THE STATE OF KARNATAKA vs MALAPPA
- Court
- Karnataka High Court
- 1 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:9329-DB
CRL.A No. 200363 of 2024
CNR: KAHC030115652024
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA
KALABURAGI BENCH
TH
DATED THIS THE 7 DAY OF SEPTEMBER, 2026
PRESENT
THE HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE ASHOK S. KINAGI
AND
THE HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE SUBRAMANYA RANGARAO
CRIMINAL APPEAL NO. 200363 OF 2024
(378(Cr.PC)/419(BNSS))
BETWEEN:
THE STATE OF KARNATAKA,
THROUGH VIJAYAPURA WOMEN POLICE STATION,
VIJAYAPURA,
VIJAYAPURA DISTRICT,
REPRESENTED BY
ADDL. STATE PUBLIC PROSECUTOR.
…APPELLANT
(BY SRI. ANILKUMAR NAVADAGI, ADDL.SPP)
AND:
1. MALAPPA
S/O TUKARAM HEBBALATTI,
AGED ABOUT 25 YEARS,
OCC: PRIVATE SERVICE,
R/O. TORAVI,
TQ. DISTRICT VIJAJAYPURA.
2. SURESH
S/O SOMAPPA PATTED,
AGED ABOUT 55 YEARS,
OCC: CENTRAL GOVT. EMPLOYEE,
Digitally signed
by B NAGAVENI
Location: HIGH
COURT OF
KARNATAKA
- 2 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:9329-DB
CRL.A No. 200363 of 2024
CNR: KAHC030115652024
R/O SAINIC SCHOOL CAMPUS
HOUSE NO. D.54
TQ. VIJAYAPURA,
DIST. VIJAYAPURA
KARNATAKA.
…RESPONDENTS
THIS CRL.A. IS FILED UNDER SECTION 419(1) AND (3)
OF BNSS (NEW), UNDER SECTION 378 (1) & (3) OF
CR.P.C(OLD), PRAYING TO
A) GRANT LEAVE TO APPEAL AGAINST THE JUDGMENT
AND ORDER DATED 10-01-2023 PASSED BY THE
ADDL. SESSIONS JUDGE FAST TRACK SPECIAL
COURT-I AT VIJAYAPURA, IN SPL. CASE (POCSO)
NO.43/2018, THEREBY ACQUITTING THE
ACCUSED/RESPONDENT No.1 FOR THE OFFENCES
PUNISHABLE UNDER SECTIONS 363 AND 376 (2)
(i) OF THE IPC, 1860 AND SECTIONS 4 AND 6 OF
THE PROTECTION OF CHILDREN FROM SEXUAL
OFFENCES ACT, 2012, (POCSO ACT, 2012).
B) SET ASIDE THE JUDGMENT AND ORDER DATED 10-
01-2023 PASSED BY THE ADDL. SESSIONS
JUDGE, FAST TRACK, SPECIAL COURT-I AT
VIJAYAPURA, IN SPL.CASE (POCSO) NO. 43/2018
THEREBY ACQUITTING THE RESPONDENT No.1-
ACCUSED FOR THE OFFENCES PUNISHABLE
UNDER SECTIONS 363 AND 376 (2) (i) OF THE
IPC, 1860 AND SECTIONS 4 AND 6 OF THE
PROTECTION OF CHILDREN FROM SEXUAL
OFFENCES ACT, 2012, (POCSO ACT, 2012).
C) CONVICT AND SENTENCE THE RESPONDENT
No.1/ACCUSED FOR THE OFFENCES PUNISHABLE
UNDER SECTIONS 363 AND 376 (2) (i) OF THE
IPC, 1890 AND SECTIONS 4 AND 6 OF THE
PROTECTION OF CHILDREN FROM SEXUAL
OFFENCES ACT, 2012 (POCSO ACT, 2012).
- 3 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:9329-DB
CRL.A No. 200363 of 2024
CNR: KAHC030115652024
THIS APPEAL, COMING ON FOR ADMISSION , THIS DAY,
JUDGMENT WAS DELIVERED THEREIN AS UNDER:
CORAM: HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE ASHOK S. KINAGI
and
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE SUBRAMANYA RANGARAO
ORAL JUDGMENT
(PER: HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE ASHOK S. KINAGI)
1. The State has filed this appeal under Sections 378(1)
and 378(3) of the Code of Criminal Procedure 1973
(for short, ‘ CrPC ’) [Subsection (1) and (3) of Section
419 of Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita, 2023
(for short, ‘ BNSS ’) ] challenging the judgment and
Order dated 10.01.2023 passed by the learned
Additional Sessions Judge, Fast Track, Special Court-
I at Vijayapura (for short, ‘ the Trial Court ’), in
Special Case (POCSO) No.43 of 2018, whereby
acquitting respondent No.1 (hereinafter referred to
as ‘ the accused ’) for the offences punishable under
Sections 363 and 376(2)(i) of the Indian Penal Code,
1860 (for short, ‘ IPC ’) and Sections 4 and 6 of the
- 4 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:9329-DB
CRL.A No. 200363 of 2024
CNR: KAHC030115652024
Protection of Children from Sexual Offences Act,
2012 (for short, ‘ POCSO Act ’).
2. The case of the prosecution is that on 15.08.2018 at
about 06.30 a.m., the accused knowing fully well
that the victim girl is a minor, kidnapped her on his
motorcycle and took her to Sindagi, where he
handed over his motorcycle to CW16. From there, he
took her to Afzalpur and Kalaburagi by bus. From
Kalaburagi, he took her to Nayanda Halli of
Bangalore by train. He kept her in his friend's room
rd
situated at 3 cross of Vinayaka Badavane and
committed rape/penetrative sexual assault on her
between 16.08.2018 and 18.08.2018 in night hours.
3. A complaint was lodged against the accused before
the Vijayapura Women Police Station. The Inspector
of said Police Station registered a criminal case in
Crime No.33 of 2018 for the offences punishable
- 5 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:9329-DB
CRL.A No. 200363 of 2024
CNR: KAHC030115652024
under Sections 363 and 376(2)(i) of IPC read with
Sections 4 and 6 of the POCSO Act.
4. The police took up the investigation and filed a
charge-sheet for the offences punishable under
aforesaid Sections. Charges came to be framed by
the learned Sessions Judge and the accused pleaded
not guilty.
5. The prosecution, in order to prove its case, examined
20 witnesses as PW-1 to PW-20 and marked 27
documents as Exhibits P-1 to 27 and two material
objects as MO-1 and MO-2.
6. While recording the statement under Section 313 of
CrPC, the accused gave an explanation and marked
four documents as Exhibits D1 to D4 and the said
documents are marked through PW3 and PW6.
7. The Trial Court after considering the entire material
placed on record held that the prosecution has failed
- 6 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:9329-DB
CRL.A No. 200363 of 2024
CNR: KAHC030115652024
to prove beyond reasonable doubt that the accused
kidnapped the victim girl and thereby committed an
offence punishable under Section 363 of IPC, and
also failed to prove beyond reasonable doubt that the
accused committed a rape on the victim girl
repeatedly and thereby committed an offence
punishable under Section 376(2)(i) of IPC and failed
to prove that the accused committed a penetrative
sexual assault/aggravated penetrative sexual assault
on the victim girl and thereby committed an offence
punishable under Sections 4 and 6 of the POCSO Act
and consequently, passed the judgment of acquittal,
under Section 235(1) of CrPC and the accused was
acquitted of the offences punishable under Sections
363 and 376(2)(i) of IPC and Sections 4 and 6 of the
POCSO Act vide judgment dated 10.01.2023.
8. The State, aggrieved by the judgment and order of
acquittal, filed this appeal.
- 7 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:9329-DB
CRL.A No. 200363 of 2024
CNR: KAHC030115652024
9. Heard the arguments of the learned Additional SPP.
10. Learned Additional SPP submitted that the Trial Court
has not properly appreciated the entire evidence on
record and also lost sight of the fact that the victim is
a minor girl of 16 years 3 months and there is a
corroborative evidence of PW11/Headmaster of the
School, who has deposed that the victim girl was a
minor as on the date of incident. He also submitted
that the Trial Court has relied more upon Exhibit P4
i.e., the statement of the victim recorded under
Section 164 of CrPC. He submitted that the said
statement is not conclusive evidence. He also
submitted that the Trial Court has failed to take note
of the presumption arising under Section 29 of the
POCSO Act. The Trial Court, without considering the
entire evidence on record, has passed the impugned
judgment. Hence, on these grounds, he prays to
allow the appeal.
- 8 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:9329-DB
CRL.A No. 200363 of 2024
CNR: KAHC030115652024
11. The points that arise for our consideration are as
follows:
“(i) Whether the State proves that
the impugned judgment and order
of acquittal passed by the Trial
Court is arbitrary and erroneous?
(ii) What order?”
Reg. Point No.1 :
12. We have considered the submissions made by the
learned Additional SPP for the State and have re-
evaluated the entire evidence placed by the
prosecution to drive home the guilt of the accused.
13. The prosecution examined the victim girl as PW1.
She has deposed that the accused belongs to her
village and used to come to her school. She knows
the accused, as such, friendship had developed
between herself and the accused and the said fact
was within the knowledge of her parents, who have
advised her and accused. The victim girl and the
- 9 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:9329-DB
CRL.A No. 200363 of 2024
CNR: KAHC030115652024
accused used to have a conversation over the phone
and thereafter, they began to talk.
14. On 14.08.2018, the accused called the victim girl in
the evening and requested her to come near the
Government Hospital on 15.08.2018 at about 06.00
a.m. in the morning. She agreed to the request
made by the accused. On 15.08.2018, her father
had gone to attend the flag hoisting ceremony and
her mother had gone to Lakshmi temple and her
brother was asleep. She left the house and waited
near the Government Hospital between 05.45 a.m.
and 06.00 a.m. While leaving the house, she took
Rs.4,50,000/- cash and packed her clothes. When
she was standing near the Government Hospital, the
accused came there and picked her on his motorcycle
and both went to Sindagi and then to Afzalpur. The
accused handed over the motorcycle to his uncle's
son. They left Kalaburagi on next day at about 05.30
a.m. and reached Bangalore on 16.08.2018 at about
- 10 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:9329-DB
CRL.A No. 200363 of 2024
CNR: KAHC030115652024
06.00 p.m. From the railway station, they went to
the house of the accused's friend situated at
Nayanda Halli and they stayed there till 18.08.2018.
She deposed that nothing happened between them
and they were there. Her brother and her uncle's son
came to the Nayanda Halli. They brought her and the
accused to the Vijayapura Police Station and lodged a
complaint. At that time, a complaint was already
lodged by her father.
15. During the course of cross-examination of PW1, she
has admitted that the statement was recorded under
Section 164 of CrPC by the learned Judicial
Magistrate. It is elicited that she has found that the
accused informed that her marriage would be
performed in her house, and told him to take her
away. It is elicited that on 15.08.2018 at about
05.30 a.m., the accused was standing in front of the
Government Hospital near gate No.1 of Sainik school
and she went there. She has specifically stated
- 11 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:9329-DB
CRL.A No. 200363 of 2024
CNR: KAHC030115652024
before the learned Judicial Magistrate that she
herself had accompanied the accused.
16. The prosecution has examined the complainant as
PW3, i.e., the father of the victim girl. He has
deposed that he knows the accused appeared before
the Court and the accused used to follow his
daughter while she was going to school. For that
reason, he called upon four elders of the village and
the parents of the accused and in their presence, the
accused was warned. He stopped his daughter to go
to school, however, the accused used to follow the
victim girl. He has deposed that he was working in
Sainik school and on 15.08.2018, he had left home
at 06.00 a.m. to the school to hoist the flag and his
wife had been to Lakshmi Temple. His wife, after
returning from Lakshmi Temple, found the absence
of the victim girl in the house, hence, she called the
complainant, and immediately, he returned to the
home and searched for the victim girl. As she was
- 12 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:9329-DB
CRL.A No. 200363 of 2024
CNR: KAHC030115652024
not traced out, he lodged a complaint on 16.08.2018
on suspicion. He also deposed that his wife's father
kept Rs.6,00,000/- in his house after selling the land.
Out of Rs.6,00,000/- the victim girl took a sum of
Rs.4,50,000/- and left the house. After coming to
know the whereabouts of the victim girl, he sent his
son to Bangalore. On 18.08.2018, his son brought
the victim girl and the accused and thereafter, they
took the victim girl to the police station.
17. The brother of the victim was examined as PW6. He
has deposed that he knew the accused and the
accused developed friendship with the victim girl i.e.,
PW-1 and PW-1 is the sister of PW-6. He has
deposed that on 15.08.2018, his father had been to
school in the morning to hoist the flag and the
mother had been to Lakshmi Temple and he was
sleeping in the house. PW-1 took an amount of
Rs.4,00,000/- which had been kept in the house and
went along with the accused. His mother returned
- 13 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:9329-DB
CRL.A No. 200363 of 2024
CNR: KAHC030115652024
from the temple and came to know that the victim
girl was not found in the house and the amount kept
in the house was missing. His mother informed the
complainant i.e., PW3 about the missing girl—their
daughter, as she was not traced. Then PW3 had
lodged a complaint. He has also deposed that on
16.08.2018, the victim girl was traced in Nayanda
Halli at Bangalore along with the accused and they
were brought to the house on the very next day.
18. The mother of the victim was examined as PW8. She
has deposed that she knows the accused and her
daughter knows the accused. She and her husband
came to know that the accused used to roam with
the victim girl. She and her husband (PW3) warned
the accused not to roam with her daughter. Despite
warnings, the accused did not leave the company of
her daughter and she has deposed that on
15.08.2018, she had been to Lakshmi Temple and
her husband had gone to the School. When she
- 14 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:9329-DB
CRL.A No. 200363 of 2024
CNR: KAHC030115652024
returned from the temple, she came to know that the
victim girl was missing and she called her husband
i.e., PW3 asking him to come home. Immediately
PW3 returned home and they searched all over the
place. They could not trace the victim girl and PW3
had kept Rs.4,50,000/- in the house and the amount
was taken by PW1 i.e., the victim and she was traced
out on 18.08.2018 at Bengaluru. Her husband and
son brought the victim girl and produced her before
the police. PW1 has informed PW8 that the accused
on promise of marriage had committed a rape on her
in the room.
19. The prosecution examined PW9 who was the owner
of the land and he sold the said land for
consideration and the said consideration was kept in
the house of the complainant. The complainant is the
son-in-law of PW9. He has deposed that he has sold
his land for Rs.25,00,000/- and same was kept in the
house. He pleads ignorance that as to whether the
- 15 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:9329-DB
CRL.A No. 200363 of 2024
CNR: KAHC030115652024
victim girl has left the house. The prosecution has
treated PW9 as a hostile witness.
20. The victim girl was subjected to medical test by
PW15 / Dr.Poonam Savalagi, who examined the
victim girl on 19.08.2018. She has deposed that she
examined the victim girl on 19.08.2018 as per the
requisition of Vijayapura Women police. A genital
examination was done by the gynecologist. She
collected the clothes of the victim girl. She had
deposed that after receiving the FSL report, she gave
a final report stating that were suggestive of signs of
sexual assault. Her medical report was marked as
Exhibit P21.
21. The prosecution also examined one more witness as
PW2 who is a pancha to Exhibit P1 i.e., the spot
panchanama. He has deposed about drawing up of
spot panchanama.
- 16 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:9329-DB
CRL.A No. 200363 of 2024
CNR: KAHC030115652024
22. From the perusal of the entire evidence of the
prosecution, it is clear that PW1—victim girl gave a
statement under Section 164 of CrPC before the
Judicial Magistrate, wherein she has stated that she
had voluntarily left the house with the accused and
she has not stated that the accused had kidnapped
or induced her.
23. Thus, PW1 has made an improvement in her
examination-in-chief and further she has admitted
during the course of cross-examination that herself
and accused used to talk on mobile phone secretly
and she was preparing to leave the house by packing
her dress and she also admitted that she gave a
statement under Section 164 of CrPC before the
learned Judicial Magistrate, wherein she admitted
that she has gone with the accused voluntarily and
the accused did not harass her in any manner.
- 17 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:9329-DB
CRL.A No. 200363 of 2024
CNR: KAHC030115652024
24. The victim girl and the brother of the victim girl i.e.,
PW6 has deposed that PW6 and his uncle's son had
been to Bangalore to bring the victim girl and
accused, but PW8—mother of the victim girl has
stated that her husband—PW3 and her son brought
the victim girl and produced before the police.
25. The evidence of PW8 and the evidence of PW6
contradicts each other, in that, PW6 has stated that
PW6 and his uncle's son had been to Bangalore to
bring the victim girl and accused, whereas the
mother of the victim girl i.e., PW8 has stated that
her husband and her son went to Bengaluru to bring
the victim girl and accused to their native place.
26. The victim girl herself has, during the course of
cross-examination, admitted that she has called the
accused informing him that she is waiting in front of
the Government Hospital near gate No.1 of Sainik
school at about 05.30 a.m. on 15.08.2018.
- 18 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:9329-DB
CRL.A No. 200363 of 2024
CNR: KAHC030115652024
27. The victim girl and the accused went to Ganihar
village and from there, they went to Sindagi on a
motorcycle and handed over that motorcycle to the
son of the accused’s uncle. The Investigating Officer
has not recorded the statement of the son of the
accused’s uncle and also not seized the motorcycle
on which the victim girl and accused proceeded from
Ganihar to Sindagi.
28. Further, the prosecution has not placed any material
to show that PW3 has kept the amount of
Rs.4,50,000/- in the house.
29. The Investigating Officer was examined as PW20. He
has deposed that on 19.08.2018, the complainant
PW3 brought the victim girl and the accused; and
they were produced before her and the victim girl
has given a statement. The portions of the statement
was marked as Exhibits D1 and D2, and also that she
has recorded the statement of PW6 and the portions
- 19 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:9329-DB
CRL.A No. 200363 of 2024
CNR: KAHC030115652024
of the statement of PW6 are marked as Exhibit D3
and Exhibit D4.
30. The prosecution examined the owner of the room as
PW-10 who had let out the room to the accused and
the victim girl on rent and it was given on rent during
2017-18. The prosecution has treated PW10 as a
hostile witness.
31. PW9 has stated that he has sold his land for
Rs.25,00,000/- and the same was kept in his house.
In order prove that PW9 has sold the land for
consideration of Rs.25,00,000/-, the prosecution has
not produced any registered sale deed to establish
that the said land was sold for Rs.25,00,000/- and
the said amount was kept in his house.
32. Admittedly, the victim girl was aged about 16 years
and 3 months as on the date of incident. In the cases
concerning the offence under POCSO Act,
- 20 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:9329-DB
CRL.A No. 200363 of 2024
CNR: KAHC030115652024
presumption operates against accused under Section
29 of the POCSO Act.
33. In light of the aforesaid contention raised by the
State, it is necessary to examine the effect of
presumption arising under Section 29 of POCSO Act
and the manner in which accused can rebut such a
presumption under Section 29 of POCSO Act, which
reads as follows:
“ 29. Presumption as to certain
offences.— Where a person is
prosecuted for committing or
abetting or attempting to commit
any offence under Sections 3, 5, 7
and Section 9 of this Act, the
Special Court shall presume, that
such person has committed or
abetted or attempted to commit the
offence, as the case may be unless
the contrary is proved.”
34. From a perusal of the said provision, it does indicate
that it is for the accused to prove the contrary,
- 21 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:9329-DB
CRL.A No. 200363 of 2024
CNR: KAHC030115652024
namely, he has not committed or abetted the
commission of offences under Sections 4 and 6 of the
POCSO Act, and in case if he failed to do so, the
presumption would operate against him, leading to
his conviction under the provisions of the POCSO Act.
Thus, it cannot be disputed that no presumption is
absolute and every presumption is rebuttable.
35. The said view has been taken by a Co-ordinate
Bench of this Court in the case of Mahadevu @
Pappi v. State of Karnataka by Pandavapura
1
Police Station , wherein it has been held as follows:
“26. In light of aforesaid
contention raised by the State, it is
necessary to examine the effect of
presumption arising under Section
29 of POCSO Act and the manner in
which accused can rebut such
presumption. Section 29 of the
POCSO Act reads as follows:
1
ILR 2020 KAR 4569
- 22 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:9329-DB
CRL.A No. 200363 of 2024
CNR: KAHC030115652024
“Section 29 — Presumption as
to certain offences — Where a
person is prosecuted for
committing or abetting or
attempting to commit any
offence under Sections 3, 5, 7
and 9 of the Act, the Special
Court shall presume, that
such person has committed or
abetted or attempted to
commit the offence, as the
case may be, unless the
contrary is proved.”
27. Perusal of the above provision
does indicate that it is for the
accused to prove the contrary
namely, he has not committed or
abetted the commission of an
offence under Section 3, 5, 7 and 9
of the POCSO Act and in case he
fails to do so, presumption would
operate against him leading to his
conviction under the provisions of
the Act. It cannot be disputed that
no presumption is absolute and
every presumption is rebuttable. It
cannot be countenanced that
presumption under Section 29 of
the Act is absolute. It would come
into operation only when
prosecution is first able to establish
- 23 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:9329-DB
CRL.A No. 200363 of 2024
CNR: KAHC030115652024
the fact and that would form the
foundation for presumption under
Section 29 of the Act to operate.
Otherwise, all the prosecution
would be required to do, is to file a
charge-sheet against the accused
under the provisions of the said Act
and then claim that evidence of
prosecution witness would have to
be accepted as gospel truth and
entire burden would be on the
accused to prove to the contrary.
Such a position of law or
interpretation of the presumption
under Section 29 of the Act cannot
be accepted as it would clearly
violate the constitutional mandate
and no person can be deprived of
liberty, except in accordance with
the procedure established by law.”
36. From the perusal of paragraph 27 in Mahadevu @
Pappi (supra) , it is clear that the said interpretation
of presumption under Section 29 of the POCSO Act
cannot be accepted as it would clearly violate the
- 24 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:9329-DB
CRL.A No. 200363 of 2024
CNR: KAHC030115652024
Constitutional mandate and no person can be
deprived of liberty.
37. From the perusal of medical records and also the
evidence of the doctor examined as PW15 and the
final opinion of PW15, who has given an opinion as
per Exhibit P21, it clearly goes to show that there
have been no injuries on the genitalia of the victim
girl.
38. PW-15, during the course of cross-examination, has
deposed that labia majoro and labia minoro are
intact; clitoris is normal; hymen shows no injuries;
and also recent signs of sexual intercourse are
absent. The medical records do not support the case
of the prosecution.
39. The Trial Court considering the entire evidence on
record has rightly recorded a finding that the
prosecution has failed to prove beyond reasonable
doubt that the accused kidnapped the victim girl and
- 25 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:9329-DB
CRL.A No. 200363 of 2024
CNR: KAHC030115652024
committed rape repeatedly and committed
penetrative sexual assault/aggravated penetrative
sexual assault on the victim girl and rightly passed
the impugned judgment.
40. The Hon’ble Apex Court in the case of
2
H.D Sundara and others v. State of Karnataka
summarized the principles governing the exercise of
the Appellate Jurisdiction while dealing with an
appeal against acquittal under Section 378 of Cr.P.C,
which is as under:
“9. Normally, when an Appellate
Court exercises appellate
jurisdiction, the duty of the
Appellate Court is to find out
whether the verdict which is under
challenge is correct or incorrect in
law and on facts. The Appellate
Court normally ascertains whether
the decision under challenge is
legal or illegal. But while dealing
2
(2023) 9 SCC 581
- 26 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:9329-DB
CRL.A No. 200363 of 2024
CNR: KAHC030115652024
with an appeal against acquittal,
the Appellate Court cannot examine
the impugned judgment only to find
out whether the view taken was
correct or incorrect. After re-
appreciating the oral and
documentary evidence, the
Appellate Court must first decide
whether the Trial Court's view was
a possible view. The Appellate
Court cannot overturn acquittal
only on the ground that after re-
appreciating evidence, it is of the
view that the guilt of the accused
was established beyond a
reasonable doubt. Only by
recording such a conclusion an
order of acquittal cannot be
reversed unless the Appellate Court
also concludes that it was the only
possible conclusion. Thus, the
Appellate Court must see
whether the view taken by the
Trial Court while acquitting an
accused can be reasonably
taken on the basis of the
evidence on record. If the view
- 27 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:9329-DB
CRL.A No. 200363 of 2024
CNR: KAHC030115652024
taken by the Trial Court is a
possible view, the Appellate
Court cannot interfere with the
order of acquittal on the ground
that another view could have
been taken. ”
(Emphasis supplied)
41. It is relevant to refer to the judgment of Hon’ble the
Apex Court rendered in the case of Sharad Birdhi
3
Chand Sarda v. State of Maharastra , wherein at
paragraph No.163, it is held as under:
“163. We then pass on to another
important point which seems to
have been completely missed by
the High Court. It is well settled
that where on the evidence two
possibilities are available or open,
one which goes in favour of the
prosecution and the other which
benefits an accused, the accused
undoubtedly entitled to benefit of
doubt. In Kali Ram v. State of
Himachal Pradesh, [(1973) 2
3
(1984) 4 SCC 116
- 28 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:9329-DB
CRL.A No. 200363 of 2024
CNR: KAHC030115652024
SCC 808] this Court made the
following observations (paragraph
25 p.820).
“Another golden thread which
runs through the web of the
administration of justice in
criminal cases is that if two
views are possible on the
evidence adduced in the case
one pointing to the guilt of
the accused and the other to
his innocence, the view which
is favourable to the accused
should be adopted. This
principle has a special
relevance in cases wherein
the guilt of the accused is
sought to be established by
circumstantial evidence.”
42. The Hon'ble Apex Court, in case of Umedbhai
4
Jadavbhai v. State of Gujarat in paragraph No.10
has held as under:
“10. Once the appeal was rightly
entertained against the order of
acquittal, the High Court was
entitled to re-appreciate the entire
evidence independently and come
to its own conclusion. Ordinarily,
the High Court would give due
4
1978 SCC (Cri) 108
- 29 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:9329-DB
CRL.A No. 200363 of 2024
CNR: KAHC030115652024
importance to the opinion of the
Sessions Judge if the same
were arrived at after proper
appreciation of the evidence... ”
(Emphasis supplied)
43. The Hon’ble Apex Court in the case of Chandrappa
5
and Others v. State of Karnataka wherein at
paragraph No. 44 it is held as under:
“44. In our view, if in the light of
above circumstances, the trial
Court felt that the accused could
get benefit of doubt, the said view
cannot be held to be illegal,
improper or contrary to law. Hence,
even though we are of the opinion
that in an appeal against acquittal,
powers of appellate Court are as
wide as that of the trial Court and it
can review, re-appreciate and
reconsider the entire evidence
brought on record by the parties
and can come to its own conclusion
on fact as well as on law, in the
5
(2007) 4 SCC 415
- 30 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:9329-DB
CRL.A No. 200363 of 2024
CNR: KAHC030115652024
present case, the view taken by the
trial Court for acquitting the
accused was possible and plausible.
On the basis of evidence, therefore,
at the most, it can be said that the
other view was equally possible.
But it is well-established that if
two views are possible on the
basis of evidence on record and
one favourable to the accused
has been taken by the trial
Court, it ought not to be
disturbed by the appellate
Court. In this case, a possible
view on the evidence of
prosecution had been taken by
the trial Court which ought not
to have been disturbed by the
appellate Court. The decision of
the appellate Court (the High
Court), therefore, is liable to be
set aside. ”
(Emphasis supplied)
- 31 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:9329-DB
CRL.A No. 200363 of 2024
CNR: KAHC030115652024
6
44. In Tota Singh and another v. State of Punjab ,
the Hon’ble Apex Court in para 6 has held as under:
“6. … The jurisdiction of the
appellate Court in dealing with an
appeal against an order of
acquittal is circumscribed by the
limitation that no interference is to
be made with the order of
acquittal unless the approach
made by the lower Court to the
consideration of the evidence in
the case is vitiated by some
manifest illegality or the
conclusion recorded by the Court
below is such which could not have
been possibly arrived at by any
Court acting reasonably and
judiciously and is, therefore, liable
to be characterized as perverse.
Where two views are possible
on an appraisal of the evidence
adduced in the case and the
Court below has taken a view
which is a plausible one, the
6
(1987) 2 SCC 529
- 32 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:9329-DB
CRL.A No. 200363 of 2024
CNR: KAHC030115652024
appellate Court cannot legally
interfere with an order of
acquittal even if it is of the
opinion that the view taken by
the Court below on its
consideration of the evidence
is erroneous .”
(Emphasis supplied)
7
45. In State of Rajasthan v. Raja Ram , the Hon’ble
Apex Court has held as follows:
“7. … The golden thread which runs
through the web of administration
of justice in criminal cases is that if
two views are possible on the
evidence adduced in the case, one
pointing to the guilt of the accused
and the other to his innocence, the
view which is favorable to the
accused should be adopted. The
paramount consideration of the
Court is to ensure that miscarriage
of justice is prevented. A
miscarriage of justice which may
arise from acquittal of the guilty is
7
(2003) 8 SCC 180
- 33 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:9329-DB
CRL.A No. 200363 of 2024
CNR: KAHC030115652024
no less than from the conviction of
an innocent. [Further, it is held
that] in a case where admissible
evidence is ignored, a duty is cast
upon the appellate Court to re-
appreciate the evidence in a case
where the accused has been
acquitted, for the purpose of
ascertaining as to whether any of
the accused committed any offence
or not. The principle to be followed
by the appellate Court considering
the appeal against the judgment of
acquittal is to interfere only where
there are compelling and
substantial reasons for doing so. If
the impugned judgment is clearly
unreasonable, it is a compelling
reason for interference.”
8
46. In Surajpal Singh v. State , the Hon'ble Apex
Court has held as under:
“7. It is well established that in an
appeal under Section 417 CrPC
[old], the High Court has full
8
1951 SCC 1207
- 34 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:9329-DB
CRL.A No. 200363 of 2024
CNR: KAHC030115652024
power to review the evidence upon
which the order of acquittal was
founded, but it is equally well
settled that the presumption of
innocence of the accused is further
reinforced by his acquittal by the
Trial Court, and the findings of the
Trial Court which had the
advantage of seeing the witnesses
and hearing their evidence can be
reversed only for very substantial
and compelling reasons.”
47. The Hon'ble Apex Court in the case of Deepak in JC
9
v. State Govt. of NCT Delhi has held that, the
statutory presumption does not absolve the Courts of
their duty to analyse the evidence in the context of a
particular case. It is also observed that, the Court
should not mechanically accept the ipse dixit of the
prosecution riding on the provisions regarding the
presumption of guilt, to give a stamp of approval to
every prosecution, even if they are absurd or
9
2026 SCC OnLine SC 1914
- 35 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:9329-DB
CRL.A No. 200363 of 2024
CNR: KAHC030115652024
improbable in its story. It is further held that, the
reverse burden contemplated in presumptive
provisions could be said to be an additional weapon
in the prosecution's armory, but said that the
accused could thwart its operation by leading
evidence to the contrary.
48. The Hon’ble Apex Court, in the case of State of
10
Uttar Pradesh v. Anurudh and Another , has
held in paragraph No.19 as follows:
“19. …. … We have referred to
certain instances of the High Courts
noting the misuse/misapplication of
the POCSO Act, somewhat in line
with the indices appended to the
impugned judgment as also its
progenitors.
Considering the fact that repeated
judicial notice has been taken of
the misuse of these laws, let a copy
of this judgment be circulated to
10
2026 SCC OnLine SC 40
- 36 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:9329-DB
CRL.A No. 200363 of 2024
CNR: KAHC030115652024
the Secretary, Law, Government of
India, to consider initiation of steps
as may be possible to curb this
menace inter alia, the introduction
of a Romeo - Juliet clause
exempting genuine adolescent
relationships from the stronghold of
this law ; enacting a mechanism
enabling the prosecution of those
persons who, by the use of these
laws seeks to settle scores etc.”
(Emphasis supplied)
49. The Hon’ble Apex Court, in the case of Nitin B.
Nikhare v. The State of Maharashtra and
11
Another , has held in paragraph No.6 as follows:
“6. This Court in a catena of
judgments has held that the mere
fact that physical relations were
established pursuant to a
promise to marry will not
amount to a rape in every case.
In order for the offence of rape to
11
Criminal appeal arising out of SLP(Crl.) No.1889/2024, disposed of
on 21.01.2025
- 37 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:9329-DB
CRL.A No. 200363 of 2024
CNR: KAHC030115652024
be made out, two conditions need
to be satisfied i.e., that the promise
of marriage was made by the
accused solely with a view to obtain
consent for sexual relations without
having any intention of fulfilling
said promise from the very
beginning, and that the false
promise of marriage had a direct
bearing on the prosecutrix giving
her consent for sexual relations.
[See: Pramod Suryabhan Pawar
v. The State of Maharashtra and
Ors. (2019) 9 SCC 608; Mahesh
Damu Khare v. The State of
Maharashtra and Ors. 2024 SCC
OnLine SC 347 ]”
(Emphasis supplied)
50. The Punjab and Haryana High Court, in the case of
12
Jaspal Singh v. State of Punjab , has held in
paragraph No.31 as follows:
“31. When the evidence on record is
appreciated in the aforesaid
12
CRA-S-1956-SB-2004
- 38 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:9329-DB
CRL.A No. 200363 of 2024
CNR: KAHC030115652024
perspective, the cumulative effect of
the circumstances noticed
hereinabove creates a serious dent
in the prosecution case. The
complete absence of injuries despite
the specific allegation of a violent
physical struggle, the absence of
any indication of the alleged
trampled wheat crop at the place of
occurrence, the withholding of Kuljit
Singh, who was projected by the
prosecution itself as a material
witness, the unexplained
discrepancy regarding the police
having visited the place of
occurrence prior to the registration
of the FIR, the unexplained delay in
lodging the First Information Report,
the inconclusive nature of the
Chemical Examiner's report and the
probability of the defence plea,
when considered together, create a
reasonable doubt regarding the
truthfulness of the prosecution
version. Individually, each of
these circumstances may not
have been sufficient to dislodge
- 39 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:9329-DB
CRL.A No. 200363 of 2024
CNR: KAHC030115652024
the prosecution case; however,
viewed cumulatively, they
render it unsafe to sustain the
conviction of the appellant .”
(Emphasis supplied)
51. The Hon’ble Apex Court, in the case of Paramjit
13
Singh Bedi v. State of Punjab , has held in
paragraph No.29 as follows:
“29. When the learned Sessions
Judge had disbelieved the
prosecution version insofar the
charge under Section 366 IPC is
concerned, the very same
prosecution version could not have
been accepted to convict the
accused-appellant under Section
376 IPC. While the conduct of the
appellant may be immoral and
unethical, that by itself would not
justify a conviction under Section
376 IPC without any clinching
evidence. Such a charge must
be proved on the basis of hard
13
2026 SCC OnLine SC 2009
- 40 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:9329-DB
CRL.A No. 200363 of 2024
CNR: KAHC030115652024
evidence and not on the basis
of the surmises and
conjectures based on the value
judgment of the presiding
judge. Immorality of an act
sans credible evidence cannot
justify a conviction .”
(Emphasis supplied)
52. The Hon’ble Apex Court, in the case of Debraj Dutta
14
v. The State of West Bengal and Another , has
held in paragraph No.15 as follows:
“15. Unless the testimony of a
victim child is found to be fully
credible and trustworthy, the
question of applying the
presumption on the strength of
such statement alone would not
arise. The foundational fact of a
sexual assault that would attract the
presumption under Section 29 of the
POCSO Act would require more than
PW-1's statement which, on the face
14
Criminal appeal arising out of SLP (Crl.) No.16838/2025, disposed
of on 07.04.2026
- 41 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:9329-DB
CRL.A No. 200363 of 2024
CNR: KAHC030115652024
of it, was not credible as what she
had stated to her mother was not
borne out by her own statement
before the trial court. The victim child
narrated the incident to her mother
on the night of the incident itself and,
according to the mother, PW-2, the
child specifically stated that the
appellant had brushed his leg against
hers but during her deposition before
the trial court 8 months later, she
failed to mention the same. This
failure on the part of the victim
child to consistently narrate the
details of the incident negates
the possibility of applying the
statutory presumption .”
(Emphasis supplied)
53. There is no embargo on the Appellate Court
reviewing the evidence upon which an order of
acquittal is based. Generally, the order of acquittal
shall not be interfered with because the presumption
of innocence of the accused is further strengthened
by acquittal. The golden thread which runs through
- 42 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:9329-DB
CRL.A No. 200363 of 2024
CNR: KAHC030115652024
the web of administration of the Justice in criminal
cases is that, if two views are possible on the
evidence adduced in the case, one pointing to the
guilt of the accused and the other to his innocence,
the view which is favourable to the accused should
be adopted. The paramount consideration of the
Court is to ensure that miscarriage of justice is
prevented. A miscarriage of justice which may arise
from acquittal of the guilty is no less than from the
conviction of an innocent. This ratio is laid down in
the case of Ramanand Yadav v. Prabhunat Jha
and in the case of C.K. Dase Gowda And Others v.
15
State of Karnataka .
54. In the instant case, on the perusal of the medical
records and admission of the victim girl, it is clear
that when she herself leaves voluntarily and makes
her own choice without active inducement or force by
15
(2003) 12 SCC 606
- 43 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:9329-DB
CRL.A No. 200363 of 2024
CNR: KAHC030115652024
the accused, it does not amount to kidnapping; as
such, the accused has not committed an offence of
kidnapping and also there are no recent signs of
sexual intercourse. The Trial Court has rightly
acquitted the accused for the said offences.
55. Considering all the aspects of the matter, the Trial
Court has rightly extended the benefit of acquittal to
the accused.
56. Hence, we do not find any grounds to interfere with
the impugned judgment of the Trial Court and as
such, we decline to interfere with the judgment of
the Trial Court.
57. In view of the above, we answer point No.1 in the
negative holding that the Criminal Appeal filed by
the State is liable to be dismissed.
Reg. Point No.2 :
58. In view of the above discussion, we proceed to pass
the following:
- 44 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:9329-DB
CRL.A No. 200363 of 2024
CNR: KAHC030115652024
ORDER
(i) The appeal is dismissed .
(ii) The judgment of acquittal dated
10.01.2023 passed in Special Case
(POCSO) No.43 of 2018 by the
learned Additional Sessions Judge,
Fast Track, Special Court-I,
Vijayapura, having acquitted the
respondent for the offences
punishable under Sections 363 and
376(2)(i) of IPC and Sections 4 and
6 of the POCSO Act is hereby
confirmed .
Sd/-
(ASHOK S. KINAGI)
JUDGE
Sd/-
(SUBRAMANYA RANGARAO)
JUDGE
RK
List No.: 1 Sl No.: 10
CT:PK