AJOY DEB MANDAL vs THE ORIENTAL INSURANCE COMPANY LIMITED AND ORS.
- Court
- Calcutta High Court
IN THE HIGH COURT AT CALCUTTA
CONSTITUTIONAL WRIT JURISDICTION
APPELLATE SIDE
Present:
The Hon’ble Justice Ajay Kumar Gupta
WPA No. 14467 of 2024
Ajoy Deb Mandal
Versus
The Oriental Insurance Company Limited & Ors.
For the Petitioner : Mr. Meghajit Mukherjee, Adv.
Ms. Kabita Mukherjee, Adv.
Mr. Gourav Das, Adv.
For the Respondent Nos. 1-4 : Mr. Ranjay De, Ld. Sr. Adv.
Mr. Basabjit Banerjee, Adv.
Mr. Adityajit Abel Bose, Adv.
Heard on : 18.09.2026
Delivered on : 19.11.2026
Uploaded on : 19.11.2026
2
Ajay Kumar Gupta, J.: -
1. The instant writ petition has been filed by the petitioner seeking
direction to quash the disciplinary proceedings initiated against the
th
petitioner herein, along with withdrawal of the orders dated 8
th th th
March, 2021, 20 December, 2021, 30 August, 2022 and 25
September, 2023, passed by the Disciplinary Authority.
2. The petitioner is an employee of the respondent no. 1, the Oriental
Insurance Company Limited, a public sector insurer owned by the
Government of India. Respondent nos. 2 to 4 are its office bearers.
The petitioner was posted at the Magma Cell/Broker Business Cell,
Kolkata, from 2010 to 2014, first as Assistant Manager I/C and
thereafter as Deputy Manager I/C.
3. The facts of the case are that Respondent no. 4 imposed a major
penalty upon the petitioner in a proceeding initiated under the
Oriental Insurance Co. (Conduct, Discipline and Appeal) Rules, 2014.
Respondent no. 4 was pleased to pass an order dated March 8, 2021,
inter alia, holding the petitioner guilty of the charges levelled against
him and imposed a penalty by reduction in basic pay by 3 increments
in the scale of pay.
4. The allegation, inter alia, was that the petitioner, in connivance with
unknown officials of DO-5, OICL, Kolkata, had approved and issued
3
more than 500 Motor TP stand-alone policies under the Motor
Miscellaneous head, in violation of the Motor Tariff applicable to
commercial vehicles. He was alleged to have issued Misc-D policies,
which carry a lower premium, in place of commercial vehicle policies,
which required a higher premium. The period involved was January
2012 to 2014. The loss to OICL was put at approximately Rs. 67
lakhs, with the possibility of more such policies.
5. A disciplinary proceeding under The Oriental Insurance Company
(Conduct, Discipline & Appeal) Rules, 2014 was initiated against the
petitioner. The Articles of Charge and Statement of Imputation of
Misconduct/Misbehaviour along with the List of Documents and
Witnesses were communicated to the petitioner. The petitioner denied
and disputed all charges in his statement of defence dated December
22, 2018. By communication dated April 9, 2019, respondent No.4
found the reply unsatisfactory, appointed an Enquiry Officer, and
directed the petitioner to take part in enquiry proceedings on the date
and time to be intimated later for such purposes.
6. The petitioner participated in such enquiry proceedings and
th
presented his defence. By a communication dated 5 February, 2020,
the respondent No. 4 forwarded the Enquiry Report dated November
26, 2019 submitted by the Enquiry Officer. Respondent no. 4 further
4
intimated the petitioner that out of five charges levelled against the
petitioner, the Enquiry Officer had arrived at a finding that charge
numbers 2, 3, 4, and 5 had been fully proved, while charge number 1
had been partially proved. Be that as it may, the respondent no. 4,
however, was of the view that Charge Number 1 had also been fully
proved because accepting unlawful and unreasonable orders of the
seniors was also misconduct. The petitioner was given an opportunity
to submit a representation within 15 days against the findings of the
Enquiry Officer and the observation of the Disciplinary Authority.
7. In pursuance of the aforesaid, the petitioner filed a representation
th
dated 4 June, 2020, before respondent no. 4, negating the
observations and findings of the Enquiry Officer and the Disciplinary
th
Authority. The petitioner further filed an Addendum dated 11 June,
2020, to the aforesaid representation.
8. Respondent no. 4, after considering the aforesaid and the materials
th
on record, was pleased to pass an order dated 8 March, 2021, inter
alia, holding the petitioner guilty of the charges levelled against him
and imposed a penalty to the following effect:
"REDUCTION IN BASIC PAY BY THREE INCREMENTS IN THE
TIME SCALE"
5
9. Being aggrieved by and dissatisfied with the aforesaid order passed
rd
by the respondent no.4, the petitioner filed an appeal dated 3 June,
2021 before the respondent no. 2 herein, being the Appellate
Authority under The Oriental Insurance Company (Conduct,
Discipline & Appeal) Rules, 2014.
10. On the same cause of action, the respondent No.1/OICL had also
initiated criminal proceedings against the petitioner and others,
which were being investigated by the Central Bureau of Investigation
(CBI), being CBI/ACB/S No.RC0102017A003 pending before the
rd
Learned 3 Special CBI Court, Bankshall Court at Calcutta. The CBI
had completed the investigation and filed a report in the form of a
th
Charge Sheet dated 28 September, 2019 in such proceedings, inter
alia , arriving at a finding that "no criminality could be made out
against Petitioner and others except one, Sri Tanmoy Ghosh.
11. In view of the aforesaid, the petitioner filed an additional
th
representation dated 13 December, 2021 in the pending appeal
before the respondent no. 2, bringing on record the aforesaid Charge
Sheet filed by the CBI, exonerating him from the criminal charge.
th
12. By an order dated 20 December, 2021, the respondent no. 2
rejected the appeal filed by the petitioner. The respondent no. 2
passed a cryptic order, as per the petitioner and came to the finding
6
that "The disciplinary authority attended to the contentions
appropriately while imposing penalty". However, no reasons were
cited by the respondent no. 2 in support of such findings. The order
th
dated 20 December, 2021 would also reveal that the Appellate
Authority did not go through the specific grounds taken in the appeal
th
nor did it refer to or examine the additional representation dated 13
December, 2021 filed by the petitioner disclosing the Charge Sheet
filed by CBI exonerating him from the criminal case.
13. Having no other alternative, the petitioner was constrained to file a
rd
representation dated 23 February, 2022, before the authority to
consider his appeal afresh along with the supplementary reply dated
th
13 December, 2021 on the specific points raised by him in the said
appeal.
st
14. In the meantime, vide order dated 21 April, 2022 passed in
rd
CBR/ACB/S No. RC01020174003, the Learned 3 Special CBI Court,
Bankshall Court at Calcutta was pleased to drop the proceedings
against the petitioner in view of the final report submitted by the CBI.
th
15. The petitioner submitted a representation dated 24 May, 2022, to
the Hon'ble Vice Chairman, National Commission for Schedule Caste,
inter alia , bringing the notice of the entire facts on record and
7
demanding justice specifically in light of the findings of the CBI Court
referred to hereinabove.
th
16. By a communication dated 14 October, 2022, the Manager of the
Personnel Department, Regional Office, Kolkata of the respondent No.
1 organization communicated an order dated August 30, 2022 passed
by the respondent No.3, inter alia, rejecting the representation dated
February 23, 2022 filed by the petitioner by holding as follows:
"Your Memorial Representation with documents of the case
was placed before the Board Sub-Committee of Appeal &
Memorial during the meeting held on 03.08.2022. The Board
Sub-Committee, after due deliberations, did not find any new
material facts in your Memorial Representation to merit
reconsideration of the decision of the Disciplinary Authority
and hence the order of the Disciplinary Authority was
unanimously upheld."
th
17. The petitioner, vide his letter dated 12 December, 2022, requested
the respondent No.4 to reconsider his case in its true perspective in
st
light of the findings of the CBI and the order dated 21 April, 2022
passed by the Learned 3rd Special CBI Court, Bankshall Court at
Calcutta, dropping the criminal case against the petitioner.
th
18. By a communication dated 6 March, 2023, the National
Commission for Scheduled Castes forwarded to the respondent no. 2
th
the minutes of the hearing held before the Commission on 24
8
February, 2023, wherein the Commission observed that in view of the
clean chit given by the CBI, the petitioner was advised to submit his
mercy petition before the CMD/OICL and the same was requested to
be sympathetically considered within a reasonable period of time.
th
19. The petitioner submitted a mercy petition dated 13 March, 2023 to
the respondent no. 2 requesting him to reconsider the matter afresh
and exonerate the petitioner from all charges, especially in view of the
Final Report filed by the CBI in the matter and acceptance of the
same by the jurisdictional Court.
20. By an order dated September 25, 2023, the respondent no. 2 revised
the penalty imposed on the petitioner, inter alia , as follows:
"Reduction in Basic Pay by Two Increments in The Time
Scale"
21. The respondent no. 2 has held that the only factual scenario which
had changed after the disposal of the memorial representation dated
th
20 February, 2023 was the Closure Report filed by the CBI and the
acceptance of the same by the Learned Magistrate vide his order
st th
dated 21 April, 2022. The said order dated 25 September, 2023,
which is impugned in the present proceedings, is conspicuously
bereft of any logical reasoning which could have prompted the
respondent no. 2 to arrive at the finding of revision of penalty
9
th
imposed on the petitioner; as such, the order dated 25 September,
2023 passed by the respondent no. 2 is bad in law and liable to be
set aside.
22. According to the petitioner, the order dated 25th September, 2023 is
wholly non-speaking and devoid of reasoning. Reasons are the
heartbeat of every conclusion, and without them an order becomes
lifeless. The failure to record reasons violates the principles of natural
justice and renders the order non est. Reasons ensure transparency
and fairness in decision-making, and enable a litigant to know why
his prayer has been accepted or rejected. Recording reasons is a
requirement of natural justice and the linchpin of the administration
of justice, being the link between the mind of the decision-maker and
the controversy in question. Failure to give reasons therefore
amounts to a denial of justice. Hence the present writ petition.
23. Mr. Mukherjee, the Learned counsel, along with others representing
the petitioner, submitted that the respondents, being public
authorities, are bound to act fairly and reasonably and not to indulge
in any unwarranted action to the detriment of the petitioner herein.
The conduct of the respondent authorities, and particularly
respondent no. 2, clearly indicates that they have proceeded with a
10
closed mind in declining/rejecting the petitioner's representation
th
dated 13 March, 2023, as well as advised of the commission.
24. It was further submitted that the respondent authority did not
consider the final result of the criminal proceedings, whereby, in the
allegation levelled against the petitioner, even a prima facie case has
not been established, and finally the CBI had completed the
investigation and filed a report in the form of a Charge Sheet dated
th
28 September, 2019 in such proceedings, inter alia, arriving at a
finding that "no criminality could be made out against Petitioner and
others except Sri Tanmoy Ghosh. The Learned 3rd Special CBI Court,
Bankshall Court at Calcutta, was pleased to drop the proceedings
against the petitioner in view of the final report submitted by the CBI
st
vide order dated 21 April, 2022 passed in CBR/ACB/S No.
RC01020174003.
25. The learned counsel further contended that mere ritual of repeating
the words or language used in the provisions, saying that no illegality
or impropriety is found therein without even a whisper of the merit of
the matter or nature of pleas raised, does not meet the requirement of
th
a decision-making process. The impugned order dated 25
September, 2023 is bald in reasoning and does not reflect the
application of mind of the respondent no. 2 whatsoever.
11
26. The impugned actions/or decisions of the respondent authorities and
particularly the respondent no. 2 are illegal, arbitrary, without
and/or in excess of jurisdiction, amount to malice in law as well also
in facts, suffer from the vices of Wednesbury Unreasonableness,
procedural impropriety and illegality and are unconstitutional, illegal,
and violative of the principles of natural justice, highhanded, in
colourable exercise of power and/or in wrongful usurpation thereof
and is also violative of Article 14 of the Constitution of India as such
the writ court may interfere and set aside the order of imposition of
penalty.
27. Reliance was placed on the following judgments to bolster his
contention that the writ court can interfere with the impugned
departmental proceeding and its findings based on without any valid
reasoning, while the criminal case against the petitioner has been
dropped by the criminal court as under: -
i. Satya Narayan Kushwaha v. The State of Madhya Pradesh
1
& Ors. ;
2
ii. Raj Kishore Jha v. State of Bihar & Ors. particularly in
paragraph no. 13 thereof ;
1 th
Writ Petition No. 19493 of 2022 dated 13 December, 2022 (M.P. High Court)
2
(2003) 11 SCC 519;
12
iii. Vishnu Dev Sharma v. State of U.P. & Ors particularly
3
paragraphs 7 thereof. .
28. Learned senior counsel appearing on behalf of the respondent nos. 1-
4 vehemently controverted the contention of the petitioner and
further submitted that the departmental proceeding had been
initiated against the petitioner and the charges were proved by the
th
witnesses and finally, vide order dated 8 March, 2021, inter alia,
declared the petitioner guilty of the charges levelled against him and
imposed a penalty by reduction in basic pay by 3 increments in the
time pay.
29. It was further contended that the petitioner had filed an appeal before
the authority, but he could not succeed in the appeal. Thereafter, he
made a representation before the National Commission of Scheduled
Castes; in turn, the Commission advised him to make a mercy
petition before the appropriate authority. Accordingly, he submitted a
mercy petition before the authority without challenging the order
passed in an appeal preferred by the petitioner in any court of law.
The petitioner has admitted the finding of respondent no. 4 and the
order passed in appeal; in any event, the same became final and
absolute.
3
(2008) 3 SCC 172;
13
30. Despite the aforesaid facts, respondent no. 2 considered the
petitioner’s mercy petition and reduced his penalty to two increments
from three increments on humanitarian grounds, as the petitioner
belongs to the Scheduled Caste based on request by the Commission
of Scheduled Castes. Reduction of penalty on humanitarian grounds
need not require assigning any reason as expected by the petitioner.
Therefore, the order of reduction of penalty on mercy petition should
not be interfered with or entertained by the writ court in exercise of
power conferred under Article 226 of the Constitution of India. The
writ petition ought to be dismissed in limine.
31. Finally, the learned counsel contended that the disciplinary authority
is not bound by the order of dropping of the criminal case against the
petitioner by the criminal court, if the evidence that is produced in
the departmental inquiry is different from that produced or brought
during investigation and/or criminal trial. In the present case,
departmental proceeding completed and found him guilty prior to
exoneration from the criminal proceeding pending before the trial
court.
32. Learned senior counsel has placed reliance on the following
judgments to bolster his contentions that the charges were proved
and punishment was imposed accordingly; therefore the question of
14
disproportionality of penalty and illegality according to the alleged
charges does not arise: -
4
i. National Fertilizers Ltd. & Anr. Vs. P.K. Khanna ;
ii. Regional Manager, UCO Bank & Anr. vs. Krishna Kumar
5
Bhardwaj ;
iii. Karnataka Power Transmission Corporation Limited
represented by Managing Director (Administration and HR)
6
Vs. C. Nagaraju and Anr. .
33. Having heard the arguments and submissions made by the learned
counsels for the respective parties and having gone through the
materials made available on record, it appears that the petitioner has
challenged the aforesaid order, one of which reduced the penalty on
the mercy petition. The questions that arise for consideration before
this Court are as under: -
i. Whether the findings and penalty in the disciplinary proceedings
call for interference?
st
ii. Whether the final report of the CBI and the order dated 21 April,
2022 have any bearing on the findings of the disciplinary authority?
34. Firstly, this Court is of the opinion that there is no scope for
th
interference with the order dated 25 September, 2023 passed by the
4
(2005) 7 SCC 597;
5
(2022) 5 SCC 695;
6
(2019) 10 SCC 367;
15
competent authority, whereby the penalty imposed upon the
petitioner has been reduced. The petitioner was found guilty of the
commission of the offence as alleged in the departmental proceedings.
The charges levelled against the petitioner were proved during the
departmental proceedings. The punishment was accordingly imposed
upon him. He had challenged the said finding of the disciplinary
authority by way of appeal. But he could not succeed. In appeal, the
order passed by the disciplinary authority was affirmed. He
submitted his mercy petition to the competent authority, based on
the advice of the Commission for Scheduled Castes.
35. It is admitted fact that the petitioner never challenged the order dated
rd
3 August, 2022 passed by the Board sub-committee of Appeal &
Memorial, which was passed after due deliberations, unanimously
upholding the order of the Disciplinary authority. The said order has
not been challenged before any forum; rather, he submitted mercy
petition before the authority on the basis of the advice of the National
Commission of Scheduled Castes. It seems that the petitioner
ultimately accepted the decision of the Disciplinary Authority and
finally made a prayer before the authority for mercy, and the
authority has considered his mercy petition on humanitarian
grounds, as the petitioner belongs to a Scheduled Caste. There is no
16
provision to challenge such order passed on a mercy petition. It is the
prerogative of the authority to either accept his mercy petition or
deny the same. In the present case, the authority has accepted his
mercy petition on humanitarian grounds.
36. It is a settled proposition of law that when the petitioner is found
guilty in a disciplinary proceeding, then subsequently dropping his
case after investigation bears no consequences on the disciplinary
authority and/or appellate authority decisions because both the
proceedings are adjudicated by two different forums.
37. The petitioner's principal contention is that the departmental findings
cannot survive once the criminal proceedings were dropped. A
disciplinary proceeding and a criminal prosecution are distinct
proceedings before different forums, with different objects. The first
determines whether the employee is guilty of misconduct under the
service rules and whether he should continue in service. The second
determines guilt of an offence as alleged on the criminal standard of
proof.
38. The judgment relied upon by the respondent nos .1 to 4 in the case of
Karnataka Power Transmission Corporation Limited (Supra) is
truly and squarely applicable in the present facts and circumstances
of the case since in the said case, the Hon’ble Supreme Court held
17
that the acquittal by a criminal court does not preclude a
departmental inquiry against the delinquent officer. The disciplinary
authority is not bound by the judgment of the criminal court if the
evidence that is produced in the departmental inquiry is different
from that produced during the criminal trial. The object of the
departmental inquiry is to find out whether the delinquent is guilty of
misconduct under the conduct rules for the purpose of determining
whether he should be continued in service. The standard of proof in
a departmental inquiry is not strictly based on the rules of evidence.
The order of dismissal, based on evidence before the inquiry officer in
the disciplinary proceedings, which is different from the evidence
available to the criminal court, is justified and needs no interference
by the High Court. In the present case, the disciplinary authority
found him guilty and awarded punishment by "REDUCTION IN
BASIC PAY BY THREE INCREMENTS IN THE TIME SCALE", and
subsequently, the penalty was further reduced upon consideration of
a mercy petition by reducing punishment by "REDUCTION IN BASIC
PAY BY TWO INCREMENTS IN THE TIME SCALE” even after
unsuccessful appeal preferred by the petitioner only on humanitarian
grounds and without touching on merits. Such a decision taken by
the competent authority calls for no interference.
18
39. The judgement relied upon by the petitioner is not at all applicable in
the present case since the facts involved are totally different and not
identical.
th
40. Insofar as the order dated 25 September, 2023 is concerned, the
th
petitioner's appeal was rejected on 20 December, 2021. His
th
memorial representation was rejected on 30 August, 2022, after the
Board Sub-Committee of Appeal & Memorial, upon due deliberation,
found no new material to warrant reconsideration. The petitioner did
not challenge either order at the time. After the Commission advised
th
him to submit a mercy petition, he did so on 13 March, 2023, and
the competent authority reduced the penalty from three increments
to two. That decision rests on humanitarian considerations and does
not disturb the finding of guilt. An order of this kind is an act of
clemency and not an adjudication of the merits afresh. It operated to
the petitioner's benefit by reducing the penalty. The absence of
elaborate reasons does not render it bad in law.
41. The petitioner's contention that the order is arbitrary, violates Article
14 of the Constitution, and suffers from Wednesbury
unreasonableness and a closed mind cannot be accepted. An
authority that reduces a penalty on a mercy petition has not acted
with a closed mind towards the delinquent. The petitioner also
19
sought, through the mercy petition, exoneration on the strength of
the CBI's final report. That prayer was in substance a request to
reopen the finding of guilt, which had already been upheld on appeal
and on the memorial representation. The authority was entitled to
decline it, and its choice to grant partial relief on humanitarian
grounds is not open to challenge under Article 226.
42. Having sought and obtained a reduction of penalty on a mercy
petition, the petitioner cannot now be permitted to contest the
th
penalty on the merits. He allowed the orders dated 20 December,
th
2021, and 30 August, 2022 to stand unchallenged, and this writ
petition was filed in 2024 challenging the order passed based on the
mercy petition. Thus, the writ petition is devoid of merits and fails.
43. Accordingly, WPA No. 14467 of 2024 stands dismissed without
order as to costs. Pending applications, if any, are also, thus,
disposed of.
44. Interim order, if any, stands vacated.
45. Parties shall act on the server copies of this Judgment downloaded
from the official website of the High Court at Calcutta.
20
46. Urgent Photostat certified copies of this Judgment, if applied for, be
supplied to the parties upon compliance of all the necessary and legal
formalities.
(Ajay Kumar Gupta, J.)
P.A.