The State Trading Corporation of India Limited vs Rajni Exports and Imports,
- Court
- Madras High Court
2026:MHC:4606
Arb O.P(COM.DIV.) No. 572 of 2026
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT MADRAS
Reserved on : 03.11.2026
Pronounced on : 18.11.2026
CORAM
THE HON'BLE MR.JUSTICE D.BHARATHA CHAKRAVARTHY
Arbitration Original Petition (COM.DIV.) No. 572 of 2026
and
A.No.3714 of 2026
CNR:{HCMA011804182026}
The State Trading Corporation of
India LimitedA Government of India
Enterprise, Having its Representative
office at STC Trade Centre,
A-29, Thiru-Vi-Ka Industrial Estate,
Guindy, Chennai-600032
..Petitioner
Vs
M/s.Rajni Exports and Imports,A
Partnership Firm, represented by its
Partner, Having its office at No.157
and 158,
Srinivasan Kumar Street, Golden
George Nagar, Nerkundram,
Chennai-600 107
..Respondent
Prayer: Arbitration Original Petition filed under Section 34 of the
Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996, to set aside the Arbitral Award in
Arbitration Case No.04 of 2025 dated 30.01.2026 passed by the Sole Arbitrator,
nd
Mr. Krishna Ravindran, Advocate, at Flat No.2A, 2 Floor, 6KE Apartments,
nd
No.6, Kasthuri Estate, 2 Street, Gopalapuram, Chennai-600 086 in its entirely,
__________
Page1 of 13
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 18/11/2026 06:18:59 pm )
2026:MHC:4606
Arb O.P(COM.DIV.) No. 572 of 2026
in the arbitral proceedings between M/s Rajni Exports and Imports Claimant
and The State Trading Corporation of India Limited Respondent, arising out of
O.P. No. 81 of 2021 and to direct the respondent to pay the costs.
Ms.Akshaya Puthram
For Petitioner :
for M/s.S.K.Singhi and Partners LLP,
Mr.P.V.S.Giridhar, Senior Counsel
For Respondent :
for M/s.P.V.S.Giridhar & Associates
ORDER
This original arbitration petition is filed challenging the award dated
30.01.2026 of the Sole Arbitrator in Arbitration Case No. 04 of 2025.
2. The brief facts leading to the dispute between the parties are that on
08.09.2017, the petitioner herein, viz., The State Trading Corporation of India
Limited, floated an e-tender for the lifting of its stock of urad dhal on the
conditions mentioned therein. The respondent participated in the tender,
requesting the petitioner to adjust the amount due to it on account of an earlier
transaction, to the tune of Rs.46,00,000/-, towards the earnest money deposit of
Rs.45,67,330/-, being 5% of the total sum of Rs.9,13,46,600/- quoted by it. The
petitioner accepted this request, and accordingly, the respondent participated in
the tender.
__________
Page2 of 13
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 18/11/2026 06:18:59 pm )
2026:MHC:4606
Arb O.P(COM.DIV.) No. 572 of 2026
3. Upon being successful, as communicated on 22.09.2017, the
respondent was awarded the tender for the offtake of 696 MT of urad dhal. As
per the award, the respondent was required to pay the entire amount due on or
before 29.09.2017. Two days before the last date, the respondent paid
Rs.3,00,00,000/- and requested an extension for the balance sum of
Rs.6,13,46,600/- between 03.10.2017 and 10.11.2017. The extension was
granted, however, subject to payment of additional EMD of Rs.3,25,475/- and
another sum of Rs.4,00,000/-, which the respondent remitted. Even up to the
final extended date of 20.11.2017, the respondent did not pay the balance and
lifted the stock.
4. In view thereof, on 21.11.2017, a Risk Sale Notice was issued stating
that if the amount was not paid within 7 days, i.e., on or before 27.11.2017, the
petitioner would proceed with the risk sale on 27.11.2017, i.e., the last date. The
respondent paid Rs.50,00,000/- and sought a further extension till 08.12.2017.
However, the petitioner floated a risk sale tender for the balance of 1176 MT by
its tender dated 06.12.2017. On 14.12.2017, the respondent paid the balance
contract amount as per the calculation, which included additional carrying costs
of Rs.20,68,603/-.
5. On 05.01.2018, the respondent was permitted to lift the stock, subject
to the condition that the EMD shall stand forfeited and that the carrying cost of
__________
Page3 of 13
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 18/11/2026 06:18:59 pm )
2026:MHC:4606
Arb O.P(COM.DIV.) No. 572 of 2026
Rs.20,68,603/- would be payable. The respondent also subsequently paid the
additional sum sought. On 24.01.2018, the respondent lifted the entire stock of
1176 MT. Post delivery, the respondent issued letters praying for the return of
cheques, etc. After verifying the statement of accounts, on 19.02.2018, it was
found that, over and above the actual value and carrying cost of Rs.20,68,603/-,
a sum of Rs.11,70,439/- had been paid in excess, and the petitioner refunded the
said amount. Thereafter, on 01.03.2018, the respondent demanded a refund of
the Security Deposit, to which the petitioner replied on 09.05.2018, confirming
the forfeiture of the Security Deposit. Thereafter, a dispute was raised, and the
Sole Arbitrator was appointed in O.P. No. 81 of 2021. After the extension of the
mandate, the Sole Arbitrator passed an award on 30.01.2026.
6. Before the Sole Arbitrator, the respondent filed a claim statement
seeking to set aside the letters dated 05.01.2018 and 09.05.2018 issued by the
petitioner to forfeit the Security Deposit and to refund the said amount of
Rs.45,67,330/- with interest at the rate of 12% per annum from 24.01.2018, and
for a further sum of Rs.5,50,000/- towards legal and further litigation expenses,
to be paid with further interest at the rate of 18% per annum. The petitioner duly
resisted the claim statement.
7. The Sole Arbitrator framed the following 6 issues:
“1. Whether time was the essence of the contract as per the E-tender
__________
Page4 of 13
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 18/11/2026 06:18:59 pm )
2026:MHC:4606
Arb O.P(COM.DIV.) No. 572 of 2026
dated 08.09.2017, the Award Letter dated 22.09.2017, and whether the
same stood altered due to the subsequent conduct and correspondence
between the parties?
2. Whether the claimant committed a breach of the terms and
conditions of the contract, and if so, the nature and extent of such
breach?
3. Whether the respondent was entitled to invoke the forfeiture
Clauses 7 and 14 of the E-Tender document, even after granting the
extensions of time without any conditions?
4. Whether the claimant through conduct has accepted the forfeiture
of EMD?
5. Whether the claimant is entitled to a refund of the Security
Deposit (EMD) amount of Rs.45,67,330?
6. What other reliefs are the parties entitled to?”
8. The Learned Arbitrator answered issue No.1 that time was the essence
of the contract, but by the subsequent conduct of the parties, the original time
frame fixed was modified and extended by mutual understanding. With
reference to issue No.2, the arbitrator concluded that, with reference to the
original term, the respondent committed a breach, but the petitioner also
subsequently extended, and therefore it cannot be concluded that the respondent
committed a total failure to conclude the contract warranting a penalty of
forfeiture of the EMD amount. With reference to issue No.3, the Arbitrator
found that, in view of the subsequent extensions and the respondent’s
performance of the contract at additional cost, forfeiture is not warranted,
justified, or proportionate, and accordingly answered.
__________
Page5 of 13
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 18/11/2026 06:18:59 pm )
2026:MHC:4606
Arb O.P(COM.DIV.) No. 572 of 2026
9. With reference to issue No.4, the Arbitrator held that the respondent
did not accept the forfeiture and only paid the additional amount and concluded
the contract. With reference to issue No.5, the Arbitrator held that the
respondent would be entitled to a refund of the EMD amount of Rs.45,67,330/-.
Though there is no further discussion under issue No.6, while passing the
award, the Arbitrator directed that the EMD be refunded with interest at the rate
of 12% per annum from the date of receipt of the award till payment. Aggrieved
by the same, the petitioner has filed the present application.
10. Ms Akshaya Puthran , learned counsel appearing on behalf of the
petitioner, would draw the attention of this court to the original terms of the
tender. With reference to Clause No.2, relating to the product, she would point
out that it is perishable. Then, she would draw the attention of this court to
Clause No.6, relating to Earnest Money Deposit, and Clause No.7, relating to
payment terms, including the clause relating to the forfeiture of the EMD.
Thereafter, the learned counsel would draw the attention to Clause No.11 of the
contract, whereby all the connected documents were treated to be part of the
contract, and to Clause No.13 relating to liquidated damages and Clause No.14
relating to forfeiture of earnest money deposit (security deposit).
11. The learned counsel would submit that a combined reading of the
contract as a whole, interpreted in the context of Sections 55 and 63 of the
__________
Page6 of 13
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 18/11/2026 06:18:59 pm )
2026:MHC:4606
Arb O.P(COM.DIV.) No. 572 of 2026
Indian Contract Act, 1872, enables the Petitioner to forfeit the security deposit.
Simultaneously, even if the Respondent had been permitted to complete the
work at an additional cost, had the Petitioner not allowed the Respondent to lift
the stock, the Respondent would still have remained liable for risk purchase
costs as stipulated in the tender. The Respondent, sensing a lower quote in the
risk sale, paid the entire amount and lifted the stock of urad dal. It can never be
argued, by way of contractual interpretation, that the Petitioner, being a State
authority floating the tender, lacks the right to forfeit the EMD.
12. While the Petitioner's right and the respondent’s failure have been
recognised by the Learned Arbitrator, the finding that the justification is
unreasonable and not proportionate is beyond the Learned Arbitrator's
jurisdiction. The Learned Arbitrator must interpret the terms of the contract and
cannot determine the dispute based on reasonableness or equity. Therefore, the
Learned Arbitrator's findings in the instant case are not only perverse but also
patently illegal. The learned counsel would specifically point out the facts
whereby the contract has been cancelled, which automatically enables the
Petitioner to forfeit the EMD.
13. The learned counsel would rely upon the following judgments of the
Hon’ble Supreme Court of India:
(i) Associate Builders Vs. Delhi Development Authority [(2015) 3 SCC
__________
Page7 of 13
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 18/11/2026 06:18:59 pm )
2026:MHC:4606
Arb O.P(COM.DIV.) No. 572 of 2026
49] more specifically paragraph No.31 of the said judgment.
(ii) Ssangyong Engineering and Construction Company Limited Vs.
National Highyways Authority of India (NHAI) [(2019) 15 SCC 131] more
specifically relying upon paragraph Nos.33, 41 to 45.
(iii) Delhi Metro Rail Corporation Limited Vs. Delhi Airport Metro
Express Private Limited [(2024) 6 SCC 357] more specifically paragraph Nos.
38 and 46.
(iv) Shreeram Builders Vs. Upendera Kantilal Thanawala and Ors. [2026
SCC Online SC 2294], more specifically paragraph Nos.47, 49, 50, 52, 56 and
58 to 61.
(v) DYNA Technologies Private Limted Vs. Crompton Greaves Limited
[(2019) 20 SCC 1] more specifically paragraph No.35.
(vi) K.R.Suresh Vs. R.Pooninma and Ors. [2025 SCC Online SC 1014]
more specifically paragraph Nos.51 and 51 with reference to the forfeiture of
earnest money deposit.
(vii) Godrej Projects Development Limited Vs. Anil Karlekar and Ors.
[(2025) 4 SCC 259] more specifically paragraph Nos. 9 to 21 and 34.
14. The learned counsel would also place reliance on certain other
judgments on the same proposition to contend that the Learned Arbitrator's
action in this case would amount to moving beyond its jurisdiction to interpret
the terms of the contract, and, as such, the entire award is perverse and patently
__________
Page8 of 13
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 18/11/2026 06:18:59 pm )
2026:MHC:4606
Arb O.P(COM.DIV.) No. 572 of 2026
illegal, and therefore this court should interfere in exercise of its power under
Section 34 of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996.
15. Per Contra, Mr P.V.S.Giridhar , the learned Senior Counsel appearing
on behalf of the respondent, would submit, by pointing out the relevant clauses,
that the clauses relating to forfeiture of the EMD only enable the petitioner to
forfeit in the event of failure to perform the contract. In this case, the parties'
subsequent conduct extended the time, and ultimately the petitioner accepted
performance of the contract even after the floating of the tender for risk
purchase.
16. The Learned Arbitrator has gone into the issue in detail in issue No.3
and has interpreted the terms of the contract and rendered a finding that, in the
instant case, if only the forfeiture is to be sustained, it should be construed as
penal in nature and in respect of penal damages, as held by the Hon’ble
Supreme Court of India in the case of Kailash Nath Associates Vs. Delhi
Development Authority and Anr. [(2015) 4 SCC 136], Section 74 of the
Contract Act, 1872 would operate, and unless the specific damages are pleaded
and proved, the respondent cannot be permitted to forfeit the deposit.
17. The Learned Arbitrator has categorically found that when the
respondent had not only lifted the goods by paying the amount originally agreed
__________
Page9 of 13
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 18/11/2026 06:18:59 pm )
2026:MHC:4606
Arb O.P(COM.DIV.) No. 572 of 2026
and the subsequent carrying costs and other expenses, and the same had been
accepted by the petitioner, there was no occasion for forfeiture of the EMD.
Therefore, the Learned Arbitrator's findings are within the contract, within the
four corners of the Arbitrator's jurisdiction, and within the manner of answering
the dispute submitted to the Arbitrator.
18. The well-considered award of the arbitrator, based on the record and
interpreting the terms of the contract and the attendant communications and
documents between the parties, cannot be interfered with by this Court, which is
not a first Appellate Court, in exercise of power under Section 34 of the Act.
Therefore, the petition has to be dismissed. The learned Senior Counsel would
submit that this is a fit case to impose costs.
19. I have considered the submissions made on either side and perused
the material records of the case. The issue on hand relates to the forfeiture of the
earnest money deposit. The petitioner herein is a public sector undertaking. I
had occasion to consider the law relating to forfeiture in M/s. P.S.T.
Engineering Construction Vs. HSCC (India) Limited (2025:MHC:981). It
must be noted in the instant case, that the money forfeited is retained as security
and does not form part of the sale price. As such, it is not ‘earnest ’, and this is
not a case of non-performance of the contract. Thus, the law laid down by the
Hon’ble Supreme Court of India in National Highways Authority of India -Vs-
Ganga Enterprises and Another(2003 7 SCC 410) does not apply.
__________
Page10 of 13
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 18/11/2026 06:18:59 pm )
2026:MHC:4606
Arb O.P(COM.DIV.) No. 572 of 2026
20. Per contra, in respect of the belated off-take of the Urad dhal, in
addition to the carrying costs and other expenses, the petitioner chose to claim
its power under the contract, as a penalty, even while extending the deadline
and permitting the respondent to perform the contract. Thus, from the law laid
down in the various other judgments from Fateh Chand, Maula Bux, Kailash
Nath, Shanmugavelu, etc., which are referred to in detail in paragraphs 10.3 to
10.16 of the above Judgment in PST Engineering , it must be seen that once the
forfeiture assumes a penal nature, then, as per Section 74, the amount will be
the outer limit and the Courts/Tribunal will allow only what is reasonable. Thus,
in the instant case, after considering the carrying costs and expenses paid by the
respondent as an additional sum, when the Learned Arbitrator had decided that
nothing further need be allowed, it is not on equity or outside the jurisdiction of
Arbitration, but only applying Section 74 of the Contract Act, 1872 by
construing the terms of the Contract and appreciating the evidence on record.
21. Thus, the award, insofar as it directs refund of the sum forfeited,
cannot be said to be erroneous, much less that any ground is made out to
interfere with the award as patently illegal or in violation of foundational and
fundamental legal principles of India.
22. As far as the post-award interest is concerned, as per the dictum of the
Constitution Bench in Gayatri Balasamy -Vs- ISG Novasoft Technologies Ltd
__________
Page11 of 13
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 18/11/2026 06:18:59 pm )
2026:MHC:4606
Arb O.P(COM.DIV.) No. 572 of 2026
(2025 7 SCC 1) , in every case, this cannot interfere or substitute its opinion
except where the facts require. In the instant case, without any discussion of the
rate of interest or the circumstances, the interest is ordered to be paid
straightaway in the operative portion of the award. Secondly, this is a case
where there is obvious delay on the part of the respondent; however,
considering the circumstances, it was allowed to lift the stock on the
understanding that the petitioner would be permitted to forfeit the security
deposit. Thus, I am of the view that 12% as awarded cannot be justified and it is
reduced to 9% per annum.
23. In the result, this Arbitration Original Petition is partly allowed on the
following terms:
(i) The award of the arbitrator dated 30.01.2026 is not interfered with in so far
as it directs refund of the sum of Rs.45,67,330/-;
(ii) However, the post-award interest awarded by the Learned Arbitrator at 12%
is modified to 9% per annum from the date of award till the date of
realisation.
(iii)No Costs. Consequently, the connected application stands closed.
18-11-2026
Neutral Citation: Yes
mp
__________
Page12 of 13
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 18/11/2026 06:18:59 pm )
2026:MHC:4606
Arb O.P(COM.DIV.) No. 572 of 2026
D.BHARATHA CHAKRAVARTHY J.
MP
Arb O.P(COM.DIV.) No. 572 of 2026
18-11-2026
__________
Page13 of 13
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 18/11/2026 06:18:59 pm )