State Of Haryana vs Ammu And Another

Court
Punjab and Haryana High Court

1-
CRA-AD-426-2026 (O&M) -


IN THE HIGH COURT OF PUNJAB & HARYANA
AT CHANDIGARH


222+241









CRA-AD-426-2026 (O&M)
Reserved on: 02.11.2026.
Pronounced on: 18.11.2026.
Uploaded on: 18.11.2026.





Whether only operative part of the
judgment is pronounced or the full
judgment is pronounced.


Operative part/full judgment





STATE OF HARYANA
... Appellant(s)


VERSUS


AMMU AND ANOTHER
...Respondent(s)





RAJ KUMAR ARORA
2026.11.18 18:18
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document

2-
CRA-AD-426-2026 (O&M) -


CORAM : HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE VINOD S. BHARDWAJ
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE RAVINDER MALIK


Present :- Dr. (Ms.) Malvika Singh, DAG, Haryana.


VINOD S. BHARDWAJ, J.


1. The present appeal is by the State of Haryana against the
judgment dated 22.03.2017 passed by the Additional Sessions Judge,
Gurugram, in the case arising out of FIR No.128 dated 23.04.2012 registered
under sections 395 and 397 of the Indian Penal Code, 1860, and section 25 of
the Arms Act, 1959, whereby the respondents-accused have been acquitted of
the charges framed against them.
FACTS IN BRIEF
2. The factual matrix of the case is that on 23.04.2012, SI Samunder
Singh, accompanied by other police officials, was present at Ambedkar
Chowk, Sohna, in connection with routine patrolling and crime detection
duties. During the course thereof, Pappu @ Illiyas approached him and
submitted a written complaint, wherein he stated that he was employed as a
driver on a TATA 1109 vehicle bearing registration No. HR-73-2351 and was
transporting goods from Hodal to Gurgaon on the intervening night.
According to the complainant, upon reaching Palwal, one person identified as
Ashok boarded his vehicle. At approximately 2:15 a.m., when they reached
the vicinity of Chungi No. 1, Sohna, another vehicle, described as a Pick-Up,
suddenly came in front of their vehicle and obstructed its movement.
Immediately thereafter, around 10–12 persons alighted from the said vehicle,
some of whom approached from the driver's side, while the others entered
RAJ KUMAR ARORA
2026.11.18 18:18
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document

3-
CRA-AD-426-2026 (O&M) -


from the conductor's side. They forcibly dragged the complainant and his
companion out of their vehicle, assaulted them and hurled abuses at them.
Thereafter, both were shifted to the assailants' Pick-Up vehicle, where their
legs, mouths and eyes were tied with pieces of cloth. They were subsequently
abandoned at an isolated location. The complainant further stated that, upon
the cloth covering his mouth becoming loose, he managed to raise an alarm,
which attracted the attention of certain villagers, who came to their rescue and
untied them. It was then that they learnt that they had been left in the forest
area of village Khedli. As per the complaint, the assailants were
approximately 25 years of age and were speaking in the Mewati dialect.
However, the complainant could not identify any of them as the incident had
occurred during the hours of darkness. He further alleged that, before
abandoning them, the assailants had threatened them against moving from the
place and had fired shots in the air. The complainant also alleged that the
assailants had taken away his two mobile phones bearing Nos. 9671661448
and 9671571853, along with cash of Rs. 975/-. Besides, the mobile phone,
ATM card, PAN card and cash belonging to his companion were also
allegedly taken away.
3. Based on said application, the case was registered. Accused
Liyakat, Mustak and Arif son of Ramjan, were later arrested and challan was
presented against them. Accused Mustak was acquitted and accused Liyakat
and Arif were however convicted by the Court of Additional Sessions Judge,
Gurugram, vide judgment dated 17.04.2013. Subsequently, the supplementary
challan was presented against the respondents-accused namely Ammu son of
Badlu and Arif @ Kala son of Jabbar.
RAJ KUMAR ARORA
2026.11.18 18:18
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document

4-
CRA-AD-426-2026 (O&M) -


4. Upon submission of the police report, copies of the report and all
accompanying documents, as mandated under Section 207 of the Code of
Criminal Procedure, 1973, were furnished to the accused. Thereafter, the case
was committed to the Court of Sessions for trial in accordance with law.
5. Upon consideration of the material available on record, charges
were framed against both the accused vide order dated 09.01.2017 for the
offences punishable under Sections 395 and 397 of the Indian Penal Code,
1860. Additionally, accused Ammu was also charged for the offence
punishable under Section 25 of the Arms Act. The substance of the charges
was read over and explained to the accused, who, however, denied the
allegations, pleaded not guilty to the same and claimed trial.
6. To prove its case against the accused, the prosecution has
examined the following witnesses: -

PW1 Pappu alias Iliyas Complainant
PW2 Ashok Kumar
PW3 SI Satish Kumar
PW4 HC Chap Singh
PW5 SI Narender Kumar
PW6 ASI Shastar Kumar
PW7 ASI Dinesh Kumar
PW8 ASI Deep Chand


PW Head Constable Ombir was given up by the learned Public
Prosecutor being unnecessary.


RAJ KUMAR ARORA
2026.11.18 18:18
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document

5-
CRA-AD-426-2026 (O&M) -


7. The prosecution witnesses, in brief, deposed as under: -

PW-1 Pappu @ Iliyas (Complainant): He reiterated the
prosecution version regarding interception of his Canter by 10–12 persons,
assault upon him and Ashok Kumar, and their being taken away and
abandoned in the forest. He also deposed regarding the theft of the Canter,
mobile phones and cash. However, during cross-examination, he admitted that
he had not seen the faces of the assailants due to darkness and could not
identify the accused present in Court.

PW-2 Ashok Kumar: He corroborated the testimony of PW-1
regarding the occurrence. However, he too admitted that he could not see the
faces of the assailants due to darkness and was unable to identify the accused
present in Court.

PW-3 SI Satish Kumar (Armourer): He proved the
examination of the country-made pistol of .315 bore as Ex. P1 and his report
as Ex. PB. During cross-examination, he admitted that he had not test-fired
the pistol to ascertain whether it was in working condition.

PW-4 Head Constable Chap Singh: He deposed regarding
delivery of the special report to the learned Illaqa Magistrate and senior police
officials.

RAJ KUMAR ARORA
2026.11.18 18:18
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document

6-
CRA-AD-426-2026 (O&M) -


PW-5 SI Narender Kumar : He proved the sanction order dated
20.02.2015, issued by Ms. Bharti Arora, IPS, as Ex. PC.

PW-6 ASI Shastar Kumar: He proved the registration of the
formal FIR as Ex. PD and the endorsement made thereupon as Ex. PD/1.

PW-7 ASI Dinesh Kumar (Investigating Officer): He deposed
regarding the apprehension of accused Liyakat and Aarif, recovery of the
Canter loaded with wheat flour, subsequent recoveries of the stepney, RC and
permit, and the arrest and disclosure statements of accused Aarif @ Kala and
Ammu. He also proved the alleged recovery of a country-made pistol at the
instance of accused Ammu. During cross-examination, he admitted that no
independent witness had been associated with the investigation, disclosure
statements, demarcation proceedings or recovery of the country-made pistol.
He further admitted that nothing was recovered pursuant to the alleged
disclosure statements.

PW8 ASI Deep Chand: He remained associated with
investigating officer ASI Dinesh Kumar. He corroborated the version of PW7
ASI Dinesh Kumar, the investigating officer.

8. The entire prosecution evidence was put to the accused and their
statement was recorded under Section 313 Cr.P.C.. They denied the same and
claimed false implication. It was pleaded that there was no evidence against
them as the prosecution witnesses did not recognize them and no recovery had
been effected. The demarcation of spot is claimed to have been done at the
RAJ KUMAR ARORA
2026.11.18 18:18
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document

7-
CRA-AD-426-2026 (O&M) -


instance of the accused, but the same was already known to the police when
they arrested the other accused. No evidence was, however, led in defence.
9 . Arguments were heard .The learned trial Court, upon
appreciation of the evidence on record, concluded that the prosecution had
failed to prove its case against the respondents beyond reasonable doubt and,
accordingly, acquitted them of the charges.
10 . Hence, the present appeal.

SUBMISSIONS ON BEHALF OF THE STATE-
APPELLANT


11 . Learned State counsel contends that the learned trial Court has
failed to appreciate the prosecution evidence in its proper perspective. It is
argued that the recovery of the stolen Canter, the disclosure statements
suffered by the accused and the subsequent recoveries and demarcation
proceedings constitute a chain of circumstances sufficient to establish their
involvement in the crime. It is further submitted that the alleged recovery of a
country-made pistol from accused Ammu furnishes an additional
incriminating circumstance which has not been appropriately appreciated by
the learned trial Court.
12. It is thus contended that the learned trial Court has adopted an
unduly technical approach while appreciating the prosecution evidence but
has failed to consider the cumulative effect of the circumstances brought on
record. On the aforesaid premises, it is prayed that the impugned judgment be
set aside and the respondents be held guilty of the offences for which they
were charged.


RAJ KUMAR ARORA
2026.11.18 18:18
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document

8-
CRA-AD-426-2026 (O&M) -



CONSIDERATION AND CONCLUSION
13. We have heard the learned counsel appearing on behalf of the
state and have gone through the documents appended with the instant appeal
with her able assistance.
14. Coming to the facts of the present case, the foremost
circumstance which assumes significance is the inability of the two material
prosecution witnesses to identify the respondents as the perpetrators of the
alleged occurrence.
15. PW-1 Pappu alias Iliyas, the complainant himself, deposed that
while he was driving the Canter during the night, 10-12 persons intercepted
his vehicle and forcibly removed him and his companion. However, he
categorically stated that he had not seen the faces of the assailants on account
of darkness. He further expressed his inability to state whether the accused
present in Court were involved in the commission of the offence or not.
16. The testimony of PW-2 Ashok Kumar, the other victim of the
occurrence, is on similar lines. He too stated that he could not see the faces of
the assailants owing to darkness and was unable to identify the respondents as
the persons involved in the commission of the alleged offence.
17. The aforesaid aspect cannot be treated as a mere omission or an
insignificant discrepancy in the prosecution case. Establishing the identity of
the perpetrators constitutes the very foundation of the prosecution’s case. Both
the material witnesses, who had allegedly been subjected to the assault and
robbery, failed to attribute any role to the respondents. Their testimony,
RAJ KUMAR ARORA
2026.11.18 18:18
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document

9-
CRA-AD-426-2026 (O&M) -


therefore, establishes the occurrence of a robbery-like incident but does not
establish the identity or participation of the present respondents therein.
18. It is equally important to notice that the prosecution has not
brought on record any other direct evidence which could independently
establish the presence of the respondents at the place of occurrence. No test
identification proceedings or other reliable identifying circumstance has been
demonstrated from the record supplied to this Court. In the absence of
identification by the victims, the prosecution was required to establish the
involvement of the respondents through cogent and legally admissible
circumstantial evidence.
19. The prosecution next seeks to rely upon the alleged recovery of
the Canter bearing registration No. HR-73-2351. A perusal of the testimony
of PW-7 ASI Dinesh Kumar reveals that the said vehicle was recovered from
accused Liyakat and Aarif. Neither of the present respondents are stated to
have been apprehended in possession of the said vehicle. The recovery,
therefore, cannot, by itself, be treated as an incriminating circumstance against
the present respondents. The arrest of the accused having taken place at
different times, the respondents would not be held liable for the offence only
because their names were recorded in the disclosure of the co-accused.
20. The mere fact that the vehicle allegedly stolen during the
occurrence was subsequently recovered during the investigation does not,
without any further corroboration, establish the involvement of persons who
were neither found in possession thereof nor otherwise connected with its
recovery through legally admissible evidence. The prosecution was required
RAJ KUMAR ARORA
2026.11.18 18:18
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document

10-
CRA-AD-426-2026 (O&M) -


to establish the necessary connecting link between the present respondents
and the recovered property.

DISCLOSURE STATEMENTS AND DEMARCATION
PROCEEDINGS


21. The next circumstance relied upon by the State pertains to the
disclosure statements allegedly suffered by the respondents and the
demarcation proceedings conducted at their instance.
22. The evidentiary value of a disclosure statement, recorded while
the accused is in police custody, is circumscribed by Section 27 of the Indian
Evidence Act, 1872. The provision constitutes an exception to the general
prohibition against proving confessional statements made to a police officer
and permits only that portion of the information which relates distinctly to the
fact thereby discovered to be proved.
23. The scope of Section 27 of the Evidence Act was explained by
the Privy Council in Pulukuri Kottaya v. King-Emperor, AIR 1947 PC 67 ,
wherein it was held that the fact discovered is not confined merely to the
physical object produced but also embraces the place from which the object
is produced and the knowledge of the accused concerning the same. However,
the information admissible is strictly confined to that which relates distinctly
to the fact discovered.
24. The aforesaid principle was reiterated by the Hon’ble Supreme
Court in Bodhraj v. State of Jammu and Kashmir, (2002) 8 SCC 45 , wherein
it was held that the information leading to discovery, and not the opinion
formed by the police officer, is admissible under Section 27. The exact
RAJ KUMAR ARORA
2026.11.18 18:18
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document

11-
CRA-AD-426-2026 (O&M) -


information supplied by the accused which led to the discovery must be
proved in accordance with law.
25. Tested on the aforesaid principles, the disclosure statements
relied upon by the prosecution do not advance its case against the present
respondents. The police was already aware of the said fact much before the
respondents were arrested since the other accused had carried out the
demarcation.
26. Similarly, the demarcation proceedings conducted at the instance
of the respondents have not resulted in the discovery of any fact which was
hitherto unknown to the investigating agency. The mere pointing out of a
place already known to the investigating agency, without any consequential
discovery, does not furnish an independent incriminating circumstance. A
demarcation memo cannot be accorded evidentiary value beyond the
discovery, if any, which it actually brings about.

RECOVERY OF COUNTRY-MADE PISTOL AND
SANCTION UNDER THE ARMS ACT


27. The prosecution has also relied upon the alleged recovery of a
country-made pistol from accused Ammu pursuant to his disclosure statement
dated 16.02.2013. The said recovery was sought to be established through the
testimony of PW-7 ASI Dinesh Kumar, who proved the recovery memo and
the relevant documents. PW-3 SI Satish Kumar, the armourer, examined the
case property and identified the country-made pistol in Court.
28. The evidentiary value of the alleged recovery, however, has to be
examined independently of the mere fact that a weapon was stated to have
been recovered. The prosecution was required to establish not only the factum
RAJ KUMAR ARORA
2026.11.18 18:18
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document

12-
CRA-AD-426-2026 (O&M) -


of recovery but also the circumstances connecting the recovered weapon with
the accused and the statutory ingredients of the offence for which he was
charged.
29. In this regard, the cross-examination of PW-7 assumes
significance. He admitted that no independent witness was present at the time
of the alleged recovery of the pistol. Further, PW-3, the armourer, admitted
that he had not fired any shot to ascertain whether the pistol was in working
condition. In Jaspal Singh v. State of Punjab, (1998) 7 SCC 289, the Hon’ble
Supreme Court set aside the conviction under Section 25 of the Arms Act
where no evidence had been led to show that the weapon was in working
condition. The relevant para is extracted as under: -

ANAVATI
“G.T. N , J. — The appellant has been convicted under
Section 25 of the Arms Act, 1959 and Section 5 of the TADA Act,
1987 as he was found in possession of one DBBL gun .12 bore
and five live cartridges on 17-3-1992/18-3-1992. The trial court
relying upon the evidence of ASI Balbir Singh and PW 4 Man
Singh who were the members of the police party held that it was
proved by the prosecution that the appellant was in possession of
those articles. The trial court further held that as the gun was
found loaded, it can be presumed that it was in working order.
Taking this view, it convicted the appellant, as stated above.

2. Admittedly, no evidence was led by the prosecution to prove
that the gun was in working condition and that the cartridges
which were found from the person of the appellant were live
cartridges. Neither ASI Balbir Singh had stated so nor was any
report from an expert obtained to establish that the gun was in
working condition and that five cartridges were live. What was
found in the gun were two empties and not live cartridges and,
therefore, it was not proper to presume that it was in working
RAJ KUMAR ARORA
2026.11.18 18:18
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document

13-
CRA-AD-426-2026 (O&M) -


condition. In the absence of any evidence to that effect, the
conviction of the appellant under both these aforesaid sections
cannot be upheld. We, therefore, allow this appeal, set aside the
judgment and order passed by the Additional Judge, Designated
Court, Sangrur, in Special Sessions Case No. 55 of 1992 and
acquit the appellant.”


30. There is yet another aspect which has weighed with the learned
trial Court. The sanction order Ex.PC, relied upon by the prosecution, does
not indicate that the alleged weapon had been produced before the competent
sanctioning authority for consideration. PW-5 SI Narender Kumar, who was
examined in connection with the sanction proceedings, did not depose that the
weapon had been produced before the authority concerned. In his cross-
examination, he stated that the sanction order had not been issued in his
presence. The law on this aspect is well settled. In Mansukhlal Vithaldas
Chauhan v. State of Gujarat, (1997) 7 SCC 622 , the Hon’ble Supreme Court
held that the validity of a sanction depends upon the material placed before
the sanctioning authority and that consideration of such material implies
application of mind. The order of sanction must ex facie disclose that the
authority had considered the evidence and material placed before it and, where
the facts constituting the offence are not so reflected, the prosecution must
establish by extraneous evidence that those facts were placed before the
authority. In the present case, Ex.PC does not reflect that the weapon was
placed before the sanctioning authority, nor has any evidence been led to that
effect. The relevant para is extracted as under: -

RAJ KUMAR ARORA
2026.11.18 18:18
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document

14-
CRA-AD-426-2026 (O&M) -


“ 18. The validity of the sanction would, therefore, depend upon
the material placed before the sanctioning authority and the fact
that all the relevant facts, material and evidence have been
considered by the sanctioning authority. Consideration implies
application of mind. The order of sanction must ex facie disclose
that the sanctioning authority had considered the evidence and
other material placed before it. This fact can also be established
by extrinsic evidence by placing the relevant files before the
Court to show that all relevant facts were considered by the
sanctioning authority. (See also Jaswant Singh v. State of Punjab
[AIR 1958 SC 124 : 1958 SCR 762] and State of Bihar v. P.P.
Sharma [1992 Supp (1) SCC 222 : 1992 SCC (Cri) 192 : 1991
Cri LJ 1438] .)”


31. The requirement of sanction under Section 39 of the Arms Act,
wherever attracted, is not an empty formality. The statutory provision is
extracted as follows: -

“39. Previous sanction of the district magistrate necessary in
certain cases . ― No prosecution shall be instituted against any
person in respect of any offence under section 3 without the
previous sanction of the district magistrate.”


32. The purpose of such statutory safeguard is to ensure that
prosecution is instituted after the competent authority has considered the
relevant material and applied its mind to the facts constituting the alleged
offence. The said principle has been reiterated in State of Karnataka v.
Ameerjan, (2007) 11 SCC 273 and Central Bureau of Investigation v. Ashok
Kumar Aggarwal, (2014) 14 SCC 295 , wherein it was emphasised that
RAJ KUMAR ARORA
2026.11.18 18:18
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document

15-
CRA-AD-426-2026 (O&M) -


sanction cannot be granted in a mechanical manner and that the sanctioning
authority must have the relevant material before it and apply its mind thereto.
33. Consequently, even the evidence pertaining to the alleged
recovery of the pistol and the sanction under the Arms Act does not furnish a
sufficient basis for interfering with the acquittal recorded by the trial Court.
34. The circumstances relied upon by the prosecution have to be
examined in their entirety, but such an exercise cannot be undertaken by
assigning to each circumstance an evidentiary value which it does not possess.
The cumulative assessment of evidence does not mean that deficiencies in
individual links can be supplied by merely placing them together. Each
circumstance must first be established through legally admissible and reliable
evidence before it can be considered as part of a chain pointing towards the
guilt of the accused.
35. The governing principles for appreciation of circumstantial
evidence have been explained by the Hon’ble Supreme Court in Sharad
Birdhichand Sarda v. State of Maharashtra, (1984) 4 SCC 116 . It has been
held that the circumstances from which the conclusion of guilt is to be drawn
must be fully established; the facts so established must be consistent only with
the hypothesis of guilt; they must be conclusive in nature and tendency; they
must exclude every possible hypothesis except the one sought to be proved;
and the chain of evidence must be so complete as not to leave any reasonable
ground for a conclusion consistent with the innocence of the accused.
36. Applying the aforesaid principles to the facts of the present case,
the prosecution has failed to establish a complete chain of circumstances
connecting the respondents with the commission of the alleged offence. The
RAJ KUMAR ARORA
2026.11.18 18:18
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document

16-
CRA-AD-426-2026 (O&M) -


two material witnesses have failed to identify them; the Canter was recovered
from other accused persons; the disclosure statements and demarcation
proceedings have not yielded any consequential discovery connecting the
respondents with the crime; and the alleged recovery of the pistol, when
examined in the backdrop of the other evidence, does not independently
establish their guilt.
37. It is settled that suspicion, however grave, cannot take the place
of proof. The seriousness of the allegations or the nature of the offence cannot
dilute the standard of proof required in a criminal trial. The prosecution is
required to establish the guilt of the accused beyond reasonable doubt and
such burden cannot be discharged by relying upon circumstances which,
individually or collectively, fail to establish the necessary connection between
the accused and the alleged crime.
38. This Court is conscious of the fact that the appellate jurisdiction
in an appeal against acquittal is not rendered ineffective merely because the
trial Court has recorded a finding of innocence. Nevertheless, the power to
reappreciate evidence has to be exercised in accordance with the settled
principles governing such appeals. Where the view taken by the trial Court is
a reasonably possible view based on the evidence available on record, the
appellate Court would not be justified in substituting the same merely because
another view is sought to be canvassed by the prosecution.
39. The position in law also needs no reiteration that where two
views are possible, the view in favour of an accused should ordinarily be given
precedence. The Hon’ble Supreme Court in Chandrappa and others v. State
RAJ KUMAR ARORA
2026.11.18 18:18
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document

17-
CRA-AD-426-2026 (O&M) -


of Karnataka, (2007) 4 SCC 415, while summarising the principles governing
appeals against acquittal, observed as under: -

(i) An appellate Court has full power to review, reappreciate and
reconsider the evidence upon which the order of acquittal is
founded.

(ii) The Code of Criminal Procedure places no limitation or
restriction upon the exercise of such power.

(iii) Expressions such as ‘substantial and compelling reasons’,
‘good and sufficient grounds’ or ‘very strong circumstances’ do
not curtail the appellate Court’s power to reappreciate the
evidence.

(iv) However, in an appeal against acquittal, there exists a
double presumption in favour of the accused. Firstly, the
presumption of innocence is available to every accused as a
fundamental principle of criminal jurisprudence. Secondly, such
presumption stands further reinforced, reaffirmed and
strengthened once the accused has secured an acquittal from the
trial Court.

(v) Where two reasonable conclusions are possible on the basis
of the evidence on record, the appellate Court should not disturb
the finding of acquittal recorded by the trial Court.

RAJ KUMAR ARORA
2026.11.18 18:18
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document

18-
CRA-AD-426-2026 (O&M) -


40. The aforesaid principle has been reiterated by the Hon’ble
Supreme Court in Ghurey Lal v. State of U.P., (2008) 10 SCC 450 , wherein
it was emphasised that due weight and consideration must be accorded to the
findings recorded by the trial Court, particularly when the credibility of
witnesses is involved. The trial Court has the distinct advantage of observing
the demeanour of witnesses and evaluating their testimony in the setting in
which it is recorded. An appellate Court, therefore, ought not to substitute its
own view merely because another interpretation of the evidence is possible.
Interference is warranted where the findings are perverse, manifestly
erroneous or wholly unsustainable.
41. We find that the present appeal lacks merit. The same is
accordingly dismissed.
42. The judgment dated 22.03.2017 passed by the Additional
Sessions Judge, Gurugram, in a case arising out of FIR no. 128 dated
23.04.2012 registered under sections 395 and 397 of the Indian Penal Code,
1860, and section 25 of the Arms Act, is affirmed.



(VINOD S. BHARDWAJ)
JUDGE




November 18, 2026. (RAVINDER MALIK)
raj arora JUDGE

Whether speaking/reasoned : Yes/No

Whether reportable : Yes/No
RAJ KUMAR ARORA
2026.11.18 18:18
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document