Balbir Singh & Others vs Hardial Singh & Others

Court
Punjab and Haryana High Court

IN THE HIGH COURT OF PUNJAB & HARYANA
AT CHANDIGARH

Reserved on : 03.07.2026
Pronounced on : 15.09.2026
(i) RSA No.443 of 1997 (O&M)
BALBIR SINGH AND OTHERS ...APPELLANTS
VERSUS
HARDIAL SINGH AND ANOTHER ...RESPONDENTS
(ii) RSA No.1070 of 1997 (O&M)
BALBIR SINGH AND OTHERS ...APPELLANTS
VERSUS
HARDIAL SINGH AND ANOTHER ...RESPONDENTS
(iii) CWP No.8450 of 2010 (O&M)
HARDIAL SINGH AND ANOTHER ...PETITIONERS
VERSUS
GURPARTAP SINGH AND OTHERS ...RESPONDENTS
(iv) CWP No.8451 of 2010 (O&M)
HARDIAL SINGH AND ANOTHER ...PETITIONERS
VERSUS
HARMINDER SINGH AND OTHERS ...RESPONDENTS
CORAM: HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE PARMOD GOYAL
Present: Ms. Manveen Pheruman Kahlon, Advocate
for appellants in both the appeals.
Mr. Vikas Mohan Gupta, Advocate
for respondents in both the appeals and
for petitioners in both the petitions.
*
PARMOD GOYAL, J.
Dispute in present regular second appeals is as regards to
validity of Will dated 30.07.1984 relied upon by Balbir Singh and Others-
RAVINDER DHANIA
2026.09.17 17:00
I agree to specified
portions of this document

RSA No.443 of 1997 and connected matters -2-
appellants-defendants and Will dated 02.04.1986 relied upon by Hardial
Singh and Another-respondents-plaintiffs.
2. In order to claim suit property by virtue of Will dated
02.04.1986, Hardial Singh and Another-respondents-plaintiffs had filed Civil
Suit No.238 of 13.05.1993 titled as Hardial Singh & Anr. Vs. Balbir Singh
& Ors . for declaration with consequential relief of permanent injunction. On
the other hand, Balbir Singh and Others-appellants-defendants, who were
arrayed as defendants in Civil Suit No.238 of 13.05.1993 had also filed a
Civil Suit No.371 of 22.07.1993 titled as Balbir Singh & Ors. Vs. Hardial
Singh & Anr. , for permanent injunction.
3. Both the suits were tried together. Civil Suit No.238 of
13.05.1993 titled as Hardial Singh & Anr. Vs. Balbir Singh & Ors. , was
dismissed, whereas Civil Suit No.371 of 22.07.1993 titled as Balbir Singh
and Ors. Vs. Hardial Singh & Anr. , was decreed by learned Court of First
Instance vide judgment and decree dated 29.07.1995. Respondents-plaintiffs
had preferred two appeals, which were allowed by first appellate Court.
4. RSA No.443 of 1997 and RSA No.1070 of 1997 have been
preferred by appellants-Balbir Singh and Others (hereinafter referred to as
‘appellants-defendants’ ) being aggrieved by judgment and decree dated
27.01.1997 passed by learned Additional District Judge, Amritsar, whereby
judgment and decree dated 29.07.1995 passed by learned Sub Judge, First
Class, Tarn Tarn, vide which suit for permanent junction preferred by Balbir
Singh and Others-appellants-defendants was decreed and suit for declaration
preferred by Hardial Singh and Another (hereinafter referred to as
RAVINDER DHANIA
‘ respondents-plaintiffs ’) was dismissed, was set aside and suit preferred by
2026.09.17 17:00
I agree to specified
portions of this document

RSA No.443 of 1997 and connected matters -3-
respondents-plaintiffs was decreed and that of appellants-defendants was
dismissed.
5. The dispute which was raised in Civil Suit No.238 of
13.05.1993 titled as Hardial Singh and Anr. Vs. Balbir Singh and Ors., and
Civil Suit No.371 of 22.07.1993 titled as Balbir Singh and Ors. Vs. Hardial
Singh and Anr., had also given rise to CWP No.8450 of 2010 preferred by
respondents-plaintiffs against orders passed by Revenue Authorities vide
which they had rejected the claim of respondents-plaintiffs regarding setting
aside of mutation and revenue entries in favour of appellants-defendants and
CWP No.8451 of 2010 regarding mutation entered and upheld by Revenue
Authorities in favour of subsequent purchaser who had purchased the suit
property by way of sale deed from appellants-defendants. All four cases i.e.
two regular second appeals and two civil writ petitions are being dealt with
together as findings in RSA No.1070 of 1997 and RSA No.443 of 1997
would decide the fate of CWP No.8456 of 2010 and CWP No.8451 of 2010
being consequential proceedings.
6. In present appeals and petitions, the main issue is whether the
learned First Appellate Court had rightly accepted Will dated 02.04.1986 set
up by respondents-plaintiffs and had rightly rejected the Will dated
30.07.1984 set up by appellants-defendants.
7. In their suit for declaration and permanent injunction,
respondents-plaintiffs had claimed suit property on the basis of Will dated
02.04.1986 and had challenged mutation entered in favour of appellants-
defendants on the basis of Will dated 30.07.1984, which was stated to be
RAVINDER DHANIA
cancelled vide Will dated 02.04.1986. On the other hand, appellants-
2026.09.17 17:00
I agree to specified
portions of this document

RSA No.443 of 1997 and connected matters -4-
defendants had claimed their right over the suit property on the basis of Will
dated 30.07.1984.
8. From the pleadings of the parties, following issues were
framed:-
i. Whether Hardila Singh and Atma Singh are the owners in
possession of the property in dispute ? OPP.
ii) Whether Tara Singh had executed a valid will dated
2.4.86 in favour of Hardial Singh and others? OPP.
iii) Whether Hardial Singh and Atma Singh are entitled to
the declaration and injunction as prayed for? OPP.
iv) Whether the plaintiffs have no locus-standi to and cause
of action to file the present suit ? OPP (Balbir Singh and
others).
v) Whether the suit filed by Hardial Singh and others is not
maintainable in the present from? OPD
vi) Whether Tara Singh had executed a valid will dated
30:7.84 in favour of Balbir Singh and others ? OPD.
vii) Relief.
9. Learned Court of First Instance vide its judgment and decree
dated 29.07.1995 had held that Will dated 02.04.1986 is surrounded by
suspicion and is therefore liable to be ignored and further held that since
Will dated 30.07.1984 was duly mentioned in Will dated 02.04.1986,
therefore, same stands established and accordingly, learned Court of First
Instance had accepted the case set up by appellants-defendants and had
rejected the case of respondents-plaintiffs.
10. R espondents-plaintiffs in order to prove their case and validity
of Will dated 02.04.1986 had examined attesting witnesses namely, Wazir
Singh as PW1, Jaswant Singh as PW3 and Bachan Singh-Scribe of Will
RAVINDER DHANIA
dated 02.04.1986 (Ex.P1) as PW2. Hardial Singh himself appeared as PW4.
2026.09.17 17:00
I agree to specified
portions of this document

RSA No.443 of 1997 and connected matters -5-
11. On the other hand, Balbir Singh had appeared as DW1, had
produced Will dated 30.07.1984 as Ex.D1 and had examined Chaman Lal-
Scribe of Will dated 30.07.1984 as DW2, Baldev Singh-Registration Clerk
as DW3 who proved the endorsement made by Tehsildar as Ex.D2 and
Dilbag Singh as DW4 to prove that the last rites of deceased Tara Singh
were performed by appellants-defendants. Joginder Singh was also
examined as DW5, who deposed that appellants-defendants had been
serving Tara Singh during his old age.
12. Learned Court of First Instance had concluded that Will pro-
pounded by respondents-plaintiffs is surrounded by suspicious
circumstances and cannot be relied upon. Learned Court of First Instance
had duly noticed that:-
i. Bachan Singh-PW2, scribe of Will dated 02.04.1986 had
not brought the Register in which the said Will was
allegedly noted by him.
ii. Scribe was serving imprisonment for committing fraud
under Section 420 of Indian Penal Code, 1860, wherein it
was alleged that he had forged a Will.
iii. Though Will dated 02.04.1986 was scribed at Tarn Taran
and as per PW3, it was given to Sub-Registrar, however,
no explanation has come forth on as to why said Will was
not registered.
Accordingly, learned Court of First Instance had held that since respondents-
plaintiffs had failed to remove the suspicion over the Will dated 02.04.1986,
same stands not proved.
13. On the other hand, learned First Appellate Court had not
RAVINDER DHANIA accepted the reasoning given by learned Court of First Instance in rejecting
2026.09.17 17:00
I agree to specified
portions of this document

RSA No.443 of 1997 and connected matters -6-
the Will dated 02.04.1986 and concluded that the suspicious circumstances
so found were not made out. It had noted that Bachan Singh-PW2, Scribe of
the Will dated 02.04.1986 was not confronted with the fact that he was
undergoing imprisonment for committing forgery & cheating, therefore, this
fact could not have been taken into consideration by learned Court of First
Instance. Learned First Appellate Court had further noticed that the
explanation given by Bachan Singh-PW2 that entry regarding Will dated
02.04.1986 has been misplaced ought to have been accepted and there was
no reason to discard the same as no circumstances were there to conclude
that non-production of Register by Bachan Singh-PW2 was intentional.
Learned First Appellate Court had also noted that ignorance of respondents-
plaintiffs regarding execution of Will dated 02.04.1986 cannot be taken
against them as he had clearly stated that the said Will was handed over to
him only by Basant Kaur, who had died on 25.04.1993, just 1½ months prior
to her death, whereas testator of Will had died on 23.09.1990. That since
respondents-plaintiffs were not aware about execution of Will, therefore,
their ignorance regarding manner of execution of Will dated 02.04.1986
cannot be taken against them and accordingly, it was held that suspicious
circumstances against Will dated 02.04.1986 are not made out..
14. Learned First Appellate Court had also found that learned Court
of First Instance had wrongly noticed that name of Basant Kaur is not
mentioned in Will (Ex.P1), whereas it is clearly mentioned and it was held
that learned Court of First Instance had wrongly ignored Will dated
02.04.1986 as same is not surrounded by suspicious circumstances and had
RAVINDER DHANIA
2026.09.17 17:00
I agree to specified
portions of this document

RSA No.443 of 1997 and connected matters -7-
been duly proved by attesting witnesses i.e. PW1 and PW3 as well as its
PW2-Scribe.
15. Judgment of Hon’ble Supreme Court in Derek A.C. Lobo &
Ors. Vs. Ulric M.A. Lobo (dead) by L.Rs. & Ors., 2024 (2) RCR (Civil) 873
serves as pivotal reference in the realm of probate law, particularly
concerning the burden of proof in validating wills under suspicious
circumstances, therein it was held :
● Mere registration of a will does not inherently validate it; it
must still satisfy the legal requirements under Section 63 of the
Indian Succession Act and Section 68 of the Indian Evidence
Act. Moturu Nalini Kanth Vs. Gainedi Kaliprasad (Dead)
Through Lrs. , Law Finder Doc Id # 2391980.;
●
Any suspicion regarding a will's validity must be explicitly
presented by the contestant opposing the will, shifting the onus
back to the propounder to dispel such doubts. Gurdial Kaur &
Ors. Vs. Kartar Kaur & Ors. , Law Finder Doc Id # 30637 ;
●
Propounder must demonstrate the testator's sound mind and free
will in the execution of the will, especially when beneficiaries
have a prominent role in its execution. Meenakshiammal
(Dead) through LRs. Vs. Chandrasekaran, (2005) 1 SCC
280;
●
Suspicion alone cannot undermine a will unless accompanied
by substantial evidence indicating issues like undue influence or
coercion. P.P.K. Gopalan Nambiar Vs. P.P.K. Balakrishnan
Nambiar, AIR 1995 SUPREME COURT 1852;
●
The initial burden to prove the execution and validity of a will
lies with the propounders.
RAVINDER DHANIA
2026.09.17 17:00
I agree to specified
portions of this document

RSA No.443 of 1997 and connected matters -8-
●
If the opposing party raises specific and well-founded
suspicious circumstances, the burden shifts back to the
propounders to dispel these doubts.
16. Evidence led by both the parties as well as findings recorded by
learned Courts below, therefore, has to be appreciated on the touchstone of
legal principles noted-above.
17. In view of finding of reversal, it is necessary for this Court to
find out as to whether finding of learned Court of First Instance is based
upon evidence led by parties or it is the finding of learned First Appellate
Court, which was correct as per evidence lead by the parties.
18. From perusal of Will dated 02.04.1986 (Ex.D1) , Will dated
30.07.1984 (Ex.D1), evidence of witnesses, especially that of attesting
witnesses i.e. PW1 and PW3 of Will dated 02.04.1986, it is clearly made out
that the said Will relied upon by respondents-plaintiffs was allegedly signed
by testator Tara Singh, whereas Will dated 30.07.1984 was thumb-marked
by Tara Singh. It is also worth noting that Will dated 30.07.1984 finds due
mention in Will dated 02.04.1986. In Will dated 02.04.1986 (Ex.P1), it was
noticed “I had scribed Will in favour of Balbir Singh, Kashmir Singh,
Jaswant Singh, Amrik Singh and Sarabjit Singh, sons of Jagir Singh,
resident of Vancheri on 30.07.1984 registered with Sub-Registrar, Tarn
Taran, which I hereby cancel because Balbir Singh, Kashmir Singh etc. have
become disobedient to me and I no longer have faith in them and therefore,
Balbir Singh etc. and their children or anyone else shall have no connection
or concern with my property.” Therefore, in Will dated 02.04.1986 itself,
execution of Will dated 30.07.1984 in favour of Balbir Singh, Kashmir
RAVINDER DHANIA
2026.09.17 17:00
I agree to specified
portions of this document

RSA No.443 of 1997 and connected matters -9-
Singh, Jaswant Singh, Amrik Singh and Sarabjit Singh, sons of Jagir Singh
i.e. appellants-defendants was duly stated and admitted. It was also admitted
that the said Will dated 30.07.1984 was duly registered with Office of Sub-
Registrar, therefore, from Will dated 02.04.1986 (Ex.P1) relied upon by
respondents-plaintiffs, it is clearly made out that as far as Will dated
30.07.1984 is concerned, its execution in favour of appellants-defendants as
well as registration with Office of Sub-Registrar was duly noticed.
19. As far as existence of Will dated 30.07.1984 in favour of
appellants-defendants is concerned, even Jaswant Singh-PW3, one of the
attesting witnesses, had stated to have seen the same at the time of execution
of Will dated 02.04.1986. PW3 had also admitted that Will dated
30.07.1984, which was shown by none but testator-Tara Singh was in fact
thumb-marked by Tara Singh. Perusal of Will dated 02.04.1986 goes to show
that it was allegedly signed by Tara Singh. Even PW1 and PW3, the attesting
witnesses, have stated that Will dated 02.04.1986 was signed by Tara Singh.
PW3, however, had admitted that previous Will dated 30.07.1984 was
thumb-marked by Tara Singh and perusal of Will dated 30.07.1984 which
was stated to be registered with the Office of Sub-Registrar shows that same
is thumb-marked by testator-Tara Singh.
20. Once it is shown that Tara Singh used to thumb-mark
documents, it was incumbent upon respondents-plaintiffs, who are relying
upon subsequent Will dated 02.04.1986, to explain as to why Will dated
02.04.1986 made after less than two years by same testator was signed and
not thumb-marked. This raises grave suspicion on Will dated 02.04.1986.
RAVINDER DHANIA
2026.09.17 17:00
I agree to specified
portions of this document

RSA No.443 of 1997 and connected matters -10-
Thumbmarks could easily be compared whereas signatures of a person who
was not signing could not be compared for want of specimen signatures.
21. In view of admission of PW3 in his cross-examination that Tara
Singh had shown Will dated 30.07.1984 to him and same was thumb-marked
by Tara Singh, it was incumbent upon respondents-plaintiffs to prove that
signatures upon Will dated 02.04.1986 were signatures of Tara Singh and
that Tara Singh used to sign instead of thumb-marking. Once, execution and
registration of Will dated 30.07.1984 is not disputed, rather admitted by
virtue of assertions made in Will dated 02.04.1986 as well as by PW-3, it
was necessary for respondents-plaintiffs to remove suspicion regarding
signatures of Tara Singh on subsequent Will dated 02.04.1986. Since Tara
Singh used to thumb-mark papers, therefore, subsequent signatures on Will
dated 02.04.1986 raises grave doubt over the execution of Will dated
02.04.1986 and this has not been clarified by respondents-plaintiffs, who
were bound to clarify and explain the suspicious circumstances over the Will
dated 02.04.1986 as it is pro-pounder of Will who is duty bound to explain
any suspicious circumstances, which may arise over the Will.
22. Learned First Appellate Court had wrongly ignored the fact
noticed by learned Court of First Instance that Bachan Singh-PW2, scribe of
Will dated 02.04.1986, had failed to produce register in which said Will was
noted and that he was undergoing imprisonment for forgery of
will/documents. No doubt, Bachan Singh-PW2, Scribe of Will dated
02.04.1986 was not confronted with fact that he was facing imprisonment
for forgery. However, this fact had come in light after examination of PW-2
in the evidence of Hardial Singh-respondent-plaintiff. It is PW-4 who had
RAVINDER DHANIA
2026.09.17 17:00
I agree to specified
portions of this document

RSA No.443 of 1997 and connected matters -11-
stated that Bachan Singh-PW2 was undergoing imprisonment for
committing the forgery. The admission made by PW4-Hardial Singh-
respondent-plaintiff that PW2 was undergoing imprisonment for causing
forgery in fact raises suspicion over the conduct of PW2 in not producing the
register in which the Will dated 02.04.1986 was noted. It is worth noticing
that in view of grave doubt over signatures of Tara Singh on Will dated
02.04.1986, it was necessary to show the entry made in Register and to show
whether the same was thumb-marked or signed by Tara Singh or the
signatures in the entry in Register and on Will dated 02.04.1986 are same in
order to clarify suspicion arising over Will dated 02.04.1986, however, no
such effort was made by respondents-plaintiffs.
23. Respondents-plaintiffs had also failed to clarify suspicion
regarding registration of Will dated 02.04.1986. Admittedly, PW3 had
clearly stated that Will was recorded at Tarn Taran Tehsil by Bachan Singh-
PW2. PW3 had also claimed that Will was handed over to Sub-Registrar for
registration and he had not appeared before the Sub-Registrar. These facts
raises suspicion over the execution of Will dated 02.04.1986 and is not duly
explained. As to why Will dated 02.04.1986 was not registered when it was
executed in the Tehsil Office at Tarn Taran and would have been registered
nd
easily especially when it was being executed for 2 time by testator
cancelling earlier registered Will. These facts, in fact raise grave suspicion
over Will dated 02.04.1986 .
24. Therefore, the conclusion drawn by learned Court of First
Instance is based upon correct appreciation of evidence. On the other hand,
learned First Appellate Court had not correctly appreciated the evidence and
RAVINDER DHANIA
2026.09.17 17:00
I agree to specified
portions of this document

RSA No.443 of 1997 and connected matters -12-
had come to wrong conclusion ignoring the facts and circumstances so stated
by none else but by witnesses of r espondents-plaintiffs . L earned First
Appellate Court had failed to take into consideration the fact that earlier
registered Will dated 30.07.1984 was thumb-marked by testator Tara Singh,
whereas the second Will dated 02.04.1986 was signed by Tara Singh without
any explanation for this manner of execution of Will, especially, when in
Will dated 02.04.1986 due execution and registration of Will dated
30.07.1984 in favour of appellants-defendants was duly noticed and even
PW3 had admitted to have seen Will dated 30.07.1984 duly thumb-marked
by Tara Singh prior to alleged execution of Will dated 02.04.1986.
25. It was incumbent upon respondents-plaintiffs to explain
circumstances in which Will dated 30.07.1984 was thumb-marked by Tara
Singh and also that the alleged signatures on Will dated 02.04.1986 are of
none else but that of Tara Singh. This fact assumes more significance
especially when respondents-plaintiffs had admitted that PW2-Bachan
Singh-Scribe of Will dated 02.04.1986 was imprisoned in a case of forgery.
The failure to notice above discussed suspicious circumstances makes the
finding of learned First Appellate Court perverse, erroneous and cannot be
accepted. It is therefore, held that Will dated 02.04.1986 is surrounded by
suspicious circumstances and its execution is doubtful and its execution is
not proved.
26. Learned First Appellate Court had also rejected the Will dated
30.07.1984 pro-pounded by appellants-defendants on the ground that none
of the attesting witnesses was examined by appellants-defendants, however,
learned First Appellate Court had failed to take into consideration evidence
RAVINDER DHANIA
2026.09.17 17:00
I agree to specified
portions of this document

RSA No.443 of 1997 and connected matters -13-
of Balbir Singh who had appeared as DW1 and had stated that both the
attesting witnesses of Will dated 30.07.1984 had died. Moreover, execution
and registration of Will dated 30.07.1984 is not being disputed by
respondents-plaintiffs. Respondents-plaintiffs had duly placed reliance upon
Will dated 02.04.1986, which they failed to prove wherein factum of
execution Will dated 30.07.1984 in favour of appellants-defendants and its
due registration in office of Sub-Registrar is duly mentioned and noticed. In
the present case, case of respondents-plaintiffs is that registered Will dated
30.07.1984 stood cancelled and they never disputed its execution rather
admitted its existence and execution by testator-Tara Singh. Moreover,
Jaswant Singh-PW3, one of the attesting witnesses of Will dated 02.04.1986,
had also admitted in his cross-examination that Will dated 30.07.1984 was
duly shown to him by Tara Singh and same was thumb-marked. These
admissions on the part of respondents-plaintiffs in fact establish due
execution of Will dated 30.07.1984 and since it had not been found
cancelled in view of fact that Will vide which it was allegedly cancelled has
not been proved, therefore, Will dated 30.07.1984 would hold the field in a
matter of succession of estate of Tara Singh.
27. Learned First Appellate Court had rejected the Will dated
30.07.1984 setup by appellants-defendants on the ground that it was not
proved in accordance with provisions of Section 63 and 68 of Indian
Evidence Act, 1872 by examining at least one of attesting witnesses.
28. Learned counsel for the appellants-defendants had argued that
in view of Section 58 of Indian Evidence Act, 1872, facts which are
admitted, need not be proved and since respondents-plaintiffs had admitted
RAVINDER DHANIA
2026.09.17 17:00
I agree to specified
portions of this document

RSA No.443 of 1997 and connected matters -14-
due execution of Will dated 30.07.1984 by way of their pleadings as well as
same was duly noticed in Will dated 02.04.1986 relied upon by respondents-
plaintiffs, therefore, in view of provisions of Section 58 of Indian Evidence
Act, 1872, Will dated 30.07.1984 was not required to be proved again by
examining attesting witnesses who had already died.
29. In order to appreciate conclusion drawn by learned First
Appellate Court as well as arguments raised on behalf of both the sides, it is
appropriate to note down the scheme of Indian Evidence Act, 1872 which is
divided into different chapters. Chapter II contains Section 5 to Section 55
which deals with relevancy of facts. Only the facts which are relevant,
defined and held admissible under provisions of Section 5 to Section 55,
alone can be led in evidence. A fact which is not relevant cannot be led in
evidence, therefore, it is important to find out whether a fact is relevant or
not as it is only relevant fact which can be adduced in evidence. Chapter III
deals with facts which though are held to be relevant under the provisions of
Section 5 to Section 55, but need not be proved. Chapter III contains Section
56 which lays down that judicially noticeable facts need not be proved.
Section 57 exempts facts of which Court must take judicial notice. Section
58 lays down that facts admitted need not be proved. Section 58 of Indian
Evidence Act, 1872 is reproduced hereunder for ready reference:-
58. Facts admitted need not be proved.
No fact need to be proved in any proceeding which the parties
thereto or their agents agree to admit at the hearing, or which,
before the hearing, they agree to admit by any writing under
their hands, or which by any rule or pleading in force at the time
they are deemed to have admitted by their pleadings:
RAVINDER DHANIA
2026.09.17 17:00
I agree to specified
portions of this document

RSA No.443 of 1997 and connected matters -15-
Provided that the Court may, in its discretion, require the facts
admitted to be proved otherwise than by such admissions.
From the reading of Section 58, it is clearly made out where the parties have
admitted a relevant fact by way of their pleadings or admitted at hearing or
by writing, they are deemed to have admitted the fact and such fact is not
required to be proved under the provisions of Indian Evidence Act, 1872.
30. Chapter IV of Indian Evidence Act, 1872 deals with oral
evidence and Chapter V of Indian Evidence Act, 1872 deals with
documentary evidence. Under Chapter V, Section 68 deals with proof of
documents required by law to be attested. Section 68 of Indian Evidence
Act, 1872 is reproduced hereunder for ready reference:-
68. Proof of execution of document required by law to be
attested.
If a document is required by law to be attested, it shall not be
used as evidence until one attesting witness at least has been
called for the purpose of proving its execution, if there be an
attesting witness alive, and subject to the process of the Court
and capable of giving evidence :
[Provided that it shall not be necessary to call an attesting
witness in proof of the execution of any document, not being a
Will, which has been registered in accordance with the
provisions of the Indian Registration Act, 1908 (XVI of 1908),
unless its execution by the person by whom it purports to have
been executed is specifically denied.]
31. From the reading of Section 68, it is therefore, clearly made out
that in case, a document which is required by law to be attested is to be
proved, the same has to be proved by examining one of the attesting
witnesses stating due execution of same in his presence identifying
signatures of the testator and other attesting witnesses.
RAVINDER DHANIA
2026.09.17 17:00
I agree to specified
portions of this document

RSA No.443 of 1997 and connected matters -16-
32. Therefore, from the above-noted scheme of Indian Evidence
Act, 1872, it is clearly made out that oral and documentary evidence which
is required to be proved alone has to be proved in accordance with
provisions of Chapter IV and Chapter V. However, by virtue of Sections 56
to 58 certain facts which are not required to be proved, have to be taken as
proved without putting parties to the manner prescribed in Chapter IV or
Chapter V of the Indian Evidence Act, 1872. Therefore, Section 68 would
come in operation only in case, a Will is not admitted by the parties or proof
of which is not exempted under Section 58.
33. Therefore, in view of above discussion, it is clearly made out
that Will dated 30.07.1984 was duly admitted by respondents-plaintiffs in
their pleadings and had been shoswn to have been admitted by PW-3 as well
as duly noticed in Will dated 02.04.1986 (Ex.P1) relied upon by
respondents-plaintiffs, the admission on the part of respondents-plaintiffs
exempts appellants-defendants from proving Will dated 30.07.1984 (Ex.D1)
as per the provisions of Section 68. Rather Will would be admissible in view
of provisions of Section 58 of Indian Evidence Act, 1872 and admitted Will
need not be proved by examining attesting witnesses. Provisions of Sections
58 and 68 needs to be read in harmony with each other and Section 68 would
come in operation only if Section 58 is not applicable.
34. Admission is the best proof. A fact which is duly admitted needs
not to be proved by leading evidence. Wherever execution and registration
of Will is admitted, it is not incumbent to prove it again by examining both
or one of the attesting witnesses. Admission on the part of respondents-
plaintiffs regarding execution and registration of Will dated 30.07.1984 in
RAVINDER DHANIA
2026.09.17 17:00
I agree to specified
portions of this document

RSA No.443 of 1997 and connected matters -17-
favour of appellants-defendants in fact duly proves Will dated 30.07.1984.
and it was not required to be proved by examining attesting witnesses as
both the attesting witnesses had already died. Moreover, in present case,
DW-1 had duly proved that both the attesting witnesses had died and scribe
and registration clerk were duly examined. Therefore, the conclusion drawn
by learned First Appellate Court rejecting Will dated 30.07.1984 cannot be
accepted. Accordingly, Suit No.238 of 13.05.1993 preferred by respondents-
plaintiffs was rightly dismissed and Suit No.371 of 22.07.1993 was rightly
decreed by learned Court of First Instance.
35. In view of above discussion, present regular second appeals are
allowed, judgment and decree dated 29.07.1995 passed by learned Court of
First Instance is upheld and judgment and decree dated 27.01.1997 passed
by learned First Appellate Court is set aside.
CWP No.8450 of 2009 & CWP No.8451 of 2010
36. In view of the fact that both the appeals are allowed in favour of
appellants-defendants, therefore, proceedings held by revenue authorities on
the basis of Will dated 30.07.1984 cannot be held to be perverse or
erroneous. Hence, both the present civil writ petitions preferred by
respondents-plaintiffs are dismissed.
37. Pending application(s), if any, stands disposed of. Photocopy of
this order be placed on file on connected case.
(PARMOD GOYAL)
JUDGE
15.09.2026
Sunil Chander/Ravinder
Whether speaking/reasoned : Yes
Whether reportable : Yes/No
RAVINDER DHANIA
2026.09.17 17:00
I agree to specified
portions of this document