MANAGER, M/S. NEW INDIA ASSURANCE CO. LTD., KHORDHA vs MAMATA RATH
- Court
- Odisha High Court
IN THE HIGH COURT OF ORISSA AT CUTTACK
MACA NO.885 of 2025
CNR No. ODHC010498672025
(In the matter of application under Section-173(1) of
M.V. Act, 1988).
Appellant
…
The Manager, M/s New
India Assurance Co. Ltd.,
Khordha
-versus-
Mamata Rath and others Respondents
…
For Appellant : Mr. S. Satapathy, Adv
For Respondents
: Mr. D. Patnaik, Adv(R-1 & 2)
CORAM: JUSTICE G. SATAPATHY
DATE OF HEARING AND JUDGMENT: 30.09.2026
G. Satapathy, J.
1.
This is an appeal U/S.173(1) of the Motor
Vehicles Act, 1988 (in short, “the Act”) by the Manager
M/s. New India Assurance Co. Ltd, Khordha (in short,
“the insurer”) assailing the impugned judgment dated
th
31.01.2025 passed by learned 5 Motor Accident
Claims Tribunal, Khordha (in short, “the Tribunal”) in
MAC Case No.09 of 2022 directing the insurer to pay a
sum of Rs.37,21,538/- along with simple interest @ 6%
MACA No.885 of 2025
Page 1 of 9
per annum w.e.f 14.03.2022 till its actual realization to
the claimants-cum-Respondent Nos. 1 & 2.
2.
The facts in background are that in an
accident which took place on 23.11.2021, one
Sarbeswar Rath (hereinafter referred to as “the
while proceeding towards Jatni from
deceased”)
Khordha on his Motor Cycle was allegedly hit by one
Mini Truck bearing Regd. No. OD-02-E-7480
(hereinafter referred to as “the offending vehicle”) near
Carmel English Medium School, Badatota resulting in
his death and an FIR being filed on the accident came
to be registered in Jatni PS Case No. 629 of 2021 which
resulted in submission of charge sheet against the
driver for offence U/Ss. 279/304(A) of IPC for rash and
negligent driving the offending vehicle. On this
accident, on claim being preferred by the dependant of
the deceased, the learned tribunal granted
compensation indicated supra to such dependants as
claimants. Being aggrieved with the quantum of
compensation and not granting recovery right thereof
MACA No.885 of 2025
Page 2 of 9
from the owner of the offending vehicle by the
impugned judgment, the insurer has preferred this
appeal.
3.
In the course of hearing, Mr. Subrat
Satpathy, learned counsel for the Appellant by drawing
attention of the Court to the finding recorded by the
learned tribunal at paragraph 18 submits that although
the claimants-respondents have not filed the route
permit of the offending vehicle, but the learned tribunal
has erroneously considered that the claimants have
filed route permit and after recording so, the learned
tribunal proceeded to observe that there is no violation
of policy conditions by the insured, since the offending
vehicle was validly registered and insured with the
appellant covering the date of accident with its driver
having valid driving license. Further, Mr. Satpathy
submits that the insurer has in fact filed an additional
written statement together with information obtained
under RTI Act to suggest that the offending vehicle was
not having valid routes permit at the relevant time of
MACA No.885 of 2025
Page 3 of 9
accident and thereby, the owner of the offending
vehicle having willfully breached the policy conditions,
the insurer is not liable to indemnify him and at best,
the insurer would liable to pay the compensation with
recovery right thereof from the insured, but the learned
tribunal has not at all granted any right to recovery of
compensation and thereby, the tribunal has not
appreciated the evidence in proper prospective.
Further, Mr. Satpathy seriously assails the quantum of
compensation for not taking into account the relevant
factors while computing compensation for the
claimants. Accordingly, Mr. Satpathy prays to modify
the impugned judgment by reducing the compensation
with right to recovery thereof from R-3.
3.1.
On the other hand, Mr. Debasish Patnaik,
learned counsel for the R1& R2-cum-claimants submits
that the learned tribunal has rightly considered the
quantum of compensation, but the claimants is ready to
accept a small reduction in compensation. Further, Mr.
Patnaik does not wish to advance any argument with
MACA No.885 of 2025
Page 4 of 9
regard to claim of the insurer for right to recovery.
None appears for R3 despite valid service of notice of
the Appeal.
4.
After having considered the rival
submission upon perusal of record, the two questions
arise for consideration in this appeal are the right of
recovery and the quantum of compensation. Adverting
st
to the 1 question of right to recovery, it is emphasized
that the insurer has not at all adduced any evidence to
support its claim for right to recovery, however, the
insurer has claimed to have pleaded in its additional
written statement that the offending vehicle in question
was not having any route permit and to that effect, the
insurer claims support from an information obtained
under RTI Act, but the same document has never seen
the light of the day as neither the said information
obtained under RTI is exhibited in evidence nor has any
application been filed by the insurer to exhibit such
information. Additionally, no oral evidence has been
adduced by the insurer to support such claim. No
MACA No.885 of 2025
Page 5 of 9
doubt, the seizure list under Ext. 3 to 5 do not indicate
about seizure of route permit, but merely because the
seizure lists do not contain the seizure of route permit,
it would not ipso facto establish the plea of the insurer
that the offending vehicle was not having any valid
route permit for plying on the road. Law on this point is
very clear that unless the fact is pleaded and
established by way of evidence, the same cannot be
acted upon by the Court and it is, therefore, a clear
case of insurer not having any evidence to support its
claim. On the contrary, the learned tribunal in
paragraph 18 of the impugned judgment has
considered the challenge of the insurer for right to
recovery by observing inter-alia as under:-
“xxx xxx. On perusal of the said documents,
it is ascertained that Tikina Swain, the OP
No.1, was the owner of the offending vehicle
at the time of accident. The offending vehicle
had valid insurance at the time of accident
and the driver had valid driving licence. So,
as per the terms and conditions of the
policy, the insurance company, the OP No.2,
is liable to pay the entire compensation
amount.”
MACA No.885 of 2025
Page 6 of 9
5.
In view of the aforesaid facts and on
consideration of the materials placed on record
together with the re-appreciation evidence on record
and in absence of any evidence contrary to the finding
of the learned tribunal for the insured not having
violated the policy conditions, this Court does concur
the finding of the learned tribunal and accordingly,
holds that the insurer has not proved the violation of
terms and conditions of policy by the insured-cum-R3.
6.
On coming back to the next challenge of
the insurer-appellant as to the quantum of
compensation, it is considered apposite to reiterate that
the learned counsel for the claimants has agreed for
reduction of small amount. In the situation and on
negotiation as well as discussion with the learned
counsel for the parties with regard to quantifying the
compensation, this Court proposes a sum of Rs. 32
Lakhs along with 6 % interest w.e.f the date of filing of
the claim towards full and final settlement of the case,
and seeks response of the learned counsel for the
MACA No.885 of 2025
Page 7 of 9
parties, to which Mr. Debasish Patnaik, learned counsel
appearing for the R1 & R2 by filing a memo agrees and
accepts the proposal, whereas Mr. Subrat Satapathy,
learned counsel for the insurer leaves it to the discretion
of this Court.
7.
In the aforesaid facts and situation and
taking into account the law laid down by Apex court in
Taslim Parvin & Another vrs. (Smt.) Usha Devi &
Another; 2018(2) TAC 22 (SC) , since the claimants-
respondent Nos. 1 & 2 agrees to the proposal of the
Court through their counsel and the counsel for the
appellant-insurer without disputing to such proposal
leaves it to the discretion of the Court, it is considered
that interest of justice would be best served, if the
compensation amount is reduced to Rs. 32,00,000/-
together with interest @ 6% per annum w.e.f. the date
of filing of the claim application i.e. 14.03.2022 till its
realization which shall be paid by the insurer to the
claimants-(R-1 & 2).
MACA No.885 of 2025
Page 8 of 9
8.
In the result, the appeal is accordingly
disposed of with modification of compensation amount
to Rs. 32,00,000/- together with interest @ 6% per
annum w.e.f. the date of filing of the claim application
i.e. 14.03.2022 till its realization and this Court
accordingly directs the insurance company to pay the
modified compensation within eight weeks hence. In
case of deposit of the modified compensation, the same
shall be disbursed to the claimant-respondents
proportionately in terms of the award and the statutory
deposit together with the accrued interest thereon be
refunded back on receipt of proof of deposit of modified
compensation by the Appellant before the learned
Tribunal.
(G. Satapathy)
Judge
Orissa High Court, Cuttack,
th
Dated the 30 day of September, 2026/Priyajit
Signature Not Verified
Digitally Signed
Signed by: JAYAKRUSHNA DASH
Designation: Jr. Stenographer
Reason: Authentication
Location: High Court of Orissa, Cuttack
Date: 01-Oct-2026 19:22:49
MACA No.885 of 2025
Page 9 of 9