Bharat Bhushan Jain (Dead) Thr. Lrs. vs M/S Goodyear India Ltd .
- Court
- Supreme Court
REPORTABLE
2026 INSC 1240
IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA
CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION
CIVIL APPEAL NOS. 9668-9669 OF 2013
BHARAT BHUSHAN JAIN (DEAD) THROUGH LRS.
AND OTHERS ETC. … APPELLANT(S)
VERSUS
M/S GOODYEAR INDIA LTD. AND ANOTHER ... RESPONDENT(S)
J U D G M E N T
PRASHANT KUMAR MISHRA, J.
1. The present Appeals arise out of a long-standing landlord-tenant
dispute concerning premises bearing No. XI/4239-A/2 (Plot No. 3A), 1, Ansari
Road, Daryaganj, New Delhi, owned by the appellants and originally let out to
the respondent no. 1, M/s Goodyear India Ltd. Although the litigation was
instituted seeking both recovery of possession of the suit premises and
damages for its continued use and occupation after termination of the
tenancy, the decree for possession has long since attained finality. The
controversy which now falls for consideration is confined to the determination
of mesne profits payable by the respondent no. 1-tenant for its continued
occupation of the premises after the tenancy stood terminated, and, more
particularly, the correctness of the rate of mesne profits and interest as
Signature Not Verified
Digitally signed by
NISHA KHULBEY
Date: 2026.11.18
17:09:40 IST
Reason:
CA Nos.9668-9669/2013 Page 1 of 10
1
determined by the High Court of Delhi in the impugned judgment dated
11.08.2011 passed in RSA No. 186 of 2010 and RSA No. 187 of 2010.
2
2. The original suit was instituted in the year 1990 by Late Shri Prem
Chandra Jain, Smt. Kund Prabha Jain and Smt. Swayam Prabha Jain, whose
legal representatives are presently on record as the appellants, seeking
recovery of possession of the suit property after termination of the respondent
no. 1’s tenancy with effect from midnight of 31.12.1989. Besides recovery of
possession, the plaintiffs claimed damages for use and occupation at the rate
of Rs. 1,47,500/- per month (equivalent to Rs. 4,916.67 per day) with effect
from 02.01.1990 till delivery of vacant possession, together with interest at
the rate of 15% per annum. During the course of the trial, both parties led
evidence, including on the issue relating to the determination of damages for
use and occupation.
3. By judgment and decree dated 22.12.1998, the learned Trial Court
decreed the suit for recovery of possession in favour of the plaintiffs. Insofar
as the claim for damages for the single day preceding the institution of the
suit was concerned, the Trial Court held that the evidence adduced by the
plaintiffs was insufficient to establish that the premises could have been let
out for a single day at the rate claimed and, consequently, declined to grant
the said relief. However, the Trial Court considered it appropriate to pass a
preliminary decree under Order XX Rule 12 of the Code of Civil Procedure,
3
1908 , directing that a separate inquiry be conducted for determination of the
1
For short, ‘High Court’
2
Earlier Suit No. 41/1990 and later renumbered as Suit No. 78/1996
3
For short, ‘CPC’
CA Nos.9668-9669/2013 Page 2 of 10
pendent lite and future mesne profits payable to the plaintiffs. Thus, while
the decree for possession stood adjudicated by the judgment dated
22.12.1998, the quantification of mesne profits was expressly left open for
determination in subsequent proceedings.
4. The respondent no. 1-tenant questioned the decree for possession by
filing RFA No. 318 of 1999 before the High Court. The appeal came to be
dismissed by judgment dated 23.11.2000, affirming the decree passed by the
Trial Court. The respondent no. 1 thereafter preferred SLP (C) No. 3879 of
2001 before this Court, which was dismissed in limine on 19.03.2001.
Consequently, the decree for possession attained finality and the lis between
the parties thereafter entered a second stage, confined exclusively to the
inquiry contemplated under Order XX Rule 12 CPC for determination of
mesne profits.
5. Pursuant to the preliminary decree, the appellants, along with the other
4
legal representatives of the original plaintiffs, initiated proceedings under
Order XX Rule 12 CPC before Trial Court seeking determination of mesne
profits payable by the respondent no. 1. By judgment and decree dated
30.04.2004, the Trial Court rejected the respondent no.1’s plea of res judicata
and held the proceedings under Order XX Rule 12 CPC to be maintainable.
On the merits of the inquiry, the Trial Court determined mesne profits at the
rate of Rs. 22/- per square foot per month in respect of the carpet area of the
ground floor and Rs. 11/- per square foot per month in respect of the carpet
area of the mezzanine floor, together with interest at the rate of 15% per
4
M-10/2002 filed in Suit No. 78/1996
CA Nos.9668-9669/2013 Page 3 of 10
annum. Certain clerical errors in the decree were thereafter corrected by
orders dated 24.05.2004 and 23.11.2004, resulting in the issuance of
amended decrees.
6. Aggrieved by the determination of mesne profits, the respondent no. 1
preferred RCA No. 40 of 2004, subsequently renumbered as RCA No. 9 of
5
2009, before the learned Additional District Judge . The appellants, in turn,
filed cross-objections contending that the Trial Court ought to have
determined mesne profits at the rate of Rs. 30/- per square foot per month
for the ground floor and Rs. 15/- per square foot per month for the mezzanine
floor on the basis of the covered area of the premises. They further contended
that interest formed an integral component of mesne profits and ought to have
been awarded from month to month from the respective dates on which each
month's mesne profits became due. By judgment and decree dated
12.07.2010, the learned First Appellate Court allowed the appeal preferred by
the respondent no. 1, set aside the judgment and decrees passed by the Trial
Court. The First Appellate Court found that the Trial Court's determination of
mesne profits at the rate of Rs. 22/- per square foot per month for the ground
floor and Rs. 11/- per square foot per month for the mezzanine floor, on the
carpet area, was unsupported by material evidence and was speculative and
presumptuous. It also held that the corresponding finding of the Trial Court
with respect to interest on mesne profits could not be sustained. The First
Appellate Court, however, proceeded on the basis of the admitted rate of rent
for determining the mesne profits payable by the respondent.
5
Hereinafter referred as ‘First Appellate Court’
CA Nos.9668-9669/2013 Page 4 of 10
7. Now aggrieved, the appellants thereupon preferred RSA Nos. 186 and
187 of 2010 before the High Court. RSA No. 186 of 2010 related to the
determination of mesne profits for the period from 02.01.1990 to 30.03.2001,
whereas RSA No. 187 of 2010 pertained to the period from 02.01.1990 to
30.04.1999. In both appeals, the appellants sought restoration of the Trial
Court's determination while simultaneously pressing their claim for
enhancement of mesne profits to Rs. 30/- per square foot per month for the
ground floor and Rs. 15/- per square foot per month for the mezzanine floor,
together with interest at the rate of 15% per annum calculated from the
respective dates on which each month's mesne profits became payable.
8. By the common judgment dated 11.08.2011, the High Court partly
allowed both the second appeals. The High Court held that the First Appellate
Court had overlooked a material admission made by the respondent no. 1's
own witness (DW-1 P.V. Ramani, officer of respondent no. 1) regarding the
prevailing rate of rent in the locality and that such omission constituted a
substantial question of law warranting interference under Section 100 of CPC.
Proceeding on that basis, the High Court modified the judgment of the First
Appellate Court and determined mesne profits at the rate of Rs. 7/- per square
foot per month in respect of the ground floor and Rs. 5/- per square foot per
month in respect of the mezzanine floor for the respective periods under
consideration. The High Court further directed payment of simple interest at
the rate of 7.5% per annum from the respective months in which the mesne
profits became payable till realization, while providing that, in the event the
decretal amount was paid within two months, interest would stand reduced
CA Nos.9668-9669/2013 Page 5 of 10
to 6% per annum. It is against this common judgment of the High Court which
has given rise to present appeals before this Court.
9. We have heard the learned counsel for the parties and have perused the
material placed on record.
10. The controversy before us lies in a narrow compass. The decree for
recovery of possession has attained finality in 2001 and what survives now
for consideration is the correctness of the determination of mesne profits by
the High Court. It is well settled that mesne profits are compensatory in
nature and are intended to recompense the true owner for the loss occasioned
by the continued wrongful occupation of his property. Their assessment is not
governed by any rigid or inflexible formula. The Court is required to arrive at
a fair and reasonable estimate having regard to the nature and location of the
property, the prevailing rental value, the evidence adduced by the parties and
the attendant circumstances of each case. Equally, such determination is
essentially one founded upon appreciation of evidence and, unless shown to
be manifestly arbitrary, unsupported by the record or based upon an
erroneous application of law, does not ordinarily warrant appellate
interference. [Refer: Martin and Harris Private Limited and Another vs.
6
Rajendra Mehta and Others ]
11. In the present case, the Trial Court had determined mesne profits at
the rate of Rs. 22/- per square foot per month for the ground floor and Rs.
11/- per square foot per month for the mezzanine floor. In arriving at the said
6
(2022) 8 SCC 527 at para 16, 19 and 20.
CA Nos.9668-9669/2013 Page 6 of 10
determination, considerable reliance was placed upon the evidence relating to
the premises let out to Vijaya Bank at No. 2/10, Ansari Road, Daryaganj,
where the ground floor and basement had been let at a consolidated rate of
Rs. 22/- per square foot. The evidence of the owner of those premises as well
as the Branch Manager of Vijaya Bank was relied upon in support of the
prevailing rental value.
12. The First Appellate Court, however, examined the comparability of the
two properties and found that the premises occupied by the respondent could
not simply be equated with the premises let out to Vijaya Bank. The former
were old buildings, stated to have been in existence since the 1950s, whereas
the Vijaya Bank premises had been constructed in 1972. Further, the suit
premises comprised the ground floor and mezzanine floor forming part of the
same premises and were being used as a godown, whereas the premises
occupied by Vijaya Bank comprised the ground floor and basement and were
being used for banking purposes. The First Appellate Court also noticed the
absence of any valuation report or municipal valuation establishing similarity
between the two properties and the absence of evidence regarding the
comparative quality of construction. It was, therefore, not persuaded to treat
the rent paid by Vijaya Bank as a reliable comparable for determining the
mesne profits of the suit premises.
13. We have carefully examined the reasoning adopted by the High Court.
The High Court noticed that, while reversing the determination made by the
Trial Court and limiting the grant of mesne profits only at the admitted rate
of rent, the First Appellate Court had failed to advert to a material admission
CA Nos.9668-9669/2013 Page 7 of 10
made by the respondent no. 1's own witness (DW-1 P.V. Ramani, officer of
respondent no. 1) in his examination-in-chief regarding the prevailing rental
value of comparable properties in the locality at the relevant point of time. The
respondent no. 1’s witness had stated that at the time the tenancy stood
terminated, the prevailing rate of rent in the locality ranged between Rs. 5/-
and Rs. 8/- per square foot per month. Such omission was not insignificant.
The omission to consider a material piece of evidence having a direct bearing
on the determination of mesne profits was rightly regarded by the High Court
as giving rise to a substantial question of law requiring correction.
14. In the impugned judgment, the High Court did not proceed on the
premise that the aforesaid admission of respondent no. 1’s witness, by itself,
concluded the matter. The admission merely constituted an important
circumstance forming part of the evidentiary record. The question was not
merely whether the lowest rate which could be said to have been admitted by
the respondent should mechanically be adopted. In the impugned judgment,
the High Court evaluated the material as a whole and thereafter determined
the mesne profits at Rs. 7/- per square foot per month in respect of the ground
floor and Rs. 5/- per square foot per month in respect of the mezzanine floor.
We find that the determination represents a balanced assessment founded
upon the evidence available on record. The High Court did not revive the Trial
Court's reliance upon the Vijaya Bank premises, nor did it equate the suit
property with the premises occupied by the bank. The rate so determined falls
within the evidentiary range disclosed by the respondent's own witness and
CA Nos.9668-9669/2013 Page 8 of 10
cannot be characterised as arbitrary, speculative or based on no evidence so
as to warrant interference by this Court.
15. We are, therefore, unable to persuade ourselves to accept the
contention that the impugned judgment suffers from any legal infirmity. On
the contrary, the High Court corrected the omission committed by the First
Appellate Court in overlooking material evidence and thereafter proceeded to
determine the mesne profits on a reasonable appreciation of the record. We
find neither perversity in the findings recorded nor any misapplication of the
governing legal principles.
16. We also find no reason to interfere with the direction relating to interest
passed by the High Court. ‘Interest’ forms an integral component of mesne
profits and is intended to compensate the owner for being deprived of the
beneficial enjoyment of the property during the period of wrongful
7
occupation. Having regard to the facts and circumstances of the present
case, the award of simple interest at the rate of 7.5% per annum, with the
concession of a reduced rate of 6% per annum upon payment within the time
stipulated by the High Court, does not call for interference.
17. There is yet another aspect which deserves notice. The present litigation
traces its origin to the termination of the tenancy with effect from 31.12.1989.
The decree for possession attained finality more than two decades ago i.e., in
2001. The impugned judgment was rendered by the High Court on
11.08.2011 and the appeals have remained pending before this Court for
7
Refer: Mahant Naryana Dasjee Varu and Others vs. Board of Trustees, The Tirumalai
Tirupathi Devasthanam, 1964 SCC OnLine SC 125 at para 13(3).
CA Nos.9668-9669/2013 Page 9 of 10
nearly fifteen years. The controversy now survives only with respect to the
quantification of mesne profits on the basis of evidence which has remained
unchanged throughout the proceedings. Having independently examined the
approach adopted by the High Court and finding no legal error therein, we are
of the considered view that the interests of justice would be better served by
according finality to a litigation which has engaged the parties for more than
three decades.
18. In view of the foregoing discussion, we are satisfied that the impugned
judgment represents a fair and reasonable determination of the mesne profits
payable by the respondent no. 1 on the basis of the evidence available on
record.
19. Consequently, no interference is warranted. The Appeals are
dismissed .
………………………………………J.
(PRASHANT KUMAR MISHRA)
………………………………………J.
(N.V. ANJARIA)
NEW DELHI;
NOVEMBER 18, 2026.
CA Nos.9668-9669/2013 Page 10 of 10