed, the transfer of the
license cannot be carried out as per Rule 17A of the Rule 1967.
In this writ petition as per the order passed by this Court, the

- 9 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:61808
WP No. 29514 of 2026
C/W WP No. 28317 of 2026

CNR: KAHC010642392026



said Ashwath Narayana Reddy has also been impleaded by the
petitioner and he had filed another writ petition i.e.,
W.P.No.29514/2026.

BRIEF FACTS OF THE CASE IN WP NO.29514/2026:

5. It is the case of the petitioner that Smt. Premamma
had a son Sri.Chandrashekar who died on 17.12.2022 and Smt.
Premamma also died on 13.08.2025, leaving behind no legal
heirs. After demise of Smt. Premamma, the Will dated
28.01.2025 came into force which was executed in favour of
the petitioners. It is the case that Smt. Premamma during her
lifetime was residing with the petitioners at Bangalore till the
date of her death. It is stated that the petitioners have
succeeded to the estate of the deceased Premamma since the
husband of Premamma had already expired and Premamma
and her husband had no surviving children to succeed to his
estate. That being the case, Rule 17A of the Rules 1967
provides that in the event of death of the licensee or the
lessee, the Deputy Commissioner may on an application by the
legal heirs of the deceased with previous sanction of the Excise
Commissioner, transfer the license or the lease as the case

- 10 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:61808
WP No. 29514 of 2026
C/W WP No. 28317 of 2026

CNR: KAHC010642392026



may be in their favour. The petitioner filed an application before
respondent No.3 requesting respondent No.3 to transfer the
CL-9 licence in his favour under Rule 17A of the Rules 1967.

6. It is the case that when Premamma had executed a
Will in favour of the petitioner, the respondents ought to have
transferred the license in favour of the petitioners who are the
legal heirs. It is stated that an administrative authority
exercising the statutory powers cannot dispose of a valuable
statutory claim by merely reproducing the existence of a
dispute. The authority is required to examine the nature of the
dispute, the documents produced, the applicable statutory
provisions and the legal consequences flowing from those
documents. Hence, the order passed by the respondent
authority needs to be quashed.

7. For the sake of convenience, the parties are
referred to as petitioner in W.P.29514/2026 and the petitioner
in W.P.28317/2026.

SUBMISSIONS IN WP NO.28317/2026:
8. Learned counsel for the petitioner submitted that
the order passed by respondent No.3 is devoid of merit,

- 11 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:61808
WP No. 29514 of 2026
C/W WP No. 28317 of 2026

CNR: KAHC010642392026



arbitrary, illegal and against the canons of law and as such, is
liable to be set aside. It is submitted that respondent No.3
failed to appreciate the provisions of the Excise Rules and more
particularly Rule 17A of the Rules,1967. Rule 17A of Rules
1967 mandates that, after the death of the licensee or the
lessee, the legal heir may make an application seeking transfer
of such licence in the name of the legal heir and the Deputy
Commissioner concerned shall transfer the licence in favour of
the legal heir. In the present case on hand, the petitioner being
one of the legal heir of late Premamma had made the
application seeking transfer along with no objection from other
legal heirs. When all the necessary statutory compliances are
fulfilled, respondent No.3 is not justified in refusing to
transfer/renew the licence. It is submitted that the petitioner's
family is legally entitled under Section 15(2)(b) of the Hindu
Succession Act, since the licence in question is the property
devolved from the petitioner's family to late Premamma and
after her death it shall come to the original source from where
the property is devolved upon. Hence, legally the petitioner's
families are entitled to hold and possess CL-9 and RVB licence.

- 12 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:61808
WP No. 29514 of 2026
C/W WP No. 28317 of 2026

CNR: KAHC010642392026



9. The action of respondent No.3 is devoid of a legal
basis and procedural sanctity, which constitutes an arbitrary
deprivation of right to trade. Respondent No. 3's action, lacking
in legal merit and procedural fairness, has led the petitioners
into a state of travelling in a boat in the middle of the sea. It is
submitted that the reason assigned while refusing to renew the
licence is that the petitioner has not produced a succession
certificate. The petitioner has already filed a petition under
Section 372 of the Indian Succession Act, 1925 seeking a
succession certificate and as the said matter is pending
adjudication before the Civil Court, the petitioner is not able to
produce the same immediately. Such being the case, refusing
to renew the licence is arbitrary and illegal.

10. It is settled proposition of law that the Government
and its instrumentalities shall not act arbitrarily but within the
bounds of fairness and with reasonableness. Respondent No.3’s
capricious refusal to renew the licence is a unilateral denial of
the legitimate right and the action of respondent No.3 is devoid
of legal basis and procedural sanctity which constitute an
arbitrary deprivation of legal right to hold, possess the licence

- 13 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:61808
WP No. 29514 of 2026
C/W WP No. 28317 of 2026

CNR: KAHC010642392026



and run the business which is mandated under the Constitution.
It is submitted that the Deputy Commissioner has clearly
violated the orders of this Court on both occasions which is
totally contempt on their part. Initially when there was an
interim order operating in WP No.29599/2025, respondent No.3
refused to receive the license fee when there was a crystal
clear order that respondent No.3 shall not precipitate or take
any coercive measures to either restrict the petitioner or close
down the license premises. Such being the case, refusing to
accept the license fee was in clear violation of the orders of this
Court. It is submitted that the petitioner is ready and willing to
provide any undertaking or indemnity bond for the purpose of
transfer under Rule 17A of the Rules 1967 and, in the event the
petitioner fails to obtain the succession within the stipulated
time, the petitioner will surrender the license.

11. The learned counsel for the petitioner had relied on
the judgment of the Madhya Pradesh High Court at Jabalpur in
case of Anand Choudhary vs. The State of Madhya

- 14 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:61808
WP No. 29514 of 2026
C/W WP No. 28317 of 2026

CNR: KAHC010642392026



1
Pradesh and others along with other writ petitions. He relied
on paragraph No. 75, sub-point No.6, which reads as under:
“75. *

6) The decision in disputed cases as
contemplated under Section 110 (4)
M.P.L.R.C. does not give any authority to
the Tehsildar to decide such dispute and
assume powers of Civil Court by going into
the authenticity of will or of any non-
testamentary registered title document
and that outer time limit has to be read
only to determine whether a dispute exists
in the matter and granting opportunity to
parties to approach the Civil Court. If such
approach to Civil Court is not made or
despite approach no injunction is granted
by Civil Court, then mutation will be
carried out on basis of succession by
ignoring disputed testamentary document
and in case of non-testamentary registered
title documents, by giving effect to such
document. Once a dispute in the matter of
competence of testator, validity of the will
(whether registered or not) or into a non-
testamentary registered title document or
dispute as to title is raised before Civil
Court and injunction is granted, then the
only course open for the Tehsildar would
be not to proceed further and to report the
matter to the Collector under Section
110(7) of MPLRC.”

12. He also relied on the Judgment of the Coordinate
Bench of this Court in case of Manjunath H.S Vs. State of

1
W.P.No.3499/2022 D.D 14.02.2025

- 15 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:61808
WP No. 29514 of 2026
C/W WP No. 28317 of 2026

CNR: KAHC010642392026



2
Karnataka and others . He relied on paragraph No.14, which
reads under:
“14. From above decisions, the legal
position emerging is that in case of death
of licencee giving rise to contingency of
transfer of licence in favour of legal heir/s
and one or some of them claim under a Will
which is disputed by others, this Court held
that revenue authorities would not be
competent to spell on legality or validity of
Will and parties would be required to settle
said dispute before competent Court.”

13. He relied on another Judgment of the Coordinate
Bench in Sri Ullas Kotian Yane Ullas K.V Vs. Government
3
of Karnataka he relied on paragraph Nos.4 and 5, which read
under:

“4. The core question that draws the
attention of this Court is as to whether the
petitioner, who is admittedly the sibling of
respondent No.5, can get his name
mutated to the revenue records based on
an alleged will executed by his mother,
Kamalamma. The full bench of this Court in
the case of C.N.Nagendra Singh vs. Special
Deputy Commissioner, Bengaluru, reported
in ILR 2002 KAR 2750, while answering
the reference, has held that the revenue
courts are prevented from recording the
statements of the parties and therefore,
the question of establishing the
genuineness of the will cannot be ventured
into in a mutation proceeding and has to

2
W.P.No.12350/2023 D.D 26.07.2023
3
W.P.No.241/2025 D.D 09.01.2025

- 16 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:61808
WP No. 29514 of 2026
C/W WP No. 28317 of 2026

CNR: KAHC010642392026



be left to the discretion of the competent
civil court. Even if respondent No.5 has
filed a suit in partition, that in itself cannot
constitute a ground to retain the name of
the NC: 2025:KHC:792 petitioner on the
strength of the will alleged to have been
executed by his mother, Kamalamma.

5. Since relations are not in dispute and
the petitioner and respondent No.5 are
tracing inheritance rights through their
mother, it becomes more relevant and
significant in retaining the mother's name
till rights of the parties are fully
adjudicated in the pending partition suit.
The petitioner is asserting exclusive title
based on a will and has to prove the will in
the manner known to law. Unless the
petitioner is able to prove the genuineness
of the will, adhering to strict compliance
under Section 63 of the Indian Succession
Act, 1925, read with Section 68 of the
Indian Evidence Act, 1872, the petitioner
does not acquire right as contemplated
under Section 128 of the Karnataka Land
Revenue Act, 1964, to get his name
mutated based on a will. Will either be
registered or not registered does not
create a right in favour of legatees. The
legatee, who claims to be a beneficiary
under the will, NC: 2025:KHC:792 has to
substantiate it and prove it. Unless
respondent No.5 is non-suited in a
partition suit, the petitioner could not have
got his name mutated to the revenue
records. These significant details are
rightly adverted to by respondent No.2-
Deputy Commissioner.”

- 17 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:61808
WP No. 29514 of 2026
C/W WP No. 28317 of 2026

CNR: KAHC010642392026



14. He relied on another judgment of the Supreme
Court in Ishwardeo Narain Singh Vs. Sm. Kamta Devi and
4
Ors .

15. Relying on these judgments, it is submitted that the
order impugned needs to be set aside and the licence has to be
transferred in favour of the petitioner.

SUBMISSIONS IN WP NO.29514/2026:

16. Learned Senior Counsel representing the counsel
for the petitioner submits that the impugned endorsement
issued by respondent No.3 is illegal, arbitrary, contrary to the
statutory scheme governing transfer of Excise licences,
contrary to the material produced by the petitioner, and
vitiated by non-application of mind. The respondent authority
had mechanically relied on Smt. Hamsamma and Ors Vs.
5
Excise Commissioner and Ors without examining the
material distinction between the facts of the said case and the
present case, including the nature of the registered Will. The
petitioner has specifically relied on the Will executed by late

4
AIR 1954 SC 280
5
W.P.No.56185/2015 & 56499-56502/2015 D.D 03.02.2016

- 18 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:61808
WP No. 29514 of 2026
C/W WP No. 28317 of 2026

CNR: KAHC010642392026



Smt. Premamma V which was subsequently registered on
16.12.2025, apart from the family tree documents and other
supporting material. The existence of the registered Will has
not been disputed by the Excise Authority as a document;
rather, the authority has declined to act upon it principally on
the ground that a Probate Certificate has not been produced.
Hence, the said endorsement and communication letter issued
by the respondent authority is liable to be quashed.

17. It is submitted that an administrative authority
exercising statutory powers cannot dispose of a valuable
statutory claim by merely reproducing the existence of a
dispute. The authority is required to examine the nature of the
dispute, the documents produced, the applicable statutory
provisions and the legal consequences flowing from those
documents. It is submitted that in the case of Manjunatha H.
S. referred supra, the Co-ordinate Bench of this Court, while
considering Rule 17A and Rule 17B of Rules 1967, has
recognised that bequeathal can constitute a permissible mode
of transfer of an excise licence while the question becomes
different when the Will itself is seriously disputed by rival heirs.

- 19 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:61808
WP No. 29514 of 2026
C/W WP No. 28317 of 2026

CNR: KAHC010642392026



The reliance placed on Smt. Hamsamma's case referred supra
is misconceived and mechanically applied the same. It is
submitted that respondent No.3 was required to examine the
factual and legal consequences of the present case
independently. Mechanical application of a precedent without
examining whether its factual foundation exists, constitutes
non-application of mind, hence liable to be quashed. It is
submitted that a hearing which culminates in a predetermined
conclusion without consideration of the material document is no
hearing in the eye of law. The petitioners registered Will, family
tree documents and other supporting material require a
reasoned consideration before determining the genuineness.
The respondent authorities failed to take into consideration all
these aspects and passed the order impugned. It is submitted
that the order impugned needs to be set aside and the licence
needs to be transferred in favour of the petitioner.

18. He relied on the judgment in the case of His
Highness Himanshuinhji Jadeja and Another Vs. The

- 20 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:61808
WP No. 29514 of 2026
C/W WP No. 28317 of 2026

CNR: KAHC010642392026



6
Commissioner of Excise and Others . He relied on
paragraph Nos. 6, 7 and 8, which reads hereinunder.
“6. Sri Mahesh Arakalgud, on the question
of the Firm operating Licenses, states
categorically that even during the
deceased's lifetime the Firm's Books of
Account and the deceased's Books of
Account as individual were maintained
separately; the licensed business is kept
separately in the deceased's individual
Books of Account; and that this
arrangement has continued even with the
renewal in terms of the interim order
granted by this Court. The learned counsel
emphasizes that it is settled that there
cannot be any inference that a particular
asset of a partner is brought into the
capital of the firm only because the
deceased was also a partner and there
must be specific instances or
circumstances to justify an inference to
that effect.

7. This Court must observe that the
proposition that there cannot be inference
that a particular individual asset of a
partner is brought into the firm is trite, and
it requires no reiteration. The respondents'
insistence on an application under Rule 17-
B of the 1967 Rules must be considered in
the light of this settled proposition in law
and the indisputable fact that the
respondents, in issuing the impugned
Endorsement, have examined no Books of
Account or conducted any enquiry
otherwise to substantiate the case that the
licenses have been operated for the benefit
of the Firm during the deceased’s lifetime.
The respondents have premised their

6
W.P.No.19478/2022

- 21 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:61808
WP No. 29514 of 2026
C/W WP No. 28317 of 2026

CNR: KAHC010642392026



conclusion only on the Petitioners’ reply
dated 04.07.2022.

8. This Court must opine that if the
respondents have premised their
insistence only in the statement made in
the reply/notice dated 04.07.2022 and that
is tenuous and cannot be accepted.
Therefore, this Court must intervene and
quash the impugned Endorsement dated
14.06.2022 [Annexure-K] and direct the
respondents to transfer the licenses in
favour of the first petitioner under Rule 17-
A of the 1967 Rules but observing that this
shall not foreclose any enquiry that would
be permissible under the Karnataka Excise
Act, 1965 to verify the actual working of
the licenses and call for any dues that may
become payable if indeed it is established
that the licenses are not operated at an
individual level but for the benefit of the
firm.”

19. He relied on Sri Ullas Kotian Yane Ullas K.V Vs.
7
Government of Karnataka . He relied on paragraph No. 5
and 6, which read hereinunder:
“5. Since relations are not in dispute and
the petitioner and respondent No.5 are
tracing inheritance rights through their
mother, it becomes more relevant and
significant in retaining the mother's name
till rights of the parties are fully
adjudicated in the pending partition suit.
The petitioner is asserting exclusive title
based on a will and has to prove the will in
the manner known to law. Unless the
petitioner is able to prove the genuineness
of the will, adhering to strict compliance

7
W.P.No.241/2025 D.D 09.01.2025

- 22 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:61808
WP No. 29514 of 2026
C/W WP No. 28317 of 2026

CNR: KAHC010642392026



under Section 63 of the Indian Succession
Act, 1925, read with Section 68 of the
Indian Evidence Act, 1872, the petitioner
does not acquire right as contemplated
under Section 128 of the Karnataka Land
Revenue Act, 1964, to get his name
mutated based on a will. Will either be
registered or not registered does not
create a right in favour of legatees. The
legatee, who claims to be a beneficiary
under the will, has to substantiate it and
prove it. Unless respondent No.5 is non-
suited in a partition suit, the petitioner
could not have got his name mutated to
the revenue records. These significant
details are rightly adverted to by
respondent No.2-Deputy Commissioner.

6. The order of respondent No.3-Assistant
Commissioner, in dismissing the appeal on
the premises that respondent No.5 has
already approached the civil court does not
align with the principles laid down by the
full bench of this Court in the judgment
cited supra and also runs contrary to the
mandate prescribed under Section 128 and
129 of the Karnataka Land Revenue Act,
1964. In that view of the matter, this Court
is not inclined to grant any indulgence. The
order passed by respondent No.2-Deputy
Commissioner, is in accordance with law.
Therefore, writ petition is devoid of merits
and liable to be dismissed.”

Relying on this, it is submitted that the order impugned needs
to be set aside.

20. The Additional Advocate General appearing on
behalf of the State submitted that when there is a dispute

- 23 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:61808
WP No. 29514 of 2026
C/W WP No. 28317 of 2026

CNR: KAHC010642392026



regarding who is the legal heir of the deceased licensee, the
authorities are not competent to deal with it and it has to be
decided by a competent civil court. Hence, the respondent had
rightly passed an order and no interference is called for.

21. She relied on the judgment of this court in Smt.
8
Hamsamma and Ors Vs. Excise Commissioner and Ors .
She relied on paragraph Nos. 7, 9 and 11, which read
hereinunder:
“7. Insofar as the contention that is put
forth by the learned counsel for the
petitioners by placing reliance on Section
17-A of the Rules 1967, a perusal of the
Rule no doubt would indicate that the legal
heirs of the deceased licencee may make
an application to the Deputy Commissioner
of Excise for transfer and such application
could be considered for transfer of licence
with the previous sanction of the Excise
Commissioner in favour of such legal heirs.
If in that light, the petitioners have sought
for transfer relying on the said provision
and if the wife of respondent No.4 who is
the daughter of the deceased licencee has
objected with regard to the transfer of
licence, neither the Deputy Commissioner
of Excise, 8 the Excise Commissioner nor
this Court in a writ proceedings can decide
with regard to the appropriate person to
be considered as the legal heir if all the
legal heirs by themselves do not unitedly
seek for transfer of licence and raise an
inter se dispute.


8
W.P.No.56185/2015 & 56499-56502/2015 D.D 03.02.2016

- 24 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:61808
WP No. 29514 of 2026
C/W WP No. 28317 of 2026

CNR: KAHC010642392026



9. Therefore, in that light, if the provision
is taken into consideration unless there is
an agreement between the legal heirs to
seek transfer of licence jointly in all their
names or in the name of any one person
with the consent 9 of the others, this Court
at this juncture cannot direct that the
licence be transferred in the name of any
one person where there are more than one
legal heir.

11. That apart, when I have already
indicated that if there are more than one
legal heir, it can only be in the joint names
or in the name of one person as agreed by
the others, in the absence of such
agreement between the legal heirs, a
direction in the writ petition to transfer the
licence to one legal heir would not be
possible.”

22. She relied on another judgment in the case of Smt.
9
Sangeetha V Vs. The State of Karnataka and others ,
relied on para 6,7 and 8, which read hereinunder:
“6. It is settled legal position that for seeking
writ of mandamus, petitioner has to establish
existence of legal right, respondents being
under corresponding legal duty, demand made
by petitioner and it's actual or deemed refusal.

7. In instant case, though petitioner sought
mandamus, there is no material placed on
record to indicate that petitioner had made
any demand or filed application with any of
respondents for inclusion of her name in CL-9
licences. Petitioner has also not filed any
documents to establish her heirship.


9
W.P.No.25774/2023 D.D 21.08.2025

- 25 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:61808
WP No. 29514 of 2026
C/W WP No. 28317 of 2026

CNR: KAHC010642392026



8. In view of above, necessary ingredients for
issuance of writ of mandamus are not satisfied
and present writ petition would be untenable.
Hence, it is disposed of reserving liberty to
petitioner to file application along with
documents establishing her heirship to Sri
G.Vasudevan, earlier licences holder. In case,
such application is filed, respondents no.1 to 4
are directed to consider same, in accordance
with law, after providing opportunity to
respondents no.5 to 7 and pass appropriate
orders thereon.
With above observations, writ petition is
disposed of.”

23. Relying on these judgments, it is submitted that
these kinds of disputed questions cannot be decided either by
the authorities or by this Court exercising jurisdiction under
Article 226 of the Constitution of India and the respondents
have rightly considered and passed orders and no interference
is called for.
24. Having heard the learned counsel on either side,
perused the material on record. Before deciding on the merits
of the case, it is appropriate to look at the statutory provisions.

STATUTORY PROVISION:

25. The Karnataka Excise Act, 1965, regulates the
grant, continuation, and transfer of an Excise licence. Section

- 26 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:61808
WP No. 29514 of 2026
C/W WP No. 28317 of 2026

CNR: KAHC010642392026



71 of the Karnataka Excise Act empowers the State
Government to frame rules for carrying out the purpose of the
Act. Rule 17A of the Rules, 1967 provides for transfer upon the
death of a licensee. The Rule empowers the Deputy
Commissioner, on an application by the legal heirs and with the
previous sanction of the Excise Commissioner, to transfer the
license in their favour. Though Rule 17A of the Rules, 1967 has
undergone amendments, including the amendment notified on
03.11.2025, the expression ‘legal heir’ continues to govern the
category of persons who may invoke the provision. The Rule
does not define who constitutes a legal heir. Neither the Excise
Act nor the General Clauses Act, 1899 provides a general
definition that resolves this question. The expression must
therefore be understood in its legal context, having regard to
the applicable law of succession. This does not mean that an
Excise licence is inheritable property in the ordinary sense. A
license is a statutory privilege, and its continuance remains
governed by the conditions prescribed under the Excise Act and
Rules. Nevertheless, where the Rules employ the expression
‘legal heirs’, the person answering the description must be

- 27 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:61808
WP No. 29514 of 2026
C/W WP No. 28317 of 2026

CNR: KAHC010642392026



identified according to law and not merely on the basis of
relationships or competing assertions.

RESPECTIVE CLAIMS AND THE LAW GOVERNING SUCCESSION:

26. The relatives of the husband of Premamma, i.e., the
petitioner in W.P.No.28317/2026, rely upon Section 15 and 16
of the Hindu Succession Act, 1956 (for short ‘1956 Act’).
Section 15 of the Hindu Succession Act prescribes the order of
succession to the property of a female Hindu dying intestate.
Section 15(1)(a) of the Hindu Succession Act provides that the
first category consists of her children, including the children of
any pre-deceased son or daughter. Under Section 15(1)(b) of
the Hindu Succession Act provides for succession upon the
heirs of the husband. The parents of the deceased woman and
the heirs of her parents occupy the succeeding categories.
Section 16 of the Hindu Succession Act prescribes the order in
which the persons falling within those categories succeed. It
reads thus:
“16. Order of succession and manner of
distribution among heirs of a female
Hindu.—

- 28 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:61808
WP No. 29514 of 2026
C/W WP No. 28317 of 2026

CNR: KAHC010642392026



The order of succession among the heirs
referred to in section 15 shall be, and the
distribution of the intestates property
among those heirs shall take place
according to the following rules, namely:—

Rule 1.— Among the heirs specified in
sub-section (1) of section 15, those in one
entry shall be preferred to those in any
succeeding entry and those included in the
same entry shall take simultaneously.

Rule 2.—If any son or daughter of the
intestate had pre-deceased the intestate
leaving his or her own children alive at the
time of the intestate’s death, the children
of such son or daughter shall take between
them the share which such son or daughter
would have taken if living at the intestate’s
death.

Rule 3.—The devolution of the property of
the intestate on the heirs referred to in
clauses (b), (d) and (e) of sub-section (1)
and in sub-section (2) to section 15 shall
be in the same order and according to the
same rules as would have applied if the
property had been the father’s or the
mother’s or the husband’s as the case may
be, and such person had died intestate in

- 29 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:61808
WP No. 29514 of 2026
C/W WP No. 28317 of 2026

CNR: KAHC010642392026



respect thereof immediately after the
intestate’s death.”

27. In the present case, the deceased woman had no
children, and her husband had predeceased her. The licence
was originally in the name of the husband which was
transferred in her favour after his death. Therefore, under the
law governing intestate succession, the heirs of the husband
constitute the preferred category. Under Section 15(1)(b) of
the Hindu Succession Act the relatives belonging to the
parental family do not occupy the same position merely by
reason of their relationship with her. The order of succession is
determined by statute and not by competing assertions of the
parties. The expression heirs of the husband must, however, be
understood in accordance with Rule 3 of Section 16 read with
Sections 8 and 9 of the schedules to the Hindu Succession Act.
The husband's brother's son falls under Entry 4 of Class 2. His
individual entitlement depends upon the absence of heirs
occupying the preceding categories. It is therefore necessary to
distinguish the statutory status of the husband's heirs as a
class from the entitlement of an individual claiming through
that class. An important circumstance in the present case is

- 30 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:61808
WP No. 29514 of 2026
C/W WP No. 28317 of 2026

CNR: KAHC010642392026



that, the other relatives of the husband's side have furnished
affidavits expressing their no objection to the claim advanced
by the husband's brother's son. There is thus no apparent
disagreement among these persons concerning the individual
representing their claim, where the relevant heirs have been
identified and have agreed upon one person. The absence of
consensus among them cannot be presumed merely because
another set of relatives have raised an independent claim. The
affidavits cannot alter the statutory order of succession, but
inter se
they are significant in determining whether an dispute
exists among the persons furnishing them. However, the
transfer of an excise license under the statutory rule cannot
automatically be equated with inheritance or ordinary property.
The legal effect of the earlier transfer must be understood in
the light of the regulatory framework under which it was made.
The claim of the deceased woman's brother and his children
stands on a different footing i.e., writ petitioner in
W.P.No.29514/2026. They rely upon three Wills. A person
claiming under a Will derives the asserted right from a
testamentary disposition. Whereas a statutory heir succeeds
under the law governing intestate succession. Sections 15 and

- 31 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:61808
WP No. 29514 of 2026
C/W WP No. 28317 of 2026

CNR: KAHC010642392026



16 of the Hindu Succession Act do not determine the validity of
a Will. Equally, the mere production of a Will does not establish
the rights claimed under it. Its genuineness and legal effect
must be established in accordance with law.

JUDICIAL PRECEDENTS :
28. Learned Additional Advocate General placed
reliance upon the decision of the Court in Smt. Hamsamma
and others vs. Excise Commissioner, Karnataka. In that
case, a widow and the deceased's sons sought the transfer of
the license, while the daughter of the deceased also asserted
her rights and opposed the proposed transfer. The Court held
that where the legal heirs themselves were in disagreement, a
direction for transfer in favor of one of them could not be
issued without resolving that dispute. The circumstances of the
present case are distinguishable. Here, the persons claiming
through the husband's family have furnished consent affidavits.
The objection comes from the deceased woman's parental
relatives, who rely on disputed Wills. Their claim is not one of
priority under Section 15(1)(b), but founded upon alleged
testamentary disposition. Such an objection cannot

- 32 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:61808
WP No. 29514 of 2026
C/W WP No. 28317 of 2026

CNR: KAHC010642392026



automatically be treated as a disagreement among persons
belonging to the same class of intestate heirs. The distinction is
material. It does not, however, authorize the court to disregard
the testamentary claims before their adjudication.
29. In Smt. S. Paranjyothi vs. The State of
10
Karnataka , a Co-ordinate Bench of this Court considered a
case in which the other legal heirs had expressed their no
objection. Having regard to the consent furnished by them, the
Court held that a separate declaration from the Civil Court was
unnecessary for the limited purpose involved in that case. The
decision recognises the distinction between a genuine dispute
concerning legal heirship and a situation where the legal heirs
11
have agreed. In Dr. P. K. Govinda v. K. Chandrashekhar ,
the Division Bench of this Court considered a dispute
concerning a Will relied upon by one of the children of the
deceased licensee, the other children disputed its genuineness,
the Court affirmed that the exclusive exercise authorities could
not conclusively determine the contested testamentary rights.
The decision establishes the limits of the authority's

10

WP No.8560/2023, D.D 19.06.2023
11

W.A.No.356/2022 C/w W.A.No.360/2022 D.D 02.08.2022

- 33 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:61808
WP No. 29514 of 2026
C/W WP No. 28317 of 2026

CNR: KAHC010642392026



jurisdiction, where the very foundation of the claim requires

adjudication upon evidence. In T.K. Kumaraswamy Vs. The
12
State of Karnataka this Court considered the effect of a
license transferred to one legal heir, with the consent of others.
The Court explained that such transfer did not necessarily
extinguish the interests of the other heirs. The decision is
relevant to the distinction between consent for a statutory
transfer and a complete relinquishment of underlying rights.
CONSIDERATION OF THE PRESENT CASE:

30. Applying these principles, this court finds that the
husband's heirs constitute the preferred category under Section
15(1)(b) of the Hindu Succession Act. Their statutory position
does not depend upon obtaining a separate civil declaration
merely because the deceased woman's parental relatives have
asserted competing claims. The individual person falling within
that category must nevertheless be identified in accordance
with Section 16 of the Hindu Succession Act and the applicable
provisions governing succession to a Hindu. The consent
affidavits furnished by the relatives of the husband's family

12

WP No. 2011 of 2023 dated 14.11.2024,

- 34 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:61808
WP No. 29514 of 2026
C/W WP No. 28317 of 2026

CNR: KAHC010642392026



inter se
establish that there is no apparent dispute among
those who have executed them. These affidavits are relevant to
the claim advanced by the husband's brother's son. The claim
advanced by the deceased women's brother and his children
rests upon their Wills. Their rights cannot be determined merely
by reference to their relationship with the deceased. If they
seek to displace the ordinary order of intestate succession on
the strength of the testamentary disposition, they must
establish their case before the competent Court. Proceedings
concerning the Wills are already pending, and the civil court
shall determine the questions falling within its jurisdiction
without being influenced by the observations made herein.

31. Section 68(b) of the Karnataka Excise Act bars the
jurisdiction of civil courts and matters entrusted to the Excise
Authorities. It does not, however, confer jurisdiction upon these
authorities to adjudicate the genuineness of Wills or disputed
civil status. The distinction must be maintained. A Civil Court
determines disputed civil rights. The statutory authority
determines the question entrusted to it under the Excise Act
and Rules. The department's direction requiring a declaration

- 35 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:61808
WP No. 29514 of 2026
C/W WP No. 28317 of 2026

CNR: KAHC010642392026



from the Civil Court must therefore be understood in that light.
A separate declaration in respect of husband's relatives is not
necessary merely to establish the statutory order of succession
under Sections 15 and 16 of the Hindu Succession Act. The
genuine testamentary controversy, however, cannot be
resolved by treating the Wills as either proved or invalid in
these writ proceedings. It is admitted that the license remains
subject to its regulatory status, distinct from the disputed
rights asserted by the parties. The pendency of civil
proceedings neither extends the license contrary to the rules
nor, by itself, constitutes a statutory ground for forfeiture.
Questions concerning its validity, renewal, or lapse must be
governed by the applicable provisions. Hence, this Court is of
the considered opinion that there is no justification in directing
the relatives of the husband to obtain an order from the Civil
Court. If the petitioner in W.P.No.28317/2026 complies with all
other requirements as per the provisions of the Excise Act the
license shall be transferred in his favour, which is subject to the
judgment of the competent Civil Court on the testamentary
succession. The petitioners in W.P.No.29514/2026 are at liberty
to pursue their remedies before the competent civil Court.

- 36 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:61808
WP No. 29514 of 2026
C/W WP No. 28317 of 2026

CNR: KAHC010642392026




NEED FOR AMENDMENT OF THE STATUTORY FRAMEWORK:
32. Before parting with the matter, this Court considers
it necessary to draw attention to a difficulty revealed by the
present litigation. Rule 17A of the Rules, 1967 enables transfer
upon the death of a licensee but does not expressly explain
who is to be treated as a legal heir when competing claims
arise under the intestate succession and under a Will nor does
it adequately distinguish disagreement among admitted legal
heirs, from an objection raised by a person claiming through a
testamentary disposition. These are not merely questions of
terminology, the absence of clear provisions can result in every
objection being treated as a reason to direct the parties to the
Civil Court. Irrespective of whether the dispute concerns a
question of law or a material question of fact requiring
evidence. The authority is then left uncertain about the extent
of its jurisdiction, while the claimant face proceedings which
may not always be necessary. The difficulty assumes greater
significance when civil proceedings continue for several years.
During that period, the license remains subject to the
conditions governing renewal and lapses. The amendments

- 37 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:61808
WP No. 29514 of 2026
C/W WP No. 28317 of 2026

CNR: KAHC010642392026



introduced in November 2025 contemplate the inclusion of
certain lapsed or forfeited licenses in the auction pool. It is
therefore possible that the subject matter of the controversy
may cease to be available by the time the parties obtain a final
determination of their civil dispute. Such uncertainty is neither
beneficial to the parties nor conducive to the orderly
administration of the Excise law. The rule do not provide for a
comprehensive mechanism addressing this difficulty. Section 71
of the Karnataka Excise Act empowers the State Government to
frame rules. The State Government therefore consider whether
Rule 17A of the Rules, 1967 requires further clarification
concerning the identification of legal heirs, the effect of consent
furnished by them, the treatment of disputed Wills and the
circumstances in which adjudication by a Civil Court becomes
necessary. Consideration may also be given to the position of
subsisting license during prolonged succession disputes, while
protecting public revenue and maintaining the regulatory
requirements prescribed under the Act. The observations are
intended to identify the practical difficulty arising under the
existing framework and not to prescribe the contents of an
amendment, since the uncertainty is capable of affecting

- 38 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:61808
WP No. 29514 of 2026
C/W WP No. 28317 of 2026

CNR: KAHC010642392026



similarly placed persons. Accordingly, this Court is passing the
following:
ORDER

i. The expression ‘legal heir’ under Rule 17A
of the Karnataka Excise Licences (General
Conditions) Rules, 1967, must be
understood having regard to the
applicable law of succession and the
statutory purpose of the rule.


ii. On the admitted facts, the heirs of the
husband, constitute the preferred
category under Section 15(1)(b) of the
Hindu Succession Act.


iii. The no-objection affidavits submitted by
the husband's relatives establish their
consent to the claim advanced by the
husband's brother’s son, without altering
the statutory order of succession or
prejudging the rights of any person not
bind by those affidavits. A separate civil
declaration is not required merely to
establish the interpretation of Sections 15
and 16 of the Hindu Succession Act set
out in this order.

- 39 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:61808
WP No. 29514 of 2026
C/W WP No. 28317 of 2026

CNR: KAHC010642392026




iv. The claims advanced under the three
Wills remain subject to adjudication in the
pending P & SC proceedings. The
competent Civil Court shall determine
those questions independently and in
accordance with law. If they succeed in
getting a declaration as legal heir the
respondent authorities are bound to
consider the same.


v. The order dated 03.09.2026 passed in
No.EXE/BUD-5/VA30/CL-9 + R.V.B/17-
A/40/2025-26 by the Deputy
Commissioner, Excise, Bengaluru.
requiring declaration from the competent
Civil Court is set aside as far as
W.P.No.28317/2026 is concerned and the
order impugned is affirmed as far as
W.P.No.29514/2026 is concerned.


vi. The respondents are directed to consider
the case of the petitioner in WP
No.28317/2026 for the transfer of the
license, provided he satisfies the other
requirements under the Act which is
subject to the declaration by the
competent Civil Court.

- 40 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:61808
WP No. 29514 of 2026
C/W WP No. 28317 of 2026

CNR: KAHC010642392026




vii. The State Government is requested to
examine the need for suitable clarification
of Rule 17A of the Act in the light of the
observations made in the preceding
paragraphs.


viii. The Registry shall forward a copy of this
order to the Principal Secretary to the
Government, Finance Department
(Excise) for appropriate consideration.


ix. Accordingly, both the writ petitions are
disposed of.


x. All I.As. in these petitions shall stand
closed.

SD/-
(LALITHA KANNEGANTI)
JUDGE


PKN
List No.: 1 Sl No.: 1
*MR