DEVENDER KUMAR vs DEFENCE
- Court
- Central Administrative Tribunal
1
Item No. 49 (C-4)
O.A. No. 4773/2025
Central Administrative Tribunal
Principal Bench, New Delhi
O.A. No. 4773/2025
th
This the 28 day of October, 2026
Hon’ble Mr. Manish Garg, Member (J)
DEVENDER KUMAR
S/o Late Shri Nihal Chand,
R/o Near Ramlia Ground, Vijay Chowk, Tauru, District Nuh,
Haryana Retired Skilled Electrician (HS-II), MES No. 375170
... Applicant
(By Advocate: Mr.Yogesh Kumar Mahur and Mr. Harkesh
Parashar)
Versus
1. UNION OF INDIA Through its Secretary, Ministry of
Defence, VERSUS 101 A, South Block, New Delhi 110001.
2. ENGINEER-IN-CHIEF, Military Engineer Services, Kashmir
House, Rajaji Marg, Ministry of Defence (Army), New Delhi -
110011.
3. HEADQUATERS Commander Works Engineers (AF) Military
Engineer Services Pal am, Delhi Cantt 110010.
4. EXECUTIVE ENGINEER GARRISON ENGINEER (AP),
Military Engineer Services, Sohna Alwar Road, Gurgaon -
122001.
... Respondents
(By Advocate: Mr. Dilbag Singh)
DEEKSHA 2026.11.05
16:24:12+05'30'
DHINGRA
2
Item No. 49 (C-4)
O.A. No. 4773/2025
O R D E R (ORAL)
Hon’ble Mr. Manish Garg, Member (J)
1. In the present Original Application, filed under Section
19 of the Administrative Tribunals Act, 1985, the
applicant has prayed for the following reliefs:
“a. Quash and Set-aside the Impugned order No.
P100IDK/285/3731E1(pens) Dated 27.10.2025 and
Impugned Order No. P-100IDK/285/3721E1(pens)
Dated 25.09.2025 to the extent that the Respondents
are unnecessarily denying the Retrial dues of the
applicant on the pretext of incorrect service records
and to the extent of an illegal demand of an
undertaking from the applicant that "he shall not
claim any interest on the delayed payment of pension
and other retiral dues which fell due on 28.02.2023".
as, such a demand is illegal and arbitrary as the
Retrial dues of the applicant have been delayed by the
Respondents on their own and not due to any fault of
the applicant.
b. Direct the Respondents to forthwith release all
pending retiral dues of the Applicant, including
pension, gratuity, leave encashment and post-
retirement facilities such as the CGRS Card and CSD
Canteen Card, along with interest at the rate of 18%
per annum from the date the said dues became
payable till the date of actual payment;
c. Award costs of the proceedings in favour of the
Applicant and against the Respondents;
d. Pass such other or further orders or directions as
this Ron'ble Tribunal may deem just, fit and proper in
the facts and circumstances of the case, in the interest
of justice.”
2. It is the case of the applicant that his claim for gratuity
and other pensionary benefits has been deferred by the
respondents for want of certain documents which have
DEEKSHA 2026.11.05
16:24:12+05'30'
DHINGRA
3
Item No. 49 (C-4)
O.A. No. 4773/2025
been outlined in Annexure A1 (quoted below) of the O.A.
Learned counsel for the applicant submits that the
applicant has submitted the requisite documents not just
once but three times and have been annexed with the
O.A. as Annexure A3 Colly.
“PENSION/GRATUITY CLAIM IN RESPECT OF
MES-375170 SHRI DAVINDER KUMAR, ELECT (SK)
RETIRED ON 28 FEB 2023
1. Further to this office letter No. P-1
OO/DK/285/372/E1 (Pens) dt 25 Sep 2025.
2. It has been noticed that despite several verbal
instructions issued from time-to-time you have still
not submilted the rectified documents till date.
Therefore, you are hereby directed to furnish the
following desired documents at the earliest for
processing of pension papers. The below mentioned
points are to be strictly adhered to while submitting
your documents this time:-
2.1 The name to be considered for processing of
pension papers in your case is Shri Davinder Kumar
as this is the same name mentioned in the
appointment letter offered to you at the time of
recruitment.
2.2 You have been informed several times to update
your Aadhaar Card and PAN Card documents
according to the correct date of birth as per service
records held with this office i.e. 01.03.1963 but you
have repeatedly submitted Aadhaar and PAN Card
reflecting your DOB as 07.07.1965. Mismatch of the
two is also a primary reason for failure of processing
of pension documents. The affidavit dated 05 Sep
2025 furnished by you to this effect will not suffice.
2.3 You were asked to get an updated cheque book
printed with the correct name spelling of self and
spouse but you have refused to furnish the same.
Instead, you have submitted a cancelled cheque
where spouse name is hand-written and stamped by
bank which is not acceptable.
2.4 You visited this office on 22 Sep 2025 and were
asked to furnish an undertaking stating that you will
DEEKSHA 2026.11.05
16:24:12+05'30'
DHINGRA
4
Item No. 49 (C-4)
O.A. No. 4773/2025
not claim any interest on pension wef 01 Mar 2023
till date but you blatantly refused to submit the
undertaking.
3. Please TREAT MATTTER URGENT.”
3. It is seen that by way of the counter affidavit the
respondents have raised their objections stating that the
O.A. is not maintainable. He submits that the date of
birth of the applicant mismatched with the service
records and the documents submitted by him and as per
his service record his DOB is 01.03.1963 and DOB on
Aadhar/PAN and other documents is 07.07.1965.
Accordingly, the applicant was directed to reconcile and
re-submit the documents duly corrected in all respect
which intimated vide office letter No
31000/DK/1004/AF/23/LC dated 08.07.2023. But, after
the several verbal and written reminders as per the
applicant has failed to submit the correct documents due
to which his pension claim was not being processed, with
PCOA (pension) Allahabad. He submits that the
following amount has been paid the applicant: (a) GPF
Claim Rs 34,81,454/- (b) Leave Encashment (LEC)- Rs
5,28,240/- (c) CGEIGS Rs 18,196/-. He also submits that
the applicant has also filed a suit for mandatory injuction
bearing case no. CS 2215/2022 seeking similar reliefs
DEEKSHA 2026.11.05
16:24:12+05'30'
DHINGRA
5
Item No. 49 (C-4)
O.A. No. 4773/2025
before the District Court, Gurugram. Therefore, the
present O.A. is liable to be dismissed. Learned counsel
for the respondents has also drawn attention to the office
order dated 11.05.2025 which reads as under:-
“PENSION/GRATUITY CLAIM IN R/O MES - 375170
SH DAVINDER KUMAR, ELECT (SK) RETIRED ON
28 FEB 2023 OA NO. 4773/20215: DEVENDER
KUMAR VS UOI
Respected Sir (s)
1. Please refer last date of hearing in the subject case.
2. It is informed to the Hon'ble Court that Sh
Davinder Kumar Elect (SK) retired on 28 Feb 2023
from GE (AF) Gurgaon. But due to non-signing of
pension documents and filing of similar nature of OA
No. CS 2215/2022 in district Court Gurgaon, his
pension documents got delayed for submission to
higher HQs i.e. HQ CWE (AF) Palam. After many
request and counseling, Sh Davinder Kumar had
signed his pension documents and the same were
submitted to HQ CWE (AF) Palam for further
uploading on Sparsh Portal. In Sparsh Portal, the
pension documents are to checked and scrutinized by
AO, GE (AF) Gurgaon and CDA (Army) Delhi Cantt
(Audit Department) for further processing the
pension case to PCDA (Pension) Allahabad (Audit
Authority) for release of his pensionary benefits.
3. Later on, his documents were rejected and
returned by HQ CWE (AF) Palam who have official
access to Sparsh Portal for uploading of pension
documents due to following observations after
scrutiny vide letter No. 1902/Sparsh/359/E1R DT 26
Jun 2025 & 1902/Sparsh/401/E1R DT 01 Dec 2025 &
1902/SPARSH/13/E1R dt 29 Apr 2026 (copies
attached):-
3.1 The name of pensioner is mismatched with service
records and other official documents. At some places,
his name was typed as Davinder Kumar and at some
places, it was Devender Kumar and Devender which
created ambiguity at various sections of department.
However, this office has prepared and processed his
pension documents as per name mentioned in his
DEEKSHA 2026.11.05
16:24:12+05'30'
DHINGRA
6
Item No. 49 (C-4)
O.A. No. 4773/2025
appointment letter and character certificate
submitted by the pensioner at the time of
appointment.
3.2 Name in Aadhar & PAN Card not matched with
service record.
3.3 Date of birth in Aadhar & PAN card not matched
with service record.
3.4 Bank details not matched with service record and
spouse name was also not printed on cheque leaf.
4. His pension documents were resubmitted thrice by
this office to HQ CWE (AF) Palam but the same was
not considered and returned with observations for
correction and re-submission of pension documents.
It is pertinent to mention here that this office has
counseled Sh Davinder Kumar for resubmission of
correct documents for our onward submission to
higher HQs but he failed to submit the same. It is the
mandatory duty of the pensioner to provide correct
and authenticated documents to the department as
per check list for early release of the pensionary
benefits. In the absence of correct documents, HQ
CWE (AF) Palam refused to accept his pension
documents for further submission on SPARSH Portal
vide their letter No. 1902/SPARSH/13/E1R dt 29 Apr
2026 (copy attached) as the same will be objected and
returned by audit authorities i.e. AO, GE (AF)
Gurgaon and CDA (Army) Delhi Cantt governed by
PCDA (Pension) Allahabad (Audit Department) at
later stage.
5. At last it is submitted to Hon'ble Court that this
office has taken all the necessary and precautionary
steps in order to release his pension, but due to lack of
submission of correct documents by the individual
which are required by HQ CWE (AF) Palam for
uploading on SPARSH Portal and non-cooperation
by individual with department, his case for release of
pension gets delayed several times. It is also
requested to Hon'ble Court that onus of delay in
submission of correct documents required by HQ
CWE (AF) Palam will rest with Sh Davinder Kumar
Elect (SK), Retd on 28 Feb 2023.”
4. Learned counsel for the respondents has also placed on
record the service record of the applicant placed as
DEEKSHA 2026.11.05
16:24:12+05'30'
DHINGRA
7
Item No. 49 (C-4)
O.A. No. 4773/2025
Annexure A3 with the reply where the date of birth of the
applicant is mentioned as 01.03.1963 and the date of
appointment as 23.03.1994. He submits that the matter
is to be decided by respondent No. 3 which is the
competent authority for deciding such claims. He further
submitted that after the introduction of the SPARSH
Portal, unless and until the applicant makes a change in
the documents in support of his claim the case of the
applicant for grant of pension cannot be processed due to
technical issues resulting in the delay.
5. In rejoinder, learned counsel for the applicant submitted
that no doubt a civil suit has been filed by the applicant,
however, the prayer in the same was different which
cannot have a bearing on the present O.A.
“It is therefore, prayed that a decree for mandatory
injunction directing the defendants to supply the copy
of information about the father nominee details as
per respondent No. 5 service record book and the
details of the family pension documents which was
signed by the plaintiff mother at the time of death of
Late Nihal Chand and other documents may kindly
be passed in favour of the plaintiff and against the
defendants with costs of the suit. Any other relief
which this Hon’ble Court deems fit and proper may
also be passed in favour of the plaintiff and against
the defendants.”
6. He submits that he has already given an undertaking
before the competent court which reads as under:-
DEEKSHA 2026.11.05
16:24:12+05'30'
DHINGRA
8
Item No. 49 (C-4)
O.A. No. 4773/2025
“I, MES-375170, Devender Kumar, applicant in Civil
Suit No. CS/2215/2022 filed against UOI & Others at
Hon’ble Civil Judge (JR DIV) Gurgaon hereby stated
that I am withdrawing the above mentioned Civil
Suit with immediate effect.”
7. He further submits that as per the service book the date
of birth of 01.03.1963 should be reckoned and he is
willing to give an undertaking in this regard and will not
seek any change or correction.
8. I have heard the learned counsels for the parties as also
gone through the pleadings available on record.
9. It is not in dispute that the applicant retired on attaining
the age of superannuation on 28.02.2023. It is also not in
dispute that certain payments have been released to the
applicant. The only technical obstacle coming in the way
of grant of pension and CGHS Card is the non-uploading
of the documents due to mismatch of the date of births
mentioned on the Aadhar Card and the PAN Card.
However, as the applicant is willing to give an
undertaking about the date of birth as per the service
record within a week from today, the abovementioned
mismatch cannot be allowed to come in the way of grant
of pensionary benefits to the applicant.
10. With reference to the mismatch in the dates of birth
mentioned in the service record, the Aadhar Card and the
DEEKSHA 2026.11.05
16:24:12+05'30'
DHINGRA
9
Item No. 49 (C-4)
O.A. No. 4773/2025
PAN Card, learned counsel for the applicant submits that
the applicant has submitted various documents in
support of his claim and is willing to give an undertaking
by way of an affidavit that he is willing to accept the date
mentioned in the service book and these documents can
always be uploaded by the respondents in the portal.
11. Contemplating another situation in the present is that
prior to the introduction of SPARSH Portal, the pension
documents were scrutinized manually and such cases
were processed manually. Moreover, it is seen that
certain amount has already been paid to the applicant,
therefore, the case of impersonation cannot be made out.
The correction of the Aadhar Card and PAN Card is all
together a different matter which cannot be delved into
here. Mere technical grounds should not be an
impediment in the grant of pension and pensionary
benefits to the applicant. The contentions of the
respondents is rejected outrightly.
12. Therefore, the O.A. is disposed of with the following
directions:-
i. The respondent (R-3) is directed to take an
appropriate decision on the undertaking and
DEEKSHA 2026.11.05
16:24:12+05'30'
DHINGRA
10
Item No. 49 (C-4)
O.A. No. 4773/2025
affidavit filed by the applicant within one week
from the date of receipt of the same.
ii. Thereafter, the respondents shall process the case
of the applicant and pass an appropriate order of
PPO and release all the pensionary benefits of the
applicant including grant of monthly pension and
all the arrears of pension, gratuity, leave
encashment etc.
iii. The respondents shall also take the necessary steps
to ensure issuance of the CGHS Card to the card.
iv. Needless to say the applicant shall be entitled to
interest on all the delayed payments at the rate
applicable on GPF deposits from the date the
payments were due till the dates when the amounts
are actually paid.
v. The aforesaid directions shall be complied with
within a period of 45 days from the date of receipt
of a certified copy of this order.
13. There shall be no order as to costs.
(Manish Garg)
Member (J)
/dd /
DEEKSHA 2026.11.05
16:24:12+05'30'
DHINGRA