Bijender Alias Sonu And Another vs State Of Haryana And Another
- Court
- Punjab and Haryana High Court
CRR-1062-2026 (O&M) - 1-
115
IN THE HIGH COURT OF PUNJAB AND HARYANA
AT CHANDIGARH
CRR-1062-2026 (O&M)
Date of Reserve:28.10.2026
Date of Decision:16.11.2026
Bijender @ Sonu and Anr. …Petitioners
Vs.
State of Haryana and Anr. …Respondents
Coram : Hon’ble Mr. Justice N.S.Shekhawat
Present: Mr. Karambir Singh Nalwa, Sr. Advocate assisted by
Mr. J. Yuvraj Singh, Advocate
for the petitioners.
Mr. Rajinder Kumar Banku, Sr. DAG, Haryana.
Mr. Madhur Jangra, Advocate (through V.C)
for respondent No.2.
*
N.S.Shekhawat J.
1. The petitioners have preferred the instant revision petition against
the impugned order dated 09.04.2026 passed by the Court of Additional
Sessions Judge, Sonipat, whereby, application under Section 358 of Bhartiya
Nagrik Suraksha Sahinta , 2023 moved by the prosecution was allowed and both
the petitioners namely Bijender @ Sonu and Ram Chander Rana were ordered
to be summoned as additional accused in a case arising out of F.I.R No.120
dated 26.02.2025, under Sections 103(1) and 61 of B.N.S,2023 {corresponding
Sections 302 and 120-B of IPC}, Sections 25 and 27 of Arms Act, Police
Station Kharkhoda, District Sonipat (Annexure P-1).
2. The F.I.R in the present case was initially ordered to be registered
on 26.02.2025 on the basis of the compliant moved by Chand Singh son of
HITESH
2026.11.17 10:05
I attest to the accuracy and integrity
of this document
CRR-1062-2026 (O&M) - 2-
Prem Singh and the same has been reproduced below:-
“ To the SHO Sahib, it is requested that I Chand Singh
S/o Prem Singh R/o Sohati, District Sonipat, we were four
brothers. The eldest one is Krishna, younger than him is Shri
Bhagwan, younger than him is Sahib Singh, who has died. My
brother Krishna's son Rakesh aged 35 years, was living with his
child in Omaxe Rohtak for the 3-4 years and used to run the
Akhada Amar Singh Pehalwan at the Dham in Sohatti. There was
a land dispute going on with my uncle Hawa Singh's son Manoj
alias Kala and his family. Due to this dispute, Manoj and his
family members had beaten me about 6/7 months ago and inflicted
injuries to me. Regarding which I had registered FIR No. 402 DT
15-7-24 U/S 115,117(2), 126(2), 351(2), 3(5) BNS at police Station
Kharkhoda. Since then there was a grudge between us. My nephew
Rakesh S/O Krishna used to favour me. Due to this reason Manoj
alias Kala had a grudge against my nephew Rakesh. Today on 26-
2-2025, my nephew Rakesh along with his son. Amrit had come to
Kundal Wrestling Arena along with other players for wrestling in
the Arena/Akhara and I had also come to watch the wrestling. At
around 5.15 PM, my nephew Rakesh along with his son Amrit and
me were going towards the car to go home after Amrit's wrestling
was over. As we were going towards the car, as soon as we
reached near the car, Manoj alias Kala S/O Hawa Singh and his
nephew Sahil came with pistols in their hands and as soon as they
came, they opened fire on Rakesh with the intention of killing him.
That my nephew Rakesh ran on the road to save his life, Manoj
and Sahil followed him and fired several shots from the pistol at
my nephew Rakesh, who fell at some distance, and they fired at
him there too. There was a huge crowd there due to the fair. There
might have been other boys with them. After firing the bullets, they
fled from the spot with their weapons. After that, on getting
information on the spot, Mahant Surya Nath R/o of Sohatti Dham
came to the spot and took Rakesh in his car to Sethi Hospital
HITESH
2026.11.17 10:05
I attest to the accuracy and integrity
of this document
CRR-1062-2026 (O&M) - 3-
Kharkhoda for treatment, where the doctor after checking declared
my nephew Rakesh dead. Manoj alias Kala and his nephew Sahil
along with their associates have conspired with Manoj's family
and murdered my nephew Rakesh. Kindly take legal action.Yours
sincerely, Chand, Village Sohati, Police Station Kharkhoda,
District Sonipat.”
3. Learned senior counsel appearing on behalf of the petitioners has
vehemently argued that the occurrence had allegedly taken place at about 05:15
P.M on 26.02.2025, whereas, the F.I.R was lodged by the police at about 10:00
P.M on the basis of the statement made by Chand Singh son of Prem Singh, a
relative of the petitioners. However, in the F.I.R, he specifically named Manoj
@ Kala and Sahil, who had allegedly caused firearm injuries to Rakesh Kumar,
since deceased on account of their personal enmity. The petitioners were neither
named in the F.I.R nor arrayed as an accused at the initial stage of investigation.
The petitioners are first cousins of the complainant and in case, they had played
any role in the alleged occurrence, the complainant would not have omitted to
name them at the first instance. After two days i.e on 28.02.2025, a
supplementary statement (Annexure P-2) of Chand Singh, complainant was
recorded by the police, whereby, the petitioners were sought to be implicated
by alleging that they had hatched a conspiracy with Manoj @ Kala and Sahil,
co-accused, 4/6 months prior to the date of occurrence. Learned counsel further
submits that in the F.I.R (Annexure P-1), there was a reference of prior incident,
which led to registration of F.I.R No.402 dated 15.07.2024, under Sections
115,117(2),126,3(5) and 351(2) of B.N.S, 2023 {corresponding Sections
323,325,339,34 and 506 of IPC}, Police Station Kharkhoda, District Sonipat.
Neither the petitioners were named as accused nor had any role whatsover in the
HITESH
2026.11.17 10:05
I attest to the accuracy and integrity
of this document
CRR-1062-2026 (O&M) - 4-
alleged incident. However, Sunita wife of Ram Chander, petitioner No.2 was
initially named in the said F.I.R. However, on the basis of said CCTV footage
and fair investigation, she was found innocent in the present case.
4. Learned senior counsel further argued that in order to
ascertain the truth, the police moved an application before the Court of Sub-
Divisional Judicial Magistrate, Kharkhoda, District Sonipat seeking permission
to conduct a lie detector (polygraph) test of the petitioners. Both the petitioners
agreed with the averments made in the said application and had undergone the
lie detector test. As per the FSL report (Annexure P-6), the analysis and
evaluation of polygrams revealed truthful responses of both the petitioners and
test also exonerated the petitioners. Even, a Special Investigation Team was
duly constituted by police and the petitioner had joined the investigation.
However, no incriminating material whatsoever could be collected against them.
Thereafter, the police had conclusively established that the petitioners were
neither present at the place of occurrence nor had conspired with other accused.
In order to arrive at such conclusions, the police had not only joined witnesses,
collected other material, but also relied upon call detail records of the accused.
Since, no evidence had surfaced against the petitioners, they were declared
innocent and the challan was presented against the other accused.
5. During the course of trial, the prosecution examined PW-1
Chand Singh before the Trial Court and the prosecution moved an application
under Section 358 of B.N.S.S (corresponding to old Section 319 Cr.P.C) for
summoning the petitioners as additional accused and vide the impugned order
dated 09.04.2026, the application was allowed by the Trial Court. Learned
senior counsel further submits that the application was founded on vague and
HITESH
2026.11.17 10:05
I attest to the accuracy and integrity
of this document
CRR-1062-2026 (O&M) - 5-
omnibus allegations and did not meet the threshold required for invoking the
extraordinary powers under Section 358 of B.N.S.S. In fact, the impugned order
was based on factually incorrect facts as recorded in the impugned order. The
Trial Court was under a wrong impression that the petitioners were also present
at the time of crime along with co-accused, whereas, even as per the admitted
case of the complainant, the petitioners had only hatched a criminal conspiracy
with other co-accused about 4/6 months ago. He further submits that the
Hon’ble Supreme Court has held in number of judgments that just by naming
the accused, they could not be summoned as additional accused, unless some
concrete evidence is found against such accused. In the present case, no such
strong or clinching evidence had emerged during trial and the impugned order
was unsustainable. He further contends that despite being close relatives of the
complainant, they were not named at the first instance by the complainant. In
fact, the complainant was well aware of any such alleged conspiracy, which was
hatched by the petitioners 4/6 months ago, he would have certainly named the
petitioners in the first version i.e. F.I.R itself. Consequently, the implication of
the petitioners by PW-1, Chand Singh, complainant is afterthought and
motivated and this aspect was completely overlooked by the Trial Court. Apart
from that, even from a bare perusal of supplementary statement (Annexure P-2)
as well as the statement of the complainant, it was apparent that no specific
allegations has been levelled against the petitioners and vague allegations of
conspiracy without any particulars did not satisfy the legal requirements, which
were required for summoning an accused under the extraordinary provisions of
Section 319 Cr.P.C. In fact, the law is well settled that an order under Section
319 Cr.P.C/358 of B.N.S.S should not be passed only because the first
HITESH
2026.11.17 10:05
I attest to the accuracy and integrity
of this document
CRR-1062-2026 (O&M) - 6-
informant or one of the witnesses seeks to implicate other persons. Sufficient
and cogent reasons are required to be assigned by the Court, so as to satisfy the
ingredients of the provision. In the present case, the evidence was completely
lacking and was not at all convincing, for the purpose of exercise of extra
ordinary jurisdiction and the impugned order is liable to be quashed by this
Court.
6. On the other hand, learned State counsel assisted by learned
counsel for the complainant have vehemently opposed the submissions made by
learned counsel for the petitioners on the ground that the powers under Section
358 of B.N.S.S was exercised by the Trial Court correctly and the cogent
evidence clearly established a strong prima facie case against the petitioners to
face trial along with remaining accused. The petitioners had acted as
conspirators with Manoj @ Kala and Sahil, co-accused and in pursuance of said
conspiracy, Rakesh was killed in the most barbaric and inhuman manner in
broad day light in village. At this stage, the Trial Court had rightly held that the
prosecution evidence carried sufficient weight to establish a strong prima facie
case against both the petitioners, who are, to be summoned to face trial along
with the already arrayed co-accused.
7. I have heard learned counsel for the parties and perused the record
carefully.
8. The Hon’ble Supreme Court, while discussing the powers under
Section 319 Cr.P.C held in the matter of “ Hardeep Singh Vs.State of Punjab,
(2014) 3 SCC 92 as follows:-
“ 105. Power under Section 319 Cr.PC is a
discretionary and an extraordinary power. It is to be exercised
HITESH
2026.11.17 10:05
I attest to the accuracy and integrity
of this document
CRR-1062-2026 (O&M) - 7-
sparingly and only in those cases where the circumstances of the
case so warrant. It is not to be exercised because the Magistrate or
the Sessions Judge is of the opinion that some other person may
also be guilty of committing that offence. Only where strong and
cogent evidence occurs against a person from the evidence led
before the court that such power should be exercised and not in a
casual and cavalier manner.
106. Thus, we hold that though only a prima facie case is to be
established from the evidence led before the court, not necessarily
tested on the anvil of cross-examination, it requires much stronger
evidence than mere probability of his complicity. The test that has
to be applied is one which is more than prima facie case as
exercised at the time of framing of charge, but short of satisfaction
to an extent that the evidence, if goes unrebutted, would lead to
conviction. In the absence of such satisfaction, the court should
refrain from exercising power under Section 319 CrPC. In Section
319 CrPC the purpose of providing if 'it appears from the evidence
that any person not being the accused has committed any offence'
is clear from the words 'for which such person could be tried
together with the accused. The words used are not 'for which such
person could be convicted'. There is, therefore, no scope for the
court acting under Section 319 CrPC to form any opinion as to the
guilt of the accused."
9. Still further, the Hon’ble Supreme Court has held in the matter of
“ Omi @ Omkar Rathore & Anr. Vs.State of Madhya Pradesh & Anr., SLP
(Crl.) No.(s) 17781 of 2024 held that the powers under Section 319 Cr.P.C
empowers the trial court to summon persons to face trial, even they were not
named in the charge-sheet, however, this power has to be exercised
extraordinarily and must be exercised sparingly and not in a casual manner and
held as follows:-
HITESH
2026.11.17 10:05
I attest to the accuracy and integrity
of this document
CRR-1062-2026 (O&M) - 8-
“ 21.The principles of law as regards Section 319 of the Cr.P.C
may be summarised as under:
a. On a careful reading of Section 319 of the CrPC as well as the
aforesaid two decisions, it becomes clear that the trial court has
undoubted jurisdiction to add any person not being the accused
before it to face the trial along with other accused persons, if the
Court is satisfied at any stage of the proceedings on the evidence
adduced that the persons who have not been arrayed as accused
should face the trial. It is further evident that such person even
though had initially been named in the F.I.R. as an accused, but
not charge sheeted, can also be added to face the trial.
b. The trial court can take such a step to add such persons as
accused only on the basis of evidence adduced before it and not on
the basis of materials available in the chargesheet or the case
diary, because such materials contained in the charge sheet or the
case diary do not constitute evidence.
c. The power of the court under Section 319 of the CrPC is not
controlled or governed by naming or not naming of the person
concerned in the FIR. Nor the same is dependent upon submission
of the chargesheet by the police against the person concerned. As
regards the contention that the phrase 'any person not being the
accused' occurred in Section 319 excludes from its operation an
accused who has been released by the police under Section 169 of
the Code and has been shown in column No. 2 of the charge sheet,
the contention has merely to be stated to be rejected. The said
expression clearly covers any person who is not being tried
already by the Court and the very purpose of enacting such a
provision like Section 319(1) clearly shows that even persons who
have been dropped by the police during investigation but against
whom evidence showing their involvement in the offence comes
before the Criminal Court are included in the said expression.
d. It would not be proper for the trial court to reject the
application for addition of new accused by considering records of
HITESH
2026.11.17 10:05
I attest to the accuracy and integrity
of this document
CRR-1062-2026 (O&M) - 9-
the Investigating Officer. When the evidence of complainant is
found to be worthy of acceptance then the satisfaction of the
Investigating Officer hardly matters. If satisfaction of Investigating
Officer is to be treated as determinative then the purpose of
Section 319 would be frustrated”.
10. Now adverting to the facts of the present case in the light of the
abovestated principles of law as laid down by the Hon’ble Supreme Court, the
F.I.R (Annexure P-1) in the present case was lodged by Chand Singh son of
Prem Singh, who was closely related to both the petitioners. In the F.I.R
(Annexure P-1), the complainant had specifically alleged that his nephew
Rakesh was killed by Manoj @Kala and Sahil, who had come to the place of
occurrence with pistols in their hands. As soon as they came, they open fire on
Rakesh with an intention to kill him. They had killed Rakesh in broad day light
in the village itself and after firing the bullets they fled from the spot with their
weapons. The occurrence had taken place on 26.02.2025 and the matter was
reported to the police after five hours.
11. I find sufficient force in the submissions made by the learned
counsel for the petitioners that in case the petitioners had hatched a conspiracy,
along with their co-accused to kill Rakesh, the complainant would have
definitely named both the petitioners, who are his first cousins. Apart from
that, even in his supplementary statement, the complainant had alleged that the
petitioners had hatched a conspiracy 4/6 months prior to the date of occurrence.
In fact, such allegations were levelled by the complainant in his supplementary
statement without any material particulars and even in the supplementary
statement, no specific role or overt act was attributed to the petitioners. Still
HITESH
2026.11.17 10:05
I attest to the accuracy and integrity
of this document
CRR-1062-2026 (O&M) - 10-
further, after registration of F.I.R, a S.I.T was duly constituted by the police and
the petitioners had joined the investigation. The police also moved an
application before the Court of Sub-Divisional Judicial Magistrate, Kharkhoda,
District Sonipat for conducting polygraph test on both the petitioners and the
petitioners had agreed to undergo the said test. Even responses of both the
petitioners were found to be truthful and the involvement could not be
established. Even, the police obtained call detail records, recorded the
statements of the witnesses and collected other material during the course of
investigation and it was conclusively found that the petitioners were neither
present at the place of occurrence at the relevant time nor had conspired with
their co-accused in any manner. Ultimately, a detailed charge-sheet was filed
against the co-accused and no credible evidence was attributed to the
petitioners. However, during the course of trial, Chand Singh, complainant
appeared as a PW-1 before the Trial Court and reiterated his supplementary
statement before the Trial Court. However, the petitioners could not have been
summoned as additional accused by the Trial Court simply because of the fact
that the complainant had named both of them in his deposition unless some
concrete evidence was found against the petitioners. The Trial Court utterly
failed to appreciate that in absence of strong and cogent evidence against the
petitioners, summoning of the petitioners on the basis of such weak,
uncorroborated and improve testimony was unwarranted. The Trial Court had
failed to appreciate that the allegations of conspiracy levelled by Chand Singh
against both the petitioners appeared to be an afterthought and the version of a
conspiracy 4/6 months prior to the occurrence was introduced subsequently by
him without any cogent and convincing evidence on record, which was highly
HITESH
2026.11.17 10:05
I attest to the accuracy and integrity
of this document
CRR-1062-2026 (O&M) - 11-
unsafe to summon the petitioners by exercising the powers under Section 319
Cr.P.C/358 B.N.S.S. Even otherwise, the law is well settled that the powers
under Section 319 Cr.P.C/358 B.N.S.S have to be exercised very sparingly and
only when the concerned Court is satisfied that some offence had been
committed by such persons.
12. Thus, in view of the above discussion, the present revision petition
succeeds and the impugned order dated 09.04.2026 passed by the Court of
Additional Sessions Judge, Sonipat is set aside.
13. Pending application(s), if any, stand(s), disposed of, accordingly.
(N.S.SHEKHAWAT)
16.11.2026 JUDGE
hitesh
Whether speaking/reasoned : Yes/No
Whether reportable : Yes/No
HITESH
2026.11.17 10:05
I attest to the accuracy and integrity
of this document