Taher Vajiyuddin Rangwala vs The State Of Gujarat

Court
Supreme Court

2026 INSC 859
Non-Reportable


IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA
CRIMINAL APPELLATE JURISDICTION

Criminal Appeal No. 76 of 2020


Taher Vajiyuddin Rangwala & Anr.
...Appellant (s)


Versus

The State of Gujarat
...Respondent (s)

J U D G M E N T

K. VINOD CHANDRAN, J.

The appellants are the accused who were alleged to
have murdered their friend; found drowned in a river. The
prosecution case was that the deceased was taken from his
house in the early morning, of 17.07.2006, on the pretext of
going to Ankleshwar to play volleyball. The deceased did
not return by evening, and his family started searching for
him. When A-2 was contacted by his wife, A-2 allegedly told
her that he was in a picture house watching a movie. PW14
Signature Not Verified
informed PW-12 about the clothes found on the banks of a
Digitally signed by
CHANDRESH
Date: 2026.08.14
10:27:32 IST
Reason:
river, which were identified by him as belonging to his
Page 1 of 15

Criminal Appeal No.76 of 2020

brother. Later, A-1 and A-2 who had taken the deceased in
the morning, came to the house of the deceased voluntarily.
They were questioned and later, inside a car, as stated by
PW-12, the brother of the deceased, the accused confessed
that they had gone swimming in the river and the deceased
accidentally drowned. In panic, they fled from the spot and
went for a movie. The villagers gathered at the riverbank
and searched for the deceased, whose clothes and other
belongings were found on the banks. The body was not
recovered till nightfall and the rescue party disbursed.
Later, on the next morning, the body was recovered and
post-mortem was conducted, which showed the victim
having died of ‘Asphyxia due to drowning’. The accusation
against the appellants herein; alleging a motive against both
the accused, was raised by the First Information Statement
on 03.11.2006, which was registered as an FIR, produced as
Annexure A-6.
2. The prosecution went to trial with 20 witnesses. The
circumstances put forth was motive, last seen together
theory, presence of accused near the scene of occurrence,
Page 2 of 15

Criminal Appeal No.76 of 2020

homicidal death, the silence of the accused, conduct of the
accused; specifically of lying to the sister of the deceased
that they had dropped him at Sahra Darwaja, and
admissions made in the bail application.

3. The Trial Court convicted both the accused under
Sections 302, 34 and 201 read with Section 120B of the Indian
Penal Code. Under Section 302, life imprisonment was
imposed with a fine of Rs.5,000/- and default sentence of
rigorous imprisonment (RI) for one year. Under Section
120B and Section 201 substantive sentences of RI of five
years and two years were imposed with fine of Rs.2,000/-
and Rs.1,000/-, with a default sentence of RI of 2 months
each, on both counts. The High Court confirmed the
conviction of the Trial Court in appeal.
4. We have heard Mr. Iqbal Syed, learned Senior
Counsel for the appellants and Ms. Swati Ghildiyal, learned
Counsel for the respondent-State.
5. Mr. Iqbal Syed argued that the appellants were, at
worst, guilty of a misadventure which turned fatal to their
friend and quite complex for themselves, leading to the
Page 3 of 15

Criminal Appeal No.76 of 2020

conviction for murder of their friend. There was absolutely
no evidence to even prove a homicidal death and the
plausible story of the defense, was that an accidental
drowning occurred. The accused were, if at all, guilty only
of having fled the scene in panic. The motive alleged is
fabricated and in the wake of the delay in the registration of
FIR, has to be disbelieved. There is no single circumstance
but the last seen theory, which even the accused accepted.
The Doctor, PW-1, who was examined, clearly indicated that
the injuries on the body could be caused while jumping into
the water and even if the body was dragged in the flow of
the river.
6. Smt. Swati Ghildiyal, however, vigorously argued for
sustaining the conviction and sentence. There was enough
material to find the circumstances projected by the
prosecution; fully established. The injuries caused clearly
indicate that the accused was struck by a soda bottle, the
fragments of which were found at the scene of occurrence.
The testimony of the shop owner who spoke of four soda
bottles having been purchased and taken, with return of
Page 4 of 15

Criminal Appeal No.76 of 2020

only three bottles clinches the culpability of the accused.
The accused were found inebriated and wet, on returning
the soda bottles. The act of returning the soda bottles clearly
indicates premeditation. There were blood stains found on
the fragments of the soda bottle found at the site.
7. At the outset, we have to notice that the victim was
found missing on 17.07.2006 and the body was recovered in
the early hours of 18.07.2006. The incident become known
when the locals detected wet clothes on the banks of the
river, which was informed to the police, who in turn
informed PW-12, the brother. The brother identified the
clothes and belongings of the victim from the banks of the
river, and a search was carried out, resulting in the recovery
of the body on the next day.
8. The first aspect to be examined is as to whether the
death was homicidal. The post-mortem report is produced
as Annexure A-2 and after the report of the chemical
examination of viscera, there was a further report on
12.10.2006, produced as Annexure A-3. Both these reports
clearly indicate the cause of death as ‘Cardio-Respiratory
Page 5 of 15

Criminal Appeal No.76 of 2020

arrest due to Asphyxia due to drowning’. The post-mortem
report also indicates that there were 3 injuries on the body:
a contused lacerated wound on the frontal bone above the
left eyebrow, abrasion between the left eye and left ear and
an abrasion on the right mid clavicular region, reddish in
colour. The wounds were not grievous and as the Doctor
opined in cross-examination, the three injuries could be
caused either when taking a bath in the river or when
dragged in the flow of the water; on the body coming into
contact with a hard substance like a stone with a sharp edge.
9. The suggestion in chief-examination that if a person is
hit with a soda bottle which is made of glass and is in a
broken condition, then the contused injury could have been
sustained, was also accepted by the Doctor. However, no
such broken soda bottle was confronted to the Doctor, nor
do we find any seizure of such fragments of glass or a
broken soda bottle from the scene of occurrence, as was
argued by the learned Counsel for the respondent-State.
We also see from the forensic report, produced as Annexure
Page 6 of 15

Criminal Appeal No.76 of 2020

A-4, that no such broken soda bottle with blood stains was
sent for forensic examination.
10. A reading of the post-mortem report, juxtaposed with
the testimony of the Doctor who conducted the post-
mortem, PW-1, cannot lead to a finding that the death was
homicidal. There is nothing to indicate that the victim was
hit on the head, rendered unconscious and then drowned
deliberately in the river, as the prosecution propounded
before the Trial Court. The post-mortem report leans in
favour of the defense version of an accidental drowning.
11. The High Court, in confirming the conviction, has
referred in detail to the relevant witnesses, which we would
also examine. In this context, we have to specifically notice
that the High Court has not found it fit to consider the
testimony of the Investigating Officer, which makes the said
testimony inconsequential.
12. As we noticed, there was gross delay in raising the
allegations against the accused, who had admittedly
accompanied the victim to the river for a bath and probably
consumed alcohol. Even after the confession of the accused
Page 7 of 15

Criminal Appeal No.76 of 2020

and recovery of the body, no allegations were levelled
against the accused, till the date on which the FIS was
recorded. As we saw, it was about 4 months later that an FIR
was registered, which again was on the basis of the motive
alleged.
13. Insofar as the motive is concerned; the deceased is
said to have had a relationship with A-1’s sister; continued
even after her marriage, which enraged A-1. A-2 is said to
have had a quarrel a few days back with the deceased
regarding a cricket match. But the motive alleged, by the
brother did not obviously deter the family of the deceased
from sending him with the accused, when he was taken
away from his home in the early hours of 17.07.2006; the
purpose of which was also asserted to participate in a
volleyball game at Ankleshwar. The very conduct of the
family members of the deceased, as coming out from the
testimonies of PW-12 and PW-13, the brother and sister,
indicates rather friendly relationship between the deceased
and the accused.
Page 8 of 15

Criminal Appeal No.76 of 2020

14. PW-12, though, spoke of the accused having taken his
brother from their house, admitted that he had heard it from
his mother when he woke up on the said day. PW-13,
witnessed her brother going off with the two accused in a
motorcycle. On the deceased having not returned to his
house till evening, both PW-12 and PW-13 enquired with A-
2, who told them that their brother was dropped at Sahra
Darwaja at 02:30 pm. Then, both the accused came
voluntarily to the house of the deceased and a little later
confessed to having gone to the river to take a bath when
the deceased accidentally drowned. PW-12, obviously did
not harbour any suspicion against the accused at that point.
This further puts the motive under a cloud, as a deliberate
afterthought.
15. We can definitely believe the testimony of PW-12 and
PW-13 that the accused had taken the deceased from their
house since the accused also admitted to it, and their
specific defense is that they had proceeded to the river for
a bath where the deceased accidentally drowned.
Page 9 of 15

Criminal Appeal No.76 of 2020

16. Insofar as the premeditated murder is concerned, PW-
18 and PW-19 were examined. PW-18 was the owner of the
shop from which four soda bottles were purchased by the
accused. PW-18 had spoken of three persons who came to
the shop to purchase the soda bottles, for which he took a
security deposit from them. Two of the persons came back
and handed over only three soda bottles and after
deducting the price of one bottle, the balance security
deposit was handed over. PW-18 also said that both the
accused were inebriated and were drenched, when they
came to his shop.
17. PW-19 was managing a Pan Parlor from where the
accused had purchased snacks before they went for soda to
PW-18. PW-18 and PW-19 were asked to identify the
accused in court, which they did. Obviously, PW-18 and
PW-19 are not acquainted with the accused, in which event
the identification in court, when the two accused were in the
dock, cannot at all be reckoned. The prosecution does not
have a case that a test identification parade was carried out
after the arrest of the accused, especially since the specific
Page 10 of 15

Criminal Appeal No.76 of 2020

allegation of murder is levelled after four months, with the
story of a motive raised by the brother of the deceased.
18. PW-12, deposed that PW-14, told him that there were
two persons who came in a motorcycle and fled from the
scene of occurrence. PW-12 also testified that the scene of
occurrence was a place frequented by shepherds and two
or three persons were present in the scene, who spoke of
the accused having called them over for a drink, which they
declined. No such witness was examined before court.
19. PW-8, a labourer and an occasional fisherman, was
examined by the prosecution as another person who saw all
the three persons at the river. PW-8 testified that he had
seen three persons who were not from his village and he
had smoked a cigarette with them. But, he declined the offer
of liquor. It is also stated that after having drinks, the three
jumped into the water to take a bath. He has stated that there
was neck deep water at the place where they jumped into
the water. PW-8 then went on his way, and it must be later
that the mishap occurred.
Page 11 of 15

Criminal Appeal No.76 of 2020

20. Again, the testimony of PW-8 does not inculpate the
accused of the murder alleged, though, they were seen
together. As stated by PW-12 and as discernible from the
testimony of PW-8, the riverbank where the accused and the
deceased were found drinking, was not a lonely spot and it
was frequented by people. It is very unlikely that the
accused would have chosen such a spot for the
premeditated murder of their friend, especially in broad
daylight. The testimony of PW-18 and PW-19 also does not
incriminate the accused, and they could, at best, be alleged
to have consumed alcohol and not returned a soda bottle.
21. The motive, as we observed, was an afterthought. The
last seen theory and the presence of the accused near the
scene of occurrence is admitted by the accused and their
defense is that the deceased accidentally drowned. As for
homicidal death, there was nothing coming out from the
post-mortem report and the testimony of the Doctor, PW-1,
in proof of homicide. On the contrary the medical evidence
tilts the scales towards an accidental drowning. The silence
of the accused and their having not informed the family
Page 12 of 15

Criminal Appeal No.76 of 2020

members of the deceased, cannot be an incriminating
circumstance since that was a probable conduct, even if
there was an accident of drowning. In fact, the specific
testimony of PW-12 was that, though not initially, but later,
the accused confessed to have fled in panic, on seeing the
deceased drowning. The conduct of the accused having lied
to PW-15 about having dropped her brother at 02:30 pm in
a specific location, again does not incriminate the accused,
given the defense.
22. Admission in the bail application, as relied on by the
High Court, is a very difficult premise to accept. In this
context, we also have to notice the High Court’s
presumption that no person who saw his friend drowning
would go to a movie or would take the trouble of bringing
back empty soda bottles to the shop from where they
purchased it. If such a presumption is accepted then it can
be presumed that even after a premeditated murder, the
accused would not conduct themselves in that manner. The
human mind, as has often been held by this Court, is at the
same time fickle, manipulative and imaginative and the
Page 13 of 15

Criminal Appeal No.76 of 2020

actions, the result of a deprived or a foolish mindset,
especially in the face of adversities, which cannot be
predicted. The subsequent conduct on which the High Court
found possible the prosecution story of murder rather than
of drowning, in this case we are unable to accept. It is the
hypothesis of an accidental drowning that looms large from
the evidence led at the trial; more plausible than a
homicide.
23. None of the circumstances having been proved, we
are inclined to find the probable and more possible version
of the accused, that the deceased drowned accidentally.
The accused are guilty of having fled from the spot and not
having attempted to rescue the drowning person, by crying
out for help. Their conduct of having gone for a movie after
witnessing their friend drowning, though reprehensible,
cannot be found to be an incriminating circumstance, to
establish murder rather than drowning. The hypothesis of
innocence is crystal clear, and circumstances indicate an
accident and not a premeditated murder.
Page 14 of 15

Criminal Appeal No.76 of 2020

24. We find absolutely no reason to sustain the order of
the Trial Court as confirmed by the High Court. We reverse
both the orders and acquit the accused.
25. The accused shall be released forthwith, if not wanted
in any other case, if they are still in custody. If they have
been released on bail, the bail bonds shall stand cancelled.
26. The appeal is allowed with the above directions.
27. Pending application(s), if any, shall stand disposed of.


.......…….……………………. J.
(J. B. PARDIWALA)


....……….……………………. J.
(K. VINOD CHANDRAN)

NEW DELHI;
AUGUST 13, 2026.
Page 15 of 15

Criminal Appeal No.76 of 2020