Sonu vs Ashok Kumar And Anr
- Court
- Punjab and Haryana High Court
1
FAO-3414-2018 (O&M)
IN THE HIGH COURT OF PUNJAB AND HARYANA
AT CHANDIGARH
FAO-3414-2018 (O&M)
Reserved on :12.11.2026
Pronounced on: 19.11.2026
Uploaded on 20.11.2026
Whether only operative part of the judgment is
pronounced or the full judgment is pronounced: Operative part/full judgment
Sonu
…...Appellant
Versus
Ashok Kumar and another …….Respondents
CORAM: HON'BLE MS. JUSTICE MANDEEP PANNU
Present:- Mr. Ashish Tewatia, Advocate for the appellant
None for respondent No.1
Mr. Punit Jain, Advocate
for respondent No.2-Insurance Company
MANDEEP PANNU, J.
1. The present appeal has been filed by the appellant-claimant
through his father/natural guardian, impugning the award dated 08.01.20218
passed by the learned Motor Accident Claims Tribunal, Palwal (hereinafter
₹
referred to as ‘Tribunal’) whereby compensation of 11,18,150/- alongwith
interest at the rate of 7.5% per annum from the date of filing of the petition till
actual realization has been awarded to him on account of injuries and
permanent disability suffered by him in a motor vehicular accident.
2. The accident in question took place on 22.04.2014 at about 8:00–
8:30 a.m. At the relevant time, the claimant was 20 years of age and was
travelling as a pillion rider on a motorcycle being driven by his relative,
REKHA SIHAG
2026.11.20 11:30
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
Chandigarh
2
FAO-3414-2018 (O&M)
namely, Ved Ram. When they reached the place of occurrence, their
motorcycle was hit by a Tata Sumo vehicle driven by respondent No. 1 in a
rash and negligent manner. As a result of the impact, Ved Ram fell onto the
kacha path alongside the road but did not sustain any injuries, whereas the
claimant, Sonu, fell onto the road and sustained serious injuries. In this
regard, FIR No.223 dated 29.04.2014 was registered under Sections 279, 337
and 338 IPC at Police Station Sadar Palwal.
3. The Tribunal held that accident in question took place on account
of rash and negligent driving by respondent No.1. It also held that claimant
has become permanently disabled to the extent of 80% and assessed the
compensation as under:-
Sr.No. Head Amount
awarded
1. Medical Expenses 5,08,150/-
2. Amount on account of 80% permanent 5,00,000/-
disability
3. Pain and suffering 60,000/-
4. Special Diet 20,000/-
5. Attendant charges 20,000/-
6. Transportation charges 10,000/-
Total Rs.11,18,150/-
4. Learned counsel for the appellant/claimant submits that the
claimant was pursuing a Diploma in Draftsman (Civil Engineering) from
Indira Gandhi Industrial and Vocational Training Institute, Sohna, Haryana at
the time of accident. Besides his studies, he was also imparting tuition,
assisting his father in agricultural activities and supervising his father's
business of selling liquor/wine. It is further contended that the claimant was
earning approximately Rs.30,000/- per month from these activities. However,
REKHA SIHAG
2026.11.20 11:30
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
Chandigarh
3
FAO-3414-2018 (O&M)
on account of the critical head injury and multiple injuries sustained by him
on vital parts of his body in the accident, he remained in coma and persistent
vegetative state. Consequently, he became permanently disabled, suffering
from 100% functional disability. It is further contended that his family had
incurred expenses amounting to approximately Rs.20,00,000/- on his
treatment, during which he remained hospitalised on several occasions and
underwent prolonged medical treatment and follow-up care. However, the
learned counsel for the appellant/claimant contends that the Tribunal has
neither assessed the income of the claimant nor awarded any amount towards
future prospects, completely ignoring the fact that the claimant was a young
man aged 20 years at the time of the accident and was pursuing a Diploma in
Draftsman. It is further submitted that, as a result of the accident, the claimant
has suffered permanent physical disability to the extent of 80%. However, in
functional terms, his disability is 100%, rendering him completely dependent
upon others. The fact that even the claim petition as well as the present appeal
has been filed through his father further demonstrates the extent of his
dependency. Learned counsel further contends that the Tribunal has awarded
only a sum of Rs.5,00,000/- towards permanent disability and has granted
meagre amounts under various heads, namely, special diet, transportation,
attendant charges and pain and suffering. It is also argued that the Tribunal
has failed to award any compensation towards loss of enjoyment of amenities
of life and loss of marriage prospects, particularly keeping in view the young
age of the claimant at the time of the accident. Learned counsel for the
appellant-claimant places reliance upon judgment of Hon’ble Supreme Court
in Deepak Singh alias Deepak Chauhan vs. Mukesh Kumar & others
REKHA SIHAG
2026.11.20 11:30
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
Chandigarh
4
FAO-3414-2018 (O&M)
2025 INSC 179 wherein notional income of the claimant who was a student
of Mechanical Engineering in his twenties and met with an accident in the
year 2012 was assessed as Rs.10,000/- and also awarded future prospects @
40%.
5. Learned counsel for the Insurance Company contends that
Tribunal has rightly assessed disability of the claimant to the extent of 80%
while relying upon disability certificate Ex.P2 which shows that the disability
is not qua the whole body. Furthermore, he submits that in so far as income
of the claimant is concerned, in view of various judgments of the Hon’ble
Supreme Court, income of claimant who was a student pursuing Diploma at
the time of accident can at best be assessed as equivalent to that of minimum
wages of an unskilled labourer.
6. This Court has considered the submissions made by the learned
counsel for the parties.
7. Let us first analyse the extent of permanent disability suffered by
the claimant. As per the disability certificate Ex.P2 proved by PW3 Dr.
Chirag Sethi, Medical Officer, Orthopedic Surgeon, Govt. Hospital, Palwal
claimant had 80% permanent disability on his person due to case of head
surgery with diffuse axonal injury with severe cerebral ataxia. Dr. Mukesh
Pandey, Senior Consultant Neurosurgery, Asian Hospital, Faridabad (PW6)
opined that course of recovery of such critical head injuries cannot be
predicted.
8. The contention of learned counsel for the Insurance Company
that the aforesaid disability does not relate to the claimant's whole body is
devoid of merit. A person suffering from 80% disability, particularly
REKHA SIHAG
2026.11.20 11:30
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
Chandigarh
5
FAO-3414-2018 (O&M)
following head surgery, can undoubtedly be considered to be 100%
functionally disabled, having regard to the overall impact of such disability on
his functional capacity and ability to perform day-to-day activities. It is well
settled law that courts should not adopt stereotypical or myopic approach in
such matters rather case should be decided taking into consideration realities
of life, both in assessment of extent of disabilities and compensation under
various heads. In medical sense, permanent disability might be on lower side,
however, its impact on earning capacity as well as basic amenities of life are
to be kept in mind while assessing compensation for such loss. Reliance in
this regard can be placed on judgment of the Hon’ble the Supreme Court in
the case of Pappu Deo Yadav vs. Naresh Kumar & Ors. [2020 (4) RCR
(Civil) 404] wherein it has been held as under :
“12. In view of the above decisive rulings of this court, the
High Court clearly erred in holding that compensation for
loss of future prospects could not be awarded. In addition
to loss of future earnings (based on a determination of the
income at the time of accident), the appellant is also
entitled to compensation for loss of future prospects, @
40% (following the Pranay Sethi principle).
13. The factual narrative discloses that the appellant, a
20-year-old data entry operator (who had studied up to
12th standard) incurred permanent disability, i.e. loss of
his right hand (which was amputated). The disability was
assessed to be 89%. However, the tribunal and the High
Court re-assessed the disability to be only 45%, on the
assumption that the assessment for compensation was to
be on a different basis, as the injury entailed loss of only
one arm. This approach, in the opinion of this court, is
completely mechanical and entirely ignores realities.
Whilst it is true that assessment of injury of one limb or to
one part may not entail permanent injury to the whole
body, the inquiry which the court has to conduct is the
resultant loss which the injury entails to the earning or
income generating capacity of the claimant. Thus, loss of
one leg to someone carrying on a vocation such as driving
or something that entails walking or constant mobility,
results in severe income generating impairment or its
extinguishment altogether. Likewise, for one involved in a
REKHA SIHAG
2026.11.20 11:30
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
Chandigarh
6
FAO-3414-2018 (O&M)
job like a carpenter or hairdresser, or machinist, and an
experienced one at that, loss of an arm, (more so a
functional arm) leads to near extinction of income
generation. If the age of the victim is beyond 40, the scope
of rehabilitation too diminishes. These individual factors
are of crucial importance which are to be borne in mind
while determining the extent of permanent disablement, for
the purpose of assessment of loss of earning capacity.”
9 . Further, reliance has been placed on judgment of the Hon’ble
Supreme Court in Arvind Kumar Mishra vs. New India Assurance Co.
Ltd. (2010) 10 SCC 254, wherein following observations have been made:-
“7. We do not intend to review in detail state of
authorities in relation to assessment of all damages for
personal injury. Suffice it to say that the basis of
assessment of all damages for personal injury is
compensation. The whole idea is to put the claimant in
the same position as he was insofar as money can.
Perfect compensation is hardly possible but one has to
keep in mind that the victim has done no wrong; he has
suffered at the hands of wrongdoer and the court must
take care to give him full and fair compensation for that
he had suffered. In some cases for personal injury, the
claim could be in respect of lifetime’s earnings lost
because, though, he will live, he cannot earn his living.
In others, the claim may be made for partial loss of
earnings. Each case has to be considered in the light of
its own facts and at the end, one must ask whether the
sum awarded is a fair and reasonable sum. The
conventional basis of assessing compensation in personal
injury cases and that is now recognised mode as to the
proper measure of compensation is taking an appropriate
multiplier of an appropriate multicipand.
10. In view of aforesaid observations of the Hon’ble Supreme Court
in Pappu Deo Yadav’s and Arvind Kumar Mishra’s cases (supra) , this
Court has no hesitation in holding that, in view of the claimant’s 80%
permanent physical disability resulting from brain injuries, his functional
disability, for the purpose of assessing loss of future earning capacity, is to be
assessed at 100%.
REKHA SIHAG
2026.11.20 11:30
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
Chandigarh
7
FAO-3414-2018 (O&M)
11. Now, this Court proceeds towards assessment of income of the
claimant. He was pursuing Diploma in Draftsman (Civil Engineering) at the
time of accident and it is also claimed that he was also assisting his father in
liquor/wine shop as well as agricultural work, besides taking tuitions. He was
claimed to be earning Rs.30,000/- per month. The claimant, in the present
case, was a young student of 20 years having good health at the time of
accident. He was unmarried. The claimant had a bright future ahead of him;
however, as a result of the accident, he has not only suffered a loss of future
prospects but has also been deprived of the prospects of marriage, thereby
suffering an irreparable loss in his personal and social life. Therefore, by
applying ratio of law laid down by Hon’ble Supreme Court in Deepak Singh
alias Deepak Chauhan’s case (supra) wherein notional income of claimant,
who was pursuing a Degree in Mechanical Engineering was assessed at Rs.
10,000/-, this Court assesses notional income of the claimant in the present
case at Rs.7000/- considering that he was pursuing a Diploma Course in
Draftsman (Civil Engineering).
12. As far as escalation in income on account of future income is
concerned, while relying upon observations of Hon’ble Supreme Court in
National Insurance Company Limited vs. Pranay Sethi and others (2017)
16 SCC 680, and considering the age of claimant (20 years), he is also held
entitled to future income @ 40% (monthly income= 7000+2800 = 9800/-).
Multiplier of 18 would be applied considering the age of the claimant.
Furthermore, amount awarded under pain & suffering is enhanced from
Rs.60,000/- to Rs.1,00,000/-. Likewise, amount awarded under Heads Special
diet is enhanced to Rs.40,000/-, Attendant Charges is enhanced to Rs.60,000/-
REKHA SIHAG
2026.11.20 11:30
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
Chandigarh
8
FAO-3414-2018 (O&M)
and transportation charges are enhanced to Rs.20,000/- The claimant is also
held entitled to Rs.3,00,000/- towards loss of marriage prospects & amenities
of life. However, amount awarded by the Tribunal under heads Medical
Expenses’’ (Rs.5,08,150/-) is maintained.
13. Accordingly, amount of compensation is reassessed as under:-
Sr.No Head Amount
awarded
1. Medical Expenses 5,08,150/-
2. Attendant charges 60,000/-
3. Pain and suffering 1,00,000/-
4. Permanent disability @ 100% 21,16,800/-
9800x12x18 =21,16,800/-)
5. Loss of marriage prospects & other 3,00,000/-
amenities of life
6. Transportation charges 20,000/-
7. Special Diet 40,000/-
Total Rs. 31,44,950/-
Difference = 31,44,950-11,18,150 = 2,026,800/-
14. The claimant shall be entitled to enhanced amount of
compensation alongwith interest at the rate of 7.5% per annum from the date
of filing of the claim petition till its realization.
15. Accordingly, the present appeal stands partly allowed.
16. All the pending miscellaneous applications, if any, are also
disposed of.
19.11.2026 (MANDEEP PANNU)
rekha JUDGE
Whether speaking/reasoned Yes/No
Whether reportable Yes/No
REKHA SIHAG
2026.11.20 11:30
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
Chandigarh