DINESH KUMAR AGARWAL A HUNDU UNDIVIDED FAMILY vs ASSESMENT UNIT INCOME TAX DEPARTMENT NATIONAL ASSESMENT CENTRE(NAFAC) AND ANR

Court
Calcutta High Court

08
19.11.2026
Court No. 10
AGM


In The High Court At Calcutta
Constitutional Writ Jurisdiction
Appellate Side


W.P.A 11162 of 2026

Dinesh Kumar Agarwal
-versus-
Assessment Unit, Income Tax Department, National
Faceless Assessment Centre(NaFAC), New Delhi &
Ors.

Mr. Avra Mazumder
Ms. Alisha Das
Ms. Sreeja Mukherjee
Ms. Saakshi Shaw
…For the Petitioner.

Ms. Sanjukta Gupta
… For the respondents.

1. The petitioner, in the present writ petition, has
approached this Court under Article 226 of the
Constitution of India, complaining that despite a clear
remand direction to decide the matter afresh after
granting hearing and cross examination, the Assessing
Officer proceeded without complying with the said
direction.
2. The petitioner is an assessee for the Assessment
Year 2015-16, and the assessment was accordingly
completed against the petitioner. Thereafter the
petitioner preferred an appeal before the Income Tax
Appellate Tribunal.

3. The Tribunal, by its order, allowed the appeal for
statistical purposes and restored the matter to the file

2
of the Assessing Officer, with a specific direction to
decide the issue afresh after affording a reasonable
opportunity of hearing to the assessee, including an
opportunity of cross examination of the persons whose
statements were relied upon in light of the case of Amit
Agarwal vs. ACIT in ITA No. 2592 /Kol/2019. The
relevant paragraph 13.2 is reproduced below:
“13.2. Considering the above discussion in respect of
provisions contained in sec. 142(3) read with sec. 142(2),
we are inclined to consider the plea taken by the ld.
Counsel to remit the matter back to the file of Ld. AO and
direct the Ld. AO to make available the material gathered
by him in the course of enquiry conducted in terms of sec.
142(2) and provide a reasonable opportunity of being
heard to the assessee as enunciated u/s. 142(3) of the
Act along with effective opportunity of cross examination
as requested several times by the assessee. Thereafter,
Ld. AO may complete the assessment in accordance with
the provisions of law. Accordingly, ground no. 3 taken by
the assessee is allowed for statistical purposes.”

4. Despite such direction, the Assessing Officer failed
and neglected to comply with the said direction without
assigning any reason whatsoever, which is the subject
matter of challenge in the present writ petition.
5. It is submitted by the petitioner that the action of
the Assessing Officer in not complying with the
Tribunal’s direction is illegal, arbitrary, lacks propriety
and is not sustainable in the eye of law and is liable to
be quashed and set aside.
6. In this context, learned counsel appearing for the
petitioner places reliance upon paragraph 8 of the
judgment of the Hon’ble Supreme Court, in the case of
Union of India –versus- Kamlakshi Finance

3
Corporation Ltd . reported in 1991 (9) TMI 72-
Supreme Court wherein it has been observed that
bypassing the orders passed by the Appellate Authority
constitutes undue harassment and violates judicial
discipline, which is reproduced below:
“8. We have dealt with this aspect at some length,
because it has been suggested by the learned
Additional Solicitor General that the observations
made by the High Court, has been harsh on the
officers. It is clear that the observations of the High
Court, seemingly vehement, and apparently
unpalatable to the Revenue, are only intended to curb
a tendency in revenue matters which, if allowed to
become widespread, could result in considerable
harassment to the assessee-public without any benefit
to the Revenue. We would like to say that the
department should take these observations in the
proper spirit. The observations of the High Court
should be kept in kind in future and utmost regard
should be paid by the adjudicating authorities and the
appellate authorities to the requirements of judicial
discipline and the need for giving effect to the orders
of the higher appellate authorities which are binding
on them. ”

7. A further reliance has also been placed on ITO v.
M. Pirai Choodi, 2010 (15) SCC 283, for the
proposition that the Assessing Officer ought to have
granted an opportunity of cross examination.
8. Learned counsel appearing for the Income Tax
Authorities fairly submits that since the entire
assessment order is passed in the faceless mode, due to
technical laches, the Faceless Assessment of Officer was
unable to comply with the directions of the Appellate
Tribunal.

4
9. It is prayed that a specific direction be issued upon
the Jurisdictional Assessing Officer to act in terms of
the direction given by the Appellate Tribunal.
10. Having heard the parties at length and upon
perusing the materials on record including the
documents annexed to the writ petition, this Court finds
that a prima facie case has been made out, warranting
interference at this stage. This Court has taken the
judicial notice of the Departments plea of technical
laches in faceless mode, but cannot be accepted as a
justification for non compliance.
11. Faceless assessment is a procedural mechanism
but cannot override substantive rights of the assessee.
Technical difficulty cannot defeat a binding judicial
direction. Administrative inconvenience can never be a
ground to deny natural justice.
12. In view of the above, this Court directs the
Jurisdictional Assessing Officer to act in terms of the
directions given by the Appellate Tribunal for the
assessment year 2015-16 peremptorily, within a period
of four weeks from the date of communication of this
order by affording an opportunity of cross examination
of the persons whose statements have been relied upon,
and pass a reasoned and speaking order in accordance
with law. Such decision shall be communicated within a
week thereafter.

5
13. Since this Court has not gone into the merits of
the case, the other points are left upon before the
Jurisdictional Assessing Officer.
14. Since no affidavits have been called for, the
allegations made in the writ petition are deemed to have
been denied and not admitted.
15. With the above observations and directions that
the Writ Petition being WPA 11162 of 2026 is disposed
of without going into the merits of the case.

16. Urgent photostat certified copy of this order be
supplied to the parties, if applied for, as early as
possible.
( Smita Das De, J.)