MD. WASIM @ WASSI vs STATE OF WEST BENGAL

Court
Calcutta High Court

IN THE HIGH COURT AT CALCUTTA
CRIMINAL REVISIONAL JURISDICTION
APPELLATE SIDE
Present:-
HON’BLE JUSTICE CHAITALI CHATTERJEE DAS.
CRR 127 OF 2025
MD. WASIM @ WASSI
VS.
STATE OF WEST BENGAL & ANR.


For the Petitioner : Mr. Sandip Kumar Bhattacharya, Adv.
Mr. Dipta Dipak Banerjee, Adv.
Ms. Srijita Dhar,Adv.
Ms. Srilekha Dhar,Adv.

For the State : Mr. Kallol Mondal, Learned Public Prosecutor
Mr. Pritam Roy, Adv.
Ms. Samira Grewal, Adv.

Heard On : 02.09.2026
Judgement on : 20.11.2026
Uploaded on : 20.11.2026

CHAITALI CHATTERJEE DAS, J.:-
1. This revisional application has been filed for setting aside the order dated
11.12.2024 passed by the learned Additional District and Sessions Judge,
Page 1 of 28

14th Court, Alipore in connection with Sessions Trial no. 127 of 2024. The
charges are framed under Section 120B/302/307/427 of IPC.
Brief fact of the case
2. The case under reference was started on the basis of a letter of complaint
dated 18.3.2024, before the Officer-in-Charge of Garden Reach Police
Station by one Pranay Tamang, S.I of Police Station upon receiving a
telephonic information during the intervening night of 17.3.2024 and
18.3.2024, at about 00:02 hours to the effect that a five storied under-
construction building situated at J – 506B and J– 506C, Azhar Molla Bagan,
Kolkata- 700024 has been collapsed. The police immediately reached at the
spot and laid by the local persons to the adjacent premises consisted of
several tiled, single story rooms which were severely damaged and they were
informed by the local people that the construction building was being
developed by a local promoter named Md. Wasim, the petitioner herein . It
was further alleged that the appropriate officials were called to carry out the
rescue of the person trapped underneath the debris. During searching found
seven persons to be dead and several others critically injured. The officers
from the Kolkata Municipal Corporation came into the spot and submitted a
written complaint to the officer in charge of the Garden Reach Police Station
to the effect that the construction was totally unauthorised and a separate
proceeding was being initiated in that regard. It was learnt that the present
petitioner and others had deliberately constructed the said building without
permission and committed the offence, which is so imminently dangerous
that it in all probability must cause death as well as bodily injury.
Page 2 of 28

Accordingly, the Garden Reach Police Station case number 55 of 2024 dated
18.3.2024, under Section 302/307/288/427/34 of the Indian Penal Code
was registered against the present petitioner and others.
3. On completion of investigation, the investigating agency filed a charge
sheet vide charge sheet no. 66 of 2024 dated 13.6.2024 against the present
petitioner and five other persons for the commission of offences punishable
under section 302/307/288/427/34/120B of the Indian Penal Code. The
learned Magistrate took cognizance of the same and thereafter committed
the case to the Court of Sessions and it was transferred to the Court of
learned Additional District and Sessions Judge, 14th Court, Alipore for trial
and disposal. On 11.12.2024, the case was fixed for consideration of charge
and by the order impugned the learned Trial Court framed the charges
against the present petitioner and other persons under the aforesaid
sections. Being aggrieved, this revision application has been filed.
Submissions
4. Learned advocate representing the petitioner argued that the case was
started under section 302/307 of the Indian Penal Code, despite the fact
that the letter of complaint did not disclose any of the essential elements of
the said offences. No explanation was given as to why, without any enquiry
the case was registered under section 302/307 of the Indian Penal Code in a
case involving the collapse of an under-construction building. The further
stand taken by the learned advocate is that the entire material collected by
the prosecution is evident from the charge sheet that the petitioner was not
the one who was carrying the day-to-day construction work and it was being
Page 3 of 28

carried out as per the supervision and instruction of one of the accused co-
accused Sk. Ripon. The role of the co-promoter Abdul Rauf Nizami alias
Sheru also surfaced who died in the incident. It is further argued that the
various statements of witnesses recorded under section 161 of the Code,
including the statements of local persons and those who were injured in the
incident specially the statement of Sarika Begum and Sahiluddin Gazi
clearly stated that construction was being carried out by said Ripon. The
main allegation is that the petitioner purchased substandard materials and
also directed the labourers to mix the same in improper quantities.
5. The prosecution recorded statements of two of the vendors who sold
materials, but none of them stated that materials were of the said locality
and the same was accepted by the prosecution and cited the persons as
witnesses. In addition, the prosecution has failed to show the direct
involvement and liability of the petitioner as the concept of vicarious liability
is alien to criminal law and hence the petitioner cannot be held liable for
any act taken by the labour contractor or any other person regarding the
construction.
It is the contention of the learned advocate that in the present case,
there is no element of intention or knowledge, which is the essential to
establish an offence of murder. In order to establish under Section 302 or
307 of the Indian Penal Code, the prosecution must show that the petitioner
had the requisite knowledge to constitute the said offence and it is settled
principle of the law that the term knowledge in the context of criminal law
imports a degree of certainty. A mere general knowledge that there is likely
Page 4 of 28

to occur from an act will not be sufficient to bring a case under the fourth
category of Section 300. The knowledge has to be of a practical certainty and
that has to be the direct and motivating force of the act. It is evident from
the charge sheet that the petitioner did not have the requisite degree or
knowledge that on a specific date and time the building so constructed after
engaging a considerable amount of fund will collapse and 15 persons
including the Co-promoter, will be there to succumb to the accident.
Nothing can be evidenced from the charge sheet that as to why the
petitioner would intend to kill those 15 persons when admittedly, there was
no enmity between them. The learned Trial Court has attributed different
degree of knowledge to the petitioner in the head of charge as the motivating
force of the actions. No hearing on the point of charge was made on behalf of
either side and the accused persons did not get any opportunity for filing
any application as the copies of several documents which the prosecution
intends to rely on agreement and other items were not supplied to the
accused persons. The prosecution did not open its case under Section 226
of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 and the charge was framed only on
the basis of filing of a draft charge. It is an afterthought to shield the
appropriate administrative authorities, including KMC as the letter of
complaint of the case and the reference speaks about the Garden Reach
Police Station case no. 56 dated 18.3.2024 and hence this case should have
been numbered after the complaint lodged by the police authorities allegedly
being intimated about the collapse of the building.
Page 5 of 28

6. The Learned Advocate has relied upon the case of Dr. Mani Kumar
Chhetri versus State of West Bengal, CRR 1918 of 2016 dated
30.6.2017, relevant portions page 18, 23 to 25, 29 to 31, 32, 33, 34, 35, 36,
39 and 41 to substantiate that the degree of knowledge has contemplated
under section 299 of the IPC imports a degree of certainty. Further relied
upon the decision of Yuvraj Laxmilal Kanther and another vs State of
1
Mahrashtra , paragraph 12 and 14 where on analysis of the essential
element to constitute an offence of homicide it was held that in absence of
intention or sufficient degree of knowledge, the same would not lie. The
learned advocate put reliance upon the case of Bhopal gas tragedy case
2
namely Keshub Mahindra vs State of Madhya Pradesh , Uphaar
3
cinema tragedy case Sushil Ansal versus State through CBI where the
charges were framed under section 304A of the Indian penal code. On the
point of framing of charge under section 226/227 of the Code of Criminal
Procedure, the learned Advocate would reliance upon the decision of Banti
4 5
alias Guddu versus State of M.P , Sajjan Kumar vs CBI paragraph 17,
Manishaben Gajjugiri Goswami vs State of Gujarat, Criminal
Revisional Application 245 of 2021 of Gujarat High Court, para 12
6
and Dipakbhai Jagdishchandra Patel vs State of Gujarat and Anr
para 71-102 .

1
(2025) 3 SCR 502
2
(1996) Supp 6 S.C.R 285
3
(2014) 2 SCC (Cri) 717
4
2004 SCC (cri) 294
5
(2008 )11 S.C.R 669
6
(2019) 6 S.C.R 701
Page 6 of 28

7. Per Contra, it is argued on behalf of the prosecution that the allegation was
serious in nature and the entire construction was made without obtaining
any permission .The status of the petitioner was one of the promoter
/developer and it was found during investigation that he himself directed
the labour contractor to mix up the construction materials which ultimately
resulted in death of 15 innocent people .Therefore the petitioner cannot take
the stand that he had no knowledge or intention since he never thought that
a five storied building constructed without obtaining permission can be
detrimental for the residents or the neighbours at any point of time . It is
admitted that he had no requisite knowledge about the kith and kin of
construction but he along with his co-promoter indulged themselves in
proceeding with the construction without having any sanctioned building
plan. It is further submitted that the Learned Judge has rightly framed the
charge under Section 302 IPC and if in course of trial the prosecution fails
to prove the same and the court thinks it fit and proper the accused may be
convicted for lesser offence and to that extent the petitioner will not be
prejudiced if the trial continued with the charge of Section 302 IPC. On the
contrary once the court framed the charge for committing lessor offence and
the trial proceeded even if the ingredients for commission of much graver
offence is established the court will face difficulty in passing the order of
conviction .In this regard relied upon the decision of the Hon’ble Supreme
7
Court Rafiq Ahmed alias Rafi vs State of Uttar Pradesh paragraph
34,35,36,41,43,53,54,55. It is further argued that the decisions relied upon
by the learned Counsel of the petitioner are mostly against an order refusing

7
(2011) 8 SCC 300
Page 7 of 28

to discharge the petitioner or assailing an order of conviction and are
factually distinguishable. Accordingly prayed for dismissal of this revisional
application.
Analysis
8. Heard the submissions of the learned Advocates. The revisional application
has been filed against an order whereby the charge has been framed against
the present petitioner under section 302/307/120B IPC . The contention of
the learned Advocate of the petitioner as can be gathered from the
arguments made before the Court that the charge framed was without giving
any opportunity of hearing to the petitioner and on the basis of the draft
charge submitted before the court the charge was framed against the
petitioner under section 302/307 Penal Code when the ingredients to
attract the said offences are absolutely missing and if the trial is allowed to
be continued on the basis of this charge and the petitioner is being
convicted for any other offences for which no charge has been framed, he
will be highly prejudiced since he will not get any opportunity to make out
his case with regard to the commission of the said offence.
9.
On perusal of the complaint lodged the factual matrix disclose that the
petitioner was the financer of the construction and the day-to-day affairs of
the building development were being exclusively, looked after by Abdul Rauf
Nizami alias Sheru who died on spot. The written complaint lodged before
the officer-in-charge Garden reach Police Station disclose that a five storied
under construction building collapsed and several people were trapped
under the debris and also the tile shed single stored rooms situated nearby
Page 8 of 28

that building were damaged severely. On examination of local people, it
could be gathered that the premises was a one storied tiles shaded house
and the building which was under construction was a five storied building.
The landlord of the said building were Pappu, Raza, Naseem and it was
developed by one local promoter, namely Md. Wasim @Wassi ,the petitioner
herein . The construction started from December 2022 on a land measuring
about 3 cottah for which an agreement was made between the landlord and
the promoters. It further transpires that after the officials of the Kolkata
Municipal Corporation Authority who arrived at the spot it was revealed
that no permission was taken from the concerned Authority for
construction of the said building. The building was constructed with four 2
BHK flats in each floor measuring about 500 square ft. On 17.3.2024 in the
night about 23:30 hours, the local people heard a huge sound due to
collapse of the entire building. During investigation, the team of experts
from Jadavpur University from the department of civil engineering,
Department of construction, Engineering and Department of architecture
also visited the place and examined the samples of debris materials, iron,
rods, etc, and the interim report suggested that the quality of hard concrete
appears to be doubtful due to poor category range. The column dimensions
were less than the minimum recommended by IS code. The steel samples
collected from the site are not up to the mark in terms of yield and ultimate
strength. However at the time of submission of charge sheet the final report
was not received and also the report from National Test House Salt Lake was
pending.
Page 9 of 28

It was also found that the present petitioner is a history sheeter and was
convicted for commission of offences under section 395/397 IPC and
25(1B)(a) Arms Act and served an imprisonment for nine years. He is also an
accused in two other cases related to Arms Act, E.A Act and other provisions
of Indian Penal Code.
10. With regard to the decisions relied upon by the petitioner on the point of
framing of charge under Section 226/227 of the Code of Criminal Procedure
it is seen that in the case of Banti @ Guddu vs State of MP (Supra) when
the complainant heard the sound of altercation and found Banti and
accused assaulting the deceased with knives and with intention to kill on
his face, chest, stomach, and thigh, the deceased fell down after crying and
become senseless. The accused persons thereafter ran away. The charges
were framed under Section 302/34 IPC and the trial commenced. The
learned Trial Court found the accused persons guilty and convicted for
commission of offence punishment under section 302 of the Indian penal
code followed by an appeal which was not interfered, and the Appeal was
dismissed. The matter went upto Supreme Court and in this case the
Hon’ble Supreme Court observed in paragraph 12 that;
“12. In trials before a Court of Sessions, the
prosecution shall be “conducted by a public
prosecutor”. Section 226 of the Code of Criminal
Procedure, 1973 enjoins on him to open up his
case by describing the charge brought against
accused. He has to state what evidence he
proposes to adduce for proving the guilt of the
accused. If he knew at that stage itself that
Page 10 of 28

certain persons cited by the investigating agency
as witnesses might not support the prosecution
case, he is at liberty to state before the court that
fact. Alternatively, he can wait further and
obtain direct information about the version which
any particular witness might speak in Court. If
that version is not in support of the prosecution
case, it would be unreasonable to insist on the
public prosecutor to examine those persons as
witnesses for prosecution.”
In the said case, the observation came with regard to the plea regarding
non-examination of certain persons who were stated to be present, which is
absolutely different in the instant case when the charge has only been
framed by the learned court.
11 . In the case of Sajjan Kumar (Supra) the observation made while
considering discharge petition/framing of charge filed under section 227
CrPC and under section 228 CrPC and in paragraph 17 discussed the
parameters to exercise of jurisdiction under Sections 227 & 228 of Cr.P.C
and held;
“17. Exercise of jurisdiction under Sections 227 &
228 of Cr.P.C.
On consideration of the authorities about the scope
of Section 227 and 228 of the Code, the following
principles emerge:-
(i) The Judge while considering the question of
framing the charges under Section 227 of the Cr.P.C.
has the undoubted power to sift and weigh the
Page 11 of 28

evidence for the limited purpose of finding out
whether or not a prima facie case against the
accused has been made out. The test to determine
prima facie case would depend upon the facts of
each case.
ii) Where the materials placed before the Court
disclose grave suspicion against the accused which
has not been properly explained, the Court will be
fully justified in framing a charge and proceeding
with the trial.
iii) The Court cannot act merely as a Post Office or a
mouthpiece of the prosecution but has to consider
the broad probabilities of the case, the total effect of
the evidence and the documents produced before the
Court, any basic infirmities etc. However, at this
stage, there cannot be a roving enquiry into the pros
and cons of the matter and weigh the evidence as if
he was conducting a trial.
iv) If on the basis of the material on record, the Court
could form an opinion that the accused might have
committed offence, it can frame the charge, though
for conviction the conclusion is required to be proved
beyond reasonable doubt that the accused has
committed the offence.
v) At the time of framing of the charges, the probative
value of the material on record cannot be gone into
but before framing a charge the Court must apply its
judicial mind on the material placed on record and
must be satisfied that the commission of offence by
the accused was possible.
Page 12 of 28

vi) At the stage of Sections 227 and 228, the Court is
required to evaluate the material and documents on
record with a view to find out if the facts emerging
therefrom taken at their face value discloses the
existence of all the ingredients constituting the
alleged offence. For this limited purpose, sift the
evidence as it cannot be expected even at that initial
stage to accept all that the prosecution states as
gospel truth even if it is opposed to common sense or
the broad probabilities of the case.
vii) If two views are possible and one of them gives
rise to suspicion only, as distinguished from grave
suspicion, the trial Judge will be empowered to
discharge the accused and at this stage, he is not to
see whether the trial will end in conviction or
acquittal. In case the charge was printed against the
appellant for the office punishable under various
sections of Indian penal code including 302 IPC. The
honourable Supreme Court after discussing several
factors were aware of the view that it cannot be
concluded that framing of charge by the trial is
either bad in law or abuse of the process of law or
without any material. Moreover no application for
discharge has been filed in the instant case.”
12. In the case of Manishaben Gajjugiri Goswami (supra) after considering
various decisions , the Hon’ble Supreme Court was the view that it is clear
that Sessions Court has to begin with the opening of the case by the
prosecution and then followed by argument on behalf of prosecution
accused culminating in passing order provided under section 227 or 228 of
the Cr.P.C either to discharge or to pass order of framing charge. In the said
Page 13 of 28

case, the matter filed challenging the order of framing of charge. The main
grievance of the applicant was that the learned session judge framed the
charge without hearing the accused and there is apparent non-compliance
of provision of section 226& 227 of Cr.P.C which transpires that the
appellant made a written request to the learned Sessions Judge to comply
with the provisions of Section 226 of Cr.P.C. so that the appellant can avail
provision of section 227 of Cr.P.C. to file discharge application. It was
observed by taking a note of the decision of the Hon’ble Supreme Court in
8
Amit Kapoor versus Ramesh Chander and another that-
“ 17. Framing of a Charge is an exercise of jurisdiction
by the trial court in terms of section 228 of the Code,
unless the accused is discharged under section 227 of
the Code. Under both the provisions, the Court is required
to consider the “record of the case” and document
submitted therewith and, after hearing the parties, may
either discharge the accused or where it appears in its
opinion there is ground for presuming that accused has
committed an offence, the charge shall be framed . The
satisfaction of the court is regarding existence of
constituent of an offence and the facts leading to the
offence is a sine qua non for exercise of such jurisdiction.
It was also observed that section 227 is the expression of
a definite opinion and judgement of the court while
section 228 is tentative. To say that at the stage of
framing of charge, the Court should form an opinion that
the accused is certainly guilty of committing an offence, is
an approach which is permissible in terms of section 228
of the Code.”

8
(2012) 9 SCC 460
Page 14 of 28

13. On perusal of the judgement, also, it appears that in the order
impugned, there was no whisper that Learned Sessions Judge evaluated and
examined chargesheet papers or he looked into charge sheet papers and
without opening the case by the prosecution decided to frame the charge
under Section 228 of Cr.P.C depriving the applicant from her valuable right
under the provision of CrP.C. The learned Judge after evaluating all the
facts and circumstances and the laws laid down ,was of the view that if
direction was given to the learned Sessions Judge to hear application or to
set aside the order of framing charge will not serve the purpose as it may
consume further time and end result would be to quash order of framing
charge, which may lead to further multiplicity of litigation. Therefore, to
avoid such an expeditious hearing of sessions case involving serious offence,
the Court decided to set aside the order impugned and quashed the order
with a direction to the concerned court to direct the learned special public
prosecutor to open the case as provided under section 226 of Cr.P.C and
then to follow further procedure prescribed in section 226 to 228 Cr.PC after
hearing both the sides in accordance with law.
In the present case, it appears that the learned Court in presence of both the
Learned Advocates after considering the materials and record and the case
diary framed the charge against the accused persons, including the
petitioners and no objection was raised on behalf of the petitioner at any
point of time. Order was passed on 11.12.2024 and thereafter their present
revisional application was filed on 7th January 2025 for setting aside the
said order.
Page 15 of 28

14. In the case of Ashok Shambhubhai (Supra) also the revisional
application was filed against an order passed by the learned Special Judge
where prayer was made seeking direction against the prosecution to open
the case in terms of Section 226 of the Cr.P.C. The learned Single Judge
concurs with a view of the learned advocate that mere production of draft
charge would not suffice and satisfy the object of the provisions of section
226 of the Cr.P.C where it would be necessary for the prosecution to open
the case and to state before the court evidences, which the prosecution
propose to produce an intention to prove the guilt of the accused. It was
reiterated that-
“7.1. At ti,mes, it has been noted that prosecution
may not examine all the witnesses, who have been
cited in the charge sheet by the police. Thus, it
becomes necessary for the prosecution to open it
before the Court prior to framing of the charge by the
Court, the list of the witnesses, to indicate the
witnesses to be examined during the trial as well as
the documents to be relied upon. Court prior to
framing of charge is required to evaluate the
materials and documents and record with a view to
find out facts, which discloses the existence of all the
ingredients constituting the alleged offence. Such
procedure is not a mere formality, but is mandatory,
and the court is also required to note such
proceedings in the Rojnama . Only after following the
provision of section 226 of Cr.P.C, the accused may
exercise option of moving discharge application under
Section 227 of the Cr.PC. If not, the Court can proceed
to frame the charge under Section 228 of the Cr.P.C.”
Page 16 of 28

15. In the instant case, no such prayer was made before the court, raising
any objection regarding framing of charge and the learned court in presence
of both the learned advocates considering the materials framed the charge.
The petitioner did not file any application for discharge nor any such prayer
seeking direction against the prosecution to open the case in terms of
Section 226 of Cr.P.C . Therefore, above cases are factually distinguishable
from the instant case in hand. The points taken by the learned advocate
representing the petitioner that on the basis of a draft charge, the learned
court framed such charge do not find any legs to stand upon since no
reflection in the order against which this revisional application has been
filed that merely on the basis of draft charge the Learned court framed the
charge .On behalf of the petitioner also no application raising objection to
the same was filed immediately after the said charge was framed specially
when the Learned defence Counsel was very much present .
16. The judgement of Dr. Mani Kumar Chhatri versus state of West Bengal
(Supra) as relied upon on behalf of the petitioner ,the revisional application
was filed against the order passed by the learned Additional Sessions Judge
3rd Court Alipore , rejecting the prayer of the petitioner to discharge him
from the said case and framing charges under Section 304, Part II, Section
308 read with section 36 of the Indian Penal Code along with other various
provisions of West Bengal Fire and Emergency Services Act. Such order was
under challenge on the ground that it was a non-speaking order and does
not deal with all the issues raised by him before the trial court. The learned
Single Bench analyses the factual matrix of the case and discussed the
Page 17 of 28

differences of the ingredients punishable under section 304(II), 304A of IPC
and observed that-
“………mere possibility of knowledge that death is a
consequence of an act is inadequate to draw an
inference as to the existence of requisite knowledge
in the mind of the accused. A degree of certainty in
the awareness of the individual as to the likelihood
of death as a consequence of his act is a prerequisite
for imputation of requisite mens rea in a case of
culpable homicide. Knowledge as to likelihood of
death must be the direct and motivating force of the
act and not a mere possibility arising therefore.
Hence, every rash and negligent act causing death
would not ipso facto result in an inference as to the
existence of knowledge that the ration and negligent
act is likely to cause death.”
17. The learned Judge quashed the charges framed under Section 304(II)/308
with Section 36 of I.P.C against the petitioner and directed the Trial Court to
frame charge against the petitioner under Section 304A/337/338 read with
Section 35 and 36 of IPC. The petitioner in that case was one of the director
there and was found that there was gross negligence of the petitioner in the
matter of supervision of the affairs of the company. Similarly, in the case of
Yuvraj Laxmilal Kanther (Supra) also the appellant sought their discharge
under Section 227 Cr.P.C, which was dismissed against which the criminal
appeal was preferred before the Supreme Court. The charge was framed
under Section 304, Part II, IPC read with section 34 IPC by the learned Trial
Court and considering various judicial pronouncements the Appeal was
allowed partially. Charges framed against them under Section 304, part II,
Page 18 of 28

324, 326 and 429 IPC was quashed and set aside instead, it was directed
that appropriate Trial Court shall frame charges against the accused as
indicated in the judgement. In the case of Uphaar Cinema tragedy (Supra)
against an order of conviction the observations were made by the Hon’ble
Apex Court and in this case only the order framing charge is under
challenge .Therefore, in none of the cases as relied upon by the Learned
Advocate, the revision application was filed against an order framing charge
by the learned Trial Court only but challenged the order, refusing to allow
the prayer for discharge filed by the accused persons or against an order of
conviction. However the broad principle regarding framing of charge and the
required formalities to be complied with at the time of framing of charge is a
settled provision of law and is squarely applicable in this case also. In the
touchstone of the said settled principle also as discussed above that in the
order impugned the Learned Judge did not mechanically framed the charge
but duly consulted the material from case Diary in presence of both the
prosecution and the Learned Defence counsel.
18. Section 227 of Code of Criminal Procedure deal with discharge and reads
as follows:-
227. Discharge
“ . If, upon consideration of the
record of the case and the documents submitted
therewith, and after hearing the submissions of
the accused and the prosecution in this behalf,
the Judge considers that there is not sufficient
ground for proceeding against the accused, he
shall discharge the accused and record his
reasons for so doing.”
Page 19 of 28

It is settled proposition of law that at the stage of passing the order, the
Court has to peruse in order to find out whether or not sufficient ground
exists to proceed against the accused. If Prima facie case is made out, charge
is to be framed in terms of section 228 Cr.P.C . It is also settled that the
court did not undertake an elaborate enquiry in considering the materials
and also not necessary to delve deep into various aspects.
Section 228 Cr.P.C deals with framing of charge, which is as follows;
“228. Framing of charge.
(1) If, after such consideration and hearing as
aforesaid, the Judge is of opinion that there is
ground for presuming that the accused has
committed an offence which -
(a) is not exclusively triable by the Court of
Session, he may, frame a charge against the
accused and, by order, transfer the case for
trial to the Chief Judicial Magistrate, [or any
other Judicial Magistrate of the first class and
direct the accused to appear before the Chief
Judicial Magistrate, or, as the case may be, the
Judicial Magistrate of the first class, on such
date as he deems fit, and thereupon such
Magistrate] shall try the offence in accordance
with the procedure for the trial of warrant-cases
instituted on a police report;
(b) is exclusively triable by the Court, he
shall frame in writing a charge against the
accused.
(2) Where the Judge frames any charge under
clause (b) of sub-section (1), the charge shall be
read and explained to accused, and the accused
shall be asked whether he pleads guilty of the
offence charged or claims to be tried.”
19. In Rafiq Ahmed (supra) as relied upon by the prosecution the Trial Court
framed charges under section 396 IPC for committing dacoity and the case
was filed after an order of conviction was passed under section 302 IPC. The
Page 20 of 28

appellant was charged with offences under Section 396 and 201 IPC. It was
observed by the Hon’ble Supreme Court that fine distinction of law, if
discerning, should normally be recognised and permitted to operate in their
respective fields. With the development of criminal jurisprudence, the law
has recognised the concept of cognate charges besides alternative charges.
The differentiation between the offences from the same family in contra
distinction to the offences, falling in different categories have persuaded the
quotes to apply the principles of ‘cognate offences’ and punish the offender
for a less grave offence because the offence of greater gravity has not been
proved beyond reasonable doubt. This principle is to be applied keeping in
view of the facts and circumstances of a given case and notwithstanding the
fact that no charge for such less grave offence had been framed against the
offender. The Apex Court took note of a Constitutional Bench Judgment of
9
Willie (Willia) Slaney vs State of MP where it was held that
“45. In adjudging the question of prejudice, the fact
and absence of a charge, or a substantial mistake in it,
is a serious lacuna will naturally operate to the benefit
of the accused and if there is any reasonable and
substantial doubt about whether he was, or was
reasonably likely to have been, misled in the
circumstances of any particular case, he is as much
entitled to the benefit of it here as elsewhere.; but if,
only careful consideration of all the facts, prejudice, or
reasonable, and substantial likelihood of it, is not
disclosed the conviction must stand; also it will always
be material to consider whether objection to the nature

9
AIR 1956 SC 116
Page 21 of 28

of the charge, or a total want of one, was taken at an
early stage.
If it was not, and particularly where the accused is
defended by councel, it may in a given case be proper
to conclude that accused was satisfied and knew just
what he was being tried for and knew what was being
alleged against him and wanted to know further
particulars, provided it is always borne in mind that no
serious defect in the mood of conducting a criminal trial
can be justified or cured by the consent of the advocate
of the accused.”
20. The Hon’ble Supreme Court examined the meaning of prejudice and in
paragraph 34 discussed the principles and examine the meaning of
prejudice, which is as follows:
“34. In light of the above principles, let us now examine
the meaning of `prejudice'. The expression has been
defined in Black's Law Dictionary (Eighth Edition), as
follows:
"Prejudice,- 1. Damage or detriment to one's legal
rights or claims. See dismissal with prejudice,
dismissal without prejudice under DISMISSAL. Legal
prejudice.- A condition that, if shown by a party, will
usu. defeat the opposing party's action; esp., a
condition that, if shown by the defendant, will defeat a
plaintiff's motion to dismiss a case without prejudice.
The defendant may show that dismissal will deprive
the defendant of a substantive property right or
preclude the defendant from raising a defense that will
be unavailable or endangered in a second suit.
Page 22 of 28

Undue prejudice. The harm resulting from a fact-
trier's being exposed to evidence that is persuasive but
inadmissible (such as evidence of prior criminal
conduct) or that so arouses the emotions that calm and
logical reasoning is abandoned.
2. A preconceived judgment formed without a factual
basis; a strong bias"
21. In paragraph 43, the Supreme Court examined the kind of offences may
fall in the same category except to the extent of grave or less grave. It was
observed that-
“43…………… we have already noticed that a
person charged with heinous or grave offence can
be punished for a less grave offence of cognate
nature whose essentials are satisfied with the
evidence on record. Examples of that kind have
already been noticed by us like a charge being
framed under Section 302 IPC and the accused
being punished under Section 304 Part I or II, as
the circumstances and facts of the case may
demand. Furthermore, a person who is charged
with an offence under Section 326 IPC can be
finally convicted for an offence of laser gravity
under Section 325 or 323 IPC if the facts of the
case so established.”
The cognate offence as described in Black Law Dictionary was considered by
the Hon’ble Supreme Court and define the expression which reads as;
“Cognate offence- A lesser offence that is related to the
greater offence because it shares several of the elements
of the greater offence and is of the same class or
Page 23 of 28

category. For example, shoplifting is a cognitive offence of
larceny because both crimes require the element of taking
property with the intent to deprive the rightful owner of
that property.”
Therefore, Apex Court held that where the offences are cognate offences with
commonality in their feature, duly supported by evidence on record, the
court can always exercise its power to punish the accused for one or the
other offence provided the accuse does not suffer any prejudice. After
considering the fact and circumstances of the case held that the applicant
has not suffered any prejudice much less a serious prejudice, then the
conviction of the applicant under Section 302 IPC cannot be set aside
merely for non framing of a specific/alternate charge for an offence
punishable under Section 302 IPC. It is more so because the dimensions
and facets of an offence under Section 302 are incorporated by the specific
language and inbuilt in the offence punishable under Section 396 IPC and
dismissed the appeal.
22. In this regard, it is pertinent to take note of a recent decision of the 3
Judges Bench of Hon’ble Supreme Court in Ghulam Hasan Beigh vs
10
Mohammad Maqbool Magrey & Ors. where the Trial Court discharged
the accused persons of the offence of murder punishable under Section 302
of IPC and proceeded to frame charge against the accused persons for the
offence of culpable homicide punishable under Section 304 of the IPC. It
was observed in paragraph 30 ,that penal code recognises two kinds of
homicides i) homicide, that deals between Section 299 and 304 IPC and ii)

10
[2022] 13 S.C.R. 34; 2022 INSC 750
Page 24 of 28

non-culpable homicide, which deals with Section 304A IPC. There are two
kinds of culpable homicides; a) homicide amounting to murder Section 303
02 IPC and b) homicide not amounting to murder Section 304II IPC. This
section provides punishment for culpable homicide not amounting to
murder. In paragraph 31 it was held that:-,
“31. Whether the case falls under section 302 or 304
Part II IPC would have been decided by the trial court
only after the evaluation of the oral evidence that may
be led by the prosecution as well as by the defence, if
any, comes on record. Ultimately, upon appreciation of
the entire evidence on record at the end of the trial,
trial court may one view of the other. i;e whether it is a
case of murder for case of culpable homicide. But at
the stage of framing of the charge, the trial court could
not have reached to such a conclusion ,merely relying
upon the postmortem report on record. ….’
In paragraph 32 down, Supreme Court observed that:-
“32; we may now proceed to consider the issue on
hand from a different angle. It is a settled position of
law that in a criminal trial, the prosecution can lead
dividend only in accordance with the charge framed by
the trial court. Where a higher charge is not framed for
which there is evidence, the accused is entitled to
assume that he is called upon to defend himself only
with regard to the lesser offence for which he has been
charged. It is not necessary then for him to meet
evidence relating to the offences with which he was not
been charged. He is merely to answer the charge as.
The code does not require him to make all evidence led
by prosecution. He has only to rebut evidence bearing
Page 25 of 28

on the charge . The prosecution cases is airily Limited
by the charge. It forms the foundation of the trial which
starts with it, and the accused can justify concentrate
on meeting the subject matter of the charge against
him. He did not cross examine witnesses with regard
to offences, he is not charged with no need. He gave
any evidence in defence in respect of such charges.
33. Once the trial court decides to discharge and
accused person from the offence punishable under
section 302 of the IPC and proceeds to frame the laser
charge for the dolphin punishable under Section 304
part-II, the prosecution thereafter would not be in a
position to lead any evidence beyond the charge as
framed. To put it, otherwise, the prosecution will be
thereafter compelled to proceed as if it has now to
establish only the case of culpable homicide and not
murder. On the other hand, even if the trial court
proceeds to frame charge under Section 302 IPC in
accordance with the case put up by the prosecution
still, it would be open for the accused to persuade the
court at the end of the trial that the case falls only
within the ambit of culpable homicide punishable
under section 304 of IPC. In such circumstances, in the
facts of the present case, it would be more prudent to
permit the prosecution to lead appropriate evidence.
Whatever it is worth in accordance with its original
case at put up in the charge-sheet. Such approach of
the trial court at times may prove to be more rationale
and prudent.”
The Hon’ble Supreme Court allowed the Appeal and set aside the order passed
by the learned Trial Court. Direction was given to the Trial Court to proceed
Page 26 of 28

to pass a fresh order framing charge in accordance with keeping in mind the
observations made by the Hon’ble Court .
Conclusions
23. Therefore, in light of the foregoing discussion of the law laid down by the
Hon’ble Supreme Court as well as various High Courts with regard to the
framing of charges in respect of commission of offence against an accused
person and the prejudice likely to be caused to the accused person by
reason of non-framing of an appropriate charge, this Court proposes to visit
to the factual matrix of the present case and of the role attributed to the
petitioner in the instant case be revisit once again. It is a specific case of the
prosecution that the petitioner was the developer along with the co-promoter
and a five storied building was constructed without obtaining any
sanctioned plan from competent authority. The charge sheet further
contains specific allegation against the present petitioner regarding use of
inferior quality of materials. In particular, statements have been recorded
indicating that the petitioner instructed the labourers engaged in the
construction to mix the ingredients of construction materials
disproportionate quantities and to use of inferior qualities materials while
raising the columns of the building. More importantly, the petitioner despite
possessing no requisite technical qualifications actively involved himself in
the construction of the building, which ultimately collapsed, resulting in
death 15 persons and injuries to several others. The prosecution has also
brought to the fore, the petitioner’s alleged criminal antecedents, including
antecedent relating to commission of offence of murder. In view of the
Page 27 of 28

statutory provisions and the principles of law discussed hereinabove, this
Court is of the considered view that if at this threshold stage, charge is
altered and a charge for substantially lesser offence is framed there would
hardly remain any scope for the prosecution to proceed effectively with the
trial in respect of the gravity of the allegation and the role attributed to the
petitioner, even if later found some ingredients against the petitioner for
commission of grave offence. On the contrary, the petitioner cannot be said
to have suffered any prejudice, since the charge has been framed in respect
of an offence carrying the maximum punishment.
24. The Court shall, therefore, have the liberty to determine the culpability of
the petitioner and the ultimate of the case upon proper appreciation of the
evidences to be adduced in course of trial. In such circumstances, this
Court does not find any reason to interfere with the impugned order.
25 . Accordingly, this revisional application stands dismissed.
26 . No orders as to cost.
27. All other connected applications, if any, hereby stand disposed of.
28. Urgent Photostat certified copies of this order, if applied for, be supplied to
the parties upon compliance of all necessary formalities.


[CHAITALI CHATTERJEE (DAS), J.]
Page 28 of 28