DAKSHINI APARTMENT OWNERS ASSOCIATION & ANR vs KOLKATA METROPOLITAN DEV AUTHORITY & ORS

Court
Calcutta High Court

1

IN THE HIGH COURT AT CALCUTTA
(CONSTITUTIONAL WRIT JURISDICTION)
APPELLATE SIDE
Present:
The Hon’ble Justice Partha Sarathi Sen


WPA 14463 of 2015

Dakshini Apartment Owners Association & Anr.
-Versus-
Kolkata Metropolitan Development Authority & Ors.

:
For the Petitioners Mr. Subhabrata Datta
Mr. Debasish Sarkar
Mr. Jatindra Barik.

For the Respondent : Mr. Anindya Lahiri, Sr. Adv.
No. 4. : Mr. Anish Chakraborty.

For the KMDA : Mr. Debanik Banerjee,


Heard on : 17.11.2026
Judgment on : 17.11.2026
Partha Sarathi Sen, J.:-

1. The subject matter of the instant writ petition is the possession
certificate dated 06.04.2015 as issued by the Executive Engineer of the
KMDA Authority, whereby and whereunder an open car parking space
no. 23 in Dakshini Phase-I Housing Complex (“the said Housing

2

Complex” in short) at Plot No. 87/1, Block-D, Baishnabghata Patuli
Township, was delivered to the private respondent no. 4.
2. At the time of hearing, Mr. Dutta, learned advocate appearing on behalf
of the writ petitioner, in course of his argument, at the very outset,
draws attention of this Court to page nos. 13 to 41 of the affidavit-in-
opposition as used by the KMDA, being a copy of the brochure as
published by the KMDA Authority in respect of the said Housing
Complex.
3. Drawing attention to various clauses of the said brochure, it has been
submitted by Mr. Dutta that as per the said brochure, the KMDA
Authority decided to sell out 90 numbers of residential apartments in
one G+10 tower and another 8 apartments in one G+4 tower with lift
facility, along with 28 numbers of covered car parking spaces and 18
numbers of open car parking spaces in the said housing complex.
4. Drawing attention to page no. 21 of the affidavit-in-reply dated
25.07.2025 as filed by the writ petitioner, it is further argued by Mr.
Dutta that by issuing a memo dated 09.04.2009, the KMDA Authority
indicated that before parting with individual possession of the
apartments, the building with common services and common areas in
the said housing complex would be handed over to the designated
person of the Co-operative Housing Society or Apartment Owners'
Association thereof. Attention of this Court is also drawn to page no. 25
of the supplementary affidavit dated 16.09.2016, being a copy of the

3

possession certificate dated 02.06.2009. It is submitted by Mr. Dutta
that on careful perusal of the said possession certificate dated
02.06.2009, it would reveal that in terms of the promise made by the
KMDA Authority, the possession of the common areas and common
services of the said Housing Complex was handed over to the Chairman
or the Secretary of the writ petitioner No.1 Co-operative Society. It is
further submitted by Mr. Dutta that along with the said possession
certificate dated 02.06.2009, a sketch map was also annexed,
wherefrom it would reveal that KMDA has subsequently decided to keep
22 numbers of open car parking spaces in the said housing complex.
5. At this juncture, Mr. Dutta took me to page no. 33 of the
supplementary affidavit dated 18.09.2016, being a copy of another
sketch map dated 22.04.2015, as prepared by the KMDA Authority in
respect of the said housing complex. It is argued by Mr. Dutta that on
comparative study of the sketch map dated 02.06.2009, as has been
annexed with the aforementioned possession certificate dated
02.06.2009, and the subsequent sketch map dated 22.04.2015, it would
reveal that the KMDA Authority most unilaterally indicated a space for
proposed car parking space no. 23, which is the subject matter of the
instant writ petition.
6. It is argued by Mr. Dutta, learned advocate for the writ petitioner Co-
operative Society, that after handing over the possession of common
services and common areas of the said housing complex, the KMDA

4

Authority has got no right and/or jurisdiction to create another open car
parking space in a place which is earmarked as common area, since
such demarcation of an open car parking space no. 23 in common area
will diminish the extent of the common area affecting the proportionate
right, title, and interest of the members of the Co-operative Society in
the said housing complex, and the said action of the KMDA Authority
tantamount to hamper the amenities attached with common services
and common area as enjoyed by the members of the writ petitioner Co-
operative Society.
7. Drawing attention to page numbers 34, 35, and onwards of the
aforementioned supplementary affidavit dated 16.9.2026, it is further
argued by Mr. Dutta that under cover of a forwarding letter dated
19.5.2011 / 6.6.2011, a model draft Deed of Conveyance was forwarded
to the Secretary of the writ petitioner society, and on perusal of the
recital clause of the said model Deed of Conveyance, it would reveal that
the said recitals are in consonance with the criteria as mentioned in the
brochure as published by the KMDA, over which the independent
allottees, who are the members of the writ petitioner No.1 cooperative
society made an applications for allotment, to which the respondent
KMDA authority agreed and that is why the said letter dated 10.5.2010
was issued forwarding therewith the said model Deed of Conveyance.
8. It is further argued by Mr. Dutta that with the execution of the Deed of
Conveyances in favour of the allottees of the different apartment owners,

5

who are the members of the writ petitioner No.1 cooperative society, the
allottees of the apartment, as well as the cooperative society as made by
them, got their proportionate right, title, and interest over the common
areas and common facilities of the said housing complex, which cannot
be put to prejudice by the KMDA authority by issuing the impugned
possession certificate, thereby allotting open car parking space number
23 in favour of the private respondent number 4.
9. Drawing attention to paragraph number 4 of the affidavit-in-opposition
dated 27.11.2015, as filed by the respondent numbers 1, 2, and 3, that
is, the KMDA and its instrumentalities, it is further argued by Mr. Dutta
that in its affidavit-in-opposition, the KMDA had taken a stand that it
has the sole authority to take decisions regarding such allotment, in
which the housing society cannot indulge in.
10. Mr. Dutta contended that such a stand of the KMDA authority has got
no legal basis, inasmuch as after handing over the possession of the
common areas and common facilities to the writ petitioner society in the
said housing complex, the KMDA authority is debarred from taking any
decision with regard to the common areas and common facilities, since
such common areas and common facilities, according to Mr. Dutta,
come under the purview of the amenities attached thereto as enjoyed by
the individual members of the cooperative society, who are the owners of
the various apartments in the said housing complex.

6

11. In course of his argument, Mr. Dutta also took me to page numbers 57
and 58 of the instant writ petition. It is argued that on conjoint perusal
of the said two pages, it would reveal that on an earlier occasion, that is,
in the year 2012, the KMDA authority did not entertain a similar
application of one Anup Kanti Dey on the ground that in the said
housing complex no other car parking space is available. It is argued by
Mr. Dutta that in the event the KMDA has taken a stand in the year
2012 that in the said housing complex no car parking space is available,
the self-same KMDA authority cannot take a contrary stand while
issuing impugned possession certificate in respect of car parking space
number 23 in favour of the private respondent number 4. It is thus
argued by Mr. Dutta that the KMDA authority, being an authority within
the meaning of Article 12 of the Constitution, is duty-bound to act in
terms of the Constitution of India, and the Act and Rules governing the
functioning of the said Authority and therefore, in terms of the
constitutional provision, the subsequent allotment of the open car
parking space number 23 in favour of the private respondent number 4
tantamount to violation of Article 14 of the Constitution of India.
12. In his next fold of submission, Mr. Dutta took me to Section 2, Section
3(d) and Section 5 of the West Bengal Apartment Ownership Act, 1972
(the said Act of 1972 in short). It is submitted by Mr. Dutta that since
the said housing complex consists of various residential units, the said
Act of 1972 is very much applicable in the facts and circumstances of

7

the present case, and therefore, the definition of common areas and
facilities as embodied in Section 3(d) of the said Act of 1972 shall have
due application in the instant writ petition.
13. It is further submitted by Mr. Dutta that on perusal of Section 2(d) and
Section 5 of the said Act of 1972, it would reveal that it is the legislative
mandate that every apartment owner shall be entitled to an undivided
interest in the common areas and facilities in the percentage expressed
in the declaration. It is submitted by Mr. Dutta that in view of such legal
provision, there cannot be any hesitation to hold that in respect of the
common areas and facilities of the said housing complex, which was
handed over to the writ petitioner No.1 society by executing a certificate
of possession dated 2.6.2009, the members of the said cooperative
society, who are the owners of the apartments in the said society, got
their undivided interest in common areas and facilities, and such
common interest has been hampered by the action of the KMDA, which
is under challenge in the instant writ petition.
14. To substantiate his contention, Mr. Dutta places his reliance upon a
judgment dated 31.08.2010 as passed by the Hon'ble Supreme Court in
connection with Civil Appeal No. 2544 of 2010 ( Nahalchand Laloochand
Private Limited versus Panchali Co-operative Housing Society Limited ). It
is submitted by Mr. Dutta that in the case of Nahalchand (supra), the
Hon'ble Supreme Court, while dealing with a similar situation, came to
a finding that a stilt parking space comes under the purview of common

8

areas and facilities of a housing complex to which each flat purchaser,
in proportion to the carpet area of the flat, has proportionate right, title
and interest.
15. To substantiate that the said Act of 1972 has got equal manner of
application in the instant lis, Mr. Dutta also places his reliance upon
the judgment of a Coordinate Bench of this Court in the case of Basana
Dutta and Others versus State of West Bengal and Others , reported
in 2004 SCC OnLine Cal 856 : (2005) 109 CWN 1056.
16. It is thus argued by Mr. Dutta that it is a fit case for quashing of the
allotment of open car parking space no. 23 in favour of the private
respondent no. 4 in the said housing complex, and thus appropriate
relief/reliefs may be granted to the writ petitioner in terms of the
prayers made in the instant writ petition.
17. Per contra, Mr. Banerjee, learned advocate appearing on behalf of the
respondent nos. 1 to 3 / KMDA and its instrumentalities, also draws
attention of this Court to the copy of the brochure as has been annexed
with the affidavit-in-opposition as filed by the KMDA.
18. It is argued by Mr. Banerjee that on careful perusal of the
aforementioned various clauses of the brochure as published by the
KMDA authority, it would reveal that the KMDA authority categorically
indicated in the said brochure that the said authority reserves its right
to allot all or any of the apartments, including surplus apartments, by
any mode as would be considered necessary by the KMDA in exigency of

9

the circumstances, and in that regard, the decision of the KMDA
authority is final.
19. Mr. Banerjee further contended that in the said brochure (page number
25 of the affidavit-in-opposition), it was also indicated that the terms
and conditions for documentation and transfer of apartments are
subject to changes as would be decided by the KMDA from time to time.
Drawing attention to page number 41 of the affidavit-in-opposition of
the KMDA, being a copy of the proceedings of lottery dated 24.02.2012,
it is argued by Mr. Banerjee that in the year 2012, the KMDA held a
lottery for allotment of open garage number 22 and covered garage
number 26, which were also allotted to the apartment owners who are
also the members of the cooperative society, to which the writ petitioner
never raised any objection. It is argued by Mr. Banerjee that the
respondent KMDA authority had taken a consistent stand while allotting
the open garage space number 23 in favour of the private respondent
number 4, as has been taken while allotting open garage number 22
and covered garage number 26, and thus, by no stretch of imagination
can it be said that the respondent KMDA authority had acted in a
partial manner, and thus the instant writ petition is liable to be
dismissed.
20. Mr. Lahiri, learned Senior Advocate appearing on behalf of the private
respondent, in course of his submission at the very outset, challenges
the maintainability of the instant writ petition. It is strongly argued by

10

Mr. Lahiri that on careful perusal of the entire materials as placed
before this Court, more specifically the annexures to the affidavit-in-
opposition as have been used by the private respondent number 4, it
would reveal that the subject matter of the instant lis is basically an
inter-se dispute between the private respondent number 4 and the other
members of the cooperative society, which comes within the periphery of
the definition of "dispute" within the meaning of Section 4(25) of the
West Bengal Cooperative Societies Act, 2006 (“the said Act of 2006” in
short), and the said dispute is to be filed before the Registrar under
Section 102 of the said Act of 2006.
21. It is further argued by Mr. Lahiri that the instant writ petition is equally
not maintainable on the ground that on account of the allotment of open
car parking space number 23 in favour of the private respondent number
4, the writ petitioner number 1 cooperative society has not suffered any
legal injury and/or no legal right of the writ petitioner number 1
cooperative society was infringed, and on this ground also, the instant writ
petition is not maintainable. To substantiate his contention, Mr. Lahiri
places his reliance upon the judgment of the Hon'ble Supreme Court in
the case of Mani Subrat Jain and Ors. vs. State of Haryana and Ors. ,
reported in (1977) 1 SCC 486 .
22. It is further argued by Mr. Lahiri that the inter-se dispute between the
private respondent No. 4 and the other members of the Co-operative
society has become very prominent inasmuch as from the materials placed

11

before this Court, it would reveal that the writ petitioner number 1/Co-
operative Society; more specifically some of its members are interested to
challenge the allotment of the car parking space No. 23 in favour of the
private respondent No. 4 only, however, they made no endeavour to
challenge the allotment of open car parking space Nos. 19 to 22, though in
the brochure of the KMDA authority, there was clear indication that only
18 members of open car parking space would be allotted. It is further
submitted by Mr. Lahiri that for the best reason best known to the writ
petitioners, they have made no prayer for setting aside of the said
allotment of the open car parking space from 19 to 22 with some oblique
motive. Drawing attention to page Nos. 29 to 39 of the affidavit-in-
opposition as filed by the private respondent, it is further argued by Mr.
Lahiri that malice against the private respondent No. 4 of some of the
members of the writ petitioner No. 1/Co-operative society is very much
prominent inasmuch as the writ petitioner No.1/society for the reason
best known to it made an endeavour to interfere with the allotment of the
open car parking space No. 23 by the KMDA authority. It is further
submitted by Mr. Lahiri that the said Act of 1972 has got no manner of
application inasmuch as no material is forthcoming before this Court that
the writ petitioner No.1/Co-operative society has complied with the
provision of Section 10 of the said Act of 1972 by submitting declaration
before the appropriate authority in the manner prescribed therein. Mr.

12

Lahiri thus submits that this is a fit case for dismissal of the instant writ
petition.
23. This Court has meticulously perused the entire materials as placed before
this Court. This Court has given its due consideration over the
submissions of the learned advocates for the contending parties.
24. Since in course of his argument, Mr. Lahiri has raised the point of
maintainability of the instant writ petition, this Court proposes to deal
with the said point of maintainability at the very first instance. In doing
so, this Court proposes to look to Section 17 of the said Act of 2006, which
reads as under :
“17. Co-operative society to be body corporate.-(1) The registration
of a co-operative society shall render it a body corporate by the
name under which it is registered, having a perpetual succession
and a common seal and the co-operative society shall be entitled
to acquire, hold and dispose of property, to enter into contracts on
its behalf, to institute and defend suits and other legal
proceedings, and to do all other things necessary to achieve its
objectives.

(2) All transactions entered into in good faith prior to registration of
the purposes of the co-operative, shall be deemed to be
transactions of the co-operative society after registration.”

25. On careful perusal of the provision of Section 17 of the said Act of 2006, it
appears to this Court that it is the legislative mandate that the registration
of a co-operative society shall render it a body corporate by the name

13

under which it was registered, having a perpetual succession and a
common seal and it can sue or be sued to achieve its objectives.
26. Keeping in mind the aforementioned provision of law if I look to the cause-
title of the instant writ petition, it appears to this Court that the writ
petitioner No. 1/Co-operative society described itself as a registered
association and therefore there cannot be any difficulty to hold that it is a
body corporate having a perpetual succession and a common seal. Such
being the position, this Court is constrained to hold that the writ
petitioner No.1/society, being a body corporate represents its members
and in the event common right, title and interest of its members in respect
of the said housing complex is hampered at the instance of any third party
and/or at the instance of any of its individual member, the writ petitioner
No.1/society being a body corporate having perpetual succession and a
common seal can very well ventilate its grievance by filing a suit and/or by
defending a suit or any other legal proceeding. It thus appears to this
Court that the reported decision in the case of Mani Subrat(supra) as
cited on behalf of the private respondent No.4 is actually helpful for the
writ petitioner in as much as it is specific case of the writ petitioner No.1
society that by the alleged action of the respondent/ KMDA authority, the
right of its members is going to be hampered.
27. On careful perusal of the entire pleadings of the writ petition, it appears to
this Court that it is the primary grievance of the writ petitioner No.
1/society that though it was in the charge of maintenance of the common

14

areas and common facilities of the said housing complex after its handing
over in the year 2009, the respondent/KMDA authority made an
endeavour to interfere with the common right, title and interest as well as
amenities attached thereto as enjoyed by its members, who are the owners
of the apartment of the said housing complex and accordingly, the writ
petitioner No. 1/society approached this Court by filing the instant writ
petition. It thus appears to this Court that from the periphery of the
instant writ petition, it does not transpire to this Court that the instant lis
arose out of an inter se dispute between the members of the Co-operative
society, rather the writ petitioner No. 1/Co-operative society being a body
corporate having perpetual succession and having authority to institute a
suit or other legal proceeding under Section 17 of the Act of 2006, has
filed the instant writ petition challenging the action of the KMDA authority
in this writ petition. In view of the discussion made hereinabove this Court
is constrained to hold that the instant writ petition is very much
maintainable.
28. At this juncture, the moot question arose for consideration is as to
whether by issuing the impugned possession certificate dated 06.04.2015
in favour of the private respondent No. 4 thereby allotment of car parking
space No. 23 in the said housing complex, the respondent/KMDA
authority has exceeded its limit and/or has done an act in contravention
of the law.

15

29. At this juncture, if I look to the copy of the brochure as has been annexed
with the affidavit-in-opposition of the KMDA authority, it reveals that
initially the KMDA authority decided to dispose of certain numbers of
apartments including 28 numbers of covered car parking spaces and 18
numbers of open car parking spaces.
30. On careful perusal of page No. 21 of the affidavit-in-reply as filed by the
writ petitioner on 25.07.2025 against the affidavit-in-opposition of the
private respondent No. 4, it appears that by issuing a memo dated
09.04.2009, it was decided by the KMDA authority that before parting
with the individual possession of the respective apartment in the said
housing complex, the building with all common services and common
areas would be handed over to the designated person of the said co-
operative society. Pursuant to such decision, the respondent / KMDA
authority by issuing a possession certificate dated 02.06.2009 as has been
annexed at page No. 23 of the supplementary affidavit of the writ
petitioner has handed over the common services and common areas of the
building at the said housing complex. Along with the said possession
certificate, a sketch map dated 02.06.2009 bearing the signature of the
Executive Engineer of the KMDA authority was also annexed, wherefrom
undisputedly existence of additional 4 car parking spaces were there. As
rightly pointed out by Mr. Lahiri that the writ petitioner no.1/society did
not object to such allotment of additional 4 open car parking spaces while

16

obtaining the possession of the common services and common areas of
said housing complex or soon thereafter for the reason best known to it.
31. It is undisputed that soon thereafter the apartments of the said housing
complex were subsequently registered in favour of the apartment owners
of the said housing complex. In course of his argument, Mr. Datta also
draws attention of this Court to the model deed of conveyance as has been
forwarded by the KMDA authority in favour of the writ petitioner No.
1/society.
32. On conjoint perusal of the said possession certificate dated 02.06.2009,
the recital of the model deed of conveyance as has been executed by the
KMDA authority to the different members of the writ petitioner
No.1/society vis-à-vis the brochure as published by the KMDA authority,
a copy of which has been annexed to the affidavit-in-opposition of the
KMDA authority, there cannot be any doubt to hold that the common
services and common areas of the said housing complex forms part and
parcel of the amenities attached to the said housing complex, which is
being enjoyed by the members of the writ petitioner No. 1/society in
common and in the event any hindrance is caused to such common
services and common areas, the writ petitioner No. 1/society which is a
body corporate having perpetual succession and common seal and which
represents the common interest of its members can very well sue the
person who is obstructing such common amenities.

17

33. The next question arises for consideration before this Court is as to
whether creation of an interest in favour of the private respondent No. 4
by allotting open car parking space No. 23 really hinderances the common
right, title and interest and the amenities attached thereto to the members
of the writ petitioner No. 1/society. At this juncture if I compare the
sketch map as has been annexed with the possession certificate dated
02.06.2009 as issued by the KMDA authority and the sketch map dated
22.04.2015 as has also been issued by the respondent/ KMDA authority,
it appears to this Court that an endeavour has been made on behalf of the
KMDA authority to allocate a portion of the common area and common
facility as proposed open car parking space No. 23. It is to be kept into
mind that such an endeavour was made by the KMDA authority in the
year 2015 especially when the KMDA authority loses its right over the
common services and common areas, since the said authority itself
executed a possession certificate in favour of the writ petitioner No.
1/society prior to the execution of the registered deed of conveyance in
favour of the independent apartment owners.
34. In considered view of this Court, the action of the respondent/KMDA
authority thereby earmarking a proposed open car parking space No. 23
over the common area and common facility of the aforementioned housing
complex, is a direct attempt to interfere with the common/proportionate
common right, title and interest of each and every individual apartment
owners who are the members of the writ petitioner No. 1/Co-operative

18

society and such action tantamount to hampering and/or interfering with
the amenities attached to such common facilities as supposed to be
enjoyed by the members of the writ petitioner No. 1/Society
uninterruptedly.
35. Though in course of his argument, Mr. Lahiri contended that the action of
the writ petitioner No. 1/society is partial inasmuch as they took no action
against the allotment of the open car parking space Nos. 19 to 21, in
considered view of this Court, such argument is not at all relevant in
deciding the instant writ petition, since the subject matter of the instant
writ petition is restricted only to the action of the KMDA authority while
allotting open car parking space No. 23 in favour of the respondent No. 4.
36. This Court has already held that the aforementioned action of the KMDA
tantamount to interference with the common/proportionate right, title and
interest of the individual members of the writ petitioner No. 1/society
which is also interference with the amenities as supposed to be enjoyed by
the said members and therefore this Court holds that the instant writ
petition must succeed.
37. Consequently, WPA 14463 of 2015 is hereby allowed .
38. Consequently, the impugned possession certificate dated 06.04.2015 in
connection with open car parking space No. 23 in Dakshini Phase-I
Housing Complex at Plot No. 87/1, Block-D, Baishnabghata Patuli
Township shall stands hereby quashed.

19

39. The respondent/KMDA authority is directed to refund the entire
consideration money after deducting Rs.3000/- per month towards
occupational charge from the date of handover of the possession of the
said open car parking space No. 23 in favour of the private respondent
No.4 till the actual date of issuance of letter of cancellation along with
6.7% interest per anum to the private respondent No. 4, positively within
sixty working days from the date of passing of this order. The occupational
charges as would be deducted by the KMDA authority thereafter shall
have to be deposited in the account of the writ petitioner No.1/society
within fifteen working days from the date of making refund to the private
respondent No. 4.
40. The time limits as fixed by this Court are peremptory and mandatory.
41. In view of passing of this order, the private respondent No. 4 loses his
right to use the said open car parking space No. 23 and in view of such,
the private respondent No. 4 is permanently injuncted with effect from
December 1, 2026 from using the said open space for parking of his car at
the aforementioned housing complex and the said open car parking space
shall have to be treated as common area of the said housing complex
henceforth.
42. Urgent photostat certified copies of this order, if applied for, be supplied to
the parties upon compliance with all the necessary formalities.

(Partha Sarathi Sen, J.)
[Sws.M[AR(c)/Susanta(AR(c)]