(O&M)Sunil Kumar vs Padma Devi

Court
Punjab and Haryana High Court

IN THE HIGH COURT OF PUNJAB & HARYANA
AT CHANDIGARH

Reserved on : 13.07.2026
Pronounced on : 15.09.2026
(i) RSA-2481-2000 (O&M)
SUNIL KUMAR ...APPELLANT
VERSUS
PADMA DEVI AND OTHERS ...RESPONDENTS
(ii) FAO-419-1992 (O&M)
SUNIL KUMAR JAIN AND ANOTHER ...APPELLANTS
VERSUS
GENERAL PUBLIC AND OTHERS ...RESPONDENTS
CORAM: HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE PARMOD GOYAL
Present: Mr. Kulwant Singh, Advocate
for appellant.
Mr. Vijay Sharma, Advocate
for respondent Nos.1(ii), 2, 3 and 5 in RSA-2481-2000 &
respondent Nos.6 and 7 in FAO-419-1992
Mr. A.K. Garg, Advocate
for respondent No.18.
*
PARMOD GOYAL, J.
Present regular second appeal has been preferred by the
appellant-defendant No.3 being aggrieved by judgment and decree dated
05.06.1993 passed by Sub-Judge, IInd Class, Malerkotla vide which suit
preferred by respondents-plaintiffs for partition and permanent injunction
was decreed and by judgment and decree dated 07.02.2000 passed by
learned Additional District Judge, Sangrur vide which first appeal preferred
by appellant-defendant was dismissed.
2. Respondents-plaintiffs had preferred a suit for possession by
SUNIL CHANDER
2026.09.16 10:21
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document

RSA No.2481 of 2000
FAO-419-1992 -2-
way of partition. It was claimed that suit property was owned by Amar Nath
son of Kaur Mall. That suit property shown in headnote (A) of the plaint was
owned and posssessed by Amar Nath whereas suit property bearing house
No.1 shown in site plan was jointly owned by Amar Nath with defendant
No.5 in equal share. That Amar Nath had died on 05.07.1984 leaving behind
his legal heirs i.e. plaintiffs and defendants No.1 and 2. That plaintiff No.1 is
widow of Amar Nath, plaintiffs No.2 to 4 are daughters of Amar Nath,
defendant No.1 is daughter of Amar Nath, defendant No.2 is son of Amar
Nath, whereas defendants No.3 and 4 are grandsons of Amarnath and sons of
defendant No.2. It was claimed that plaintiffs and defendants No.1 and 2 had
become owners in possession of suit land by way of natural succession and
plaintiffs do not want joint property, therefore, they sought possession of suit
property by way of partition. It was also asserted that claim of defendants
No.3 and 4, based upon will dated 09.03.1973, was untenable as said will is
forged, fictitious and invalid. Therefore, claim of defendants No.3 and 4 on
the basis of will dated 09.03.1973 was liable to be ignored. Along with suit
for partition and possession, respondents-plaintiffs had also sought
permanent injunction.
3. Suit was contested by defendants No.3 and 4. Defendants had
admitted that suit property was owned by Amar Nath and had also admitted
relationship of respondents-plaintiffs and defendants No.1 and 2 with
deceased Amar Nath, however, inheritance by way of natural succession was
denied. It was asserted that defendants No.3 and 4 were sons of defendant
No.2-Rameshwar Lal Jain and Amarnath was their grandfather and out of
love and affection for defendants No.3 and 4 and being happy with their
SUNIL CHANDER
2026.09.16 10:21
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document

RSA No.2481 of 2000
FAO-419-1992 -3-
services to Amar Nath, Amar Nath had executed will dated 09.03.1973
bequeathing his entire property to defendants No.3 and 4. It was claimed that
defendant No.5 had nothing to do with the suit property and is not a
necessary party as property stood partitioned between defendant No.5 and
Amar Nath. Accordingly, dismissal of suit was prayed for.
4. From the pleadings of the parties, following issues were
framed:-
i. Whether the property in dispute was ancestral in the
hands of Amar Nath deceased ? OPP
th
ii. Whether the plaintiffs are owners to the extent of 4/6
share and defendants No.1 and 2 are the owners to the
extent of 2/6th share ? OPP
iii. Whether Amar Nath deceased executed a valid will dated
09.03.1973 in favour of defendants No.3 and 4 ? OPD
iv. Whether the plaintiffs have no locus standi to file the
present suit ? OPD
v. Whether the suit is not maintainable for the purpose of
court fee and jurisdiction ? OPD
vi. Whether the suit is barred u/s 23 of Hindu Succession
Act, 1956 ? OPD
Vii. Whether the suit is bad for mis-joinder of defendant No.5
as party ? OPD
viii. Relief.
5. Learned Court of First Instance decided issue No.1 against the
respondents-plaintiffs and in favour of defendants. Issue No.3 regarding
validity of will dated 09.03.1973 was decided against defendants No.3 and
4. Issue No.2 was decided in favour of respondents-plaintiffs and against
defendants. Issues No.4 and 5 were also decided against defendants No.3
SUNIL CHANDER
2026.09.16 10:21
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document

RSA No.2481 of 2000
FAO-419-1992 -4-
and 4 and in favour of respondents-plaintiffs. Issue No.6 was decided against
defendants No.3 and 4 and in favour of respondents-plaintiffs. Issue No.7
was decided as not pressed. Accordingly, suit of respondents-plaintiffs was
decreed and preliminary decree for partition was passed.
6. Learned Appellate Court had upheld the findings of learned
Court of First Instance and had dismissed the first appeal preferred by
defendants No.3 and 4.
7. In present case, respondents-plaintiffs had claimed their right by
way of natural succession being wife and daughters of deceased Amar Nath,
who admittedly was the owner of suit property. They have claimed that suit
property was ancestral property in the hands of Amar Nath and therefore
neither he had executed any will nor he could have executed the same and
will dated 09.03.1973 was stated to be forged and fabricated.
8. On the other hand, the entire claim of defendants No.3 and 4 is
based upon will dated 09.03.1973 as ownership of Amar Nath as well as
relationship of parties with Amar Nath are not in dispute.
9. Both the Courts have rightly come to the conclusion that
respondents-plaintiffs have failed to prove that property in the hands of
Amar Nath was ancestral property and therefore, no will could have been
executed by him. In fact, no evidence except for oral assertions was placed
on record as to prove that the property in the hands of Amar Nath was
ancestral which he could not have alienated by way of will. Therefore, no
exceptions to the findings recorded by learned Courts below on issue No.1
can be taken and accordingly findings of learned Courts below on issue No.1
is upheld. It is held that property in the hands of Amar Nath was not
SUNIL CHANDER
2026.09.16 10:21
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document

RSA No.2481 of 2000
FAO-419-1992 -5-
ancestral but was self-acquired and he could have alienated the same by way
of will.
10. The main dispute in present appeal is validity of will dated
09.03.1973. Ownership of Amar Nath and relationship of respondents-
plaintiffs as well as appellant-defendant No.3 and defendant No.4 is
admitted. Admittedly, respondents-plaintiffs are wife and daughters, whereas
defendant No.2 is son of Amar Nath and defendant No.1 is daughter of Amar
Nath. Appellant-defendant No.3 and defendant No.4 are sons of defendant
No.2 and grand-son of Amar Nath.
11. Appellant-defendant No.3 and defendant No.4 have claimed
their rights over the suit property on the basis of will dated 09.03.1973 stated
to be executed by Amar Nath owner of property who had died on
05.07.1984. Therefore, it is the validity of Will which is the moot issue in
present appeal. Both the Courts below after appreciating evidence lead by
parties had held will dated 09.03.1973 to be suspicious and not executed by
Amar Nath and held respondents-plaintiffs and defendants No.1 and 2 are
entitled to suit property by way of natural succession.
12. Since, appellant-defendant No.3 is pro-pounder of Will dated
09.03.1973, it was his duty to prove its due execution as well as dispel any
suspicious circumstances regarding execution of will by its testator Amar
Nath.
13. Onus to prove due execution of will dated 09.03.1973 was upon
pre-pounders of will i.e. appellant-defendant No.3 and defendant No.4.
Appellant-defendant No.3 and defendant No.4 had claimed that will dated
09.03.1973 was holographic will which was written by none other than
SUNIL CHANDER
2026.09.16 10:21
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document

RSA No.2481 of 2000
FAO-419-1992 -6-
Amar Nath with his own hands while being in sound deposing mind out of
his free will. It was claimed that relationship of Amar Nath were strained
with respondents-plaintiffs and defendants No.1 and 2 which he had duly
noticed while executing will dated 09.03.1973.
14. DW-3 claimed himself to be attesting witness of the Will.
However, on appreciation of evidence of DW-3, both the Courts had
concluded that he was not present rather had appended his signatures
subsequently. Learned Court of First Instance had noticed that Sohan Lal
Singla while appearing as DW-3 before the Court had claimed that he had
signed and put his signatures on the will dated 09.03.1973 with the same pen
and with the same ink, which was used by Amar Nath. Learned Court of
First Instance accordingly had summoned the will which was attached in
some other case from judicial record room of District and Sessions Judge,
Sangrur. After examination of original will, learned Court of First Instance
had held that signatures of DW-3 were got amended or put on the margin of
document-will dated 09.03.1973 and are not with same ink and with same
pen with which Amar Nath had signed. It was concluded by learned Court of
First Instance that DW-3 was either not present at the time of writing of will
dated 09.03.1973 and his signatures were got afterwards to meet requirement
of Section 68 of Indian Succession Act, 1925. Accordingly, presence of DW-
3 at the time of execution of Will dated 09.03.1973 was not accepted. In
view of this finding, non-examination of second attesting witness, namely
Niranjan, was taken adversely against the case of appellant.
15. Learned Court of First Instance had further taken into
consideration report (Ex.PW5/A) of document expert, Sh. Dewan K.S. Puri,
SUNIL CHANDER
2026.09.16 10:21
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document

RSA No.2481 of 2000
FAO-419-1992 -7-
who was examined as PW5. It was noticed that paper where signatures of
executant existed was torn. It was also noted by hand-writing expert that
cloth beneath torn portion of signatures was in tact, which goes to confirm
that the cloth was affixed when will was torn and after paper had became
weak.
16. It was further noticed by learned Court of First Instance that
body of Will was written with violet ink whereas witnesses had signed with
blue ink. Hand-writing expert had also noted that DW-3 had signed on the
margins of the Will and while writing the descriptions one of the stroke had
touched the cloth which was affixed later on when the Will was torn off
which goes to show that when the witnesses had signed, supporting cloth
was present or signatures of witnesses were procured after fixing the cloth
on the back of the damaged Will.
17. Learned Court of First Instance had accordingly arrived at
conclusion that signatures by DW-3 were not appended at the time of
execution of will but were appended subsequently. It had further concluded
that DW-3 had put his signatures ante-dated to meet the requirement of
Section 68 of Indian Evidence Act, 1872 as DW-3 had himself admitted that
at the time of writing of Will no cloth at the backside of the paper was
existing and accordingly will was held to be forged and fabricated
document. The relevant finding of learned Court of First Instance as noted in
paragraphs No.16 to 18 are reproduced hereunder for ready reference:-
“16. Besides this, according to learned counsel for the
plaintiffs with which I am also in full agreement, during the
exhaustive perusal of the statement of DW3 Sohan lal Siingla,
SUNIL CHANDER he himself has admitted dealings and other transactions with
2026.09.16 10:21
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document

RSA No.2481 of 2000
FAO-419-1992 -8-
the beneficiaries under the spurious and invalid will dated
09.03.1973 i.e. defendants No.3 and 4 and as such, I am also of
affirmed view that Sohan Lal is a procured witness, whose
signatures have been obtained by the answering defendants
No.3 and 4 with an ulterior motive and with an effort to make
the invalid document as valid one, which cannot be relied upon
at all and the will dated 09.03.1973 is a suspicious document,
which cannot be relied upon in the light of the guidelines, laid
down by Hon’ble Supreme Court of India in Jaswant Kaur Vs.
Amrit Kaur, reported as 1977 CLJ.237. So, there exist material
suspicious circumstances, which stand unexplained on record.
Moreover, learned counsel for the answering defendants No.3
and 4 could not advance any cogent argument in rebuttal to the
arguments and case laws, as well as the evidence on record on
behalf of the plaintiffs.
17. In addition to the above, Diwan K.S. Puri, Document
Expert has also proved that the signatures of Sohan Lal DW3
attesting witness of the will dated 9-3-73 have been taken
subsequently, i.e. after the lapse of a sufficient time from 9-3-73
as per the date of the will, which means that the signatures, of
Sohan Lal Singla attesting witness are ant-dated which also
raises a deep rooted doubt and suspicion regarding the
genuinity of the alleged will dated 9-3-73.
18. As a result of the above discussion, I hold that the will
dated 9-3-73 Ex. D2 was never executed by Amar Nath on 9-3-
73 as alleged in favour of defendants No.3 and 4 and the same
is not a valid document and it does not confer any right upon
defendants No.3 and 4. Accordingly, this issue is decided
against defendants No.3 and 4 and in favour of the plaintiffs
and defendants No.1 and 2. ”
18. Learned First Appellate Court had concurred with the finding of
learned Court of First Instance and had also examined the evidence lead by
SUNIL CHANDER
2026.09.16 10:21
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document

RSA No.2481 of 2000
FAO-419-1992 -9-
defendants regarding due execution of Will in paragraphs No.10 to 12,
which is reproduced hereunder for ready reference:-
“ 10. Sohan Lal DW3 who is one of the attesting witnesses of the
Will stated, that Amar Nath was also residing at Katcha Kot
Malerkotla but lateron he started residing in the Chobars of the
shop in Moti Bazar Malerkotla because he was annoyed with
the behaviour of his wife and son. He stated further that Amar
Nath executed the Will of his estate in his presence in favour of
the appellants. The will was scribed in the Chobara where he
was residing. The other attesting witness Niranjan Rai was also
present. The contents of the Will were read over and it was
signed by Amar Nath in the presence of the witnesses and the
witnesses signed in the presence of Amar Nath. In the cross-
examination Sohan Lal DW3 stated, that he put his signatures
on the will with the same pen and ink by which the document
was written by Amar Nath, but the document expert Dewan K.S.
Puri Pus on examination of the Will in question has given the
report Ex.PW5/A, that witnesses did not sign the Will along
with the executant and particularly Sohan Lal must have signed
the will subsequently after the condition of the paper was
damaged and supporting cloth was already there. Ex.PW5/B is
the photographic chart consisting of four photo enlargements
from negatives Ex.PL5/C1 to Ex.PL5/C4, without any touching.
Another original Will was also produced during the cross-
examination of Dewan K.S. Puri marked as DX/1 and second
copy of the Will was in the summoned file, certified copy of
which is Ex.D2. The document expert has given the firm
opinion that the cloth was pasted with the paper on which the
will was written after the document was torn or deteriorated, so
that it does not get further damaged. Had the cloth been pasted
originally at the time of execution of the Will the cloth beneath
the paper would also have been affected with the passage of
SUNIL CHANDER
2026.09.16 10:21
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document

RSA No.2481 of 2000
FAO-419-1992 -10-
time and it can never be so intact in the manner as it was now.
The expert has found that the bottom of the letter ‘L’ “L
Harparashad" has touched the supporting cloth of the Will thus
showing that this writing was written when the supporting cloth
was already on the back of the paper of the Will. The ink on the
back side of the supporting cloth has also been shown in
photographic chart Ex.PW5/B. There was an extensive cross-
examination of the document expert. But there is absolutely
nothing to disbelieve Dewan K.S. Puri was a person of
unimpeachable Credibility as has also been observed in the
reported judgments of our Hon'ble High Court, which fact is
also admitted. Both the parties reposed complete faith in
Dewan K.S.Puri because he was examined as an expert in case
Sunil Kumar Vs. Pawan Kumar to prove the genuineness of the
Will and Dewan K.S. Puri gave his report Ex.DX dated
08.03.88 in that case. That was the opinion with regard to the
comparison of the signatures of Amar Nath on the Will. The
conclusion arrived at by the document expert that the ink and
pen used for the signatures of the attesting witnesses and their
names is different from the subject matter of the Will, and that
there is the spot of the ink on the cloth at the place where letter
‘L’ of words” L. Harparashad" are written, could not be
challenged in his entire cross-examination nor the appellant-
respondents No. 3 and 4 have lead any evidence in rebuttal to
the expert opinion of Dewan K.S. Puri. In the cross-
examination Dewan K.S.Puri admitted that different inks fade
differently according to the nature of the composition of the ink
and its colour. No advantage can be taken by the appellants
from this statement because the version of the appellants is that
attesting witnesses put their signatures with the same pen and
ink as used by Amar Nath. The fact that the spot of the ink was
appearing on the cloth below the paper of the Will is also not
disputed, rather suggestion is put to the witness that the upper
SUNIL CHANDER
2026.09.16 10:21
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document

RSA No.2481 of 2000
FAO-419-1992 -11-
portion of the Letter 'L' of words “Harparshad" is of another
ink and lower portion of the letter 'L' which is touching the
cloth is with another ink and this suggestion is denied by
Dewan K.S. Puri. It is also stated by him that the ink has
suppressed and colour of the cloth has intermingled. It is also
stated by Dewan K.S.Puri that apart from joining of Letter 'L'
with the supporting cloth, no other stroke has touched the
supporting cloth suggesting that the signatures were made after
the supporting paper was affixed. Нe further stated that the
signatures have been written with different writing material
than the one with which the Will was written. To add to the
above finding, which had made the proposition quite clear, the
argument of the learned counsel for the respondent plaintiffs
that if Amar Nath was so careful and vigilant in writing the
Will, by himself and excluding his natural heirs, he could not
miss, to mention in the document itself, that the Will was being
scribed and executed in the presence of Niranjan Rai and
Sohan Lal the attesting witnesses, as he had touched the
conduct of every legal heir minutesly. If he has left out this
important aspect in the subject matter of the Will he must have
done so under the impression that this being "Holograph will
does not require attestation as already observed, despite the
fact that Amar Nath Jain had admittedly been working as
Ahlmad in Judicial Courts.
11. It is contended by the learned counsel for the plaintiff-
respondents that Sohan Lal the attesting witness was very close
to the appellants and his signing the wall as a witness after the
death of Amar Nath, was possible. For this reference is made to
statement of Sohan Lal DW3 that the appellant-defendants No.
3 and 4 were working at out-stations since the year 1971-72
which is before the execution of Will. He stated that they are
living with their families outside, since then. It is also stated by
PWB Padma Devi one of the plaintiff-respondents, that both the
SUNIL CHANDER
2026.09.16 10:21
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document

RSA No.2481 of 2000
FAO-419-1992 -12-
appellants are living outside. Even they were not present at
Malerkotle at the time of death of Amar Nath. According to
Sohan Lal DW3. Amar Nath died at about 4.45 AM. At that time
one of the appellant was posted in Himachal Pradesh and the
other at Delhi. He despatched telegrams to them and they had
reached for the cremation, which was performed at about 4 or
4-30 P.M. Daughters of Amar Nath were also telegraphically
informed by him. According to his Amar Nath died at his
residential house at Katcha Kot, Malerkotla where he was
brought from Moti Bazar two days earlier by, Narati Devi and
her daughter-in-law.
12. The learned counsel for the appellants on the other hand
contended that the plaintiffs were not living with Amar Nath for
many years before the death of Amar Nath and appellants are
also sons of Rameshwar Dayal son of Amar Nath who has been
excluded from the inheritance. Amar Nath also never thought of
cancelling the Will. The learned counsel for the appellants also
pointed out that the will was found in the joint locker of bank
which was obtained in the names of Amar Nath and Sunil
Kumar appellants. In support of this contention the learned
counsel for the appellants has produced Amandeep Attri Clerk
Punjab National Bank DW4 and he stated that locker was
obtained on 25-5-1983 in joint name of Amar Nath and Sunil
Kumar. From the evidence discussed above, dispelling all the
attacks to the will to be a document shrouded with suspicious
circumstances, I am of the considered view that this document
of Will of Amar Nath is not proved to be a legal document
having been executed in terms of Section 63 of the Indian
Succession Act and attestation of the witnesses has been made
lateron in the margin of the Will. Simply in order to make the
document in conformity with law and thus it cannot be accepted
in order to deviate from the natural succession. As a result of
this discussion I confirm the finding of the learned trial court
SUNIL CHANDER
2026.09.16 10:21
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document

RSA No.2481 of 2000
FAO-419-1992 -13-
on this issue. ”
19. From above noted findings of learned First Appellate Court, it
is, therefore, clearly made out that it had also found that DW-3 had signed
the Will not at the time of its execution on 09.03.1973 but later on. Learned
First Appellate Court had also concluded that since appellant-defendant No.3
and defendant No.4 were not living in Malerkotla since 1971-1972 i.e.
before execution of Will as they were working and living with their family
outside Malerkotla and were not present at the time of death of Amar Nath
as one of the defendants from defendants No.3 and 4 was posted in
Himachal Pradesh and other at Delhi. Learned First Appellate Court had also
concluded that Will dated 09.03.1973 is forged and fabricated.
20. Learned counsel for appellant-defendant No.3 has tried to argue
that since Will was holographic Will, therefore, it has to be appreciated
differently from other type of wills and has to be treated on a better footing
than a registered Will. It is asserted that the last will of testator must be
honoured by the Courts and should not be rejected lightly. That if the
witnesses are examined after gap of substantial time, they cannot be
expected to give details with mathematical precision. Learned counsel for
appellant-defendant No.3 It is also asserted that learned Trial Court has erred
in concluding that Will is doubtful merely because marginal witnesses had
signed in different ink. Learned counsel for appellant-defendant No.3 further
asserted that learned Courts have erred in relying upon report of document
expert, which is mere opinion and cannot substitute substantive evidence i.e.
evidence of DW-3. Learned Counsel for appellant-defendant No.3 further
asserted that hand-writing expert has given his opinion which is not
SUNIL CHANDER
2026.09.16 10:21
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document

RSA No.2481 of 2000
FAO-419-1992 -14-
supported by any chemical test as regards to age of ink regarding the
attestation of Will.
21. Learned counsel for appellant has made reference to following
judgments:-
i. Shashi Kumar Banerjeet and Ors. Vs. Subodh
Kumar Banerjee and Ors. , 1964 AIR Supreme Court
529.
ii. Rajnish Tuli Vs. General Public and Ors. , 2013(4)
CivCC 92.
iii. Mrs. Joyee Primrose Prestor (Nee Vas) Vs. Miss
Vera Marie Vas , 1996(9) SCC 324.
iv. Malayammal and Ors. Vs. A. Malayalam Pillai and
Ors. , 1991 CivCC 227.
v. Rama Kant Verma Vs. State of U.P. , 2009 AIR
Supreme Court 1093.
vi. Dhameshwar Vs. Gish Pati and Ors. , 2015(4) CivCC
263.
vii. Ishwari Prasad Misra Vs. Mohammad Isa , 1963
AIR Supreme Court 1728.
viii. Narendera Nath Nanda Vs. State & Ors. , 2017(3)
CEC 209
ix. Amar Singh (since deceased) thr. Lrs Vs. Mukhtiar
Singh and Ors. , 2018(3) PLR 121.
22. Learned counsel for respondents on the other hand argued that
concurrent findings of fact cannot be re-appreciated in the present regular
second appeal and conclusion arrived at by learned Courts below is based on
correct appreciation of evidence. Learned counsel for respondent No.1(ii), 2,
3 and 5 has made reference to following judgments:-
i. Jaswant Kaur Vs. Amrit Kaur , 1977 AIR Supreme
Court 74.
SUNIL CHANDER ii. Murthy and Ors. Vs. C. Sardambal and Ors. , 2022
2026.09.16 10:21
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document

RSA No.2481 of 2000
FAO-419-1992 -15-
AIR Supreme Court 167.
iii. Randhir Kaur Vs. Prithvi Pal Singh and Ors. , 2019
(3) RCR (Civil) 877.
iv. Ramanuja Naidu Vs. V. Kanniah Naidu and Anr. ,
1996 AIR Supreme Court 3021.
v. Karnataka Board of Wakf Vs. Anjuman-E-Ismail
Madris-un-Niswan , 1999 AIR Supreme Court 3067.
23. The principle of law stated in judgments referred by both the
parties are not in doubt. It is not in doubt that once due execution of Will is
proved in said case, holographic Will carries more value being a special
case. However, even holographic Will needs to be proved to have been
executed by testator in accordance with provisions of Section 68 of Indian
Evidence Act, 1872. It is also not in doubt that Will executed by testator
should not be lightly rejected and once, its execution is proved as per law, it
should be accepted and minor discrepancies and contradictions needs to be
avoided. Similarly, while appreciating evidence of witnesses, witnesses
cannot be expected to depose with mathematical precision. However, this
again is dependent upon facts and circumstances of each case and the Court
has to appreciate the relevant evidence in each case on its own merit and no
straight jacket formula to appreciate evidence can be laid down. A witness
can sign Will using different ink and there is no requirement to sign the Will
by attesting witness with the same ink, however again, validity of Will is
dependent upon facts and circumstances of each case and in case, suspicion
arises over a due execution, it is for the propounder of Will to remove the
same.
24. The principle of law that expert opinion is an opinion and
SUNIL CHANDER cannot replace substantive evidence in well established principle, however,
2026.09.16 10:21
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document

RSA No.2481 of 2000
FAO-419-1992 -16-
again there is no straight jacket formula. The expert opinion can always be
considered by Court to appreciate substantive evidence regarding execution
of Will. Opinion of expert can be relevant in the facts and circumstances of
case if, it raises suspicion on due execution of Will, in said case, the said
suspicion has to be dispelled by none but propounder of Will.
25. It is also not in doubt that onus to prove Will and explain
suspicious circumstances regarding execution of Will is always on the
propounder of Will. The said onus has to be discharged by propounder of
Will by standing on his own legs and he cannot rely upon weakness of case
of defendants. In second appeal, finding of facts cannot be re-appreciated
and set aside, merely because another view is probable. Interference in
second appeal can be made by High Court only when, substantial questions
of law are made out and findings recorded by learned Courts below are
totally perverse or result of exclusion of valid material or result of admission
of inadmissible material.
26. Judgment of Hon’ble Supreme Court in Derek A.C. Lobo &
Ors. Vs. Ulric M.A. Lobo (dead) by L.Rs. & Ors. , 2024 (2) RCR (Civil)
873 serves as pivotal reference in the realm of probate law, particularly
concerning the burden of proof in validating wills under suspicious
circumstances, therein it was held :
●
Mere registration of a will does not inherently validate
it; it must still satisfy the legal requirements under
Section 63 of the Indian Succession Act and Section 68
of the Indian Evidence Act. Moturu Nalini Kanth Vs.
Gainedi Kaliprasad (Dead) Through Lrs. , Law
Finder Doc Id # 2391980.;
SUNIL CHANDER
2026.09.16 10:21
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document

RSA No.2481 of 2000
FAO-419-1992 -17-
●
Any suspicion regarding a will's validity must be
explicitly presented by the contestant opposing the will,
shifting the onus back to the propounder to dispel such
doubts. Gurdial Kaur & Ors. Vs. Kartar Kaur &
Ors. , Law Finder Doc Id # 30637 ;
●
Propounder must demonstrate the testator's sound mind
and free will in the execution of the will, especially
when beneficiaries have a prominent role in its
execution. Meenakshiammal (Dead) through LRs.
Vs. Chandrasekaran , (2005) 1 SCC 280;
●
Suspicion alone cannot undermine a will unless
accompanied by substantial evidence indicating issues
like undue influence or coercion.
P.P.K. Gopalan
Nambiar Vs. P.P.K. Balakrishnan Nambiar , AIR
1995 SUPREME COURT 1852;
●
The initial burden to prove the execution and validity of
a will lies with the propounders.
●
If the opposing party raises specific and well-founded
suspicious circumstances, the burden shifts back to the
propounders to dispel these doubts.
27. Evidence led by both the parties as well as concurrent findings
recorded by learned Courts below, therefore, has to be appreciated on the
touchstone of legal principles noted-above.
28. In the present case, appellant-defendant No.3 and defendant
No.4 have been non-suited and Will dated 09.03.1973 was rejected by
learned Courts below on the twin grounds:-
i. That evidence of Sohan Lal DW-3 attesting witness
regarding execution of Will is not reliable and
trustworthy.
ii. Report of handwriting expert goes to raise serious doubt
SUNIL CHANDER
2026.09.16 10:21
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document

RSA No.2481 of 2000
FAO-419-1992 -18-
over its execution in presence of Sohan Lal DW-3.
29. Learned Courts had also found Will to be suspicious as
appellant-defendant No.3 and defendant No.4 in whose favour Will was
executed were neither staying with testator nor were serving him. Testator
had excluded his wife, daughters and even father of defendants No.3 and 4
from succession and not preferred any of his other grandsons and
granddaughters.
30. On appreciation of evidence as well as findings recorded by
learned Courts below, I find that both the learned Courts below have
threadbarely examined the evidence of DW-3 as well as handwriting expert
Sh. Dewan K.S. Puri PW-5 and have rightly concluded that Will was not
executed in presence of DW-3 and DW-3 had signed subsequently and not at
the time of alleged execution of Will. The reasoning given by both the
Courts is based upon correct appreciation of evidence.
31. In the present case, it was the claim of DW-3 who had claimed
himself to be attesting witness who had signed the Will in presence of
testator along with second attesting witness and testator. The original Will
was duly summoned by the Court and perused, and was found that it was in
torn condition. It was also found that to secure the torn paper upon which
Will was written, a cloth was pasted. It has also come on record as admitted
by DW-3, that at the time of signing of Will, the cloth was not in existence at
the back of Will. Therefore, the conclusion drawn by learned Courts below
that the cloth was pasted after Will had started to torn off to protect further
damage to the paper upon which Will was written. Once this fact is
established that cloth was subsequently attached to the Will then the
SUNIL CHANDER
2026.09.16 10:21
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document

RSA No.2481 of 2000
FAO-419-1992 -19-
evidence of PW-5 handwriting expert assumes significance wherein, he has
categorically stated that while writing particulars of witnesses on the
margins of Will, pen stroke impression had come on the end of the paper and
on the cloth pasted on the Will. On finding pen stroke on cloth in continuity
with paper, it was opined by handwriting expert PW-5 that Will was signed
by attesting witness DW-3, only after cloth was attached to it that means at
the time of execution of Will, DW-3 was neither present nor had signed the
Will at the time of alleged writing and signing of Will by testator.
32. In the present case, even in absence of handwriting expert, if the
Court had found above-noted facts as were noted by handwriting expert, the
Court would have appreciated the evidence of DW-3 as was appreciated by
learned Courts below. If the impression of pen has continued on the cloth, it
goes to prove that signatures/particulars were appended to the Will after
cloth was affixed upon it, which was not present at the time of
execution/writing of Will and goes to show that signatures of DW-3 attesting
witness were ante-dated. Therefore, present is not a case where the
substantive evidence has been rejected on the basis of handwriting expert,
rather is a case where substantive evidence of DW-3 attesting witness was
appreciated in light of handwriting expert who had found the pen stroke on
the cloth indicating that signatures were appended by DW-3 not at the time
of execution of Will but after lapse of substantial time. This is a serious
suspicion which arises over the due execution of Will. Therefore, it was duty
of propounder of Will i.e. appellant-defendant No.3 and defendant No.4 to
remove this suspicion. It was for the appellant-defendant No.3 to prove that
the report of PW-5 was wrong and no pen stroke continued from paper to
SUNIL CHANDER
2026.09.16 10:21
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document

RSA No.2481 of 2000
FAO-419-1992 -20-
cloth indicating that Will was not signed at the time of its execution.
33. In this case, appellant-defendant No.3 had neither examined any
handwriting expert to rebut the evidence of PW-5 or to prove the age of
signatures by forensic examination. It was not upon respondents-plaintiffs to
lead forensic examination to prove age of signatures of testator/attesting
witnesses. They have very well been able to create a suspicion by examining
PW-5 and said suspicion ought to have been removed by none other than
appellant-defendant No.3 and defendant No.4. The onus to dispel suspicious
circumstances is upon appellant-defendant No.3 and defendant No.4 who are
propounder of Will and not upon respondents-plaintiffs.
34. The onus to raise suspicion was duly discharged by
respondents-plaintiffs and it was the duty of appellant-defendant No.3 and
defendant No.4 to dispel the same, in which they have failed. Similarly, the
fact that DW-3 had claimed that he had signed the Will with the same ink
assumes significance as from Will, it is proved that body of Will as well as
signatures of testator were in different ink and that of attesting witness were
in different ink. No doubt a witness is not required to state the facts with
mathematical precision. However, when he states that with definite surety
and such facts are proved to be wrong, in said cases, raising suspicion by the
Courts is fully justified.
35. In the present case, DW-3 had specifically asserted to have
signed the Will with the same ink. He could very well have stated that he
does not remember with passage of time or that he is not sure about ink of
Will. However, he rather claimed a particular fact which was found to be
wrong, therefore, fact regarding different ink used contrary to claim of DW3
SUNIL CHANDER
2026.09.16 10:21
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document

RSA No.2481 of 2000
FAO-419-1992 -21-
was rightly appreciated by the Courts. Therefore, it was the duty of
appellant-defendant No.3 to dispel suspicion arising out of said conduct of
DW-3 which has not been done.
36. Appreciation of evidence by learned Courts below cannot be
faulted with and the conclusion drawn by them that DW-3 attesting witness
had not signed the Will at the time of its execution is made out from the
evidence led by the parties. The findings recorded by both the Courts below,
therefore, is pure finding on fact, based upon evidence and therefore, cannot
be interfered in the present regular second appeal. Appellant-defendant No.3
had failed to show that the finding of learned Courts below is perverse or has
been result of admission of inadmissible evidence or omission of admissible
evidence. The conclusions drawn by learned Courts below is based upon
evidence led by the parties. No substantial question of law arises for
consideration in present appeal.
37. In view of above noted conclusion, there is no merit in the
present regular second appeal, therefore, same is liable to be dismissed.
Hence dismissed.
FAO NO.419 OF 1992
38. In view of above noted conclusion, wherein it has been found
that Will dated 09.03.1973 was not validly executed, FAO No.419 of 1992
arising from probate proceedings initiated by appellant-defendant No.3 and
defendant No.4 has become infructuous as finding by learned Civil Courts
that Will is not validly executed after appreciating evidence of attesting
witnesses are binding on parties and now cannot be gone into by Court in
probate proceedings. In probate proceedings, above-noted findings would be
SUNIL CHANDER
2026.09.16 10:21
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document

RSA No.2481 of 2000
FAO-419-1992 -22-
binding and therefore, present FAO No.419 of 1992 is also dismissed.
39. Pending application(s), if any, stands disposed of. Photocopy of
this order be placed on file on connected case.
(PARMOD GOYAL)
JUDGE
15.09.2026
Sunil Chander/Ravinder
Whether speaking/reasoned : Yes/No
Whether reportable : Yes/No
SUNIL CHANDER
2026.09.16 10:21
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document