Tilak Nagar Sri Gurudatta Cooperative Housing Society Limited vs Mishal Construction Pvt Ltd

Court
Bombay High Court

CNR No : HCBM020303962026

cpcdl30395-2026-J.doc
AGK
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAY
ORDINARY ORIGINAL CIVIL JURISDICTION
Digitally
signed by
ATUL
GANESH
KULKARNI
Date:
2026.11.21
12:31:42
+0530
IN ITS COMMERCIAL DIVISION
ATUL
GANESH
KULKARNI
CONTEMPT PETITION (L) NO.30395 OF 2026
IN
COMM ARBITRATION PETITION NO.203 OF 2025
WITH
INTERIM APPLICATION (L) NO.35499 OF 2026
Tilak Nagar Sri Gurudutta Cooperative
Housing Society Limited
… Petitioner
Vs.
1. Mishal Construction Pvt. Ltd.
2. Ajit Jain
3. Naveenkumar Jain
… Respondents
Mr. Kalpesh Joshi with Mr. Rushikesh Kekane and Mr.
Amar Parab i/by Kalpesh Joshi Associates for the
Petitioner.
Mr. Rohan Sawant with Mr. Chirag Sarawagi and Mr.
Shubham Shah i/by Mr. Tushar Goradia for the
Respondent.
Mr. Suresh Sabrad with Ms. Jessy Payne and Ms. Neha
Parte i/by Payne & Associate for the Applicant in IAL/
35499/2026.
CORAM : AMIT BORKAR, J.
RESERVED ON : NOVEMBER 18, 2026.
PRONOUNCED ON : NOVEMBER 21, 2026
JUDGMENT:
Background of the dispute:
1. The Petitioner is a Co-operative Housing Society. The Society
had appointed Respondent No.1, Mishal Construction Pvt. Ltd., as
1
Uploaded on - 21/11/2026 Downloaded on - 21/11/2026 12:35:48

cpcdl30395-2026-J.doc
the Developer for redevelopment of its building. Respondent Nos.2
and 3 are the Directors of Respondent No.1. The parties had
entered into a Development Agreement on 20 July 2010.
Thereafter, they entered into a Supplementary Agreement on 10
November 2014. Under these agreements, Respondent No.1 was
required to complete the redevelopment work and give permanent
alternate accommodation to the existing members of the Society.
However, the redevelopment work was not completed for a long
time. There were disputes between the parties regarding payment
of transit rent to the members. According to the Petitioner,
Respondent No.1 stopped paying transit rent from October 2018. It
failed to complete the redevelopment work within the agreed time.
Therefore, the Petitioner issued a notice dated 12 September 2023,
terminating the Development Agreement and the Power of
Attorney. After that, the Petitioner filed a Petition before this Court
under Section 9 of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996.
While that Petition was pending before this Court, the parties held
discussions and settled their disputes. For this purpose, they signed
Consent Terms on 10 October 2024. These Consent Terms were
placed before this Court on 17 October 2024.
2. By order dated 17 October 2024, this Court recorded that
the parties had signed the Consent Terms voluntarily and without
any pressure. The Court accepted the Consent Terms and disposed
of the Commercial Arbitration Petition in terms of the settlement
between the parties. The present contempt proceedings have been
filed because, according to the Petitioner, the Respondents have
failed to follow the Consent Terms. It is necessary to refer to some
2
Uploaded on - 21/11/2026 Downloaded on - 21/11/2026 12:35:48

cpcdl30395-2026-J.doc
of the clauses of those Consent Terms. Clause 4 of the Consent
Terms reads as under:
"These Consent Terms have been arrived at between the
parties for the purpose of completing the redevelopment
project of the Petitioner society in a time bound manner in
the manner recorded in the Development Agreement (i.e.
with full OC) and record the respective obligations of the
parties as the undertakings given to the Hon’ble Court"
3. It can be seen from this clause that the parties have stated
that their respective obligations under the Consent Terms are
undertakings given to this Court.
4. Clause 7 provides that Respondent No.1 would complete the
remaining construction work and obtain Full Occupancy Certificate
within six months from the date on which MHADA revoked the
stop-work notice. Respondent No.1 had agreed to give this
undertaking to the Court. It was agreed that actual construction
work would start within seven days from the filing of the Consent
Terms, subject to the Petitioner Society and Respondent No.2
carrying out their respective obligations. The parties were required
to approach MHADA and MahaRERA within seven days for
obtaining the necessary permissions. They were required to make
efforts to obtain these permissions within thirty days. Clause 8
provides that the Society and Respondent No.2 would open a new
Project Bank Account. Both were required to operate this account
jointly. Respondent No.2 was required to deposit Rs.2.20 Crores in
this account. The remaining amount of Rs.91.53 Lakhs, which was
receivable from the flat purchasers, was required to be deposited.
After these amounts were used for completing the remaining work,
3
Uploaded on - 21/11/2026 Downloaded on - 21/11/2026 12:35:48

cpcdl30395-2026-J.doc
Respondent No.1 was required to bring money, if required, from its
own sources and from the amounts receivable from other flat
purchasers. Clause 11 provides that the money deposited in the
Project Bank Account would be used for construction work and
other expenses of the project. Before any payment was made, the
bills raised by the contractors were required to be checked and
certified by Respondent No.1.
5. Clause 13 provides that Respondent No.1 would give two
cheques to the Petitioner Society. The first cheque was for Rs.51
Lakhs. It was agreed that this cheque could be deposited only after
MHADA granted permission to start construction and MahaRERA
removed the project from abeyance and granted the necessary
extension. The second cheque was for Rs.77 Lakhs towards the
outstanding transit rent. It was agreed that this cheque could be
deposited at or before handing over possession of the
rehabilitation flats or within 180 days from the filing of the
Consent Terms, whichever was earlier. This clause provides:
"And in the event even one of the cheque is dishonoured the
same will be treated as breach these Consent Terms."
6. Clause 26 provides that disputes and differences relating to
the Development Agreement, Supplementary Agreement and other
claims in law would be referred to arbitration after six months
from the date of signing the Consent Terms. Clause 38 provides
that if Respondent No.1 commits breach of any condition of the
Consent Terms, the Petitioner Society would be entitled to bring
back the earlier termination of the Development Agreement,
Supplementary Agreement and Power of Attorney into effect. For
4
Uploaded on - 21/11/2026 Downloaded on - 21/11/2026 12:35:48

cpcdl30395-2026-J.doc
this purpose, the Society would have to issue a seven-day
termination confirmation letter. The clause states:
"This clause shall be treated as undertaking of Respondent
No. 1 and its directors to the Hon’ble Court."
7. Clause 39 provides that after termination of the
Development Agreement and Supplementary Agreement, the
Petitioner Society and Respondent No.2 would be entitled to
complete the remaining work themselves. It gives the Society the
right to deal with three unregistered flats if the cheques of Rs.51
Lakhs and Rs.77 Lakhs are dishonoured. Clause 46 provides that
none of the parties would create any obstruction or difficulty in
completing the remaining work. All parties were required to
cooperate with each other. It provides that if any default takes
place, the Petitioner Society and Respondent No.2 would be
entitled to start execution proceedings and contempt proceedings
against Respondent No.1 and its Directors. This right is subject to
the Petitioner Society and the members of Respondent No.2 first
fulfilling their obligations under the Consent Terms. Clauses 56
and 57 provide that if there is any default, the Petitioner Society
and Respondent No.2 would be entitled to complete the remaining
work. If any difficulty or dispute comes up while carrying out that
work, they can approach this Court and ask for directions.
Submissions of the Petitioner:
8. Mr. Kalpesh Joshi, learned Advocate appearing for the
Petitioner submits that the Consent Terms cannot be treated as
only a arrangement between the parties. According to the
5
Uploaded on - 21/11/2026 Downloaded on - 21/11/2026 12:35:48

cpcdl30395-2026-J.doc
Petitioner, these terms were placed before this Court and the
original Petition filed under Section 9 of the Arbitration and
Conciliation Act was disposed of in terms of those Consent Terms.
It is submitted that Clause 4 says that the obligations of the parties
are undertakings given to this Court. Clause 7 contains a
undertaking by Respondent No.1 to complete the remaining
construction work. Similarly, Clause 38 states that the undertaking
under that clause is given by Respondent No.1 and its Directors to
this Court. The Petitioner relies upon Clause 46 of the Consent
Terms. According to the Petitioner, this clause gives it the right to
start contempt proceedings against Respondent No.1 and its
Directors if any default is committed. Therefore, the Respondents
cannot now say that the Consent Terms are only a arrangement
and that the Petitioner can take action only through arbitration. It
is submitted that Respondent No.1 had voluntarily given the two
cheques. It had agreed that dishonour of even one cheque would
amount to breach of the Consent Terms. Both cheques have been
returned unpaid because of insufficient funds. According to the
Petitioner, this shows that Respondent No.1 has deliberately failed
to honour the undertaking given to this Court. The Petitioner
submits that the Respondents cannot escape their obligations by
raising disputes about accounts and expenditure. According to the
Petitioner, the Society and the association of flat purchasers have
provided substantial amounts for completing the remaining work.
However, the Respondents have not provided money and have
failed to complete the project as agreed.
6
Uploaded on - 21/11/2026 Downloaded on - 21/11/2026 12:35:48

cpcdl30395-2026-J.doc
Submissions of the Respondents:
9. Mr. Rohan Sawant learned Advocate appearing for the
Respondents opposes the contempt petition. It is submitted that all
the Consent Terms must be read together. According to the
Respondents, one clause cannot be read separately without
considering the other conditions agreed between the parties. The
Consent Terms provide what action can be taken if Respondent
No.1 commits any default. Clauses 13, 38, 39 and 56 set out the
remedies available to the Petitioner Society in such a situation. It is
submitted that under Clause 26, the parties had agreed that
disputes regarding transit rent and other outstanding amounts
would be referred to arbitration. Therefore, according to the
Respondents, the Petitioner cannot use contempt proceedings
instead of arbitration or use them to recover amounts which are
disputed between the parties. The Respondents submit that the
cheque of Rs.51 Lakhs could be deposited only after MHADA
granted permission to start construction and MahaRERA removed
the project from abeyance. According to them, these conditions
were not fulfilled. The Respondents rely upon the Petitioner's own
letter dated 11 September 2025 and reminder dated 20 October
2025. According to them, these letters show that the project was
still under abeyance and the necessary permissions had not been
obtained. Therefore, the Petitioner was not entitled to deposit the
cheque of Rs.51 Lakhs. Regarding the cheque of Rs.77 Lakhs, the
Respondents submit that this amount is towards outstanding
transit rent. According to them, the Society's claim for this amount
is disputed and must be decided in arbitration. They point out that
7
Uploaded on - 21/11/2026 Downloaded on - 21/11/2026 12:35:48

cpcdl30395-2026-J.doc
the cheque was deposited in December 2025, whereas Clause 13
provides for depositing the cheque within 180 days from the filing
of the Consent Terms. The Respondents submit that the Society
and the Flat Purchasers' Association were required to open and
operate the Project Bank Account jointly. They were required to
give details of the amounts spent from that account. Respondent
No.1 was required to check and certify the construction bills before
payment was made. According to the Respondents, the Society and
the Association are operating the Project Bank Account. However,
they have not given the bank statements, bills and other necessary
details to Respondent No.1. In support of this submission, the
Respondents rely upon their reply dated 7 November 2025. By that
reply, they had asked the Society to provide details of the actual
expenditure, amounts deposited by the flat purchasers, bank
statements and bills relating to the remaining work.
10. The Respondents submit that the Society has taken over the
project and has received substantial amounts from the flat
purchasers. However, the accounts showing how these amounts
have been spent have not been given to Respondent No.1.
Therefore, according to the Respondents, Respondent No.1 cannot
be held responsible for every delay or every amount spent on the
project. The Respondents rely upon the proceedings relating to
three unregistered flats, namely A-203, A-304 and B-1003. It is
submitted that MahaRERA and other authorities have passed
orders in proceedings filed by different flat purchasers. According
to the Respondents, these proceedings have affected the rights of
the parties and have created difficulties in dealing with these flats.
8
Uploaded on - 21/11/2026 Downloaded on - 21/11/2026 12:35:48

cpcdl30395-2026-J.doc
The Respondents submit that there is no deliberate failure to
follow any specific undertaking given to this Court. In support of
this submission, they rely upon Bharat Shah v. Ramesh Shah &
Ors., Contempt Petition (L) No.33780 of 2024 , Starlift Services
Pvt. Ltd. v. Alba Asia Pvt. Ltd., 2024 SCC OnLine Bom 1170 , and
Nirmal Urban Co-operative Bank Ltd. v. Mamta Kennedy Naidu,
2019 SCC OnLine Bom 5636 . According to the Respondents, when
the Consent Terms provide what action can be taken in case of
default, contempt proceedings should not be used to enforce
contractual obligations which are disputed between the parties.
Questions for consideration:
11. At this stage, this Court is not required to finally decide
whether the Respondents have committed contempt. The question
now is whether the material placed before this Court is enough to
show a prima facie case against the Respondents. In other words,
whether there is sufficient material to call upon them to explain
what they have done and why. After considering the submissions
made by both sides, the following questions arise for
consideration:
(i) Whether the Consent Terms dated 10 October 2024 contain
undertakings given to this Court?
(ii) Whether the allegations and documents placed on record
show a prima facie case of wilful breach of any continuing
undertaking by the Respondents?
(iii) Whether the Respondents can avoid contempt proceedings
only because the Consent Terms provide other remedies, including
9
Uploaded on - 21/11/2026 Downloaded on - 21/11/2026 12:35:48

cpcdl30395-2026-J.doc
termination of the agreements and arbitration?
(iv) Whether notice can be issued against the three Respondents
under the Bombay High Court (Original Side) Rules?
Legal position regarding issue of contempt notice:
12. Section 2(b) of the Contempt of Courts Act, 1971 explains
what is civil contempt. It includes a deliberate failure to follow any
judgment, decree, direction, order, writ or other process of a Court.
It includes a deliberate breach of an undertaking given to a Court.
Therefore, the failure must be wilful and deliberate. Every failure
to carry out an obligation under a contract cannot be treated as
contempt. The Court must first see whether the obligation was
given to the Court or was made part of an order passed by the
Court. There must be some material to show that the failure was
deliberate and was not due to some genuine difficulty or reason.
The Supreme Court in Rama Narang v. Ramesh Narang, (2006) 11
SCC 114 , has held that only because a consent order can be
enforced through execution proceedings, it does not mean that the
Court loses its power to take action for contempt. If the terms of a
consent order contain directions of the Court or undertakings
given to the Court, a wilful breach of those terms can be examined
in contempt proceedings. At the same time, there must be a clear
undertaking given to the Court. A promise made by one party to
another party does not become an undertaking to the Court only
because it is written in a consent document. This difference was
explained by the Supreme Court in Babu Ram Gupta v. Sudhir
Bhasin, (1980) 3 SCC 47, and was considered in Rama Narang.
10
Uploaded on - 21/11/2026 Downloaded on - 21/11/2026 12:35:48

cpcdl30395-2026-J.doc
13. The procedure for dealing with contempt proceedings is
provided in Chapter LVIII of the Bombay High Court (Original
Side) Rules, 1980. Rule 1035(1) provides that the contempt
petition must be placed before the Court for preliminary hearing. If
the Court finds that a prima facie case is made out, it may issue
notice to the person against whom contempt is alleged. If the
Court does not find such a case, it can dismiss the petition. Rule
1036 provides that the notice must be issued in Form I. Unless the
Court gives some different direction, the person against whom
contempt is alleged must remain personally present before the
Court. A copy of the contempt petition, along with its annexures
and affidavits, must be served upon that person. Rule 1037 permits
the person against whom notice is issued to file an affidavit in
reply within fourteen days from the date on which the notice is
served. Thus, Rule 1035 deals with whether notice should be
issued or not. Rule 1036 provides the form and manner in which
the notice is to be issued and served.
14. There is a difference between the stage of issuing notice and
the stage of finally deciding the contempt petition. When the Court
considers whether notice should be issued, it is not required to
decide the entire dispute or give a final finding that the person is
guilty of contempt. At that stage, the Court has only to see whether
there is sufficient material which requires an explanation from the
person against whom contempt is alleged. This approach has been
followed by this Court in Anchor Point Developer Limited v. PMT
Machines Limited, Contempt Petition (L) No.32546 of 2026,
decided on 27 October 2026 . This Court has explained that notice
11
Uploaded on - 21/11/2026 Downloaded on - 21/11/2026 12:35:48

cpcdl30395-2026-J.doc
should not be issued mechanically in every case. At the same time,
before issuing notice, the Court is not required to finally decide
whether the persons against whom contempt is alleged are guilty.
If the material placed before the Court requires an explanation,
they can be called upon to give that explanation.
Whether the Consent Terms contain undertakings to this Court:
15. I find substance in the submission made on behalf of the
Petitioner that the Consent Terms cannot be treated as only a
arrangement between the parties. Clause 4 states that the
obligations of the parties are recorded as undertakings given to
this Court. This is an important condition in the Consent Terms.
These terms were not merely exchanged or signed between the
parties. They were placed before this Court and accepted on
record. The original Petition under Section 9 of the Arbitration and
Conciliation Act was disposed of in terms of these Consent Terms.
Clause 7 makes the position clear. Under this clause, Respondent
No.1 has agreed and given an undertaking to this Court that it
would complete the remaining work and obtain the Full
Occupancy Certificate within the period mentioned in that clause.
Clause 38 states that the obligation relating to termination of the
Development Agreement and revocation of the Power of Attorney
would be treated as an undertaking given by Respondent No.1 and
its Directors to this Court. Clause 46 records that the parties would
not create any obstruction or difficulty in completing the
remaining work and would cooperate with each other. More
importantly, this clause keeps open the right of the Petitioner
Society and Respondent No.2 to start execution proceedings and
12
Uploaded on - 21/11/2026 Downloaded on - 21/11/2026 12:35:48

cpcdl30395-2026-J.doc
contempt proceedings against Respondent No.1 and its Directors if
there is any default. This right is subject to the other parties first
carrying out their respective obligations under the Consent Terms.
In view of these clauses, the submission of the Respondents that
the entire Consent Terms are only a contract and that contempt
proceedings can never be started for breach of these terms cannot
be accepted.
16. In Nirmal Urban Co-operative Bank Ltd. , this Court
considered a case where the Consent Terms contained an
undertaking to repay the outstanding loan amount. However, the
same Consent Terms provided that the bank could sell the
mortgaged property if the amount was not paid within the agreed
period. It was held that the entire arrangement had to be read
together. On the facts of that case, the undertaking was mainly
given to the bank and not to the Court, because the parties had
decided what would happen if the amount was not paid.
17. Similarly, in Starlift Services Pvt. Ltd. , this Court considered
an order which provided for an automatic consequence if the
amount was not deposited within the fixed time. If the amount
was not deposited, the Respondents lost their right to file a
statement of defence or counter-claim in the arbitration
proceedings. The Court considered this condition while deciding
whether contempt proceedings should be started.
18. The present case is different in an important way. Clause 4
records that the obligations of the parties are undertakings given
to this Court. Clause 38 describes the undertaking of Respondent
13
Uploaded on - 21/11/2026 Downloaded on - 21/11/2026 12:35:48

cpcdl30395-2026-J.doc
No.1 and its Directors as an undertaking given to this Court.
Clause 46 keeps open the right to start contempt proceedings.
Clauses 38 and 39 provide certain consequences if there is breach
of the Consent Terms. However, only because these consequences
are provided, it cannot be said that this Court has no power to
examine a separate breach of an undertaking given to it. In fact,
Clause 46 keeps open the right to start contempt proceedings.
Therefore, only because the Petitioner has a right to terminate the
Development Agreement, deal with the three unregistered flats or
refer disputes to arbitration, it cannot be said that this Court is
prevented from examining whether there has been a wilful breach
of an undertaking given to it. At the same time, it must be kept in
mind that every failure to follow the Development Agreement
cannot be treated as contempt. The Court has to examine whether
there is a clear breach of an undertaking given to it.
19. The Petitioner has placed considerable reliance upon the
dishonour of the two cheques issued by Respondent No.1 under
Clause 13 of the Consent Terms. According to the Petitioner, both
cheques were returned unpaid on 5 December 2025 with the
endorsement "Funds Insufficient". The Petitioner submits that this
amounts to a clear breach of the undertaking given to this Court.
The Respondents submit that the conditions for depositing the
cheques were not fulfilled and, therefore, contempt cannot be
alleged on this ground.
20. I have considered the submissions made by both sides and
the relevant part of Clause 13. Under this clause, Respondent No.1
agreed to give two cheques to the Petitioner Society. The first
14
Uploaded on - 21/11/2026 Downloaded on - 21/11/2026 12:35:48

cpcdl30395-2026-J.doc
cheque was for Rs.51 Lakhs and the second cheque was for Rs.77
Lakhs. The first cheque was connected with obtaining permission
from MHADA to start construction and removal of the project from
abeyance by MahaRERA. The second cheque was towards
outstanding transit rent. It was payable at or before handing over
possession of the rehabilitation flats or within 180 days from filing
of the Consent Terms, whichever was earlier. Clause 13 provides
that:
"And in the event even one of the cheque is dishonoured the
same will be treated as breach these Consent Terms."
21. Thus, the parties have decided what would happen if even
one cheque is dishonoured. The Petitioner is not asking this Court
to introduce any new consequence which was not agreed between
the parties. The consequence of dishonour is written in the
Consent Terms.
22. It is not disputed that Respondent No.1 issued both cheques.
It is not disputed, at least at this stage, that both cheques were
returned unpaid with the endorsement "Funds Insufficient". The
Respondents have not denied that the cheques were dishonoured.
Their defence is that the cheques could not have been deposited
because the conditions mentioned in Clause 13 were not fulfilled.
So far as the cheque of Rs.51 Lakhs is concerned, the Respondents
rely upon the Petitioner's letters dated 11 September 2025 and 20
October 2025. According to them, these letters show that the
project had not been removed from abeyance by MahaRERA and
that the necessary permissions had not been obtained. Therefore,
they submit that the Petitioner was not entitled to deposit this
15
Uploaded on - 21/11/2026 Downloaded on - 21/11/2026 12:35:48

cpcdl30395-2026-J.doc
cheque.
23. I find that this submission raises a question which will have
to be examined. The condition regarding permission from MHADA
and removal of the project from abeyance by MahaRERA cannot be
ignored. However, it is a fact that Respondent No.1 had issued this
cheque as part of the settlement. It had agreed that dishonour of
even one cheque would amount to breach of the Consent Terms.
Whether the conditions for depositing the cheque were fulfilled,
whether the Petitioner was entitled to deposit it and whether any
failure by the other parties prevented Respondent No.1 from
carrying out its obligation are matters which the Respondents can
explain after notice is issued.
24. The position regarding the cheque of Rs.77 Lakhs needs to
be considered. This cheque was issued towards outstanding transit
rent payable to the members of the Petitioner Society. Clause 13
provides that the amount was payable at or before handing over
possession of the rehabilitation flats or within 180 days from filing
of the Consent Terms, whichever was earlier. The Consent Terms
were filed on 17 October 2024. Therefore, if possession had not
been handed over earlier, the period of 180 days came to an end in
April 2025. The Respondents have not shown that the outstanding
amount of Rs.77 Lakhs was paid within the period mentioned in
Clause 13. Instead, the cheque issued towards this amount was
returned unpaid because of insufficient funds. The fact that the
cheque was presented in December 2025, after the period of 180
days had ended, does not answer the Petitioner's allegation that
the amount had remained unpaid even after the agreed date. The
16
Uploaded on - 21/11/2026 Downloaded on - 21/11/2026 12:35:48

cpcdl30395-2026-J.doc
Respondents will have to explain why the amount was not paid
within the agreed period and why the cheque issued towards that
amount was not honoured.
25. The Respondents rely upon Clause 26. They submit that the
outstanding transit rent is a disputed claim and must be decided in
arbitration. I am unable to accept that this submission is enough to
reject the allegation of contempt at this stage. The Petitioner is not
relying only upon an independent claim for recovery of transit
rent. It is relying upon the undertaking recorded in Clause 13 and
the agreement that dishonour of even one cheque would amount
to breach of the Consent Terms. The existence of an arbitration
clause does not take away the power of this Court to examine an
alleged breach of an undertaking given to it.
26. The Respondents submit that Clause 39 gives a remedy to
the Petitioner Society if the cheques are dishonoured. This includes
the right to deal with the three unregistered flats. According to the
Respondents, once such a remedy is provided, the Petitioner
cannot start contempt proceedings. This submission cannot be
accepted at this preliminary stage. Clause 39 provides a
consequence under the Consent Terms if the cheques are
dishonoured. It does not say that the undertaking recorded in
Clause 13 will come to an end or that this Court will have no
power to examine its breach. On the contrary, Clause 46 keeps
open the right to start contempt proceedings in case of default,
subject to the parties fulfilling their respective obligations.
17
Uploaded on - 21/11/2026 Downloaded on - 21/11/2026 12:35:48

cpcdl30395-2026-J.doc
27. I am aware that every breach of a consent term does not
amount to contempt. The Court must be satisfied that there is an
undertaking given to it and that there appears to be a wilful breach
of that undertaking. In the present case, Clause 4 records that the
obligations of the parties are undertakings given to this Court.
Clause 13 provides for the two cheques and says that dishonour of
even one cheque would be treated as breach of the Consent Terms.
The cheques were issued by Respondent No.1 and were returned
unpaid because of insufficient funds. When all these facts are
considered together, there is sufficient material to ask the
Respondents to explain their conduct. At this stage, it would not be
proper to finally decide whether the conditions for depositing the
cheque of Rs.51 Lakhs were fulfilled or whether the Respondents
have any valid explanation for not paying the amount of Rs.77
Lakhs. These matters can be considered after the Respondents file
their affidavits. However, the condition regarding dishonour of
even one cheque, together with the fact that both cheques were
returned unpaid for insufficient funds, is enough to issue notice. I
am satisfied that the Petitioner has made out a prima facie case of
breach of the undertaking recorded in Clause 13 of the Consent
Terms. The Respondents must be called upon to explain why this
breach should not be treated as wilful disobedience of an
undertaking given to this Court.
Whether there is a prima facie breach of the construction and
cooperation obligations:
28. Another allegation of the Petitioner is that Respondent No.1
did not cooperate in obtaining the necessary permissions and did
18
Uploaded on - 21/11/2026 Downloaded on - 21/11/2026 12:35:48

cpcdl30395-2026-J.doc
not take proper steps to start and complete the remaining
construction work.
29. Clause 7 requires the parties to approach MHADA and
MahaRERA for obtaining the necessary permissions. It requires
Respondent No.1, with the cooperation of the Society and
Respondent No.2, to take steps for completing the project. Clause
15 requires all parties to cooperate with each other for obtaining
the necessary permissions from MHADA, MCGM and MahaRERA.
Clause 46 provides that the parties should not create any
obstruction or difficulty and should cooperate with each other for
completing the remaining work. These clauses relate to the actual
progress of the redevelopment project. They do not deal only with
payment of money. They require all parties to cooperate with each
other so that the remaining construction work can be completed.
30. The Petitioner has placed on record its letter dated 11
September 2025. In that letter, the Society stated that about eleven
months had passed after filing of the Consent Terms. However,
MahaRERA had still not removed the project from abeyance. The
Society stated that a major part of the remaining work had been
completed by using the amounts provided by the New Buyers'
Association. However, substantial work was still left to be done.
The Society gave details of the work and expenses which were still
pending. These included fire NOC, lifts, property tax, painting,
paver blocks, entrance gates and other work. The Society
requested Respondent No.1 to provide the money required for
completing this work. Thereafter, the Society sent another letter
dated 20 October 2025. By this letter, it again requested
19
Uploaded on - 21/11/2026 Downloaded on - 21/11/2026 12:35:48

cpcdl30395-2026-J.doc
Respondent No.1 to take steps for removing the project from
abeyance and arrange the money required for completing the
remaining work.
31. Respondent No.1 replied to the Society on 7 November
2025. In its reply, it stated that the Society had not given details of
the construction work, actual expenses incurred, amounts
deposited by the flat purchasers and statements of the Project Bank
Account. Respondent No.1 asked for inspection of the bank
statements, bills and receipts. According to Respondent No.1,
without these details, it was not possible to know whether money
was required and whether the amounts provided had been used.
32. This defence raised by the Respondents cannot be ignored.
Clauses 8 and 11 of the Consent Terms require the Project Bank
Account to be operated in the agreed manner. They require the
construction bills to be checked and certified by Respondent No.1
before payment is made. The Respondents point out that the
Society and the Association have received Rs.2.20 Crores, Rs.91.53
Lakhs and other amounts from the flat purchasers. According to
them, the Society has not explained how these amounts have been
spent. The Petitioner submits that these amounts have been used
for carrying out the remaining work and that Respondent No.1 has
failed to provide money. At this stage, it is difficult to decide which
side is correct regarding the accounts. The actual expenditure, the
amount still available in the account, the bills submitted for
checking and the date on which Respondent No.1 was required to
provide money are matters which need to be explained. However,
there is another aspect which needs to be considered. Respondent
20
Uploaded on - 21/11/2026 Downloaded on - 21/11/2026 12:35:48

cpcdl30395-2026-J.doc
No.1 has raised objections regarding the accounts. But its reply
dated 7 November 2025 does not show what steps it had actually
taken with MHADA and MahaRERA during the earlier period for
obtaining the necessary permissions. It does not fully answer the
Petitioner's allegation that Respondent No.1 had not made proper
efforts to take the redevelopment work forward.
33. The Respondents may have proper reasons for their conduct.
They may show that the Society or Respondent No.2 failed to
perform their obligations and that the delay took place for reasons
which were not within their control. These matters will have to be
considered after they file their affidavits. However, the letter dated
11 September 2025, the reminder dated 20 October 2025 and the
reply dated 7 November 2025 show that there is a serious dispute
between the parties regarding cooperation in obtaining
permissions and completing the remaining work. At this stage, the
question is only whether the Respondents should be asked to
explain their conduct. In my view, the correspondence between the
parties and the undertakings recorded in Clauses 7, 15 and 46
provide sufficient material to issue notice on this allegation.
Effect of termination and other remedies:
34. The Respondents submit that the Society has terminated the
Development Agreement and revoked the Power of Attorney under
Clause 38. According to them, after taking this step under the
contract, the Society cannot again ask for contempt proceedings on
the basis of the same default.
21
Uploaded on - 21/11/2026 Downloaded on - 21/11/2026 12:35:48

cpcdl30395-2026-J.doc
35. I am unable to accept this submission as an absolute rule.
Clause 46 keeps open the right of the Society and Respondent No.2
to start execution and contempt proceedings in case of default.
Therefore, only because the Society has issued a termination
notice, it cannot be said that this Court has lost its power to
examine whether contempt has been committed. At the same time,
the termination notice dated 9 January 2026 has to be considered
in the light of the Consent Terms. Under Clause 38, termination is
required to be carried out in the manner stated in that clause. The
Respondents submit that they have accepted the termination and
have not challenged it. Whether the Society can now deal with the
three unregistered flats, whether the termination affects the rights
of the flat purchasers and whether the Respondents still have any
rights in the project are matters which cannot be decided in these
preliminary contempt proceedings.
36. The Respondents rely upon Clause 26. This clause provides
that disputes relating to the Development Agreement,
Supplementary Agreement and other claims in law would be
referred to arbitration. I agree that disputed claims regarding
transit rent, accounts, additional construction expenses and
amounts payable by the respective parties will have to be decided
through the proper contractual or arbitral proceedings. However,
only because there is an arbitration clause, it does not mean that
this Court cannot examine an alleged breach of an undertaking
given to it. There is a difference between deciding a disputed claim
for money and examining whether a party has deliberately failed
to follow an express undertaking given to the Court. Therefore, the
22
Uploaded on - 21/11/2026 Downloaded on - 21/11/2026 12:35:48

cpcdl30395-2026-J.doc
contempt notice in the present case will cover the alleged failure to
cooperate in obtaining the necessary permissions and completing
the remaining work. It will cover the alleged breach relating to
dishonour of the two cheques.
Limitation under Section 20 of the Contempt of Courts Act:
37. The question of limitation needs to be considered. Section 20
of the Contempt of Courts Act provides that no Court can start
contempt proceedings after one year from the date on which the
alleged contempt was committed. In Pallav Sheth v. Custodian,
(2001) 7 SCC 549, the Supreme Court held that where a contempt
petition is filed by a party, the date on which the application is
filed is important for deciding whether the contempt proceedings
have been started within time. The Supreme Court in S. Tirupathi
Rao v. M. Lingamaiah, 2024 INSC 544, held that every continuing
effect of an earlier breach cannot be treated as continuing
contempt. There must be an obligation which continues and there
must be a continuing failure to follow that obligation. An act
which was completed earlier does not become a continuing wrong
only because its effect continues.
38. In the present case, the parties were required to approach
the authorities within seven days and make efforts to obtain
permissions within thirty days after the Consent Terms were filed
in October 2024. These steps were required to be taken within
fixed periods. If the allegation is only that these steps were not
taken within those particular periods, such failure cannot be
treated as a fresh breach on every following day only because the
23
Uploaded on - 21/11/2026 Downloaded on - 21/11/2026 12:35:48

cpcdl30395-2026-J.doc
permissions continued to remain pending. Similarly, the period of
six months for completing the remaining work under Clause 7
depends upon the date on which MHADA revoked the stop-work
notice. The Petitioner has not shown that date from the material
presently placed before this Court. Therefore, at this stage, notice
is not being issued on the specific allegation that the six-month
period for completing the work has expired. However, the
Petitioner has alleged that the Respondents continued to fail to
cooperate and take effective steps for the project during September
2025, October 2025 and thereafter. Clause 46 contains an
obligation which continues. It requires the parties not to obstruct
or create difficulties in completing the remaining work and to
cooperate with each other.
39. The letters dated 11 September 2025 and 20 October 2025,
the reply dated 7 November 2025 and the termination notice
dated 9 January 2026 are relevant for examining this allegation of
continuing non-cooperation. These events have taken place within
one year before the filing of the present contempt petition in 2026.
Therefore, the allegation regarding continuing failure to cooperate
requires an explanation from the Respondents. However, the notice
will not cover the separate failure to meet the original seven-day
or thirty-day deadlines in October and November 2024. It will not
cover the six-month completion period unless the date on which
MHADA revoked the stop-work notice is established.
Whether notice can be issued against the Directors:
40. Respondent Nos.2 and 3 are the Directors of Respondent
24
Uploaded on - 21/11/2026 Downloaded on - 21/11/2026 12:35:48

cpcdl30395-2026-J.doc
No.1. They have signed the Consent Terms on behalf of
Respondent No.1. Clause 38 records that the undertaking under
that clause is given by Respondent No.1 and its Directors to this
Court. Clause 46 refers to the right of the Petitioner to start
contempt proceedings against Respondent No.1 and its Directors.
Therefore, at this preliminary stage, there is sufficient material to
call upon Respondent Nos.2 and 3 to explain what role they had in
the alleged failure to follow the continuing obligations recorded in
the Consent Terms. However, this does not mean that every
Director of a company becomes guilty of contempt only because
the company has committed some default. The responsibility of
each Director will have to be considered separately under Section
12(4) and Section 12(5) of the Contempt of Courts Act and on the
basis of the material placed before this Court. At this stage, I am
not recording any final finding about the personal responsibility of
Respondent Nos.2 and 3.
Conclusion:
41. After considering the entire material placed before this
Court, I find that the Consent Terms dated 10 October 2024
contain clear undertakings given to this Court. By order dated 17
October 2024, the original Petition filed under Section 9 of the
Arbitration and Conciliation Act was disposed of in terms of those
Consent Terms.
42. The submission of the Respondents that contempt
proceedings cannot be started because the parties have provided
other contractual remedies cannot be accepted. Clause 46 keeps
25
Uploaded on - 21/11/2026 Downloaded on - 21/11/2026 12:35:48

cpcdl30395-2026-J.doc
open the right to start execution proceedings and contempt
proceedings in case of default.
43. I am unable to accept the submission of the Respondents that
dishonour of the two cheques is only a contractual dispute which
must necessarily be referred to arbitration. Clause 13 provides that
dishonour of even one cheque would be treated as breach of the
Consent Terms. The parties had agreed to this condition while
settling the pending proceedings before this Court. Both cheques
issued by Respondent No.1 have been returned unpaid because of
insufficient funds. This fact, when read with the clear words used
in Clause 13, is sufficient to make out a prima facie case and call
upon the Respondents to explain their conduct. The defence that
the conditions for depositing the cheque of Rs.51 Lakhs were not
fulfilled requires consideration. Similarly, the Respondents will
have to explain why the amount of Rs.77 Lakhs was not paid
within the period mentioned in Clause 13. However, these
defences cannot be treated as finally proved at this preliminary
stage. The Respondents will have to place the facts on which they
rely before this Court. It would not be proper to reject the
contempt petition without first asking them to explain why the
cheques were dishonoured. The fact that Clause 39 gives a right to
deal with the three unregistered flats and Clause 26 provides for
arbitration does not take away the power of this Court to examine
an alleged breach of an undertaking given to it. The parties have
kept open the right to start contempt proceedings under Clause 46.
Therefore, the contractual remedies and the power of this Court to
examine contempt can operate in their respective areas. I am
26
Uploaded on - 21/11/2026 Downloaded on - 21/11/2026 12:35:48

cpcdl30395-2026-J.doc
satisfied that dishonour of the two cheques, particularly the failure
to honour the cheque of Rs.77 Lakhs towards outstanding transit
rent within the agreed period, together with the express condition
in Clause 13, makes out a prima facie case for issuing contempt
notice. The allegations regarding failure to cooperate in obtaining
statutory permissions and taking forward the remaining
construction work require an explanation. Clauses 7, 15 and 46
contain obligations regarding cooperation and completion of the
redevelopment project. The letters exchanged between the parties
during September to November 2025 show that there were serious
differences regarding performance of these obligations. The
Respondents have raised questions regarding the Project Bank
Account, expenditure and the obligations of the Society and
Respondent No.2. These matters will have to be examined after the
affidavits are filed.
44. Considering the clear undertakings recorded in the Consent
Terms, dishonour of the cheques and the allegations regarding
continuing failure to cooperate in completing the project, I am
satisfied that a prima facie case is made out for issuing notice
under Rule 1035(1), read with Rule 1036 of the Bombay High
Court (Original Side) Rules, 1980. The notice will cover the
alleged breach of Clause 13 and the alleged continuing breach of
Clauses 7, 15 and 46, read with Clause 4 of the Consent Terms.
45. In view of the foregoing discussion, and upon overall
assessment of the material record, the following order is passed:
27
Uploaded on - 21/11/2026 Downloaded on - 21/11/2026 12:35:48

cpcdl30395-2026-J.doc
(i) Show-cause notice under Rule 1035(1), read with Rule
1036 of the Bombay High Court (Original Side) Rules, 1980,
shall be issued to Respondent Nos.1, 2 and 3. They shall
show cause why proceedings for civil contempt under
Section 12 read with Section 2(b) of the Contempt of Courts
Act, 1971 should not be initiated against them for the
alleged wilful breach of the undertakings recorded in Clauses
7, 13, 15 and 46, read with Clause 4 of the Consent Terms
dated 10 October 2024;
(ii) The notice shall include the allegation regarding
dishonour of Cheque No.000955 for Rs.51 Lakhs and Cheque
No.000956 for Rs.77 Lakhs. Both cheques were returned
unpaid because of insufficient funds. The Respondents shall
explain how the cheques came to be dishonoured, whether
the conditions for depositing the cheques were fulfilled and
why the amount of Rs.77 Lakhs was not paid within the
period mentioned in Clause 13;
(iii) The notice shall include the allegation that the
Respondents failed to cooperate in obtaining the necessary
permissions and in taking forward the remaining
redevelopment work, as required under Clauses 7, 15 and 46
of the Consent Terms;
(iv) The Petitioner has already served the complete
contempt petition, along with all annexures and affidavits,
upon the Respondents in accordance with Rule 1036 of the
Original Side Rules;
28
Uploaded on - 21/11/2026 Downloaded on - 21/11/2026 12:35:48

cpcdl30395-2026-J.doc
(v) Respondent Nos.1 to 3 shall file their affidavits in reply
within fourteen days from today, as provided under Rule
1037 of the Original Side Rules. A copy of the reply shall be
served upon the learned Advocate for the Petitioner at least
forty-eight hours before the next date of hearing. In the
event the Respondents fail to file their reply within the time
granted above, their right to file the reply shall stand
forfeited;
(vi) Respondent Nos.2 and 3 shall remain personally
present before this Court on the returnable date, unless their
personal appearance is dispensed with by an order of this
Court.
46. List the petition on 16 December 2026.
(AMIT BORKAR, J.)
29
Uploaded on - 21/11/2026 Downloaded on - 21/11/2026 12:35:48
Powered by TCPDF (www.tcpdf.org)