Murari Padma vs The State of Telangana

Court
High Court for the State of Telangana

*THE HON’BLE SRI JUSTICE VAKITI RAMAKRISHNA REDDY

+ W.P. No. 18025 of 2021
Between :

Murari Padma and others …. Petitioners
AND

The State of Telangana, represented by its
Principal Secretary, Revenue Department,
Secretariat, Hyderabad and others ….Respondents

JUDGMENT PRONOUNCED ON : 24.09.2026

SUBMITTED FOR APPROVAL:

1. Whether Reporters of Local
newspapers may be allowed to see
the Judgment ?
: Yes/No


2. Whether the copies of judgment
: Yes/No

may be marked to Law
Reports/Journals
3. Whether Their Lordship/Ladyship
: Yes/No
wish to see the fair copy of
judgment




___________________________________
VAKITI RAMAKRISHNA REDDY, J


-2-
VRKR,J
WP_18025_2021

THE HON’BLE SRI JUSTICE VAKITI RAMAKRISHNA REDDY

W.P. No. 21945 of 2021
% 24.09.2026

Between:
# Murari Padma and others …. Petitioners
AND

$ The State of Telangana, represented by its
Principal Secretary, Revenue Department,
Secretariat, Hyderabad and others ….Respondents


! Counsel for the Petitioners : Sri A. Ravinder Reddy, learned
Senior Counsel representing
Smt. L. Vani, learned counsel
appearing for the petitioners

^ Counsel for respondents : Sri H. Rakesh Kumar, learned
Assistant Government Pleader
for Revenue appearing for
respondent Nos.1 to 5

: Sri M. Krupakar, learned
counsel representing Sri
Dhramapuri Abhiram, learned
counsel appearing for
respondent Nos.7 to 9
< GIST :
> HEAD NOTE :
? Cases referred :

(1997) 3 SCC 261
(1993) 4 SCC 41
AIR 1978 AP 279
(2017) 9 SCC 700
AIR 1954 SC 340
(2017) 13 SCC 414
(1979) 3 SCC 578
(1998) 5 SCC 567
(1996) 6 SCC 223
(2007) 13 SCC 565
2021 SCC OnLine SC 802
(1997) 7 SCC 137
(2013) 9 SCC 319
(2017) 7 SCC 342
(2019) 3 SCC 191
(2019) 10 SCC 259
(2019) 13 SCC 70
2026 INSC 450
2004 (7) ALT 963
2009 (2) ALD 212 : 2009 (2) ALT 742

HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE OF TELANGANA
AT HYDERABAD

THE HON'BLE SRI JUSTICE VAKITI RAMAKRISHNA REDDY

WRIT PETITION No.18025 of 2021
(CNR No.HBHC010295852021)

Date: 24.09.2026
Reserved on: 30.06.2026 Pronounced on: 24.09.2026
ploaded on: 24.09.2026
Between:
Murari Padma and others .... Petitioners
AND
The State of Telangana, represented by its
Principal Secretary, Revenue Department,
Secretariat, Hyderabad and others .... Respondents

ORDER:

This writ petition is filed by the petitioners under Article 226 of
the Constitution of India seeking the following relief:
“… to issue such appropriate writ, order or direction more so
particularly one in the nature of certiorari by setting aside the order
passed by the respondent No.2 in Tribunal Case No. 273 of 2021 (ROR
Appeal Petition No. E/656/2016/RDO) dated 25.06.2021 by declaring
the same as arbitrary, illegal, without jurisdiction and against the
statutory provisions and pass such other order as this Hon’ble Court
may deem just in the circumstances of the case…”

2. Heard Sri A. Ravinder Reddy, learned Senior Counsel
representing Smt. L. Vani, learned counsel appearing for the
petitioners; Sri H. Rakesh Kumar, learned Assistant Government
Pleader for Revenue appearing for respondent Nos.1 to 5; and

-2-
VRKR,J
WP_18025_2021

Sri M. Krupakar, learned counsel representing Sri Dhramapuri
Abhiram, learned counsel appearing for respondent Nos.7 to 9.
Perused the available record.

FACTS IN BRIEF
3. The dispute in the present writ petition concerns agricultural
land admeasuring Ac.3.00 in Sy.No.727/1 situated at Chinnagudur
Village and Mandal, Mahabubabad District (hereinafter referred to as
“the subject land”). An extent of Ac.1.00 in Sy.No.727/1/A out of the
said land forms the immediate subject matter of the rival claim.

4. According to the petitioners, the subject land originally
belonged to one Murari Somaiah and, upon his demise, devolved
upon his son, Murari Chandraiah, whose name was duly mutated in
the revenue records and to whom a pattadar pass book was issued.
After the death of Murari Chandraiah on 28.05.2017 the property was
mutated in the name of petitioner No.1, his widow, by way of
succession. Petitioner No.1 thereafter executed registered gift deeds in
favour of her sons, including petitioner Nos.2 and 3, pursuant to
which their names were also mutated in the revenue records and
digital pattadar pass books were issued to them. The petitioners

-3-
VRKR,J
WP_18025_2021

assert that they have at all material times been, and continue to be,
in possession and enjoyment of the subject land.

5. The case of respondent No.6 and, after his death, that of
respondent Nos.7 to 9 who are his legal representatives, as set out in
the counter affidavit filed on behalf of respondent Nos.8 and 9, is that
Murari Somaiah died on 07.02.2001 and that his legal heirs, namely
Murari Somamma and Murari Chandraiah, executed a registered sale
deed bearing Document No.2941 of 2001 dated 31.12.2001 in favour
of the deceased respondent No.6, who thereupon acquired valid title
and remained in peaceful possession and enjoyment of the property.
It is their specific case that, taking advantage of the continuance of
the vendors’ names in the revenue records, the writ petitioners
unlawfully asserted rights over the property and interfered with the
possession. It is further contended that, upon execution of the
registered sale deed, the vendors stood divested of all their right, title
and interest, and consequently petitioner No.1 had no subsisting right
or authority to execute the subsequent gift settlement deeds in favour
of petitioner Nos.2 and 3.

6. Respondent No.6 preferred ROR Appeal Petition
No.E/656/2016/RDO before the Revenue Divisional Officer under the

-4-
VRKR,J
WP_18025_2021

provisions of the Telangana Rights in Land and Pattadar Pass Books
Act, 1971 (“the Act of 1971”), seeking cancellation of the mutations
and pattadar pass books standing in the names of the petitioners. The
petitioners contested the said proceedings, disputing the validity of
the alleged sale deed, asserting that respondent No.6 had never at any
point of time secured mutation of his name in the revenue records,
and contending that the claim involved disputed questions of title
which could be adjudicated only by a competent civil court.

7. During the pendency of the proceedings the Act of 1971 stood
repealed by the Telangana Rights in Land and Pattadar Pass Books
Act, 2020 (“the Act of 2020”), which came into force on 29.10.2020. In
terms of Section 16(1) of the Act of 2020 all appeals and revisions
pending under the repealed Act stood transferred to the Special
Tribunals constituted for that purpose, and the appeal of respondent
No.6 was accordingly transferred and renumbered as Tribunal Case
No.273 of 2021 on the file of respondent No.2. Respondent No.6 died
on 29.01.2021. Neither was the factum of his death brought to the
notice of the Special Tribunal, nor did respondent Nos.7 to 9 take any
steps to come on record in his place in the transferred appeal.

-5-
VRKR,J
WP_18025_2021

8. During the pendency of this writ petition the law has changed
once again. The Act of 2020 has been repealed by the Telangana Bhu
Bharati (Record of Rights in Land) Act, 2025 (Act No.1 of 2025) (“the
Act of 2025”), which received the assent of the Governor on
03.01.2025 and was published in the Telangana Gazette on
04.01.2025, and the Telangana Bhu Bharati (Record of Rights in
Land) Rules, 2025 framed thereunder were brought into force with
effect from 14.04.2025 by G.O.Ms.No.39, Revenue (Land
Administration) Department, dated 14.04.2025. Section 23 of the Act
of 2025 provides:
“23. (1) The Telangana Rights in Land and Pattadar Pass Books
Act, 2020 is hereby repealed:
Provided that the provisions of section 8 of the Telangana General
Clauses Act, 1891 shall be applicable in respect of the repeal of the
said enactment, standing orders and other provisions of Law, and
section 8 and 18 of the said Act shall be applicable as if the
enactment, standing orders, provisions of law had been repealed
and re-enacted by this Act.
… (3) Any action taken or decision made under the Telangana
Rights in Land and Pattadar Pass Books Act, 2020 until it was in
force shall be valid and enforceable as if the said Act is in force.”

9. The legality of the impugned order therefore continues to be
tested by reference to the Act of 2020, under which it was passed and
which was then in force. The relief to be moulded, however, must have

-6-
VRKR,J
WP_18025_2021

regard to the law as it now stands, and the corresponding provisions
of the Act of 2025 are noticed at the appropriate places hereafter.

The order of the Special Tribunal
10. The Special Tribunal passed a first order on 20.02.2021 and
thereafter, by the impugned order dated 25.06.2021 in Tribunal Case
No.273 of 2021, directed cancellation of the mutations and pattadar
pass books standing in the names of the petitioners, recording that it
had afforded an opportunity of hearing to the parties and had
conducted a detailed enquiry. Significantly, while cancelling the
entries, the Tribunal simultaneously observed that respondent No.6
should approach the competent civil court for a declaration of title,
and directed the parties to work out their remedies before that forum.

11. Pursuant to the impugned order, and after the death of
respondent No.6, respondent Nos.7 to 9 instituted O.S.No.288 of 2021
on 14.09.2021 on the file of the Court of the learned Junior Civil
Judge, Thorrur, seeking declaration of title, recovery of possession,
rectification of the entries in the revenue records and a permanent
injunction restraining alienation. That suit is stated to be pending
adjudication.

-7-
VRKR,J
WP_18025_2021

12. Aggrieved by the order dated 25.06.2021, the petitioners have
instituted the present writ petition. By way of reply affidavit they have
denied the allegations made in the counter affidavit, contending that
the sale deed dated 31.12.2001 is a sham and fraudulent transaction
which confers no right, title or interest upon the respondents,
whereas the petitioners claim lawful title and continuous possession
by virtue of succession, valid mutation, issuance of pattadar pass
books and the subsequent gift deeds duly reflected in the revenue
records. They have denied any suppression of material facts,
explaining that the impleadment of a deceased respondent was
inadvertent and has since been rectified by bringing his legal
representatives on record.

Submissions on behalf of the Petitioners:
13. Sri A. Ravinder Reddy, learned Senior Counsel appearing for
the petitioners, submitted that the impugned order is beyond the
scope of the enquiry contemplated under the provisions of the ROR
Act. The Special Tribunal, exercising jurisdiction transferred to it
under Section 16 of the Act of 2020, stands in the shoes of the
appellate authority under the Act of 1971 and possesses no larger
power; its function is confined to the correctness of entries in the
record of rights and it is not a forum for the adjudication of title. The

-8-
VRKR,J
WP_18025_2021

rival claims here rest upon documents whose genuineness is in issue
– on the one hand succession followed by registered gift deeds, and on
the other a sale deed of the year 2001 alleged to be sham and
fraudulent – and the determination of such a controversy requires
pleadings, issues, evidence and cross-examination, and lies
exclusively within the province of the civil court.

14. It was further submitted that, having itself directed the parties
to approach the competent civil court for declaration of title, the
Special Tribunal could not have simultaneously ordered deletion of
the entries made in favour of the petitioners and cancelled the
pattadar pass books standing in their names; the order is internally
inconsistent. The unofficial respondents have in fact approached the
civil court in O.S.No.288 of 2021 seeking declaration of title,
restoration of possession and permanent injunction, and the very
frame of that suit, being one for recovery of possession, is an
admission that the petitioners and not the unofficial respondents are
in possession. There was therefore no occasion whatever for the
Special Tribunal to order deletion of entries or cancellation of pattadar
pass books. In any event, entries in the revenue record neither confer
title nor take away rights vested in any party, so that the cancellation

-9-
VRKR,J
WP_18025_2021

could serve no legitimate purpose and has only disturbed the position
obtaining between the parties during the pendency of the suit.

15. On the question of the death of respondent No.6, the learned
Senior Counsel submitted that he expired on 29.01.2021, that is,
even before the first order passed by the Special Tribunal on
20.02.2021 and well before the impugned order dated 25.06.2021,
and that it is settled law that an order passed for or against a dead
person is void in law. He clarified that neither the petitioners were
aware of the death, nor did respondent Nos.7 to 9 inform the Special
Tribunal or the petitioners of that fact during the pendency of the
proceedings, so that there was no occasion for the petitioners to bring
the legal representatives of the deceased respondent No.6 on record at
the time of institution of the writ petition; the omission was
inadvertent and has since been cured.

Submissions on behalf of the official Respondent Nos. 1 to 5
16. Sri H. Rakesh Kumar, learned Assistant Government Pleader
for Revenue appearing for respondent Nos.1 to 5, submitted that the
official respondents have no interest of their own in the subject land,
that the lis is essentially one between rival private claimants, and that
no relief is sought and no allegation of mala fides is made against

-10-
VRKR,J
WP_18025_2021

respondent Nos.1 to 5. The mutation in favour of petitioner No.1 was
effected upon the death of Murari Chandraiah on 28.05.2017 on the
basis of succession, and the subsequent mutations in favour of
petitioner Nos.2 and 3 were effected upon registered gift deeds, in
each case following the procedure prescribed by the statute and the
rules, and no irregularity in the making of those entries is attributable
to the revenue authorities.

17. It is further submitted that the appeal preferred by respondent
No.6 in the year 2016 stood transferred to the Special Tribunal by
operation of Section 16(1) of the Act of 2020, the Special Tribunals
having been constituted by G.O.Ms.No.4, Revenue (Assignment–I)
Department, dated 12.01.2021, and that the transfer and
renumbering of the appeal as Tribunal Case No.273 of 2021 are
unexceptionable. He submitted that the record does not disclose that
the factum of the death of respondent No.6 on 29.01.2021 was at any
stage brought to the notice of the Special Tribunal, that no
application for substitution of his legal representatives was filed
before that authority, and that the Special Tribunal proceeded upon
the material placed before it and in ignorance of the death.

-11-
VRKR,J
WP_18025_2021

18. It was fairly submitted that the record of rights maintained
under the Act is essentially a fiscal record; that Section 11 of the Act
of 2020 confers upon the pattadar pass book-cum-title deed
evidentiary value with regard to title only for the limited purpose of
creation of an equitable mortgage; and that the Act does not
constitute the revenue authorities into a forum for the adjudication of
title, the summary jurisdiction being inadequate where, as here, rival
claims rest upon contested registered documents and upon disputed
succession. Whichever party ultimately succeeds in O.S.No.288 of
2021 may apply for a corresponding change in the record of rights
under Section 7 of the Act of 2020, which expressly provided for
effecting change in the record of rights when a right over land is
acquired through a decree of court, and now under Section 8 of the
Act of 2025, which makes the like provision in respect of the modes of
mutation specified in clause (h) of sub-section (12) of Section 2 of that
Act; the official respondents will give effect to such decree and will
abide by whatever orders this Court may pass.

Submissions on behalf of the unofficial Respondents 7 to 9:
19. Sri M. Krupakar, learned counsel representing Sri Dhramapuri
Abhiram, learned counsel appearing for respondent Nos.7 to 9,
specifically contended that the petitioners intentionally filed the

-12-
VRKR,J
WP_18025_2021

present writ petition against a dead person, namely respondent No.6,
and also obtained interim orders of stay and suspension of the
impugned order without impleading his legal heirs, and that on that
ground alone the writ petition is liable to be dismissed. It was further
contended that though the petitioners themselves, through their
predecessors-in-title, had alienated the property in favour of
respondent No.6 under the registered sale deed dated 31.12.2001,
they thereafter created gift settlement deeds among themselves,
illegally sought mutation of their names in the revenue records and
obtained pattadar pass books without notice to respondent No.6.

20. It was submitted that upon execution of the registered sale deed
the vendors stood divested of all right, title and interest, that
petitioner No.1 consequently had no subsisting right or authority to
execute the gift settlement deeds, and that the petitioners, not being
entitled to claim title over the subject land, are not entitled to
maintain the present writ petition. The Special Tribunal, it was urged,
passed the impugned order after conducting a detailed enquiry and
after affording opportunity to all concerned; no jurisdictional error or
error apparent on the face of the record is made out; and the writ
petition is devoid of merit and liable to be dismissed.


-13-
VRKR,J
WP_18025_2021

POINTS FOR CONSIDERATION
21. In the light of the rival pleadings and the submissions made by
the learned counsel on either side, the following points arise for
consideration:
(i) Whether the writ petition is maintainable, having regard
to the finality attached by Section 16(2) of the Act of
2020 to an order of the Special Tribunal, and to the fact
that it was instituted arraying as respondent No.6 a
person who was then dead?

(ii) Whether the impugned order dated 25.06.2021 passed
by the Special Tribunal is liable to be set aside on the
ground that it was passed after the death of respondent
No.6 without bringing his legal representatives on record
and affording them an opportunity of hearing?

(iii) Whether the Special Tribunal, while exercising
jurisdiction under the Telangana Rights in Land and
Pattadar Pass Books Act, was justified in cancelling the
mutations and pattadar pass books standing in the
names of the petitioners, notwithstanding that the

-14-
VRKR,J
WP_18025_2021

dispute between the parties involves disputed questions
of title to be adjudicated by the competent civil court?

(iv) To what relief?

ANALYSIS AND FINDINGS:
Point (i): Maintainability of the writ petition:
22. Section 16 of the Act of 2020, which constitutes the Special
Tribunals and transfers to them the appeals and revisions pending
under the repealed Act of 1971, reads as follows:
“16. (1) On such repeal all the pending Appeals and Revision
cases under the provisions of Telangana Rights in Land and
Pattadar Pass Books Act, 1971 shall stand transferred to the Special
Tribunals.
(2) On disposal of appeal or revision by the Tribunal, the order of
the Tribunal shall be final and shall be implemented under the
provisions of this Act.”

23. The finality declared by sub-section (2) operates within the
hierarchy created by the statute. It brings the departmental remedies
to a close; it does not, and constitutionally cannot, denude this Court
of its jurisdiction under Article 226 of the Constitution of India. The
power of judicial review vested in the High Courts under Articles 226
and 227 is part of the basic structure of the Constitution and cannot
be excluded by a legislative declaration of finality, as held by the

-15-
VRKR,J
WP_18025_2021

1
Constitution Bench in L. Chandra Kumar v. Union of India . Where, as
here, the challenge is that the authority has acted without
jurisdiction, contrary to the scheme of the statute and in breach of
the principles of natural justice, a finality clause furnishes no answer.

24. The second limb of the objection to maintainability is that the
writ petition was instituted against a dead person. It is not in dispute
that respondent No.6 died on 29.01.2021 and that he was
nevertheless arrayed as a respondent. The petitioners assert that they
were unaware of his death, and there is nothing on the record to
indicate that the death was ever communicated to them, or indeed to
the Special Tribunal, by respondent Nos.7 to 9.

2
25. In Karuppaswamy v. C. Ramamurthy , the Hon’ble Supreme
Court, dealing with a suit instituted against a defendant who had died
before its presentation, held that where the mistake had occurred in
good faith the institution was not void ab initio and that the
impleadment of the legal representatives would relate back to the date
of presentation of the plaint. It was observed:
“5. … While invoking the beneficent proviso to sub-section (1) of
Section 21 of the Act an averment that a mistake was made in good
faith by impleading a dead defendant in the suit should be made

1
(1997) 3 SCC 261
2
(1993) 4 SCC 41

-16-
VRKR,J
WP_18025_2021

and the court must on proof be satisfied that the motion to include
the right defendant by substitution or addition was just and proper,
the mistake having occurred in good faith. The court’s satisfaction
alone breaths life in the suit.”

26. In so holding the Hon’ble Supreme Court approved the view
taken by the High Court of Composite State of Andhra Pradesh in
3
Rasetty Rajyalakshmamma v. Rajamuru Kanniah , where, the mistake
having been found to have occurred in good faith, the impleadment of
the legal representatives was allowed even after the expiry of the
period of limitation and the institution of the suit was held not to be
void ab initio. The same approach was adopted in Pankajbhai
4
Rameshbhai Zalavadiya v. Jethabhai Kalabhai Zalavadiya , where the
Hon’ble Supreme Court held:
“10. Order 1 Rule 10 of the Code enables the court to add any
person as a party at any stage of the proceedings, if the person whose
presence in court is necessary in order to enable the court to effectively
and completely adjudicate upon and settle all the questions involved
in the suit. Avoidance of multiplicity of proceedings is also one of the
objects of the said provision. Order 1 Rule 10 of the Code empowers
the court to substitute a party in the suit who is a wrong person with a
right person. If the court is satisfied that the suit has been instituted
through a bona fide mistake, and also that it is necessary for the
determination of the real matter in controversy to substitute a party in
the suit, it may direct it to be done.”

3
AIR 1978 AP 279
4
(2017) 9 SCC 700

-17-
VRKR,J
WP_18025_2021

27. In the present case the legal representatives of the deceased
respondent No.6 have since been brought on record as respondent
Nos.7 to 9. They have filed a counter affidavit, have been represented
by counsel and have been heard at length upon the merits. No
prejudice of any description has been demonstrated. Rules of
procedure are the handmaid of justice and are not to be employed to
defeat a hearing on the merits where the defect complained of has
been cured and the party raising the objection is itself before the
Court.

28. There is a further and more fundamental answer to the
objection. Respondent Nos.7 to 9 were admittedly aware of the death
of respondent No.6 and yet took no steps to come on record before the
Special Tribunal in the appeal preferred by him. Having permitted
that authority to proceed and to pass an order in favour of a person
who was no longer alive, they cannot be heard to contend that
proceedings involving a dead person are a nullity when the contention
suits them and are unexceptionable when it does not. The maxim
nullus commodum capere potest de injuria sua propria precludes a
party from founding an objection upon its own default. For these
reasons the writ petition is held to be maintainable, and Point (i) is
answered accordingly.

-18-
VRKR,J
WP_18025_2021

Point (ii): Effect of the death of respondent No.6 upon the
impugned order:

29. The following facts are not in dispute. Respondent No.6 died on
29.01.2021. The appeal which was transferred to the Special Tribunal
and renumbered as Tribunal Case No.273 of 2021 had been preferred
by respondent No.6 himself during his lifetime. The first order in that
appeal was passed on 20.02.2021 and the impugned order on
25.06.2021, both after his death. Respondent Nos.7 to 9, his legal
representatives, took no steps to come on record in his place. The
impugned order is therefore an order made in favour of a person who
had, on the date it was made, ceased to exist in the eye of law.

30. A dead person has no legal persona. Upon the death of a party
a proceeding can be continued only by or against those upon whom
the right to sue devolves, and only after they are brought on record.
An adjudication rendered without such substitution is not a mere
irregularity capable of being waived; it is a nullity, for the authority is
then exercising jurisdiction over a party that does not exist. The
foundational statement of the principle is that of the Honourable
5
Supreme Court in Kiran Singh v. Chaman Paswan , wherein it was
held :

5
AIR 1954 SC 340

-19-
VRKR,J
WP_18025_2021

“6. … It is a fundamental principle well established that a
decree passed by a court without jurisdiction is a nullity, and that
its invalidity could be set up whenever and wherever it is sought to
be enforced or relied upon, even at the stage of execution and even
in collateral proceedings. A defect of jurisdiction, whether it is
pecuniary or territorial, or whether it is in respect of the subject
matter of the action, strikes at the very authority of the court to
pass any decree, and such a defect cannot be cured even by
consent of the parties.”

31. The said principle was applied to the case of a dead party in
Gurnam Singh (dead) through Legal Representatives v. Gurbachan
6
Kaur (dead) by Legal Representatives , where a second appeal had
been decided both in favour of and against persons who had died
during its pendency without their legal representatives being brought
on record. The Honourable Court Lordships held:
“22. This principle, in our considered opinion, squarely applies to
this case because it is a settled principle of law that the decree passed
by a Court for or against a dead person is a “nullity” (See – N. Jayaram
Reddy & Anr. Vs. Revenue Divisional Officer & Land Acquisition Officer,
Kurnool, (1979) 3 SCC 578, Ashok Transport Agency vs. Awadhesh
Kumar & Anr., (1998) 5 SCC 567 and Amba Bai & Ors. Vs. Gopal &
Ors., (2001) 5 SCC 570).
23. The appellants are the legal representatives of defendant
Nos. 2 and 4 on whom the right to sue has devolved. They had,
therefore, right to question the legality of the impugned order inter alia
on the ground of it being a nullity. Such objection, in our opinion, could
be raised in appeal or even in execution proceedings arising out of such
decree.”

6
(2017) 13 SCC 414

-20-
VRKR,J
WP_18025_2021

32. It is to be noticed that among the decisions relied upon in
Gurnam Singh is N. Jayaram Reddy v. Revenue Divisional Officer and
7
Land Acquisition Officer, Kurnool , which arose from the erstwhile
composite State of Andhra Pradesh, and Ashok Transport Agency v.
8
Awadhesh Kumar , where a suit instituted against a proprietary
concern whose proprietor had died before its institution was held to
be a nullity. The principle is thus of long standing and is not confined
to decrees of civil courts.

33. That the principle governs statutory tribunals and quasi-
judicial authorities equally is placed beyond doubt by the statute
itself. Section 13 of the Act of 2020 provides:
“13. The Government or any Authority authorized by the
Government while holding enquiry under this Act shall have the
powers as are vested in Civil Court under the Code of Civil
Procedure, 1908.”

34. The like provision is carried forward by Section 17(1) of the Act
of 2025, which confers upon a recording, appellate or revisional
authority, for the purpose of holding any enquiry under that Act, the
same powers as are vested in a civil court under the Code of Civil
Procedure, 1908 when trying a suit. An authority clothed with the

7
(1979) 3 SCC 578
8
(1998) 5 SCC 567

-21-
VRKR,J
WP_18025_2021

powers of a civil court while holding an enquiry must observe the
corresponding discipline in the conduct of that enquiry. The rule
embodied in Order 22 of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 is not a
technicality of pleading; it is an incident of the rule audi alteram
partem , since an order affecting the rights of a deceased party is in
substance an order affecting the rights of those upon whom his estate
has devolved, and they cannot be bound by an adjudication to which
they were never parties.

35. Applying these principles, once respondent No.6 died on
29.01.2021 the transferred appeal could not have proceeded further
without his legal representatives being brought on record. The Special
Tribunal proceeded in ignorance of the death – a state of affairs
brought about by the default of respondent Nos.7 to 9 themselves –
and passed the impugned order in favour of a non-existent person.
The order dated 25.06.2021 is, on that ground, a nullity in law and
cannot be sustained. The contention of the unofficial respondents
that a proceeding against a dead person is not maintainable, if it be
sound, must apply with far greater force to the proceedings before the
Special Tribunal, where the death had occurred nearly five months
before the impugned order and where the legal representatives were

-22-
VRKR,J
WP_18025_2021

fully aware of it. The objection therefore recoils upon those who raise
it. Point (ii) is answered in favour of the petitioners.

Point (iii): Jurisdiction of the Special Tribunal to cancel
mutations and pattadar pass books:

36. Even leaving aside the ground dealt with under Point (ii), the
impugned order does not survive scrutiny on the merits. The scheme
of the enactment must first be noticed. The Act of 1971, and the Act
of 2020 which replaced it, are enactments for the preparation,
maintenance and updating of the record of rights in land. Sections 5,
6 and 7 of the Act of 2020 respectively provide for effecting changes in
the record of rights where a right is acquired by sale, gift, mortgage or
exchange; where it is acquired through succession, survivorship or
inheritance; and where it is acquired through a decree of court.
Section 9 bars a suit against the Government or any of its officers in
respect of an entry made in, amended in, or omitted from the record
of rights – a bar directed at the State and its officers, and not at a suit
between rival claimants for a declaration of title. Section 11 provides:
“11. The Pattadar Pass Book-cum-Title Deed issued under
this Act shall be deemed to be the title deed and it shall have the
same evidentiary value with regard to the title for the purpose of
creation of equitable mortgage under the provisions of the Transfer of
Property Act, 1882 as a document registered in accordance with the
provisions of the Registration Act, 1908 has, under the law.”

-23-
VRKR,J
WP_18025_2021

37. The deeming is expressly confined. The legislature has
conferred upon the pattadar pass book-cum-title deed the evidentiary
value of a registered document with regard to title only for the
purpose of creation of an equitable mortgage, and has pointedly
refrained from making that document conclusive proof of title for all
purposes. A statute which so carefully limits the evidentiary
consequence of the document it creates cannot be read as having
constituted the authority that issues it into a tribunal for the trial of
title.

38. The Act of 2025, which has since replaced the Act of 2020,
proceeds upon precisely the same premise, and indeed states it more
explicitly. Section 10(5) reproduces, in identical terms, the limited
deeming earlier found in Section 11 of the Act of 2020, confining the
evidentiary value of the pattadar pass book-cum-title deed with regard
to title to the purpose of creation of an equitable mortgage. Section 11
provides that every entry in the record of rights shall be presumed to
be true and correct “until the contrary is proved”, thereby making the
presumption a rebuttable one. Section 19(1) bars a suit against the
Government or its officers in respect of an entry. And Section 18,
which bears the marginal heading “Jurisdiction of Civil Courts”,
provides:

-24-
VRKR,J
WP_18025_2021

“18. If any person is aggrieved as to any right of which he is
in possession by an entry made in any Record of Rights, he may
institute a suit against any person denying or interested to deny his
title to such right for declaration of his right under Chapter-VI of the
Specific Relief Act, 1963, and the entry in the Record of Rights shall
be amended in accordance with any such declaration.”

39. The legislature has thus itself declared, in terms, that where
title is denied the remedy lies in a suit for declaration before the civil
court, and that the entry in the record of rights is to be amended so
as to conform to that declaration. The entry follows the decree; it does
not precede or displace it. That is the very scheme which the Special
Tribunal inverted.

40. The corollary is settled beyond argument: entries in the revenue
record, and mutations effected therein, neither create nor extinguish
9
title. In Sawarni v. Inder Kaur , the Supreme Court held:
“7. … He has been swayed away by the so-called mutation in
the revenue record in favour of Inder Kaur. Mutation of a property in
the revenue record does not create or extinguish title nor has it any
presumptive value on title. It only enables the person in whose
favour mutation is ordered to pay the land revenue in question. The
learned Additional District Judge was wholly in error in coming to a
conclusion that mutation in favour of Inder Kaur conveys title in her
favour.”

9
(1996) 6 SCC 223

-25-
VRKR,J
WP_18025_2021

41. In Suraj Bhan v. Financial Commissioner , (2007) 6 SCC 186, it
was observed:
“9. There is an additional reason as to why we need not
interfere with that order under Article 136 of the Constitution. It is
well settled that an entry in revenue records does not confer title on a
person whose name appears in record-of-rights. It is settled law that
entries in the revenue records or jamabandi have only “fiscal
purpose” i.e. payment of land revenue, and no ownership is
conferred on the basis of such entries. So far as title to the property
is concerned, it can only be decided by a competent civil court (vide
Jattu Ram v. Hakam Singh). As already noted earlier, civil
proceedings in regard to genuineness of will are pending with the
High Court of Delhi. In the circumstances, we see no reason to
interfere with the order passed by the High Court in the writ
petition.”

42. The evidentiary character of the record was explained in
10
Gurunath Manohar Pavaskar v. Nagesh Siddappa Navalgund , thus:
“12. … A revenue record is not a document of title. It merely
raises a presumption in regard to possession. Presumption of
possession and/or continuity thereof both forward and backward
can also be raised under Section 110 of the Evidence Act. The courts
below, were, therefore, required to appreciate the evidence keeping
in view the correct legal principles in mind.”

11
43. More recently, in Jitendra Singh v. State of Madhya Pradesh ,
the Supreme Court, after surveying the earlier decisions, held:

10
(2007) 13 SCC 565
11
2021 SCC OnLine SC 802

-26-
VRKR,J
WP_18025_2021

“5. … Be that as it may, as per the settled proposition of law,
mutation entry does not confer any right, title or interest in favour of
the person and the mutation entry in the revenue record is only for
the fiscal purpose. As per the settled proposition of law, if there is
any dispute with respect to the title and more particularly when the
mutation entry is sought to be made on the basis of the will, the
party who is claiming title/right on the basis of the will has to
approach the appropriate civil court/court and get his rights
crystalised and only thereafter on the basis of the decision before the
civil court necessary mutation entry can be made.”

44. The same principle runs through Balwant Singh v. Daulat
12
Singh ; State of Andhra Pradesh v. Star Bone Mill and Fertiliser
13 14
Company ; T. Ravi v. B. Chinna Narasimha ; Bhimabai Mahadeo
15
Kambekar v. Arthur Import and Export Company ; Prahlad Pradhan v.
16 17
Sonu Kumhar ; and Ajit Kaur v. Darshan Singh . It has been
reiterated, in Vadiyala Prabhakar Rao v. Government of Andhra
18
Pradesh .

45. The High Court of the erstwhile composite State of Andhra
Pradesh has applied these principles in the specific setting of the ROR
Act. In Singamaneni Pullamma v. Joint Collector, Ongole, Prakasam

12
(1997) 7 SCC 137
13
(2013) 9 SCC 319
14
(2017) 7 SCC 342
15
(2019) 3 SCC 191
16
(2019) 10 SCC 259
17
(2019) 13 SCC 70
18
2026 INSC 450

-27-
VRKR,J
WP_18025_2021

19
District , a Division Bench held that the pendency of a civil suit does
not relieve the revenue authorities of the duty to discharge the
functions entrusted to them by the Act, and that entries so made
remain open to challenge in a civil suit. The reach and the limits of
20
that jurisdiction were explained in K. Pratap Reddy v. Joint Collector ,
where, considering the scope of Sections 5 and 9 of the Act of 1971,
this Court observed:
“… The Rules of 1989 framed under the Act of 1971 detail
the procedure to be followed by the revenue authorities in the course
of preparation of the record of rights as envisaged by the Act. The
scheme of the said Rules clearly indicates that the revenue
authorities are required to hold a summary enquiry into issues of title
also in certain circumstances while deciding disputes as to the
entries to be incorporated in the record of rights. The decision of a
learned Division Bench of this Court in SINGAMANENI PULLAMMA’s
case (18 supra) is also to this effect. However, this authorization to
the revenue authorities is subject to judicial determination of
disputes over issues of title and as demonstrated by Rule 9(1)(c)(ii),
once a declaration is filed by a party that he has instituted a suit in
a civil Court …”

46. The position that emerges is that the authorities under the Act
may hold a summary enquiry in order to decide who is to be recorded,
but that this authorisation is at all times subservient to the judicial

19
2004 (7) ALT 963
20
2009 (2) ALD 212 : 2009 (2) ALT 742

-28-
VRKR,J
WP_18025_2021

determination of title; where a competent civil court is seized of the
question, the revenue authorities must stay their hand.

47. Judged by these standards, the impugned order cannot stand,
for four reasons. First, the order is internally inconsistent. The
Special Tribunal itself recognised that the controversy turned upon
title and directed respondent No.6 to approach the competent civil
court for a declaration. Having so held, it was not open to the
Tribunal to proceed, in the same breath, to cancel the mutations and
the pattadar pass books standing in the names of the petitioners. An
authority which disclaims jurisdiction to decide the principal question
cannot grant consequential relief which presupposes the very
determination it has declined to make. The cancellation was, in
substance, an adjudication of title by indirection.

48. Secondly, the cancellation could serve no legitimate purpose.
Since entries in the record of rights neither confer title nor take away
rights vested in any party, their deletion could not improve the
position of respondent No.6, or of his legal representatives, in the suit
which they have since instituted. What the cancellation did achieve
was to displace the petitioners from the record of rights during the
pendency of that suit and thereby to disturb the presumption in

-29-
VRKR,J
WP_18025_2021

regard to possession which such entries raise. The Special Tribunal
thus altered the position of the parties in a manner which the civil
court alone was competent to alter.

49. Thirdly, the frame of O.S.No.288 of 2021 is itself instructive.
The suit instituted by the unofficial respondents is comprehensive in
nature, seeking not merely a declaration of title but also recovery of
possession, rectification of the entries in the revenue records and an
injunction against alienation. A prayer for recovery of possession
proceeds necessarily upon the footing that the plaintiff is out of
possession. The unofficial respondents’ own pleading therefore
establishes that the petitioners are in possession of the subject land,
and in such a situation the entries and the pattadar pass books
standing in their names ought to have been left undisturbed, to abide
the result of the suit.

50. Fourthly, the statute itself furnishes the appropriate
mechanism, and has continued to do so across the change in the law.
Section 7 of the Act of 2020, which was in force when the impugned
order was passed, provided for effecting a change in the record of
rights where a right over land was acquired through a decree of court.
Upon the repeal of that Act, the same provision is made by Section 8

-30-
VRKR,J
WP_18025_2021

of the Act of 2025, which requires a person who acquires rights over
land through any of the modes stated in clauses (h) and (s) of sub-
section (12) of Section 2 – clause (h) being an “Order / Decree of any
competent Court of Law” – to apply to the Revenue Divisional Officer
for mutation, and obliges that authority, after notice to all persons
interested or affected, to determine whether and in what manner the
record of rights is to be amended and to carry out the amendment
accordingly. Section 8 of the Act of 2025 must, moreover, be read with
Section 18 of that Act, which in terms directs that the entry in the
record of rights shall be amended in accordance with a declaration
obtained from the civil court. Whichever party succeeds in O.S.No.288
of 2021 may therefore apply under Section 8, and the revenue
authorities are obliged to give effect to the decree. The continued
presence of that machinery, under the repealed Act and under the Act
which has replaced it alike, is a further indication that the record of
rights is designed to follow the adjudication of title and not to
anticipate it. The submission of the learned Assistant Government
Pleader to that effect is well founded and is accepted. Point (iii) is
accordingly answered in favour of the petitioners and against the
unofficial respondents.


-31-
VRKR,J
WP_18025_2021

Point (iv): Relief:
51. In view of the findings recorded on Points (ii) and (iii), the
impugned order dated 25.06.2021 is liable to be set aside. Two
clarifications are, however, necessary. The first is that nothing said in
this order is to be understood as an expression of opinion upon the
title to, or the possession of, the subject property. Those questions
await adjudication in O.S.No.288 of 2021 and must be decided by the
learned Junior Civil Judge, Thorrur, uninfluenced by any observation
made here. The revenue entries and the pattadar pass books-cum-
title deeds standing in the names of the petitioners are restored to the
position obtaining immediately prior to the impugned order and shall
abide by the result of that suit, and upon its disposal it will be open
to either party to apply for a change in the record of rights under
Section 8 of the Act of 2025, being the provision now in force
corresponding to Section 7 of the Act of 2020.

52. The second is that, having regard to the finding recorded on
Point (iii), no useful purpose would be served by remitting Tribunal
Case No.273 of 2021 to the Special Tribunal or any competent
authority under the Act of 2025, for fresh disposal. The controversy is
one which the civil court alone can resolve and it is already seized of

-32-
VRKR,J
WP_18025_2021

it. The parties shall accordingly work out their rights in the pending
suit.

CONCLUSION AND RESULT
53. For the foregoing reasons, this Court is of the considered view
that the order dated 25.06.2021 passed by the Special Tribunal
cannot be sustained, both because it was passed after the death of
respondent No.6 without his legal representatives being brought on
record, and because the Special Tribunal, having relegated the parties
to the civil court upon the question of title, had no jurisdiction to
cancel the mutations and the pattadar pass books standing in the
names of the petitioners. The repeal of the Act of 2020 by the Act of
2025 during the pendency of this writ petition makes no difference to
that conclusion; if anything, Sections 8 and 18 of the Act of 2025
place the position beyond doubt.

54. Accordingly, the writ petition is allowed. The order passed by
the Special Tribunal in Tribunal Case No.273 of 2021 (ROR Appeal
Petition No.E/656/2016/RDO), dated 25.06.2021, is hereby set aside.
It is, however, made clear that this order shall not be construed as an
expression of opinion on the title or possession of either party in
respect of the subject property. The revenue entries and the Pattadar

-33-
VRKR,J
WP_18025_2021

Pass Books-cum-Title Deeds standing in the names of the petitioners
shall abide by the result of O.S.No.288 of 2021 pending on the file of
the Court of the learned Junior Civil Judge, Thorrur. There shall be
no order as to costs.

As a sequel, all pending miscellaneous applications, if any, shall
stand closed.

____________________________________
VAKITI RAMAKRISHNA REDDY, J
Date: 24.09.2026

Note: LR copy to be marked.
B/o. AS

-34-
VRKR,J
WP_18025_2021


THE HON'BLE SRI JUSTICE VAKITI RAMAKRISHNA REDDY



















WRIT PETITION No.18025 of 2021
(CNR No.HBHC010295852021)

Date: 24.09.2026









AS