The State Of Himachal Pradesh vs Sulender

Court
Supreme Court

2026 INSC 1077
NON-REPORTABLE
IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA
CRIMINAL APPELLATE JURISDICTION

CRIMINAL APPEAL NO(S). 2400 OF 2014

STATE OF HIMACHAL
PRADESH ….APPELLANT(S)

VERSUS

SULENDER ….RESPONDENT(S)
J U D G M E N T
1. Heard.
2. The State of Himachal Pradesh is in appeal
nd
before us, assailing the judgment dated 22 April,
2014 rendered by the High Court of Himachal
1
Pradesh whereby the Division Bench, accepted the
appeal against conviction filed by the accused-
st
Sulender and set aside the judgment dated 21 May,
2008 passed by the Additional Sessions Judge, Fast
2
Track Court, Shimla in Sessions Trial No. 17-R of
2008/07 whereby the respondent had been convicted
for the offence punishable under Section 302 of the
3
Indian Penal Code, 1860 and was sentenced to

1
Hereinafter, referred to as “High Court”.
2
Hereinafter, referred to as “trial Court”.
3
For short, “IPC”.
Signature Not Verified
Digitally signed by
RAJNI MUKHI
Date: 2026.10.03
13:07:47 IST
Reason:
1

undergo rigorous imprisonment for life along with a
fine of Rs.20,000/-. The Division Bench of the High
Court, acquitted the accused of the charge of
committing the murder of his own wife Smt. Devki on
th
27 June, 2006.
3. In brief, the prosecution case is that the
respondent and his wife Smt. Devki (since deceased)
were working as labourers in the construction work
of the school building of which Krishan Kumar (PW-
5) was the Contractor.
4. The respondent-Sulender appeared at the Police
th
Station, Chirgaon on 27 June, 2006 and made a
complaint that he and his wife had gone into the open
to answer the call of nature. His wife was standing on
the roadside whereas he went to the valley side.
While he was in the process of easing himself, he
heard the cries of his wife but when he came back on
the road, she was not to be seen anywhere. Despite
making a fervent search near the road and the
riverside, when he could not trace his wife, he
returned to camp and there too, did not find his wife
present. He suspected that his wife had gone missing
with a co-labourer. On this report of the respondent,
2

a missing person report (Exhibit PW15/A) was
registered at the police station.
5. The prosecution has come out with a totally
different story, alleging that, as a matter of fact, the
accused had taken his wife to the jungle in the early
hours of morning on the pretext of having sexual
intercourse with her. She was made to lie down and
instead of performing sexual intercourse, the
respondent assaulted her with a knife and caused
injuries on her stomach, head and other parts of the
body thereby killing her. He then lifted her clothes
upwards and covered the body with the shawl and
returned to the camp. The prosecution further claims
that while the respondent was returning to the camp,
he was seen by Brahma Nand (PW-13) at a distance
of about 500 meters from the place of occurrence.
6. The trial Court concluded that the prosecution
had established the guilt of the accused by leading a
complete chain of circumstantial evidence which
pointed to the guilt of the respondent alone. These
circumstances were comprised of last seen together,
recovery of the weapon of the offence in furtherance
of the disclosure made by the respondent, and the
3

extra judicial confession made before Surender Singh
(PW-1) and Pyare Lal (PW-4).
7. In appeal, the High Court found that
circumstance No. 1, i.e. , the last seen together, was
not proved by the prosecution. Two co-labourers
Vikas and his wife Pyari Devi were cited by the
prosecution in the list of witnesses to prove this fact
but both of them were not examined at the trial.
Hence, the High Court concluded that there was no
evidence on record to show that the respondent and
the deceased had gone together from the camp at
4.30 a.m. The missing person report (Exhibit
PW15/A) lodged by the respondent was admitted, but
as per this report, the respondent and his wife went
out at about 6.00 a.m. to answer the call of nature.
8. The High Court further found that the dead
body was found at a place about 4 to 5 kilometres
away from the dera /camp and there could not be any
reason as to why the respondent and his wife would
go to such a distant place for answering the call of
nature. Thus, the High Court was of the view that the
allegation of last seen together was doubtful and not
proved on account of non-examination of the material
witnesses.
4

nd
9. The 2 circumstance relied upon by the
prosecution was pertaining to the alleged suspicious
conduct of the respondent, which was allegedly
observed by Brahma Nand (PW-13). The High Court
noticed that the only aspersion which Brahma Nand
(PW-13) made in his evidence was that he had seen
one person walking briskly, having covered himself
with a grey shawl. However, the fact remains that
Brahma Nand (PW-13) did not identify the accused to
be the said suspicious person. The High Court
further found that the mere fact that the witness (PW-
13) had seen the suspect walking briskly, that, by
itself, could not be treated to be an incriminating
circumstance and had no consequence on the case of
the prosecution.
rd
10. The 3 circumstance, being the soiling of the
clothes of the respondent by the stains of the soil,
was held to be inconsequential because admittedly
the respondent was present at the spot with the
police when the dead body was discovered. The High
Court held that it was absolutely natural that the
respondent would have assisted in lifting the dead
body of his wife and in this process, he may have got
the stains of soil on his clothes. Hence, in our
5

opinion, the said circumstance was also rightly held
to be not proved against the respondent and correctly
discarded.
th
11. The 4 circumstance was the alleged extra
judicial confession made by the respondent in the
presence of Pyare Lal (PW-4). In this regard, the High
Court considered the evidence of the material
witnesses and found that the alleged extra judicial
confession was made by the accused when PW-4
questioned him at the instance of the police. The High
Court also found that when the extra judicial
confession was allegedly made, the respondent was
in physical custody of the police, though his formal
arrest was shown later and hence, the extra judicial
confession could not be admitted in evidence.
12. The last circumstance was the recovery of the
knife. Suffice it to say that the High Court found
various lacunae in the evidence of the material
witnesses who deposed about the recovery of the
knife. Further, the High Court found that the FSL
report did not connect the recovered knife with the
commission of the crime as no opinion of matching
blood group was given by the FSL.
6

13. The High Court also took note of the fact that
the prosecution could not prove that the respondent
had any motive to murder his own wife. Concluding
thus, the High Court proceeded to acquit the
respondent of the charges by the impugned
judgment.
14. Having heard learned counsel for the appellant-
State and considering the material placed on record,
we are in complete agreement with the reasons
assigned by the High Court in the impugned
judgment whereby the respondent was acquitted of
the charges. The circumstances sought to be relied
upon by the prosecution as being incriminating
against the respondent were neither proved by
convincing evidence nor were the said circumstances
of such a nature which could form a complete
incriminating chain pointing exclusively to the guilt
of the respondent.
15. Law is well settled by a catena of decisions
4
rendered by this Court that, where two views are
possible, one favouring the prosecution and the other
favouring the accused, the appellate Court, while

4
See, Chandrappa & Ors. v. State of Karnataka , (2007) 4 SCC 415.
7

exercising jurisdiction in an appeal against acquittal,
should adopt the view favourable to the accused and
refrain from interfering with the judgment of acquittal
unless such judgment suffers from patent perversity.
16.
In the present case, having gone through the
judgment rendered by the High Court, the judgment
rendered by the trial Court and the evidence placed
on record, we are of the view that the prosecution has
fallen woefully short of bringing home the guilt of the
respondent by evidence which is conclusive and
points exclusively to the guilt of the respondent. The
nd
impugned judgment dated 22 April, 2014 does not
suffer from any infirmity warranting interference.
17. Hence, the appeal lacks merit and is accordingly
dismissed as such.
18. Pending application(s), if any, shall stand
disposed of.

……………..….……………………J.
(AUGUSTINE GEORGE MASIH)


…………….....…………………….J.
(SANDEEP MEHTA)

NEW DELHI;
SEPTEMBER 16, 2026.
8