MADHU NEGI vs GANESH DUTT SHARMA AND OTHERS
- Court
- High Court of Himachal Pradesh
1 2026:HHC:42167
IN THE HIGH COURT OF HIMACHAL PRADESH
AT SHIMLA
High Court of H.P.
CMPMO No. 435 of 2026
Reserved on : 22.9.2026
Decided on: 30.9.2026
Uploaded on: 30.9.2026
Madhu Negi
… Petitioner
Versus
Ganesh Dutt Sharma & others
…Respondents
_____________________________ ______________
Coram
Hon’ble Mr. Justice Virender Singh, Judge
Whether approved for reporting? yes
___________________________________________________
For the Petitioners: Mr. N.K. Bhalla and Ms.
Chehak Bhalla, Advocates.
For the Respondents : Mr. Sudhir Thakur, Senior
Advocate, assisted by Mr.
Karun Negi, Advocate, for
respondents No. 1 and 2.
Mr. Narender Sharma, Ms.
Minakshi Sharma and Mr.
Suraj Sharma, Advocates, for
respondent No. 3.
Virender Singh, Judge
Petitioner Madhu Negi has filed the present
petition, under Article 227 of the Constitution of India,
against the order dated 20.05.2026, passed by the Court
of learned Civil Judge, Court No. 1, Solan, District
::: Downloaded on - 30/09/2026 15:43:06 :::CIS
2 2026:HHC:42167
Solan, HP (hereinafter referred to as, ‘the trial Court’) in
High Court of H.P.
CMA No. 292 of 2025, in Civil Suit titled as, ‘Ganesh
Dutt Sharma and others versus Smt. Madhu Negi and
another’.
2. By virtue of order dated 20.05.2026, the learned
trial Court has rejected the application, filed under
Order 7 Rule 11 CPC, filed by the petitioner, in the said
suit.
3. For the sake of convenience, parties to the lis are
hereinafter referred to, in the same manner, in which,
they were referred to, by the learned trial Court.
4. Necessary facts, as borne out from the
documents, annexed with the petition, may be summed
up, as under:
The plaintiffs Shri Ganesh Dutt Sharma and
Smt. Ram Prabha Sharma have filed a suit for
declaration and permanent prohibitory injunction, under
Sections 34/38 of the Specific Relief Act, 1963, against
defendants Smt. Madhu Negi and Baghat Urban
Cooperative Bank Ltd.
::: Downloaded on - 30/09/2026 15:43:06 :::CIS
3 2026:HHC:42167
4.1 The said suit has been filed by the plaintiffs on
High Court of H.P.
the ground that they are owners in possession of the
land measuring Khata Khatauni No. 327, min 548,
khasra Nos. 1115/918, and 1117/919 kita 2, total
measuring 0-15-27 hectares, situated in mauja Basal
Patti Kather, Hadbast No. 48, Pargana Sumana, Basal
Tehsil and District Solan, HP, along with the house/
structure existing thereupon (hereinafter referred to as
‘the suit land’).
4.2 The ownership and possession over the suit land
is also stated to be in the knowledge of defendants, prior
to 21.03.2016. Defendant No.1, in connivance with her
husband, had played a fraud upon the plaintiffs and
misrepresented the facts and by misrepresentation, got
executed a sale deed, in her favour, on 21.03.2016
which was registered with Sub-Registrar Solan, District
Solan, H.P., whereby, defendant No. 1 had got the suit
land transferred, in her favour, for a total sale
consideration of Rs. 56,00,000/-.
4.3 According to the plaintiffs, in para-3 of the sale
deed, it has been mentioned that defendant No. 1 had
::: Downloaded on - 30/09/2026 15:43:06 :::CIS
4 2026:HHC:42167
paid the total agreed sale consideration of Rs.
High Court of H.P.
56,00,000/- to the plaintiffs, through cheque No.
158470, drawn on the Baghat Urban Cooperative Bank
Limited, Solan.
4.4 On the basis of the above recital in the sale deed,
defendant No. 1 had prominently got the sale deed
executed, whereas, at the time of issuing the said
cheque No. 158470 dated 21.03.2016, in favour of the
plaintiffs, defendant No.1 and her husband had
requested the plaintiffs not to present the said cheque
for encashment, for some days, and relying upon the
version of defendant No. 1 and her husband, plaintiffs
have not presented the said cheque for encashment.
4.5 It is the further case of the plaintiffs that
defendant No. 1, immediately after getting the sale deed
executed in her favour, had mortgaged the suit land with
defendant No. 2, on the very next date i.e. on 23.03.2016
through Mortgage Deed No. 650/16 dated 23.03.2016,
but, the amount has not been paid to the plaintiffs.
Despite the request made by the plaintiffs, defendant
No.1 and her husband had not made the payment of the
::: Downloaded on - 30/09/2026 15:43:06 :::CIS
5 2026:HHC:42167
cheque to them, and till the time of filing of the suit,
High Court of H.P.
they have not paid the said amount.
4.6 The sale deed is stated to be without any
consideration and has been obtained by playing fraud
upon the plaintiffs.
4.7 On the basis of the above facts, a prayer has
been made to decree the suit for declaration to the effect
that the sale deed dated 21.03.2016 be declared as null
and void and not binding upon the rights of the
plaintiffs.
4.8 Similarly, the subsequent mortgage has also
been challenged and a prayer has been made to pass a
decree for declaration, in favour of the plaintiffs, by
declaring them the owners in possession of the suit
land.
5. In the said Civil Suit, defendant No. 1 has filed
the application, under Order 7 Rule 11 of CPC, on the
ground that the plaintiffs have averred in the plaint that
they have signed and executed the sale deed, in favour of
defendant No. 1, for a sale consideration of Rs.
56,00,000/-.
::: Downloaded on - 30/09/2026 15:43:06 :::CIS
6 2026:HHC:42167
5.1 By virtue of the application, following grounds
High Court of H.P.
have been taken:
a) Sale deed has been challenged by the executant.
b) The amount of sale deed is 56,00,000/-.
5.2 On the basis of above facts, a prayer has been
made to pay the court fees of Rs. 56,00,000/-, as
according to them, the suit has not been valued properly
for the purpose of court fees and jurisdiction. The suit of
the plaintiffs is prayed to be rejected, on account of
incorrect valuation. It has further been averred that the
plaintiffs cannot seek the relief, without affixing the
court fees.
5.3 In addition to this, another application has also
been moved for rejection of the plaint, on the ground
that the plaintiffs have no cause of action to file and
maintain the suit. Defendant No. 1 has further averred
that the sale deed cannot be annulled, solely, on the
basis of the dishonour of the cheque, in favour of the
plaintiffs, towards the sale consideration.
6. These applications have been contested by the
plaintiffs on the ground that defendant No. 1 had got
executed the sale deed, by playing fraud with the
::: Downloaded on - 30/09/2026 15:43:06 :::CIS
7 2026:HHC:42167
defendants, without making the payment of the sale
High Court of H.P.
consideration, and thereafter, she had mortgaged the
suit land, with Baghat Urban Cooperative Bank Limited,
on the very next day, i.e. 23.03.2016, through Mortgage
Deed. This act of defendant No.1 has been pleaded as
her intention to defraud the plaintiffs.
6.1 The other application has been contested on the
ground that the sale deed in question, cannot be
annulled, solely on the basis of dishonour of cheque,
delivered to the plaintiffs, towards the sale
consideration.
6.2 Re-asserting the fact that the sale deed is null
and void, and as such, they have sought the declaration
on the basis of the stand, as taken in the application, a
prayer has been made to dismiss the application.
7. The learned trial Court had dismissed the
applications, vide order dated 20.5.2026.
8. The aforesaid findings have been assailed by
defendant No. 1, before this Court, mainly on the ground
that the learned trial Court has wrongly ignored the
averments, as made in the sale deed, as well as, in the
::: Downloaded on - 30/09/2026 15:43:06 :::CIS
8 2026:HHC:42167
plaint and re-asserted the fact that the alleged non-
High Court of H.P.
payment of the sale price or part thereof, does not affect
the validity of the sale deed.
9. On the basis of the above facts, Mr. Navneet
Kumar Bhalla and Ms. Chehak Bhalla, Advocates,
appearing for defendant No. 1 have prayed that the
present petition may kindly be allowed, by setting aside
the order, passed by the learned trial Court, on
20.5.2026 and their applications for rejection of the
plaint, may kindly be allowed, by rejecting the plaint.
10. Per contra, Mr. Sudhir Thakur, learned Senior
Advocate, assisted by Mr. Karun Negi, Advocate
appearing for respondent Nos. 1 and 2/plaintiffs have
supported the order passed by the learned trial Court
and prayed that the revision petition sans merit and the
same may kindly be dismissed.
11. Defendant No.1 has moved the application for
rejection of the plaint, on two counts; firstly, that the
suit has not been valued, for the purpose of court fees
and jurisdiction, and deficient court fee has been paid;
and secondly, that the plaintiffs have no cause of action
::: Downloaded on - 30/09/2026 15:43:06 :::CIS
9 2026:HHC:42167
to file the present suit, as their suit is not maintainable,
High Court of H.P.
on account of alleged non-payment, of the sale
consideration, to the plaintiffs.
12. The learned trial Court, in the present case, has
dismissed the application, under Order 7 Rule 11 CPC,
on the ground, that the plaintiffs have pleaded that
since, the sale consideration was not paid, as such,
possession was not delivered, and fraud has been
committed with them.
13. According to the learned trial Court, these
disputed facts require evidence and need to be
adjudicated upon, during trial. As stated above, the
applications were rejected by the learned trial Court.
14. The scope of provisions of Order 7 Rule 11 of the
CPC has elaborately been discussed by Hon’ble Supreme
Court in Madanuri Sri Rama Chandra Murthy vs. Syed
Jalal, reported in (2017) 13 Supreme Court Cases 174.
Relevant paragraph-7 of the judgment is reproduced, as
under:
“7. The plaint can be rejected under Order VII Rule 11 if
conditions enumerated in the said provision are fulfilled.
It is needless to observe that the power under Order VII
::: Downloaded on - 30/09/2026 15:43:06 :::CIS
10 2026:HHC:42167
Rule 11, CPC can be exercised by the Court at any stage
of the suit. The relevant facts which need to be looked
High Court of H.P.
into for deciding the application are the averments of the
plaint only. If on an entire and meaningful reading of the
plaint, it is found that the suit is manifestly vexatious
and meritless in the sense of not disclosing any right to
sue, the court should exercise power under Order VII
Rule 11, CPC . Since the power conferred on the Court to
terminate civil action at the threshold is drastic, the
conditions enumerated under Order VII Rule 11 of CPC to
the exercise of power of rejection of plaint have to be
strictly adhered to. The averments of the plaint have to be
read as a whole to find out whether the averments
disclose a cause of action or whether the suit is barred by
any law. It is needless to observe that the question as to
whether the suit is barred by any law, would always
depend upon the facts and circumstances of each case.
The averments in the written statement as well as the
contentions of the defendant are wholly immaterial while
considering the prayer of the defendant for rejection of
the plaint. Even when, the allegations made in the plaint
are taken to be correct as a whole on their face value, if
they show that the suit is barred by any law, or do not
disclose cause of action, the application for rejection of
plaint can be entertained and the power under Order VII
Rule 11 of CPC can be exercised. If clever drafting of the
plaint has created the illusion of a cause of action, the
court will nip it in the bud at the earliest so that bogus
litigation will end at the earlier stage.”
(self emphasis supplied)
15. Similar view has again been taken by the Hon’ble
Supreme Court in Dahiben versus Arvindbhai Kalyanji
::: Downloaded on - 30/09/2026 15:43:06 :::CIS
11 2026:HHC:42167
Bhanusali, reported in (2020) 7 SCC 366. Relevant
High Court of H.P.
paragraph-12 of the judgment is reproduced as under:
“12. We have heard the learned Counsel for the parties,
perused the plaint and documents filed therewith, as also
the written submissions filed on behalf of the parties.
12.1 We will first briefly touch upon the law applicable for
deciding an application under Order VII Rule 11 CPC,
which reads as under:
“11. Rejection of plaint.– The plaint shall be rejected in
the following cases:–
(a) where it does not disclose a cause of action;
(b) where the relief claimed in undervalued, and the
plaintiff, on being required by the Court to correct the
valuation within a time to be fixed by the Court, fails to
do so;
(c) where the relief claimed is properly valued but the
plaint is written upon paper insufficiently stamped, and
the plaintiff, on being required by the Court to supply the
requisite stamp-paper within a time to be fixed by the
Court, fails to do so;
(d) where the suit appears from the statement in the
plaint to be barred by any law;
(e) where it is not filed in duplicate;
(f) where the plaintiff fails to comply with the provisions of
rule 9 Provided that the time fixed by the Court for the
correction of the valuation or supplying of the requisite
stamp-paper shall not be extended unless the Court, for
reasons to be recorded, is satisfied that the plaintiff was
prevent by any cause of exceptional nature for correction
the valuation or supplying the requisite stamp-paper, as
the case may be, within the time fixed by the Court and
::: Downloaded on - 30/09/2026 15:43:06 :::CIS
12 2026:HHC:42167
that refusal to extend such time would cause grave
injustice to the plaintiff.”
High Court of H.P.
The remedy under Order VII Rule 11 is an
independent and special remedy, wherein the Court is
empowered to summarily dismiss a suit at the threshold,
without proceeding to record evidence, and conducting a
trial, on the basis of the evidence adduced, if it is
satisfied that the action should be terminated on any of
the grounds contained in this provision.
The underlying object of Order VII Rule 11 (a) is
that if in a suit, no cause of action is disclosed, or the
suit is barred by limitation under Rule 11 (d), the Court
would not permit the plaintiff to unnecessarily protract
the proceedings in the suit. In such a case, it would be
necessary to put an end to the sham litigation, so that
further judicial time is not wasted.
In Azhar Hussain v. Rajiv Gandhi1 this Court held that
the whole purpose of conferment of powers under this
provision is to ensure that a litigation which is
meaningless, and bound to prove abortive, should not be
11986 Supp. SCC 315 Followed in Maharaj Shri
Manvendrasinhji Jadeja v. Rajmata Vijaykunverba w/o
Late Maharaja Mahedrasinhji, (1998) 2 GLH
823 permitted to waste judicial time of the court, in the
following words :
“12. …The whole purpose of conferment of such
power is to ensure that a litigation which is
meaningless, and bound to prove abortive
should not be permitted to occupy the time of
the Court, and exercise the mind of the
respondent. The sword of Damocles need not be
kept hanging over his head unnecessarily
without point or purpose. Even if an ordinary
::: Downloaded on - 30/09/2026 15:43:06 :::CIS
13 2026:HHC:42167
civil litigation, the Court readily exercises the
power to reject a plaint, if it does not disclose
High Court of H.P.
any cause of action.”
12.2 The power conferred on the court to terminate a civil
action is, however, a drastic one, and the conditions
enumerated in Order VII Rule 11 are required to be
strictly adhered to.
12.3 Under Order VII Rule 11, a duty is cast on the Court
to determine whether the plaint discloses a cause of
action by scrutinizing the averments in the plaint, read in
conjunction with the documents relied upon, or whether
the suit is barred by any law.
12.4 Order VII Rule 14(1) provides for production of
documents, on which the plaintiff places reliance in his
suit, which reads as under :
“Order 7 Rule 14: Production of document on which
plaintiff sues or relies.–
(1)Where a plaintiff sues upon a document or relies
upon document in his possession or power in
support of his claim, he shall enter such documents
in a list, and shall produce it in Court when the
plaint is presented by him and shall, at the same
time deliver the document and a copy thereof, to be
filed with the plaint.
(2)Where any such document is not in the
possession or power of the plaintiff, he shall,
wherever possible, state in whose possession or
power it is.
(3) A document which ought to be produced in
Court by the plaintiff when the plaint is presented,
or to be entered in the list to be added or annexed
to the plaint but is not produced or entered
accordingly, shall not, without the leave of the
::: Downloaded on - 30/09/2026 15:43:06 :::CIS
14 2026:HHC:42167
Court, be received in evidence on his behalf at the
hearing of the suit.
High Court of H.P.
(4)Nothing in this rule shall apply to document
produced for the cross examination of the plaintiff's
witnesses, or, handed over to a witness merely to
refresh his memory.”
Having regard to Order VII Rule 14 CPC, the
documents filed alongwith the plaint, are required to be
taken into consideration for deciding the application
under Order VII Rule 11 (a). When a document referred
to in the plaint, forms the basis of the plaint, it should be
treated as a part of the plaint.
12.5 In exercise of power under this provision, the Court
would determine if the assertions made in the plaint are
contrary to statutory law, or judicial dicta, for deciding
whether a case for rejecting the plaint at the threshold is
made out.
12.6 At this stage, the pleas taken by the defendant in
the written statement and application for rejection of the
plaint on the merits, would be irrelevant, and cannot be
adverted to, or taken into consideration.
12.7. The test for exercising the power under Order VII
Rule 11 is that if the averments made in the plaint are
taken in entirety, in conjunction with the documents
relied upon, would the same result in a decree being
passed. This test was laid down in Liverpool & London
S.P. & I Assn. Ltd. v. M.V.Sea Success I & Anr.,4 which
reads as :
“139. Whether a plaint discloses a cause of action
or not is essentially a question of fact. But whether
it does or does not must be found out from reading
the plaint itself. For the said purpose, the
averments made in the plaint in their entirety must
::: Downloaded on - 30/09/2026 15:43:06 :::CIS
15 2026:HHC:42167
be held to be correct. The test is as to whether if the
averments made in the plaint are taken to be
High Court of H.P.
correct in their entirety, a decree would be passed.”
In Hardesh Ores (P.) Ltd. v. Hede & Co.5 the Court
further held that it is not permissible to cull out a
sentence or a passage, and to read it in isolation. It is the
substance, and not merely the form, which has to be
looked into. The plaint has to be construed as it stands,
without addition or subtraction of words. If the
allegations in the plaint prima facie show a cause of
action, the court cannot embark upon an enquiry
whether the allegations are true in fact.
12.8 If on a meaningful reading of the plaint, it is found
that the suit is manifestly vexatious and without any
merit, and does not disclose a right to sue, the court
would be justified in exercising the power under Order
VII Rule 11 CPC.
12.9 The power under Order VII Rule 11 CPC may be
exercised by the Court at any stage of the suit, either
before registering the plaint, or after issuing summons to
the defendant, or before conclusion of the trial, as held
by this Court in the judgment of Saleem Bhai v. State of
Maharashtra.7 The plea that once issues are framed, the
matter must necessarily go to trial was repelled by this
Court in Azhar Hussain (supra).
12.10. The provision of Order VII Rule 11 is mandatory
in nature. It states that the plaint “shall” be rejected if
any of the grounds specified in clause (a) to (e) are made
out. If the Court finds that the plaint does not disclose a
cause of action, or that the suit is barred by any law, the
Court has no option, but to reject the plaint.”
::: Downloaded on - 30/09/2026 15:43:06 :::CIS
16 2026:HHC:42167
High Court of H.P.
16. Guided by the above two decisions, now, this
Court would proceed further to ascertain the fact
whether the learned trial Court has committed an
irregularity, in dismissing the applications, for rejection
of the plaint or there is any jurisdictional error on the
part of learned trial Court.
17. While holding so, view of this Court is being
guided by the Hon’ble Supreme Court in a case titled as,
‘Bhudev Mallick Alias Bhudeb Mallick & anr. versus
Ranajit Ghoshal & ors.’, 2025 INSC 175. Relevant
paragraphs 53, 54 and 55 of the judgment are
reproduced as under:
53. We are a bit disappointed with the manner in which
the High Court dealt with the present litigation, more
particularly while deciding the revision application filed
by the appellants herein against the order passed by the
executing court. All that the High Court has said in one
line is that it did not find any jurisdictional error in the
order passed by the executing court ordering arrest,
detention in a civil prison and attachment of the property
of the appellants. We fail to understand, why the High
Court was not able to see the gross error in the order
passed by the executing court, be it called an error of law
or a jurisdictional error. Undoubtedly, the High Court in
::: Downloaded on - 30/09/2026 15:43:06 :::CIS
17 2026:HHC:42167
exercise of its supervisory jurisdiction under Article
227 of the Constitution must ascertain before interfering
High Court of H.P.
with any order passed by a subordinate court or tribunal
whether the same suffers from any jurisdictional error. At
times in litigation like the one on hand, the court should
be guided by its conscience, more particularly keeping in
mind the peculiar facts and circumstances of the case
and not strictly go by the term “jurisdictional error”. It is
very easy for the High Court to say that there is no
jurisdictional error and, therefore, no interference is
warranted but before saying so, the High Court should be
mindful of the consequences that would follow like arrest,
detention in civil prison and attachment of property.
54. What is a jurisdictional error has been the subject of
a legion of illuminating judicial decisions. In this case,
however, we need concern ourselves with only one aspect
of that matter and it is enough for us to refer in this
connection to the decision of the Privy Council in the case
of Joy Chand Lal Babu v. Kamalaksha Chaudhury, AIR
1949 PC 239, where Sir John Beaumont, delivering the
judgment of the Board, observed inter alia as follows:-
“although error in a decision of a Subordinate Court does
not by itself involve that the subordinate Court has acted
illegally or with material irregularity so as to justify
interference in revision under Subsection (c). nevertheless
if the erroneous decision results in the subordinate Court
exercising a jurisdiction, not vested in it by law or failing
to exercise a jurisdiction so vested, a case for revision
arises under Sub-section (a) or Sub-section (b) and Sub
section (c) can be ignored.”
55. If, therefore, an error, be it an error of fact or of law,
is such that the erroneous decision has resulted in the
subordinate Court or tribunal exercising jurisdiction, not
::: Downloaded on - 30/09/2026 15:43:06 :::CIS
18 2026:HHC:42167
vested in it by law, or in its having failed to exercise
jurisdiction, vested in it by law, that will come within the
High Court of H.P.
scope of Section 115 of the Code or, for the matter of
that, of Article 227 of the Constitution, as the case may
be. This error may have resulted from a violation of rules
of natural justice, by taking into consideration matters
which are extraneous and irrelevant, or by substituting
judicial consideration by bias, based on suspicion, arising
from those extraneous matters or from any other cause
whatsoever but if it has affected the assumption or
exercise of jurisdiction, as envisaged above, it will be a
jurisdictional error for purposes of the above Article.”
18. It is no longer res integra that while deciding the
application, under Order 7 Rule 11 of the CPC, no
amount of evidence or merit of the controversy can be
examined and only the averments of the plaint are to be
seen, as held in a case titled as, ‘Eldeco Housing &
Industries Limited versus Ashok Vidyarthi & others’,
reported in (2024) 11 Supreme Court Cases 503.
Relevant paragraph-26 of the judgment is reproduced as
under:
“26. However, the fact remains that all the aforesaid
documents, referred to by the respondent in support of
his plea for rejection of the plaint, cannot be considered
at this stage as these are not part of the record with the
Court filed along with the plaint. This is the stand taken
by the respondent-defendant in the application filed
::: Downloaded on - 30/09/2026 15:43:06 :::CIS
19 2026:HHC:42167
under Order VII Rule 11 C.P.C. As noticed above, no
amount of evidence or merits of the controversy can be
High Court of H.P.
examined at the stage of decision of the application
under Order VII Rule 11 C.P.C . Hence, in our view, the
impugned order of the High Court passed in the Review
Application deserves to be set aside. Ordered
accordingly.”
(self emphasis supplied)
19. As per the averments made in the plaint, it is
the case of the plaintiffs, in nutshell, that defendant No.
1, in connivance with her husband, played a fraud upon
the plaintiffs, and by misrepresentation, got executed
the sale deed, in her favour, on 21.03.2026, which was
also registered and the consideration amount was paid
through cheque No. 158470, drawn on Baghat Urban
Co-operative Bank Limited Solan, H.P., for a sum of Rs.
56,00,000/- and when, the cheque was issued,
defendant No.1 and her husband had requested the
plaintiffs not to present the cheque, in the bank for
encashment, and acting upon the said request, the
plaintiffs have not presented the cheque with the banker
of defendant No.1, for encashment.
::: Downloaded on - 30/09/2026 15:43:06 :::CIS
20 2026:HHC:42167
20. It is also the case of the plaintiffs that the sale
High Court of H.P.
deed was got executed by defendant No. 1, in her favour,
without making the payment of the sale consideration.
21. It has further been alleged that on the very next
day of execution of the sale deed, i.e. on 22.03.2016,
defendant No. 1 has mortgaged the subject matter of the
lis to defendant No. 2.
22. The very basis of the challenge to the sale deed is
non-payment of the sale consideration, amounting to Rs.
56,00,000/-, which, as per the plaint, was given to the
plaintiffs, by defendant No. 1, by way of cheque, for a
sum of rupees 56,00,000/-. At the best, it can be said
that the challenge to the sale deed is on account of non-
payment of the sale consideration.
23. The term ‘sale’ has also been discussed by the
Hon’ble Supreme Court in Dahiben’s case (supra).
Relevant paragraph-15 of the judgment is reproduced as
under:
“15.3 The Plaintiffs have made out a case of alleged non-
payment of a part of the sale consideration in the Plaint,
and prayed for the relief of cancellation of the Sale Deed
on this ground.
::: Downloaded on - 30/09/2026 15:43:06 :::CIS
21 2026:HHC:42167
Section 54 of the Transfer of Property Act, 1882 provides
as under :
High Court of H.P.
“54. ‘Sale’ defined.—‘Sale’ is a transfer of ownership in
exchange for a price paid or promised or part-paid and
part- promised.” The definition of “sale” indicates that
there must be a transfer of ownership from one person to
another i.e. transfer of all rights and interest in the
property, which was possessed by the transferor to the
transferee. The transferor cannot retain any part of the
interest or right in the property, or else it would not be a
sale. The definition further indicates that the transfer of
ownership has to be made for a “price paid or promised
or part paid and part promised”. Price thus constitutes
an essential ingredient of the transaction of sale.
In Vidyadhar v. Manikrao & Anr., this Court held that the
words “price paid or promised or part paid and part
promised” indicates that actual payment of the whole of
the price at the time of the execution of the Sale Deed is
not a sine qua non for completion of the sale. Even if the
whole of the price is not paid, but the document is
executed, and thereafter registered, the sale would be
complete, and the title would pass on to the transferee
under the transaction. The non-payment of a part of the
sale price would not affect the validity of the sale. Once
the title in the property has already passed, even if the
balance sale consideration is not paid, the sale could not
be invalidated on this ground. In order to constitute a
“sale”, the parties must intend to transfer the ownership
of the property, on the agreement to pay the price either
in praesenti, or in future. The intention is to be gathered
from the recitals of the sale deed, the conduct of the
parties, and the evidence on record.
::: Downloaded on - 30/09/2026 15:43:06 :::CIS
22 2026:HHC:42167
In view of the law laid down by this Court, even if the
averments of the Plaintiffs are taken to be true, that the
High Court of H.P.
entire sale consideration had not in fact been paid, it
could not be a ground for cancellation of the Sale Deed.
We find that the suit filed by the Plaintiffs is vexatious,
meritless, and does not disclose a right to sue. The plaint
is liable to be rejected under Order VII Rule 11 (a).”
(self emphasis supplied)
24. In view of the aforesaid judgment, the sale deed
cannot be declared as null and void on account of
alleged non-payment of the sale consideration.
25. The order passed by the learned trial Court, in
application under Order 7 Rule 11 of the CPC also does
not sustain in judicial scrutiny, as Hon’ble Supreme
Court, in a case titled as, Razia Begum and others
versus Nafisa Begum Abdul Hamid and others, reported
in 2026 SCC Online SC 1511 has held that the non-
payment of the remaining part of the sale price would
not invalidate it and remedy would be to recover the
balance sale consideration, but not cancellation of sale
deed for non-payment of balance sale consideration.
Relevant paragraphs 9 to 12 are reproduced as under:
“9. Learned Counsel for the respondent on the other hand
emphasized that the view of the High Court flows from the
findings of the Trial Court itself. No fact finding of the
::: Downloaded on - 30/09/2026 15:43:06 :::CIS
23 2026:HHC:42167
Trial Court was disturbed and it was merely on the aspect
of law, the binding nature of the sale deeds, in the
High Court of H.P.
absence of full consideration being paid, the High Court
reversed the Trial Court judgment and decreed the suit.
The High Court acted within the contours of the
jurisdiction conferred under Section 100 of the Civil
Procedure Code, 1908. It never reappreciated the evidence
led or substituted the findings of the Trial Court but
merely gave legal effect to the findings already rendered.
10. In Vidhyadhar (supra), it was held so in Paragraph
Nos. 36, 37 and 38 with respect to Section 54 of the
Transfer of Property Act, 18823:—
“36. The definition indicates that in order to constitute a
sale, there must be a transfer of ownership from one
person to another, i.e., transfer of all rights and interests
in the properties which are possessed by that person are
transferred by him to another person. The transferor
cannot retain any part of his interest or right in that
property or else it would not be a sale. The definition
further says that the transfer of ownership has to be for a
“price paid or promised or part-paid and part-promised”.
Price thus constitutes an essential ingredient of the
transaction of sale. The words “price paid or promised or
part-paid and part-promised” indicate that actual
payment of the whole of the price at the time of the
execution of sale deed is not a sine qua non to the
completion of the sale. Even if the whole of the price is not
paid but the document is executed and thereafter
registered, if the property is of the value of more than Rs.
100, the sale would be complete.
37. There is a catena of decisions of various High Courts
in which it has been held that even if the whole of the
price is not paid, the transaction of sale will take effect
::: Downloaded on - 30/09/2026 15:43:06 :::CIS
24 2026:HHC:42167
and the title would pass under that transaction. To cite
only a few, in Gayatri Prasad v. Board of Revenue [1973
High Court of H.P.
All LJ 412] it was held that non-payment of a portion of
the sale price would not affect validity of sale. It was
observed that part-payment of consideration by the
vendee itself proved the intention to pay the remaining
amount of the sale price. To the same effect is the decision
of the Madhya Pradesh High Court
in Sukaloo v. Punau [AIR 1961 MP 176 : ILR 1960 MP
614].
38. The real test is the intention of the parties. In order to
constitute a “sale”, the parties must intend to transfer the
ownership of the property and they must also intend that
the price would be paid either in praesenti or in future.
The intention is to be gathered from the recital in the sale
deed, the conduct of the parties and the evidence on
record.”
11. Dahiben (supra) also, while interpreting Section 54 of
the Act, held that actual payment of entire sale price at
the time of execution of sale deed is not an essential
condition for completion of sale. When a sale deed is
registered, even upon part payment of the sale price, title
would pass to the transferee. The non-payment of
remaining part of the sale price would not invalidate it
and the remedy would be to recover the balance sale
consideration, but not cancellation of sale deed for non-
payment of balance sale consideration.
12. Section 54 of the Act squarely applies to the above
case. A reading of the translated sale deeds produced
along with the appeal, clearly indicates that the defendant
had retained Rs. 4,500/- for clearing the dues of the
plaintiffs. Obviously, the same was not paid and later, by
::: Downloaded on - 30/09/2026 15:43:06 :::CIS
25 2026:HHC:42167
two agreements, the defendant agreed to pay the full
consideration and to repay all the government loans.”
High Court of H.P.
(self-emphasis supplied)
26. In this case, the learned counsel for the plaintiffs
has also relied upon the decision of Hon’ble Supreme
Court in a case, titled as, ‘Saleem Bhai and others
versus State of Maharashtra & ors.’ reported in AIR
2003 SC 759 to buttress his arguments that the learned
trial Court has rightly dismissed the application. But,
the said decision is of no hep to the plaintiffs as there is
no dispute, with regard to the principle of Order 7 Rule
11, as discussed by the Hon’ble Supreme Court, in the
above mentioned case. Relevant paragraphs 7 to 9 of the
judgment are reproduced as under:
“ 7. The short common question that arises for
consideration in these appeals is, whether an application
under Order VII Rule 11 C.P.C. ought to be decided on the
allegations in the plaint and filing of the written statement
by the constesting defendant is irrelevant and
unnecessary.
Order VII Rule 11 C.P.C. reads as under:
"11. Rejection of plaint.-The plaint shall be rejected in the
following cases:-
(a) Where it does not disclose a cause of action;
(b) Where the relief claimed is undervalued, and the
plaintiff, on being required by the Court to correct the
::: Downloaded on - 30/09/2026 15:43:06 :::CIS
26 2026:HHC:42167
valuation within a time to be fixed by the court, fails to do
so;
High Court of H.P.
(c) Where the relief claimed is properly valued by the
plaint is written upon paper insufficiently stamped, and
the plaintiff, on being required by the Court to supply the
requisite stamp-paper within a time to be fixed by the
Court, failed to do so:
(d) Where the suit appears from the statement in the
plaint to be barred by any law;
(e) Where it is not filed in duplicate;
(f) Where the plaintiff fails to comply with the provisions of
Rule 9;
Provided that the time fixed by the Court for the
correction of the valuation or supplying of the requisite
stamp-paper shall not be extended unless the Court, for
reasons to be recorded, is satisfied that the plaintiff was
prevented by any cause of an exceptional nature for
correcting the valuation or supplying the requisite stamp-
paper, as the case may be, within the time fixed by the
Court and that refusal to extend such time would cause
great injustice to the plaintiff."
9. A perusal of Order VII Rule 11 C.P.C. makes it
clear that the relevant facts which need to be looked into
for deciding an application thereunder are the averments
in the plaint. The trial court can exercise the power
under Order VII Rule 11 C.P.C. at any stage of the suit-
before registering the plaint or after issuing summons to
the defendant at any time before the conclusion of the
trial. For the purposes of deciding an application under
clauses (a) and (d) of Rule 11 of Order VII C.P.C. the
averments in the plaint are germane; the pleas taken by
the defendant in the written statement would be wholly
irrelevant at that stage, therefore, a direction to file the
::: Downloaded on - 30/09/2026 15:43:06 :::CIS
27 2026:HHC:42167
written statement without deciding the application
under Order VII Rule 11 C.P.C. cannot but be procedural
High Court of H.P.
irregularity touching the exercise of jurisdiction by the
trial court. The order, therefore, suffers from non-
exercising of the jurisdiction vested in the court as well as
procedural irregularity. The High Court, however, did not
advert to these aspects.”
27. Similar view has also been taken by the Hon’ble
Supreme Court, in a case titled as, ‘Mayar (H.K.) Ltd. &
others versus Owners and Parties, Vessel M.V. Fortune
& others’, reported in AIR 2006 SC 1828. Relevant
paragraph-11 of the judgment is reproduced as under.
“11. From the aforesaid, it is apparent that the plaint
cannot be rejected on the basis of the allegations made by
the defendant in his written statement or in an
application for rejection of the plaint. The Court has to
read the entire plaint as a whole to find out whether it
discloses a cause of action and if it does, then the plaint
cannot be rejected by the Court exercising the powers
under Order VII Rule 11 of the Code. Essentially, whether
the plaint discloses a cause of action, is a question of fact
which has to be gathered on the basis of the averments
made in the plaint in its entirety taking those averments
to be correct. A cause of action is a bundle of facts which
are required to be proved for obtaining relief and for the
said purpose, the material facts are required to be stated
but not the evidence except in certain cases where the
pleadings relied on are in regard to misrepresentation,
fraud, wilful default, undue influence or of the same
::: Downloaded on - 30/09/2026 15:43:06 :::CIS
28 2026:HHC:42167
nature. So long as the plaint discloses some cause of
action which requires determination by the court, mere
High Court of H.P.
fact that in the opinion of the Judge the plaintiff may not
succeed cannot be a ground for rejection of the plaint. In
the present case, the averments made in the plaint, as
has been noticed by us, do disclose the cause of action
and, therefore, the High Court has rightly said that the
powers under Order VII Rule 11 of the Code cannot be
exercised for rejection of the suit filed by the plaintiff-
appellants.”
28. The learned senior counsel for the
respondents/plaintiffs have also relied upon the decision
of Hon’ble Supreme Court in ‘Sopan Sukhdeo Sable and
others versus Assistant Charity Commissioner and
others, reported in AIR 2004 SC 1801. Relevant
paragraph 15 of the judgment is reproduced as under:
“15. There cannot be any compartmentalization,
dissection, segregation and inversions of the language of
various paragraphs in the plaint. If such a course is
adopted it would run counter to the cardinal canon of
interpretation according to which a pleading has to be
read as a whole to ascertain its true import. It is not
permissible to cull out a sentence or a passage and to
read it out of the context in isolation. Although it is the
substance and not merely the form that has to be looked
into, the pleading has to be construed as it stands
without addition or subtraction or words or change of its
apparent grammatical sense. The intention of the party
concerned is to be gathered primarily from the tenor and
terms of his pleadings taken as a whole. At the same time
::: Downloaded on - 30/09/2026 15:43:06 :::CIS
29 2026:HHC:42167
it should be borne in mind that no pedantic approach
should be adopted to defeat justice on hair- splitting
High Court of H.P.
technicalities.”
29. The above case law, in no way helps the case of
the plaintiffs, as no one can deny the principles, which
have been enumerated by the Hon’ble Supreme Court in
the aforesaid decisions, however, in this case, defendant
No. 1 has sought the rejection of the plaint, on account
of the fact that the plaintiffs have no cause of action to
file the suit, as the proper course for them is to file the
suit for recovery, on account of non-payment of sale
consideration and they have no cause of action to get the
sale deed cancelled.
30. In this case, the copy of the sale deed has also
been annexed with the petition, in which, there is a clear
recital that the plaintiffs have received the full and final
agreed sale consideration and handed over the actual
possession of the suit land to defendant No.1, in para-
11 of the sale deed. The plaintiffs cannot blow hot and
cold in the same breath, as the main ground of attack is
non-payment of the sale consideration, by defendant
No. 1. Moreover, the plaint is totally silent about the fate
::: Downloaded on - 30/09/2026 15:43:06 :::CIS
30 2026:HHC:42167
of the cheque, issued by defendant No. 1 for a sum
High Court of H.P.
rupees 56,00,000/-, which has been accepted by the
plaintiffs, as sale consideration.
31. Considering all these facts, defendant No.1 is
able to make out a case in her favour. Consequently,
impugned order, passed by learned trial Court, is set
aside and the application, under Order 7 Rule 11 of the
CPC is allowed, on account of the fact that the plaintiff
has no cause of action to file the present suit.
Consequently, the plaint is rejected.
32. With these observations, the present petition is
allowed, so also the pending application(s), if any.
(Virender Singh)
30.9.2026 Judge
Kalpana)
(
::: Downloaded on - 30/09/2026 15:43:06 :::CIS