Fool Sai vs State Of Chhattisgarh
- Court
- Chhattisgarh High Court
1 / 13
CGHC010281972016 2026:CGHC:47512
AFR
HIGH COURT OF CHHATTISGARH AT BILASPUR
CRR No. 632 of 2016
Order reserved on 24.09.2026
Order delivered on 18.11.2026
Fool Sai S/o Sukh Sai, Aged about 29 years, R/o. Keshawpur, P.S. Ramanuj
Nagar, District Surajpur (CG)
... Applicant (s)
versus
State of Chhattisgarh Through Police Station P.S. Ramanuj Nagar, District
Surajpur Chhattisgarh
... Respondents
For Applicant : Mr. Maneesh Sharma, Advocate
For Respondents : Ms. Shailja Shukla, Govt. Advocate
Hon'ble Shri Justice Narendra Kumar Vyas
C A V Order
1. This revision under Sectons 397 & 401 of the CrPC has been filed by
the applicant challenging the order dated 22.04.2016 passed by
nd
learned 2 Additional Sessions Judge, Surajpur District Surajpur in
Criminal Appeal No. 17 of 2015 wherein learned Appellate Court partly
allowed the appeal, by affirming the judgment of conviction passed on
Digitally
signed by
SANTOSH
KUMAR
SHARMA
Date:
2026.11.18
05:49:07
+0530
SANTOSH
KUMAR
SHARMA
2 / 13
15.10.2015 by Judicial Magistrate, First Class, Surajpur, Chhattisgarh
in Criminal Case No. 37 of 2015 whereby the applicant has been
convicted under Sections 279, 337(two counts) and 304-A of the IPC
and sentenced him to undergo R.I. for 1 month and to pay fine of Rs.
100/- under Section 337 of the IPC, R.I. for 1 month and to pay fine of
Rs. 100 under Section 337 of the IPC and reduced the sentence of 1
year to R.I. for 6 months and to pay fine of Rs. 300 under Section 304-
A of the IPC.
2. Facts of the case in brief are that on 24.05.2008 complainant Sahdev
Singh lodged the report (Ex.P-9) at Police Station Ramanujnagar
alleging that the driver of the offending vehicle Sonalika Tractor bearing
registration No. CG-15-A-4289 while driving the vehicle in rash and
negligent manner jerked the tractor due to which victims Indraman and
Sahdev Singh fell down from the tractor and sustained minor injuries on
their bodies. It is also alleged that Budhan Singh came under the wheel
of tractor and succumbed to death. On the complaint of Sahdev Singh,
a criminal Case No. 38 of 2008 under Sections 279, 337 (two counts)
and 304-A of the IPC was registered against the applicant. After
completion of the investigation, charge-sheet was filed before Judicial
Magistrate First Class, Surajpur against the applicant.
3. Learned Judicial Magistrate First Class Surajpur after considering the
material, evidence on record has convicted the applicant of the charge
under Sections 279, 337 (two counts) and 304-A of the IPC and
sentened him to undergo as aforementioend above. Against that order,
3 / 13
the applicant has filed Criminal appeal before the Appellate Court
wherein the appellate Court has partly allowed the appeal as detailed
above. Being aggrieved with the order of the Appellate Court, the
applicant has filed this Criminal Revision before this Court.
4. Learned counsel for the applicant would submit that the orders passed
by the Appellate court as well as trial Court are bad in law and contrary
to the facts and material available on record. He would further submit
no witnesses have stated that the applicant was driving the vehicle
rashly and negligently still he has been convicted. He would further
submit that even if the entire prosecution is taken as it is, no offence
under Section 304-A of the IPC is made out. He would further submit
that there are contradictions and ommissions in the statements given
by two eye-witnesses who did not disclose the name of the applicant to
the police and the same has been disclosed in the court for the first
time. He would further submit that the name of the applicant is not
mentioned in the FIR despite the person who has lodged the FIR was
knowing the accused. To substantiate his submission, he would refer to
the judgment of Hon’ble Supreme Court in the case of Rihitas Kumar
vs. State of Haryana reported 2013(4) CCHC 1942 SC, State of
Karnataka vs. Satish reported 1998(8) SCC 493 and the judgment of
Delhi High Court in the case of State vs. Garibullah in
CRL No. 721 of 2003 decided on 12.12.2025 and would pray for
setting aside the orders passed by both the Courts below.
4 / 13
5. On the other hand learned counsel for the State opposes the
submission made by learned counsel for the applicant and would
submit that the orders passed by the trial Court as well as Appellate
Court are legal, justified as no illegality or irregularity has been pointed
out by the applicant which entails this court to interfere in the orders
while exercising its revisional jurisdiction and would pray for dismissal
of revision.
6. I have considered rival submissions made by learned counsel for the
respective parties and also perused the record of the Courts below.
7. From the submissions made by the parties and the record of the trial
Court the points emerge for determination are;-
(i) Whether the Courts below were justified in convicting the
applicant for the offence punishable under Sections 279, 337
(two counts) and 304-A of the IPC?
(ii) Whether the impugned judgments warrant interference in
the exercise of revisional jurisdiction by this Court?.
8. The prosecution to prove the guilt of the applicant has examined
witness Sahdev Singh (PW-1) who has deposed that on the date of
incident he alongwith Jagmohan, Indra Mohan and deceased Budhan
were sitting in front of the tractor, on the way the tractor suddenly
jerked, due to which all the people sitting on it jumped and deceased
Budhan fell and trapped under the wheels of the tractor. He further
deposed that the tractor was being driven by Phulsai at the time of
incident and he had reported the matter to police station. The tractor
was identifed by the Police at Ramanujanagar police station. This
5 / 13
witness was turned hostile, as such the prosecution has put leading
queston to him wherein he has deposed that the tractor was driven by
the accused negligently. In the cross-examination by the defense, this
witness has deposed that he did not remember whether he had told
name of the owner of the vehicle when the report was made by him
and the incident occurred at 7 pm in the dark.
9. Injured Indra Mohan (PW-2) deposed that fertilizer was being loaded in
the tractor for field and Budhan was sitting in the tractor, due to jerk of
the tractror, he fell down from the tractor and trapped under a wheel of
tractor. This witness has turned hostile and has not supported the case
of the prosecution, therefore, he was put leading question by the
prosecution wherein he has stated that the accused was driving the
tractor negligently. In the cross-examination, this witness stated that he
could not identify the owner of the tractor.
10. Baldev (PW-4) deposed that on the date of incident, Indramohan,
Sahadev, deceased and others persons were sitting on the tractor. The
tractor was being driven by the accused. They were loading fertilizer in
the tractor and were going to the field. His brother, Sahadev, had
rented the tractor to transport of fertilizer. In the cross-examination, he
has deposed that he was not present at the place of incident, as such
he cannot tell as to how the tractor was driven by the applicant.
11. Shanti (PW-5) deposed that on the date of the incident, Indramohan,
Sahadev and Budhan were going to spread fertilizer in the field. He
further deposed that the offending vehicle was being jerked by the
6 / 13
driver of the vehilce, as such Budhan fell down from the tractor. She
has admitted in the cross-examination that at the time of incident she
was at home, therefore, she cannot tell as to how the tractor was
driven by the applicant.
12. Dr. H. P. Singh (PW-10) deposed that on 24/08/2008, constable
Bhuneshwar Singh brought the injured Indra Mohan for treatment. He
noticed laceration of 4 inch on the right side of back and lacerated
wound on his lower back near the hip. Injured Sahadev was also
brought for treatment and he noticed 2-inch long laceration on the front
of his right leg. The injuries sustained by the injured were minor in
nature. He has submitted his report (Ex.P.16 and Ex.P.17).
13. From minute scrutiny of the above witnesses, it is apparent that, the
applicant was driving the offendcing vehicle and the other witnesses
were sitting in the tractor. Their testimonies remained un-rebutted and
identified to be driver of offending truck. But none of the witnesses was
able to demonstrate that the vehile was driven by the applicant rashly
and negligently which are essential ingredients to attract Section 304 -
A of the IPC.
14. For better undestanding the point of determination, it is expedient for
this Court to attact section 304-A of the IPC which is as under:
“ 304A. Causing death by negligence . -- Whoever causes the
death of any person by doing any rash or negligent act not
amounting to culpable homicide, shall be punished with
imprisonment of either description for a term which may extend to
two years, or with fine, or with both.”
7 / 13
15. From perusal of this Section, it is quite vivid that for conviction in an
offence under Section 304A of the IPC, the Court has to examine
whether the alleged act of the accused is the direct result of a rash and
negligent act, and that act was the proximate and sufficient cause of
the death without the intervention of others' negligence. Therefore, rash
and negligence are not the same things. Mere negligence cannot be
construed to mean rashness. There are degrees of negligence and
rashness and in order to amount to criminal rashness or criminal
negligence one must find that the rashness has been of such a degree
as to amount to taking hazard knowing that the hazard was of such a
degree that injury was most likely to be occasioned thereby. The
criminality lies in running the risk or doing such an act with
recklessness and indifference to the consequences. Criminal
negligence is gross and culpable neglect, that is to say, failure to
exercise the reasonable and proper care and precaution that a prudent
person would use under the same circumstances, as such it was the
imperative duty of the individual to take. The criminality lies in not
taking the precautions to prevent the happening of the consequences
in the hope that they may not happen.
16. Considering the evidence and material on record, it is quite vivid that
the prosecution is unable to prove that the tractor was driven rashly
and negligently as none of the witnesses examined by the prosection
could give an indication and only balled statements were given about
driven the vehicle negligently. There is no wishper as to how the tractor
8 / 13
was driven negligently which is essential to prove the offence of
Section 304-A of the IPC against the applicant, as such there being
evidence on record to establish negligence or rashness in driving the
tractor.
17. The Hon’ble Supreme Court in the case of Matin Shankarrao Bhosale
and Another vs. State of Maharashtra and Another reported in
2026 INSC 1198 has examined the provison of Section 304-A of the
IPC and has held as under:-
56. We may quote with profit the case of Ambalal D. Bhatt v. State of
Gujarat, reported in (1972) 3 SCC 525, wherein the following
observations made by this Court are worth taking note of;-
8...........................
9............................
10. It appears to us that in a prosecution for an offence under
section 304A, the mere fact that an accused contravenes certain
rules or regulations in the doing of an act which causes death of
another, does not establish that the death was the result of a rash or
negligent act or that any such act was the proximate and efficient
cause of the death. If that were so, the acquittal of the appellant for
contravention of the provisions of the Act and the Rules would itself
have then examined to what extent additional evidence of his
acquittal would have to be allowed, but since that is not the criteria,
we have to determine whether the appellant's act in giving only one
batch number to all the four lots manufactured on 12-11-62 in
preparing batch no. 211105 was the cause of deaths and whether
those deaths were a direct consequence of the appellant's act that
is, whether the appellant's act is the direct result of a rash and
negligent act and that act was the proximate and efficient cause
without the intervention of another's negligence. As observed by Sir
Lawrence Jenkins in Emperor v. Omkar Rampratap. (1902) 4 Bom
LR 679 the act causing the deaths "must be the cause causans; it is
not enough that it may have been the causa sine qua non". This
view has been adopted by this Court in several decisions. In Kurban
Hussein Mohem-medali Rangwala v. State of Maharashtra, 1965-2
SCR 622 = (AIR 1965 SC 1616), the accused who had
manufactured wet paints without a licence was acquitted of the
charge under section 304A because it was held that the mere fact
that he allowed the burners to be used in the same room in which
varnish and turpentine were stored, even though it would be a
9 / 13
negligent act, would not be enough to make the accused
responsible for the fire which broke out. The cause of the fire was
not merely the presence of the burners within the room in which
varnish and turpentine were stored, though this circumstance was
indirectly responsible for the fire which broke out, but was also due
to the overflowing of froth out of the barrels. In Suleman Rahiman
Mulani v. State of Maharashtra (1968) 2 SCR 515 = (AIR 1968 SC
829) the accused who was driving a car only with a learner's licence
without a trainer by his side, had injured a person. It was held that
by itself was no sufficient to warrant a conviction under section
304A. It would be different if it can be established as in the case of
Balachandra v. State of Maharashtra, (1968) 3 SCR 766 = (AIR
1968 SC 1319) that deaths and injuries caused by the contravention
of a prohibition in respect of the substance which are highly
dangerous as in the case of explosives in a cracker factory which
are considered to be of a highly hazardous and dangerous nature
having sensitive composition where even friction or percussion
could cause an explosion, that contravention would be the causa
causans.
We may also quote with profit a decision of this Court in the case of
Balwant Singh v. State of Punjab, reported in 1994 Supp (2) SCC
67. The following observations of this Court are worth taking note of.
8. Then the question would be whether an offence under Sec.
304-A, I.P.C, is made out? The provisions of this Section apply to
cases where there is no intention to cause death and no
knowledge that the act done in all probabilities will cause death.
Therefore, this provision is directed at offences outside the range
of Ss. 299 and 300, I.P.C. and obviously contemplates those
cases into which neither intention nor knowledge enters. The
words "not amounting to culpable homicide" in the Section are
very significant and it must therefore be understood that
intentionally or knowingly inflicted violence directly and wilfully
caused is excluded. The Section applies only to such acts which
are rash or negligent and are directly the cause of death of
another person. In other words, a rash act is primarily an over
hasty act as opposed to a deliberate act but done without due care
and caution. Then the question whether the conduct of the
accused amounted to culpable rashness or negligence depends
on the amount of care and circumspection which a prudent and
reasonable man would consider it to be sufficient and this depends
on the circumstances in each case."
(emphasis supplied)
10 / 13
18. Further considering the evidence of the prosecution witnesses who
have stated that the accident took place at 7 pm in the dark and there
is nothing on record which can suggest that any street light was there
or not. Thus in such a situation it cannot be held that the vehile was
driven by the accused rashly and negligently. Considering this aspect
of the matter that though the accident was very unfortunate, however,
there are insufficient materials on record to prove that the accused had
driven the offending vehicle in a rash and negligent manner at the time
of accident.
19. From the evidence brought on record, it is quite vivid that the
prosecution is unable to prove that the applicant caused hurt to the
other injured person by doing any act so rashly and negligently as to
endanger their life or personal safty, as such the learned trial Court has
committed illegality in convicting the applicant under Sections 279, 337
(2 counts) of the IPC.
20. In a criminal trial, the onus remains on the prosecution to prove the
guilt of accused beyond all reasonable doubts and the benefit of doubt,
if any, must necessarily go in favour of the accused. It is for the
prosecution to travel the entire distance from 'may have' to 'must have'.
In the case titled as Dr. S.L. Goswami Vs. State of Madhya Pradsh
reported in 1972 (3) SCC 22 , Hon'ble Apex Court has held that:
6......................
In our view, the onus of proving all the ingredients of an
offence is always;upon the prosecution and at no stage does
it shift to the accused. It is no part of the prosecution duty to
somehow hook the crook. Even in cases where the defence
11 / 13
of the accused does not appear to be credible or is Palpably
false that burden does not become any the less. It is only
when this burden is discharged that it will be for the accused
to explain or controvert the essential elements in the
prosecution case which would negative it. It is not however
for the accused even at the initial stage to prove something
which has to be eliminated by the prosecution to establish
the ingredients of the offence with which he is charged, and
even if the onus shifts upon the accused and the accused
has to establish his plea, the standard of proof is not the
same as that which rests. upon the prosecution. Where the
onus shifts to the accused, and the evidence on his behalf
probabilises the plea he will be entitled to the benefit of
reasonable doubt.
21. Again the Hon’ble Supreme Court in the recent judgment passed in the
case of Surendrea Koli vs. State of Uttar Pradesh 2025 INSC 1308,
has reiterated the fundamental principle of the criminal jurisprudence
that the criminal law does not permit conviction on conjectures or grave
suspicions.
22. From the above stated factual and legal position, it is quite vivid that
mere negligence or rashness is, therefore, not enough to bring a case
within the ambit of Section 304-A IPC. Negligence or rashness proved
by evidence must be such as should necessarily carry with it a criminal
liability. Whether such liability which is present may depend on the
degree of culpability having regard in each case to the particular time,
place and circumstances. If it is merely a case of compensation or
reparation for injury or damage caused to a person or property, it is
clearly not punishable under the said Section. The culpability to be
criminal should be such as concerns not merely the person injured or
property damaged but the safety of the public on the road. But the
nature and extent of the injury or damage will be irrelevant in fixing
12 / 13
criminal liability for negligence under the sections and also considering
that the prosecution is unable to prove this vital ingredients to attract
the offence under Section 304-A of the IPC.
23. Similarly, there are insufficient materials on record to convict the
applicant/accused in the present case for the offence punishable under
Section 279 and 337(two counts) IPC, therefore, the conviction passed
by the learned trial Court and affirmed by the Appellate Court deserves
to be set aside and it is set aside by this Court exercsing its revisional
jurisdiction as the conviction passed by the both the Courts are on
perverse finding, suffers from illegality and there is pulpable error and
the order of conviction passed by both the Courts are completely
erronous as per the law regarding jurisdiction of this Court while
exercising the revisional power in the case of Amit Kapoor vs.
Ramesh Chander reported in 2012(9) SCC 407 and has held as
under:-
20. The jurisdiction of the Court under Section 397 can be exercised
so as to examine the correctness, legality or proprietary of an order
passed by the trial court or the inferior court, as the case may be.
Though the section does not specifically use the expression ‘prevent
abuse of process of any court or otherwise to secure the ends of
justice’, the jurisdiction under Section 397 is a very limited one. The
legality, proprietary or correctness of an order passed by a court is
the very foundation of exercise of jurisdiction under Section 397 but
ultimately it also requires justice to be done. The jurisdiction could
be exercised where there is palpable error, non-compliance with the
provisions of law, the decision is completely erroneous or where the
judicial discretion is exercised arbitrarily. On the other hand, Section
482 is based upon the maxim quando lex liquid alicuiconcedit,
conceder videtur id quo res ipsa esse non protest, i.e., when the law
gives anything to anyone, it also gives all those things without which
the thing itself would be unavoidable. The Section confers very wide
power on the Court to do justice and to ensure that the process of
the Court is not permitted to be abused.
13 / 13
24. Therefore, in view of the above discussions and findings, I find that the
conviction passed by the both the Courts below are on perverse
finding, suffers from illegality, pulpable error and the order of conviction
passed by both the Courts are completely erronous as per the law.
Accordingly, the judgments passed by both the Courts are set aside
and it is set aside and the criminal Revision is allowed by acquitting the
applicant from the offence under Sections 279, 337 (two counts) and
304-A of the IPC.
25. Since the applicant is reported to be on bail, his bail bond shall remain
in force for a period of six months from today in view of provision of
Section 437-A of the CrPC/ Section 481 of the Bharatiya Nagarik
Suraksha Sanhita, 2023.
Sd/-
(Narendra Kumar Vyas)
Judge
Santosh