G DAMODAR vs KARNATAKA STATE ROAD TRANSPORT CORPORATION

Court
Karnataka High Court

- 1 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:64475
WP No. 35467 of 2025
C/W WP No. 10460 of 2022
WP No. 13395 of 2022
AND 3 OTHERS


CNR: KAHC010762852025




IN THE HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA AT BENGALURU

TH
DATED THIS THE 18 DAY OF NOVEMBER, 2026

®

BEFORE

THE HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE SURAJ GOVINDARAJ

WRIT PETITION NO. 35467 OF 2025 (GM-RES)

C/W

WRIT PETITION NO. 10460 OF 2022 (GM-RES)

WRIT PETITION NO. 13395 OF 2022 (GM-RES)

WRIT PETITION NO. 20426 OF 2022 (GM-RES)

WRIT PETITION NO. 7641 OF 2023 (S-KSRTC)


WRIT PETITION NO. 27997 OF 2023 (GM-RES)



IN W.P.NO.35467/2025
BETWEEN

KSMZ PROPERTIES PRIVATE LIMITED
TH
NO.350, 12 'A' CROSS
ST
OFF. DOUBLE ROAD, 1 STAGE,
INDIRANAGARA
BENGALURU-560038.
REPRESENTED BY ITS DIRECTOR
KHADIJA NIYAS
AGED ABOUT 47 YEARS
D/O KADER ELLIKKA
... PETITIONER

(BY SRI. P.N. HARISH., ADVOCATE)


AND

1. DIVISIONAL CONTROLLER

KARNATAKA STATE ROAD TRANSPORT
CORPORATION (KSRTC)




Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
20/11/2026, 13:32, Bengaluru
Verified

- 2 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:64475
WP No. 35467 of 2025
C/W WP No. 10460 of 2022
WP No. 13395 of 2022
AND 3 OTHERS


CNR: KAHC010762852025


SHIVAMOGGA DIVISION,
TRAFFIC SECTION,
KSRTC BUS STAND, O.T. ROAD,
SHIVAMOGGA-577 202.

2. KARNATAKA STATE ROAD
TRANSPORT CORPORATION (KSRTC)
CENTRAL OFFICE, NO.27, K.H. ROAD
SHANTHINAGAR
BENGALURU-560 027.
BY ITS MANAGING DIRECTOR

3. KARNATAKA STATE ROAD TRANSPORT
CORPORATION (KSRTC)
CENTRAL OFFICE, NO.27, K.H. ROAD
SHANTHINAGAR
BENGALURU-560 027.
TRAFFIC (COMMERCIAL)
BY ITS CHIEF TRAFFIC MANAGER
…. RESPONDENTS

(BY SMT. H.R. RENUKA., ADVOCATE FOR R1 TO R3)

THIS WRIT PETITION IS FILED UNDER ARTICLES 226 AND 227
OF THE CONSTITUTION OF INDIA PRAYING TO ISSUE A WRIT IN THE
NATURE OF CERTIORARI AND QUASH THE NOTICE DATED
18.08.2025 IN NO.KST/SMG/TR/COM/1249/2025-26 PRODUCED AS
ANNEXURE-E TO THE WRIT PETITION AND SO ALSO
CONSEQUENTIAL DEMAND NOTICES DATED 01.09.2025 IN
NO.KST/SMG/TR/COM/1368/2025-26 PRODUCED AS ANNEXURE-E1
TO THE WRIT PETITION AND DEMAND NOTICE DATED 16.10.2025 IN
NO.KST/SMG/TR/COM/1812/ 2025-26 PRODUCED ANNEXURE-E2 TO
THE WRIT PETITION WHICH ARE ISSUED BY THE FIRST
RESPONDENT AND ETC.

IN W.P.NO.10460/2022
BETWEEN

1 . SRI JAYARAMA N SHETTY
S/O LT NARASIMHA MURTHY
AGED 54 YEARS
R/AT MANDIRA NILAYA
SHIVAMOGA ROAD
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
20/11/2026, 13:32, Bengaluru
Verified

- 3 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:64475
WP No. 35467 of 2025
C/W WP No. 10460 of 2022
WP No. 13395 of 2022
AND 3 OTHERS


CNR: KAHC010762852025


A BLOCK 4368
VIDYA NAGAR
OPP TO BALAJI RICE MILL
HARIHARA TOWN
DAVANAGERE DIST 577601
2 . SRI K GANESH
S/O LT SHANAKRA NARAYANA
AGED 55 YEARS
R/AT NO 3419
JOGIMATTI ROAD
CHITRADURGA DIST 577501
3 . SRI K A VENAKATESH PURANIK
S/O LT K VANANTHA KRISHNA PURANIK
AGED 46 YEARS
R/AT NO T-2
V N RESIDENCY
DOCTORS LAYOUT
CHIKKALSANDRA
BENGALURU DIST 560061
4 . SMT LAKSHMI VYASA RAJ
W/O K S VYASARA RAJ
AGED 50 YEARS
R/AT NO 3682/104-4
RD
3 CROSS ND VANI RICE MIL
TARALABALU LAYOUT
DAVANAGERE TOWN
DAVANAGERE DIST 577005
5 . SRI C N THYAGARAJA
S/O NINGEGOWDA
AGED 45 YEARS
R/AT 4, CHALLENAHALLI
CHIKKODU
BELUR TQ
HASSAN DIST 573115
6 . MAHESH SHETTY
S/O MAHABALA SHETTY
AGED 42 YEARS
R/AT HOTEL UDUPI URAPHARA
JPN ROAD
SHIVAMOGA DIST 577201
7 . SRI K S SHIVAMURTHY
S/O SURESHCHARI
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
20/11/2026, 13:32, Bengaluru
Verified

- 4 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:64475
WP No. 35467 of 2025
C/W WP No. 10460 of 2022
WP No. 13395 of 2022
AND 3 OTHERS


CNR: KAHC010762852025


AGED 38 YEARS
R/AT THRITHAHALLI
SHIVAMOGGA DIT 577432

... PETITIONERS

(BY SRI. SOMASHEKHARAIAH R.P. ADVOCATE)


AND

1. THE STATE OF KARNATAKA
DEPARTMENT OF TRASNPORT
M S BUILDDING
BENGALURU 560001
REP BY SECRETARY
2. THE MANAGING DIRECTOR
KARNATAKA STATE ROAD
TRANSPORT CORPORATIN
CENTRAL OFFICE
SHANTHI NAGAR
BENGALURU 560027

3. THE DIRECTOR
SECURITY AND VIGILENCE
DEPARTMENT
KARNATAKA STATE ROAD
TRANSPORT CORPORATION
CENTRAL OFFICE
SHANTHI NAGAR
BENGALURU 560027
4. THE CHIEF TRAFFIC MANAGER (COM)
KARNATAKA STATE ROAD
TRANSPORT CORPORATION
CENTRAL OFFICE
SHANTHI NAGAR
BENGALURU 560027
5. THE DIVISONAL CONTROLLER
KARNATAKA STATE ROAD
TRANSPORT CORPORATION
CENTRAL OFFICE
SHANTHI NAGAR
BENGALURU 560027
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
20/11/2026, 13:32, Bengaluru
Verified

- 5 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:64475
WP No. 35467 of 2025
C/W WP No. 10460 of 2022
WP No. 13395 of 2022
AND 3 OTHERS


CNR: KAHC010762852025


…. RESPONDENTS

(BY SRI. MOHAMMED JAFAR SHAH., AGA FOR R1;
SRI. P.D. SURANA., ADVOCATE FOR R2 TO R5)

THIS WRIT PETITION IS FILED UNDER ARTICLES 226 AND 227
OF THE CONSTITUTION OF INDIA PRAYING TO QUASH THE LETTER
DTD.6.4.2022 ISSUED BY THE R-2 VIDE ANNEXURE-D AND THE
NOTICE ISSUE DBY R-5 UNDER ANNEXURE-C, C1, C6 TO C6 AND
ETC.

IN W.P.NO.13395/2022
BETWEEN

1. SRI K GANESH
S/O LATE SHANKARA NARAYANA,
AGED ABOUT 55 YEARS,
R/AT NO.3419,
JOGIMATTI ROAD,
CHITRADURGA DISTRICT 577501.
2. SMT SUMITHRA K
W/O GANESH K,
AGED ABOUT 49 YEARS,
R/AT NO.3419,
JOGIMATTI ROAD,
CHITRADURGA DISTRICT 577501.
3. SRI ABHISHEK K G
S/O GURUMURTHY K K,
AGED ABOUT 30 YEARS,
R/AT NO.THANKAKA BYLU VILLAGE,
THANGINA KOPPA POST,
THIRTHAHALLI TALUK,
SHIVAMOGGA DISTRICT 577414.
4. SRI MANJUNATH T
S/O THIPPE SWAMY,
AGED ABOUT 42 YEARS,
R/AT SURENAHALLI,
MUDDAPURA,
CHITRADURGA TQ AND DISTRICT
577501.
5. SRI SAMPATH KUMAR C
S/O CHIKKAPPA,
AGED ABOUT 45 YEARS,
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
20/11/2026, 13:32, Bengaluru
Verified

- 6 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:64475
WP No. 35467 of 2025
C/W WP No. 10460 of 2022
WP No. 13395 of 2022
AND 3 OTHERS


CNR: KAHC010762852025


R/AT THAGARANAHATTI,
CHITRADURGA TQ AND DISTRICT
577501.
6. SRI SHOBHARAJ P
S/O PRAKASH,
AGED ABOUT 24 YEARS,
R/AT NO.3, BOMMANAHALLI VILLAGE,
NEAR GOVT. SCHOOL,
CHITRADURGA TQ AND DISTRICT
577501.
7. SRI HARISH C
S/O CHANDRAPPA,
AGED ABOUT 38 YEARS,
R/AT NO.82, NAYAKANAHATTI,
THAGARANAHATTI,
SIDDAPURA,
CHITRADURGA TQ AND DISTRICT
577501.
8. SRI SHIVAPPA M
S/O MANJAPPA GODABANA HALLI,
AGED ABOUT 40 YEARS,
R/AT CHITRADURGA TOWN,
CHITRADURGA TQ AND DISTRICT.
9. SRI SRINIVASA
S/O KARIYAPPA,
AGED ABOUT 35 YEARS,
R/AT NO.82, NAYAKANAHATTI,
THAGARANAHATTI,
SIDDAPURA,
CHITRADURGA TQ AND DISTRICT
577501.
10.SRI CHANDRASHEKHARAIAH SHETTY
S/O NARASIMHA SHETTY,
AGED ABOUT 56 YEARS,
GOPALAPURA ROAD,
CHITRADURGA TQ AND DISTRICT
577501.

... PETITIONERS

(BY SRI. SOMASHEKHARAIAH R.P., ADVOCATE)


Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
20/11/2026, 13:32, Bengaluru
Verified

- 7 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:64475
WP No. 35467 of 2025
C/W WP No. 10460 of 2022
WP No. 13395 of 2022
AND 3 OTHERS


CNR: KAHC010762852025


AND

1. THE STATE OF KARNATAKA
DEPARTMENT OF TRANSPORT,
M.S.BUILDING,
BENGALURU-560001
REPRESENTED BY ITS SECRETARY.
2. THE MANAGING DIRECTOR
KARNATAKA STATE ROAD TRANSPORT
CORPORATION,
CENTRAL OFFICE,
SHANTHI NAGAR,
BENGALURU-560027.
3. THE DIRECTOR
SECURITY AND VIGILANCE DEPARTMENT,
KARNATAKA STATE ROAD TRANSPORT
CORPORATION,
CENTRAL OFFICE,
SHANTHI NAGAR,
BENGALURU-560027.
4. THE CHIEF TRAFFIC MANAGER (COM.)
KARNATAKA STATE ROAD TRANSPORT
CORPORATION,
CENTRAL OFFICE,
SHANTHI NAGAR,
BENGALURU 560027.
5. THE DIVISIONAL CONTROLLER
KARNATAKA STATE ROAD TRANSPORT
CORPORATION,
CHITRADURGA DIVISION,
CHITRADURGA
CHITRADURGA DISTRICT 577501.

…. RESPONDENTS

(BY SRI. MOHAMMED JAFAR SHAH., AGA FOR R1;
SRI. P.D. SURANA ADVOCATE FOR R2 TO R5)

THIS WRIT PETITION IS FILED UNDER ARTICLES 226 AND 227
OF THE CONSTITUTION OF INDIA PRAYING TO QUASH THE LETTER
DTD 06.04.2022 IN NO. KARASA.KEKA.SAM.VAA-1.22.2022-23
ISSUED BY THE R-2 VIDE ANNX-D AND THE NOTICE DTD 10.05.2022
ISSUED BY R-5 UNDER ANNEXURE-C, C1 TO C13 AND ETC.
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
20/11/2026, 13:32, Bengaluru
Verified

- 8 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:64475
WP No. 35467 of 2025
C/W WP No. 10460 of 2022
WP No. 13395 of 2022
AND 3 OTHERS


CNR: KAHC010762852025



IN W.P.NO.20426/2022
BETWEEN

1. G DAMODAR
SON OF GOPAL G
AGED ABOUT 38 YEARS
TH
NO.29 13 CROSS
KRISHNANANDANAGAR
ND
NAGARABHAVI 2 STAGE
MALAGALA
VISWANEEDAM
BANGALORE-560091.

ALSO AT SHOP NO.1 TERMINAL -2A
KSRTC BUS TERMINAL
SUBASH NAGAR
BANGALORE-9.

2. V VISHWANATHA NAVADA
SON OF SURYANARAYANA NAVADA
AGED ABOUT 55 YEARS
ND
NO.2890/A 2 FLOOR
TH
14 MAIN ROAD
E BLOCK
ND
RAJAJINAGAR 2 STAGE
BANGALORE-560010

ALSO AT SHOP NO.125
KSRTC BUS TERMINAL-1
SUBASH NAGAR
BANGALORE-560009.
3. PRASAD U H
SON OF HOOVIAH
AGED ABOUT 42 YEARS
NO. U.T.U.-13 BELLICHUKKIMANE
ST
1 MAIN ROAD
GANESH BLOCK
SHESHADRIPURAM
BANGALORE-560020.

ALSO AT HOTEL SHOP NO.10
TERMINAL-2A
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
20/11/2026, 13:32, Bengaluru
Verified

- 9 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:64475
WP No. 35467 of 2025
C/W WP No. 10460 of 2022
WP No. 13395 of 2022
AND 3 OTHERS


CNR: KAHC010762852025


KSRTC BUS TERMINAL
SUBASH NAGAR
BANGALORE-560009.
4. SRI CHANNAPPA
SON OF CHANDRAPPA
AGED ABOUT 40 YEARS
BANKANAHALLI
BEVAKAL
MANDYA-571405.

ALSO AT SHOP NO.23
KSRTC BUS TERMINAL-1
SUBASH NAGAR
BANGALORE-560009.
5. N SATHYANARAYANA
SON OF R NAGARAJU
AGED ABOUT 40 YEARS
ST
NO.51A, 116/3 1 MAIN ROAD
WEST OF CHORD ROAD
MAHAGANAPATHINAGAR
TH
6 PHASE
BANGALORE NORTH
RAJAJINAGAR
BANGALORE-560010.

ALSO AT SHOP NO.28
KSRTC BUS TERMINAL-1
SUBASH NAGAR
BANGALORE-560009.
6. NATARAJA G V
SON OF VENKATAPPA
AGED ABOUT 58 YEARS
NO.21-B 1ST FLOOR
7TH MAIN ROAD
4TH BLOCK
RAJAJINAGAR
BANGALORE-560010.

ALSO AT SHOP NO.78 AND 112
KSRTC BUS TERMINAL-1
SUBASH NAGAR
BANGALORE-560009.
7. MOHAN D S
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
20/11/2026, 13:32, Bengaluru
Verified

- 10 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:64475
WP No. 35467 of 2025
C/W WP No. 10460 of 2022
WP No. 13395 of 2022
AND 3 OTHERS


CNR: KAHC010762852025


SON OF SHIVEGOWDA
AGED ABOUT 42 YEARS
KARTHIK NILAYA
RD
3 CROSS
VASANTHAPURA MAIN ROAD
KONANAKUNTE CROSS
DODDAKALLASANDRA
BANGALORE-560062.


ALSO AT SHOP NO.111
TERMINAL-2
KSRTC BUS TERMINAL
SUBASH NAGAR
BANGALORE-560009.
8. SHANKAR C
SON OF CHALUVAIAH
AGED ABOUT 36 YEARS
BANAKANAHALLI, BEVAKAL
MANDYA-571401

ALSO AT SHOP NO.27
KSRTC BUS TERMINAL-1
SUBASH NAGAR
BANGALORE-9.
9. G RAJA
S/O GANAPATHI
AGED ABOUT 46 YEARS
TH
NO.105 9 CROSS RAMAKRISHNA
LAYOUT
PATEGARA PALYA MAIN ROAD
NAGARABHAVI 2ND STAGE
BANGALORE-560091.
10.V NARASIMHA MURTHY
SON OF SURYANARYANA
AGED ABOUT 50 YEARS
ND
NO.2890/A 2 FLOOR
TH
14 MAIN ROAD
ND
E BLOCK, 2 STAGE
RAJAJINAGAR
BANGALORE-560010.
... PETITIONERS

Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
20/11/2026, 13:32, Bengaluru
Verified

- 11 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:64475
WP No. 35467 of 2025
C/W WP No. 10460 of 2022
WP No. 13395 of 2022
AND 3 OTHERS


CNR: KAHC010762852025


(BY SRI. SARAVANA S., ADVOCATE)


AND

1. KARNATAKA STATE ROAD TRANSPORT CORPORATION
KEMPEGOWDA BUS STATION
DIVISION-BENGALURU
BY ITS MANAGING DIRECTOR
SUBASH NAGAR
BANGALORE-560009.
2. CHIEF TRAFFIC MANAGER (COMMERCIAL)
OF TRANSPORT DEPARTMENT, KSRTC
SUBASH NAGAR
BANGALORE-560009.
3. DIVISIONAL CONTROLLER
KEMPEGOWDA BUS STAND
SUBASH NAGAR
BANGALORE-560009.
4. KSRTC/BMTC/N.E/N.W/
HOTEL AND SHOP OWNERS ASSOCIATION
REGISTERED UNDER THE CO-OP SOCIETIES ACT,
NO.59 OPPOSITE TO MAYURA HOTEL
KEMPEGOWDA BUS STATION
SUBASH NAGAR
BANGALORE-560009.

…. RESPONDENTS

(BY SRI. P.D. SURANA ADVOCATE FOR R1 TO R3;
SRI. RAMU S., ADVOCATE FOR R4)

THIS WRIT PETITION IS FILED UNDER ARTICLES 226 AND 227
OF THE CONSTITUTION OF INDIA PRAYING TO QUASH ANNEXURE-F
VIDE NO.KARAASAA/KEKA/SAM/VAA-1/22/2022-23 DTD.6.4.2022
ISSUED BY TH R-3 AND CONSEQUENTLY DIRECT THE R-1 TO 3 TO
BE BOUND BY POLICY DECISION AS PER ANNEXURE-D VIDE
NO.KARAASAA/KEKA/SAM/VAA-1/770/2021-22 DTD.1.8.2021 IN SO
FOR AS PETITIONERS CONCERN AND ETC.

IN W.P.NO.7641/2023
BETWEEN
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
20/11/2026, 13:32, Bengaluru
Verified

- 12 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:64475
WP No. 35467 of 2025
C/W WP No. 10460 of 2022
WP No. 13395 of 2022
AND 3 OTHERS


CNR: KAHC010762852025



SRI. N.S. VADIRAJA
AGED ABOUT 66 YEARS,
S/O LATE N SUBBARAO,
PARTNER OF M/S SRI GURU VADIRAJA ASSOCIATES,
R/AT NO.54,
TH
ASHIRVAD, 7 MAIN,
KAMAKSHI HOSPITAL ROAD,
SARASWATHIPURAM,
MYSURU-570009.
... PETITIONER

(BY SRI. Y.K. NARAYAN SHARMA., ADVOCATE)


AND

1. KARNATAKA STATE ROAD TRANSPORT CORPORATION
REPRESENTED BY ITS MANAGING DIRECTOR,
KENGAL HANUMANTHAIAH ROAD,
SHANTHINAGAR,
BANGALORE-560027.
2. CHIEF TRAFFIC MANAGER
(COMMERCIAL TRANSPORT DEPARTMENT KSRTC)
KENGAL HANUMANTHAIAH ROAD,
SHANTHINAGAR,
BANGALORE-560027.
3. DIVISIONAL CONTROLLER
KSRTC, MYSURU DIVISION,
DIVISIONAL OFFICE,
BANNIMANTAP ROAD,
MYSURU-570001.
4. STATE OF KARNATAKA
REPRESENTED BY ITS CHIEF SECRETARY,
VIDHANA SOUDHA,
DR.B.R.AMBEDKAR ROAD,
BENGALURU-560001.

…. RESPONDENTS

(BY SRI. P.D. SURANA., ADVOCATE FOR R1 TO R3;
SRI. MOHAMMED JAFAR SHAH., AGA FOR R4)

Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
20/11/2026, 13:32, Bengaluru
Verified

- 13 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:64475
WP No. 35467 of 2025
C/W WP No. 10460 of 2022
WP No. 13395 of 2022
AND 3 OTHERS


CNR: KAHC010762852025


THIS WRIT PETITION IS FILED UNDER ARTICLES 226 AND 227
OF THE CONSTITUTION OF INDIA PRAYING TO ISSUE A WRIT OF
CERTIORARI OR OTHER APPROPRIATE WRIT OR DIRECTION
QUASHING THE DEMAND MADE BY THE RESPONDENT NO.3 BY
LETTER DATED 03-05-2022 AS PER ANNEXURE-"F" AND THE
RESOLUTION DATED 21.03.2022 AS PER ANNEXURE-'L' AND
RESOLUTION DATED 13.11.2024 AS PER ANNEXURE-'M' AND THE
LETTER DATED 22.12.2021 AS PER ANNEXURE-'N' AND DIRECT THE
RESPONDENT NO. 1TO 3 TO REFUND THE ENTIRE SECURITY
DEPOSIT AMOUNT TOGETHER WITH INTERESTED 2% PER MONTH
FROM 01.07.2022 UP TO DATE OF PAYMENT AFTER GIVING
DEDUCTION TO THE PAYMENT MADE DURING THE COURSE OF THE
PENDENCY OF THE ABOVE WRIT PETITION" PASS OTHER SUITABLE
ORDERS, AS DEEMED FIT BY THIS HON'BLE COURT UNDER THE
FACTS AND CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE BY ALLOWING THIS
WRIT PETITION WITH COSTS IN THE INTEREST OF JUSTICE. .

IN W.P.NO.27997/2023
BETWEEN

CHANDAN SINGH
S/O PRATHAP SINGH,
AGED ABOUT 33 YEARS,
ST
RESIDING AT NO. 58, 1 FLOOR,
ST ST
1 MAIN, 1 CROSS,
ASHWATHNAGAR, RMV EXTENSION II STAGE,
BENGALURU 560094.
... PETITIONER

(BY SRI. DILIP KUMAR., ADVOCATE)


AND

1 . KARNATAKA STATE ROAD TRANSPORT CORPORATION
KEMPEGOWDA BUS STATION DIVISION,
BENGALURU,
REP BY ITS MANAGING DIRECTOR
SHUBASH NAGAR,
BENGALURU 560009.
2 . CHIEF TRAFFIC MANAGER (COMMERCIAL)
OF TRANSPORT DEPARTMENT,
KARNATAKA STATE ROAD TRANSPORT CORPORATION,
SHUBASH NAGAR,
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
20/11/2026, 13:32, Bengaluru
Verified

- 14 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:64475
WP No. 35467 of 2025
C/W WP No. 10460 of 2022
WP No. 13395 of 2022
AND 3 OTHERS


CNR: KAHC010762852025


BENGALURU 560009.
3 . DIVISIONAL CONTROLLER
KARNATAKA STATE ROAD TRANSPORT CONRPORATION,
KEMPEGOWDA BUS STATION DIVISION,
BENGALURU 560009.
4 . KSRTC/BMTC/N.E./N.W/
HOTELS AND SHOPS OWNERS ASSOCIATION,
REGISTERED UNDER CO OPERATIVE SOCIETIES ACT,
REP BY ITS SECRETARY,
OFFICE AT NO. 59, OPP TO MAYURA HOTEL,
KEMPEGOWDA BUS STATION,
SHUBASH NAGAR,
BENGALURU 560009.
…. RESPONDENTS

(BY SRI. P.D. SURANA., ADVOCATE FOR R1 TO R3;
SRI. RAMU S., ADVOCATE FOR R4)

THIS WRIT PETITION IS FILED UNDER ARTICLES 226 AND 227
OF THE CONSTITUTION OF INDIA PRAYING TO QUASH THE
NOTIFICATION AT ANNNX-G VIDE NO. KARAASAA KEKA SAM VAA -
1/22/2022-23 DTD 06.04.2022 ISSUED BY THE R-2 AND
CONSEQUENTLY DIRECT THE R-1 TO 3 TO BE BOUND BY THE POLICY
DECISION AS PER ANNX-F VIDE NO.KARASAA KEKA SAM VAA 1 770
2021-22 DTD 01.09.2021 AND ETC.


THESE WRIT PETITIONS COMING ON FOR ORDERS AND
HAVING BEEN RESERVED FOR ORDERS ON 20.08.2026, THIS DAY,
THE COURT PRONOUNCED THE FOLLOWING:

CORAM: HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE SURAJ GOVINDARAJ

CAV ORDER


1. The petitioner in W.P.No.35467/2025 is before this
Court seeking for the following reliefs:
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
20/11/2026, 13:32, Bengaluru
Verified

- 15 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:64475
WP No. 35467 of 2025
C/W WP No. 10460 of 2022
WP No. 13395 of 2022
AND 3 OTHERS


CNR: KAHC010762852025


a) Issue a writ in the nature of certiorari and quash
the notice dated 18.08.2025 in
No.KST/SMG/TR/COM/1249/2025-26 produced as
Annexure-E to the writ petition and so also
consequential demand notices dated 01.09.2025 in
No.KST/SMG/TR/COM/1368/2025-26 produced as
Annexure-E1 to the writ petition and demand notice
dated 16.10.2025 in No.KST/SMG/TR/COM/1812/
2025-26 produced Annexure-E2 to the writ petition
which are issued by the first respondent;
b) Issue any other appropriate writ or order or
direction as this Hon'ble Court deems it appropriate in
the admitted facts and circumstances of the case in
the interest of justice;
c) Pass such other suitable orders as this Hon'ble court
deems it appropriate in the attendant circumstances
and facts of the case;
d) Award the cost of this proceeding.

2. The petitioners in W.P.No.10460/2022 are before this
Court seeking for the following reliefs
a. Issue writ in the nature of certiorari and quash the
letter dtd.6/4/2022 in No.KARASA: KEKA: SAM:VAA-
1:22:2022-23 D and the issued by the respondent
No.2 vide Annexure notices issued by Respondent
No.5 under Annexure- C, C1 to C6 vide:
i) Dtd.9/4/2022, in No.KARASA: DAVI: SAMCHARA:
VANIJYA /81/2022-23 in respect of petitioner No.1 is
concerned.
ii) Dtd.8/4/2022, in No.KARASA: DAVI:SAMCHARA:
VANIJYA /61/2022-23 in respect of petitioner No.2 is
concerned.
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
20/11/2026, 13:32, Bengaluru
Verified

- 16 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:64475
WP No. 35467 of 2025
C/W WP No. 10460 of 2022
WP No. 13395 of 2022
AND 3 OTHERS


CNR: KAHC010762852025


iii) Dtd.8/4/2022, in No.KARASA: DAVI: SAMCHARA:
VANIJYA /64/2022-23 in respect of petitioner No.3 is
concerned.
iv) Dtd.8/4/2022, in No.KARASA: DAVI: SAMCHARA:
VANIJYA /63/2022-23 in respect of petitioner No.4 is
concerned.
v) Dtd.8/4/2022, in No.KARASA: DAVI: SAMCHARA:
VANIJYA /62/2022-23 in respect of petitioner No.5 is
concerned.
vi) Dtd.11/5/2022, in No.KARASA: DAVI: SAMCHARA:
VANIJYA/379/2022-23 in respect of petitioner No.6 is
concerned.
vii) Dtd.9/4/2022, in No.KARASA: DAVI:SAMCHARA:
VANIJYA/77/2022-23 in respect of petitioner No.7 is
concerned.
b. Issue such other order or direction as may be
deemed fit to grant in the circumstances of the case.

3. The petitioners in W.P.No.13395/2022 are before this
Court seeking for the following reliefs:
a) QUASH THE LETTER DTD 06.04.2022 IN NO.
KARASA.KEKA.SAM.VAA-1.22.2022-23 ISSUED BY THE R-2
VIDE ANNX-D AND THE NOTICE DTD 10.05.2022 ISSUED
BY R-5 UNDER ANNEXURE-C, C1 TO C13 VIDE-

i) dtd 10.05.2022, IN NO.KARASA.CHIV.SANCHARA.
VANIJYA/280/2022-23 in respect of petitioner no.1 is
concerned.

ii) dtd 10.05.2022, IN NO.KARASA.CHIV.SANCHARA.
VANIJYA/278/2022-23 in respect of petitioner no.2 is
concerned.

Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
20/11/2026, 13:32, Bengaluru
Verified

- 17 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:64475
WP No. 35467 of 2025
C/W WP No. 10460 of 2022
WP No. 13395 of 2022
AND 3 OTHERS


CNR: KAHC010762852025


iii) dtd 10.05.2022, IN NO.KARASA.CHIV.SANCHARA.
VANIJYA/283/2022-23 in respect of petitioner no.3 is
concerned.

iv) dtd 10.05.2022, IN NO.KARASA.CHIV.SANCHARA.
VANIJYA/284/2022-23 in respect of petitioner no.4 is
concerned.

v) dtd 10.05.2022, IN NO.KARASA.CHIV.SANCHARA.
VANIJYA/282/2022-23 in respect of petitioner no.5 is
concerned.

vi) dtd 10.05.2022, IN NO.KARASA.CHIV.SANCHARA.
VANIJYA/276/2022-23 in respect of petitioner no.6 is
concerned.

vii) dtd 10.05.2022, IN NO.KARASA.CHIV.SANCHARA.
VANIJYA/ 265/2022-23 in respect of petitioner no.7 is
concerned.

viii) dtd 10.05.2022, IN NO.KARASA.CHIV.SANCHARA.
VANIJYA/ 269/2022-23 in respect of petitioner no.8 is
concerned.

ix) dtd 10.05.2022, IN NO.KARASA.CHIV.SANCHARA.
VANIJYA/ 266/2022-23 in respect of petitioner no.9 is
concerned.

x) dtd 10.05.2022, IN NO.KARASA.CHIV.SANCHARA.
VANIJYA/ 267/2022-23 in respect of petitioner no.10 is
concerned.

xi) dtd 10.05.2022, IN NO.KARASA.CHIV.SANCHARA.
VANIJYA/ 279/2022-23 in respect of petitioner no.11 is
concerned.

xii) dtd 10.05.2022, IN NO.KARASA.CHIV.SANCHARA.
VANIJYA/ 281/2022-23 in respect of petitioner no.12 is
concerned.

xiii) dtd 10.05.2022, IN NO.KARASA.CHIV.SANCHARA.
VANIJYA/ 265/2022-23 in respect of petitioner no.13 is
concerned.
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
20/11/2026, 13:32, Bengaluru
Verified

- 18 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:64475
WP No. 35467 of 2025
C/W WP No. 10460 of 2022
WP No. 13395 of 2022
AND 3 OTHERS


CNR: KAHC010762852025


b. Issue such other order or direction as may be
deemed fit to grant in the circumstances of the case.


4. The petitioners in W.P.No.20426/2022 are before this
Court seeking for the following reliefs:
a. Issue a Writ in the nature of Certiorari to quash
Annexure-F, Vide No. KARAASAA/ dated.06/04/2022,
issued by the KEKA/SAM/VAA-1/22/2022-23,
respondent no-3 and consequently direct the
respondents no.1 to 3 to be bound by policy decision
as per Annexure-D, Vide No.KARAASAA/KEKA
/SAM/VAA-1/770/2021-22, dated.01.08.2021 as
petitioners concern., in so for
b. Issue a writ of Mandamus directing the respondents
no. 1 to 3 to refund the lease deposit amount to the
petitioner no.9 & 10 as held by them in terms of lease
agreements as per Annexure-A10 & 11 forthwith
without giving effect to Annexure-F in the ends of the
justice; and
c. Issue such other ancillary or incidental reliefs as the
circumstance of the case warrants in the ends of the
justice.

5. The petitioner in W.P.No.7641/2023 is before this
Court seeking for the following reliefs:
“Issue a writ of certiorari or other appropriate writ or
direction quashing the demand made by the
respondent No.3 by letter dated 03-05-2022 as per
Annexure-"F" and the resolution dated 21.03.2022 as
per Annexure-'L' and resolution dated 13.11.2024 as
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
20/11/2026, 13:32, Bengaluru
Verified

- 19 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:64475
WP No. 35467 of 2025
C/W WP No. 10460 of 2022
WP No. 13395 of 2022
AND 3 OTHERS


CNR: KAHC010762852025


per Annexure-'M' and the letter dated 22.12.2021 as
per Annexure-'N' and direct the respondent No. 1to 3
to refund the entire Security Deposit amount together
with interested 2% per month from 01.07.2022 up to
date of payment after giving deduction to the payment
made during the course of the pendency of the above
writ petition" pass other suitable orders, as deemed fit
by this Hon'ble Court under the facts and
circumstances of the case by allowing this Writ Petition
with costs in the interest of justice.”

6. The petitioner in W.P.No.27997/2023 is before this
Court seeking for the following reliefs:
(i) Issue a Writ in the nature of Certiorari to quash the
notification at Annexure-GVide No.
KARAASAA:KEKA:SAM:VAA-1/22:2022-23 dated
06.04.2022, issued by the respondent No.2 and
consequently direct the respondents No.1 to 3 to be
bound by the policy decision as per Annexure-F, Vide
No. KARAASAA: KEKA:SAM:VAA-1:770:2021-22
dated.01.09.2021.
(ii) Issue a Writ of Mandamus directing the
respondents No. 1 to 3 to keep the lease/security
deposit amount deposited by the petitioner being the
sum of Rs. 6,68,668/-as Deposit amount only and
directing the respondents No. 1 to 3 not to adjust /
deduct from the deposit amount towards arrears of
rent for the period of April to June 2021 by giving
effect to impugned Annexure-G in the ends of the
justice; and
(iii) Issue such other ancillary or incidental reliefs as
the circumstance of the case warrants in the ends of
the justice and equity.

Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
20/11/2026, 13:32, Bengaluru
Verified

- 20 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:64475
WP No. 35467 of 2025
C/W WP No. 10460 of 2022
WP No. 13395 of 2022
AND 3 OTHERS


CNR: KAHC010762852025


7. The facts in all the above matters are more or less
the same. The respondents-KSRTC had executed a
registered concession agreement for operation and
maintenance of commercial-cum-retail space at
Shivamogga Bus Terminal in favour of KSMZ
Properties Private Limited (‘ KSMZ’ for short), the
petitioner in W.P.No.35467/2025 on 27.06.2012
under the said concession agreement permission was
granted for operation, marketing and maintenance of
commercial-cum-retail space in the said bus stand.
The concession agreement was extended BY KSRTC
until 15.03.2025. The concessionaire namely KSMZ
entered into various sub leases in respect of the
commercial premises in the said bus stand in favour
of the petitioners in the other petitions. The said sub
leases were back-to-back arrangements with that in
favour of KSMZ. The arrangement was that the terms
of the concession agreement would mutatis mutandis
apply to the sub leases executed by KSMZ in favour
of its sub-lessees.
8. In all the above matters, the issue which has arisen
is as regards the concession to be offered during the
COVID-19 pandemic. Both the concessionaire as also
sub lessees claiming that each of them is entitled for
concession during the COVID-19 pandemic requiring
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
20/11/2026, 13:32, Bengaluru
Verified

- 21 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:64475
WP No. 35467 of 2025
C/W WP No. 10460 of 2022
WP No. 13395 of 2022
AND 3 OTHERS


CNR: KAHC010762852025


them not to make payment of any lease rentals. In
this regard, the relevant Clause being Article 8 of the
Concession Agreement, which is reproduced
hereunder for easy reference:
ARTICLE-8: FORCE MAJEURE
8.1 Force Majeure (Force Majeure Events):
A Force Majeure event means any event or
circumstance or a combination of events and
circumstances, or consequences thereof which effect
or prevent the Party ("Affected Party") claiming Force
Majeure from performing its obligation in whole or in
part, under this Agreement and which event or
circumstance (a) is beyond the reasonable control and
not arising out of the fault of the Affected Party, (b)
Affected Party has been unable to overcome such
event or circumstance by the exercise of due diligence
and reasonable efforts, skill, care and (c) has a
Material Adverse Effect. Such events shall mean and
include:
8.1.1 Non Political Events
(a) Acts of God or natural disasters beyond the
reasonable control of the Affected Party which could
not reasonably have been expected to occur, including
but not limited to storm, cyclone, typhoon, hurricane,
flood, landslide, drought, lightning, earthquakes,
volcanic eruption, fire or exceptionally adverse
weather conditions affecting the Project.
(b) Radioactive contamination, ionizing radiation.
(c) Epidemic and famine.
(d) An act of war (whether declared or undeclared),
invasion, armed conflict or act of foreign enemy,
blockade, embargo, revolution, riot, insurrection,
terrorist or military action, nuclear blast/explosion,
sabotage or civil commotion.
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
20/11/2026, 13:32, Bengaluru
Verified

- 22 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:64475
WP No. 35467 of 2025
C/W WP No. 10460 of 2022
WP No. 13395 of 2022
AND 3 OTHERS


CNR: KAHC010762852025


(e) Industry wide or state wide or India wide strikes or
industrial action or disturbances which has a Material
Adverse Effect and which are not on account of acts of
the Concessionaire, its subcontractors or persons
claiming through or under it; or
(f) Any judgment or order of any court of competent
jurisdiction or statutory authority in India made
against any of the Parties in any proceedings (which
are non collusive and duly prosecuted by the Party) for
reasons other than failure of the Party or of any
Person claiming through or under it to comply with any
Applicable Law or terms of Clearances or on account of
breach thereof, or of any contract, or enforcement of
this Agreement or exercise of any of its rights under
this Agreement.
(g) Any event or circumstances of a nature analogous
to any of the foregoing.
8.1.2 Political Events
(a) Expropriation or compulsory acquisition by any
Competent Authority of the Project or part thereof or
rights of the Concessionaire relating thereto, provided
the same has not resulted from an act or default of the
Concessionaire or any Person claiming through or
under it.
(b) Any unlawful unauthorized or without jurisdiction
revocation of, or refusal to renew or grant without
valid cause any Clearance required by the
Concessionaire to perform his obligations as per this
Agreement; provided that such delay, modification,
denial, refusal or revocation did not result from the
Concessionaire's (i) inability or failure to comply with
any condition relating to grant, maintenance or
renewal of such consents or permits; or (ii) breach or
failure in complying with the provisions hereof,
including this Agreement, Applicable Laws, the terms
of Clearances, any judgement or order or Directive of
any Competent Authority or of any concession to
which the Concessionaire is bound.
8.2 Exceptions Applicable to the Concessionaire
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
20/11/2026, 13:32, Bengaluru
Verified

- 23 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:64475
WP No. 35467 of 2025
C/W WP No. 10460 of 2022
WP No. 13395 of 2022
AND 3 OTHERS


CNR: KAHC010762852025


of the following circumstances to the Concessionaire
shall not have the right to consider any of t be an
event of Force Majeure that would suspend the
performance or excuse the non-performance of its
obligations under this Agreement other than to the
extent that such circumstances result from an event of
Force Majeure:
(a) Delay in performance by any sub-contractor,
agents and employees of the Concessionaire.
(b) Breakdown or ordinary wear and tear of materials,
equipment machinery or parts relating to the facilities
at the Commercial-cum-Retail Space.
(c) Unavailability, late delivery or changes in cost of
plant, machinery, equipment, materials spare parts,
fuel or consumables for the Concessionaire; or
(d) Non-performance caused by or connected with the
non-performing Party's
(i) negligent or intentional acts, errors or omissions,
(ii) failure to comply with Law or
(iii) breach of or Default under this Agreement.
8.3 Obligations of the Parties
8.3.1 Obligation to Notify
(1) As soon as practicable and in any case within 7
days of the date of occurrence of a Force Majeure
Event or the date of knowledge thereof, the Affected
Party shall notify the other Party of the Force Majeure
Event setting out, inter alia, the following in
reasonable detail:
(a) The nature and extent of the Force Majeure Event.
(b) The estimated Force Majeure Period.
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
20/11/2026, 13:32, Bengaluru
Verified

- 24 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:64475
WP No. 35467 of 2025
C/W WP No. 10460 of 2022
WP No. 13395 of 2022
AND 3 OTHERS


CNR: KAHC010762852025


(c) The nature of and the extent to which,
performance of any of its obligations under this
Agreement is affected by the Force Majeure Event.
(d) The measures which the Affected Party has taken
or proposes to take to alleviate / mitigate the impact
of the Force Majeure Event and to resume
performance of such of its obligations affected
thereby.
(e) Any other relevant information concerning the
Force Majeure Event, and/or the rights and obligations
of the Parties under this Agreement.
(ii) As soon as practicable and in any case within 5
days of notification by the Affected Party in accordance
with the preceding sub-article (i), the Parties shall,
meet, hold discussions in good faith and where
necessary conduct physical inspection/survey of the
Project/Project Site in order to:
(a) Assess the impact of the underlying Force Majeure
Event.
(b) To determine the likely duration of Force Majeure
Period and,
(c) To formulate damage mitigation measures and
steps to be undertaken by the Parties for resumption
of obligations the performance of which shall have
been affected by the underlying Force Majeure Event.
(iii) The Affected Party shall during the Force Majeure
Period provide the other Party with regular (not less
than weekly) reports concerning the matters set out in
the preceding sub-article (ii) as also any information,
details or document, which the other Party may
reasonably require.
8.3.2 Performance of Obligations
If the Affected Party is rendered wholly or partially
unable to perform any of its obligations under this
Agreement because of a Force Majeure Event, it shall
be excused from performance of such obligations to
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
20/11/2026, 13:32, Bengaluru
Verified

- 25 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:64475
WP No. 35467 of 2025
C/W WP No. 10460 of 2022
WP No. 13395 of 2022
AND 3 OTHERS


CNR: KAHC010762852025


the extent it is unable to perform the same on account
of such Force Majeure Event provided that:
(i) The excuse from performance shall be of no greater
scope and of no longer duration than is necessitated
by the Force Majeure Event.
(ii) The Affected Party shall make all reasonable efforts
to mitigate or limit damage, if any, caused or is likely
to be caused to the Project/Project Site as a result of
the Force Majeure Event and to restore the
Project/Project Site/Commercial-cum-Retail Space and
related facilities, in accordance with the Good Industry
Practice and its relative obligations under this
Agreement.
(iii) The Affected Party shall take all remedial
measures including duly prosecuting and exhausting
all such remedies available to the Affected Party under
the Applicable Laws.
(iv) When the Affected Party is able to resume
performance of its obligations under this Agreement, it
shall give to the other Parties and the Concessioning
Authority written notice to that effect and shall
promptly resume performance of its obligations
hereunder.
(v) The Affected Party shall continue to perform such
of its obligations which are not affected by the Force
Majeure Event and which are capable of being
performed in accordance with this Agreement.
8.4 Revised Timetable
If the Party claiming to be affected by the Force
Majeure event has complied with the notice procedure
under Article 8.3.2, any time period specified in this
Agreement for the performance of an obligation,
including the Concession shall be appropriately
extended for a period equal to that during which the
effect of the Force Majeure event applies to the
obligation.

Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
20/11/2026, 13:32, Bengaluru
Verified

- 26 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:64475
WP No. 35467 of 2025
C/W WP No. 10460 of 2022
WP No. 13395 of 2022
AND 3 OTHERS


CNR: KAHC010762852025


8.5 Consultation and Duty to Mitigate
The Party claiming relief under Force Majeure shall, at
its own cost, take all steps reasonably required to
remedy and mitigate the effects of the Force Majeure
event and restore its ability to perform its obligations
under this Agreement as soon as reasonably The
Parties shall consult with each other to determine the
reasonable measures to be implemented to minimize
the losses of each Party resulting from the Force
Majeure Event. The Party affected by Force Majeure
shall keep the other Parties informed of its efforts to
remedy the effect of the Force Majure event and shall
make reasonable efforts to mitigate such event on a
continuous basis and shall provide written notice of the
resumption of performance obligations under this
Agreement by reason of impossibility of performance
or any other specifically stated to the contrary, no
Party shall be relieved of its hereunder. Except
circumstance whatsoever beyond its control.

9. It is the interpretation of the aforesaid Clause and
the applicability to the COVID-19 pandemic which is
the subject matter of the present writ petitions.
10. The submission of Sri P.N Harish, learned counsel for
the petitioner in W.P.No.35467/2025, is that
10.1. During COVID-19 pandemic, there was a
complete lockdown which had been imposed by
the Central government. There was also a
curfew which was in force, which resulted in
complete shutdown of all businesses including
the shops and the premises in question. It is
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
20/11/2026, 13:32, Bengaluru
Verified

- 27 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:64475
WP No. 35467 of 2025
C/W WP No. 10460 of 2022
WP No. 13395 of 2022
AND 3 OTHERS


CNR: KAHC010762852025


claimed that on account of this fact, the KSRTC
had issued a notification on 01.09.2021 through
the Divisional Controller Stating as under:
/ ,
ಎ ಾ ಯ
ಾ ೕಯ ಯಂತಾಾಗಳ
. . . .
ಕ ಾ ರ ಾ ಗಮ

,
ಾನೇ

: - 19 - 2021
ಷಯ ೋ " ರ ಎರಡ$ೇ ಅ ೆಯ $ೆ&ೆಯ' ಏ)* ಮತು,
- 2021
ಜೂ. ರ ಾ/ೆಗಳ' ಗಮದ ಪರ2ಾನ 3ಾರ4ೆ
.
ಪರ2ಾನ ಶುಲ7 8ಾವ:ಯ' ೕಡಾ ರುವ $ಾ;:ಯ ಬ4ೆ=

: 1. 27.08.2021 .
ಉ ೇಲು ?$ಾಂಕ ರಂದು ನ@ೆದ ಸ
ೆಯ'ನ :ೕಾBನ
2. No.KARASA/KAEK/SUM/VA-1/391/2021-22
?$ಾಂಕ
02.06.2021.
3. No.KARASA/KAEK/SUM/VA-1/215/2021-22
?$ಾಂಕ
02.06.2021.
, - 2021
Cೕಲ7ಂಡ ಷಯ ಮತು, ಉೇಖಗE4ೆ ಸಂಬಂFದಂGೆ ಏ) * ರ
07.04.2021 21.04.2021(14 )
ಾ/ೆಯ' ?$ಾಂಕ ಂದ ?ನಗಳ 
,
ರವ ೆ4ೆ ಾ4ೆ ಗಮದ $ೌಕರರ ಮುಷ7ರ ನ@ೆ?ದುI ಬJ ಾIಣಗEಂದ

ಗಮದ ಾ4ೆಗಳ ಪLಣB ಪಾಣದ' ಾMಾBಚರೆMಾ ರುವO?ಲ
- 19 2 ,
/ಾಗೂ ೋ " ರ $ೇ ಅ ೆಯ Pೕ:ಯ ಮುಂQಾಗೃತ $ೆ&ೆಯ'
21-04-2021 .
ಸ ಾBರವO ?$ಾಂಕ ಂದ ಾ: ಕಷB 2ಾರಂತ ದ
.
ಾS @ೌ. ಇGಾ? ಕUಣ ಯಮಗಳನು& Qಾ4ೆ ತಂ?ರುತ,3ೆ ?$ಾಂಕ
27-04-2021 9.00 12-05-2021
ರ ಾ: ಗಂVೆ;ಂದ ?$ಾಂಕ ರ
6.00 .
WೆE4ೆ= ಗಂVೆಯವ ೆ4ೆ ಜನGಾ ಕಪLB XೂೕYFರುತ,3ೆ ಪOನಃ ?$ಾಂಕ
24-05-2021 6.00 .
ರ WೆE4ೆ= ಗಂVೆಯವ ೆ4ೆ ಾS @ೌ. XೂೕYYರುತ,3ೆ
- 2021 - 2021 20-
ಏ) * ರ ಾ/ೆಯ' ಜೂ. ರ ಾ/ೆಯ' ?$ಾಂಕ
06-2021 , ,
ರವ ೆ4ೆ ಾS @ೌ. ಮುಂದುವೆ?ದುI Cೖಸೂರು /ಾಸನ ದ\ಣ
05-07-2021 -
ಕನ&ಡ ಮತು, ೊಡಗು ]ೆಗಳ' ?$ಾಂಕ ಮತು, ಜೂ.
21
ರ ಾ/ೆಗಳ $ಾ;: ^ತ,ವನು& ಇನ&ಷು_ ಪಷ7F ೕಡುವಂGೆ
.
ಾಕಷು_ ಮನ ಗಳನು& ಈ ಕaೇಯ' FbೕಕF ಪcೕ'ಸಾ ರುತ,3ೆ ಈ
27-08-2021
ಸಂಬಂಧ ?$ಾಂಕ ರಂದು ಾನ ವವಾeಪಕ
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
20/11/2026, 13:32, Bengaluru
Verified

- 28 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:64475
WP No. 35467 of 2025
C/W WP No. 10460 of 2022
WP No. 13395 of 2022
AND 3 OTHERS


CNR: KAHC010762852025



3ೇBಶಕರವರ ಅಧfGೆಯ' ನ@ೆದ FFg ಸ
ೆಯ' ಸು?ೕಘB2ಾ

ಚiBಸಾ ರುತ,3ೆ.

ಗಮದ ಬJ ಾIಣಗಳ'ನ ಎkಎಂ ೌಂಟm ಮತು, ^Wೈ* ಟವm
,
ಪರ2ಾನ 3ಾರರನು& /ೊರತುಪnF ಏ ೈಕ ಪರ2ಾನ 3ಾರರನು&
( . . . )
ಒಳ4ೊಂಡಂGೆ ಪOತೂ,ರು ) ) ) ಬJ ಾIಣ ೇ ಎ ಾ 2ಾpಜ
, /
ಮE4ೆಗಳ ಪರ2ಾನ 3ಾರ4ೆ ಬJ ಾIಣ ಬJ ಗಳ Cೕ'ನ
Qಾ ೕಾತು ಪದಶBನದ ಏQೆ q3ಾರ4ೆ /ಾಗೂ ಾವBಜ ಕ ಉ3ೋಷಾ
PAS) 21 21
( - -
ವವೆe ಪರ2ಾನ 3ಾರಂದ ಎ)* ಮತು, ಜೂ. ರ
ಾ/ೆಗಳ' ಾFಕ ಪರ2ಾದ ಶುಲ7 8ಾವ:ಯ ಸಂಬಂಧ ೆಳಕಂಡಂGೆ ಕಮ
.
ೈ4ೊಳrಲು :ೕಾB ಸಾ ರುತ,3ೆ


1. - 21 - 2021
ಏ) * ಮತು, ಜೂ. ರ ಾ/ೆಗಳ' ಎkಎಂ ೌಂಟm ಮತು,
,
^Wೈ* ಟವm ಪರ2ಾನ 3ಾರರನು& /ೊರತುಪnF Cೕಲ7ಂಡ ಎ ಾ

ಪರ2ಾನ 3ಾರಂದ ಕಾರು ಒಪsಂದದನbಯ ಗ?ತ ಾFಕ ಪರ2ಾನ
. 70 ( . 50
ಶುಲ7ದ' tೇ ಈ4ಾಗ ೇ ೕnರುವ tೇ ಾFಕ ಪರ2ಾನ ಶುಲೆ7
. 20 ) . 30
ಾತ tೇ ರಷು_ ರಷು_ $ಾ;: ೕಡುವOದು ಮತು, tೇ ರಷು_
,
. . .
ಾFಕ ಪರ2ಾನ ಶುಲ7ವನು& 8ಾವ:FೊಳrವOದು ] ಎJ k
.

8ಾವ:ಯ'  $ಾ;: ಇರುವO?ಲ 

2. - 21 - 21
/ಾ' ಏ) * ಮತು, ಜೂ. ರ ಾ/ೆಗಳ ಾFಕ ಪರ2ಾನ
ಶುಲ7ವನು& Wಾu ಉEFೊಂnರುವ ಪರ2ಾನ 3ಾರ4ೆ ಬnvರತ2ಾ
15-09-2021
8ಾವ:ಸಲು ?$ಾಂಕ ರವ ೆ4ೆ ಾಾವಾಶ ೕಡುವOದು
/ಾಗೂ ಈ4ಾಗೇ ಪರ2ಾನ ಶುಲ7ವನು& 8ಾವ:Fದ' /ೊಂ3ಾpೆ
.
ಾnೊಳrವOದು

3. - 2021
ಜು ೈ ರ ಾ/ೆ;ಂದ /ಾಗೂ ಮುಂದೆ7 ಪರ2ಾನ ಶುಲ7
.
8ಾವ:ಯ' MಾವO3ೇ $ಾ;: ಇರುವO?ಲ

- 2021
Cೕಲ7ಂಡಂGೆ ಅಗತ  ಕಮ ೈ4ೊಳrಲು /ಾಗೂ ಆಗJ_ ರ
ಾ/ೆಯವೆಗೂ ಪರ2ಾನ 3ಾರಂದ MಾವO3ೇ Wಾu ^ತ, ಲದಂGೆ
.
ವಸೂಾ:4ೆ ಕಮವಸಲು :Eಸಾ 3ೆ ಈ ಕು ತು ೈ4ೊಂಡ ಕಮದ ಬ4ೆ=
.
ಈ ಕaೇ4ೆ ಅನುಸರಾ ವರ? ೕಡುವOದು
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
20/11/2026, 13:32, Bengaluru
Verified

- 29 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:64475
WP No. 35467 of 2025
C/W WP No. 10460 of 2022
WP No. 13395 of 2022
AND 3 OTHERS


CNR: KAHC010762852025


10.2. By relying on the said notification which had
been addressed to all Divisional Controllers
across the State, Sri P.N Harish submits that
the KSRTC took into account the COVID-19
pandemic, the disruption in the business, there
being no buses running from the bus stand, the
shops could not be operated and even if they
were operational, there would be no customers.
10.3. Neither the shop owners and/or the employees
could come to the said shops due to social
distancing norms and it is in that background
that the concession as recorded in the
letter/notification dated 01.09.2021 was issued.
10.4. This concession offered to the main
concessionaire i.e. KSMZ, was passed on by
KSMZ to all the other sublessees and the
concessionaire has not received the full rentals
from the sublessees. Hence, when the
concessionaire has not received the full rentals,
the question of the concessionaire making
payment of full rentals would not arise.
10.5. Despite the said notification on 01.09.2021,
subsequently in the year 2022, the KSRTC
started demanding KSMZ to make payment of
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
20/11/2026, 13:32, Bengaluru
Verified

- 30 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:64475
WP No. 35467 of 2025
C/W WP No. 10460 of 2022
WP No. 13395 of 2022
AND 3 OTHERS


CNR: KAHC010762852025


concession fees from April-2021 to June-2021
by issuing various notices, which was replied to
by KSMZ as also by the sublessees.
10.6. On receipt of the reply, Sri P.N Harish submits
that KSRTC would keep quiet for sometime,
then once again raised a demand which was
replied to by the concessionaire, KSRTC kept
quiet for sometime and again issued demand
notice, which cycle went on for some time.
10.7. Sri P.N Harish submits that the sublessees
having received the benefit of the exemption
from KSMZ, they did not come forward to make
payment of the demanded amounts citing the
COVID-19 pandemic, lockdown, and lack of
business.
10.8. On 18.08.2025, a notice came to be issued by
the Divisional Controller, Shivamogga Division
stating that for the months of April, May and
June 2021, the entire amounts had not been
paid. Only 30% having been paid, the balance
70% was demanded to be paid for the months
of April and June 2021 and 100% for the month
of May 2021 was demanded.
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
20/11/2026, 13:32, Bengaluru
Verified

- 31 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:64475
WP No. 35467 of 2025
C/W WP No. 10460 of 2022
WP No. 13395 of 2022
AND 3 OTHERS


CNR: KAHC010762852025


10.9. Thereafter, further notices were issued on
01.09.2025 calling upon KSMZ to make
payment of a sum of ₹1,80,75,797/-. Out of
which, an amount of ₹43,86,818/- was
demanded on account of COVID-19 relaxation
being withdrawn being ₹37,17,642/- as a
license fee for April-2021 to June-2021 and GST
amount of ₹6,69,176/- totally amounting to
₹43,86,818/-.
10.10. Again, a demand notice was issued on
16.10.2025 claiming the license fee pending for
the period of April, May and June 2021 as also
the very same amount of ₹43,86,818/-. KSMZ
replied on 29.10.2025 to all the demands,
invoking the force majeure clause stating that
the occurrence of the pandemic was for reasons
beyond the control of KSMZ.
10.11. The State guidelines directed the closure of

malls and other establishments. Due to which
the shops in the Shivamogga bus stand were
closed. The buses and other transportation
vehicles were not plying. Hence, it is taking into
account that factor that the relaxation had been
granted, where the tenants had suffered huge
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
20/11/2026, 13:32, Bengaluru
Verified

- 32 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:64475
WP No. 35467 of 2025
C/W WP No. 10460 of 2022
WP No. 13395 of 2022
AND 3 OTHERS


CNR: KAHC010762852025


losses due to closure of their businesses, the
benefits of the relaxation having been already
passed on to the sublessees. KSMZ could not
recover it from the sublessees and informed the
KSRTC that it would be fair that KSRTC does
not retrospectively reverse the exemption
provided and accept the amounts already paid
contending that there were survival challenges
being faced by KSMZ and the sublessees.
10.12. On that basis requested for active support on
behalf of KSMZ. The said request also was not
accepted and the KSRTC continued to demand.
It is in that background that KSMZ has sought
for the reliefs indicated above in
W.P.No.35467/2025.
11. Sri R.P.Somashekharaiah, learned counsel appearing
for the petitioners in W.P. No.10460/2022 and
W.P.No.13395/2022 reiterates the submission of
Sri.P.N. Harish .
11.1. Sri R.P.Somashekharaiah submits that the
KSRTC employees, namely the drivers and
conductors, had called for a strike on
07.04.2021 to 21.04.2021 as also due to the
second wave of COVID-19, a complete
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
20/11/2026, 13:32, Bengaluru
Verified

- 33 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:64475
WP No. 35467 of 2025
C/W WP No. 10460 of 2022
WP No. 13395 of 2022
AND 3 OTHERS


CNR: KAHC010762852025


lockdown had been imposed by the State
Government from 21.04.2021 to 20.06.2021.
During which there was no business.
11.2. Sri R.P.Somashekharaiah, also reiterates that in
the meeting held on 01.09.2021, the difficulties
faced by the sublessees were placed before the
CCG. The CCG had accepted the difficulties and
agreed to give reduction in license fee of about
70% for the month of April and June 2021 and
for 100% reduction, concession for the month
of May 2021.
11.3. Sri R.P.Somashekharaiah, submits that the
second meeting having been held on
04.09.2021, the payment of GST was also
waived since there was no payment of rentals
required to be made. On that basis, he submits
that the notice dated 06.04.2022 calling upon
the sublessees to pay the license fee for the
said period without any reduction is not
permissible.
11.4. The notices dated 08.04.2022 calling upon the
sublessees to make payment of the amount
exempted or giving reduction to are not
permissible. The demands having been made
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
20/11/2026, 13:32, Bengaluru
Verified

- 34 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:64475
WP No. 35467 of 2025
C/W WP No. 10460 of 2022
WP No. 13395 of 2022
AND 3 OTHERS


CNR: KAHC010762852025


subsequently on 06.04.2022 and the notices
issued on 08.04.2022, 09.04.2022 and
11.05.2022 are without considering the force
majeure clause.
11.5. The said notices having been issued on the
th
basis of the resolution passed in the 447
meeting of the KSRTC held on 21.03.2022 to
withdraw the benefit are not sustainable. He
also submits that once the benefit had been
provided, the same could not be withdrawn.
12. Sri S. Saravana, learned counsel appearing for the
petitioners in W.P.No.20426/2022 reiterated the
submission of Sri P.N.Harish and
Sri.R.P.Somashekaraiah, learned counsel and further
submitted that:
12.1. Sri S. Saravana submits that during the entire
COVID period, the sublessees had suffered
various losses. The losses suffered by them in
the first wave of COVID-19 were so much that
the sublessees have not recovered from that.
By which time the second wave of COVID-19
pandemic came about when again the
sublessees suffered various losses.
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
20/11/2026, 13:32, Bengaluru
Verified

- 35 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:64475
WP No. 35467 of 2025
C/W WP No. 10460 of 2022
WP No. 13395 of 2022
AND 3 OTHERS


CNR: KAHC010762852025


12.2. During the first wave, recognizing the said
issues, the KSRTC issued a circular giving a
rebate of 90% and collected only 10% by
circular dated 03.08.2020 for the months of
June, July and August 2020, by circular dated
03.11.2020 for the month of October 2020 and
by circular dated 09.11.2020 for November
2020.
12.3. Sri S. Saravana submits that due to the second
wave of COVID-19, the sublessees gave various
representations of 19.06.2021, 01.07.2021,
26.07.2021 and 23.08.2021 contending that
the Railway Department had granted similar
exemption and requested the KSRTC to give
such exemption. It is in pursuance thereof that
notification dated 01.09.2021 came to be
issued by the Chief Traffic Manager stating that
70% rebate is required to be provided and
license fee only to an extent of 30% is required
to be collected.
12.4. Despite the same for the month of April, May
and June 2021, the exemption having been
th
granted. The Board of Directors in its 447
meeting held on 21.03.2022 revoked the said
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
20/11/2026, 13:32, Bengaluru
Verified

- 36 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:64475
WP No. 35467 of 2025
C/W WP No. 10460 of 2022
WP No. 13395 of 2022
AND 3 OTHERS


CNR: KAHC010762852025


rebate. In furtherance of which demand notices
were issued calling upon the sublessees to
make payment of the entire amounts by
withdrawing the concession. The sublessees
gave a representation to the Managing Director,
KSRTC on 18.05.2022 to reconsider the
decision of withdrawing the concession.
However, the same was not considered.
12.5. Sri S. Saravana submits that the withdrawal of
the concession already offered during second
wave of COVID-19 was violative of Article 14 of
the Constitution . Concession having been
provided for the first wave, it was required for
the similar concession to be provided in the
second wave.
12.6. Sri S. Saravana submits that there is a
legitimate expectation on the part of the
sublessees that such reduction once granted
will be complied with. In this regard he relies
upon the decision in GNCT of Delhi v. Naresh
Kumar , [2010 SCC OnLine Del 3942], more
particularly paragraph 22 thereof which is
reproduced hereunder for easy reference:

Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
20/11/2026, 13:32, Bengaluru
Verified

- 37 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:64475
WP No. 35467 of 2025
C/W WP No. 10460 of 2022
WP No. 13395 of 2022
AND 3 OTHERS


CNR: KAHC010762852025


22. After a survey of leading decisions on the point,
the legal position with respect to legitimate
expectation can be summarized as under:
I. Mere reasonable or legitimate expectation of
a citizen may not by itself be a distinct
enforceable right, but failure to consider and
give due weightage to it may lender the
decision arbitrary.
II. Legitimate expectation may arise (a) if
there is an express promise given by a public
authority; or (b) because of acceptance of a
regular practice, a claimant can reasonably
expect it to continue; and (c) such expectation
may be reasonable.
III. For a legitimate expectation to arise, the
decision of administrative authority must
affect the person by depriving him of some
benefit or advantage which he had in the past
been permitted, by the decision maker, to
enjoy and which he can legitimately expect to
be permitted to continue, until some rational
grounds for withdrawing it have been
communicated to him.
IV. If the authority proposes to defeat a
person's legitimate expectation, it should
afford him an opportunity to make a
representation in the matter.
V. The doctrine of legitimate expectation
permits the Court to find out if the change in
policy which is the cause for defeating the
legitimate expectation is irrational or perverse
or one which no reasonable person could have
made.
12.7. By relying on Nareshkumar , his submission is
that when there is an express promise made by
the Public Authority, there is a legitimate
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
20/11/2026, 13:32, Bengaluru
Verified

- 38 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:64475
WP No. 35467 of 2025
C/W WP No. 10460 of 2022
WP No. 13395 of 2022
AND 3 OTHERS


CNR: KAHC010762852025


expectation on the part of the sublessees that
reduction would be complied with.
12.8. Sri S. Saravana’s submission is also that the
KSRTC is bound by the rule of estoppel in
equity acting on the said promise held out by
KSRTC. The sublessees have taken various
actions and as such, there cannot be a demand
made to them to make payment of the balance
lease amounts by withdrawing the concession
offered.
12.9. Insofar as petitioners No.9 and 10 in
W.P.No.20426/2022 are concerned, Sri S.
Saravana submits that they have vacated the
premises. On vacating the premises, it was
required for KSRTC to refund the entire security
deposit. Instead of doing so the KSRTC has
deducted the claimed amounts and as such,
these claimed amounts are also required to be
refunded to petitioners No.9 and 10 in
W.P.No.20426/2022.
13. Sri Y.K.Narayan Sharma, learned counsel appearing
for the petitioner in W.P. No .7641/2023 also reiterates
and adopts the submissions made by the other
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
20/11/2026, 13:32, Bengaluru
Verified

- 39 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:64475
WP No. 35467 of 2025
C/W WP No. 10460 of 2022
WP No. 13395 of 2022
AND 3 OTHERS


CNR: KAHC010762852025


counsels appearing in the matter, in addition he
submits that:
13.1. Sri Y.K.Narayan Sharma submits that the
contract entered into by the petitioner in
W.P.No.7641/2023 was for a period of 5 years
under which a security deposit of ₹22,38,596/-
was made and advance rental amount was paid
under the agreement dated 24.12.2020.
13.2. The petitioner in W.P.No.7641/2023 running a
canteen, empty shop was made available to the
said petitioner, who invested more than
₹20,00,000/- for furniture and fittings in the
said premises. However, within a short time
COVID-19 pandemic ensued resulting in the
petitioner not being able to carry on his
business.
13.3. Sri Y.K.Narayan Sharma also reiterates that due
to COVID-19 pandemic, it became impossible
for the petitioner to perform the duties and
obligations under the agreement. In that
background, this petitioner also requested for
reduction in rent and to waive the payment of
rent through license fee for the period of
lockdown. Being unable to carry on the said
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
20/11/2026, 13:32, Bengaluru
Verified

- 40 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:64475
WP No. 35467 of 2025
C/W WP No. 10460 of 2022
WP No. 13395 of 2022
AND 3 OTHERS


CNR: KAHC010762852025


business due to various losses, the petitioner
requested to surrender the premises which was
accepted by the KSRTC on 31.01.2022.
13.4. This Sri Y.K.Narayan Sharma submits is on
account of the contract having been frustrated
and having become impossible for performance.
The petitioner had as on the date of
surrendering the possession paid all the due
rentals/license fees, electricity charges and
other charges and had called upon KSRTC to
refund the security deposit which was not done.
Without refunding the security deposit, a
demand was made by KSRTC by withdrawing
the reduction provided and calling upon the
petitioner to make payment of a sum of
₹10,19,317/- on the threat of forfeiture of the
security deposit. Despite repeated requests
being made, the security deposit was not
refunded and on that basis, he contends that
the KSRTC is liable to make payment of interest
at the rate of 2% per month on the said
withheld amounts calculated from 01.07.2022
since the possession was handed over to the
KSRTC by the petitioner on 30.06.2022.
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
20/11/2026, 13:32, Bengaluru
Verified

- 41 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:64475
WP No. 35467 of 2025
C/W WP No. 10460 of 2022
WP No. 13395 of 2022
AND 3 OTHERS


CNR: KAHC010762852025


13.5. Sri Y.K.Narayan Sharma submits that the third
respondent being the concerned Authority, who
had issued the circular to all the divisional
controllers and all the divisional controllers
having acted on the said circular/notification.
The petitioner and all the other sublessees
believed that the said concession and/or
reduction was offered by KSRTC. Hence, his
th
submission is that in the 447 meeting, it could
not be said that such concession could not have
been offered on 01.09.2021 and as such, the
resolution dated 21.03.2022 and 13.11.2024
are opposed to law.
13.6. Sri Y.K.Narayan Sharma’s submission is also
that once a concession or reduction is offered,
the benefit having been availed, the same could
not have been unilaterally withdrawn by the
Board without providing a hearing to the
petitioner which is a violation of the principles
of natural justice.
13.7. Sri Y.K.Narayan Sharma’s submission is that the
COVID-19 pandemic is a force majeure event
amounting to vis major and non-payment of
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
20/11/2026, 13:32, Bengaluru
Verified

- 42 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:64475
WP No. 35467 of 2025
C/W WP No. 10460 of 2022
WP No. 13395 of 2022
AND 3 OTHERS


CNR: KAHC010762852025


complete rentals is not a default on the part of
the sublessees.
13.8. On that basis, Sri Y.K.Narayan Sharma submits
that insofar as the petitioner in
W.P.No.7641/2023 is concerned, the said
petitioner is entitled for refund of the entire
security deposit along with interest at 2% p.a.
calculated from 01.07.2022 till the date of
payment.
13.9. Sri Y.K.Narayan Sharma relies upon the decision
of the Hon'ble Supreme Court in Dattatraya v.
Rangnath Gopalrao Kawathekar [ AIR 1971
SC 2548], more particularly paragraph 10
thereof, which is reproduced hereunder for easy
reference:
10. From this document it is clear that the
second defendant admitted that the suit
properties were of the exclusive ownership of the
first defendant, his brother and that he had no
right in the same. The plaintiffs evidently were
put to the necessity of taking this document from
the second defendant in view of the destruction
of the records referred to earlier. It is clear that
the second defendant after executing that
document is now trying to resile from the
admissions made by him with a view to take
advantage of the situation in which the plaintiffs
are placed. Mr Sanghi contended that unless we
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
20/11/2026, 13:32, Bengaluru
Verified

- 43 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:64475
WP No. 35467 of 2025
C/W WP No. 10460 of 2022
WP No. 13395 of 2022
AND 3 OTHERS


CNR: KAHC010762852025


come to the conclusion that in view of Ext. 2, the
appellant is estopped from putting forward his
title to the suit properties, Ext. 2 is irrelevant. We
are unable to accept this contention. Ext. 2 is
relied on by the plaintiffs to prove the admission
of the second defendant that the suit properties
belonged to his brother and that his brother had
sold the same to the plaintiffs. Admission is an
But it is open to
important piece of evidence.
the person who made the admission to prove that
those admissions are not true. It was not the
case of the appellant that the admissions
contained in Ext. 2 are wrong admissions and he
made those admissions under some erroneous
impression or that they were obtained from him
by misrepresentation. His case was that he never
executed Ext. 2. We have already rejected that
case. Hence the admissions contained in Ext. 2
assume importance. Admission is one thing,
estoppel is another. Admission is a piece of
evidence but estoppel creates title. Ex. 2 was
relied on as an admission and not as an estoppel.
We agree with the High Court that Ex. 2 affords
satisfactory evidence to prove the first
defendant's title to the suit properties. It further
proves the alienation effected by the first
defendant in favour of the plaintiffs.
13.10. By relying on Dattatraya , Sri Y.K.Narayan
Sharma’s submission is that the respondents
are estopped from causing a demand once
concession was provided.
13.11. Sri Y.K.Narayan Sharma relies upon the decision
of the Hon'ble Supreme Court in Pratima
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
20/11/2026, 13:32, Bengaluru
Verified

- 44 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:64475
WP No. 35467 of 2025
C/W WP No. 10460 of 2022
WP No. 13395 of 2022
AND 3 OTHERS


CNR: KAHC010762852025


Chowdhury v. Kalpana Mukherjee AIR
[
2014 SC 1304], more particularly paragraphs
34 to 40 thereof, which are reproduced
hereunder for easy reference:
34. The Cooperative Tribunal in its order dated
16-5-2002 had invoked the principle of estoppel,
postulated in Section 115 of the Evidence Act.
The High Court affirmed the conclusions drawn by
the Cooperative Tribunal. In addition to the above
principle, the High Court invoked the principles of
equity and fairness. Insofar as the latter
principles are concerned, we shall delve upon
them after examining the contentions of the rival
parties, as equity and fairness would depend
upon the entirety and totality of the facts. The
above aspect can therefore only be determined
after dealing with the intricacies of the factual
circumstances involved. We shall, however,
endeavour to deal with the principle of estoppel,
so as to figure whether the rule contained in
Section 115 of the Evidence Act could have been
invoked, in the facts and circumstances of the
present case.
35. Section 115 of the Evidence Act is being
extracted hereinbelow:
“ 115.Estoppel .—When one person has, by his
declaration, act or omission, intentionally caused
or permitted another person to believe a thing to
be true and to act upon such belief, neither he
nor his representative shall be allowed, in any
suit or proceeding between himself and such
person or his representative, to deny the truth of
that thing.
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
20/11/2026, 13:32, Bengaluru
Verified

- 45 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:64475
WP No. 35467 of 2025
C/W WP No. 10460 of 2022
WP No. 13395 of 2022
AND 3 OTHERS


CNR: KAHC010762852025


Illustration
A intentionally and falsely leads B to believe that
certain land belongs to A, and thereby induces B
to buy and pay for it. The land afterwards
becomes the property of A, and A seeks to set
aside the sale on the ground that, at the time of
the sale, he had no title. He must not be allowed
to prove his want of title.”
It needs to be understood that the rule of
estoppel is a doctrine based on fairness. It
postulates the exclusion of the truth of the
matter. All for the sake of fairness. A perusal of
the above provision reveals four salient
preconditions before invoking the rule of
estoppel.
(i) Firstly, one party should make a factual
representation to the other party.
(ii) Secondly, the other party should accept
and rely upon the aforesaid factual
representation.
(iii) Thirdly, having relied on the aforesaid
factual representation, the second party
should alter his position.
(iv) Fourthly, the instant altering of
position, should be such, that it would be
iniquitous to require him to revert back to
the original position.
Therefore, the doctrine of estoppel would
apply only when, based on a representation
by the first party, the second party alters his
position, in such manner, that it would be
unfair to restore the initial position.
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
20/11/2026, 13:32, Bengaluru
Verified

- 46 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:64475
WP No. 35467 of 2025
C/W WP No. 10460 of 2022
WP No. 13395 of 2022
AND 3 OTHERS


CNR: KAHC010762852025


36. In our considered view, none of the
ingredients of principle of estoppel contained in
Section 115 of the Evidence Act, can be stated to
have been satisfied in the facts and
circumstances of this case. Herein, the first party
has made no representation. The second party
has therefore not accepted any representation
made to her. Furthermore, the second party has
not acted in any manner, nor has the second
party altered its position. Therefore, the question
whether the restoration of the original position
would be iniquitous or unfair does not arise at all.
Even if consideration had passed from Kalpana
Mukherjee to Pratima Chowdhury, on the basis of
the representation made by Pratima Chowdhury,
we could have accepted that Kalpana Mukherjee
had altered her position. In the facts as they have
been presented by the rival parties, especially in
the background of the order passed by the
arbitrator, that no consideration had passed in
lieu of the transfer of the flat, and especially in
the background of the factual finding recorded by
the Cooperative Tribunal and the High Court, that
passing of consideration in the present
controversy was inconsequential, we have no
hesitation whatsoever in concluding, that the
principle of estoppel relied upon by the
Cooperative Tribunal and the High Court, could
not have been invoked, to the detriment of
Pratima Chowdhury, in the facts and
circumstances of the present case.
37. Insofar as the instant aspect of the matter is
concerned, the legal position declared by this
Court fully supports the conclusion drawn by us
hereinabove. In this behalf, reference may be
made, firstly, to the judgment rendered by this
Court in Kasinka Trading v. Union of India
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
20/11/2026, 13:32, Bengaluru
Verified

- 47 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:64475
WP No. 35467 of 2025
C/W WP No. 10460 of 2022
WP No. 13395 of 2022
AND 3 OTHERS


CNR: KAHC010762852025


[(1995) 1 SCC 274] , wherein this Court noticed
as under: (SCC p. 283, para 11)
“11. The doctrine of promissory estoppel or
equitable estoppel is well established in the
administrative law of the country. To put it
simply, the doctrine represents a principle
evolved by equity to avoid injustice. The basis of
the doctrine is that where any party has by his
word or conduct made to the other party an
unequivocal promise or representation by word or
conduct, which is intended to create legal
relations or effect a legal relationship to arise in
the future, knowing as well as intending that the
representation, assurance or the promise would
be acted upon by the other party to whom it has
been made and has in fact been so acted upon by
the other party, the promise, assurance or
representation should be binding on the party
making it and that party should not be permitted
to go back upon it, if it would be inequitable to
allow him to do so, having regard to the dealings,
which have taken place or are intended to take
place between the parties.”
(emphasis supplied)
38. The above sentiment recorded in respect of
the principle of estoppel was noticed again by this
Court in Monnet Ispat & Energy Ltd. v. Union of
India, wherein this Court expressed its views in
respect of the principle of estoppel as under:
“289. As we have seen earlier, for invoking the
principle of promissory estoppel there has to be a
promise, and on that basis the party concerned
must have acted to its prejudice.”
(emphasis supplied)
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
20/11/2026, 13:32, Bengaluru
Verified

- 48 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:64475
WP No. 35467 of 2025
C/W WP No. 10460 of 2022
WP No. 13395 of 2022
AND 3 OTHERS


CNR: KAHC010762852025


39. The ingredients of the doctrine of estoppel in
the manner expressed above were also projected
in H.R. Basavaraj v. Canara Bank, (2010) 12 SCC
458 (SCC p. 469, para 30)
“30. In general words, estoppel is a principle
applicable when one person induces another or
intentionally causes the other person to believe
something to be true and to act upon such belief
as to change his/her position. In such a case, the
former shall be estopped from going back on the
word given. The principle of estoppel is, however,
only applicable in cases where the other party
has changed his position relying upon the
representation thereby made.”
(emphasis supplied)
40. As already noticed hereinabove, none of the
ingredients of estoppel can be culled out from the
facts and circumstances of the present case. In
view of the above, we hereby set aside the
determination by the Cooperative Tribunal, as
also the High Court, in having relied on the
principle of estoppel, and thereby, excluding the
pleas/defences raised by Pratima Chowdhury to
support her claim.

13.12. By relying on Pratima Chowdhury , Sri
Y.K.Narayan Sharma’s submission is that the
rule of estoppel is a doctrine based on fairness
and equity. A representation having been made
by the KSRTC on 01.09.2021. The same having
been accepted by the lessee and sublessees.
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
20/11/2026, 13:32, Bengaluru
Verified

- 49 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:64475
WP No. 35467 of 2025
C/W WP No. 10460 of 2022
WP No. 13395 of 2022
AND 3 OTHERS


CNR: KAHC010762852025


The lessee and sublessees having altered their
position, it is iniquitous to require such lessee
and sublessees to revert to the original
position. On that basis, he submits that
concession having been offered for the month
of April, May and June 2021. The lessee and
sublessee having paid the amount due after
taking into account the concession. The said
concession could not be revoked and a demand
made to make payment of the concession
amounts.
14. Sri Dilip Kumar, learned counsel for the petitioner in
W.P.No.27997/2023 adopts the submissions made by
the other counsels.
15. Sri P.D.Surana, learned counsel for the respondents-
KSRTC in all the matters submits that
15.1. The writ petitions are not maintainable since
the concession agreement is governed by the
Arbitration Clause in Clause 12.3, which is
reproduced hereunder for easy reference:
"12.3 Dispute Resolution Procedure
12.3.1 Arbitration
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
20/11/2026, 13:32, Bengaluru
Verified

- 50 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:64475
WP No. 35467 of 2025
C/W WP No. 10460 of 2022
WP No. 13395 of 2022
AND 3 OTHERS


CNR: KAHC010762852025


(i) in the event any dispute or differences or
claim’s the case may be arising between the
parties, the same shall be referred to the
Managing Director of the BMTC for resolution and
the Managing Director of BMTC shall be the sole
arbitrator. The arbitrator shall resolve the dispute
between the parties under the arbitration and
Conciliation Act-1996. The decision of the
arbitrator shall be final and binding on both the
parties."
15.2. By relying on the said Arbitration Clause, Sri
P.D.Surana submits that any dispute/s that the
petitioners may have in respect of refund of the
amounts, security deposit, adjustment of the
lease rentals from security deposit or the like
would have to be agitated in arbitral
proceedings and not before this Court in writ
proceedings.
15.3. In so far as force majeure Sri P.D.Surana

submits firstly, that the force majeure clause
under Article 8 was not invoked by the
petitioners. Secondly, the said force majeure
clause is not applicable to the present matter.
15.4. As regards invocation, Sri P.D.Surana submits
that the procedure prescribed under Article 8
extracted hereinabove has to be followed. A
notice was required to be issued on the
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
20/11/2026, 13:32, Bengaluru
Verified

- 51 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:64475
WP No. 35467 of 2025
C/W WP No. 10460 of 2022
WP No. 13395 of 2022
AND 3 OTHERS


CNR: KAHC010762852025


occurrence of a force majeure event within a
period of 7 days from the occurrence of the said
event describing the force majeure event. On
such notice being issued, it was required for the
parties to hold a meeting within 5 days from
the date of receipt of the notice and assess the
impact of the force majeure event and agree
upon the duration, measures to mitigate the
said force majeure event. Unless the procedure
under Clause 8 are followed, the question of
invoking the force majeure clause under Clause
8 would not arise.
15.5. Sri P.D.Surana relies on Article 9.4 of the
Concession Agreement, which is reproduced
hereunder for easy reference.
9.4 Termination Following Force Majeure
9.4.1 In the event Force Majeure continuously
impedes or prevents a Party's performance for
longer than 30 days from the date of
commencement of such Force Majeure event,
notwithstanding the suspension of the obligations
of the Parties, they shall decide by mutual
consent through consultation either the terms
upon which to continue the performance of this
Agreement or to terminate this Agreement. If the
Parties are unable to agree on such terms or to
terminate the Agreement by mutual consent
within 120 days from the date of the
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
20/11/2026, 13:32, Bengaluru
Verified

- 52 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:64475
WP No. 35467 of 2025
C/W WP No. 10460 of 2022
WP No. 13395 of 2022
AND 3 OTHERS


CNR: KAHC010762852025


commencement of such Force Majeure event,
either Party may issue a Notice of Intention to
Terminate.
9.4.2 If, following Force Majeure due to non-
political events as defined in Article 8.1.1, Party
elects to terminate this Agreement, the
Concessioning Authority shall return to the
Concessionaire the Performance Security after
adjusting any outstanding dues from the
Concessionaire, but the Concessioning Authority
shall not be liable to pay any compensation to the
Concessionaire.
9.4.3 If, following Force Majeure due to political
events as defined in Article 8.1.2, Party elects to
terminate this Agreement, the Concessioning
Authority shall:
(i) Not compensate the Concessionaire with
regard to the costs incurred for the Project.
(ii) Return to the Concessionaire the Performance
Security, after adjusting any outstanding dues.
15.6. By relying on Article 9.4, Sri P.D.Surana’s
submission is that if a force majeure event
continues beyond 30 days and the force
majeure event does not come to an end within
120 days. Either party can issue a notice of
intention to terminate the agreement, upon
which the agreement would stand terminated.
No such notice having been issued by either the
lessee or the sub-lessee, his submission is that
the force majeure clause cannot be made
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
20/11/2026, 13:32, Bengaluru
Verified

- 53 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:64475
WP No. 35467 of 2025
C/W WP No. 10460 of 2022
WP No. 13395 of 2022
AND 3 OTHERS


CNR: KAHC010762852025


applicable to the present facts and
circumstances.
15.7. Sri P.D.Surana submits that the so-called
notification/circular dated 01.09.2021 is an
internal correspondence between the
departmental officials of the KSRTC. They have
not been issued to the lessee or sublessee for
them to claim any benefit. The communication
by the CCG was an intra-departmental
communication. The said communication was
placed before the board of the KSRTC on
21.03.2022. When the board rejected the
recommendation of the CCG and resolved to
collect the full lease rentals.
15.8. Sri P.D.Surana submits that at the most, the
communication of 01.09.2021 is a
recommendation by the CCG and not a decision
by the KSRTC. His submission is that the CCG
cannot decide for the KSRTC, it is only the
board of directors who can decide for and on
behalf of the KSRTC. Thus, his submission is
that the entire reliance placed on the said
interdepartmental communication though
termed as a circular or a notification is
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
20/11/2026, 13:33, Bengaluru
Verified

- 54 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:64475
WP No. 35467 of 2025
C/W WP No. 10460 of 2022
WP No. 13395 of 2022
AND 3 OTHERS


CNR: KAHC010762852025


completely misplaced. It is only a
communication not a circular or a notification is
his submission.
15.9. Sri P.D.Surana therefore submits that once the
Board of KSRTC had rejected the
recommendation on part of the CCG and
directed the collection of the full license fee, the
lessee and sublessee were duty bound to make
payment of the entire amount.
15.10. Sri P.D.Surana relies on the decision of the
Hon’ble Delhi High Court in Ramanand and
Ors vs Girish Soni and Anr. [2020 DHC
1963], more particularly paragraphs 20, 24, 27
and 32 thereof, which are reproduced
hereunder for easy reference:
20. The doctrine of force majeure is recognised in
Section 108(B)(e) of the TPA. Section 108(B)(l)
also enumerates the `Rights and Liabilities' of the
lessee. The relevant clauses of the TPA are as
under:
"108. Rights and liabilities of lessor and
lessee. --In the absence of a contract or local
usage to the contrary, the lessor and the lessee
of immoveable property, as against one another,
respectively, possess the rights and are subject
to the liabilities mentioned in the rules next
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
20/11/2026, 13:33, Bengaluru
Verified

- 55 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:64475
WP No. 35467 of 2025
C/W WP No. 10460 of 2022
WP No. 13395 of 2022
AND 3 OTHERS


CNR: KAHC010762852025


following, or such of them as are applicable to the
property leased:--
(A) Rights and liabilities of the lessor- ...
(B) Rights and liabilities of the lessee- ...
(e)
if by fire, tempest or flood, or violence of
an army or of a mob, or other irresistible
force, any material part of the property be
wholly destroyed or rendered substantially
and permanently unfit for the purposes for
which it was let, the lease shall, at the
option of the lessee, be void:
Provided that, if the injury be occasioned by the
wrongful act or default of the lessee, he shall not
be entitled to avail himself of the benefit of this
provision: ...
(f) to (k).......
(l) the lessee is bound to pay or tender, at
the proper time and place, the premium or
rent to the lessor or his agent in this
behalf ;"
A perusal of the above shows that the provision
itself would apply only in the absence of a
contractual stipulation. Further, on the
occurrence of any of the situations contemplated
under (e) above, which would render the property
`substantially and permanently unfit' to be used
for the purpose for which it was leased, at the
option of the lessee, the lease would be void.
24. More recently, this view has been reaffirmed
by this Court in Sangeeta Batra v. M/s VND Foods
& Ors., (2015) 3 DLT (Cri) 422 wherein it has
been held that the fact that the leased premises,
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
20/11/2026, 13:33, Bengaluru
Verified

- 56 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:64475
WP No. 35467 of 2025
C/W WP No. 10460 of 2022
WP No. 13395 of 2022
AND 3 OTHERS


CNR: KAHC010762852025


intended to be run as a restaurant, was sealed on
two occasions is of no relevance as the tenants
did not choose to avoid the lease. Interpreting
Section 108 of the TPA, the ld. Single Judge of
this Court observed:
"26. Section 108 of the Transfer of Property Act
deals with the aspect of rights and liabilities of
lessor and lessee. The rights and liabilities of the
lessee are enumerated from clause (d) onwards
upto clause (q). Clause (e) of Section 108 reads:
"(e) if by fire, tempest or flood, or violence of an
army or of a mob, or other irresistible force, any
material part of the property be wholly destroyed
or rendered substantially and permanently unfit
for the purposes for which it was let, the lease
shall, at the option of the lessee, be void:
Provided that, if the injury be occasioned by the
wrongful act or default of the lessee, he shall not
be entitled to avail himself of the benefit of this
provision;" (Emphasis supplied)
27. Thus, if the leased premises is rendered
substantially and permanently unfit for the
purpose for which it was let, the lessee has
the option to avoid the lease. Unless the
lessee so avoids the lease, he cannot avoid
his obligation contained in clause (l) of
Section 108, which states that "the lessee is
bound to pay or tender, at the proper time and
place, the premium or rent to the lessor or his
agent in this behalf;".
27 . In Raichurmatham Prabhakar and Ors. v.
Rawatmal Dugar, (2004) 4 SCC 766 the Supreme
Court held that suspension of rent may be
claimed by the tenant if the lessee has been
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
20/11/2026, 13:33, Bengaluru
Verified

- 57 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:64475
WP No. 35467 of 2025
C/W WP No. 10460 of 2022
WP No. 13395 of 2022
AND 3 OTHERS


CNR: KAHC010762852025


dispossessed. Thus, mere non- use may not
always entitle the tenant for suspension of rent.
32. The Tenants' application for suspension
of rent is thus liable to be rejected inasmuch
as while invoking the doctrine of suspension
of rent on the basis of a force majeure
event, it is clear from the submissions made
that the Tenants do not intend to surrender
the tenanted premises. While holding that
suspension of rent is not permissible in these
facts, some postponement or relaxation in
the schedule of payment can be granted
owing to the lockdown.

15.11. By relying on Ramanand , Sri P.D.Surana’s
submission is that mere fact that the leased
premises could not be used, or that their use
was temporarily interrupted on account of a
force majeure event, would not automatically
absolve the lessee from the obligation to pay
rent. He submits that, in the absence of a
contractual provision permitting suspension or
waiver of rent, the lessee would continue to be
bound by the obligation under Section 108(B)(l)
of the Transfer of Property Act, 1882. The
lessee can seek to avoid the lease under
Section 108(B)(e) only where the property is
wholly destroyed or rendered substantially and
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
20/11/2026, 13:33, Bengaluru
Verified

- 58 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:64475
WP No. 35467 of 2025
C/W WP No. 10460 of 2022
WP No. 13395 of 2022
AND 3 OTHERS


CNR: KAHC010762852025


permanently unfit for the purpose for which it
was leased, and such option is exercised by the
lessee. Mere non-use or temporary inability to
enjoy the premises would not, by itself, entitle
the lessee to suspend payment of rent. At best,
depending on the facts and circumstances, the
Court may consider granting some
postponement or relaxation in the schedule of
payment, without granting suspension of rent.
15.12. Sri P.D.Surana relies on the decision of the
Hon’ble Calcutta High Court in P.H. Avari v.
State of West Bengal AIR 1958 Calcutta
[
203], more particularly paragraph 11 thereof,
which is reproduced hereunder for easy
reference:
11. Reliability of official advice cannot in my
judgment alter the construction of the Statutes
and the Rules made thereunder. There can be
no estoppel against the Government on a
point of law and construction of statute.
Neither the Government nor this court will be
bound by interpretation of the Act and the Rules
made by the Collector of Excise. The law of this
country is what the Statute and rules thereunder
say and how the courts of the land interpret them
and not what a particular Government or
administrative officer says. If the Government
officer's interpretation is wrong, the party
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
20/11/2026, 13:33, Bengaluru
Verified

- 59 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:64475
WP No. 35467 of 2025
C/W WP No. 10460 of 2022
WP No. 13395 of 2022
AND 3 OTHERS


CNR: KAHC010762852025


acting on it takes the risk. This view that I am
taking is supported by the decision of the
American Supreme Court in Federal Crop
Insurance Corporation v. Merrill (1) (332 U.S.
380) in which the court held that a farmer could
not recover on insurance issued in violation of a
published regulation even though the application
for insurance had been approved by the local
agency of the Corporation. Similarly in Howell v.
Falmouth Boat Construction Ltd. (2) (1951) A.C.
837, the House of Lords says that the fact that a
Government officer in his dealings with the
subject may have assumed an authority, which
he did not possess, to grant a licence, does not
debar the Crown from enforcing a statutory
prohibition or entitle the subject to maintain that
there has been no breach of it. See the
observations of Lord Simonds at p. 845 of the
Report and Lord Normand at p. 849 of the same
Report. The Privy Council decision in Attorney
General for Ceylon v. A.D. Silva (3) is the latest
pronouncement on this subject and takes the
same view. In India the law insists that where
contracts or engagements are required to be in
particular forms with particular officers of
authority to sign them, that must be strictly
complied with in order to bind the government.
For obvious reasons the government and the
administration cannot like an ordinary person be
estopped by the acts of its numerous agents and
officers each parforming his work in a limited
sphere and with his specially limited authority
imposed by his very nature of work. Reference
may in this connection be made to s. 175 (3) of
the old Government of India Act. 1935 and the
present Article 299 of the Constitution and such
cases as Chaturbhuj v. Moreswar (4) [(1954)
S.C.A. 373] and Anath v. Dominion of India (5)
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
20/11/2026, 13:33, Bengaluru
Verified

- 60 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:64475
WP No. 35467 of 2025
C/W WP No. 10460 of 2022
WP No. 13395 of 2022
AND 3 OTHERS


CNR: KAHC010762852025


(A.I.R. 1955 Cal. 626). If the laws of the land are
to be found and taken from official
correspondence and official advise contained in
demi-official communication and circulars, then
the Constitution and the Statutes passed by the
constitutionally authorised institutions of
Parliament and State Legislatures will find their
substance and authority gravely imperilled,
supplanted and undermined, a situation which I
consider wholly inconsistent with the theory and
practice of Parliamentary democracy in India with
the courts as the exclusive constitutional organs
for interpreting the laws of the realm. I shall
conclude this branch of the argument by quoting
the following observations of Lord Simonds in
Howell's case (2) (supra) at p. 845 of the Report
to which I have already made a reference where
his lordship not only put the legal implications of
the reliability of official advice generally with
great clarity but also in particular examined the
case of such reliability even in criminal matters—
“The illegality of an act is the same whether or
not the actor has been misled by an assumption
of authority on the part of a Government officer,
however high or low in the hierarchy. I do not
doubt that in criminal proceedings it would be a
material factor that the actor had been thus
misled if knowledge was a necessary element of
the offence and in any case it would have a
bearing on the sentence imposed. But that is not
the question. The question is whether the
character of an act done in face of a statutory
prohibition is affected by the fact that it has been
induced by a misleading assumption of authority.
In my opinion the answer is clearly no. Such an
answer may make more difficult the task of the
citizen who is anxious to walk in the narrow way,
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
20/11/2026, 13:33, Bengaluru
Verified

- 61 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:64475
WP No. 35467 of 2025
C/W WP No. 10460 of 2022
WP No. 13395 of 2022
AND 3 OTHERS


CNR: KAHC010762852025


but that does not justify a different answer being
given.”
15.13. By relying on P.H. Avari, Sri P.D.Surana’s
submission is that there can be no estoppel
against the Government on a question of law or
statutory interpretation. The rights and
obligations of the parties must be determined
with reference to the statute and the rules
made thereunder, and not on the basis of any
interpretation or assurance given by an
administrative officer. An officer's incorrect
interpretation of a statutory provision cannot
confer a benefit or authority which the statute
does not contemplate, nor can it prevent the
Government from enforcing the statutory
provisions. Even where a person has acted on
the basis of such official advice, the illegality of
an act prohibited by statute does not stand
altered merely because the person was misled
by the officer's representation. Such reliance
may, however, be a relevant consideration
where knowledge is an essential ingredient of
the offence or while determining the
appropriate sentence.
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
20/11/2026, 13:33, Bengaluru
Verified

- 62 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:64475
WP No. 35467 of 2025
C/W WP No. 10460 of 2022
WP No. 13395 of 2022
AND 3 OTHERS


CNR: KAHC010762852025


15.14. Sri P.D.Surana relies on the decision of the
Hon’ble Andhra Pradesh High Court in
Rachapudi Subrahmanyam v. Collector
[ AIR 1974 Andhra Pradesh 55], more
particularly paragraph 54 thereof, which is
reproduced hereunder for easy reference:
54. This is the position of law regarding equitable
estoppel as we comprehend it to be. Bearing in
mind the principles of law enunciated above, we
must examine the facts of the present case. On a
careful examination of the proceedings of the
Collector and having regard to other facts and
circumstances of the case, it cannot be
legitimately contended that by the proceedings of
the Collector dated 12-4-1972 the petitioners or
any one of them were expressly or by necessary
implication assured that they would be supplied
with levy sugar which the Government of India
allots to the State Government. Even a casual
reading of the proceedings would indicate that
the petitioners were provisionally appointed as
fair price shop dealers. It is under this provisional
order that the petitioners were asked to furnish
deposit, to execute the agreement and complete
other necessary formalities. They were also
warned that if it is found that correct information
has not been provided, the allotment is liable to
be cancelled. The provisional allotment was
subject to the approval of the Government
Admittedly no such approval was granted. On the
other hand, the Government after having found
that more number of shops are not required, the
petitioners could not be authorised finally and
quota released to them. The agreements said to
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
20/11/2026, 13:33, Bengaluru
Verified

- 63 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:64475
WP No. 35467 of 2025
C/W WP No. 10460 of 2022
WP No. 13395 of 2022
AND 3 OTHERS


CNR: KAHC010762852025


have been executed by them were also not
approved by the Government. Furthermore, it has
to be borne in mind that the scheme of
distribution of levy sugar in reality is framed by
the Central Government. The Central Government
while allotting the quota to the States indicated
that for fair distribution of sugar the medium of
fair price shops should be adopted. What number
of shops are necessary to distribute the sugar in
a certain locality is for the Government to
determine. The registration of ration cards on the
foot of which sugar is distributed is in the hands
of the Government. Allotment of such cards to
individual fair price shops is also left with the
Government. What quota based upon these cards
should be given to a shop is also left with the
Government. In these circumstances, how can it
be contended that there was a firm, clear,
unambiguous and unequivocal representation
made by the Collector to the petitioners that in
any case under the provisional allotment of shops
they would get certain quota of sugar. Allotment
of fair price shops would entitle them to deal not
only in sugar which is a controlled commodity
because of the allotment; there is no restriction
whatsoever on these shops in dealing in other
food-grain permitted to be distributed through
these shops. Even non-levy sugar may be
available to them to deal in. We are therefore
satisfied that there was no representation
whatsoever made by the Collector or any
other officer that they would be given levy
sugar relying on which they could have
acted to their detriment thus binding the
Government by estoppel. It is seen that the
Collector was not competent, to finally allot the
shops and levy sugar quota without the prior
approval of the Government. The Government
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
20/11/2026, 13:33, Bengaluru
Verified

- 64 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:64475
WP No. 35467 of 2025
C/W WP No. 10460 of 2022
WP No. 13395 of 2022
AND 3 OTHERS


CNR: KAHC010762852025


had the necessary authority to keep in
abeyance or even cancel the provisional
allotment which was sought to be made by
the Collector. Application of doctrine of
estoppel therefore in the view which we
have taken about the law is not possible.
15.15. By relying on Rachapudi Subrahmanyam , Sri
P.D.Surana’s submission is that the doctrine of
equitable estoppel can be invoked against the
Government only where there is a clear, firm,
unambiguous and unequivocal representation
made by an authority competent to make such
representation, and the person seeking to
invoke the doctrine has acted upon it to his
detriment. A provisional or conditional order,
particularly one made subject to approval by a
higher authority, cannot be treated as a final
assurance giving rise to a claim of estoppel. He
submits that where the officer making the
representation lacks the authority to grant the
benefit or make the commitment in question,
no estoppel can operate against the
Government on the basis of such
representation. The Government cannot,
therefore, be prevented from exercising its
statutory powers merely because a person has
acted upon an expectation arising from an
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
20/11/2026, 13:33, Bengaluru
Verified

- 65 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:64475
WP No. 35467 of 2025
C/W WP No. 10460 of 2022
WP No. 13395 of 2022
AND 3 OTHERS


CNR: KAHC010762852025


unauthorised or conditional representation
made by an administrative officer.
15.16. Sri P.D.Surana relies on the decision of the
Hon'ble Supreme Court in P.C. Sethi v. Union
of India, AIR 1975 SC 2164], more
[
particularly paragraph 22 thereof, which is
reproduced hereunder for easy reference:
The petitioners also sought to take advantage
22.
of what they described as admission in
Government's affidavits filed in connection with
certain earlier proceedings of similar nature and
other admissions in Parliament on behalf of the
Government. We, are, however, unable to hold
that such admissions, if any, which are mere
expression of opinion limited to the context
and also being rather vague hopes, not
specific assurances, are binding on the
Government to create an estoppel.
15.17. By relying on P. C. Sethi , Sri P.D.Surana’s
submission is that mere statements or
admissions made in affidavits filed by the
Government in earlier proceedings, or
expressions made on behalf of the Government
in Parliament, cannot, by themselves, operate
as a representation giving rise to an estoppel
against the Government. He submits that such
statements, particularly where they are
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
20/11/2026, 13:33, Bengaluru
Verified

- 66 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:64475
WP No. 35467 of 2025
C/W WP No. 10460 of 2022
WP No. 13395 of 2022
AND 3 OTHERS


CNR: KAHC010762852025


expressions of opinion, confined to the context
of the proceedings in which they were made, or
merely indicate vague expectations rather than
specific assurances, cannot bind the
Government. For the doctrine of estoppel to
operate, there must be a clear and specific
representation capable of being relied upon; a
general expression of opinion or an uncertain
expectation cannot create an enforceable
assurance against the Government.
15.18. Sri P.D.Surana relies on the Central Coalfields
Ltd. v. SLL-SML (Joint Venture
Consortium) [(2016) 8 SCC 622] , more
particularly paragraphs 52 and 53 thereof,
which are reproduced hereunder for easy
reference:
52. There is a wholesome principle that the
courts have been following for a very long time
and which was articulated in Nazir Ahmad v. King
Emperor , namely : (SCC OnLine PC)
“… where a power is given to do a certain
thing in a certain way the thing must be
done in that way or not at all. Other
methods of performance are necessarily
forbidden. ”
There is no valid reason to give up this salutary
principle or not to apply it mutatis mutandis to
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
20/11/2026, 13:33, Bengaluru
Verified

- 67 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:64475
WP No. 35467 of 2025
C/W WP No. 10460 of 2022
WP No. 13395 of 2022
AND 3 OTHERS


CNR: KAHC010762852025


bid documents. This principle deserves to be
applied in contractual disputes, particularly in
commercial contracts or bids leading up to
commercial contracts, where there is stiff
competition. It must follow from the application
of the principle laid down in Nazir Ahmad that if
the employer prescribes a particular format of the
bank guarantee to be furnished, then a bidder
ought to submit the bank guarantee in that
particular format only and not in any other
format. However, as mentioned above, there is
no inflexibility in this regard and an employer
could deviate from the terms of the bid document
but only within the parameters mentioned above.
Nazir Ahmad has been followed in dozens of
53.
decisions rendered by this Court and by other
constitutional courts in the country. The Central
Vigilance Commission has accepted this principle
in a modified form as a guiding principle in its
circular dated 31-12-2007 wherein it is
mentioned that all organisations ought to evolve
a procedure for acceptance of bank guarantees
that is compatible with the guidelines of banks
and Reserve Bank of India. One such requirement
is that the bank guarantee should be in a proper
prescribed format and should be verified verbatim
on receipt with the original. Adherence to this
principle of verbatim verification would not only
avoid undue problems for the employer but would
also virtually eliminate subjectivity on the part of
the employer.
15.19. By relying on Central Coalfields Ltd. , Sri
P.D.Surana’s submission is that where a statute,
rule or contractual document prescribes a
particular manner in which an act is required to
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
20/11/2026, 13:33, Bengaluru
Verified

- 68 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:64475
WP No. 35467 of 2025
C/W WP No. 10460 of 2022
WP No. 13395 of 2022
AND 3 OTHERS


CNR: KAHC010762852025


be performed, such requirement must be
strictly complied with and the act cannot be
performed in any other manner. He submits
that the principle laid down in Nazir Ahmad v.
King Emperor—that where a power is conferred
to do a particular act in a prescribed manner, it
must be done in that manner or not at all—
applies with particular force to contractual and
commercial arrangements. Any deviation from
the prescribed terms or procedure can be
permitted only within the parameters
contemplated by the governing document and
cannot be founded upon an informal
understanding or an unauthorised relaxation.
He therefore contends that the parties must be
governed by the prescribed terms and
procedure, and no departure therefrom can be
recognised merely on the basis of an
inconsistent practice or representation.
15.20. Lastly, Sri P.D.Surana submits that there is no
force majeure event. The COVID-19 pandemic
did not stop the functioning of the business of
the petitioners. The petitioners continued to
function by using the premises belonging to
KSRTC, they did not surrender possession.
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
20/11/2026, 13:33, Bengaluru
Verified

- 69 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:64475
WP No. 35467 of 2025
C/W WP No. 10460 of 2022
WP No. 13395 of 2022
AND 3 OTHERS


CNR: KAHC010762852025


Having continued to be in possession and
having continued to use the premises of KSRTC,
the lease rental/license fee as agreed upon are
required to be paid by the petitioners. The
above writ petitions filed seeking for the relief
as sought for are not maintainable. There is no
public law remedy which the petitioners have
invoked so as to invoke the powers of this Court
under Articles 226 and 227 of the Constitution.
15.21. On all the above, he submits that all the writ
petitions are required to be dismissed.
16. Heard Sri P.N.Harish, learned counsel for the
petitioner and Smt.H.R.Renuka, learned counsel for
the respondents in W.P.No.35467/2025, Sri
R.P.Somashekharaiah, learned counsel for the
petitioners in W.P.No.10460/2022 and
W.P.No.13395/2022, Sri S. Saravana, learned counsel
for the petitioners in W.P.No.20426/2022, Sri Y.K.
Narayan Sharma, learned counsel for the petitioner
in W.P.No.7641/2023, Sri Dilip Kumar, learned
counsel for the petitioners in W.P.No.27997/2023 and
Sri P.D.Surana, learned counsel for the respondents-
KSRTC in all the matters. Perused papers.

Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
20/11/2026, 13:33, Bengaluru
Verified

- 70 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:64475
WP No. 35467 of 2025
C/W WP No. 10460 of 2022
WP No. 13395 of 2022
AND 3 OTHERS


CNR: KAHC010762852025


17. The points that would arise for consideration are:
i. Whether the writ petitions are maintainable
in view of the arbitration clause contained in
the Concession Agreement?

ii. Whether the communication dated
01.09.2021 constituted a final and binding
grant of concession by KSRTC for the months
of April, May and June 2021, whether the
authority issuing it was competent to do so,
and whether the concession extended to the
sub-lessees covered GST?
iii. Whether the COVID-19 pandemic and the
consequential restrictions attracted the Force
Majeure clause under Article 8 of the
Concession Agreement; and whether the
petitioners complied with the prescribed
procedure for invoking the clause, including
the requirements of notice, consultation and
mitigation, and the provisions relating to
termination under Article 9.4?
iv. Whether the petitioners' continued
possession of the premises, despite the
restrictions on business operations,
disentitled them from claiming suspension or
waiver of licence fee under the Concession
Agreement and Sections 108(B)(e) and
108(B)(I) of the Transfer of Property Act,
1882?
v. Whether the resolutions dated 21.03.2022
and 13.11.2024 withdrawing the concession
and directing recovery of the balance licence
fee, and the consequential demand notices,
are sustainable in law, having regard to the
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
20/11/2026, 13:33, Bengaluru
Verified

- 71 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:64475
WP No. 35467 of 2025
C/W WP No. 10460 of 2022
WP No. 13395 of 2022
AND 3 OTHERS


CNR: KAHC010762852025


authority of KSRTC to withdraw the
concession, the principles of natural justice,
and the doctrines of promissory estoppel and
legitimate expectation?
vi. Whether the petitioners in the respective
writ petitions are entitled to refund of their
security deposits, protection against
adjustment of the disputed dues, and
interest thereon?
vii. What order?

18. This Court answers the above points as follows:
19. Answer to Point No.(i): Whether the writ
petitions are maintainable in view of the
arbitration clause contained in the Concession
Agreement?
19.1. The case of the petitioners, as emerging from
the pleadings and their submissions on the
merits, is that the dispute is not confined to the
computation of licence fee or enforcement of
individual contractual obligations. They
challenge the resolutions of the KSRTC Board
dated 21.03.2022 and 13.11.2024, by which
the concession stated to have been extended to
licensees across the State was withdrawn and
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
20/11/2026, 13:33, Bengaluru
Verified

- 72 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:64475
WP No. 35467 of 2025
C/W WP No. 10460 of 2022
WP No. 13395 of 2022
AND 3 OTHERS


CNR: KAHC010762852025


recovery of the balance licence fee was
directed. They contend that the legality of such
a common administrative decision, particularly
its withdrawal without affording an opportunity
of hearing to the affected licensees, is open to
judicial review under Article 226 of the
Constitution.
19.2. Sri P.D. Surana, learned counsel appearing for

KSRTC, would submit that Clause 12.3 of the
Concession Agreement provides for resolution
of disputes between the parties by arbitration
before the Managing Director of BMTC, who is
designated as the sole arbitrator. The decision
of the arbitrator is declared final and binding on
the parties. He would contend that claims
relating to refund of licence fee, security
deposits, adjustment of rentals and other
consequential monetary reliefs arise directly out
of the contractual relationship and must,
therefore, be agitated before the agreed arbitral
forum and not in writ proceedings.
19.3. Clause 12.3.1 of the Concession Agreement
reads as follows:

Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
20/11/2026, 13:33, Bengaluru
Verified

- 73 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:64475
WP No. 35467 of 2025
C/W WP No. 10460 of 2022
WP No. 13395 of 2022
AND 3 OTHERS


CNR: KAHC010762852025


"12.3 Dispute Resolution Procedure
12.3.1 Arbitration
(i) in the event any dispute or differences or
claim's the case may be arising between the
parties, the same shall be referred to the
Managing Director of the BMTC for resolution and
the Managing Director of BMTC shall be the sole
arbitrator. The arbitrator shall resolve the dispute
between the parties under the arbitration and
Conciliation Act-1996. The decision of the
arbitrator shall be final and binding on both the
parties."
19.4. On a plain reading, the clause provides that any
dispute, difference or claim arising between the
parties to the Concession Agreement shall be
referred to the Managing Director of BMTC for
resolution by arbitration under the Arbitration
and Conciliation Act, 1996. The decision of the
arbitrator is made final and binding on both
parties.
19.5. The existence of an arbitration clause does not
oust the constitutional jurisdiction of this Court
under Article 226. However, the exercise of that
jurisdiction is discretionary. Where parties have
agreed upon a specific mechanism for resolving
their disputes, the writ Court will ordinarily
require them to pursue that remedy.
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
20/11/2026, 13:33, Bengaluru
Verified

- 74 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:64475
WP No. 35467 of 2025
C/W WP No. 10460 of 2022
WP No. 13395 of 2022
AND 3 OTHERS


CNR: KAHC010762852025


19.6. The jurisdiction under Article 226 is not
excluded merely because the dispute arises out
of a contract, however the Court must exercise
that jurisdiction with circumspection.
19.7. The existence of an arbitration clause is viewed
as a near bar to entertaining a writ petition.
Ordinarily, the Court will not exercise its
discretion where the dispute is purely
contractual, the agreement provides a specific
mechanism for its resolution, or the
determination of the controversy requires
adjudication of serious and complex disputed
questions of fact. A contractual dispute must
have a genuine public-law element before the
jurisdiction under Article 226 can be invoked. A
mere allegation of breach of contract or
arbitrariness, without more, is not sufficient.
19.8. At the same time, the State and its

instrumentalities remain bound by the
requirements of fairness and non-arbitrariness
even in their contractual dealings. Where the
action challenged is palpably arbitrary,
unauthorised or contrary to the principles of
natural justice, judicial review is not excluded
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
20/11/2026, 13:33, Bengaluru
Verified

- 75 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:64475
WP No. 35467 of 2025
C/W WP No. 10460 of 2022
WP No. 13395 of 2022
AND 3 OTHERS


CNR: KAHC010762852025


merely because the dispute has arisen in the
course of a contractual relationship.
19.9. Applying these principles, the nature of the
challenge in the present writ petitions assumes
significance. The petitioners do not merely
dispute the computation of licence fee or the
amount recoverable under their respective
agreements. They challenge the resolutions
dated 21.03.2022 and 13.11.2024, contending
that KSRTC had extended a concession in
respect of the licence fee for April, May and
June 2021 through the communication dated
01.09.2021 and that the subsequent withdrawal
of the concession, without affording an
opportunity of hearing to the affected licensees,
is arbitrary and contrary to Article 14 of the
Constitution.
19.10. KSRTC disputes this foundational assertion. Its

case is that the communication dated
01.09.2021 was only an internal communication
recording the recommendation of the CCG and
that the Board of Directors, being the
competent authority, rejected the
recommendation at its 447th meeting held on
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
20/11/2026, 13:33, Bengaluru
Verified

- 76 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:64475
WP No. 35467 of 2025
C/W WP No. 10460 of 2022
WP No. 13395 of 2022
AND 3 OTHERS


CNR: KAHC010762852025


21.03.2022 and resolved to recover the full
licence fee. Thus, the nature and effect of the
communication dated 01.09.2021, the authority
under which it was issued and the legal effect
of the subsequent Board resolutions are central
to the controversy.
19.11. The challenge to the authority of KSRTC to
withdraw the concession, the manner in which
the Board exercised its power and the alleged
failure to afford an opportunity of hearing are
matters which, if established from the
contemporaneous records, attract the scrutiny
of this Court under Article 226. These questions
cannot be rejected at the threshold merely on
the ground that the underlying relationship
between the parties is contractual. At the same
time, the mere fact that the impugned
resolutions affect several licensees does not, by
itself, take the dispute outside the contractual
framework. What is material is whether the
challenge raises a genuine issue of arbitrary
exercise of public power and whether that issue
can be determined on the basis of the
documents and admitted circumstances,
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
20/11/2026, 13:33, Bengaluru
Verified

- 77 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:64475
WP No. 35467 of 2025
C/W WP No. 10460 of 2022
WP No. 13395 of 2022
AND 3 OTHERS


CNR: KAHC010762852025


without requiring an elaborate evidentiary
inquiry.
19.12. This Court must also distinguish the challenge
to the common administrative decisions from
the individual contractual claims. The claims
relating to computation of licence fee, GST,
adjustment of rentals, refund of security
deposits, interest and other monetary
entitlements arise from the respective
contractual arrangements. Such claims would
ordinarily fall within the agreed dispute-
resolution mechanism, wherever the arbitration
clause is applicable. Insofar as the principal
concessionaire, KSMZ Properties Private
Limited, is concerned, it is a party to the
Concession Agreement and is bound by Clause
12.3.1 in respect of disputes falling within its
scope. The sub-lessees are also bound by it on
account of their contracts being mutatis
mutandis.
19.13. The objection raised by KSRTC is, therefore, not
sufficient to non-suit the petitioners at the
threshold. The existence of Clause 12.3.1 does
not constitute an absolute bar to examining the
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
20/11/2026, 13:33, Bengaluru
Verified

- 78 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:64475
WP No. 35467 of 2025
C/W WP No. 10460 of 2022
WP No. 13395 of 2022
AND 3 OTHERS


CNR: KAHC010762852025


legality of the Board resolutions dated
21.03.2022 and 13.11.2024 on grounds
involving a genuine public-law element.
However, this does not confer an unrestricted
right upon the petitioners to have every
individual contractual claim adjudicated in these
writ petitions. Those claims shall remain subject
to the agreed dispute-resolution mechanism,
wherever applicable. The extent to which the
petitioners are entitled to relief in respect of the
impugned resolutions and the consequential
demands will be determined on the merits of
the respective cases.
19.14. For the foregoing reasons, this Court answers
point no. (i) by holding that the arbitration
clause contained in Clause 12.3.1 of the
Concession Agreement does not, by itself, bar
these writ petitions insofar as they challenge
the legality of the common administrative
decisions of KSRTC on grounds falling within the
scope of judicial review under Article 226 of the
Constitution. The individual contractual claims
of the petitioners remain subject to the dispute-
resolution mechanism contained in the
applicable agreements.
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
20/11/2026, 13:33, Bengaluru
Verified

- 79 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:64475
WP No. 35467 of 2025
C/W WP No. 10460 of 2022
WP No. 13395 of 2022
AND 3 OTHERS


CNR: KAHC010762852025


20. Answer to Point No.(ii): Whether the
communication dated 01.09.2021 constituted a
final and binding grant of concession by KSRTC
for the months of April, May and June 2021,
whether the authority issuing it was competent
to do so, and whether the concession extended
to the sub-lessees covered GST?
20.1. Sri P.N. Harish, learned counsel for the

petitioner in W.P. No.35467/2025, submits that
the lockdown and curfew imposed during the
COVID-19 pandemic brought business activities
to a standstill, including the businesses carried
on in the shops in question. He submits that
KSRTC, having taken into account the
disruption to business, the absence of buses at
the bus stands and the resulting absence of
customers, issued the communication dated
01.09.2021 through the Divisional Controller.
The communication was addressed to the
Divisional Controllers across the State and
provided for a concession in the licence fee.
According to him, the concession granted to
KSMZ, the principal concessionaire, was passed
on to the sub-lessees. KSMZ was itself unable
to recover the full rentals from the sub-lessees
and, therefore, could not be required to pay the
full licence fee to KSRTC.
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
20/11/2026, 13:33, Bengaluru
Verified

- 80 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:64475
WP No. 35467 of 2025
C/W WP No. 10460 of 2022
WP No. 13395 of 2022
AND 3 OTHERS


CNR: KAHC010762852025


20.2. Sri R.P. Somashekharaiah, learned counsel for
the petitioners in W.P. Nos.10460/2022 and
13395/2022, adopts the above submissions. He
further submits that the difficulties faced by the
sub-lessees were placed before the CCG and
that, considering their circumstances, a
concession was granted for the period from
April to June 2021 by reducing the licence fee
by 70% for April and June and granting a 100%
exemption for May 2021. He also submits that,
at a subsequent meeting held on 04.09.2021,
GST was waived on the ground that no rentals
were payable for the relevant period. On this
basis, he contends that the notice dated
06.04.2022 and the subsequent demand
notices, which call upon the sub-lessees to pay
the full licence fee for the said period, are
unsustainable.
20.3. Sri S. Saravana, learned counsel for the
petitioners in W.P. No.20426/2022, submits that
the sub-lessees had made representations
dated 19.06.2021, 01.07.2021, 26.07.2021 and
23.08.2021, referring to the concessions
granted by the Railway Department. According
to him, the communication dated 01.09.2021
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
20/11/2026, 13:33, Bengaluru
Verified

- 81 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:64475
WP No. 35467 of 2025
C/W WP No. 10460 of 2022
WP No. 13395 of 2022
AND 3 OTHERS


CNR: KAHC010762852025


was issued in response to these representations
and provided for a 70% concession in the
licence fee for the period from April to June
2021, with only 30% of the licence fee being
collected.
20.4. Sri Y.K. Narayan Sharma, learned counsel for
the petitioner in W.P. No.7641/2023, adopts the
above submissions. He further submits that the
communication was issued by the concerned
authority to all Divisional Controllers and was
acted upon by the field officers. The petitioner
and the other sub-lessees were, therefore,
entitled to proceed on the basis that the
concession had been validly granted by KSRTC.
20.5. Sri P.D. Surana, learned counsel for KSRTC,
disputes the petitioners’ interpretation of the
communication dated 01.09.2021. He submits
that it was an internal communication between
the officers of KSRTC and was never issued to
the concessionaire or the sub-lessees as an
order granting them any concession. According
to him, the communication merely conveyed a
recommendation of the CCG, which was
subsequently placed before the Board of
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
20/11/2026, 13:33, Bengaluru
Verified

- 82 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:64475
WP No. 35467 of 2025
C/W WP No. 10460 of 2022
WP No. 13395 of 2022
AND 3 OTHERS


CNR: KAHC010762852025


Directors on 21.03.2022. The Board rejected
the recommendation and resolved to collect the
full licence fee.
20.6. He further submits that the CCG had no
authority to grant such a concession on behalf
of KSRTC and that the decision could be taken
only by the Board of Directors. The
communication dated 01.09.2021, therefore,
did not create any enforceable right in favour of
the petitioners. Once the Board resolved to
recover the full licence fee, the concessionaire
and the sub-lessees were liable to pay the
outstanding amounts in full.
20.7. The rival submissions raise four issues: the
nature and effect of the communication dated
01.09.2021; the authority of the officers who
issued and acted upon it; the extent to which
the concession applied to the sub-lessees; and
whether the concession extended to GST.
20.8. The communication dated 01.09.2021 is
extracted above. On a plain reading, it is
addressed to all Senior and Divisional
Controllers of KSRTC and refers to a decision
taken at the CCG meeting held on 27.08.2021
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
20/11/2026, 13:33, Bengaluru
Verified

- 83 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:64475
WP No. 35467 of 2025
C/W WP No. 10460 of 2022
WP No. 13395 of 2022
AND 3 OTHERS


CNR: KAHC010762852025


under the chairmanship of the Managing
Director. It records that a concession in the
monthly licence fee would be granted to all
licensees, except ATM counter and mobile tower
licensees, for the period from April to June
2021. It also provides that licensees having
arrears for the said period could pay the
amount by 15.09.2021 without interest. The
communication expressly states that there
would be no exemption from payment of GST
and that no concession in licence fee would be
available from July 2021 onwards.
20.9. The communication must be read as granting
relief for the entire period from April to June
2021. The petitioners’ case is that the
concession was implemented by allowing a 70%
reduction for April and June and a complete
exemption for May. KSRTC’s subsequent
demand notices also treat April, May and June
2021 as one continuous period for the purpose
of recovering the alleged arrears. The nature
and extent of the concession, therefore, have to
be considered with reference not only to the
communication but also to the manner in which
KSRTC acted upon it.
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
20/11/2026, 13:33, Bengaluru
Verified

- 84 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:64475
WP No. 35467 of 2025
C/W WP No. 10460 of 2022
WP No. 13395 of 2022
AND 3 OTHERS


CNR: KAHC010762852025


20.10. This Court is unable to accept the submission of
Sri P.D. Surana that the communication dated
01.09.2021 was a mere internal
recommendation incapable of creating any
right. The communication was addressed to the
field officers of KSRTC for the specific purpose
of being acted upon in their dealings with
licensees. It was not merely an
uncommunicated proposal or an internal note.
The petitioners contend that the concession was
implemented by the field officers and that the
licensees, including KSMZ, were permitted to
pay the reduced licence fee for the period from
April to June 2021. KSRTC began demanding
the balance amounts only in 2022, several
months after the communication was issued.
20.11. The manner in which the communication was
acted upon is relevant in determining its legal
effect. An administrative decision
communicated to the officers concerned and
implemented by them cannot be treated, after
the event, as though it had never taken effect
merely because KSRTC subsequently describes
it as a recommendation. KSRTC cannot
disregard the representation made through its
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
20/11/2026, 13:33, Bengaluru
Verified

- 85 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:64475
WP No. 35467 of 2025
C/W WP No. 10460 of 2022
WP No. 13395 of 2022
AND 3 OTHERS


CNR: KAHC010762852025


own administrative machinery without
establishing the basis on which the
communication was issued and the authority
under which it was implemented.
20.12. As regards the competence of the authority
issuing the communication, Sri P.D. Surana
submits that only the Board of Directors could
decide on behalf of KSRTC and that the CCG
had no such power. However, no regulation,
rule of business, resolution or delegation of
powers has been placed before this Court to
establish the respective powers of the Board,
the CCG, the Managing Director or the Chief
Traffic Manager in matters relating to
concessions in licence fee.
20.13. The relevant rules governing the internal
allocation of powers and the records relating to
the constitution and functions of the CCG are
matters within the knowledge and custody of
KSRTC. Having disputed the authority of the
officers who issued and implemented the
communication, KSRTC was required to place
the relevant material before this Court. In the
absence of such material, its contention that
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
20/11/2026, 13:33, Bengaluru
Verified

- 86 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:64475
WP No. 35467 of 2025
C/W WP No. 10460 of 2022
WP No. 13395 of 2022
AND 3 OTHERS


CNR: KAHC010762852025


the CCG and the officers concerned had no
authority cannot be accepted merely on the
basis of an assertion.
20.14. The communication was addressed to the field
officers across the State and was intended to
govern the treatment of the specified category
of licensees during the relevant period. KSRTC,
having permitted its officers to act on that
communication, cannot disown it without
establishing that the decision was beyond the
authority of the officers concerned and action
having been taken against such officers for
having acted beyond their authority. On the
material placed before this Court, the
communication carried the authority of KSRTC
for the purpose for which it was issued, and the
petitioners were entitled to act upon it in good
faith. The consequences of the subsequent
decision of the Board dated 21.03.2022 are
considered separately under Point No.(v).
20.15. Sri S. Saravana, learned counsel for the
petitioners, relies upon the decision in GNCT of
Delhi v. Naresh Kumar [2010 SCC OnLine Del
3942], particularly paragraph 22, in support of
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
20/11/2026, 13:33, Bengaluru
Verified

- 87 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:64475
WP No. 35467 of 2025
C/W WP No. 10460 of 2022
WP No. 13395 of 2022
AND 3 OTHERS


CNR: KAHC010762852025


the proposition that an express representation
made by a public authority may give rise to a
legitimate expectation.
20.16. The principle relied upon is relevant to the
present case. KSRTC, through a communication
addressed to its own field officers, represented
that a concession in licence fee would be
extended to the specified category of licensees
for the period from April to June 2021. The
petitioners contend that the officers acted upon
that communication and that the licensees
arranged their payments on that basis. Once
such a representation was made and acted
upon, KSRTC could not subsequently disregard
it merely by describing it as an internal
recommendation. The principle of legitimate
expectation, therefore, supports the petitioners’
contention that the representation made by
KSRTC cannot be withdrawn or disregarded
arbitrarily. The legality of the subsequent
decision of the Board and the manner in which
it was given effect to are considered under
Point No.(v).
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
20/11/2026, 13:33, Bengaluru
Verified

- 88 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:64475
WP No. 35467 of 2025
C/W WP No. 10460 of 2022
WP No. 13395 of 2022
AND 3 OTHERS


CNR: KAHC010762852025


20.17. This Court accordingly finds that the
communication dated 01.09.2021 constituted
an administrative decision of KSRTC granting a
concession in licence fee for the entire period
from April to June 2021. The concession
covered the licensees specified in the
communication, other than ATM counter and
mobile tower licensees. The concession was
implemented through the field officers of KSRTC
and cannot be treated as a mere
recommendation having no legal effect.
20.18. The concession for the period from April to June
2021 was at the rate of 70% for April and June
and a complete exemption for May 2021.
KSRTC, having communicated and acted upon
the concession through its administrative
machinery, was bound by the representation
made to the licensees, subject to the question
whether it could subsequently be withdrawn or
modified by the Board in accordance with law.
20.19. The next question is whether the concession
extended to the sub-lessees. The admitted facts
show that KSMZ granted sub-leases in respect
of the premises forming part of the concession
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
20/11/2026, 13:33, Bengaluru
Verified

- 89 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:64475
WP No. 35467 of 2025
C/W WP No. 10460 of 2022
WP No. 13395 of 2022
AND 3 OTHERS


CNR: KAHC010762852025


granted to it by KSRTC. The sub-leases were
back-to-back arrangements, and the terms of
the principal concession agreement were made
applicable, mutatis mutandis, to the sub-leases.
20.20. In such circumstances, the concession granted
in respect of the licence fee payable for the
premises cannot be considered in isolation from
the corresponding sub-lease arrangements. The
sub-lessees occupied the premises under
arrangements linked to the principal
concession. To the extent that their liability was
linked to the licence fee payable by KSMZ to
KSRTC, the benefit of the concession granted
by KSRTC must also be reflected in the
amounts recoverable from them. Otherwise, the
benefit of the concession would remain with the
principal concessionaire, even though the sub-
lessees occupied the premises and bore the
corresponding financial liability.
20.21. Accordingly, the concession granted for the
period from April to June 2021 extends to the
sub-lessees on the same basis, subject to the
terms of their respective sub-lease agreements
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
20/11/2026, 13:33, Bengaluru
Verified

- 90 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:64475
WP No. 35467 of 2025
C/W WP No. 10460 of 2022
WP No. 13395 of 2022
AND 3 OTHERS


CNR: KAHC010762852025


and the extent to which their liability was linked
to the licence fee payable by KSMZ.
20.22. The question whether the concession extended
to GST admits of a different answer. The
communication dated 01.09.2021 expressly
states that there would be no exemption from
payment of GST. The submission of Sri R.P.
Somashekharaiah, learned counsel for the
petitioners, that GST was also waived at a
meeting held on 04.09.2021 is based on a
separate alleged decision.
20.23. In the absence of any supporting record, this
Court cannot accept the claim of waiver of GST,
particularly when the communication dated
01.09.2021 expressly excludes GST from the
concession. The concession granted for the
period from April to June 2021 must, therefore,
be confined to the licence fee and cannot be
extended to GST on the basis of the material
presently available.
20.24. This Court answers Point No.(ii) by holding that
the communication dated 01.09.2021
constituted an administrative decision of KSRTC
granting a concession in licence fee for the
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
20/11/2026, 13:33, Bengaluru
Verified

- 91 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:64475
WP No. 35467 of 2025
C/W WP No. 10460 of 2022
WP No. 13395 of 2022
AND 3 OTHERS


CNR: KAHC010762852025


entire period from April to June 2021,
comprising a 70% concession for April and June
and a 100% exemption for May 2021. The
concession applied to the categories of
licensees specified in the communication, other
than ATM counter and mobile tower licensees.
KSRTC cannot avoid the effect of the
communication merely by describing it as an
internal recommendation, particularly when it
was addressed to the field officers for
implementation and was acted upon by them.
The corresponding benefit of the concession
extends to the sub-lessees to the extent
provided by their respective back-to-back
arrangements with KSMZ.
20.25. The concession did not extend to GST, as the
communication dated 01.09.2021 expressly
excludes GST from the relief. The claim of a
further waiver of GST at the alleged meeting
held on 04.09.2021 is not established by the
material placed before this Court.
21. Answer to Point No.(iii): Whether the COVID-19
pandemic and the consequential restrictions
attracted the Force Majeure clause under
Article 8 of the Concession Agreement; and
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
20/11/2026, 13:33, Bengaluru
Verified

- 92 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:64475
WP No. 35467 of 2025
C/W WP No. 10460 of 2022
WP No. 13395 of 2022
AND 3 OTHERS


CNR: KAHC010762852025


whether the petitioners complied with the
prescribed procedure for invoking the clause,
including the requirements of notice,
consultation and mitigation, and the provisions
relating to termination under Article 9.4?
21.1. Sri P.N. Harish, learned counsel for the
petitioner in W.P. No.35467/2025, submits that
the complete lockdown and curfew imposed on
account of the COVID-19 pandemic brought
business activities to a standstill, including the
businesses carried on in the shops in question.
He submits that KSRTC itself recognised the
impact of the pandemic on its licensees and
granted a concession through the
communication dated 01.09.2021.
21.2. Sri R.P. Somashekharaiah, learned counsel for
the petitioners in W.P. Nos.10460/2022 and
13395/2022, further submits that KSRTC
employees, including drivers and conductors,
went on strike from 07.04.2021 to 21.04.2021.
Thereafter, owing to the second wave of
COVID-19, the State Government imposed a
complete lockdown from 21.04.2021 to
20.06.2021, during which the petitioners could
not carry on their businesses. He submits that
these circumstances constituted a Force
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
20/11/2026, 13:33, Bengaluru
Verified

- 93 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:64475
WP No. 35467 of 2025
C/W WP No. 10460 of 2022
WP No. 13395 of 2022
AND 3 OTHERS


CNR: KAHC010762852025


Majeure event under Article 8 of the Concession
Agreement and that the petitioners cannot be
treated as having defaulted in payment of the
full licence fee for the period during which their
businesses were affected.
21.3. Sri Y.K. Narayan Sharma, learned counsel for
the petitioner in W.P. No.7641/2023, submits
that the pandemic made it impossible for the
petitioner to perform his obligations under the
agreement and that the agreement must,
therefore, be treated as having been frustrated.
He contends that the pandemic and the
consequential restrictions constituted vis major
and that the non-payment of the full rentals
cannot be treated as a contractual default.
21.4. Sri P.D. Surana, learned counsel for KSRTC,
submits that the petitioners never invoked the
Force Majeure clause under Article 8 of the
Concession Agreement. He points out that
Article 8 prescribes a specific procedure. The
affected party is required to issue a notice
within seven days of the occurrence of the
Force Majeure event, setting out the nature of
the event and its impact. On receipt of such
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
20/11/2026, 13:33, Bengaluru
Verified

- 94 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:64475
WP No. 35467 of 2025
C/W WP No. 10460 of 2022
WP No. 13395 of 2022
AND 3 OTHERS


CNR: KAHC010762852025


notice, the parties are required to meet within
five days to assess the consequences of the
event, determine its likely duration and
consider measures for mitigating its impact.
According to him, none of the petitioners
followed this procedure and, therefore, they
cannot claim relief under Article 8.
21.5. He further relies on Article 9.4 and submits that

where a Force Majeure event continues for
more than thirty days and remains unresolved
for 120 days, either party may issue a notice of
intention to terminate the agreement. No such
notice was issued by either side. The
petitioners, therefore, cannot rely on the
pandemic to avoid their contractual liability
while continuing to occupy the licensed
premises.
21.6. Sri P.D. Surana also relies on Central

Coalfields Ltd. v. SLL-SML (Joint Venture
Consortium) [(2016) 8 SCC 622], particularly
paragraphs 52 and 53, for the principle that
where a power is required to be exercised in a
particular manner, it must be exercised in that
manner or not at all. He submits that this
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
20/11/2026, 13:33, Bengaluru
Verified

- 95 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:64475
WP No. 35467 of 2025
C/W WP No. 10460 of 2022
WP No. 13395 of 2022
AND 3 OTHERS


CNR: KAHC010762852025


principle applies equally to contractual and
commercial arrangements and that the
petitioners cannot claim the benefit of Article 8
without following the procedure prescribed
therein.
21.7. The dispute under this Point concerns the
application of Articles 8 and 9.4 of the
Concession Agreement. These are contractual
provisions and are required to be interpreted in
the light of their terms and the circumstances
placed before this Court.
21.8. Article 8 of the Concession Agreement is
extracted above. Article 8.1 defines a Force
Majeure event as an event beyond the
reasonable control of the affected party, which
the party is unable to overcome despite the
exercise of due diligence and which has a
Material Adverse Effect on the performance of
its obligations.
21.9. Among the Non-Political Events specified in
Article 8.1.1, clause (c) expressly includes an
"epidemic and famine". Clause (e) covers a
State-wide strike, while clause (g) includes an
event or circumstance analogous to those
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
20/11/2026, 13:33, Bengaluru
Verified

- 96 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:64475
WP No. 35467 of 2025
C/W WP No. 10460 of 2022
WP No. 13395 of 2022
AND 3 OTHERS


CNR: KAHC010762852025


specifically listed. The strike by KSRTC
employees between 07.04.2021 and
21.04.2021 and the lockdown and curfew
imposed by the Government following the
outbreak of the pandemic are, therefore,
required to be examined under these
provisions. Clause (d), which deals with war,
invasion and similar events, has no application
to the present facts.
21.10. Article 8 also prescribes the procedure to be
followed by a party seeking to rely upon a Force
Majeure event. Under Article 8.3, the affected
party is required to give written notice within
seven days of the occurrence of the event or of
acquiring knowledge of it. The notice must set
out the nature of the event, its likely duration,
the manner in which performance is affected
and the steps proposed or taken to mitigate its
consequences. The parties are thereafter
required to meet within the period prescribed
under the agreement to assess the impact of
the event and consider appropriate measures.
The affected party is also required to take
reasonable steps to mitigate the consequences
and resume performance when the
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
20/11/2026, 13:33, Bengaluru
Verified

- 97 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:64475
WP No. 35467 of 2025
C/W WP No. 10460 of 2022
WP No. 13395 of 2022
AND 3 OTHERS


CNR: KAHC010762852025


circumstances permit. Thus, Article 8 not only
identifies the events that may constitute Force
Majeure but also prescribes the procedure and
conditions for obtaining relief on that basis.
21.11. The COVID-19 pandemic was not only an
epidemic within the meaning of Article 8.1.1(c),
but was a pandemic, higher than an epidemic.
21.12. The State-wide strike by KSRTC employees
between 07.04.2021 and 21.04.2021 is also
covered by clause (e), subject to the conditions
specified in Article 8.1.
21.13. The lockdown and curfew imposed by the
Government, which followed the outbreak of
the pandemic, fall within the scope of clause
(g), being circumstances analogous to the
events expressly listed in Article 8.1.1.
21.14. The restrictions imposed during the relevant
period were beyond the reasonable control of
the petitioners. The closure of business
establishments, the suspension or substantial
reduction of bus services and the resulting
absence of customers materially affected the
businesses carried on at the bus terminals.
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
20/11/2026, 13:33, Bengaluru
Verified

- 98 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:64475
WP No. 35467 of 2025
C/W WP No. 10460 of 2022
WP No. 13395 of 2022
AND 3 OTHERS


CNR: KAHC010762852025


These circumstances could not have been
avoided or overcome by the petitioners through
the exercise of due diligence. They also had a
direct adverse effect on the commercial
activities for which the licensed premises had
been taken.
21.15. This Court, therefore, holds that the COVID-19
pandemic and the consequential restrictions,
together with the State-wide strike relied upon
by the petitioners, answer the description of
Force Majeure events under Article 8.1.1(c), (e)
and (g), subject to the conditions contained in
Article 8.1.
21.16. The existence of a Force Majeure event,
however, does not by itself dispense with the
procedure prescribed under Article 8.3. The
agreement requires the affected party to issue
written notice within seven days and to comply
with the subsequent requirements of
consultation, assessment and mitigation. Article
8.3.2 provides for the excuse of performance
only to the extent that the affected party is
unable to perform its obligations on account of
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
20/11/2026, 13:33, Bengaluru
Verified

- 99 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:64475
WP No. 35467 of 2025
C/W WP No. 10460 of 2022
WP No. 13395 of 2022
AND 3 OTHERS


CNR: KAHC010762852025


the Force Majeure event, in accordance with the
contractual procedure.
21.17. Sri P.D. Surana is, therefore, right in contending
that the petitioners have not produced any
notice issued to KSRTC under Article 8.3.1
formally invoking the Force Majeure clause.
There is also no material to show that the
petitioners sought or participated in the
consultation contemplated under Article 8.3, or
furnished the information and updates required
under that provision.
21.18. The principle stated in Central Coalfields Ltd ,
particularly paragraphs 52 and 53, that where a
contractual provision prescribes a particular
manner of doing an act, it must be done in that
manner, is relevant. Article 8.3 prescribes the
manner in which a party must notify and rely
upon a Force Majeure event. A party seeking
independent contractual relief under that
provision cannot ordinarily bypass the
stipulated procedure and claim its benefit
merely by referring to the occurrence of a
pandemic.
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
20/11/2026, 13:33, Bengaluru
Verified

- 100 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:64475
WP No. 35467 of 2025
C/W WP No. 10460 of 2022
WP No. 13395 of 2022
AND 3 OTHERS


CNR: KAHC010762852025


21.19. However, the above conclusion must be
understood in the context of the concession
independently granted by KSRTC. The
petitioners are not relying solely upon an
independent invocation of Article 8 for the relief
granted through the communication dated
01.09.2021. As considered under Point No.(ii),
KSRTC itself communicated a concession in
licence fee for the period from April to June
2021 and its field officers were expected to act
upon that decision.
21.20. The concession was, therefore, a relief granted
by KSRTC through its own administrative
decision. Its legal effect does not depend upon
whether each licensee had separately issued a
notice invoking Article 8. KSRTC cannot rely
upon the absence of an individual Force
Majeure notice to deny a concession that it had
itself communicated and implemented. At the
same time, the petitioners cannot rely upon the
general occurrence of the pandemic, without
complying with Article 8.3, to claim any
additional contractual relief beyond the
concession granted by KSRTC.
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
20/11/2026, 13:33, Bengaluru
Verified

- 101 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:64475
WP No. 35467 of 2025
C/W WP No. 10460 of 2022
WP No. 13395 of 2022
AND 3 OTHERS


CNR: KAHC010762852025


21.21. The principle in Central Coalfields Ltd ., does
not alter this position. The petitioners cannot
disregard the procedure prescribed under
Article 8 when seeking relief under that Clause.
Equally, KSRTC cannot disregard the legal effect
of the separate concession communicated by it
merely because the petitioners did not invoke
Article 8 in the prescribed manner.
21.22. Accordingly, the pandemic and the
consequential restrictions constituted Force
Majeure events within the meaning of Article
8.1.1. However, the petitioners have not shown
that they independently invoked Article 8.3 by
issuing the prescribed notices and complying
with the requirements of consultation and
mitigation. They are, therefore, not entitled to
claim any further relief under Article 8 beyond
the concession independently granted by
KSRTC through the communication dated
01.09.2021.
21.23. The next question concerns Article 9.4, which is
extracted above. Article 9.4 provides for
termination of the Concession Agreement
where a Force Majeure event continues for
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
20/11/2026, 13:33, Bengaluru
Verified

- 102 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:64475
WP No. 35467 of 2025
C/W WP No. 10460 of 2022
WP No. 13395 of 2022
AND 3 OTHERS


CNR: KAHC010762852025


more than thirty days and remains unresolved
for 120 days. In such circumstances, either
party may issue a notice of intention to
terminate in accordance with the terms of that
provision.
21.24. It is not disputed that neither KSRTC nor any of
the petitioners issued a notice of intention to
terminate under Article 9.4. On the contrary,
the petitioners continued to occupy the licensed
premises, or did so until the respective dates of
surrender pleaded by them. Article 9.4 provides
a mechanism for bringing the agreement to an
end on account of a prolonged Force Majeure
event. It does not, by itself, provide for
suspension or reduction of licence fee during
the subsistence of the agreement. The present
dispute concerns the liability to pay licence fee
while the contractual arrangements continued.
In the absence of any notice of intention to
terminate under Article 9.4, that provision does
not assist the petitioners in avoiding their
contractual obligations.
21.25. The above findings also answer the submission
of Sri Y.K. Narayan Sharma, learned counsel for
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
20/11/2026, 13:33, Bengaluru
Verified

- 103 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:64475
WP No. 35467 of 2025
C/W WP No. 10460 of 2022
WP No. 13395 of 2022
AND 3 OTHERS


CNR: KAHC010762852025


the petitioner in W.P. No.7641/2023, that the
pandemic made performance of the agreement
impossible and that the agreement must be
treated as having been frustrated.
21.26. The parties had expressly provided for events
beyond their control through Article 8 and had
also prescribed a mechanism for termination
where such an event continued for the period
specified in Article 9.4. The rights and
obligations of the parties in relation to the Force
Majeure event must, therefore, be considered
with reference to these contractual provisions.
The petitioner has not shown that the
agreement was terminated in accordance with
Article 9.4 or that it otherwise came to an end
on account of frustration.
21.27. On the petitioner's own case, he sought to
surrender the licensed premises because of the
difficulties faced in carrying on the business,
and KSRTC accepted the surrender. Such
surrender, if accepted by KSRTC, constitutes an
exit from the contractual arrangement by
consent of the parties. It is distinct from the
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
20/11/2026, 13:33, Bengaluru
Verified

- 104 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:64475
WP No. 35467 of 2025
C/W WP No. 10460 of 2022
WP No. 13395 of 2022
AND 3 OTHERS


CNR: KAHC010762852025


agreement being automatically discharged on
the ground of frustration.
21.28. The plea that the agreement stood frustrated
is, therefore, not accepted. This does not mean
that the hardship suffered by the petitioner is
disregarded. The circumstances leading to the
surrender and their effect on the petitioner's
claims are considered separately while granting
appropriate relief.
21.29. This Court answers Point No.(iii) by holding that
the COVID-19 pandemic, the consequential
lockdown and curfew, and the State-wide strike
relied upon by the petitioners constituted Force
Majeure events within the meaning of Article
8.1.1(c), (e) and (g) of the Concession
Agreement, subject to the conditions contained
in Article 8.1. However, the petitioners have not
established that they independently invoked
Article 8 by issuing the prescribed notices and
complying with the requirements of
consultation and mitigation under Article 8.3.
They cannot, therefore, claim any additional
relief under Article 8 beyond the concession
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
20/11/2026, 13:33, Bengaluru
Verified

- 105 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:64475
WP No. 35467 of 2025
C/W WP No. 10460 of 2022
WP No. 13395 of 2022
AND 3 OTHERS


CNR: KAHC010762852025


independently granted by KSRTC through the
communication dated 01.09.2021.
21.30. Article 9.4, which provides for termination on
account of a prolonged Force Majeure event,
was not invoked by either party, and the
agreements were not terminated under that
provision. The claim that the agreements stood
frustrated is also not accepted, as the parties
had expressly provided for Force Majeure
events and the consequences of their prolonged
occurrence under Articles 8 and 9.4.
22. Answer to Point No.(iv): Whether the
petitioners' continued possession of the
premises, despite the restrictions on business
operations, disentitled them from claiming
suspension or waiver of licence fee under the
Concession Agreement and Sections 108(B)(e)
and 108(B)(I) of the Transfer of Property Act,
1882?

22.1. Sri P.D. Surana, learned counsel for KSRTC,
relies on the decision of the Hon'ble Delhi High
Court in Ramanand and Ors. v. Girish Soni
and Anr. [2020 DHC 1963], particularly
paragraphs 20, 24, 27 and 32. He submits that
mere non-use of leased premises, or a
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
20/11/2026, 13:33, Bengaluru
Verified

- 106 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:64475
WP No. 35467 of 2025
C/W WP No. 10460 of 2022
WP No. 13395 of 2022
AND 3 OTHERS


CNR: KAHC010762852025


temporary inability to enjoy them on account of
a Force Majeure event, does not automatically
relieve the lessee of the obligation to pay rent.
According to him, under Section 108(B)(e) of
the Transfer of Property Act, 1882, the lessee
may avoid the lease only where the property is
wholly destroyed or rendered substantially and
permanently unfit for the purpose for which it
was let. Unless that option is exercised, the
lessee remains bound by Section 108(B)(I) to
pay rent. He further submits that the
petitioners, except the petitioner in W.P.
No.7641/2023, continued to hold the premises
and, therefore, remain liable to pay the licence
fee in accordance with their agreements.
22.2. In Ramanand , the Hon'ble Delhi High Court
extracted the relevant parts of Section 108 of
the Transfer of Property Act, 1882, at
paragraph 20. The provisions read as follows:
"(e) if by fire, tempest or flood, or violence of an
army or of a mob, or other irresistible force, any
material part of the property be wholly destroyed
or rendered substantially and permanently unfit for
the purposes for which it was let, the lease shall,
at the option of the lessee, be void: Provided that,
if the injury be occasioned by the wrongful act or
default of the lessee, he shall not be entitled to
avail himself of the benefit of this provision ...
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
20/11/2026, 13:33, Bengaluru
Verified

- 107 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:64475
WP No. 35467 of 2025
C/W WP No. 10460 of 2022
WP No. 13395 of 2022
AND 3 OTHERS


CNR: KAHC010762852025


(l) the lessee is bound to pay or tender, at the
proper time and place, the premium or rent to the
lessor or his agent in this behalf."

22.3. A plain reading of clause (e) shows that the
lessee may avoid the lease where the property
is wholly destroyed or rendered substantially
and permanently unfit for the purpose for which
it was let. The lease does not become void
automatically; the lessee must exercise the
option available under that provision. Clause
(I), in turn, requires the lessee to pay rent in
accordance with the terms of the lease. Thus,
temporary difficulty in using the premises or
carrying on business does not, by itself,
suspend the obligation to pay rent.
22.4. At paragraph 24, Ramanand refers to an
earlier decision concerning restaurant premises
which had been sealed by the authorities. The
Court reiterated that:
"if the leased premises is rendered substantially and
permanently unfit for the purpose for which it was
let, the lessee has the option to avoid the lease.
Unless the lessee so avoids the lease, he cannot
avoid his obligation contained in clause (l) ... which
states that the lessee is bound to pay or tender, at
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
20/11/2026, 13:33, Bengaluru
Verified

- 108 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:64475
WP No. 35467 of 2025
C/W WP No. 10460 of 2022
WP No. 13395 of 2022
AND 3 OTHERS


CNR: KAHC010762852025


the proper time and place, the premium or rent to
the lessor or his agent in this behalf."
22.5. The principle is that even where the lessee is
prevented from using the premises, the
obligation to pay rent does not cease merely on
that account. The lessee must establish the
condition contemplated under clause (e) and
exercise the option to avoid the lease. Mere
inability to carry on business during a period of
lockdown does not establish that the premises
themselves were wholly destroyed or had
become substantially and permanently unfit for
the purpose for which they were let.
22.6. At paragraph 27, Ramanand , referring to an
earlier decision concerning a tenant who had
been dispossessed of the premises, observes
that suspension of rent may be claimed where
dispossession has actually occurred, but that:
"mere non-use may not always entitle the tenant
for suspension of rent."
22.7. This distinction is material. Non-use of the
premises and loss of possession are not the
same. The petitioners, except the petitioner in
W.P. No.7641/2023, continued to hold the
licensed premises. Their grievance is that the
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
20/11/2026, 13:33, Bengaluru
Verified

- 109 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:64475
WP No. 35467 of 2025
C/W WP No. 10460 of 2022
WP No. 13395 of 2022
AND 3 OTHERS


CNR: KAHC010762852025


lockdown, curfew and absence of customers
prevented or substantially reduced their
business activities. They do not claim that
KSRTC took possession of the premises or
otherwise dispossessed them during the
relevant period. The principle stated in
paragraph 27 of Ramanand is, therefore,
relevant to their claim for suspension of the
licence fee.
22.8. At paragraph 32, Ramanand applies the above
principles to the claim for suspension of rent
during the COVID-19 lockdown and holds:
"the Tenants' application for suspension of rent is
thus liable to be rejected inasmuch as while
invoking the doctrine of suspension of rent on the
basis of a force majeure event, it is clear from the
submissions made that the Tenants do not intend to
surrender the tenanted premises. While holding that
suspension of rent is not permissible in these facts,
some postponement or relaxation in the schedule of
payment can be granted owing to the lockdown."

22.9. The decision thus distinguishes between a claim
for suspension of rent and a request for
relaxation or postponement of payment. It
recognises that temporary restrictions on the
use of premises may justify some
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
20/11/2026, 13:33, Bengaluru
Verified

- 110 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:64475
WP No. 35467 of 2025
C/W WP No. 10460 of 2022
WP No. 13395 of 2022
AND 3 OTHERS


CNR: KAHC010762852025


accommodation in the payment schedule, but
do not, by themselves, extinguish the
contractual liability to pay rent.
22.10. This Court respectfully agrees with the
principles laid down in Ramanand . A
temporary inability to carry on business
because of a lockdown, curfew or absence of
customers is not equivalent to the property
being wholly destroyed or rendered
substantially and permanently unfit for the
purpose for which it was let. The petitioners
have not shown that the licensed premises
themselves suffered such destruction or
permanent unfitness. Nor have they shown that
they were dispossessed during the period in
question. They continued to hold the premises,
although their ability to carry on business was
affected by the restrictions.
22.11. To the extent that the relationship between the
parties is in substance that of lessor and lessee,
Sections 108(B)(e) and 108(B)(I) are relevant.
In any event, the contractual obligation to pay
the licence fee continues in accordance with the
terms of the respective agreements, unless the
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
20/11/2026, 13:33, Bengaluru
Verified

- 111 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:64475
WP No. 35467 of 2025
C/W WP No. 10460 of 2022
WP No. 13395 of 2022
AND 3 OTHERS


CNR: KAHC010762852025


agreement itself or a valid concession provides
otherwise. The petitioners who continued in
possession cannot claim suspension or waiver
of the licence fee merely because they were
temporarily unable to carry on business or earn
the expected income from the premises.
22.12. This conclusion is, however, subject to the
concession granted by KSRTC for the period
from April to June 2021, as considered under
Point No.(ii), and to the question whether
KSRTC could subsequently withdraw that
concession, which is considered under Point
No.(v).
22.13. The above finding must be confined to the claim
for suspension or waiver of licence fee on the
ground of temporary non-use or inability to
carry on business. It does not determine
whether KSRTC could withdraw a concession
already communicated and acted upon by its
licensees, or whether such withdrawal was
permissible without notice and an opportunity
of hearing. The latter issue concerns the legal
effect of KSRTC's own representation and the
principles of promissory estoppel, legitimate
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
20/11/2026, 13:33, Bengaluru
Verified

- 112 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:64475
WP No. 35467 of 2025
C/W WP No. 10460 of 2022
WP No. 13395 of 2022
AND 3 OTHERS


CNR: KAHC010762852025


expectation and natural justice. It is distinct
from the petitioners' claim for suspension of
licence fee under Section 108 of the Transfer of
Property Act, 1882, and is considered
separately under Point No.(v).
22.14. The position of the petitioner in W.P.
No.7641/2023 requires separate consideration.
Unlike the other petitioners, he sought to
surrender the premises on account of the
difficulties faced in carrying on the business,
and KSRTC accepted the surrender. He
thereafter handed over possession. His case,
therefore, stands on a different footing for the
period following the accepted surrender. The
principle that a licensee who continues in
possession remains liable to pay the licence fee
does not apply to the period after possession
was surrendered and accepted by KSRTC.
22.15. The petitioner's claim for refund of the security
deposit, and the adjustments, if any, that
KSRTC is entitled to make up to the date of
surrender, are matters to be considered under
Point No.(vi). The acceptance of surrender does
not, by itself, establish that the agreement
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
20/11/2026, 13:33, Bengaluru
Verified

- 113 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:64475
WP No. 35467 of 2025
C/W WP No. 10460 of 2022
WP No. 13395 of 2022
AND 3 OTHERS


CNR: KAHC010762852025


stood frustrated or that all liabilities arising
before the date of surrender stood
extinguished.
22.16. This Court answers Point No.(iv) by holding that
the petitioners who continued in possession of
the licensed premises cannot claim suspension
or waiver of the licence fee merely on the
ground that the lockdown, curfew and other
restrictions temporarily prevented or restricted
the conduct of their businesses. To the extent
that their arrangements are governed by
Sections 108(B)(e) and 108(B)(I) of the
Transfer of Property Act, 1882, the conditions
for avoiding the lease under clause (e) have not
been established. Their contractual liability to
pay the licence fee, therefore, continues,
subject to the concession granted by KSRTC for
the period from April to June 2021, as
considered under Point No.(ii), and the findings
under Point No.(v) concerning its subsequent
withdrawal.
22.17. This finding does not apply to the period after
the petitioner in W.P. No.7641/2023
surrendered possession and KSRTC accepted it.
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
20/11/2026, 13:33, Bengaluru
Verified

- 114 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:64475
WP No. 35467 of 2025
C/W WP No. 10460 of 2022
WP No. 13395 of 2022
AND 3 OTHERS


CNR: KAHC010762852025


His claim for refund of the security deposit and
the adjustment of dues up to the date of
surrender are considered separately under Point
No.(vi).
23. Answer to Point No.(v): Whether the
resolutions dated 21.03.2022 and 13.11.2024
withdrawing the concession and directing
recovery of the balance licence fee, and the
consequential demand notices, are sustainable
in law, having regard to the authority of KSRTC
to withdraw the concession, the principles of
natural justice, and the doctrines of promissory
estoppel and legitimate expectation?

23.1. Sri S. Saravana, learned counsel for the
petitioners, submits that the withdrawal of the
concession granted during the second wave of
COVID-19 is arbitrary and violative of Article 14
of the Constitution. He points out that KSRTC
had granted substantial concessions during the
first wave in 2020 and submits that similar
relief was warranted during the second wave.
He further submits that the petitioners had a
legitimate expectation that the concession
communicated by KSRTC would be honoured.
In this regard, he relies upon GNCT of Delhi v.
Naresh Kumar [2010 SCC OnLine Del 3942],
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
20/11/2026, 13:33, Bengaluru
Verified

- 115 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:64475
WP No. 35467 of 2025
C/W WP No. 10460 of 2022
WP No. 13395 of 2022
AND 3 OTHERS


CNR: KAHC010762852025


particularly paragraph 22, which summarises
the principles governing legitimate expectation.
He contends that a public authority must give
due consideration to an expectation arising
from an express promise or an established
practice and cannot defeat it arbitrarily. Where
the authority proposes to withdraw a benefit
already extended, it must give the affected
persons an opportunity to make a
representation and must have rational grounds
for its decision.
23.2. He further submits that KSRTC is bound by the
principle of estoppel, since the concession was
communicated by its own officers and was
acted upon by the licensees and sub-lessees.
Having paid the reduced amounts on the basis
of that representation, the petitioners cannot
now be called upon to pay the balance for the
same period.
23.3. Sri S. Saravana also points out that, after the
Board's resolution dated 21.03.2022 and the
consequential demand notices, the sub-lessees
submitted a representation dated 18.05.2022
to the Managing Director of KSRTC requesting
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
20/11/2026, 13:33, Bengaluru
Verified

- 116 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:64475
WP No. 35467 of 2025
C/W WP No. 10460 of 2022
WP No. 13395 of 2022
AND 3 OTHERS


CNR: KAHC010762852025


reconsideration of the withdrawal. The
representation was not considered. He further
submits that petitioners No.9 and 10 in W.P.
No.20426/2022 had vacated the premises and
that their security deposits could not be
adjusted towards the disputed amounts.
23.4. Sri Y.K. Narayan Sharma, learned counsel for
the petitioner in W.P. No.7641/2023, submits
that once the concession had been granted and
its benefit acted upon, KSRTC could not
withdraw it unilaterally without giving the
affected licensees an opportunity of hearing. He
relies upon Dattatraya v. Rangnath
Gopalrao Kawathekar [AIR 1971 SC 2548],
particularly paragraph 10, to submit that an
admission made and acted upon cannot be
withdrawn without sufficient explanation.
23.5. He also relies upon Pratima Chowdhury v.

Kalpana Mukherjee [AIR 2014 SC 1304],
particularly paragraphs 34 to 40, for the
principles governing estoppel under Section 115
of the Evidence Act, 1872. He submits that the
essential requirements are a representation by
one party, its acceptance and reliance by the
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
20/11/2026, 13:33, Bengaluru
Verified

- 117 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:64475
WP No. 35467 of 2025
C/W WP No. 10460 of 2022
WP No. 13395 of 2022
AND 3 OTHERS


CNR: KAHC010762852025


other, an alteration of position on account of
that reliance, and the inequity of requiring the
latter to return to its earlier position. Applying
these principles, he submits that KSRTC made a
representation through its communication
dated 01.09.2021; the licensees acted upon it
by paying the reduced licence fee; and it would
be unfair to demand the balance amounts after
the relevant period had passed.
23.6. Sri P.D. Surana, learned counsel for KSRTC,
submits that the communication dated
01.09.2021 was only a recommendation of the
CCG and had not been approved by the Board
of Directors. The Board, in its resolution dated
21.03.2022, rejected the recommendation and
directed recovery of the full licence fee.
According to him, the licensees were
consequently liable to pay the entire amount.
23.7. In support of the contention that no estoppel
can arise against an unauthorised
representation by a public authority, he relies
upon the following decisions:
23.8. P.H. Avari v. State of West Bengal [AIR
1958 Calcutta 203], particularly paragraph 11,
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
20/11/2026, 13:33, Bengaluru
Verified

- 118 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:64475
WP No. 35467 of 2025
C/W WP No. 10460 of 2022
WP No. 13395 of 2022
AND 3 OTHERS


CNR: KAHC010762852025


for the proposition that there can be no
estoppel against the Government on a question
of law or on the interpretation of a statute, and
that an officer's erroneous interpretation cannot
bind the Government.
23.9. Rachapudi Subrahmanyam v. Collector [AIR
1974 Andhra Pradesh 55], particularly
paragraph 54, for the proposition that equitable
estoppel against the Government requires a
clear, firm and unequivocal representation
made by an authority competent to make it. A
provisional representation, or one made by an
authority lacking the necessary power, cannot
create an estoppel.
23.10. P.C. Sethi v. Union of India [AIR 1975 SC
2164], particularly paragraph 22, for the
proposition that vague statements or
expressions of opinion do not create an
enforceable estoppel against the Government.
23.11. Central Coalfields Ltd. v. SLL-SML (Joint
Venture Consortium) [(2016) 8 SCC 622],
paragraphs 52 and 53, for the proposition that
parties to a contract must comply with the
prescribed terms and procedure and cannot rely
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
20/11/2026, 13:33, Bengaluru
Verified

- 119 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:64475
WP No. 35467 of 2025
C/W WP No. 10460 of 2022
WP No. 13395 of 2022
AND 3 OTHERS


CNR: KAHC010762852025


upon an informal understanding or an
unauthorised relaxation to avoid those terms.
23.12. The principal question is whether KSRTC could,
by its resolutions dated 21.03.2022 and
13.11.2024, retrospectively withdraw the
concession granted for April, May and June
2021 and recover the balance licence fee from
the petitioners.
23.13. Under Point No.(ii), this Court has held that
KSRTC communicated a concession through the
communication dated 01.09.2021, extending a
70% reduction in licence fee for April and June
2021 and a 100% exemption for May 2021. The
concession was acted upon by the field officers,
and reduced payments were accepted from the
licensees, including KSMZ. The corresponding
benefit extended to the sub-lessees under the
back-to-back arrangements. This Court has also
found that KSRTC did not establish that the
CCG or the Chief Traffic Manager lacked
authority to issue and communicate the
decision. The present Point must be decided on
the basis of those findings.

Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
20/11/2026, 13:33, Bengaluru
Verified

- 120 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:64475
WP No. 35467 of 2025
C/W WP No. 10460 of 2022
WP No. 13395 of 2022
AND 3 OTHERS


CNR: KAHC010762852025


Legitimate expectation.
23.14. In GNCT of Delhi v. Naresh Kumar [2010
SCC OnLine Del 3942], paragraph 22, the
Hon'ble Delhi High Court summarised the
principles governing legitimate expectation. The
relevant propositions are that such an
expectation may arise from an express promise
made by a public authority or from an
established practice; that it may arise where a
person has been permitted to enjoy a benefit
and can reasonably expect its continuance
unless rational grounds for withdrawal are
communicated; that the authority proposing to
defeat the expectation should afford the
affected person an opportunity to make a
representation; and that the Court may
examine whether the decision defeating the
expectation is irrational or arbitrary.
23.15. Applying those principles, the communication
dated 01.09.2021 was not a vague assurance
or an expression of future intent. It
communicated a specific concession in licence
fee for the relevant period. The concession was
acted upon, and the licensees were permitted
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
20/11/2026, 13:33, Bengaluru
Verified

- 121 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:64475
WP No. 35467 of 2025
C/W WP No. 10460 of 2022
WP No. 13395 of 2022
AND 3 OTHERS


CNR: KAHC010762852025


to pay the reduced amounts. The petitioners
could, therefore, legitimately expect that the
concession would be honoured for the period to
which it related.
23.16. The Board was not necessarily precluded from
changing KSRTC's policy for the future. The
issue here, however, is different. The resolution
dated 21.03.2022 sought to withdraw a
concession already communicated and acted
upon for a period that had ended several
months earlier, and thereby sought to revive
liability for amounts which the licensees had
been permitted to pay at a reduced rate or not
to pay at all. Such retrospective withdrawal
required fair consideration of the affected
licensees' interests and an opportunity for them
to make their representations.
23.17. There is no material before this Court to show

that the affected licensees were given such an
opportunity before the resolution dated
21.03.2022 was passed. The sub-lessees
thereafter submitted a representation dated
18.05.2022 to the Managing Director seeking
reconsideration of the decision. That
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
20/11/2026, 13:33, Bengaluru
Verified

- 122 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:64475
WP No. 35467 of 2025
C/W WP No. 10460 of 2022
WP No. 13395 of 2022
AND 3 OTHERS


CNR: KAHC010762852025


representation was not considered. A
representation made after the decision had
been taken, and left unanswered, does not cure
the failure to provide an opportunity before the
adverse decision was made.
23.18. The subsequent resolution dated 13.11.2024,
insofar as it continues or gives effect to the
withdrawal and recovery of the concession,
does not cure the earlier defect. No material
has been placed before this Court to show that
the petitioners' representation was considered
or that they were afforded an opportunity of
hearing before the decision was reaffirmed or
acted upon.
Estoppel.
23.19. Before considering the submissions on estoppel,
it is necessary to examine the decision in
Dattatraya v. Rangnath Gopalrao
Kawathekar [AIR 1971 SC 2548], relied upon
by Sri Y.K. Narayan Sharma. Paragraph 10 of
that decision makes a distinction between an
admission and estoppel. The Hon'ble Supreme
Court observed that:
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
20/11/2026, 13:33, Bengaluru
Verified

- 123 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:64475
WP No. 35467 of 2025
C/W WP No. 10460 of 2022
WP No. 13395 of 2022
AND 3 OTHERS


CNR: KAHC010762852025


"admission is one thing, estoppel is another"
and further stated that:
"admission is a piece of evidence but estoppel
creates title."
23.20. Dattatraya does not lay down that every
admission, by itself, creates an estoppel. It
recognises that a clear admission is relevant
evidence and that a party cannot ordinarily
resile from it without a satisfactory explanation,
such as mistake or misrepresentation. Applied
by analogy, the principle supports the
petitioners' contention that KSRTC cannot
simply deny the concession communicated
through its own administrative machinery after
permitting the licensees to act upon it. The
question whether a legal estoppel arises must,
however, be examined separately.
23.21. Sri Y.K. Narayan Sharma also relies upon
Pratima Chowdhury v. Kalpana Mukherjee
[AIR 2014 SC 1304], particularly paragraphs 34
to 40, which deal with the doctrine of estoppel
under Section 115 of the Evidence Act, 1872.
The relevant provision reads:
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
20/11/2026, 13:33, Bengaluru
Verified

- 124 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:64475
WP No. 35467 of 2025
C/W WP No. 10460 of 2022
WP No. 13395 of 2022
AND 3 OTHERS


CNR: KAHC010762852025


115. Estoppel.— When one person has, by his
declaration, act or omission, intentionally caused or
permitted another person to believe a thing to be
true and to act upon such belief, neither he nor his
representative shall be allowed, in any suit or
proceeding between himself and such person or his
representative, to deny the truth of that thing.
23.22. In Pratima Chowdhury , the Hon'ble Supreme

Court explained that the principle requires a
representation by one party, acceptance and
reliance by the other, an alteration of position
consequent upon such reliance, and
circumstances in which it would be inequitable
to require the latter to return to the original
position.
23.23. These requirements are satisfied on the facts in
the present case.
23.23.1. First, KSRTC communicated the
concession through the communication
dated 01.09.2021.
23.23.2. Secondly, the licensees acted upon that
representation and paid the reduced
licence fee for the relevant period. The
subsequent demand notices themselves
seek recovery of the alleged balance
amounts, thereby acknowledging that
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
20/11/2026, 13:33, Bengaluru
Verified

- 125 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:64475
WP No. 35467 of 2025
C/W WP No. 10460 of 2022
WP No. 13395 of 2022
AND 3 OTHERS


CNR: KAHC010762852025


the reduced payments had been
accepted.
23.23.3. Thirdly, KSMZ and the sub-lessees
arranged their respective financial
obligations on the basis of the
concession, which was passed on
through their back-to-back
arrangements.
23.23.4. Finally, after permitting the licensees to
act on the concession and accepting the
reduced payments for a period that had
already ended, it would be inequitable to
require them to pay the balance
amounts retrospectively.
23.24. The representation was specific and related to
an identified period and a quantified reduction.
It was not merely an expectation that KSRTC
might grant relief at some future date. The
petitioners' reliance is also supported by the
fact that the reduced payments were accepted
by KSRTC's officers and the demand for the
balance was raised only subsequently. The
elements of representation, reliance and
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
20/11/2026, 13:33, Bengaluru
Verified

- 126 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:64475
WP No. 35467 of 2025
C/W WP No. 10460 of 2022
WP No. 13395 of 2022
AND 3 OTHERS


CNR: KAHC010762852025


alteration of position are, therefore, established
on the material considered under Point No.(ii).
23.25. Authorities relied upon by KSRTC. The decisions
cited by Sri P.D. Surana do not require a
different conclusion.
23.26. In P.H. Avari , the principle that there can be
no estoppel against the Government on a
question of law or the construction of a statute
was applied to a representation concerning the
interpretation of a statutory provision. The
present case does not concern an officer's
interpretation of a statute. It concerns a
concession in licence fee communicated by
KSRTC in the course of its commercial and
administrative dealings with its licensees. No
statutory provision has been identified which
prohibited KSRTC from granting such a
concession.
23.27. In Rachapudi Subrahmanyam , the Court
emphasised that the representation must be
clear and must emanate from an authority
competent to make it. The principle is not in
dispute. However, as already considered under
Point No.(ii), KSRTC has not produced the
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
20/11/2026, 13:33, Bengaluru
Verified

- 127 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:64475
WP No. 35467 of 2025
C/W WP No. 10460 of 2022
WP No. 13395 of 2022
AND 3 OTHERS


CNR: KAHC010762852025


relevant rules or delegation of powers to
establish that the CCG or the Chief Traffic
Manager lacked authority to communicate the
concession. The communication was clear as to
the relief granted and was acted upon by the
Corporation's field officers. The respondents
cannot establish want of authority merely by
asserting that the Board subsequently rejected
the recommendation. KSRTC has also not
placed on record action taken against CCG or
the Chief Traffic Manager for having issued a
communication as regards which they lacked
authority.
23.28. In P.C. Sethi , the Hon'ble Supreme Court held
that vague statements or expressions of
opinion, confined to a particular context, do not
create an estoppel against the Government.
The communication in the present case stands
on a different footing. It specified the
concession, the period for which it was available
and the categories of licensees covered. It was
also implemented by KSRTC's officers. It cannot
be treated as a vague or tentative assurance.
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
20/11/2026, 13:33, Bengaluru
Verified

- 128 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:64475
WP No. 35467 of 2025
C/W WP No. 10460 of 2022
WP No. 13395 of 2022
AND 3 OTHERS


CNR: KAHC010762852025


23.29. The principle in Central Coalfields Ltd. ,
paragraphs 52 and 53, requires parties to
comply with the procedure and conditions
prescribed by their contractual documents. That
principle was considered under Point No.(iii) in
relation to the procedure for invoking Article 8
of the Concession Agreement. It does not,
however, answer the distinct question arising
here: whether KSRTC could retrospectively
withdraw a concession separately
communicated by it and acted upon by the
licensees. The decision does not permit a party
to disregard the legal consequences of its own
representation and conduct. The principle in
Central Coalfields is, therefore, not
inconsistent with the conclusion reached in the
present case.
Article 14 of the Constitution.
23.30. Sri S. Saravana submits that the withdrawal of
the concession is also contrary to Article 14 of
the Constitution, which provides that:
"the State shall not deny to any person equality
before the law or the equal protection of the laws
within the territory of India."
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
20/11/2026, 13:33, Bengaluru
Verified

- 129 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:64475
WP No. 35467 of 2025
C/W WP No. 10460 of 2022
WP No. 13395 of 2022
AND 3 OTHERS


CNR: KAHC010762852025


23.31. The submission is that KSRTC having granted
concessions during the first wave of COVID-19
in 2020 was required to extend similar
concessions during the second wave in 2021.
This Court is unable to accept that contention
as an independent ground. The concessions
granted during the two waves were separate
administrative decisions taken at different
times. The petitioners have not established that
the two situations were materially identical or
identified a class of similarly situated persons
who were treated differently in comparable
circumstances. The grant of a concession during
the first wave did not, by itself, create a
constitutional right to an identical concession
during the second wave.
23.32. The infirmity in the present case lies elsewhere.
KSRTC had communicated and implemented a
concession for the second wave and
subsequently sought to withdraw it
retrospectively, without first giving the affected
licensees an opportunity to make a
representation. That action is more
appropriately examined under the principles of
legitimate expectation and estoppel discussed
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
20/11/2026, 13:33, Bengaluru
Verified

- 130 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:64475
WP No. 35467 of 2025
C/W WP No. 10460 of 2022
WP No. 13395 of 2022
AND 3 OTHERS


CNR: KAHC010762852025


above. The submission under Article 14 is,
therefore, not accepted as a separate ground
for relief.
23.33. Effect of the resolutions and demand notices.
The findings under Point No.(ii) establish that
the concession for April, May and June 2021
was communicated by KSRTC and acted upon
by its officers. The findings under the present
Point establish that the affected licensees relied
upon that concession and paid the reduced
amounts. The Board's resolution dated
21.03.2022 sought to withdraw the concession
retrospectively and recover the balance licence
fee without first giving the affected licensees an
opportunity to make a representation. The
subsequent resolution dated 13.11.2024,
insofar as it continues or gives effect to that
decision, is subject to the same infirmity.
23.34. In the circumstances, the resolutions dated
21.03.2022 and 13.11.2024 cannot be
sustained insofar as they seek to recover from
the petitioners the licence fee component of the
concession granted for April, May and June
2021. The consequential demand notices are
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
20/11/2026, 13:33, Bengaluru
Verified

- 131 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:64475
WP No. 35467 of 2025
C/W WP No. 10460 of 2022
WP No. 13395 of 2022
AND 3 OTHERS


CNR: KAHC010762852025


also unsustainable to that extent and are liable
to be quashed.
23.35. This finding is confined to the licence fee
component of the concession. As held under
Point No.(ii), the concession did not extend to
GST. The GST component, therefore, remains
payable and recoverable in accordance with
law. KSRTC is also not precluded from
recovering licence fee or other dues for periods
outside April to June 2021, including the period
from July 2021 onwards.
23.36. This Court answers Point No.(v) by holding that
the resolutions dated 21.03.2022 and
13.11.2024, and the consequential demand
notices, are unsustainable insofar as they seek
to recover from the petitioners the licence fee
component of the concession granted for April,
May and June 2021. They are accordingly
quashed to that limited extent.
23.37. The demands relating to GST and dues for
periods other than April to June 2021 are not
disturbed and may be recovered in accordance
with law.
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
20/11/2026, 13:33, Bengaluru
Verified

- 132 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:64475
WP No. 35467 of 2025
C/W WP No. 10460 of 2022
WP No. 13395 of 2022
AND 3 OTHERS


CNR: KAHC010762852025


24. Answer to Point No.(vi): Whether the
petitioners in the respective writ petitions are
entitled to refund of their security deposits,
protection against adjustment of the disputed
dues, and interest thereon?

24.1. Sri Y.K. Narayan Sharma, learned counsel for
the petitioner in W.P. No.7641/2023, submits
that the petitioner had paid a security deposit
of ₹22,38,596 and advance rental under the
agreement dated 24.12.2020. He had also
invested more than ₹20,00,000 in furniture and
fittings. Owing to the difficulties caused by the
pandemic, he sought permission to surrender
the premises, which KSRTC accepted. He
submits that the petitioner had paid all rentals,
licence fee, electricity charges and other dues
payable as on the date of surrender. Despite
this, KSRTC has withheld the security deposit
and has demanded a further sum of
₹10,19,317, threatening to forfeit the deposit.
He accordingly seeks refund of the security
deposit with interest at 2% per month from
01.07.2022, the date following the handing
over of possession.
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
20/11/2026, 13:33, Bengaluru
Verified

- 133 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:64475
WP No. 35467 of 2025
C/W WP No. 10460 of 2022
WP No. 13395 of 2022
AND 3 OTHERS


CNR: KAHC010762852025


24.2. Sri S. Saravana, learned counsel for the
petitioners in W.P. No.20426/2022, submits that
petitioners No.9 and 10 have vacated the
premises and are entitled to refund of their
security deposits. He contends that KSRTC
cannot adjust those deposits towards the
disputed licence fee amounts sought to be
recovered by withdrawing the concession.
24.3. Sri Dilip Kumar, learned counsel for the
petitioner in W.P. No.27997/2023, adopts the
submissions made on behalf of the other
petitioners. He submits that the petitioner's
security deposit of ₹6,68,668 should be
protected against adjustment towards the
alleged arrears of licence fee for April to June
2021 arising from the impugned withdrawal of
the concession.
24.4. Sri P.D. Surana, learned counsel for KSRTC,

submits that the concession is not enforceable
and that the petitioners remain liable to pay the
full licence fee. On that basis, he opposes the
claims for refund of the security deposits and
protection against adjustment.
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
20/11/2026, 13:33, Bengaluru
Verified

- 134 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:64475
WP No. 35467 of 2025
C/W WP No. 10460 of 2022
WP No. 13395 of 2022
AND 3 OTHERS


CNR: KAHC010762852025


24.5. The petitioner in W.P. No.7641/2023 paid a
security deposit of ₹22,38,596 and thereafter
surrendered the premises, which surrender was
accepted by KSRTC. It follows from the finding
under Point No.(v) that the demand for
₹10,19,317 cannot be enforced to the extent
that it represents recovery of the licence fee
component of the concession granted for April,
May and June 2021. That disputed amount
cannot, therefore, be treated as a lawful due or
used as a ground to withhold or forfeit the
security deposit.
24.6. It is also not disputed by Sri P.D. Surana that
the petitioner had paid the other amounts due
towards rentals, licence fee, electricity and
other charges as on the date of surrender.
KSRTC is accordingly liable to refund the
security deposit, after adjusting only such other
amounts, if any, as are established to be
lawfully due from the petitioner and are
consistent with the findings in this order. The
quashed licence fee demand for April to June
2021 shall not be included in such adjustment.
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
20/11/2026, 13:33, Bengaluru
Verified

- 135 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:64475
WP No. 35467 of 2025
C/W WP No. 10460 of 2022
WP No. 13395 of 2022
AND 3 OTHERS


CNR: KAHC010762852025


24.7. Petitioners No.9 and 10 in W.P. No.20426/2022
have also vacated the premises. Their security
deposits are, therefore, liable to be refunded,
subject to adjustment of any other dues
lawfully recoverable from them. KSRTC cannot
adjust the amounts claimed towards the
withdrawn concession for April to June 2021,
since the demand for that component has been
quashed under Point No.(v). The refund shall
accordingly be made after deducting only such
other dues, if any, as are lawfully recoverable.
24.8. The position of the petitioner in W.P.
No.27997/2023 is different. He does not seek
refund of the security deposit of ₹6,68,668, but
protection against its adjustment towards the
alleged arrears of licence fee for April to June
2021. In view of the finding under Point No.(v),
KSRTC is not entitled to adjust the security
deposit towards the licence fee component of
the concession which has been quashed. The
protection sought is, therefore, granted to that
extent. It does not prevent KSRTC from
adjusting the deposit towards any other dues
that are lawfully payable by the petitioner.
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
20/11/2026, 13:33, Bengaluru
Verified

- 136 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:64475
WP No. 35467 of 2025
C/W WP No. 10460 of 2022
WP No. 13395 of 2022
AND 3 OTHERS


CNR: KAHC010762852025


24.9. Interest on the amounts refundable. The
petitioner in W.P. No.7641/2023 has claimed
interest at 2% per month in the prayer. Having
regard to the period for which the deposit has
been withheld after surrender of the premises,
interest at 6% per annum on the amount found
refundable is considered reasonable. The
petitioner is accordingly entitled to simple
interest at that rate from 01.07.2022 until the
date of actual payment.
24.10. As regards petitioners No.9 and 10 in W.P.
No.20426/2022, no specific rate of interest has
been claimed either in their submissions or in
the prayer. Considering that they have vacated
the premises and that their deposits have been
withheld, this Court considers simple interest at
6% per annum on the amounts found
refundable to be reasonable compensation for
the delay. Such interest shall run from the date
on which the respective deposits became
refundable under the applicable arrangements
until the date of actual payment.
24.11. In both cases, interest shall be calculated on
the net amount refundable after adjustment of
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
20/11/2026, 13:33, Bengaluru
Verified

- 137 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:64475
WP No. 35467 of 2025
C/W WP No. 10460 of 2022
WP No. 13395 of 2022
AND 3 OTHERS


CNR: KAHC010762852025


only such dues as are found to be lawfully
recoverable in accordance with this order.
24.12. This Court answers Point No.(vi) by holding that
the petitioner in W.P. No.7641/2023 is entitled
to refund of his security deposit of ₹22,38,596,
after adjustment of only such other dues, if
any, as are lawfully recoverable in accordance
with this order. He is also entitled to simple
interest at 6% per annum on the net amount
refundable, from 01.07.2022 until payment.
24.13. Petitioners No.9 and 10 in W.P. No.20426/2022
are entitled to refund of their respective
security deposits, after adjustment of only such
other dues, if any, as are lawfully recoverable,
together with simple interest at 6% per annum
on the net amounts refundable, from the
respective dates on which their deposits
became refundable until payment.
24.14. The petitioner in W.P. No.27997/2023 is entitled
to protection of his security deposit of
₹6,68,668 against adjustment towards the
licence fee component of the concession for
April to June 2021, which has been quashed
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
20/11/2026, 13:33, Bengaluru
Verified

- 138 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:64475
WP No. 35467 of 2025
C/W WP No. 10460 of 2022
WP No. 13395 of 2022
AND 3 OTHERS


CNR: KAHC010762852025


under Point No.(v). This protection does not
extend to any other lawfully due arrears.
25. Answer to Point No.(vii): What order?
25.1. In view of this court answers to all the points
above, this court passes the following:
ORDER
i. W.P.No.35467/2025 is partly allowed. The
demand notice dated 18.08.2025 bearing
No.KST/SMG/TR/COM/1249/2025-26, the
consequential demand notice dated 01.09.2025
bearing No.KST/SMG/TR/COM/1368/2025-26,
and the demand notice dated 16.10.2025
bearing No.KST/SMG/TR/COM/1812/2025-26,
produced as Annexures-E, E1 and E2
respectively, are quashed in so far as they seek
to recover the licence fee component of
₹37,17,642 representing the withdrawn
concession for the months of April, May and
June 2021. The said notices are not disturbed in
so far as they relate to the GST component of
₹6,69,176 or to any dues for any period other
than April to June 2021, which the first
respondent is at liberty to recover in
accordance with law.

ii. W.P.No.10460/2022 and W.P.No.13395/2022,
for the same reasons, are partly allowed. The
letter dated 06.04.2022 bearing
No.KARASA.KEKA.SAM.VAA-1.22.2022-23,
produced as Annexure-D and the consequential
notices issued under Annexures-C and C1 to C6
in W.P.No.10460/2022 and under Annexures-C
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
20/11/2026, 13:33, Bengaluru
Verified

- 139 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:64475
WP No. 35467 of 2025
C/W WP No. 10460 of 2022
WP No. 13395 of 2022
AND 3 OTHERS


CNR: KAHC010762852025


and C1 to C13 in W.P.No.13395/2022, are
quashed in so far as they seek to recover the
licence fee component of the concession
withdrawn for the months of April, May and
June 2021. The said letter and notices are not
disturbed in so far as they relate to GST or to
dues for any other period.

iii. W.P.No.20426/2022 is, likewise, partly allowed.
Annexure-F dated 06.04.2022 is quashed in so
far as it seeks to recover the licence fee
component of the withdrawn concession for
April, May and June 2021 from the petitioners;
respondents No.1 to 3 are directed to be bound
by the policy decision at Annexure-D dated
01.08.2021. Respondents No.1 to 3 are further
directed to refund to petitioners No.9 and 10
the security deposit held in respect of the
premises vacated by them, after adjustment of
only such dues as are lawfully due consistently
with this order, together with simple interest at
6% per annum from the date such refund fell
due until payment.

iv. W.P.No.7641/2023 is partly allowed. The
demand made by the third respondent by letter
dated 03.05.2022, produced as Annexure-F,
and the resolutions dated 21.03.2022 and
13.11.2024, produced as Annexures-L and M,
are quashed in so far as they seek to recover
the licence fee component of the withdrawn
concession for April, May and June 2021 from
the petitioner. Respondents No.1 to 3 are
directed to refund the petitioner's security
deposit of ₹22,38,596, after adjustment of only
such dues, if any, as are lawfully due
consistently with this order, together with
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
20/11/2026, 13:33, Bengaluru
Verified

- 140 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:64475
WP No. 35467 of 2025
C/W WP No. 10460 of 2022
WP No. 13395 of 2022
AND 3 OTHERS


CNR: KAHC010762852025


simple interest at 6% per annum from
01.07.2022 until the date of payment.

v. W.P.No.27997/2023 is partly allowed.
Respondents No.1 to 3 are directed not to
adjust, against the petitioner's security deposit
of ₹6,68,668, the licence fee component of the
arrears for April, May and June 2021 that has
been quashed under this order by giving effect
to Annexure-G dated 06.04.2022; respondents
No.1 to 3 remain at liberty to adjust against the

said deposit any other lawfully due arrears.

vi. Save as modified above, the demands of the
respondents-KSRTC for licence fee and GST for
periods other than April, May and June 2021,
and in respect of any petitioner or sub-lessee
not specifically dealt with above, are not
interfered with, and the respondents-KSRTC are
at liberty to recover the same in accordance
with law.

vii. All pending applications, if any, in these writ

petitions stand disposed of accordingly.

This Court has been assisted by Mr. Sourav, Law
Clerk, in reviewing this Judgement.


Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
20/11/2026, 13:33, Bengaluru
Verified

(SURAJ GOVINDARAJ)
JUDGE
KTY, List No.: 1 Sl No.: 63