SYED ABBAS PASHA vs THE MANAGING DIRECTOR
- Court
- Karnataka High Court
- 1 -
MFA No. 1776 of 2024
C/W MFA No. 5069 of 2024
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA AT BENGALURU
DATED THIS THE 19TH DAY OF NOVEMBER, 2026
BEFORE
THE HON'BLE MRS. JUSTICE GEETHA K.B.
MISCELLANEOUS FIRST APPEAL NO. 1776/2024 (MV-I)
C/W
MISCELLANEOUS FIRST APPEAL NO. 5069/2024 (MV-I)
IN MFA No. 1776/2024
BETWEEN:
1. THE MANAGING DIRECTOR,
BMTC, REGIONAL OFFICE
K H ROAD, SHANTHINAGAR
BENGALURU-560027
…APPELLANT
(BY SRI. D VIJAYAKUMAR.,ADVOCATE)
AND:
1. SYED ABBAS PASHA
S/O SYED JAVID PASHA
AGED ABOUT 23 YEARS
R/A NO.69, 19TH A MAIN
BTM 1ST STAGE, BEHIND AXIS BANK
BENGALURU SOUTH, BENGALURU-560029
…RESPONDENT
(BY SRI. JAGADEESH H T.,ADVOCATE)
THIS MFA IS FILED U/S 173(1) OF MV ACT AGAINST THE
JUDGMENT AND AWARD DATED: 02.12.2023 PASSED IN MVC
NO.1709/2020 ON THE FILE OF THE XIII ADDITIONAL SMALL
CAUSES JUDGE, ACMM, COURT OF SMALL CAUSES AND
Digitally Signed By:
K B GEETHA
- 2 -
MFA No. 1776 of 2024
C/W MFA No. 5069 of 2024
MEMBER, MACT-15, BENGALURU, AWARDING COMPENSATION
OF RS.17,30,700/- WITH INTEREST AT 6 PERCENT P.A. FROM
THE DATE OF PETITION TILL THE DATE OF DEPOSIT OF AWARD
AMOUNT.
IN MFA NO. 5069/2024
BETWEEN:
1.
SYED ABBAS PASHA
S/O SYED JAVID PASHA
AGED ABOUT 23 YEARS
R/AT NO.69, 19TH A MAIN, BTM 1ST STAGE
BEHIND AXIS BANK
BENGALURU SOUTH, BENGALURU 560029
...APPELLANT
(BY SRI. JAGADEESH H T.,ADVOCATE)
AND:
1. THE MANAGING DIRECTOR
BMTC, K H ROAD,
SHANTHINAGARA, DOUBLE ROAD,
BENGALURU 560027
...RESPONDENT
(BY SRI.D.VIJAYAKUMAR, ADVOCATE)
THIS MFA IS FILED U/S 173(1) OF MV ACT AGAINST
THE JUDGMENT AND AWARD DATED 02.12.2023 PASSED
IN MVC NO. 1709/2020 ON THE FILE OF THE XIII
ADDITIONAL SMALL CAUSES JUDGE, ACMM, COURT OF
SMALL CAUSES AND MEMBER, MACT-15, BENGALURU
(SCCH-15), PARTLY ALLOWING THE CLAIM PETITION FOR
COMPENSATION AND SEEKING ENHANCEMENT OF
COMPENSATION.
Digitally Signed By:
K B GEETHA
- 3 -
MFA No. 1776 of 2024
C/W MFA No. 5069 of 2024
THESE APPEALS HAVING BEEN HEARD AND RESERVED
ON 12.11.2026, COMING ON FOR PRONOUNCEMENT OF
JUDGMENT THIS DAY, THE COURT DELIVERED THE
FOLLOWING:
CORAM: HON'BLE MRS. JUSTICE GEETHA K.B.
CAV JUDGMENT
MFA Nos.1776/2024 and 5069/2024 are filed under
Section 173(1) of the Motor Vehicles Act, 1988 (for short,
‘M.V. Act’) by BMTC and the claimant, respectively,
challenging the judgment and award dated 02.12.2023
passed in M.V.C. No.1709/2020, on the file of the XIII
Additional Small Causes and ACMM and Additional Motor
Accident Claims Tribunal (SCCH-15), Bengaluru (in short,
‘the Tribunal’). The BMTC is challenging the negligence
and quantum of the compensation , whereas the claimant
seeks enhancement of the compensation.
2. Parties would be referred with their ranks, as
they were before the Tribunal for the sake of convenience
and clarity.
Digitally Signed By:
K B GEETHA
- 4 -
MFA No. 1776 of 2024
C/W MFA No. 5069 of 2024
3. The claimant has filed the claim petition before
the Tribunal under Section 166 of the M.V. Act claiming
compensation in respect of the injuries suffered by him in
the road traffic accident that has taken place on
12.02.2020 at about 06:50 a.m. involving the motorcycle
bearing Reg.No.KA-53/ET-3809 and BMTC bus bearing
Reg.No.KA-57/F-3215 (in short, ‘the offending bus’).
4. The case of the claimant before the Tribunal in
nutshell is that on the date of accident, the claimant was
the rider of the motorcycle near Udupi Garden Signal 100
th nd
feet road 16 Main junction, BTM 2 stage, Bengaluru; at
that time, the offending bus came from behind, dashed
against the motorcycle being driven by its driver rashly
and negligently and caused the accident. Due to the
accident, the claimant sustained grievous injuries.
Immediately, he was shifted to Sai Ram Hospital, B.G.
Road, Bengaluru wherein he received first aid treatment;
thereafter, he was shifted to HOSMAT Hospital, Bengaluru,
wherein he has taken treatment as inpatient. Hence, he
claimed compensation under different heads.
Digitally Signed By:
K B GEETHA
- 5 -
MFA No. 1776 of 2024
C/W MFA No. 5069 of 2024
5. The respondent appeared through its counsel
and filed objection statement wherein it denied the
averments made in the petition in toto and further
contended that the accident happened due to rash and
negligent driving of the rider of the motorcycle and not
due to the driver of the offending bus. The rider of the
motorcycle tried to overtake the bus from right side and
then the left handle of the motorcycle came in contact with
the right middle portion of the bus and thereby, the
accident has taken place. Hence, prayed for dismissal of
the petition.
6. After framing issues, recording evidence and
hearing arguments of both sides, the Tribunal concluded
that the claimant is entitled for a total compensation of
` 17,30,700/- under following heads:
Sl.
Particulars Amount in `
No.
1 Pain, shock & Suffering 1,00,000/-
2 Loss of amenities 1,00,000/-
3 Loss of income during the laid up period 72,500/-
Attendant's charges, Extra diet, and
4 45,000/-
conveyance
5 Medical Expenses 8,93,400/-
6 Loss of Future Income 4,69,800/-
7 Future Medical Expenses 50,000/-
Total compensation amount 17,30,700
Digitally Signed By:
K B GEETHA
- 6 -
MFA No. 1776 of 2024
C/W MFA No. 5069 of 2024
7. Further the Tribunal held that the accident has
taken place only due to rash and negligent driving of the
driver of the offending bus and not due to the rider of the
motorcycle.
8.
Not satisfied with the said compensation, the
claimant is before this Court; being aggrieved by the
fastening entire negligence on the driver of the BMTC bus
and the quantum of compensation awarded, the BMTC is
before this Court.
9. Heard arguments of both sides.
10. The learned counsel for BMTC Sri D.
Vijayakumar would submit that the rider of the motorcycle
with an intention to overtake the BMTC bus has taken
right side and the left handle of the motorcycle contacted
to the right middle portion of the bus and thereby, the
accident has taken place.
11. The learned counsel would further submit that
the compensation awarded by the tribunal on all heads is
on higher side. Hence, prayed for allowing his appeal and
to dismiss the appeal of the claimant.
Digitally Signed By:
K B GEETHA
- 7 -
MFA No. 1776 of 2024
C/W MFA No. 5069 of 2024
12. The learned counsel for respondent would
submit that the tribunal after verifying the records, rightly
fastened negligence on the part of BMTC driver; there was
no negligence on the part of the claimant. As far as
compensation is concerned, the doctor assessed the
disability at 19% on whole body, however, the tribunal
had taken it at 15% without assigning cogent reasons.
Further, the compensation awarded by the tribunal on all
heads is on lower side. Hence, prayed for allowing his
appeal and to dismiss the appeal of the insurance
Company.
13. Having heard arguments of both sides, verifying
the appeal papers and trial Court records, the points that
arise for consideration are:
"1. Whether the attributing negligence
entirely on the driver of the offending bus by
the Tribunal is proper?
2. Whether the compensation awarded by
the Tribunal requires modification?"
Digitally Signed By:
K B GEETHA
- 8 -
MFA No. 1776 of 2024
C/W MFA No. 5069 of 2024
14. Finding of this Court on point No.1 is in
' Negative' and point No.2 is in ' Affirmative' for the
following:
REASONS
15. The facts established before the Tribunal are
that the claimant sustained injuries in the road traffic
accident involving the motor cycle and the offending bus
and because of the accident, the claimant sustained
grievous injuries and he had taken treatment as inpatient
in the hospital for 61 days. The claimant was aged 19
years as on the date of accident. He undergone surgery.
The doctor assessed disability at 55% to particular limb
and at 19% to the whole body and the claimant has
suffered three grievous injuries.
16. The contention of the insurance Company is
that the rider of the motorcycle with an intention to
overtake the BMTC bus has taken the vehicle on right side
and the left handle of the motorcycle contacted to the
right middle portion of the bus and thereby, the accident
has taken place.
Digitally Signed By:
K B GEETHA
- 9 -
MFA No. 1776 of 2024
C/W MFA No. 5069 of 2024
17. To substantiate the above contentions, the
respondent examined the driver of the bus as RW.1 and
produced the copies of order sheet and judgment passed
in the criminal case as per Exs.R.1 and R2. But the
aforesaid contention of BMTC is not at all established. On
the other hand, Ex.P.5 - the Motor Vehicles Accident
Report shows that the damages to the motorcycle on its
rear side and there was no visible damages to the BMTC
bus. Furthermore, the evidence of RW.1 is not helpful to
the contention of the respondent. He has admitted that
charge-sheet is filed against him after completion of
investigation. Thus, the accident has not taken place as
contended by the insurance Company, but it was taken
place as alleged by the claimant.
18. Considering this aspect, rightly the Tribunal
held that there is rashness and negligence on the part of
driver of the offending bus and not on the part of the
claimant. Even the spot panchanama and spot sketch
establishes the aforesaid facts.
Digitally Signed By:
K B GEETHA
- 10 -
MFA No. 1776 of 2024
C/W MFA No. 5069 of 2024
19. As far as quantum is concerned, the claimant
has suffered three injuries i.e. left Iliac wing fracture, right
superior and inferior Pubic rami fracture and open
Perennial injury and rectal tear. Totally, the claimant was
in-patient in the hospital for 61 days. His Aadhar card
shows that he was 19 years old as on the date of accident.
The doctor who treated the complainant has given opinion
that there is 55% disability to particular limb and 19% to
the whole body. However, by assigning cogent reasons,
the Tribunal held that the disability to the whole body of
the claimant is 15% which requires no interference.
20. The Tribunal has taken the income of the
claimant at ` 14,500/- by considering the notional income
chart prepared by the KSLSA for Lok Adalat and has
applied the appropriate multiplier - 18. Thus, the
compensation awarded by the Tribunal under the head
‘loss of dependency’ requires no interference. Even though
the claimant has sustained three grievous injuries, the
Tribunal has awarded the compensation of ` 1,00,000/-
towards 'pain and suffering'; ` 1,00,000/- towards 'loss of
Digitally Signed By:
K B GEETHA
- 11 -
MFA No. 1776 of 2024
C/W MFA No. 5069 of 2024
amenities' and ` 72,500/- towards 'loss of income during
laid up period' (for five months) which are exorbitant.
Under these heads, the claimant is entitled for ` 50,000/-,
` 50,000/-, and ` 43,500/- (for three months) respectively.
21. As far as compensation awarded by the Tribunal
under other heads is concerned, they are just and
reasonable and require no interference.
22. Thus, the claimant is entitled for total
compensation of ` 16,01,700/- instead of ` 17,30,700/-
as awarded by the Tribunal under the following heads:
Sl.
Particulars Amount in `
No.
1 Pain, shock & Suffering 50,000/-
2 Loss of amenities 50,000/-
3 Loss of income during the laid up period 43,500/-
Attendant's charges, Extra diet, and
4 45,000/-
conveyance
5 Medical Expenses 8,93,400/-
6 Loss of Future Income 4,69,800/-
7 Future Medical Expenses 50,000/-
Total compensation amount
` 16,01,700/-
23. Hence, this Court passes the following:
ORDER
i) MFA No.1776/2024 filed by the BMTC is
allowed in part.
Digitally Signed By:
K B GEETHA
- 12 -
MFA No. 1776 of 2024
C/W MFA No. 5069 of 2024
ii) MFA No.5069/2024 filed by the claimant is
dismissed.
iii) The claimant is entitled for compensation of
` 16,01,700/- instead of ` 17,30,700/- as
awarded by the Tribunal ;
iv) No order as to costs;
v) Draw modified award accordingly.
vi) The amount in deposit be transmitted to the
Tribunal.
vii) Registry to transmit TCR to the Tribunal
forthwith.
Digitally Signed By:
K B GEETHA
(GEETHA K.B.)
JUDGE
SPV