Manoj Mandal vs The State Of Bihar
- Court
- Patna High Court
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT PATNA
CRIMINAL APPEAL (DB) No.1319 of 2018
CNR No. BRHC010613322018
Arising Out of PS. Case No.-37 Year-1995 Thana- BARHARA KOTHI District- Purnia
======================================================
Manoj Mandal S/o late Pradip Mandal Resident of Village- Gulelavitta, P.S.
Barhara, District- Purnea.
... ... Appellant/s
Versus
The State of Bihar
... ... Respondent/s
======================================================
with
CRIMINAL APPEAL (DB) No. 1372 of 2018
CNR No. BRHC010613322018
Arising Out of PS. Case No.-37 Year-1995 Thana- BARHARA KOTHI District- Purnia
======================================================
Ravindra Mandal Son of Radha Mandal, R/o Village-Gulelavitta, P.S.-
Barhara, District-Purnea.
... ... Appellant/s
Versus
The State of Bihar
... ... Respondent/s
======================================================
with
CRIMINAL APPEAL (DB) No. 1387 of 2018
CNR No. BRHC010613322018
Arising Out of PS. Case No.-37 Year-1995 Thana- BARHARA KOTHI District- Purnia
======================================================
Kesho Mandal Son of Saryug Mandal, Resident of Village Gulela Bhitha,
Police Station Barhara, District- Purnea.
... ... Appellant/s
Versus
The State of Bihar
... ... Respondent/s
======================================================
Appearance :
(In CRIMINAL APPEAL (DB) No. 1319 of 2018)
For the Appellant/s : Mr. Ranjan Kumar Dubey, Advocate
For the Respondent/s : Mr. Mayanand Jha, A.P.P.
(In CRIMINAL APPEAL (DB) No. 1372 of 2018)
For the Appellant/s : Dr. Bidhu Ranjan, Advocate
For the Respondent/s : Mr. Shivesh Chandra Mishra, A.P.P.
(In CRIMINAL APPEAL (DB) No. 1387 of 2018)
For the Appellant/s : Mr. Viveka Nandsingh, Advocate
Patna High Court CR. APP (DB) No.1319 of 2018 dt.20-11-2026
2/15
For the Respondent/s : Mr. Ashwani Kumar Sinha, A.P.P.
======================================================
CORAM: HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE PRABHAT KUMAR SINGH
and
HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE RANA VIKRAM SINGH
C.A.V. JUDGMENT
(Per: HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE PRABHAT KUMAR SINGH)
Date : 20-11-2026
All the above mentioned appeals arise out of same
Barhara Kothi P. S. Case No. 37 of 1995 and are being heard
and disposed of by a common judgment.
2. Heard learned counsel appearing for the appellants
and learned Additional Public Prosecutors appearing for the
State.
3. These appeals have been filed challenging the
judgment of conviction dated 24.09.2018 and order of sentence
dated 26.09.2018 passed by the learned Fast Track Court No. 1,
Purnea in Sessions Trial No. 244 of 1997/T.R. No. 473/2018
arising out of Barhara Kothi P. S. Case No. 37 of 1995 whereby
and whereunder these appellants have been convicted under
Section 302/34 of the Indian Penal Code and have been
sentenced to undergo rigorous imprisonment for life with a fine
of Rs. 20,000/- each and in default of payment of fine, to
undergo further four months’ imprisonment.
4. The prosecution case, as disclosed in the fardbeyan
of informant Lakshman Mandal, is that on 25.03.1995, at
Patna High Court CR. APP (DB) No.1319 of 2018 dt.20-11-2026
3/15
approximately 8:00 P.M., the informant, his elder brother
Chulhai Mandal and deceased Giro Mandal were present near
their common courtyard at village Gulela Bhitha, P.S. Barhara,
District Purnea. The deceased was resting on a cot near the
Darwaja after watching television. A lantern was allegedly
burning at the place of occurrence. It is alleged that Pradeep
Mandal, Ravindra Mandal, Nawal Mandal, Kesho Mandal and
Manoj Mandal arrived and surrounded the deceased. Upon
Pradeep Mandal ordering the others to kill him, Kesho and
Nawal allegedly caught hold of the hands of the deceased, while
Ravindra Mandal fired at his back with a country-made pistol.
After the deceased fell down, Manoj Mandal allegedly assaulted
him with a dagger, inflicting injuries upon his body. On hearing
the gunshot, the informant and other family members rushed
towards the place of occurrence. The deceased allegedly
disclosed the names of his assailants before succumbing to his
injuries. The alleged motive behind the occurrence was a
longstanding land dispute between the parties concerning land
belonging to the Sonbarsa Adivasi community. It was further
alleged that the accused persons had conspired to eliminate the
deceased.
5. On the basis of the fardbeyan recorded on
Patna High Court CR. APP (DB) No.1319 of 2018 dt.20-11-2026
4/15
26.03.1995 at 1:45 A.M., Barhara P.S. Case No. 37 of 1995 was
registered under Sections 302/34 and 120-B IPC against eleven
named accused persons.
6. In this case, in order to bring home guilt of these
appellants, the prosecution has examined altogether eleven
witnesses. P.W. 1-Ishwar Mandal identified the carbon copy of
the inquest report, marked as Exhibit 1. He stated that he had
seen the dead body bearing gunshot and dagger injuries and
confirmed that the police had prepared the inquest report and
sent the body for postmortem. However, in cross-examination,
he stated that he had not seen any bullet at the place of
occurrence. P.W. 2-Bijendra Mandal (son of the deceased)
claimed to have witnessed the occurrence and stated that
Pradeep, Nawal, Kesho, Ravindra and Manoj had surrounded his
father. He specifically attributed the act of holding the deceased
to Nawal and Kesho and firing from a country-made pistol to
Ravindra Mandal. He also alleged that Manoj Mandal assaulted
his father with a dagger after he fell down and stated that his
father disclosed the names of the assailants before dying. P.W. 2
in his examination-in-chief stated that after being shot, his father
was crying on the ground and after the incident, he raised alarm
whereupon, Lakshman Mandal (informant), Chulhai Mandal
Patna High Court CR. APP (DB) No.1319 of 2018 dt.20-11-2026
5/15
(brother of the deceased), Baleshwar Mandal, Baijnath Mandal
and my mother Gauri Devi, mausi Sushila Devi and other
villagers came at the place of occurrence. P.W. 3-Ramesh
Murmu is an independent witness who reached the place after
hearing the sound of firing and saw the deceased injured and
several persons fleeing. He identified Ravindra, Kesho, Manoj
and Nawal among those fleeing and stated that he had seen the
bullet injury on the deceased. P.W. 4-Gauri Devi (wife of the
deceased) s tated that she was cooking when she heard the
gunshot and came towards the Darwaja and allegedly saw
Ravindra carrying a pistol. She attributed dagger blows to
Manoj Mandal and stated that Pradeep, Kesho and Nawal were
also present there. She supported the prosecution version
regarding the previous land dispute. In her cross-examination,
she disclosed that she came outside after hearing the gunshot
and found her husband fallen on the ground. P.W. 5-Chulhai
Mandal (brother of the deceased) supported the prosecution
version regarding the occurrence. He stated that at the time of
occurrence, I was at the Darwaja of Giro Mandal and by that
time, my brother was already shot and stabbed by the accused
persons. He corroborated the deceased having disclosed the
names of the assailants and identified Pradeep Mandal and
Patna High Court CR. APP (DB) No.1319 of 2018 dt.20-11-2026
6/15
Akhilesh Mandal in Court. P.W.6-Lakshman Mandal
(informant) fully supported the prosecution case as disclosed in
the fardbeyan . He attributed the firing to Ravindra Mandal and
dagger assault to Manoj Mandal. He stated that Kesho and
Nawal had caught hold of the deceased and identified Exhibits
1, 2 and 3, being the inquest report, fardbeyan and formal FIR
respectively. P.W. 7-Shambhu Kumar Mandal did not support
the prosecution case regarding the actual occurrence and stated
that he had only subsequently learnt about the murder. P.W. 8-
Sone Lal Tudu reached the place of occurrence after hearing an
alarm and saw the deceased lying injured and his wife weeping.
He did not hear the sound of firing. P.W. 9-Mahendra Mandal
also reached the place after hearing cries and saw the
bloodstained dead body. He did not hear firing or notice any
injury. P.W. 10-Nand Lal Mandal reached the place after
hearing cries and saw the deceased lying in a bloodstained
condition. He stated that the deceased was saying that the
miscreants had killed him and fled. He was declared hostile by
the prosecution and denied having named the accused persons
before the police. P.W. 11-Dr. Satyendra Prasad Singh was a
member of the medical board which conducted the postmortem
examination on 26.03.1995 along with Dr. P.C. Prasad and Dr.
Patna High Court CR. APP (DB) No.1319 of 2018 dt.20-11-2026
7/15
N.K. Sah. He proved the attested copy of the postmortem report,
marked Exhibit 4 with objection and supported the existence of
a fatal sharp-cutting injury extending up to the heart. His
evidence did not establish any definite firearm injury. The doctor
opined that death had occurred due to the injury caused by a
deep cutting instrument, resulting in haemorrhage and shock.
7. Defence also examined one witness,
D.W.1 Ganga Prasad Chouhan who identified Exhibit A. He
further stated that appellants were at their house at time of
occurrence.
8. Learned counsel for appellants submitted that
ocular evidence is wholly unreliable as it is contradicted by
medical evidence. The entire case against Ravindra Mandal is
that he fired with a country-made pistol at the left side back of
deceased. P.W.11, the doctor, found no firearm injury at all. He
stated that the injuries are only sharp-cutting. This is not a minor
discrepancy and it completely rules out the prosecution version
of firing. When the specific overt act attributed to an accused is
medically ruled out, his conviction cannot be sustained. Case
against Manoj Mandal is also doubtful as he is alleged to have
assaulted with dagger after deceased fell due to gun-shot but
P.W.1 did not see the assault and he reached after gunshot. P.W.2
Patna High Court CR. APP (DB) No.1319 of 2018 dt.20-11-2026
8/15
and P.W.6 are interested witnesses and their statements about
sequence - first firing, then dagger are inconsistent with medical
evidence which shows only sharp injuries and no gunshot. If
firing did not happen, the entire sequence as narrated collapses.
It is further submitted that allegation against Kesho Mandal is
that he caught hold of hands. This is based only on the
allegations made by P.W.2 and P.W.6, both interested and no
independent witness supports it. In dark, with only lantern light
which was never seized, identification of catching hold is
doubtful. Mere presence cannot attract Section 34 IPC. There is
no evidence of prior meeting of minds. Pradeep Mandal, who
allegedly ordered killing has been acquitted on same evidence
and police submitted final form against Nawal Mandal, who is
alleged to have caught hold of the deceased. Same witnesses
cannot be believed for Kesho Mandal and disbelieved for
Pradeep and Nawal Mandal. Further submission is that the I.O.
was never examined which has caused great prejudice to the
defence. Defence could not confront P.W.2, P.W.5, P.W.6 with
their Section 161 statements. Non-seizure of lantern, pistol,
dagger, cartridges, bullets, blood-stained clothes, and non-proof
of place of occurrence could not be explained. In a night
occurrence depending on lantern light, non-seizure of lantern is
Patna High Court CR. APP (DB) No.1319 of 2018 dt.20-11-2026
9/15
fatal. Furthermore, post-mortem report is inadmissible as only
attested copy Exhibit 4 was produced and not the original copy.
The requirements concerning secondary evidence were not
fulfilled. Section 68 does not cure defect. Mere marking of
Exhibit 4 does not prove the contents as observed in Ashok
Dulichand v. Madahavlal Dube, (1975) 4 SCC 664. P.W.11's
oral evidence cannot cure it because he admitted joint report and
not the original. Therefore medical evidence cannot be relied to
corroborate ocular evidence. Learned counsel for the appellants
further submitted that dying declaration also could not be
proved. Alleged oral dying declaration by deceased naming
assailants is not proved by independent witness, no doctor
certified that deceased was in fit state to speak, and P.W.1
admitted he reached after occurrence. Exhibit A shows P.W.3
was made to depose falsely and benefit of doubt must go to
appellants. There are material improvements in the case.
Learned counsel for the appellants submits that learned Trial
Court failed to observe the defence evidence as there is an
admitted land dispute which proves false implication due to
enmity and thus, benefit of doubt must go to the appellants are
fit to be acquitted.
9. On the other hand, learned counsel for State
Patna High Court CR. APP (DB) No.1319 of 2018 dt.20-11-2026
10/15
submitted that P.W.1, P.W.2, P.W.6 are natural, consistent
witnesses. They have consistently stated participation of these
three appellants. Minor contradictions are natural. Medical
evidence supports Manoj Mandal - injuries are sharp-cutting,
consistent with dagger. Absence of firearm injury does not
disprove Ravindra Mandal’s participation, because country-
made pistol may have missed or injury may be misinterpreted.
Medical evidence only corroborates, it does not displace ocular
evidence. P.W.2 and P.W.6 specifically state Kesho Mandal
caught hold of deceased. This is not mere presence, it is active
participation facilitating assault, attracting Section 34 IPC. Non-
examination of I.O. is a lapse but not fatal. No prejudice shown.
Bahadur Naik (Supra) requires proof of actual prejudice.
P.W.11 was member of Medical Board, his oral testimony
proves cause of death independently of Exhibit 4. Postmortem
report is only corroborative. He further submits that land dispute
provides motive for murder. Exhibit A was obtained under
pressure, P.W.3 explained it in Court. Acquittal of 8 accused
persons does not mean that appellants are innocent. Learned
Court must separate grain from chaff, accused-wise assessment
is permissible. There is no reason to differ with the findings of
the learned trial court and the judgment of conviction and order
Patna High Court CR. APP (DB) No.1319 of 2018 dt.20-11-2026
11/15
of sentence are justified and legal.
10. Heard learned counsel for the parties and carefully
perused the materials available on record.
11. In this case, out of 11 witnesses, P.W. 2, P.W. 5 and
P.W. 6 claims to be eye witnesses of the occurrence and stated
that the deceased fell down due to gun-shot but but in
examination-in-chief, P.W. 2, son of the deceased, P.W. 5 and
P.W. 6, brothers of the deceased, improved their statements and
stated that Manoj Mandal gave dagger blow on the same place
where there was wound of gun-shot just to cover up the gun-shot
theory. P.W. 2 in his cross-examination, stated that upon alarm
raised by the deceased, he along with others reached at the place
of occurrence. When the star witnesses themselves disown their
earlier statements, the Court cannot safely convict on their
testimony alone. We find their credibility seriously dented. It is
specific case of the prosecution that Ravindra Manal shot the
deceased but no bullet was recovered either from the place of
occurrence or from the body of the deceased. This is a classic
case of implication by improvement. The prosecution case thus
rests only on interested witnesses without corroboration.
12. In this case, the Investigating Officer has not been
examined, which has caused great prejudice as the defence
Patna High Court CR. APP (DB) No.1319 of 2018 dt.20-11-2026
12/15
could not get documentary evidence, explain the material
discrepancy and contradict the witnesses. As a part of fair trial
the Investigating Officer should be examined in the trial cases
especially when a serious sessions trial was being held against
the accused. If any of the prosecution witnesses give any
evidence contrary to their previous statement recorded under
Section 161 Cr.P.C. or if there is any omission of certain
material particulars, the previous statement of these witnesses
could be proved only by examining the Investigating Officer
who must have recorded the statement of these witnesses under
Section 161 Cr.P.C. Non-examination of the I.O. lacks defence
opportunity of bringing on record materials that could have
shown mode, manner and genesis of the occurrence and their
innocence. Furthermore, non-seizure of lantern is also critical
because occurrence is alleged in dark. Without lantern,
identification becomes doubtful. This is not a case of mere
irregularity. As also, there is no evidence of prior concert,
meeting of minds, or active participation by Kesho Mandal in
the fatal blows. Mere presence or surrounding, without proof of
sharing intention to kill, is insufficient for Section 34 IPC. The
prosecution having failed to prove conspiracy against 8 accused
on same evidence, cannot succeed against Kesho Mandal.
Patna High Court CR. APP (DB) No.1319 of 2018 dt.20-11-2026
13/15
13. We hold that Exhibit 4 is inadmissible as no
foundation under Section 65 Evidence Act was laid. The
prosecution never explained where original is, nor sought
permission to lead secondary evidence. Mere marking does not
dispense with proof. Ashok Dulichand (supra) applies. P.W.11's
evidence, though relevant, cannot fill the gap because he
admitted the report was joint and he did not prove the original.
Medical evidence therefore does not conclusively corroborate
ocular evidence. It is settled law that if the medical evidence
contradicts and completely rules out the possibility of ocular
evidence being true, the eyewitness testimony may be
disbelieved as observed in Abdul Sayeed v. State of Madhya
Pradesh (2010) 10 SCC 259 . The overall picture gives rise to
substantial doubt regarding the integrity of the case. The
material contradiction apparent in the deposition of eye
witnesses significantly undermines that credibility of the
prosecution version. These inconsistencies render prosecution
case doubtful on the face of such evident discrepancies,
recording conviction becomes untenable.
14. Motive of land dispute is double-edged. It can
explain murder, but also explains false implication. Where
eyewitness evidence is doubtful, motive alone cannot sustain
Patna High Court CR. APP (DB) No.1319 of 2018 dt.20-11-2026
14/15
conviction. Suspicion, however strong, cannot replace proof
beyond reasonable doubt. The Trial Court erred in separating
evidence accused-wise to convict 3 accused while acquitting 8
accused on the same set of witnesses, without explaining why
the same witnesses are reliable for 3 accused and unreliable for
8 accused.
15. For the reasons recorded above, the prosecution
has failed to prove guilt beyond reasonable doubt. This Court
finds that the impugned judgment of conviction and order of
sentence suffers from material infirmity.
16. In that view of the matter, the impugned judgment
of conviction dated 24.09.2018 and order of sentence dated
26.09.2018 passed by the learned Fast Track Court No. 1,
Purnea in Sessions Trial No. 244 of 1997/T.R. No. 473/2018
arising out of Barhara Kothi P. S. Case No. 37 of 1995 are
hereby set aside with respect to these appellants.
17. Appellants, above named, are acquitted of all the
charges and are discharged from the liability of the bail bonds in
connection with this case. Since, learned counsel for the
appellants submits that appellant in Cr. Appeal (DB) No. 1319
of 2018, Manoj Mandal, is in custody, he shall be released
forthwith, if not wanted in any other case.
Patna High Court CR. APP (DB) No.1319 of 2018 dt.20-11-2026
15/15
18. Accordingly, this appeal stands allowed.
19. Interlocutory application/s, if any, also stands
disposed of.
(Prabhat Kumar Singh, J)
(Rana Vikram Singh, J)
Navya/-
AFR/NAFR NAFR
CAV DATE 04.11.2026
Uploading Date 20.11.2026
Transmission Date 20.11.2026