THE STATE OF KARNATAKA vs DR VISHAL LAGAMAPPA HADAPAD S/O LAGAMAPPA
- Court
- Karnataka High Court
- 1 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-D:18956-DB
WP No. 102668 of 2025
CNR: KAHC020073292025
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA AT DHARWAD
TH
DATED THIS THE 18 DAY OF NOVEMBER, 2026
PRESENT
THE HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE M.NAGAPRASANNA
AND
THE HON'BLE MRS JUSTICE HEMA KULKARNI
WRIT PETITION NO.102668 OF 2025 (S-KAT)
BETWEEN:
1. THE STATE OF KARNATAKA,
REP. BY PRL. SECRETARY,
DEPARTMENT OF HEALTH AND
FAMILY WELFARE SERVICES,
105, FIRST FLOOR, VIKASA SOUDHA,
BENGALURU – 560 001.
2. THE COMMISSIONER,
DEPARTMENT OF HEALTH AND
TH
FAMILY WELFARE SERVICES, 5 FLOOR,
AROGYA SOUDHA, MAGADI ROAD,
BENGALURU - 560 001.
3. THE ADDITIONAL HEALTH
AND FAMILY WELFARE OFFICER,
HARI NAGAR, CHIKODI,
DIST: BELAGAVI - 591 201.
Digitally signed
by RAKESH S
HARIHAR
Location: High
Court of
Karnatka,
Dharwad Bench
… PETITIONERS
(BY SMT. GIRIJA S. HIREMATH, HCGP)
- 2 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-D:18956-DB
WP No. 102668 of 2025
CNR: KAHC020073292025
AND:
DR. VISHAL LAGAMAPPA HADAPAD S/O. LAGAMAPPA,
AGE: 46 YEARS, OCC: OPTHALMOLOGIST,
GENERAL HOSPITAL, CHIKODI,
R/O: PLOT NO.1028, SECT NO.6/1.
VANTAMURI COLONY, MAL MARUTI EXTENSION,
BELAGAVI, DIST: BELAGAVI - 590 017.
… RESPONDENT
(BY SRI. SHIVAKUMAR S. BADAWADAGI, ADVOCATE)
THIS WRIT PETITION IS FILED UNDER ARTICLES 26 AND
227 OF THE CONSTITUTION OF INDIA, PRAYING TO ISSUE A
WRIT, ORDER OR DIRECTION IN THE NATURE OF CERTIORARI
TO QUASH THE ORDER DATED 07.12.2023 PASSED BY THE
HON’BLE KARNATAKA STATE ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL,
BELAGAVI BENCH IN APPLICATION NO.10675/2022 (ANNEXURE-
B TO THE WRIT PETITION) AND ETC.
THIS WRIT PETITION, COMING ON FOR PRELIMINARY
HEARING THIS DAY, ORDER WAS MADE THEREIN AS UNDER:
CORAM: HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE M.NAGAPRASANNA
AND
HON'BLE MRS JUSTICE HEMA KULKARNI
- 3 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-D:18956-DB
WP No. 102668 of 2025
CNR: KAHC020073292025
ORAL ORDER
(PER: HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE M.NAGAPRASANNA )
1. The petitioner-State stands before us, calling in
question an order passed by the Karnataka State
Administrative Tribunal (hereinafter referred to as “the
Tribunal” for short), by which the Tribunal grants the
respondent the benefit of past service and treats him as
being under the Old Pension Scheme for the purpose of
calculation of pension and other terminal benefits, as also
for pay fixation, as is available under the Rules.
2. Heard Smt. Girija S.Hiremath, learned HCGP
appearing for the petitioners and Shri Shivakumar
S.Basawadagi, learned counsel appearing for the
respondent.
3. The facts, in brief, are as follows:
The respondent, pursuant to a direct recruitment
process, was appointed as a Medical Officer in the rank of
Assistant Commandant in the Central Reserve Police Force
(CRPF). During the subsistence of his employment in the
- 4 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-D:18956-DB
WP No. 102668 of 2025
CNR: KAHC020073292025
CRPF, the Karnataka Public Service Commission issued a
notification dated 22.07.2015, inviting applications for 82
posts of Medical Officers (Ophthalmologists). The
respondent, finding himself eligible, applied under the Ex-
Servicemen quota. He was selected and appointed as a
Medical Officer.
4. The issue is not with regard to his selection, but
with regard to fixation of his pay. The pay drawn by the
respondent as a Medical Officer in the CRPF was not
reckoned for the purpose of pay protection, nor would the
said service be reckoned for the purpose of gratuity or
terminal benefits when the time arises. Therefore, the
respondent approached the Tribunal by filing the subject
application.
5. The Tribunal, after recording elaborate reasons
and following the Rules in subsistence, allowed the
application. The same reads as under:
“13. On considering the rival contentions the
provisions under KCSRs which are relevant for
deciding the applicant’s case are:
- 5 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-D:18956-DB
WP No. 102668 of 2025
CNR: KAHC020073292025
“222. The service of a Government servant
does not qualify for pension unless it conforms
to the following three conditions:-
First - The service must be under Government.
Second - The employment must be substantive
and permanent.
Third - The service must be paid for by
Government.
These three conditions are fully explained in
the following sections.
[Note-Service of Government servants deputed
to work under the Tungabhadra Board is
deemed to be service qualifying for pension
under this rule:]
[Provided minimum qualifying service required
for a Government servant for earning pension
is [10 years]:
[Provided further that Government servants
retired between 1-9-2003 and 8-9-2006 shall
be eligible for notional fixation but not for any
arrears up to 22nd October, 2007.]
*
235-B. (1) In the cases of employees of
Central autonomous institutions who have been
allowed to be absorbed in the State
Government and vice versa their cases shall be
decided in accordance with the following
provisions, namely.-
…… …… ……
- 6 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-D:18956-DB
WP No. 102668 of 2025
CNR: KAHC020073292025
(6) These rules will be applicable only where
the transfer of the employee from one
organisation to another was/is with the consent
of the organisation under which he was serving
earlier, including cases where the individual
had secured employment directly on his own
volition provided he has applied through proper
channel/with proper permission of the
administrative authority concerned.
*
236. Service which satisfies the conditions
prescribed in Sections II and III qualifies or
does not qualify, according to the source from
which it is paid; with reference to this Rule,
service is classified as follows:-
(a) paid from the Consolidated Fund of
the State;
(b) paid from Local or other Funds
specified by Government from time to
time;
(c) paid from funds in respect to which
Government holds the position of
trustee;
(d) paid by fees levied by law, or under
the authority of Government or by
Commission;
(e) paid by the grant, in accordance with
law or custom, of a tenure in land, or any
source of income, or right to collect
money.
*
417. (2) The Government servants
claiming the benefit of combined service
shall be categorized as follows.-
- 7 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-D:18956-DB
WP No. 102668 of 2025
CNR: KAHC020073292025
(i) Those who having been
retrenched from the service of
Central/State Government secured
on their own are employed under
State/Central Government either
with or without interruption
between the date of retirement and
date of new appointment;
(ii) Those who while holding
temporary posts under
Central/State Government apply for
the posts under State/Central
Government through proper
channel with proper permission of
the administrative authority
concerned;
(iii) Those who while holding
temporary posts under
Central/State Government apply for
posts under State/Central
Government directly without
permission of the administrative
authority concerned and resign
their previous posts to join
the new appointments/posts under
Central/State Government.
(3) The benefit of combined service
may be allowed to the Government
servants in categories (i) and (ii) above.
Where an employee under category (ii) is
required for administrative reasons for
satisfying a technical requirement to
tender resignation from the temporary
post held by him before joining the new
appointment, a certificate to the effect
that such resignation had been tendered
for administrative reasons and/or to
- 8 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-D:18956-DB
WP No. 102668 of 2025
CNR: KAHC020073292025
satisfy a technical requirement to join,
with proper permission, the new posts
may be issued by the authority accepting
the resignation. A record of this
certificate may also be made in his
service book under proper attestation to
enable him to get this benefit at the time
of retirement. Government servants
under category (iii) will not be entitled to
count their previous service for pension.]
14. The reading of the above provisions makes
clear states that the past service rendered by an
employee of the Government of India has to be
taken into account for the purpose of Gratuity and
pensionary benefits. Hence, the service rendered by
the applicant in the CRPF from 15.04.2005 to
19.05.2016 has to be considered for the purpose of
Gratuity and the pensionary benefits. Further, when
the PRAN account of the applicant of Central
Government is already transferred to the Sub-
Treasury office at Chikkodi and the pensionary
contribution allowance of self and State Government
are deposited to the said account, the contention of
the respondents that the applicant’s earlier service
rendered in the Central Government cannot be
considered for pension and pensionary benefits as he
is appointed on 01.06.2016 under Rule 235 & 252-B
of KCSRs lakhs merits. Since the applicant is not
claiming any benefits under the Old Pension Scheme.
15. Further, the master Circular on lien/Technical
resignation in Central Services at Clause 9 regarding
applicability of pension scheme reads as under:
“9. Applicability of pension scheme:
In cases where Government servants,
who had originally joined government
service prior to 01.01.2004, apply for
posts in the same or other Departments
- 9 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-D:18956-DB
WP No. 102668 of 2025
CNR: KAHC020073292025
and on selection they are asked to
tender technical resignation, the past
services are counted towards pension if
the new post is in a pensionable
establishment in terms of Rule 26(2) of
CCS (Pension) Rules, 1972. They will
thus continue to be covered under the
CCS (Pension) Rules, 1972 even if they
join the new post after 01.01.2004.”
16. This Circular also clearly stipulates that
the past service rendered in the earlier Government
has to be counted towards
pension, if the new post is in a pensionable
establishment.
17. The learned Counsel for the applicant has
relied on order passed by this Tribunal in
A.No.4741/2014 which was allowed on 22.03.2019
wherein the applicant was appointed as Assistant
Geologist-1 in the Department of Geological Survey
of India and when appeared through KPSC and
appointed as Commercial Tax Officer (Vigilance-2) in
the Commercial Taxes Department he was denied
the benefit of counting past service rendered in the
Central Government. He challenged the said order
before this Tribunal and this Tribunal has quashed
the endorsement and directed the respondents to
consider the case of applicant for counting his past
service rendered in the Central Government for the
purpose of pension and service benefits in terms of
Rule 224- B read with Rule 417 of KCSRs. Aggrieved
by the said order passed by this Tribunal, the State
preferred Writ Petition before the Hon'ble High Court
of Karnataka and the Hon'ble High Court has
dismissed the said Writ Petition. Thereafter, the
benefit was extended to the said applicant.
18. Considering the said matter, even on
parity also, the benefit has to be extended to the
applicant, when already in similar circumstances the
- 10 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-D:18956-DB
WP No. 102668 of 2025
CNR: KAHC020073292025
Commercial Tax Department has extended the
benefit of past service rendered to an employee.
19. In view of the discussions made above,
we are of the considered opinion that the applicant
has made out a case for our interference.
Accordingly,
a) The application is allowed;
b) The impugned endorsement bearing
No.AaKuKa 723 HSM 2021 dated
07.01.2022 (Annexure-A38) issued by
the 1st respondent is quashed.
c) The Respondents 1 & 2 are directed to
count the past service rendered by the
applicant in the CRPF for the purpose of
pay fixation and other benefits under
Rule 222, Rule 235-B(6), Rule 236(6)
and Rule 417 of KCSRs.
d) The time for compliance is four months
from the date of receipt of copy of this
order.”
6. The State now calls in question the said order on
the solitary ground that the appointment in the Central
Reserve Police Force in the rank of Assistant Commandant
cannot be treated as service for the purpose of pay
protection or for the purpose of calculation of terminal
benefits, as the case would be.
- 11 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-D:18956-DB
WP No. 102668 of 2025
CNR: KAHC020073292025
7. The said submission would not merit acceptance
in the teeth of the Rules themselves, which permit the past
service rendered by an employee of the Central
Government, who enters the service of the State
Government, to be reckoned for the purpose of pay fixation
or for the purpose of calculation of terminal benefits, as the
case would be.
8. In identical circumstances, the Co-ordinate
Bench of this Court, in W.P. No.7609 of 2020, has held as
follows:
“The State of Karnataka through its
functionaries has filed the present writ petition being
aggrieved by the order dated 22.03.2019 passed by
the Karnataka State Administrative Tribunal,
Bangalore, in application No.4741/2014.
2. The undisputed facts reveal that the
respondent employee before this Court was a regular
employee in the Department of Geological Survey of
India. He has joined as an Assistant Geologist Grade-
I by an order dated 27.08.2001 and reported to duty
on 21.11.2001. The respondent employee appeared
in the examination of KSPC Gazetted Probationers
Examination, 1998 and the result of the examination
was declared only in the year 2006. Meaning
thereby, the respondent employee, by the time of
declaration of result during the year 2006, was
serving as an Assistant Geologist under the
Government of India. He submitted a proper
- 12 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-D:18956-DB
WP No. 102668 of 2025
CNR: KAHC020073292025
application to the Controlling Authority on
08.05.2006 seeking permission to join to the post of
Commercial Tax Inspector under the State of
Karnataka. He has subsequently joined the State of
Karnataka on 09.05.2006. The respondent-employee
thereafter submitted a representation on 10.05.2006
requesting the State of Karnataka to grant him the
benefit of the past services rendered w.e.f.
21.11.2001 i.e. the services rendered as an Assistant
Geologist in the Government of India along with pay
protection and the representation was rejected by a
communication dated 30.08.2008. It is pertinent to
note that Rule 224(b) of Karnataka Civil Service
Rules (hereinafter referred to as ‘KCSR’ for short)
was brought to the statute book by way of an
amendment on 08.05.2006. According to which an
opportunity to the employees, who were earlier
employed in the Department of Geological Survey of
India and the other Government departments, was
granted to submit a representation within three
years of their joining, for counting past services
under Rule 417 of the KCSR. He again submitted a
representation and it was rejected on 13.08.2013.
The Tribunal has allowed the application and the
State of Karnataka has filed the present writ petition
stating that Karnataka Civil Services (Extra Ordinary
Pension)(I amendment) Rules, 2010 (hereinafter
referred to as ‘Rules of 2010’ for short) came into
force on 19.11.2010 and the aforesaid Rules
provided that new recruitees to the State of
Karnataka joining on or before 01.04.2006 shall not
be entitled for pension.
3. The provisions which are necessary for
deciding the present case are reproduced as under:
Rule 214: (1) (a) Withholding or
withdrawing pension for misconduct or
negligence. - The Government reserve to
themselves the right of either withholding or
withdrawing a pension or part thereof, whether
- 13 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-D:18956-DB
WP No. 102668 of 2025
CNR: KAHC020073292025
permanently or for a specified period, if in any
departmental or judicial proceedings, the
pensioner is found guilty of grave misconduct
or negligence during the period of his service
including the service under a foreign employer
and the service rendered upon re-employment
after retirement.
(b) Recovery of pecuniary loss from
pension: The Government reserve to
themselves the right of ordering recovery from
a pension, the whole or part of any pecuniary
loss caused to the Government or to a foreign
employer under whom the Government servant
has worked on deputation or otherwise [along
with interest at eight percent per annum from
the date of occurrence of pecuniary loss to
government] If in any departmental or judicial
proceedings, the pensioner is found guilty of
grave negligence during the period of his
service, including the service rendered upon
re-employment after retirement: Provided that
the Public Service Commission shall be
consulted before any final orders are passed:
Provided further that where a part of pension is
withheld or withdrawn, the amount of pension
shall not be reduced below the amount of
minimum pension prescribed under the rules.
(2)(a) The departmental proceedings
referred to in sub-rule (1), if instituted while
the Government servant was in service
whether before his retirement or during his re-
employment, shall, after the final retirement of
the Government servant, be deemed to be
proceedings under this rule and shall be
continued and concluded by the authority by
which they were commenced in the same
manner as if the Government servant had
continued in service :
- 14 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-D:18956-DB
WP No. 102668 of 2025
CNR: KAHC020073292025
Provided that where the departmental
proceedings are instituted by an authority
other than Government, that authority shall
submit a report recording its findings to the
Government.
(b) The departmental proceedings, if not
instituted while the Government Servant was in
service, whether before his retirement or
during his re-employment,-
(i) shall not be instituted save with the
sanction of the Government.
(ii) shall not be in respect of any event
which took place more than four years
before such institution, and
(iii) shall be conducted by such authority
and in such place as the Government
may direct and in accordance with the
procedure applicable to departmental
proceedings in which an order of
dismissal from service could be made in
relation to the Government servant
during his service.
(3) No judicial proceedings, if not
instituted while the Government servant was in
service, whether before his retirement or
during his re-employment, shall be instituted in
respect of a cause of action which arose or in
respect of an event which took place, more
than four years before such institution.
(4) In the case of a Government servant
who has retired on attaining the age of
superannuation or otherwise and against whom
any departmental or judicial proceedings are
instituted or where departmental proceedings
are continued under sub-rule (2), a provisional
- 15 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-D:18956-DB
WP No. 102668 of 2025
CNR: KAHC020073292025
pension as provided in Rule 214A shall be
sanctioned.
(5) Where the Government decided not
to withhold or withdraw pension but orders
recovery of pecuniary loss from pension, the
recovery shall not ordinarily be made at a rate
exceeding one third of the pension admissible
on the date of retirement of a Government
servant.
(6) For the purpose of this rule,-
(a) departmental proceedings shall be
deemed to be instituted on the date on which
the statement of charges is issued to the
Government Servant or pensioner, or if the
Government servant has been placed under
suspension from an earlier date, on such date:
and
(b) judicial proceedings shall be deemed
to be instituted-
(i) in the case of criminal proceedings, on
the date on which the complaint or report
of a police officer, of which the
Magistrate takes cognizance is made;
and
(ii) in the case of civil proceedings, on
the date the plaint is presented in the
Court].
214-A. (1) Where any departmental or
judicial proceedings is instituted under rule
214, or where a departmental proceedings is
continued under clause (a) of the proviso
thereto against an officer who has retired on
attaining the age of compulsory retirement or
otherwise, he shall be paid during the period
- 16 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-D:18956-DB
WP No. 102668 of 2025
CNR: KAHC020073292025
commencing from the date of his retirement to
the date on which, upon conclusion of such
proceeding, final orders are passed, a
provisional pension not exceeding the
maximum pension which would have been
admissible on the basis of his qualifying service
upto the date of retirement, or if he was under
suspension on the date of retirement upto the
date immediately preceding the date on which
he was placed under suspension; but no
gratuity or deathcum-retirement gratuity shall
be paid to him until the conclusion of such
proceeding and the issue of final orders
thereon.
(2) Payment of provisional pension made
under clause (1) shall be adjusted against the
final retirement benefits sanctioned to such
officer upon conclusion of the aforesaid
proceeding but no recovery shall be made
where the pension finally sanctioned is less
than the provisional pension or the pension is
reduced or withheld either permanently or for a
specified period.
224-B. Request for counting of
qualifying service pension:
(1) Notwithstanding anything contained
in Rules 219-A, 224-A, 235, 235-A, 235-B,
248, 248-A, 248- AA, 252(b), 416, 417 every
employee desires to have benefit of counting
their previous service of additional years as
qualifying service for pension, as the case may
be under these rules shall make a request in
writing to the appointing Authority within three
years from the date of joining the Government
service or [within 31st July 2014] as the case
may be. No claim made after the above
specified time limit shall be entertained by the
appointing authority.
- 17 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-D:18956-DB
WP No. 102668 of 2025
CNR: KAHC020073292025
(2) The Appointing Authority in turn
shall, with requisite records in support of the
claim, obtain the approval of the Government
before passing the appropriate order.
417: (1) The system of allocating the
liability on account of leave salary and
pensionary charges in respect of both
permanent and temporary Government
Servants who have served under the Central
Government and State Government is as
specified below:-
(a) The liability for leave salary shall be
borne in full by the Department from
which the Government servant proceeds
on leave whether it be his parent
department or a borrowing department
with whom he is on deputation.
(b) The liability for pension including
gratuity shall be borne in full by the
Central / State Government to which the
Government servant permanently
belongs at the time of retirement.
(c) The liability for Government
contributions shall be borne by the
parent department of the Central
Government or State Government
(2) The Government Servants claiming
the benefit of combined service shall be
categorized as follows:-
(i) Those who having been retrenched
from the service of Central/State
Government secured on their own are
employed under State/ Central
Government either with or without
- 18 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-D:18956-DB
WP No. 102668 of 2025
CNR: KAHC020073292025
interruption between the date of
retirement and date of new appointment.
(ii) Those who while holding temporary
posts under Central/ State Government
apply for the posts under State/ Central
Government through proper channel with
proper permission of the administrative
authority concerned ;
(iii) Those who, while holding temporary
posts under Central / State Government
apply for the posts under State / Central
Government directly without permission
of the administrative authority concerned
and resign their previous posts to join the
new appointments / posts under Central /
State Government.
(3) The benefit of combined service may be
allowed to the Government servants in
categories (i) and (ii) above. Where an
employee under category (ii) is required for
administrative reasons for satisfying a technical
requirement to tender resignation from the
temporary post held by him before joining the
new appointment, a certificate to the effect
that such resignation had been tendered for
administrative reasons and / or to satisfy a
technical requirement to join, with proper
permission, the new posts may be issued by
the Authority accepting the resignation. A
record of this certificate may also be made in
his service book under proper attestation to
enable him to get this benefit at the time of
retirement. Government servants under
category (iii) will not be entitled to count their
previous service for pension.”
4. The aforesaid statutory provisions of
law make it very clear that the past services
- 19 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-D:18956-DB
WP No. 102668 of 2025
CNR: KAHC020073292025
rendered by an employee of the Government of
India are to be taken into account for the
purpose of granting the pensionery benefits.
Meaning thereby, for computing the pensionery
benefits, the services rendered in the
Government of India w.e.f. 21.11.2001 has to
be taken into account as has been done by the
Tribunal. The amendment to the Rules of 2010
notified on 19.11.2010 will not take away the
rights already accrued in favour of the
respondent employee prior to 01.04.2006.
(Emphasis supplied)
5. The other shocking aspect of the case is
that the Government has allowed the benefit of Rule
224-B read with Rule 417 of the KCSR to an
identically placed person in the same department
namely Sri. Veerachadra B. Hanchinal.
6. In the considered opinion of this Court,
the benefit was rightly granted to Sri. Veerachadra
B. Hanchinal by giving the correct interpretation to
the statutory provisions under Rule 224-B read with
Rule 417 of the KCSR. However, the present case is
not the case of a new recruitee/fresh recruitee to the
State of Karnataka service. The person who was
already in the services of the Government of India
has joined the services of the State of Karnataka by
submitting a technical resignation. Therefore, this
Court does not find reason to interfere with the order
passed by the Tribunal.
Resultantly, the writ petition dismissed.”
9. The Division Bench holds that, in the light of the
statutory provisions relied upon by the Tribunal in the case
at hand, it is clear that the past service rendered by an
- 20 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-D:18956-DB
WP No. 102668 of 2025
CNR: KAHC020073292025
employee in the Government of India is to be taken note of
for the purpose of grant of pensionary benefits and
computation of pension.
10. In that light, we do not find any warrant to
interfere with the well-reasoned order of the Tribunal. The
writ petition lacking in merit, stands rejected .
Sd/-
(M.NAGAPRASANNA)
JUDGE
Sd/-
(HEMA KULKARNI)
JUDGE
VNP/C: ASC
List No.: 1 Sl No.: 13