Sri Raj Kumar Bhar @ Mithun vs The State of Tripura
- Court
- Tripura High Court
TRHC010001462025 2026:THC:1536-DB
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
Crl.A(J)No.6 of 2025
Sri Raj Kumar Bhar @ Miithun,
Son of Late Laxman Kanta Bhar,
Resident of village-Mayachari, Ranchi Para,
P.S.: Kamalpur, Dhalai District, Tripura.
---- Convict-Appellant (s)
Versus
The State of Tripura
----Respondent(s)
For Appellant(s) : Mr. Pranabashis Majumder, Adv.
Mr. Suraj Dhanuk, Adv.
For Respondent(s) : Mr. Raju Datta, P.P.
Date of hearing and
date of delivery of
Judgment and Order : 18.11.2026
Whether fit for
Reporting : NO
HON’BLE JUSTICE DR. T. AMARNATH GOUD
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE BISWAJIT PALIT
Judgment & Order (Oral)
[Dr. T. Amarnath Goud, J]
This appeal is filed under Section 374(2) of Cr.P.C.
challenging the judgment of conviction and sentence dated 17.10.2023,
delivered by Learned Special Judge (POCSO), Dhalai Judicial District,
Kamalpur in case No. Special (POCSO) 06 of 2019. By the said
judgment of conviction and sentence, Learned Special Judge (POCSO)
has convicted the appellant under Section 6 of the POCSO Act, 2012
and sentenced him to suffer R.I. for 20(twenty) years and to pay a fine
of Rs.10,000/- in default to suffer R.I. for 3(three) months.
2. Heard Learned Counsel, Mr. Pranabashis Majumder
appearing on behalf of the convict-appellant. Also heard Learned P.P.,
Mr. Raju Datta appearing on behalf of the State-respondent.
Page 2 of 11
3. Arguments on behalf of the appellant in custody:
3.1. At the time of hearing, Learned Counsel for the accused in
custody first of all submitted that the present case was registered on
the basis of an FIR laid by one Sukanti Kanda and on completion of
investigation, the I.O. laid charge-sheet against the convict-appellant. It
was further submitted that on the basis of the materials on record,
Learned Special Judge, Dhalai Judicial District, Kamalpur framed a
charge against the convict-appellant under Section 6 of the POCSO Act,
2012. Learned Counsel further submitted that to substantiate the
charge, the prosecution has adduced in total 12 numbers of witnesses
and on conclusion of trial, Learned Special Judge found the appellant
guilty and convicted him accordingly. Being aggrieved by the judgment
of conviction passed by Learned Trial Court, the present appeal has
been preferred.
3.2. Learned Counsel for the appellant further submitted that the
judgment passed by Learned Trial Court suffers from various infirmities
and that on the basis of materials on record, there was no scope to
presume the convict-appellant to be guilty. But, the Learned Trial Court
did not appreciate the evidence on record properly and warranted
conviction against the convict-appellant which needs to be interfered
with.
3.3. It was further submitted by Learned Counsel for the
convict-appellant that the medical evidence on record of the prosecution
did not support the prosecution case. However, the Learned Trial Court
did not consider the same and convicted him under Section 6 of the
POCSO Act, 2012.
3.4. Learned Counsel further submitted that the evidence of the
child witnesses could not be relied upon being tutored witness but the
Page 3 of 11
Learned Trial Court, without properly considering the same, held the
appellant to be guilty. According to Learned Counsel for the convict-
appellant, the judgment passed by the Learned Trial Court suffers from
perversity, which needs to be interfered with.
3.5. Alternatively, Learned Counsel submitted that even if the
Learned Court finds the appellant to be guilty, in that case, he may be
convicted for lesser punishment as there was no specific evidence of
commission of rape or penetrative sexual assault by the appellant in
custody.
4. Arguments on behalf of the prosecution:
4.1. Learned P.P., Mr. Raju Datta appearing on behalf of the
State-respondent strongly opposed the submissions made by Learned
Counsel for the convict-appellant. Learned P.P. submitted that this is a
very unfortunate case wherein a father has committed rape upon his
own minor daughter. So, Learned P.P. submitted that there is no scope
to take any lenient view in favour of the convict-appellant and urged for
dismissal of the appeal.
4.2. It was further submitted by Learned P.P. that the evidence
of the child witnesses i.e. the victim and her brother are so trustworthy
and believable that there is no room to disbelieve their evidence.
Furthermore, the Medical Officer also very categorically stated that
there was evidence of penetration by the appellant to his own daughter.
So, there is no scope to presume the convict-appellant to be innocent
and urged for dismissal of this appeal.
5. Gist of the prosecution case:
5.1. In this case, prosecution was set into motion on the basis of
an FIR laid by one Smt. Sukanti Kanda to O/C, Kamalpur PS alleging
inter alia that on 23.01.2019, in the morning at about 9 a.m., the minor
Page 4 of 11
daughter (name withheld), aged about 4(four Years) of Rajkumar Bhar
alias Mithun Bhar, a resident of their locality informed the staff of
Anganwadi Centre at Bishnupur No.2 (Ranchi Para) that yesterday
night, when she and her brother, Rajbir Bhar were sleeping in their
room, her father i.e. the alleged accused-appellant namely, Mithun Bhar
came and removed his wearing apparel and penetrated his male organ
inside her urinal point. When the victim cried out, her father pressed
her mouth. The victim was then suffering from pain at her urinal point.
The didimani (Anganwadi staff), Anupama Debbarma i.e. helper of
Anganwadi Centre, mami (maternal aunt) of the victim namely, Sumita
Urang were also present and heard about the incident. Thereafter, her
grandmother, Jiten Urang came to the Anganwadi Centre, after getting
the news from the mami. The victim also described the incident to her.
After that, Jiten Urang informed the incident to Tapan Kharia, and he
informed the incident to the Panchayet Pradhan, Geshia Kharia and
brought all of them along with the victim to their house.
She further stated that the Panchayet Pradhan, Geshia
Kharia accompanied by some more persons, had come to the house of
Tapan Kharia when the villagers had brought Rajkumar Bhar alias
Mithun to the house of Tapan Kharia. As there was pain at the urinal
point of the victim so coconut oil was administered. Said Sukanti Kanda
laid the FIR and accordingly, this case was registered. The I.O.
completed investigation and after completion of investigation, the I.O.
laid charge-sheet against the convict-appellant.
5.2. Before the Learned Special Judge, formal charge under
Section 6 of POCSO Act, 2012 was framed to which the convict-
appellant pleaded not guilty.
Page 5 of 11
5.3. To substantiate the charge, as already stated, the
prosecution in total had adduced 12 numbers of witnesses, and the
prosecution relied upon some documents, which were marked as
exhibits.
6. We have perused the judgment delivered by the Learned
Trial Court. We have also gone through the evidence on record.
7. For the sake of convenience, let us make some reference of
the relevant part of the evidence on record.
7.1. PW1 is the victim. She deposed that few months back her
father caught hold her at night and opened her pant. After that he did
bad act with her. He inserted his male organ into her private part when
her brother was present. She could not shout as her father pressed her
mouth. She suffered pain. During her cross-examination, nothing came
out relevant.
7.2. PW2 is the Medical Officer who examined the victim and
identified the report marked as Exhibit-1. After medical examination she
stated that she found that the victim girl sustained abrasion injury over
Right Labia Majora size 0.25 x 0.15 cm in upper part of vagina size 0.15
x 0.15 cm. On examination of her private parts, she found the hymen
ruptured, centrally, fresh in nature which was suggesting that there was
recent sign of penetration into her vagina. She also examined the
accused. She put her signature on the seizure list and identified her
signature marked as Exhibit-4.
During cross-examination she stated that at the time of
examination, one woman constable was there. She further stated that
the type of abrasion suffered by the victim girl may be suffered in case
such a child falls during playing and from examination of the victim she
Page 6 of 11
arrived at the opinion that the victim girl might have been or might not
have been subjected to sexual assault.
7.3. PW12 is the brother of the victim namely, Rajbir Bhar. He
deposed that around a year back, at night, when he was sleeping with
his father and sister i.e. the victim at their home, all on a sudden, he
saw that his father was inserting his male organ to the urinal point of
his sister i.e. the victim. His sister cried out due to pain but his father
did not stop. He saw the incident but could not raise any voice due to
fear. He informed the matter to his mami on the following day. There
was light in their room so he clearly saw the incident with his own eyes.
His father also threatened him. He further deposed that at that time his
mother was in the house of his mami. He gave statement before the
Court and he put his thumb impression. He further stated that on the
following day, his sister went with him to the school Anganwadi where
her sister i.e. the victim informed the matter to their mami. His sister
also told her mami that she had burning feeling while passing urine.
During cross-examination, save and except denial, nothing came out
relevant. These are the material witnesses of the prosecution.
7.4. PW3 is Sumita Urang. She deposed that the victim is her
niece and her mother is the sister of her husband. Her mother resided
in their home and around 6(six) months back, the father of her niece
raped her at night in front of her brother. The name of the father is Raj
Kumar Bhar alias Mithun. She deposed that around 6(six) months back,
the victim informed her that she had burning sensation in her urinal
point and ultimately disclosed that on the previous night, which was a
Tuesday, her father raped her at her home in presence of her young
brother. She further deposed that at that time, the mother of the victim
was suffering from illness and ultimately she died after few days. During
Page 7 of 11
cross-examination, she stated that she had bad relation with the family
of the appellant. Nothing more came out relevant.
7.5. PW4 is a seizure list witness in whose presence the blood
specimen and materials for forensic analysis were seized by the I.O.
and he identified his signature on the seizure list marked as Exhibit-6.
7.6. PW5 is the Scientific Officer-cum-ACE, SFSL. She in course
of her examination-in-chief stated that she examined the samples and
her findings were as follows:
"The above described exhibits were subjected to visual examination
under different light sources, chemical tests and microscopic
examination. The results based on the tests are:
"The above described exhibits were subjected to visual
examination under different light sources, chemical tests and
microscopic examination. The results based on the tests are:
(i) Seminal stain/ Spermatozoa/blood stain of human origin
could not be detected in the exhibits marked as B(3), B(4) and
E.
(ii) No epithelial cell/ blood stain of human origin could be
detected in the exhibits marked as D(4) and F.
(iii) No opinion could be given regarding presence of any
foreign hair in the exhibits marked as B(2), D(2), D(3) and
D(5).
(iv) No blood stain of human origin could be detected in the
exhibit marked as B(5) and D(1)."
She declined to cross-examine by the convict-appellant.
7.7. PW6 is the recording officer who identified the Ejahar laid by
one Sukanti Kanda. He identified the Ejahar and his endorsement was
marked as Exhibit-8. Printed FIR form was marked as Exhibit-9. He also
stated that he entrusted the case to SI Jakir Hossain of Kamalpur PS for
investigation. He was declined to cross-examination by the accused-
appellant.
7.8. PW7, Sri Sabyasachi Gowala is a hearsay witness. He stated
that when he went to the Anganwadi Centre, he found the daughter of
the appellant-Raj Kumar Bhar when the daughter told him that her
Page 8 of 11
father had raped her on the night of 22.01.2019 and she was suffering
from pain in her private parts and identified the accused. During cross-
examination nothing came out relevant.
7.9. PW8, Jakir Hossain is the I.O. who conducted the
investigation of this case and laid charge-sheet against the convict-
appellant.
7.10. PW9, Smt. Sukanti Kanda is the informant who in course of
her examination-in-chief tried to reiterate her version in the FIR. During
cross-examination she stated that the mama and mami of the victim
are alive and they reside within a short distance. Nothing more came
out relevant.
7.11. PW10, Dali Urang stated that the accused was arrested by
police and that his wife had already died.
7.12. PW11, Smt. Anupama Das (Debbarma) is also a hearsay
witness. She stated that on 23.01.2019, the victim came to their
Anganwadi Centre when she disclosed that her father committed rape
upon her and identified the accused in the dock. She further stated that
the victim used to stay with her father at the relevant time and her
mother was staying at her brother’s house and was very seriously ill at
that relevant point of time and she died few days after the incident.
rd
During cross-examination she deposed that although 23 January, 2019
was a declared holiday by the Government but on that day their
Anganwadi Centre was open.
8. Discussion and conclusion:
8.1. From the evidence on record, it appears that the evidence
of the victim and her brother i.e. PW12 are so trustworthy that there is
no room to disbelieve their evidence. Furthermore, the evidence of the
Medical Officer is also crystal clear that there was abrasion injury on her
Page 9 of 11
private parts which suggest that the alleged appellant had committed
the offence upon the victim. The other witnesses of the prosecution
excepting the police personnel are although hearsay witnesses but they
categorically stated that on the following day of the incident they could
know the fact from the victim.
Learned Counsel for the convict-appellant although
submitted that the child witnesses are tutored but in this regard, he
could not satisfy this Court as to why their evidence be disbelieved.
Furthermore, the evidence of the Medical Officer was also so
trustworthy that there was no scope to disbelieve the evidence of
Medical Officer also. However, from the cross-examination of the
witnesses of the prosecution by the appellant further it appears to us
that the appellant, by the trend of cross-examination, could not raise
any doubt to disbelieve the evidences on record of the prosecution.
Thus, in our considered view, Learned Trial Court has rightly found the
appellant to be guilty.
8.2. More interestingly, in course of the examination under
Section 313 of Cr.P.C., the present appellant save and except denial,
did not say anything. He only stated that on the alleged day in the
night, the children were not with him but in this regard, by the style of
cross-examination, the accused could not make out any defence case
that on that relevant point of time those children were not present at
this residence and were not sleeping with him. Moreso, to disbelieve the
prosecution case, no evidence was also adduced by the appellant before
the Learned Trial Court.
So, it appears that after proper scrutiny of the evidence on
record and also after appreciating the evidence on record, Learned Trial
Page 10 of 11
Court has rightly found the appellant to be guilty and convicted him
accordingly.
8.3. Now, in this case, the Learned Trial Court has convicted the
appellant for commission of offence punishable under Section 6 of the
POCSO Act, 2012 to suffer R.I. for a period of 20 years and to pay fine
of Rs.10,000/- in default to suffer R.I. for 3(three) months.
The alleged incident took place on 22.01.2019. The Section
6 of POCSO Act, 2012 was amended by the Act 25 of 2019 w.e.f.
16.08.2019 and by the said amendment, the punishment was enhanced
from 10 years to 20 years.
In our considered opinion, probably, Learned Trial Court at
the time of passing of judgment did not go through the said provision or
the same was not brought to the knowledge of the Learned Trial Court
from either of the parties. So, Learned Trial Court found the appellant to
be guilty and convicted him for a period of 20 years.
Since the incident took place on 22.01.2019 i.e. prior to the
amendment of 2019 by Act 25 of 2019, which came into effect w.e.f.
16.08.2019, so, in our considered view, it would meet the ends of
justice if the punishment imposed is reduced to 10 years in place of 20
years.
8.4. In view of the above, the appeal filed by the convict-
appellant is hereby partly allowed with modification that the appellant
shall undergo R.I. for a period of 10 years in place of 20 years and he
shall also pay fine of Rs.10,000/- in default to suffer R.I. for a further
period of 3(three) months.
8.5. Fine money, if any realized, be given to the victim by the
Learned Trial Court. The period of detention undergone by the convict-
Page 11 of 11
appellant during investigation and trial in custody be set off in view of
the provision provided under Section 428 of Cr.P.C.
Learned Trial Court be asked to issue modified custody
warrant accordingly after receipt of the record immediately.
9. With this observation and direction, the present appeal
stands allowed in part and disposed of on contest.
10. Send down the LCR, if any, to the Learned Trial Court.
Supply a copy of this judgment and order to the appellant free of cost.
Also supply a copy of this judgment and order to the Superintendent
Central Jail for information and compliance.
Pending application(s), if any, also stands disposed.
JUDGE JUDGE
Snigdha
SNIGDH
A DAS
Digitally signed
by SNIGDHA DAS
Date: 2026.11.19
17:12:04 +05'30'