JANMESH KUMAR vs COMMISSIONER OF POLICE

Court
Central Administrative Tribunal

1
Item No.7 (C-V)
O.A. No.4220/2026

Central Administrative Tribunal
Principal Bench, New Delhi

OA No.4220/2026
MA No.5414/2026

th
This, the 27 day of October, 2026

Hon’ble Dr. Chhabilendra Roul, Member (A)
Hon’ble Mr. Rajveer Singh Verma, Member (J)


1. JANMESH KUMAR,
SON OF SHRI MAHESH CHANDRA,
AGED ABOUT 44 YEARS, GROUP-C,
DESIGNATION-HEAD CONSTABLE (DRIVER),
PIS NO.28120124, BELT NO.619/CRIME,
PRESENTLY POSTED AT : MT, CRIME BRANCH,
DELHI POLIDCE AND ATTACHED WITH ACP/SCRB,
KAMLA MARKET, DELHI,
RESIDENT OF-QUARTER NO.601,
TH
6 FLOOR, TYPE-2,
PS GTB ENCLAVE, NAND NAGRI, NORTH-EAST
DELHI, DELHI-110093.


2. VIKASH KUMAR,
SON OF SHRI HARBIR SINGH TANWAR,
AGED ABOUT 41 YEARS, GROUP-C,
DESIGNATION-HEAD CONSTABLE (DRIVER),
PIS NO.28120188, BELT NO.614/CRIME,
PRESENTLY POSTED : MT, CRIME BRANCH,
DELHI POLICE,
RESIDENT OF VILLAGE-SUNEHRA,
DISTRICT – BAGHPAT, UTTAR PRADESH-250101.
...APPLICANTS
(By Advocate : Shri Bajrang Vats)

VERSUS

1. THE COMMISSIONER OF POLICE,
DELHI POLICE, POLICE HEADQUARTERS,
JAI SINGH ROAD, NEW DELHI-110001

2. THE DEPUTY COMMISSIONER OF POLICE,
CRIME BRANCH, DELHI POLICE,
POLICE HEADQUARTERS,
JAI SINGH ROAD, NEW DELHI-110001.
Digitally signed by
RACHNA KAPOOR
RACHNA KAPOOR
…RESPONDENTS
(By Advocate : Shri Jatin Parashar )

2
Item No.7 (C-V)
O.A. No.4220/2026
O R D E R (ORAL)

By Hon’ble Mr. Rajveer Singh Verma, Member (J) :-
MA No.5414/2026
This Application has been filed by the applicants
seeking permission of this Tribunal to file a single OA.
2. For the reasons mentioned therein, the MA is
allowed.
OA No.4220/2026
3. In the present Original Application, filed under
Section 19 of the Administrative Tribunals Act, 1985,
the applicants have prayed for the following relief(s):
“ I) Allow the present Original Application and
Quash/set aside the Impugned Remarks
Dated 29.09.2026 on the Representation
Dated 22.09.2026 (Annexure-1); and

II) issue directions to the respondents to
treat 01.05.2010 as deemed/notional date of
appointment of the applicants for all
consequential service benefits viz. MACP
from 01.05.2020, NPS contribution for
notional service period etc. counting service
from deemed date of appointment i.e.
01.05.2010; and

III) issue directions to the respondents for
grant of MACP to the applicants from
01.05.2020 after counting notional service
w.e.f. 01.05.2010 towards 10 years’ service
requirement; and
Digitally signed by
RACHNA KAPOOR
RACHNA KAPOOR
IV) Issue directions to the respondents for
grant of NPS contribution for notional service

3
Item No.7 (C-V)
O.A. No.4220/2026
period to the applicants w.e.f. 01.05.2010
with statutory compound interest at GPF
rate of interest on delayed payment &
difference in NPS contribution after pay re-
fixation with statutory compound interest at
GPF rate of interest on delayed payment; and
V) Issue directions to the respondents for
release of consequential arrears/monetary
benefits of NPS & MACP fixation to the
applicants from the date of actual joining of
service with 12% interest per annum; and
VI) Pass such other order(s)/direction(s) as
deem necessary in the interest of justice.‖

4. The brief facts of the case are that the applicants
applied under the advertisement issued by the Delhi
Police in 2009 for recruitment of temporary Constable
(Driver) Male - 2009. However, owing solely to
administrative delays, the applicants could not join
training with the first batch on 01.05.2010, and were
allowed to join only on 02.01.2012. The respondents
published an Inter-Se Seniority List on 12.01.2018,
assigning seniority to the applicants based on their
merit position in the 2009 recruitment examination,
w.e.f. 01.05.2010, at par with their actual
batchmates. Despite assigning retrospective seniority,
the respondents denied them notional pay fixation,
Digitally signed by
RACHNA KAPOOR
RACHNA KAPOOR
st
increments, and 1 MACP benefits. The
representation of the applicant No.1 dated 22.09.2026
seeking pay refixation at par with batchmates was

4
Item No.7 (C-V)
O.A. No.4220/2026
returned in original by the respondents vide impugned
remarks dated 29.09.2026 on the ground that ― Please
provide copy of Judgment of OA wherein your name is
mentioned so that your case may be further
processed.” Aggrieved by this creation of an
anomaly—wherein service is counted from 2010 for
seniority but pay fixation is granted only from the
actual date of joining — the applicants have filed the
present OA.
5. At the outset, learned counsel for the applicants
submitted that similar matters have been allowed by
this Bench of the Tribunal including OA
No.1329/2025 decided by order dated 21.11.2025.
The said OA has been allowed in terms of the earlier
OA No.3371/2018 decided by this Tribunal on
15.04.2023, after relying upon the ratio decided by
the Hon’ble High Court in WP(C) No.13987/2009 in
the matter of Director of Education and Anr. Vs.
Smt. Krishna Kumari. He submitted that since the
present OA is similar to the aforesaid OAs, therefore,
it can be disposed of in terms of O.A. No.1329/2025.
Digitally signed by
RACHNA KAPOOR
RACHNA KAPOOR
For the sake of better appreciation, the relevant
portion of the order of this Tribunal in O.A.

5
Item No.7 (C-V)
O.A. No.4220/2026
No.1329/2025 dated 21.11.2025 is reproduced herein
below :-
―15. It is an admitted fact that the
applicant applied for the post of Constable
(Driver) in Delhi Police in the year 2009
and the batch-mates of the applicants were
allowed to join the said post on 01.05.2010
to the exclusion of the applicant. However,
in the year 2012, he was found eligible to
be appointed and he joined his duties on
02.01.2012. The seniority of the applicant
has been fixed as per his merit along with
his batch-mates but respondents refused
to accord the benefit of notional fixation of
pay to the applicant viz-a-viz his batch-
mates.
16. The Hon’ble High Court of Delhi vide
its judgment dated 21.12.2009 passed in
WP(C) No.13987/2009 in the matter of
Director of Education and Anr. Vs. Smt.
Krishna Kumari has held as under :-
―4. Once the respondent had been
granted notional seniority from 1984, i.e.
she is being treated as being in service
from 1984 onwards, the said fiction has to
be given its full effect, including for
purposes of pay fixation. Therefore, the pay
of the respondent ought to have been fixed
as if she had joined in the year 1984 and
on the basis that she had earned the
increments, and benefitted from wage
revision, which may have taken place in
the meantime. She would also be entitled
to benefits under the Assured Progression
Scheme.‖
17. The facts and issues involved in the
present OA are squarely covered by the
order dated 15.04.2023 passed by this
Tribunal in OA No.3318/2018 and ratio
decided by the Hon’ble High Court of Delhi
in the matter of Smt. Krishna Kumari
(supra). Thus, the present OA deserves to
be allowed.
Digitally signed by
RACHNA KAPOOR
RACHNA KAPOOR

6
Item No.7 (C-V)
O.A. No.4220/2026
18. In view of the above, we allow the
instant OA with the following directions :-
(i) Impugned remarks dated 27.02.2025
(Annexure-A/1) passed on the
representation of the applicant dated
04.11.2025, is quashed and set aside.
(ii) The Impugned Order dated
20.09.2024, being not applicable to the
applicant, is quashed and set aside.
(iii) Pay and allowances of applicant shall
be re-fixed at par his batch-mates, strictly
on notional basis.
(iv) After such fixation, the applicant
shall be entitled to all the consequential
benefits including arrears/monetary
benefits which, however, shall be
calculated with respect to his entitlement
for actual benefits with effect from the date
of his joining service at par his
batchmates/juniors and beneficiaries of
office order dated 21.08.2023 and office
order dated 23.09.2024 issued by the
respondents.
(v) The applicant shall be entitled for
grant of MACP w.e.f. 01.05.2020 instead of
01.02.2022 after counting notional service
towards 10 years’ service requirement.
(vi) The respondents shall grant NPS
contribution for notional service period and
difference in NPS contribution after pay re-
fixation shall be granted in favour of the
applicant.
(vii) Applicant shall not be entitled to
claim any interest on the payment of
arrears, if any.
(viii) The above directions shall be
complied with within a period of 90 days
from the date of receipt of a certified copy
of this order.
Digitally signed by
RACHNA KAPOOR
RACHNA KAPOOR

7
Item No.7 (C-V)
O.A. No.4220/2026
Pending MAs, if any, shall stand
disposed of.
There shall be no order as to costs.‖

6. Learned counsel appeared on behalf of the
respondents after receipt of advance notice and he
does not dispute the fact that the present OA is
identical to O.A. No.1329/2025.

7. It is an admitted fact that the present applicants
had participated in the same selection process as the
applicant in OA No.1329/2025 titled Anil Kumar
(supra) and the issue inter alia involved in the present
case is identical to the case of Anil Kumar (supra).

8. In view of the above, the present OA is disposed
of in terms of O.A. No. 1329/2025 decided on
21.11.2025 titled Anil Kumar Vs. Commissioner of
Police and Anr. The respondents shall take the
decision accordingly.

9. All pending MAs, if any, shall also stand
disposed of.
There shall be no order as to costs



Digitally signed by
RACHNA KAPOOR
RACHNA KAPOOR

(Rajveer Singh Verma) (Dr.Chhabilendra Roul)
Member (J) Member (A)

‘rk’