MANJIT ORAON @ ORS vs THE STATE OF WEST BENGAL
- Court
- Calcutta High Court
1 / 9
WBCHCJ0043062026
Item No.1
Ct. No.1
PG
IN THE HIGH COURT AT CALCUTTA
CIRCUIT BENCH AT JALPAIGURI
FROM PRINCIPAL BENCH
CONSTITUTIONAL WRIT JURISDICTION
APPELLATE SIDE
WPA 1846 of 2026
Manjit Oraon & Ors.
Versus
The State of West Bengal & Ors.
Appearance:
Mr. Gopal Sah ………...Advocates for the Petitioners
Mr. Kunaljit Bhattacharjee, Ld. AGP
Ms. Esha Acharya
Mr. Bibek Tarafder …….Advocates for the State
CORAM: RAVINDRA VITHALRAO GHUGE,
CHIEF JUSTICE
&
OM NARAYAN RAI J.
Date: November 13, 2026
JUDGMENT (Per Ravindra V. Ghuge, CJ.):-
1. Rule. Rule made returnable forthwith and heard finally by the
consent of the parties.
2 / 9
2. The three Petitioners before this Court, claim to be labourers at
Goodway Tea Garden Private Limited in the Baradighi Tea Estate and
residents of the same locality under Bidhan Nagar Gram Panchayat.
3. It is their contention that they are using a bamboo bridge
constructed over the Kurti river, since 2019 for the purpose of travelling from
their village to the adjoining tea gardens, where substantial number of
villagers are engaged in employment.
4. The Petitioners have approached this Court because some persons
started demolishing the bridge on 11.08.2026. The villagers objected to the
demolition of the bridge. In view of this objection, the demolition was
stopped. The Petitioners are under the belief that the demolition is an unlawful
act. No order purportedly passed by the Sub-Divisional Magistrate has been
served upon the villagers. No notice of hearing was given to the villagers. If
the said bamboo bridge is demolished, the villagers, including the Petitioners,
would be compelled to take a longer route of approximately 7 to 8 kilometers
to reach the tea gardens, where they are working. It is likely to cause grave
hardships and additional expenditure to these villagers to reach the tea garden
for earning their livelihood.
3 / 9
5. The Petitioners further contend that since the villagers have been
using the bamboo bridge for around 8 years, the Respondents cannot
arbitrarily demolish the only bridge, which is a convenient means of access for
their livelihood. The bridge can be retained, repaired, strengthened or replaced
by an alternative permanent structure. It is further contended that the
Respondent authorities should consider providing a safe alternative bridge or
convenient access before dismantling the existing means of communication as
the villagers are dependent upon such bridge for reaching the tea garden.
6. In the above backdrop and the pleadings, the Petitioners have put
forth their prayers below clauses (a), (b), (c), (d) and (e), which read as under:
“a) writ of and/or in the nature of mandamus commanding the
respondent authorities concerned and their agents and
subordinates not to demolish, dismantle or otherwise interfere
with the bamboo bridge situated over the Kurti River at Village:
Mathachulka, Police Station: Matelli, District: Jalpaiguri, which
is being used by the petitioners and other villagers for accessing
the tea garden for work;
b) direction upon the concerned respondent authorities to first
arrange for a safe alternative means of access/bridge before
taking any step of demolition of said bridge, so that the
petitioners and other villagers are not deprived of access to their
place of work at tea garden;
4 / 9
c) direction upon the concerned respondent authorities to conduct
a proper technical inspection/safety assessment of the bamboo
bridge through a competent engineering authority and thereafter
take a reasoned decision in accordance with Law;
d) direction upon concerned respondent authorities to provide a
reasonable opportunity of hearing to the petitioners and the
affected villagers before taking any decision concerning such
bamboo bridge;
e) pending disposal of the present writ petition, pass an interim
order restraining the respondent authorities and their agents
from demolishing, dismantling, removing or interfering with the
bamboo bridge over the Kurti River at village: Mathachulka,
under Matelli Police Station, District:Jalpaiguri.”
7. The State Government has entered a Report (undated) under the
signature of the Executive Magistrate, Mal, Jalpaiguri. The same is
accompanied with certain documents, which have being marked as ‘X-1’ for
identification. In the said report (‘X-1’) , it is stated that the Deputy Magistrate
and Deputy Collector, Mal Sub-Division, along with the Food Safety Officer,
Mal Sub-Division and ASI of the Matilali Police Station, had inspected the
licence of the said Resort. Certain irregularities relating to food safety and
non-production of documents, were noticed. The resort providing the food and
lodging facilities, was found to be indulging in acts, which were not in
adherence to the food safety norms.
5 / 9
8. While carrying out such an inspection, a bridge was noticed to
have been built over a natural river, on Government land. When the concerned
resort, identified as Rahaman Farm House at Baradighi Basty, Batabari, P.S.
Matiali, District-Jalpaiguri, was inspected on 24.07.2026, the proprietor of the
said resort could not point out any permission by virtue of which he had
constructed the said bamboo bridge. Exercising powers under section 152 of
the Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita, 2023, an order was passed by the
Executive Magistrate directing the proprietor to discontinue the food serving,
on account of food safety violations. He was called upon to show documents
in a hearing scheduled on 07.08.2026, so as to justify the construction of the
bamboo bridge.
9. In the light of the order passed on 24.07.2026, a hearing was
conducted on 07.08.2026. The proprietor appeared before the concerned
authority on the said date. He had no permission for constructing the bamboo
bridge. Therefore, the concerned Magistrate directed the offending party to
remove the bamboo bridge immediately.
10. The State has tendered an Additional Report (3 pages) . The
Executive Magistrate has initialed below every page on the Report and has put
6 / 9
a date as 10.11.2026. Notwithstanding the displeasure expressed in the order
dated 15.10.2026 as regards the manner of submitting the Report (‘X-1’) , the
Executive Magistrate has apparently failed to understand our order and has
once again submitted a Report in a most shabby manner. The learned State
Government Advocate does not even know the name of the officer, who has
signed the Report, which the State Advocate has tendered to the Court. The
said Additional Report is marked as ‘X-2’ for identification.
he issue raised by the Petitioners in this Petition is with regard to
11. T
dismantling an apparently illegally erected bamboo structure. Below ‘X-1’, the
Executive Magistrate has mentioned that a permanent bridge exists across the
same river at a distance of about 2 to 2.5 kilometers from the said bamboo
bridge, which is meant for the use of the general public. The said permanent
bridge has been constructed by the State for facilitating an access/bridge way
over the river for the villagers residing in the said area. That bridge has been
used for a long time.
12. We apparently find that the bamboo bridge at issue has been
constructed by way of a shortcut convenience by the resort owner. The learned
State Government counsel submits that the bridge has been constructed on
7 / 9
Government land. Learned Advocate for the Petitioners vehemently submits that
if the existing concrete bridge is to be utilised, the villagers will have to walk a
further distance to have access to the existing concrete bridge constructed by the
State Government.
1 3 . The Block Development Officer, Matiali Block, Jalpaiguri, has
submitted a Report to the Sub-Divisional Officer, Mal Sub-Division dated
07.09.2026, which is at page-2 below ‘X-1’ . The Joint Block Development
Officer, Block Land and Land Reforms Officer, the Assistant Sub-Inspector of
Matelli Police Station and the BDO, have signed on the said joint inquiry report,
which is in connection with the land of Rahaman Farm House Resort.
1 4 . It is pointed out in the said Report that the field inquiry revealed a
250 feet private wooden bridge constructed by the resort owner to cross over the
river Kurti for his own purpose. The Plot Nos. of the river land are 313 (LR) and
314 (LR). There is a private tea garden, viz., ‘Good Ways’ on the back side of the
resort. The tea garden workers working with ‘Good Ways’, as well as the staff
and guests of the resort use the same wooden bridge to cross river Kurti. The
existing concrete bridge known as ‘Kurtia Bridge’, is around 01 kilometer away
from the said illegal wooden bridge.
8 / 9
1 5 . In the above peculiar circumstances, this Court cannot venture into
granting relief to a Resort owner, who has apparently erected a bridge illegally.
There is an existing ‘Kurtia Bridge’, said to be around 2 kilometers away from
the spot. As per the Report ‘X-1’ adverted to herein above, the said bridge is
around 1 kilometer away.
16. W e cannot grant protection to an illegal structure. If the Petitioners
and the villagers desire that a new bridge should be erected as per their
convenience, which would be closer to their village, notwithstanding the fact that
there cannot be a direction by the High Court to the State Government to provide
bridges as per the personal convenience of the Petitioners, it is for these villagers
to follow a particular procedure by approaching the Government, through the
Peoples’ Representative from their constituency. These are policy matters, which
are within the domain of the State Government. Had it been a case that there was
not a single bridge available, this Court could have treated this Petition as a PIL.
However, since a bridge is already existing and which is constructed by the State
Government to cater to the needs of the villagers residing in areas in proximity to
the said bridge, it would be best left to the wisdom of the State authorities to take
9 / 9
a call on such a demand. The convenience of the Petitioners cannot be ground to
protect an illegally constructed bamboo bridge.
17. The learned State Government counsel informs us that the resort
owner, who has participated in the hearing before the concerned Magistrate, had
started the demolition of the bridge in the light of the order of the Executive
Magistrate dated 07.08.2026. He has not approached any Court for seeking any
relief against the said order.
18. Considering the above, this Petition is dismissed .
19. Rule is discharged .
(OM NARAYAN RAI, J.) (RAVINDRA V. GHUGE)
CHIEF JUSTICE