MR JAVAREGOWDA vs THE MANAGING DIRECTOR
- Court
- Karnataka High Court
- 1 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:55637-DB
COMAP No. 29 of 2026
C/W COMAP No. 468 of 2025
CNR: KAHC010022642026
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA AT BENGALURU
TH
DATED THIS THE 6 DAY OF OCTOBER, 2026
PRESENT
THE HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE D K SINGH
AND
THE HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE H.SHANTHI BHUSHAN
COMMERCIAL APPEAL NO. 29 OF 2026
C/W
COMMERCIAL APPEAL NO. 468 OF 2025
IN COMAP No. 29/2026:
BETWEEN:
1. THE MANAGING DIRECTOR
CAUVERY NEERAVARI NIGAM LIMITED,
ANANDA RAO CIRCLE, BANGALORE 560 001.
REP. BY DEVARAJ.S.M
2. THE CHIEF ENGINEER
CAUVERY NEERVARI NIGAMMA (L)
GORURU (POST) HASSAN DISTRICT.
REP BY BEEMANAIK.G
3. THE EXECUTIVE ENGINEER
NO.7, H.L.B.C DIVISION,
CAUVERY NEERAVARI NIGAMA (L)
NAGAMANGALA, MANDYA DISTRICT.
REP BY SUBRAMANYA.
…APPELLANTS
(BY SRI. GAUTHAM B.S, ADVOCATE)
AND:
SRI.JAVAREGOWDA
CONTRACTOR,
B2/4, SRI. ANNAPURNESHWARI NILAYA,
NEAR B M TEMPLE, VAGDEVI NAGAR,
ST
TELECOM LAYOUT, 1 STAGE, MYSORE – 560 009.
…RESPONDENT
(BY SRI. S.K.MITHUN, ADVOCATE)
Digitally signed
by B VEENA
KUMARI
Location:
HIGH COURT
OF
KARNATAKA
- 2 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:55637-DB
COMAP No. 29 of 2026
C/W COMAP No. 468 of 2025
CNR: KAHC010022642026
THIS COMAP FILED UNDER SECTION 13(1-A) OF COMMERCIAL
COURTS ACT, PRAYING TO SET ASIDE THE JUDGMENT AND DECREE
DATED 28.03.2025 PASSED IN COMMERCIAL OS NO.1/2020 ON THE
FILE OF THE PRINCIPAL DISTRICT JUDGE, AT MANDYA, SUIT BE
DISMISSED AND THIS APPEAL BE ALLOWED WITH COSTS
THROUGHOUT, IN THE INTEREST OF JUSTICE AND EQUITY.
IN COMAP NO. 468/2025:
BETWEEN:
MR.JAVAREGOWDA
S/O LATE THIMME GOWDA
AGED ABOUT 71 YEARS,
CLASS I REGD. CONTRACTOR (CIVIL),
RESIDENT AT NO.B 2/4,
SRI.ANNAPURNESHWARI NILAYA,
NEAR B.M. TEMPLE, VAGDEVI NAGAR,
ST
TELECOM LAYOUT, 1 STAGE, MYSORE - 560 009.
...APPELLANT
(BY SRI. S.K.MITHUN ,ADVOCATE)
AND:
1. THE MANAGING DIRECTOR
CAUVERY NEERAVARI NIGAMA (L)
ANANDA RAO CIRCLE, BANGALORE - 560 001.
2. THE CHIEF ENGINEER,
CAUVERY NEERAVARI NIGAM LIMITED,
GORUR (POST), HASSAN DISTRICT – 573 201.
3. THE EXECUTIVE ENGINEER,
NO. 7, H.L.B.C DIVISION,
CAUVERY NEERAVARI NIGAMA (L)
NAGAMANGALA, MANDYA DISTRICT – 571 401.
...RESPONDENTS
(BY SRI. GAUTHAM B.S, ADVOCATE FOR R1 TO R3)
THIS COMAP FILED UNDER SECTION 13 (1-A) OF
COMMERCIAL COURTS ACT, PRAYING TO SET ASIDE THE
JUDGMENT AND DECREE PASSED IN COM.OS NO.1/2020 DATED
28.03.2025 PASSED BY THE LEARNED PRL DISTRICT AND
SESSIONS JUDGE, MANDYA AND ALLOW THIS APPEAL, IN THE
INTERESTS OF JUSTICE AND EQUITY.
- 3 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:55637-DB
COMAP No. 29 of 2026
C/W COMAP No. 468 of 2025
CNR: KAHC010022642026
THESE APPEALS, COMING ON FOR ADMISSION, THIS DAY,
JUDGMENT WAS DELIVERED THEREIN AS UNDER:
CORAM: HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE D K SINGH
AND
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE H.SHANTHI BHUSHAN
ORAL JUDGMENT
(PER: HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE H.SHANTHI BHUSHAN)
These connected appeals are filed calling in question the
common Judgment and Decree dated 28.03.2025 passed by
the Principal District Judge, Mandya ( ‘Commercial Court’ ), in
Comm.O.S.No.1/2020.
2. Commercial Appeal No.468/2025 has been
preferred by the plaintiff, while Commercial Appeal No.29/2026
has been preferred by the defendants. Since both appeals arise
out of the same Judgment and Decree and involve common
questions for consideration, COMAP No.468/2025 is taken up as
the lead matter and both appeals are heard and disposed of by
this common judgment.
3. For the sake of convenience and to avoid confusion,
the parties shall be referred to by their respective ranks before
the Commercial Court.
- 4 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:55637-DB
COMAP No. 29 of 2026
C/W COMAP No. 468 of 2025
CNR: KAHC010022642026
I. Facts of the Plaintiff:
4. The plaintiff, a Class-I registered Civil Contractor,
participated in the Tender notification issued by the
Government of Karnataka for the work of formation of
"Muruhallada Kere" under 5-L Sub-Distributary of D-72. His
tender was accepted by the defendants on 14.02.2008 and a
letter of acceptance was issued on 31.03.2008. The contract
was valued at Rs.62,64,200/- under Agreement No.163/2007-
08 dated 31.03.2008. According to the plaintiff, immediately
upon receipt of the work order, he deployed machinery, labour
and other necessary resources at the site. He claims to have
completed nearly 90% of the work by 24.02.2009, within the
stipulated period. However, by communication dated
17.04.2009, the defendants instructed him to stop further
execution of the work on the ground that the designs and other
necessary approvals had not been obtained.
5. It is his specific case that the defendants had
neither furnished the required drawings along with the tender
documents nor made them available during execution of the
work. Owing to this, the remaining work could not be
- 5 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:55637-DB
COMAP No. 29 of 2026
C/W COMAP No. 468 of 2025
CNR: KAHC010022642026
proceeded with, though the machinery and labour had already
been deployed at the site.
6. The plaintiff further contended that there was
considerable delay in making payments for the work already
executed and that several quantities of work carried out under
the instructions of the site engineers were not properly
recorded in the measurement books. He alleged that the
defendants had also failed to account for excess excavation,
embankment work, steel, concrete and other additional items
executed at the site. According to him, these claims arose out
of successive breaches committed by the defendants and could
be quantified only after completion of the work and
examination of the actual quantities. He relied upon the
correspondence addressed to the defendants, the measurement
records, bills, photographs and the reports produced in the
proceedings.
7. The plaintiff also referred to his representations
dated 12.04.2013 and 22.05.2023 as well as the subsequent
rejection of his claims by communication dated 27.05.2013.
Ultimately, seeking settlement of the outstanding claims, he
- 6 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:55637-DB
COMAP No. 29 of 2026
C/W COMAP No. 468 of 2025
CNR: KAHC010022642026
instituted the suit on 09.06.2014, claiming Rs.1,75,27,456/-
with interest at 12% per annum, under 21 heads of claim.
II. Defence of the defendants
8. The defendants, while admitting the award of the
contract and execution of the agreement, disputed the extent
of work claimed by the plaintiff. The third defendant, who alone
filed the written statement, contended that the plaintiff had
completed only 82% of the work and that payments had been
made in accordance with the measurements recorded and the
work actually executed. It was specifically contended that the
First and Part Bill for Rs.50,88,010/- had been submitted on
24.02.2009. Thereafter, a sum of Rs.22,00,000/- was paid on
13.03.2009. A further sum of Rs.10,00,000/- was paid under
Voucher No.23 dated 18.04.2009 and Rs.18,88,000/- under
Voucher No.61 dated 27.08.2009.
9. Thus, according to the defendants, a total sum of
Rs.50,88,000/- had been paid to the plaintiff. They also
contended that the plaintiff had accepted the payments without
raising any objection either to the measurements recorded or
to the quantities taken into account while preparing the bills.
- 7 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:55637-DB
COMAP No. 29 of 2026
C/W COMAP No. 468 of 2025
CNR: KAHC010022642026
10. It was further contended that the plaintiff could not
claim payment for additional quantities without complying with
the relevant conditions of the agreement, particularly Clause
13(a)(ii) and (iii). The defendants relied upon the original
tender document, Schedule-B, running bills, measurement
reports, log books and the report prepared by the Assistant
Executive Engineer. According to them, the measurements had
been properly recorded and the plaintiff was not entitled to
claim amounts beyond the quantities actually executed and
verified.
11. They also disputed the allegations of breach and
delay in payment, contending that the claims were
exaggerated, unsupported by the contractual records and
largely imaginary. The defendants maintained that the plaintiff
had received the amounts due to him without protest and
sought dismissal of the suit.
III. Issues framed by the Commercial Court:
12. On the basis of the pleadings, the Commercial Court
framed the following issues for consideration:
1. Whether the plaintiff proves that he carried out
contract work as per tender notification, and
agreement dated 31.03.2008?
- 8 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:55637-DB
COMAP No. 29 of 2026
C/W COMAP No. 468 of 2025
CNR: KAHC010022642026
2. Whether the plaintiff further proves that the
defendant has to pay Rs.1,75,27,456-00 as
arrears of bill amount?
3. Whether the defendants proves that already they
have paid all due amount as per agreement and
as per work done by the plaintiff?
4. Whether the plaintiff is entitle for recovery of
Rs.1,75,27,456-00 with interest at the rate of
Rs.12% per annum?
5. What or Decree?
IV. Judgment of the Commercial Court:
13. The Commercial Court, after considering the oral
and documentary evidence, answered Issue Nos.1, 2 and 4
partly in the affirmative and Issue No.3 in the negative. The
plaintiff examined himself as PW-1 and examined one
T.Thimmaiah, a retired Assistant Executive Engineer, as PW-2.
Exs.P-1 to P-43 were marked on his behalf. On the other hand,
M.R.Nataraju, Executive Engineer, was examined as DW-1 and
Smt.Shilpa, Executive Engineer, as DW-2, and Exs.D-1 to D-30
were marked for the defendants.
14. The Commercial Court noticed that the award of the
contract, execution of the agreement and the defendants'
direction dated 17.04.2009 to stop the work were admitted.
However, it did not accept the plaintiff's claim that all the
quantities and additional works stated by him had been
- 9 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:55637-DB
COMAP No. 29 of 2026
C/W COMAP No. 468 of 2025
CNR: KAHC010022642026
established. In particular, while examining the individual
claims, the Court compared the entries in the Measurement
Book, Ex.P-29, with the reports submitted by the Assistant
Executive Engineer, including Ex.D-19, and the statements
showing the additional financial implication prepared by the
defendants under Exs.D-25 and D-26.
15. The Court noticed that the defendants themselves
had acknowledged additional work and had quantified an
amount of Rs.7,22,000/- as payable towards such work. At the
same time, the Court declined to accept several other claims
for want of supporting material and independent proof of the
quantities asserted by the plaintiff.
16. Insofar as the claim for interest was concerned, the
Commercial Court did not accept the plaintiff's demand for
interest at 12% per annum from the date of the agreement.
Taking 28.08.2009, the date on which the last payment of
Rs.18,80,000/- was made, as the relevant date, it awarded
interest at 9% per annum till realization. The Court referred to
the decision of the Hon'ble Supreme Court in Kailash Nath
- 10 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:55637-DB
COMAP No. 29 of 2026
C/W COMAP No. 468 of 2025
CNR: KAHC010022642026
1
Associates v. Delhi Development Authority and Another .
Accordingly, by judgment and decree dated 28.03.2025, the
suit was decreed in part with costs, directing the defendants to
pay Rs.19,03,170/- with interest at 9% per annum from
28.08.2009 till realization. The decree was signed on
09.04.2025.
V. Commercial Appeal No.468/2025 & Commercial
Appeal No.29/2026
17. Aggrieved by the judgment and decree dated
28.03.2025 passed in Com.O.S.No.1/2020, the plaintiff has
preferred Commercial Appeal No.468/2025 under Section
13(1A) of the Commercial Courts Act, 2015 read with Section
96 of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908, calling in question the
decree passed by the Commercial Court. The defendants have
also preferred Commercial Appeal No.29/2026, seeking to set
aside the judgment and decree in its entirety and consequently
dismiss the suit.
18. While the plaintiff assails the decree insofar as it is
adverse to his claims, the defendants dispute their liability to
1
(2015) 4 SCC 136.
- 11 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:55637-DB
COMAP No. 29 of 2026
C/W COMAP No. 468 of 2025
CNR: KAHC010022642026
pay the amount decreed, contending that the Commercial Court
has erroneously appreciated the evidence, overlooked the plea
of limitation and awarded amounts unsupported by the
contractual records. Thus, both sides have challenged the same
judgment and decree, though on different grounds and seeking
opposing reliefs.
VI. Grounds urged in the appeal in 468/2025
19. The principal grievance of the plaintiff is that the
Commercial Court, despite noticing the defendants' own
documents acknowledging execution of excess quantities and
additional work, failed to properly appreciate the claims under
the different heads. It is contended that the Court has placed
undue reliance upon Ex.D-29, the Measurement Book, though
its correctness was specifically disputed by the plaintiff with
reference to Ex.P-33. The plaintiff further submits that the
Commercial Court failed to properly consider Ex.P-5, Ex.P-8,
the Civil Aid report, Ex.P-38 photographs and the evidence of
PW-2, particularly with regard to the additional excavation,
removal of jungle growth, use of steel and other materials.
- 12 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:55637-DB
COMAP No. 29 of 2026
C/W COMAP No. 468 of 2025
CNR: KAHC010022642026
20. It is also urged that the defendants had not
disputed the work contemporaneously, despite receiving
several representations from the plaintiff. According to the
plaintiff, the Commercial Court has therefore failed to
appreciate the cumulative effect of the contractual breaches
and the documentary evidence, and has rejected several claims
without proper reasons. The plaintiff assails the findings of the
Commercial Court insofar as they deny the balance of his claim
of Rs.1,75,27,456/-, together with the interest claimed
thereon.
VII. Grounds urged in the appeal in 29/2026:
21. The defendants contend that the Commercial Court
has failed to properly appreciate the oral and documentary
evidence and has erroneously decreed the suit for
Rs.19,03,170/- with interest at 9% per annum from
28.08.2009 till realization, despite the fact that the plaintiff had
completed only 82% of the contractual work and had already
received a total sum of Rs.50,88,000/-, as well as a further
balance payment of Rs.1,47,711/, without raising any
objection.
- 13 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:55637-DB
COMAP No. 29 of 2026
C/W COMAP No. 468 of 2025
CNR: KAHC010022642026
22. It is further contended that the plaintiff had
undertaken additional work contrary to the terms of the
agreement and, therefore, could not claim any amount for such
unauthorised work. The defendants also question the finding
recorded on Issue No.3 and contend that the Commercial Court
failed to consider the plea of limitation, though the suit was
instituted after receipt of the final payment and without any
proper explanation for the delay.
23. The amounts awarded under the heads of overhead
charges and idle charges, particularly Rs.2,00,000/- under each
head, are assailed as being without supporting evidence and
based on assumptions. It is their further grievance that the
Commercial Court has awarded interest at 9% per annum
without proper justification. On these grounds, the defendants
contend that the impugned judgment is contrary to the
pleadings and evidence on record, suffers from erroneous
appreciation of facts and law, and is liable to be set aside in its
entirety.
24. We have heard Shri Gautham B.S., learned counsel
appearing for the defendants and Shri S.K.Mithun, learned
- 14 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:55637-DB
COMAP No. 29 of 2026
C/W COMAP No. 468 of 2025
CNR: KAHC010022642026
counsel appearing for the plaintiff and we have carefully
perused the records of the case before us. As such, the point
that arises for our consideration is:
"Whether plaintiff and defendants have made out
any ground to interfere with the judgment and
decree dated 28.03.2025 passed by the learned
Commercial Court in Com.O.S.No.1/2020?"
VIII. Reasoning and Conclusion:
25. The controversy in these two appeals arises out of
the same contract agreement dated 31.03.2008, entered into
between the plaintiff and the defendants for formation of
Muruhallada Kere under 5-L Sub-Distributary of D-72, for a
total contract value of Rs.62,64,200/-. The plaintiff was
required to complete the work on or before 11.07.2009. His
specific case is that nearly 90% of the work had been
completed by 24.02.2009, but the defendants dispute the
extent of work executed and maintain that only 82% of the
work had been completed. It is not in dispute that, by
communication dated 17.04.2009, the defendants instructed
the plaintiff to stop further execution of the work.
26. The defendants claim to have paid Rs.50,88,000/-
towards the contract. Subsequently, by letter dated
- 15 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:55637-DB
COMAP No. 29 of 2026
C/W COMAP No. 468 of 2025
CNR: KAHC010022642026
29.12.2012, the plaintiff was called upon to collect the
remaining amount of Rs.1,47,711/-, which, according to the
defendants, was received without any protest or reservation.
The suit, however, came to be instituted in the year 2014,
claiming Rs.1,75,27,456/- with interest at 12% per annum. The
magnitude of the claim itself requires examination in the
background of the original contract value and the payments
admittedly received.
27. The plaintiff examined himself as PW-1 and
examined T. Thimmaiah, a retired Assistant Executive Engineer,
as PW-2. The defendants examined M.R.Nataraju, Executive
Engineer, as DW-1 and Shilpa, Executive Engineer, as DW-2.
Exs.P-1 to P-43 and Exs.D-1 to D-30 were marked. On a careful
consideration of the cross-examination of PW-1 dated
02.12.2015, certain admissions assume considerable
importance. The plaintiff's assertion that 90% of the work had
been completed by 24.02.2009 does not satisfactorily
correspond with the contemporaneous measurement records. If
such a substantial portion of the work had indeed been
- 16 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:55637-DB
COMAP No. 29 of 2026
C/W COMAP No. 468 of 2025
CNR: KAHC010022642026
completed, the corresponding entries ought ordinarily to have
found a place in the Measurement Book.
28. The plaintiff cannot establish the execution of the
work merely by asserting that the site engineers had instructed
him to carry out additional quantities. The Measurement Book,
particularly Ex.P-29, was the best available record to establish
the actual work executed, the measurements taken and the
quantities accepted by the departmental officers. Ex.P-38
photographs may indicate the existence of certain work at the
site, but they do not establish the precise quantity executed,
the date of execution or the contractual liability of the
defendants to make payment for such work. The photographs,
therefore, cannot substitute the measurement records.
29. There is another circumstance which cannot be
overlooked. Ex.P-8, described as the First and Part Bill, was
prepared by PW-2, Thimmaiah, who, after retirement, was
working in the plaintiff's office. PW-1 admitted in his cross-
examination that the said bill was prepared by PW-2. He also
gave inconsistent answers regarding the presence of PW-2 at
the time of taking measurements. More importantly, Ex.P-8,
- 17 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:55637-DB
COMAP No. 29 of 2026
C/W COMAP No. 468 of 2025
CNR: KAHC010022642026
running into over 40 pages, does not bear the signatures of the
engineers or the responsible officers of Cauvery Neeravari
Nigama. Had the measurements and quantities been accepted
by the departmental authorities, their signatures would have
lent considerable assurance to the plaintiff's claim. That is not
the position here.
30. The plaintiff's own evidence, therefore, does not
provide the necessary assurance regarding the correctness of
the quantities claimed. Ex.D-19, the report of the Assistant
Executive Engineer, and Exs.D-25 and D-26, the statements
prepared by the defendants showing the additional financial
implications, also require consideration. Ex.D-19 indicates that,
out of the 26 items of work, certain items had not been
executed at all, while in respect of some other items the
quantities exceeded those mentioned in Schedule-B.
31. The defendants had nevertheless acknowledged an
amount of Rs.7,22,000/- as payable towards excess quantities.
Such an admission cannot be ignored, but neither can it be
treated as proof of every other claim made by the plaintiff. The
additional work had to be established item-wise and in
- 18 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:55637-DB
COMAP No. 29 of 2026
C/W COMAP No. 468 of 2025
CNR: KAHC010022642026
accordance with the terms of the agreement. A contractor
cannot claim payment for work which was not executed, nor
can an amount be claimed merely because the plaintiff says
that the site engineer orally instructed him to undertake work
beyond the tender quantities.
32. The plea of limitation raised by the defendants goes
to the root of the matter and, in the facts of the present case,
deserves serious consideration. The work was stopped on
17.04.2009. The defendants thereafter undertook verification of
the work and, by letter dated 29.12.2012, called upon the
plaintiff to receive the balance amount of Rs.1,47,711/-. The
defendants specifically contend that the plaintiff received the
said amount without raising any objection. Even if the date of
receipt of this final balance amount is taken as the relevant
starting point, the plaintiff ought to have instituted the suit
within three years thereafter.
33. The legal notice dated 02.09.2013 and the reply
dated 04.12.2013 do not, by themselves, extend the period of
limitation. There is no material to establish any subsequent
acknowledgment of liability by the defendants within the
- 19 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:55637-DB
COMAP No. 29 of 2026
C/W COMAP No. 468 of 2025
CNR: KAHC010022642026
prescribed period so as to attract Section 18 of the Limitation
Act. The suit instituted in the year 2020 is thus beyond the
period of three years. The defendants had specifically pleaded
that the suit was barred by limitation.
34. The Supreme Court while dealing with a similar
2
issue in State of Gujarat v. Kothari & Associates observed
as follows:
“11. It also appears to us that the contract was
clearly not broken as the respondents chose to
keep it alive despite its repeated breaches by the
appellant State. The factual matrix presents a
situation of successive or multiple breaches,
rather than of a continuous breach, as each delay
in handing over the canal/site by the appellant
State constituted to a breach that was distinct
and complete in itself and gave rise to a separate
cause of action for which the respondent could
have rescinded the contract or possibly claimed
compensation due to prolongation of time and
resultant escalation of costs. Of course the
respondent is enabled to combine all these causes of
action in one plaint, as postulated in CPC provided
each claim is itself justiciable. Even the respondent has
argued before the High Court that the suit was based
on successive breaches committed by the appellant
State . In our opinion, the suit was required to be
filed within three years of the happening of each
breach, which would constitute a distinct cause
of action. xxxxx”
(emphasis supplied)
2
(2016) 14 SCC 761.
- 20 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:55637-DB
COMAP No. 29 of 2026
C/W COMAP No. 468 of 2025
CNR: KAHC010022642026
35. We also place reliance on the judgment of Apex
Court in OPG Power Generation (P) Ltd. v. Enexio Power
3
Cooling Solutions (India) (P) Ltd. wherein it held:
“156. xxxxx However, where an acknowledgment is in
respect of a specified sum of money or a specific right
only, and not in general terms, it would extend the
period of limitation only in respect thereof, and not of
other claims which, though may have arisen out of
same jural relationship, are not specified therein. In
other words, where an acknowledgment of liability is
made only with reference to a portion of the claim put
forward by the plaintiff/claimant, it would extend
limitation only in respect of such portion, and not of
the entire claim of the plaintiff.”
36. The Commercial Court, therefore, ought to have
framed an appropriate issue and examined this objection.
Failure to do so cannot defeat a plea which goes to the
maintainability of the claim. The Court is required to examine
limitation even where the parties have not properly raised or
pursued the issue, in view of Section 3 of the Limitation Act.
The subsequent correspondence between the parties,
particularly when the defendants had expressly denied the
monetary claims, cannot revive a claim which had already
become time-barred.
3
(2025) 2 SCC 417.
- 21 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:55637-DB
COMAP No. 29 of 2026
C/W COMAP No. 468 of 2025
CNR: KAHC010022642026
37. Coming to the judgment under challenge, the
Commercial Court has awarded Rs.19,03,170/- with interest at
9% per annum from 28.08.2009 till realization, although the
plaintiff had claimed Rs.1,75,27,456/- with interest at 12% per
annum. The award of Rs.2,00,000/- towards overhead charges
and another Rs.2,00,000/- towards idle charges also does not
rest on satisfactory material establishing the actual expenditure
incurred by the plaintiff. The mere fact that machinery and
labour had been deployed at the site does not, by itself,
establish the precise loss suffered or the period for which the
machinery and labour remained idle. The Commercial Court
was required to examine whether such expenditure had actually
been incurred, whether it was attributable to any breach by the
defendants and whether the amount claimed had been
established by acceptable evidence.
38. The plaintiff's admissions, the absence of
departmental signatures on Ex.P-8 and the entries in Ex.P-29
could not have been overlooked while quantifying the amount
payable. Further, the defendants' admission of Rs.7,22,000/- in
Exs.D-25 and D-26 cannot automatically justify an award of
- 22 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:55637-DB
COMAP No. 29 of 2026
C/W COMAP No. 468 of 2025
CNR: KAHC010022642026
Rs.19,03,170/-. Each additional claim required independent
proof. The Commercial Court has not satisfactorily explained
how the evidence supporting the individual claims ultimately
resulted in the decretal amount.
39. The plaintiff, who seeks enhancement in
Commercial Appeal No.468/2025, has not been able to
demonstrate that the rejected claims are supported by reliable
measurements or accepted bills. On the contrary, the evidence
on record gives sufficient reason to decline the enhancement
sought by him.
40. On an overall consideration of the pleadings, the
contractual documents, the measurement records and, more
particularly, the admissions elicited from PW-1 in cross-
examination, this Court is unable to sustain the decree passed
by the Commercial Court. The plaintiff cannot claim amounts
for work which he has not established to have executed. Nor
can the additional quantities, allegedly undertaken at the oral
instructions of the site engineers, be accepted without proof of
their execution and acceptance by the defendants. The original
project value was Rs.62,64,200/-, whereas the plaintiff sought
- 23 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:55637-DB
COMAP No. 29 of 2026
C/W COMAP No. 468 of 2025
CNR: KAHC010022642026
recovery of Rs.1,75,27,456/-, a claim substantially exceeding
the contract value. Such a claim necessarily required clear and
convincing proof, which is lacking in the present case.
41. More importantly, the suit itself was instituted
beyond the prescribed period of limitation. The finding of the
Commercial Court granting a decree for Rs.19,03,170/- with
interest, therefore, cannot be sustained. Accordingly,
Commercial Appeal No.29/2026 filed by the defendants
deserves to be allowed and Commercial Appeal No.468/2025
filed by the plaintiff deserves to be dismissed.
42. The judgment and decree dated 28.03.2025 passed
in Com.O.S. No.1/2020 are liable to be set aside and the suit
filed by the plaintiff is liable to be dismissed as barred by
limitation and also for want of sufficient proof of the monetary
claims. Accordingly, we pass the following;
ORDER
(i) Commercial Appeal No.29/2026 filed by the
defendants is allowed ;
(ii) The Judgment and Decree dated 28.03.2025
passed by the Principal District Judge,
- 24 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:55637-DB
COMAP No. 29 of 2026
C/W COMAP No. 468 of 2025
CNR: KAHC010022642026
Mandya, in Commercial O.S.No.1/2020 is
hereby set aside .
(iii) Consequently, the suit filed by the plaintiff in
Com.O.S. No.1/2020 stands dismissed as
barred by limitation and for want of sufficient
proof of the monetary claims.
(iv) Commercial Appeal No.468/2025 filed by the
plaintiff is dismissed.
(v) No order as to costs.
Sd/-
(D K SINGH)
JUDGE
Sd/-
(H.SHANTHI BHUSHAN)
JUDGE
KNM
List No.: 1 Sl No.: 13