Maragadham vs Periyaraja
- Court
- Supreme Court
Non-reportable
IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA
CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION
2026 INSC 757
Civil Appeal No. 12190 of 2025
Maragadham …Appellant
versus
Periyaraja and others …Respondents
J U D G M E N T
SANJAY KUMAR, J
1. Successful before the Trial Court, the appellant-plaintiff failed in
appeal before the First Appellate Court and, thereafter, in second appeal
before the Madras High Court. Ergo, she is before us.
2. Parties shall, hereinafter, be referred to as arrayed in the suit.
3. Original Suit No. 697 of 1996 was filed by Maragadham, the plaintiff,
before the District Munsiff, Tirupattur, seeking declaration of her title;
recovery of possession; and consequential reliefs in relation to certain
extents of land in different survey numbers of Mallapalli Village, Tirupattur
Taluk, Vellore District. She asserted title over the suit properties under the
registered gift settlement deed, bearing Document No. 871 of 1990, dated
13.12.1990 executed in her favour by her grandfather, Kuttiyappa
Signature Not Verified
Digitally signed by
Deepak Guglani
Date: 2026.07.29
13:40:57 IST
Reason:
Goundar, defendant No. 1. She claimed that she was put in possession
thereof but was divested of the same by defendant Nos. 1 to 4 in the year
1995. She alleged that defendant Nos. 1 to 4 then inducted Nandimalai,
defendant No. 5, into possession to cultivate the suit lands. She asserted
that the defendants failed to handover possession of the property to her
despite her entreaties and, accordingly, instituted the suit seeking the
reliefs as aforestated.
Her claims were contested by Periyaraja and Muniammal,
4.
defendant Nos. 2 and 3, and their son, Vijayakumar, defendant No.4.
Muniammal, defendant No.3, is none other than the daughter of
Kuttiyappa Goundar, defendant No.1, through his first wife, Muniyammal.
It was her case that her father, defendant No.1, had no rights over the suit
properties and, therefore, the gift deed executed by him did not bind her.
She also denied that possession was delivered to the plaintiff pursuant to
the said gift deed. She asserted that the suit properties belonged to her
mother, Muniyammal, by virtue of the sale deed dated 05.01.1949 and the
gift settlement deed dated 03.01.1949, executed in her favour by her
father, Ammakara Goundar. She stated that her mother died about 20
years prior to the institution of the suit and after her death, the property
was in her possession and enjoyment. Kuttiyappa Goundar, defendant
No. 1, and Nandimalai, defendant No. 5, did not enter appearance before
the Trial Court and were set ex parte .
5. The Trial Court framed nine issues for consideration. The plaintiff
examined herself as PW1 and examined her grandfather, Kuttiyappa
2
Goundar, as PW2. Gaundappan, one of the sons of Kuttiyappa Goundar,
was examined by her as PW3. Exhibits A1 and A2 were marked by her.
Exhibit A1 was a copy of the gift deed dated 13.12.1990 while Exhibit A2
was its original. DWs 1 and 2 were examined by the defendants.
Muniammal, defendant No. 3, was examined as DW1. Exhibits B1 to B10
were marked on their behalf in evidence.
The Trial Court decreed the suit by its judgment dated 13.04.2006.
6.
Therein, opining that the suit properties devolved upon Kuttiyappa
Goundar, defendant No. 1, upon the death of his wife, Muniyammal, and
became his exclusive properties, the Trial Court held that he, thereupon,
had absolute right to gift the same to his granddaughter to the exclusion
of his other heirs.
7. Assailing the judgment and decree of the Trial Court, defendant Nos.
2 to 4 filed AS No. 77 of 2006 before the learned Sub Judge, Tirupattur,
Vellore District. The First Appellate Court reversed the judgment and
decree of the Trial Court by its judgment dated 16.04.2007. The First
Appellate Court was of the opinion that, upon the death of Muniyammal,
her properties devolved upon her husband, Kuttiyappa Goundar, and her
daughter, Muniammal, in equal shares under the provisions of the Hindu
1
Succession Act, 1956 , and having only a half share in those properties,
Kuttiyappa Goundar did not have the right to execute a gift deed in respect
1
For short, ‘the Act of 1956’
3
of the entire extent of the suit properties in favour of his granddaughter.
The First Appellate Court was, therefore, of the opinion that the said gift
deed was void and could not be acted upon. The Court further found that
the recital therein to the effect that possession had been delivered
pursuant thereto was also not borne out on facts. Holding so, the First
Appellate Court non suited the plaintiff. It was, however, left open to
Kuttiyappa Goundar, who had a half share in the suit properties, to claim
his rights by way of a separate suit.
8. Aggrieved by this turn of events, the plaintiff filed Second Appeal
No. 1393 of 2007 before the Madras High Court. A learned Judge framed
two substantial questions of law therein, viz., whether the First Appellate
Court was justified in drawing an adverse inference by reason of the fact
that Kuttiyappa Goundar, defendant No.1, was examined as PW2; and
whether the Courts below ought to have appreciated that, in a suit for
declaration, the lesser relief of partition could be granted under Order VII
Rule 7 of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 (CPC).
However, by judgment dated 09.06.2015, the Second Appeal was
9.
dismissed. Therein, a learned Judge answered both questions of law
against the plaintiff and in favour of the defendants. The learned Judge
concurred with the view taken by the First Appellate Court that, upon the
death of Muniyammal, her husband, Kuttiyappa Goundar, and her
daughter, Muniammal, jointly succeeded to her properties under Section
4
15 of the Act of 1956. The learned Judge was also in agreement with the
view that, without the concurrence of Muniammal, the co-sharer,
Kuttiyappa Goundar could not have gifted even his half share in the suit
properties in favour of the plaintiff. As he had executed the gift deed dated
13.12.1990 in relation to the entire suit properties and as consent had not
been taken from Muniammal, the co-sharer, the learned Judge affirmed
the views of the First Appellate Court.
10. We may now note the admitted factual position. Kuttiyappa Goundar
was married to Muniyammal and they had only one daughter, named
Muniammal. The suit properties belonged to Muniyammal, having come
to her from her father, Ammakara Goundar. Muniyammal died after the Act
of 1956 came into effect. It is not clear whether Kuttiyappa Goundar
remarried or only had a relationship with one Muthammal. It is, however,
an admitted fact that she had one son and five daughters with Kuttiyappa
Goundar. Muniammal, defendant No. 3, also admits this in her deposition
before the Trial Court. It is not proved in absolute terms that Muthammal
was married earlier to one Venkitachalam and had a son through that
marriage, but the oral evidence hints to that effect. Gaundappan (PW3)
spoke of the plaintiff, Maragadham, being the daughter of his elder
brother. The inference that can be drawn therefrom is that Raja @
Munusamy, the father of Maragadham, the plaintiff, must have been the
son of Muthammal with Venkitachalam, as it is an admitted fact that only
5
one son, apart from five daughters, were born to Kuttiyappa Goundar and
Muthammal. Therefore, the status of Maragadham as Kuttiyappa
Goundar’s own granddaughter is open to question.
11. However, the same does not have any impact on the validity of the
gift deed dated 13.12.1990 executed by Kuttiyappa Goundar in favour of
Maragadham. The First Appellate Court and the High Court rightly held
that the properties of Muniyammal, who admittedly died intestate, would
devolve under Section 15(1)(a) of the Act of 1956 upon her only daughter
and her husband in equal shares. Be it noted that this undivided half share
in the hands of Kuttiyappa Goundar did not partake the character of
‘coparcenary property’ and belonged to him absolutely. He, therefore, had
every right in law to gift or alienate the same to anyone, including a total
stranger. There was no need for him to take the consent of the co-owner,
Muniammal, before parting with his undivided half share in the suit
properties. The issue of such consent being obtained may have arisen
had the property been coparcenary property, but not when the undivided
half share was the absolute property of Kuttiyappa Goundar.
12. That being said, the fact remains that the properties remained joint
and without partition by metes and bounds, the plaintiff could not have
sought the relief of recovery of possession of that half share. Further, be
it noted that her suit claim was that she was the absolute owner of the
entire suit properties under the registered gift deed dated 13.12.1990 and
6
that she was put in possession. Her claim of ownership over the entire suit
properties is not valid and tenable in law and her claim of being put in
possession was not established on facts. In that regard, we may note that
Order VII Rule 7 CPC authorizes the Court to grant a smaller relief than
the larger relief claimed, if entitlement therefor is made out on facts.
However, such discretion would not be available when a plaintiff sets up
an altogether different case from the one ultimately found established on
facts and in law by the Court. Presently, contrary to the plaintiff’s claim of
ownership over the suit properties in their entirety, we find that she has a
right only over an undivided half share in the suit properties and no more.
Without division of the property by metes and bounds, the question of the
right of the plaintiff crystallising would not arise. However, as she sought
declaration of title under the registered gift deed dated 13.12.1990, she
would be entitled to such declaration only in respect of an undivided half
share in the suit properties thereunder. She would necessarily have to
seek partition of the suit properties by metes and bounds to actually claim
her separate half share. Such relief of partition cannot be granted at this
stage as the same is entirely alien to her suit claims. We, accordingly,
leave it open to the plaintiff to take recourse to such measure by way of
appropriate proceedings before the competent forum in accordance with
law. However, as her right to a half share in the suit properties already
stands decided and only the crystallisation of that right on the ground
7
remains to be determined by way of partition of the suit properties by
metes and bounds, we would request the jurisdictional Court that
entertains the plaintiff’s suit for partition to decide the same as
expeditiously as possible.
The appeal is, accordingly, allowed in part as indicated hereinabove
13.
and the judgments and decrees of the Courts below, to the extent they
hold otherwise, are set aside. Decree to be drawn up accordingly.
.
The parties shall bear their own costs
……………………...,J.
[SANJAY KUMAR]
.……………………...,J.
[SANJEEV SACHDEVA]
New Delhi;
July 29, 2026.
8