THE STATE OF RAJASTHAN vs SIMARJEET KAUR
- Court
- Rajasthan High Court
[2026:RJ-JD:55838-DB]
Reportable
HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE FOR RAJASTHAN
AT JODHPUR
Judgment reserved on: 15.10.2026
Judgment delivered on:__18.11.2026
Judgment (Full) Uploaded on :_ 19.11.2026
D.B. Special Appeal Writ No. 62/2026
CNR: RJHC010951652025 | URN: SAW / 127U / 2026
1. The State Of Rajasthan, Through Secretary, Department
Of Medical And Health, Govt. Of Rajasthan Secretariat,
Rajasthan, Jaipur.
2. The Director, State Health And Family Welfare Institute,
Rajasthan Jaipur.
----Appellants
Versus
Simarjeet Kaur D/o Prithvipal Singh, Aged About 35 Years,
Village 27 Rb Tehsil Raisinghnagar District Sri Ganganagar.
----Respondent
For Appellant(s) : Mr. Narendra Singh Rajpurohit, AAG
with Ms. Aditi Sharma.
For Respondent(s) : Mr. Yashpal Khileree.
Division Bench
HON'BLE THE CHIEF JUSTICE MR. SANJAY K. AGRAWAL
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE BALJINDER SINGH SANDHU
C.A.V. Judgment
BALJINDER SINGH SANDHU, J.
1. The present special appeal has been filed by the State of
Rajasthan and its functionaries challenging the order dated
16.01.2025 passed by the learned Single Judge. By the order
under challenge, the writ petition filed by the respondent was
allowed and the appellants were directed to consider her
candidature for appointment to the post of Nursing Officer in the
(Uploaded on 19/11/2026 at 05:53:47 PM)
(Downloaded on 19/11/2026 at 06:32:23 PM)
(2 of 15)
[2026:RJ-JD:55838-DB] [SAW-62/2026]
category in which she had applied, and if she was otherwise found
meritorious, to offer her appointment from the date on which
other successful candidates selected pursuant to the same
advertisement were appointed.
2. The respondent-petitioner holds a three-year Diploma in
Nursing and was registered with the Punjab Nurses Registration
Council on 10.08.2022. The appellants issued an advertisement
dated 05.05.2023 for recruitment to the post of Nursing Officer.
The last date for submission of the application form was
04.06.2023. The respondent submitted her application within the
prescribed period. She applied for registration with the Rajasthan
Nursing Council on 25.09.2023 and was granted registration on
13.01.2024.
3. The respondent appeared for document verification, which
was held from 02.09.2023 to 11.09.2023. Her candidature was,
however, not included in the select list on the ground that she was
not registered with the Rajasthan Nursing Council. She had
secured 71.140 marks, as against the cut-off marks of 66.922
prescribed for the OBC (female) category. She, therefore,
approached this Court by way of a writ petition.
4. The learned Single Judge allowed the writ petition, taking
note of the respondent’s registration with the Punjab Nurses
Registration Council before the recruitment process and her
subsequent registration with the Rajasthan Nursing Council. The
learned Single Judge also referred to Rajkumari Chahar v.
State of Rajasthan & Others, S.B. Civil Writ Petition No.
(Uploaded on 19/11/2026 at 05:53:47 PM)
(Downloaded on 19/11/2026 at 06:32:23 PM)
(3 of 15)
[2026:RJ-JD:55838-DB] [SAW-62/2026]
15010/2023 , and directed the appellants to consider the
respondent’s candidature and offer appointment if she was
otherwise found eligible and meritorious.
5. Learned counsel for the appellants-State submits that
04.06.2023, being the last date for submission of the application
form, was the relevant date for determining eligibility. On that
date, the respondent was not registered with the Rajasthan
Nursing Council (hereinafter referred to as ‘the RNC’). It is
contended that such registration was specifically prescribed in the
Recruitment Rules and the advertisement, and that in the absence
of the same, the candidature of the respondent could not be
considered. The appellants, therefore, submit that the learned
Single Judge was not justified in allowing the writ petition and
directing consideration of her candidature.
6. Per contra , learned counsel for the respondent submits that
the Recruitment Rules and the provisions governing registration
must be read together. The respondent already held registration
from the Punjab Nurses Registration Council before issuance of the
advertisement. Section 13(ii) of the Rajasthan Nurses, Midwives,
Health Visitors and Auxiliary Nurse-Midwives Registration Act,
1964 (hereinafter referred to as ‘the Registration Act’) recognizes
corresponding nursing certificates issued by authorities in other
States, subject to the conditions specified therein. Further, Section
2(h) of the Act defines the expression “registered” by reference to
the Act as well as the Rules and Regulations made thereunder.
Regulation 46(2) of the Rajasthan Nursing Council Regulations,
1964 (hereinafter referred to as ‘the RNC Regulations’) provides
(Uploaded on 19/11/2026 at 05:53:47 PM)
(Downloaded on 19/11/2026 at 06:32:23 PM)
(4 of 15)
[2026:RJ-JD:55838-DB] [SAW-62/2026]
for registration with the RNC within three months after joining
service in Rajasthan from another State. It is, therefore,
submitted that the respondent’s candidature could not have been
rejected merely because she did not hold the RNC registration
certificate on the last date for submission of the application form.
It is also pointed out that she obtained such registration on
13.01.2024, before publication of the final select list on
06.12.2024.
7. We have considered the rival submissions and perused the
material available on record.
8. The controversy is not about the respondent’s nursing
qualification or her status as a registered nursing professional
before the recruitment process. She held a three-year Diploma in
Nursing and was registered with the Punjab Nurses Registration
Council since 10.08.2022. The question is whether her candidature
could be rejected solely because she had not obtained a separate
registration certificate from the RNC by 04.06.2023, without
considering the statutory provisions governing registration in
Rajasthan.
9. The post in question is governed by the Rajasthan Medical
and Health Subordinate Service Rules, 1965 (hereinafter referred
to as ‘the Recruitment Rules’). The entry under the head Group ‘A’
(medical side) (separate male and female cadres) in Schedule-I
prescribes the qualifications for the post. The relevant entry reads
as under:
(Uploaded on 19/11/2026 at 05:53:47 PM)
(Downloaded on 19/11/2026 at 06:32:23 PM)
(5 of 15)
[2026:RJ-JD:55838-DB] [SAW-62/2026]
Sr
No
Name of
Source of recruitment
Minimum
qualification
and experience
Posts from
Minimum
qualification
Remarks
Post
with percentage
which
promotion is
and
experience
required for
for direct
recruitment
to made
promotion
Direct
Recruitment
Promotion
4 Nursing
90% 10% 1.Senior
Secondary or
its equivalent
2.G.N.M. course
or its equivalent
Departmental
1. G.N.M.
course or its
1. As
regards
criteria for
promotion,
the persons
Officer
employees
equivalent
qualification
from
institute
recognized
qualification
from institute
recognized by
who have
trained
earlier shall
by
Government
Government
be given
preference
and in case
and
3.Registered in
and 2.
Registered in
RNC
RNC
the year of
training is
same then
the length of
service shall
be given
preference.
2. If suitable
department
al
employees
are not
available for
promotion
such posts
shall be
filled in by
direct
recruitment
10. The above entry prescribes registration with the RNC as a
requirement for the post. The manner in which such registration is
to be obtained, particularly by a person who already holds a
corresponding nursing qualification and registration from another
State, is governed by the Registration Act, 1964 and the RNC
Regulations framed thereunder. The Registration Act provides for
registration of nurses, midwives, health visitors and auxiliary
nurse-midwives in Rajasthan. Section 2(e) defines a ‘nurse’ and
Section 2(h) defines the expression ‘registered’. Section 13
specifies the persons entitled to be registered. The relevant
provisions of the Act read as under:
(e) "nurse" means a person who holds a certificate in
nursing granted by any authority recognized in this behalf
by the Council;
(Uploaded on 19/11/2026 at 05:53:47 PM)
(Downloaded on 19/11/2026 at 06:32:23 PM)
(6 of 15)
[2026:RJ-JD:55838-DB] [SAW-62/2026]
(h) “registered” means registered in accordance with the
provisions of this Act and the rules and regulations made
thereunder.
13. Persons entitled to be registered. - The following persons
shall be entitled to be registered under this Act, namely:-
(i)nurses, midwives, health visitors and auxiliary nurse-
midwives who have undergone the course of training
prescribed by the Council and have passed the prescribed
examinations held by the Council and fulfill such further
conditions as may be prescribed;
(ii)nurses, midwives, health visitors and auxiliary nurse-
midwives holding corresponding certificates issued by
authorities in other States in India and foreign Council if
such certificates are recognized by the Indian Nursing
Council;
(iii)nurses, midwives, health visitors and auxiliary nurse-
midwives who are already in practice at the
commencement of this Act and fulfill such conditions as
may be prescribed.”
11. The Legislature has not confined the meaning of ‘registered’
to the provisions of the Act alone. It expressly includes the Rules
and Regulations made thereunder. Section 13(ii) recognizes
persons holding corresponding nursing certificates issued by
authorities in other States, subject to recognition by the Indian
Nursing Council. It thus makes provision for such persons to seek
registration with the Rajasthan Nursing Council. These provisions
are, therefore, relevant while examining the registration
requirement under the Recruitment Rules.
12. The RNC Regulations have been framed under the
Registration Act. Sections 10 and 33 of the Act provide for the
making of Regulations, subject to the conditions prescribed
therein. Regulation 46 deals with applications for registration. The
same is reproduced below:
“ 46. Application for Registration.—
(Uploaded on 19/11/2026 at 05:53:47 PM)
(Downloaded on 19/11/2026 at 06:32:23 PM)
(7 of 15)
[2026:RJ-JD:55838-DB] [SAW-62/2026]
(1) A candidate after passing the Final/Second examination of any of
the above courses shall apply in Form VII for registration of her/his
name under Section 14 of the Act to the Council through the Head of
the Institution from which she/he appeared for the Final/Second
Examination. The certificate and the registration number which shall be
endorsed on the body of the certificate shall be transmitted to the
candidate through the Head of the Institution on payment of the
prescribed fees.
(2) Nurses, Midwives, Lady Health Visitors who join the service in
Rajasthan from any other State must have herself/himself registered
with the Rajasthan Nursing Council within 3 months after joining under
clause (ii) of Section 13 of the Act by applying in Form VIII.
(3) Nurses, Midwives and Health Visitors entitled to be registered under
clause (iii) of Section 13 of the Act shall apply to the Registrar in Form
VIII for registration to the Rajasthan Nursing Council.”
13. Regulation 46(2) specifically deals with nurses, midwives and
lady health visitors who join service in Rajasthan from another
State under Section 13(ii) of the Registration Act. It requires them
to obtain registration with the Rajasthan Nursing Council within
three months after joining service. The Regulation thus recognizes
a period after joining service for obtaining RNC registration in the
case of persons covered by Section 13(ii). The effect of the
provision on the registration qualification prescribed under the
Recruitment Rules has to be considered in the context of the
statutory scheme as a whole.
14. While the Recruitment Rules prescribe registration with the
Rajasthan Nursing Council as a qualification for appointment,
Regulation 46(2), framed under the Registration Act, provides for
the time within which persons coming to Rajasthan from other
States are required to obtain such registration after joining
service. Regulation 46 forms part of the Regulations framed under
the Registration Act and must be read in the light of that Act. The
(Uploaded on 19/11/2026 at 05:53:47 PM)
(Downloaded on 19/11/2026 at 06:32:23 PM)
(8 of 15)
[2026:RJ-JD:55838-DB] [SAW-62/2026]
registration requirement under the Recruitment Rules must also
be considered in the light of the specific procedure and time
framework prescribed under Regulation 46(2) for inter-State
registrants. We find that these provisions deal with different
aspects of the same subject and must, therefore, be read together
and harmoniously construed so that effect is given to both.
15. The principle of harmonious construction requires that
statutory provisions dealing with different aspects of the same
subject be read together and interpreted in a manner that gives
effect to both, rather than allowing one to defeat the other. This
principle was explained by the Hon’ble Supreme Court in Sultana
Begum v. Prem Chand Jain, (1997) 1 SCC 373 wherein it was
held that:-
11. The statute has to be read as a whole to find out the real
intention of the legislature.
12. In Canada Sugar Refining Co. vs. R. (1898) AC 735, Lord
Davy observed:-
"Every clause of a statute should be construed with
reference to the context and other clauses of the Act, so
as, as far as possible, to make a consistent enactment of
the whole statute or series of statutes relating to the
subject-matter."
14. This rule of construction which is also spoken of as "ex
visceribus actus" helps in avoiding any inconsistency either
within a Section or between two different Section or provisions
of the same statute.
15. On a conspectus of the case law indicated above, the
following principles are clearly discernible:
(1) It is the duty of the courts to avoid a head-on clash
between two Sections of the Act and to construe the
provisions which appear to be in conflict with each other
in such a manner as to harmonise them.
(2) The provisions of one Section of a statute cannot be
used to defeat the other provisions unless the court, in
(Uploaded on 19/11/2026 at 05:53:47 PM)
(Downloaded on 19/11/2026 at 06:32:23 PM)
(9 of 15)
[2026:RJ-JD:55838-DB] [SAW-62/2026]
spite of its efforts, finds it impossible to effect
reconciliation between them.
(3) It has to be borne in mind by all the courts all the
time that when there are two conflicting provisions in an
Act, which cannot be reconciled with each other, they
should be so interpreted that, if possible, effect should
be given to both. This is the essence of the rule of
"harmonious construction".
(4) The courts have also to keep in mind that an
interpretation which reduces one of the provisions as a
"dead letter" or "useless lumber" is not harmonious
construction.
(5) To harmonise is not to destroy any statutory
provision or to render it otiose. ”
16. Further, the same principles were reaffirmed by a Seven-
Judge Bench of the Hon’ble Supreme Court in In Re: Interplay
Between Arbitration Agreements under the Arbitration and
Conciliation Act, 1996 and the Indian Stamp Act, 1899 ,
2023 INSC 1066 , wherein the Court emphasised that provisions
of different statutes should, as far as possible, be interpreted
harmoniously so that effect is given to both without defeating their
respective purposes. In this regard, it would be useful to
reproduce the relevant observations of the Court:
“
159. One of the cardinal principles of the
interpretation of statutes is to discover and give
effect to the legislative intention. If a statute is
susceptible to two interpretations, the court will
have to reject the construction which will defeat
the plain intention of the legislation. The court has
to ascertain the intention of the legislation by
considering not only the clause to be interpreted,
but also the entirety of the statute. The legislature
often enacts a statute to give effect to legislative
policy. When enacting a statute, the legislature
often endeavors to ensure that the provisions of a
statute do not contradict the provisions of the
same statute or provisions of another statute.
However, inconsistencies or contradictions may
nonetheless arise between statutes. In such
situations, it is left to the court to bring about a
harmony between the working of such statutes.”
(Uploaded on 19/11/2026 at 05:53:47 PM)
(Downloaded on 19/11/2026 at 06:32:23 PM)
(10 of 15)
[2026:RJ-JD:55838-DB] [SAW-62/2026]
“165. In the present reference, the challenge
before this Court is to harmonize the provisions of
the Arbitration Act and the Stamp Act. The object
of the Arbitration Act is to, inter alia, ensure an
efficacious process of arbitration and minimize the
supervisory role of courts in the arbitral process.
On the other hand, the object of the Stamp Act is
to secure revenue for the State. It is a cardinal
principle of interpretation of statutes that
provisions contained in two statutes must, if
possible, be interpreted in a harmonious manner
to give full effect to both the statutes. In
providing a harmonious interpretation, this Court
has to be cognizant of the fact that it does not
defeat the purpose of the statutes or render them
ineffective. The challenge, therefore, before this
Court is to preserve the workability and efficacy of
both the Arbitration Act and the Stamp Act. ”
17. The aforesaid principle underscores that no provision of a
statute is to be construed in isolation, rather, each provision must
be interpreted in the context of the statutory scheme as a whole,
so as to give effect to the legislative intent and maintain
consistency and harmony amongst its various provisions.
18. Applying these principles, the requirement of registration
with the Rajasthan Nursing Council under the Recruitment Rules
has to be considered along with Section 2(h), Section 13(ii) and
Regulation 46(2) of the Registration Act and the RNC Regulations.
Section 13(ii) recognizes persons holding corresponding nursing
certificates issued by authorities in other States, and Regulation
46(2) prescribes a period for obtaining Rajasthan registration after
joining service. The time allowed under the Regulations for such
persons must also be given due effect while applying the RNC
registration requirement to their case.
19. A similar issue came up for consideration before the Division
Bench of this Court in Prakashwati v. State of Rajasthan &
(Uploaded on 19/11/2026 at 05:53:47 PM)
(Downloaded on 19/11/2026 at 06:32:23 PM)
(11 of 15)
[2026:RJ-JD:55838-DB] [SAW-62/2026]
Others, D.B. Civil Writ Petition No. 7973/2016, decided on
17.01.2018 . The Division Bench examined the qualification
prescribed under the Recruitment Rules in the context of the
Registration Act, including Section 13(ii), and Regulation 46. The
petitioners therein held nursing qualifications recognized by the
Indian Nursing Council and were registered with Nursing Councils
of other States. Their candidature was rejected for want of
registration with the Rajasthan Nursing Council on the date of the
advertisement.
20. The Division Bench upheld the requirement of registration
with the Rajasthan Nursing Council, but considered its application
in the context of the provisions of the Registration Act and
Regulation 46. It took note of Regulation 46(2), which provides for
registration with the RNC within three months of joining service by
persons entering service in Rajasthan from another State. The
relief granted in that case was also based on the particular
circumstances before the Court, particularly the short interval
between the amendment prescribing the requirement of RNC
registration and the issuance of the advertisement, which afforded
the candidates little time to obtain such registration. The decision
is, therefore, relevant for the interpretation of the statutory
scheme, while the factual circumstances in which relief was
granted must be considered separately.
21. The facts of Prakashwati (supra) differ from those of the
present case, as the present recruitment was initiated in 2023.
However, the interpretation of Section 13(ii) and Regulation 46(2)
(Uploaded on 19/11/2026 at 05:53:47 PM)
(Downloaded on 19/11/2026 at 06:32:23 PM)
(12 of 15)
[2026:RJ-JD:55838-DB] [SAW-62/2026]
adopted therein remains relevant to the present controversy.
While the relief granted in that case was based on its particular
facts, the statutory provisions considered therein continue to
govern the registration of nursing professionals coming to
Rajasthan from other States. The respondent’s claim must,
therefore, be examined in the light of that statutory interpretation
and the facts of the present case.
22. The appellants contend that the respondent was required to
fulfill the eligibility conditions by the last date prescribed for
submission of applications. In support of this contention, reliance
has been placed upon the decision of the Hon’ble Supreme Court
in Sakshi Arha v. The Rajasthan High Court & Others
reported in 2025 INSC 463 . The Apex Court in the said judgment
reiterated that the date for determining eligibility must be
ascertained from the applicable service rules, and where the Rules
are silent, from the advertisement. If both are silent, the last date
for submission of applications ordinarily becomes the relevant
date. The Court also observed that the date of selection cannot
ordinarily be adopted as the date for determining eligibility. The
general principles laid down by the Supreme Court are well
settled.
23. However, before applying the general rule regarding the cut-
off date, it is necessary to examine the specific provisions
governing registration of nursing professionals coming to
Rajasthan from other States. Unlike a case where the applicable
statutory provisions are silent regarding the time for obtaining the
(Uploaded on 19/11/2026 at 05:53:47 PM)
(Downloaded on 19/11/2026 at 06:32:23 PM)
(13 of 15)
[2026:RJ-JD:55838-DB] [SAW-62/2026]
requisite registration, the present case involves Regulation 46(2),
which specifically provides for obtaining RNC registration within
three months after joining service. The effect of this provision
must, therefore, be considered while determining the date by
which such registration was required to be obtained.
24. The respondent was already registered with the Punjab
Nurses Registration Council on 10.08.2022, much before the
issuance of the advertisement. Thus, this is not a case where she
acquired the nursing qualification or obtained registration as a
nursing professional for the first time after the cut-off date. She
was already registered with the Nursing Council of another State,
and her case is required to be examined in the light of the
provisions governing such persons, subject to fulfillment of the
conditions of Section 13(ii) of the Registration Act.
25. Regulation 46(2) provides that persons covered by Section
13(ii), who join service in Rajasthan from another State, are
required to obtain registration with the Rajasthan Nursing Council
within three months of joining service. The Regulation does not
expressly prescribe the last date for submission of applications or
the date by which such registration must be obtained. It does,
however, provide a specific time period for obtaining RNC
registration. This provision must be given due effect while
applying the registration requirement under the Recruitment
Rules. Read together, these provisions do not warrant treating
possession of an RNC registration certificate on the last date of
(Uploaded on 19/11/2026 at 05:53:47 PM)
(Downloaded on 19/11/2026 at 06:32:23 PM)
(14 of 15)
[2026:RJ-JD:55838-DB] [SAW-62/2026]
submission of applications as an inflexible requirement in the case
of persons covered by this statutory framework.
26. The learned Single Judge also referred to the decision in
Rajkumari Chahar (supra) . It is not necessary for us to
examine the reasoning in that decision in detail, as the order
under appeal can be sustained on an independent ground. The
requirement of registration under the Recruitment Rules has to be
read along with Section 2(h), Section 13(ii) and Regulation 46(2)
of the Registration Act and the RNC Regulations.
27. The respondent secured 71.140 marks, as against the cut-off
of 66.922 marks prescribed for the OBC (female) category. She
had obtained registration with the Rajasthan Nursing Council on
13.01.2024, before publication of the final select list on
06.12.2024. In view of the statutory framework discussed above,
and particularly the time period prescribed under Regulation
46(2), her candidature could not have been rejected solely on the
ground that she did not hold an RNC registration certificate on the
last date for submission of applications, i.e., 04.06.2023. The
learned Single Judge, therefore, committed no error in directing
consideration of her candidature, in the category she applied, and
to offer her appointment on the post in question, with effect from
the date as the other successful candidates were given
appointment.
28. For the reasons recorded hereinabove, we find no ground to
interfere with the order dated 16.01.2025 passed by the learned
(Uploaded on 19/11/2026 at 05:53:47 PM)
(Downloaded on 19/11/2026 at 06:32:23 PM)
(15 of 15)
[2026:RJ-JD:55838-DB] [SAW-62/2026]
Single Judge. Consequently, the special appeal is dismissed and
the order of the learned Single Judge is affirmed, albeit for the
reasons and on the grounds recorded herein. The appellants shall
comply with the directions issued by the learned Single Judge.
29. There shall be no order as to costs.
(BALJINDER SINGH SANDHU),J (SANJAY K. AGRAWAL),CJ
Crt_1 (2095)
D-A/49
Hanuman
(Uploaded on 19/11/2026 at 05:53:47 PM)
(Downloaded on 19/11/2026 at 06:32:23 PM)
Powered by TCPDF (www.tcpdf.org)