Smt Chandrakanta vs State of U.P.
- Court
- Allahabad High Court
A.F.R.
HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT ALLAHABAD
CRIMINAL MISC. BAIL APPLICATION No. - 30325 of 2026
Smt Chandrakanta
.....Applicant(s)
Versus
State of U.P.
.....Opposite Party(s)
Counsel for Applicant(s) : Himanshu Mishra
Counsel for Opposite Party(s) : Ashish Kumar Srivastava, G.A.,
Virendra Kumar Srivastava
Court No. - 66
HON'BLE ARUN KUMAR SINGH DESHWAL, J.
1. Heard Sri Himanshu Mishra, learned counsel for the applicant, Sri
Virendra Kumar Srivastava, learned counsel for the first informant and Sri
D.P.S. Chauhan, learned A.G.A. for the State and perused the record.
2. Instant bail application has been filed with a prayer to release the
applicant on bail during the trial in Case Crime No.17 of 2026, under
Sections 85, 80(2), 352, 115(2), 351(3) B.N.S and Section 3/4 Dowry
Prohibition Act, Police Station- Basauni, District-Agra.
3. In pursuance of the order dated 31st August, 2026, I.O. of this case Sri
Anil Kumar, Assistant Commissioner of Police, Agra is present. He apprised
to the Court that he has not prepared audio and video during recording the
statement of first informant under Section 180 BNSS. When the Court
confronted him regarding DGP's Circular No.24 of 2025 dated 21.07.2025
and Circular No.39 of 2026 dated 04.08.2026 which makes it clear that
while recording the statement of witnesses under Section 180 BNSS, audio-
video may also be prepared, he could not reply the same except to offer
unconditional apology.
4. This Court came across in number of cases, wherein taking advantage of
option given by the DGP in his circulars to prepare the audio-video during
recording the statement of the witnesses under Section 180 BNSS, I.Os. have
not prepared the audio-video. In many cases the I.Os. do not prepare the
audio and video just to save themselves from the allegation that the
statements of the witnesses under Section 180 BNSS are written by I.Os.
BAIL No. 30325 of 2026
2
themselves by copying the FIR itself.
5. As per proviso of Section 180(3) BNSS and as per Rule 20(1) of BNSS
Rules, 2024, the investigating officer may also record the statement of
witnesses through audio-video electronic communication.
6. Therefore, DGP had issued directions to prepare audio-video at different
stages of investigation. As per the direction of DGP through Circular No.24
of 2025 dated 21.07.2025 preparation of audio-video of statement of rape
victim has made compulsory but preparation of audio-video of the statement
under Section 180 BNSS in other cases is made optional which has been
widely misused by several Investigating Officers.
7. A DGP's Circular 2024 was also issued regarding the procedure of
investigation which includes mandatorily asking the question in case FIR is
lodged after delay but same is not followed by the several Investigating
Officer in U.P.
8. Section 176 of BNSS, 2023 provides the procedure for investigation
which includes; to immediately proceed to spot, to investigate the fact and
circumstances and if necessary to take measure for discovery and arrest of
the offender immediately after receiving the information about the
cognizable offence.
9. Section 179 of BNSS provides that, during investigation if the police
officer came to know any person appears to be acquainted with fact and
circumstance then the police officer by order require the
in writing
attendance of that person before himself except the male below 15 years or
above 60 years or women or mentally or physically disabled person or a
person with acute illness should examine at the place of their residence.
10. Section 180 of BNSS further provides that to examination of persons
who appear before the police station or police officer reached at the place of
their residence and also bound to answer truly all questions.
11. The procedure of investigation has also been mentioned in Regulation
106 to 128 of U.P. Police Regulations. The para 107 of the Regulation
provides that an Investigating Officer is not to be regarded as mere clerk for
recording the statements. He is duty bond to observe and to infer in any
cases by using his expert observations of the scene of the offence and
general circumstances to check the evidence of witnesses. It is further
BAIL No. 30325 of 2026
3
mentioned that it is duty of Investigating Officer to find out the truth not
merely to obtain conviction and he must not prematurely commit himself to
any view of the facts for or against any person. Investigating Officer must
always give opportunity to the accused persons to produce defence evidence
before him and he must consider carefully, if produced. Para 107 of U.P.
Police Regulations is being quoted as under;
"107. Duties of an Investigating Officer.- An investigating officer is not to regard
himself as a mere clerk for the recording of statements. It is his duty to observe and to
infer. In every case he must use his own expert observations of the scene of the offence
and of the general circumstances to check the evidence of witnesses, and in cases in
which the culprits are unknown to determine the direction in which he shall look for
them. He must study the methods of local offenders who are known to the police with a
view to recognizing their handiwork, and he must be on his guard against accepting
the suspicions of witness and complainants when they conflict with obvious inferences
from facts. He must remember that it is his duty to find out the truth and not merely to
obtain convictions. He must not prematurely commit himself to any view of the facts
for or against any person and though he need not go out of his way to hunt up
evidence for the defence in a case in which he has satisfactory grounds for believing
that an accused person is guilty, he must always give accused persons an opportunity
of producing defence evidence before him, and must consider such evidence carefully
if produced. Burglary investigations should be conducted in accordance with the
special orders on the subject."
12. Similarly, in paragraph 108 of U.P. Police Regulations, it has been
mentioned that on beginning the investigation, Investigating Officers are
immediately inspect the scene of offence and question the complainant or
any other persons, who may be able to throw lights on the circumstances.
Para 108 of Regulations is being quoted as follows;
"108. Steps for Investigating Officer to investigate the case.- The first step of the
investigating officer should be to note in the case diary prescribed by Section 172 of
the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 (2 of 1974) the time and place at which he has
received the information on which he acts and to make in the diary a copy of the first
information report. When beginning his investigation he must note in the diary the
time and place at which he begins. He should then inspect the scene of the alleged
offence and question the complainant and any other persons who may be able to
throw light on the circumstances. At an early stage of the investigation he should
consult the village crime note-book to learn of any matter recorded there which may
have a bearing on the case."
13. Similarly Para 109 of the Regulations further prescribes, if there is
BAIL No. 30325 of 2026
4
variation in the statement of complainant from the first information report
that should be mentioned in the case diary by recording the supplementary
statement of the complainant, if any.
14. Procedure of Test Identification Parade as well as procedure for
identification of stolen property recovered from the suspect allegedly stolen
the property are mentioned in paras 116 and 117 of the Regulation.
"116. Identification parade of suspects.- In all cases in which there is any likelihood
that suspects will at any stage have to be paraded for identification by witness, the
investigating officer must take steps from the very beginning of his investigation to
ensure that witnesses are given no opportunity of seeing the suspects before
identification proceedings are held. Such proceedings should whenever possible, be
postponed until they can be held in the jail under the provisions of the Manual of
Government Orders and Paragraph 31 of these regulations, for the due observance of
which, as far as the police are concerned, the Public Prosecutor will then be
responsible. When identification proceedings cannot be held in the jails, own to there
being no sufficient evidence on which the suspects can be arrested for any other
reason, the instructions referred to above must be followed by the investigating officer
as far as they can be made applicable. In such cases the proceedings should take
place before a Magistrate, as they would if they were held in the jails or if no
magistrate is available before two respectable and impartial persons who should be
asked to satisfy themselves that the proceedings are fair both to witnesses and to
accused. In any case of importance, when no Magistrate is available to conduct
identification proceedings not held in the jails, a gazetted police officer should
arrange to attend.
117. Identification of articles of property recovered from suspects:- In important cases
the practice of having articles of property, recovered from suspects and suspected to
be stolen, mixed up with other articles of a similar nature when the property is shown
to complainants for identification may often be followed with advantage. In such cases
precautions should be taken similar to those laid down for observance in the case of
identification parades of accused persons, the person before whom the identification
is held must be above suspicion, and it will be essential to prove that neither the
property suspected, nor that with which it has been mixed could have been seen by the
witnesses beforehand."
15. From the above quoted provision, it is clear that the Police Officer
should not mechanically proceed to record the statement of witnesses at the
instance of complainant but he should try to extract the truth by recording
the statement of independent witnesses.
16. The purpose of investigation is to collect the material not to create the
BAIL No. 30325 of 2026
5
materiel regarding the offence in question and in several cases, the I.Os.
themselves suggested the incriminating material to the first informant or
witnesses and same was seriously deprecated by this Court and direction was
issued to the DGP in
Criminal Misc. Bail Application No. 24645 of 2026
. In
(Aatish @ Krishnkant vs State of U.P.) vide order dated 06.08.2026
pursuance of the direction of this Court, the DGP has also issued circular
directing the all the Police of U.P. not to suggest incriminating material to
the witness except asking question which is clarificatory in nature.
17. The Hon'ble Apex Court in the case of State of Uttar Pradesh vs
Bhagwant Kishore Joshi; 1913 SCC OnLine SC 91 observed about
investigation and its purpose. The relevant extract of para 17 of the
is being quoted as follows;
Bhagwant Kishore Joshi (supra)
"17. What is investigation is not defined in the Code of Criminal Procedure; but in
H.N Rishbud and Inder Singh v. State of Delhi this Court has described the procedure
for investigation as follows:
"Thus, under the Code investigation consists generally of the following steps; (1)
Proceeding to the spot,(2) Ascertainment of the facts and circumstances of the
case,(3) Discovery and arrest of the suspected offender, (4)Collection of evidence
relating to the commission of the offence which may consist of (a) the examination of
various persons (including the accused) and the reduction of their statements into
writing, if the officer thinks fit, (b) the search of places or seizure of things considered
necessary for the investigation and to be produced at the trial, and (5) formation of
the opinion as to whether on the material collected there is a case to place the
accused before a Magistrate for trial and if so taking the necessary steps for the same
by the filing of a charge sheet under S. 173."
Investigation, in substance, means collection of evidence relating to the commission of
the offence. The Investigating Officer is, for this purpose, entitled to question persons
who, in his opinion, are able to throw light on the offence which has been committed
and is likewise entitled to question the suspect and is entitled to reduce the statements
of persons questioned by him to writing. He is also entitled to search the place of the
offence and to search other places with the object of seizing articles connected with
the offence. No doubt, for this purpose he has to proceed to the spot where the offence
was committed and do various other things. But the main object of investigation being
to bring home the offence to the offender the essential part of the duties of an
Investigating Officer in this connection is, apart from arresting the offender, to collect
all material necessary for establishing the accusation against the offender. Merely
making some preliminary enquiries upon receipt of information from an anonymous
source or a source of doubtful reliability for checking up the correctness of the
information does not amount to collection of evidence and so cannot be regarded as
BAIL No. 30325 of 2026
6
investigation. In the absence of any prohibition in the Code, express or implied, I am
of opinion that it is open to a Police Officer to make preliminary enquiries before
registering an offence and making a full scale investigation into it.
18. The Hon'ble Apex Court in the case of Vinay Tyagi vs Irshad Ali alia
Deepak and others reported in (2013) 5 SCC 762 further observed that the
investigation must be fair and proper to bring out the truth of case before the
court of competent jurisdiction. The para 48 of the
Vinay Tyagi (supra)
case is being quoted as follows;
"48. What ultimately is the aim or significance of the expression "fair and proper
investigation" in criminal jurisprudence? It has a twin purpose: Firstly, the
investigation must be unbiased, honest, just and in accordance with law; secondly, the
entire emphasis on a fair investigation has to be to bring out the truth of the case
before the court of competent jurisdiction. Once these twin paradigms of fair
investigation are satisfied, there will be the least requirement for the court of law to
interfere with the investigation, much less quash the same, or transfer it to another
agency. Bringing out the truth by fair and investigative means in accordance with law
would essentially repel the very basis of an unfair, tainted investigation or cases of
false implication. Thus, it is inevitable for a court of law to pass a specific order as to
the fate of the investigation, which in its opinion is unfair, tainted and in violation of
the settled principles of investigative canons."
19. From the above quoted provision as well as observation of the Hon'ble
Apex Court, it is clear the basic purpose of investigation is to collect the
evidence to bring out the truth of the case and not to collect the evidence
with the prejudice against any person to hold him guilty. Therefore, if the
accused want to produce any evidence before the Investigating Officer to
prove his innocence the same must also be considered carefully by the
investigating officer. . Now a day, it has become a tendency in certain type
of cases like demand of dowry, dowry death, offence under POCSO Act and
SC/ST Act to falsely implicate, even to those persons who are not involved
therein. Therefore, it is the duty of investigating officer to collect the
evidence fairly to bring out the real culprit before the court of competent
jurisdiction and initiation of criminal proceeding itself should not be allowed
to be a mode to harass the innocence persons on the part of the complainant.
Taking cue from above analysis, this Court issues following directions
which has to be followed by the Investigating Officer during investigation;
i. Immediately after receiving information about the cognizable offence,
Investigating Officer should rush to the place of incident and record the
BAIL No. 30325 of 2026
7
statement of first informant and other witnesses as expeditiously as possible
without any delay and audio-video of statement should also be prepared
preferably with E-Sakshya App and same should be available to the
concerned court on its demand.
ii. During investigation, the Investigating Officer not only record the
statement of complainant, victim and other persons associates to him but
should also try to record the statement of independent witnesses to extract
the truth regarding incident in question.
iii. In case of rape and sexual assault, the statement of victim should be
recorded at her place of residence or as per her convenience by the women
police officer (Second proviso of Section 180(3) of BNSS). In such cases,
the victim should be sent to the registered practitioner for her medical
examination with her consent within 24 hours from the time of receiving
information relating to the commission of such offence (Section 184(1)
BNSS, 2023)
iii. Where the offence is punishable with imprisonment for 10 years or
more, then the police officer should produce the witnesses before the
concerned Magistrate to record his statement and in case of offence of rape
or sexual assault, the victim should be produced before the Magistrate to
record her statement as soon as commission of offence is brought to notice
to the police. In such cases, there should not be unnecessary delay which
may some time result in tutoring the victim by her family members. (Section
183(6) of BNSS, 2023).
iv. Where there is allegation of preparing of obscene video in case of sexual
assault, in such cases, the I.O. should collect the mobile phone of the
accused and if require, the same should be sent to FSL to retrieve data. If
there is allegation of making viral of obscene video of the victim, in such
cases assistance of Cyber Cell and FSL should also be taken.
v. Where location of accused or any other persons as well as conversation
with another person is relevant, in that cases CDR of mobile phone of that
person should also be collected to extract the truth.
vi. Where the victim does not know the accused but only recognize him, in
those cases, test identification parade must be conducted as per the
procedure mentioned in para 116 of U.P. Police Regulation.
BAIL No. 30325 of 2026
8
vii. Similarly when identification of recovered property from the suspect
allegedly stolen, is required then in such cases identification of article of
property should be conducted as per the procedure mentioned in para 117 of
U.P. Police Regulation i.e mixing the recovered property with other articles
of similar nature before conducting the identification of property.
20. Therefore, this Court directs the DGP, U.P. to consider, making it
mandatory to prepare audio-video of statements recorded under Section 180
BNSS, so as to make the investigation more transparent and fair and same
would also be helpful to the Court while deciding the bail application and
other judicial proceedings. The, Director General of Police is further directed
to apprise the above guidelines to all the Investigating Officers so that real
culprit may be brought to the justice and innocence person may not be
subject to harassment due to faulty investigation.
21. Now coming to the merit of this case, learned counsel for the applicant
submitted that the applicant is mother-in-law of the deceased, who
committed suicide by hanging herself after a petty dispute over household
issues. It is further submitted that the story of first informant is different in
FIR from his statement recorded under Section 180 BNSS. The applicant has
been falsely implicated merely being mother-in-law of the deceased, though
there is no sufficient material against her to show that she harassed the
deceased for non- fulfillment of demand of dowry prior to death. The
applicant has been falsely implicated by making general and vague
allegations along with other family members. It is further submitted that for
invoking presumption of dowry death in case of death under unnatural
circumstances within 7 years of marriage, there must be sufficient material
to show that the deceased was subjected to cruelty soon before the death, but
there is no such material. It is lastly submitted that the applicant has no
criminal history and being a lady, she is entitled to be released on bail in
view of Section 480 BNSS. She is languishing in jail since 18.05.2026. In
case, she is granted bail, she will not misuse the liberty of bail and would
cooperate in the trial proceedings.
22. On the other hand, learned counsel for the first informant as well as
learned A.G.A. for the State opposed the prayer for bail but could not
dispute the aforesaid facts.
23. Considering the entire facts and circumstances of the case, submissions
BAIL No. 30325 of 2026
9
of learned counsel for the parties and taking into account the fact that the
applicant is lady (mother-in-law) and keeping in view the nature of offence,
evidence, complicity of accused and taking into account overcrowded jails
and heavy pendency of criminal cases before the trial courts as well as
considering the mandate of the judgement of the Apex Court in the case of
reported in
Kapil Wadhawan vs Central Bureau of Investigation 2025
SCC Online SC 3038 as well as guideline of this Court in the case of Maya
Tiwari vs State of U.P. reported in 2024 SCC Online All 6765 regarding
grant of bail and without expressing any opinion on the merits of the case, I
am of the opinion that the applicant is entitled to be enlarged on bail.
Accordingly, the present application is allowed.
24. Let the applicant- involved in the aforementioned
Smt. Chandrakanta
crime be released on bail, on her furnishing a personal bond and two sureties
each in the like amount, to the satisfaction of the court concerned, with the
following conditions:-
i. The applicant shall not directly or indirectly make any inducement, threat
or promise to any person acquainted with the facts of the case so as to
dissuade her from disclosing such facts to the Court or to any police officer
or tamper with the evidence.
ii. The applicant shall cooperate in the trial/investigation sincerely without
seeking any adjournment.
iii. The applicant shall not indulge in any criminal activity or commission of
any crime after being released on bail.
iv. The applicant shall attend in accordance with the conditions of the bond
executed by him.
25. In case of breach of any of the above conditions, it shall be a ground for
cancellation of bail.
26. Identity, status and residence proof of the applicant and sureties be
verified by the court concerned before the bonds are accepted.
27. Verification of mobile number as well as Aadhar Card of the applicant
and sureties should also be conducted by the court concerned.
28. It is made clear that the applicant shall be released on the basis of
BAIL No. 30325 of 2026
10
downloaded copy of this order from the official website of High Court
Allahabad and verified by the concerned counsel with the undertaking that
the certified copy will be filed within 15 days.
29. It is directed that the trial court shall send the release order to the
concerned jail through Bail Order Management System (BOMS) to ensure
early release of the applicant.
30. Office is directed to send a copy of this order to the applicant through
via e-mail or e-prison portal and Trial Court via
Agra Jail Superintendent
e-mode within 24 hours in compliance of the order of the Apex Court in the
case of Policy Strategy for Grant of Bail, In Re: Suo Motu Writ Petition
(Crl.) No. 4 of 2021 decided on 31.01.2023 reported in (2024) 10 SCC 685
as well as in the case of Pila Pahan @ Peela Pahan and others vs State of
Jharkhand and another, in Writ Petition (Criminal) No.169 of 2025
decided on .
29.05.2026
31. Application, if any, stands disposed of.
32. is directed to send a copy of this order to the
Registrar (Compliance)
Director General of Police, U.P. for compliance of paragraph no.20 of this
order.
September 15, 2026
A.Kr.
(Arun Kumar Singh Deshwal,J.)
Digitally signed by :-
AJAY KUMAR
High Court of Judicature at Allahabad