Jairam And Another vs Union Of India Throu General Manager Northern Railway N.Delh

Court
Allahabad High Court

A.F.R.
Reserved
HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT ALLAHABAD
LUCKNOW
FIRST APPEAL FROM ORDER No. - 167 of 2013
Jairam and another
…..Appellant(s)
Versus
Union of India Throu General Manager Northern Railway N.Delh
…..Respondent(s)
Counsel for Appellant(s) : Qazi Mohd.ahmad, Saleem Ahmad
Counsel for Respondent(s) : Vinay Tripathi, Pratul Kr.
Srivastava, Smt. Suman Lata Singh
Court No. - 16
HON'BLE SYED QAMAR HASAN RIZVI, J.
1. Sri Qazi Mohd. Ahmad, learned counsel for the appellants and Sri
Vinay Tripathi, learned counsel for the Union of India / respondent, are
present.
2. By means of the present Appeal, filed under Section 23 of the Railway
Claims Tribunal Act, 1987, the appellants / claimants have assailed the
judgment and order dated 17.01.2013 passed by Railway Claims
Tribunal, Lucknow Bench, Lucknow (hereinafter referred to as 'Claims
Tribunal') in Case No. OA/II/U/511/2010 (Jairam and another versus
Union of India), whereby the Original Application filed by the appellants
claiming compensation under Section 16 of the Railway Claims Tribunal
Act, 1987 read with Section 123(c)(2) and Section 124-A of the
Railways Act, 1989, came to be rejected.
3. The facts culled out from the pleadings are that the deceased / Sanjay
son of the appellants, boarded Train No. 5274, Satyagrah Express , at
Delhi Railway Station to travel to Sitapur, on the strength of a second-

2
FAFO No. - 167 of 2013
class general journey ticket. It is the case of the appellant that on
06.08.2009, during the course of the said journey, the deceased
accidentally fell down from the moving train between Sitapur City and
Hempur Railway Station near Gram Ameer Nagar, thereby sustaining
grievous injuries which resulted in his death. Thereafter, inquest
( panchnama ) was conducted and post-mortem examination of the
deceased was carried out on 06.08.2009 at the District Hospital, Sitapur.
It is the case of the appellants that the journey ticket was lost in the
accident.
4. The appellants are the father and mother of the deceased, namely,
Jairam and Smt. Bhanmati, residents of Village Ameernagar Allipur
Aliraj, District Sitapur. They lodged their claim by instituting an Original
Application, filed and registered on 02.08.2010, under Section 16 of the
Railway Claims Tribunal Act, 1987 read with Section 123(c)(2) and
Section 124-A of the Railways Act, 1989, before the learned Claims
Tribunal inter-alia claiming a sum of Rs. 8,00,000/- (Rupees Eight Lacs
only) together with interest, as compensation.
6. The learned Tribunal framed the following issues for determination:
1. Whether the deceased was a bonafide passenger of the train in
question?
2. Whether incident of death of the deceased falls under the ambit of
an untoward incident as defined U/s 123(c)(2) read with Section
124-A of the Railways Act?
3. Who are the dependants of the deceased?
4. To what relief?"
7. In support of the claim, the appellant no. 1 / Jai Ram (AW-1) filed his
affidavit along with an affidavit of one Mr. Baijnath (AW-2), who is
stated to be a witness of purchasing the journey ticket. The witness Mr.
Baijnath (AW-2) was cross-examined on 12.10.2011 by the learned
counsel for the respondent. In evidence, the appellants adduced the
panchnama , post-mortem report, voters card and ration card, as
documentary evidence. On the other hand, the respondent filed the
statutory DRM report containing a letter of Post Commandant, RPF
dated 10.03.2011, inquiry report of Mr. Sanjeev Verma, SI/RPF/SPC
(E.O.) dated 16.03.2011, memo of Station Master, Ramkot, copy of diary

3
FAFO No. - 167 of 2013
book, memo given by Gangman Mr. Ram Baksh, statement of Token
Porter-Rajendra Prasad, statement of Keyman-Ram Baksh, certified
copy of panchnama and certified copy of post-mortem report, as
evidence.
8. The learned Claims Tribunal decided the issues in the following
manner:
“ ISSUE NO. 3
This claim application is filed by the applicants, Mr. Jai Ram
and Smt. Bhanmati, on account of death of their son Sanjai.
Applicant no 1-Jai Ram has also filed his affidavit and deposed
that after death of deceased, he himself (father) and Smt.
Bhanmati (mother), are his dependants as the deceased was
unmarried. In support, applicants have filed photocopy of ration
card. No rebuttal evidence has been filed on behalf of the
respondent Railway. Hence, I hold that the above persons are the
only dependants of the deceased as provided under
Section-123(b) of the Act 1989'. This issue is decided
accordingly.
ISSUE NOS. 1 & 2
These two Issues are co-related, hence, they are taken up
together for discussion. The respondent in its reply statement
have come out with the general defence that the alleged Incident
might be one other than fall from the train and will not come
under the definition of untoward incident within the meaning of
Section 123 (c) (2) of the Railways Act, 1989. In support, the
respondent have filed statutory DRM report, containing a
लखनऊ
letter of Post Commandant, RPF dtd. 10.03.2011, inquiry report
of Mr. Sanjeev Verma, SI/RPF/SPC (E.O.) dated 16.03.2011,
memo of Station Master, Ramkot, copy of diary book, memo
given by Gangman Mr. Ram Baksh, statement of Rajendra
Prasad, Token Porter, statement of Ram Baksh, Keyman,
certified copy of panchanama and certified copy of post-mortem
report, as evidence.
On the other hand, the applicants have produced certain
documents i.e. panchanama, post-mortem report and have tried
to substantiate their stand to the fact that untoward incident did
occur with the deceased and attracts the provisions of Section
123 (2) of the Railways Act, 1989. In support of the claim,
applicant no. 1, Jal Ram, (AW-1) has filed his own affidavit
along with an affidavit of one Mr. Baljnath (AW-2), who is
stated to be a witness for purchasing the journey ticket. The
witness Mr. Baijnath (AW-2) has been cross-examined on
12.10.2011 by the Ld. Counsel for the respondent. On perusal of
the panchanama, it is evident that applicant no. 1, Jal Ram
(father of the deceased), was a member in the inquest
committee. He has opined along with other members of the
inquest committee that death of deceased was caused due to
being cut down by the train. No where in the inquest report, it
has been mentioned that the deceased died due falling down
from the train while travelling. Hence, there is material
contradiction. Moreover, applicants have also not filed any

4
FAFO No. - 167 of 2013
document to show or suggest that the deceased died due to
falling down from the train. No eye-witness of the alleged
Incident have been produced by the applicants who may state on
oath that death of the deceased was caused due to falling down
from the train. However, the applicants have filed an affidavit of
one Mr. Baijnath (AW-2), who is stated to be a witness for
purchasing the journey ticket, but so far as falling down
(untoward incident) of the deceased is concerned, nothing is
mentioned in it.
It is also clear from the post-mortem report filed by the
applicants that the deceased received crush injuries. This can
only happen if the body comes under the wheels of running
train. If somebody falls from a running train, it is impossible
that his body would be crushed by the wheels of the train as the
distance between two rails of the broad gauge railway track is 5
ft 6 inches. The width of railway coach in case of a broad gauge
train is 10 ft 6 inches. In other words, width of a coach is 5 ft
more than the gauge of the track (distance between two rails)
and as such, the doors of the coach will be 2 ft 6 inches away
from the rall on both the sides. If somebody falls from the
railway coach he will fall at least 2 feet 6 inches away from the
rail. Under these circumstances, it is impossible that body of the
deceased will come over the rail and get crushed
On the other hand, respondent have filed the statutory DRM
report in a very casual manner. The DRM report is containing
letter of Post Commandant, RPF dtd. 10.03.2011, Inquiry report
of Mr. Sanjeev Verma, SI/RPF/SPC (E.O.) dated 16.03.2011,
memo of Station Master, Ramkot, copy of diary book, memo
given by Gangman Mr. Ram Baksh, statement of Rajendra
Prasad, Token Porter, statement of Ram Baksh, Keyman,
certified copy of panchanama and certified copy of post-mortem
report, as evidence. On perusal of the inquiry report prepared by
Mr. Sanjeev Verma, SI/RPF/SPC (E.O.) dated 16.03.2011, it has
been mentioned that dead body of the deceased was lying at
Sitapur City-Hempur railway station and same was cut down
into two pieces. The inquest report is filed which was prepared
for unknown person, whereas, the applicant has filed inquest
report which was prepared in the name of Sanjai. The post-
mortem report filed by the respondent was prepared in favour of
Mr. Chhotoo, whereas, the deceased in this case is Sanjai.
Hence, the DRM report is prepared for any other person and not
the deceased Sanjal, hence, same is irrelevant so far as this case
is concerned.
It is pertinent to mention that U/S 101 and 102 of the Evidence
Act, the burden to prove the facts on which the legal right or
liability depends is on the person who asserts existence of such
facts. In this case,the applicants have failed to discharge their
burden. The Respondent Railway need not disprove the case of
the applicants when the case of the applicants itself stands
disproved. The facts as pleaded by the applicants are not
convincing to believe their version.
On the basis of evidence on record and attending circumstances
of the case, I hold that the deceased was not a bonafide
passenger of the train in question and his death was not caused
due to untoward incident as defined u/s 123 (c) (2) read with
Section 124-A of the Railways Act, 1989. Both these issues are,

5
FAFO No. - 167 of 2013
thus, decided against the applicants and in favour of the
respondent.
ISSUE NO.4
In view of our findings given in Issue No.1 & 2, I am of the
view that the applicants are not entitled to get any
compensation. As such, case of applicants is liable to be
dismissed. Hence ordered.
ORDER
The claim application of the applicants Mr. Jai Ram and Smt.
Bhanmati, is dismissed on contest against respondent, but in the
peculiar circumstances of the case, there is no order as to costs.”
9. The learned Claims Tribunal decided the above mentioned case vide
judgment and order dated 17.01.2013 thereby rejected the claim of the
present appellants.
10. Aggrieved by the aforesaid order, the appellants preferred the instant
Appeal, assailing the judgment and order dated 17.01.2013 passed by the
learned Railway Claims Tribunal, Lucknow Bench, Lucknow in Case
No. OA/II/U/511/2010 (Jairam and another versus Union of India).
11. Contention of the learned counsel appearing on behalf of the
appellants is that the findings recorded by the learned Claims Tribunal
are perverse to the available record and the judgment and order dated
17.01.2013 is totally based on assumption and presumption and cannot
be sustained in the eyes of law. His submission is that the learned
Tribunal has committed a manifest error in holding that the deceased
was not a bonafide passenger and that the injuries sustained by the
deceased were not from falling from a running train.
12. It is further submitted on behalf of the appellants that the learned
Tribunal did not consider the evidence available on record and merely on
the basis of hypothesis held that no person can come under the rail by
falling from the door of the train.
13. Learned counsel appearing for the appellants has further submitted
that the learned Tribunal has failed to appreciate that the deceased was a
bonafide passenger, as is evident from the statement of AW-2 Baijnath,
who was the witness of purchasing the journey ticket by the deceased.
He also asserted that the appellant (AW-1) specifically deposed before
the learned Claims Tribunal that the deceased purchased a valid railway

6
FAFO No. - 167 of 2013
ticket in the presence of AW-2 and boarded the Satyagrah Express on
05.08.2009 from Delhi Railway. It is urged by the learned counsel that
the appellant also deposed on oath that the journey ticket is lost during
the time of incident. It is also contended that no material is available on
record to establish that no railway ticket had been issued from Delhi
Railway Station for the journey in question, nor were the relevant ticket
sale records produced by the respondent before the learned Tribunal.
14. It is also asserted that the learned Tribunal failed to appreciate that
the respondent never denied the occurrence of the accident, and that the
evidence on record clearly establishes the case under the ambit of
'untoward incident' as defined under Section 123(c)(2) read with Section
124-A of the Railways Act, 1989.
15. It is urged by the appellants' learned counsel that the learned Tribunal
failed to appreciate that on the same date of occurrence two persons had
died from untoward accident, as is evident from the memo of the Station
Master and the report of the Keyman. It is submitted that the appellants
submitted the inquest ( Panchnama ) and post-mortem report of their son,
the deceased Sanjay, whereas the respondent submitted the inquest and
post-mortem report of another person, on account of misunderstanding,
which are liable to be ignored, and that the learned Tribunal arrived at a
conclusion that the panchnama and post-mortem report filed by the
respondent did not tally with the documents filed by the appellants,
which might be the ignorance of the respondent.
16. It is further urged that the learned Tribunal has taken a very
hypothetical view that the manner of accident would not be possible as
the body of the deceased was found bisected, and the findings so
recorded are contrary to the evidence available on record as well as the
settled principles governing claims arising out of 'untoward incident'. He
submits that the learned Tribunal has erred in law by deciding only Issue
Nos. 1 and 2 that too on a wrong premise and thereby in declining to
adjudicate the Issue No. 4.
18. Per Contra, learned counsel appearing on behalf of the respondent /
Railway Administration has opposed the appeal on the basis of the

7
FAFO No. - 167 of 2013
counter affidavit / objection dated 25.02.2014 and the written submission
dated 24.08.2026 and has submitted that the learned Railway Claims
Tribunal, after due consideration of the evidence on record and the
attending circumstances, has rightly held that the deceased was neither a
bonafide passenger of the train in question nor did he accidentally fell
down from the said train, and that the judgment and order dated
17.01.2013 is a well reasoned order and the present appeal is liable to be
dismissed. He contended that as per Sections 101 and 102 of the
Evidence Act, the burden to prove the facts on which the legal right or
liability depends is on the person who asserts existence of such facts and
the appellants have failed to discharge their burden.
19. Learned counsel for the respondent has further submitted that in the
inquest ( panchnama ) proceedings the appellant no. 1 Jairam was himself
a member of the inquest committee and opined along with the other
members that the death of the deceased was caused on being cut down
by the train; that 'cut down' does not mean falling down from the train;
that nowhere in the inquest report it has been mentioned that the
deceased died due to falling down from the train while travelling; and
that the claimants have not produced any eye-witness to state on oath
that the death of the deceased was caused due to falling down from the
train. It is further submitted that Mr. Baijnath (AW-2) stated about the
purchase of the journey ticket at Delhi only but said nothing about the
falling down of the deceased from Train No. 5274, Satyagrah Express,
and that, being a resident of Sitapur, he has not disclosed in his affidavit
the bonafide reasons of his presence at Delhi Railway Station, therefore,
his statement is not trustworthy.
20. It is also contended on behalf of the respondent that the post-mortem
report reveals that the deceased received crush injuries, which can only
happen if the body comes under the wheels of a running train, and that if
somebody falls from a running train it is impossible that his body would
be crushed by the wheels, as the distance between two rails of the broad
gauge track is 5 ft 6 inches whereas the width of the broad gauge coach
is 10 ft 6 inches, the doors of the coach being 2 ft 6 inches away from

8
FAFO No. - 167 of 2013
the rail on both sides. It is argued that the physics forces a body to 'fall
away' from a moving train, meaning thereby that a body cut into pieces
indicates track-crossing or suicide.
21. Elaborating the aforesaid submission, learned counsel for the
respondent has submitted that the respondent filed the statutory DRM
report, in terms of the ‘Rules of Manner of Investigation (Untoward
Incident) Rules, 2003’, along with the evidence referred to hereinabove,
and that Section 191 of the Railways Act, 1989 deals with the proof of
entries in railway records and documents and states that official entries
made by the railway administration can be used as evidence in legal
proceedings involving the railway. It is submitted that the report of the
RPF, the report of the Station Master, Sitapur City Railway Station and
the memo and statement of Ram Baksh (contained at pages 17, 18, 20
and 22 to the supplementary affidavit dated 18.08.2026) prove that two
men were lying cut between the railway track at Km. 76/6-9 near Sitapur
City Railway Station; that there is no whisper in the statement of the
appellant Jairam about the second body found between the railway track;
that the claimant has not informed the police and therefore, in the light
of the railway records, the statements of AW-1 and AW-2 are not
trustworthy and the claimants have failed to discharge the primary
liability to prove bonafide passenger and untoward incident.
22. It is submitted that in the present case the claimant witness (AW-2)
has made a statement regarding purchase of a ticket at Delhi station only
without disclosing all the relevant facts regarding his presence at Delhi,
that the claimant is silent about the death of another person as two dead
bodies were recovered from the accident site in the middle of the railway
track and the learned Railway Claims Tribunal has rightly rejected the
claim. It is lastly submitted that, for the reasons aforesaid, the order
dated 17.01.2013 passed by the learned Railway Claims Tribunal suffers
from no illegality and therefore the instant appeal is liable to be
dismissed.
23. Heard learned counsel for the parties and perused the material
available on record.

9
FAFO No. - 167 of 2013
24. The questions that fall for consideration before this Court, in the
present case, are whether the claim for compensation can be turned
down treating the deceased to be 'not a bonafide passenger' of the train in
question merely because no train ticket was found with the deceased and
whether the incident in question falls within the class of an 'untoward
incident' under Section 123(c)(2) read with Section 124-A of the
Railways Act, 1989 notwithstanding that the body of the deceased was
found severed into two pieces with crush injuries; and, consequently,
whether the appellants are entitled to compensation and, if so, to what
extent.
25. Insofar as the first question as referred herein above, this Court finds
that the same has been elucidated by the Hon'ble Supreme Court in the
case of Union of India versus Rina Devi reported in (2019) 3 Supreme
Court Cases 572 wherein the Hon'ble Court has been pleased to
consider the aspect of burden of proof where a body is found on railway
premises without journey ticket. For ready reference, the relevant
paragraph is quoted herein below:
"29 We thus hold that mere presence of a body on the Railway
premises will not be conclusive to hold that injured or deceased
was a bona fide passenger for which claim for compensation
could be maintained. However, mere absence of ticket with such
injured or deceased will not negative the claim that he was a bona
fide passenger. Initial burden will be on the claimant which can be
discharged by filing an affidavit of the relevant facts and burden
will then shift on the Railways and the issue can be decided on the
facts shown or the attending circumstances. This will have to be
dealt with from case to case on the basis of facts found. The legal
position in this regard will stand explained accordingly."
(emphasis supplied by this Court)
26. Recently, the Hon’ble Supreme Court in the case of Lata versus
Union of India and Another reported in 2026 SCC OnLine SC 1350,
has been pleased to hold that on the aspect of burden of proof, the
presence of a valid ticket is quite not possibly the only way the  bona
fide  nature of the passenger can be established. The Apex Court
categorically observed that technical approaches and lapses in procedure
should not defeat the welfare aim of the statute as it does not befit the
Railways, as an instrumentality of the State, to take such restrictive,

10
FAFO No. - 167 of 2013
pigeonhole view. The governing standard is the preponderance of
probabilities and not beyond reasonable doubt, as in criminal trials. The
foundational facts that need to be established are – (i) travelling on the
basis of a valid ticket; and (ii) an accident leading to death.Courts and
Tribunals should always take a view that retains the objective of the
Section as being accessible compensation with an underlying
humanitarian perspective.
27. The Hon’ble Supreme Court in the case of Sukhabhai Nanjibhai
Makwana and Another versus Union of India, reported in 2026 SCC
OnLine SC 2008 has observed as under:
“10.  ……………. In these circumstances, we are of the view that
the Tribunal was justified in concluding that the victim was a  bona
fide  passenger. The High Court gave undue importance to the
absence of the railway ticket without taking into consideration the
statement made on oath by the victim's father and the fact that the
victim had been hospitalised for a period of more than one month.
On preponderance of probabilities, it can be concluded that the
victim was a  bona fide  passenger and that absence of recovery of
his ticket cannot result in defeating the claim for compensation.
The principle of ‘strict liability’ flowing from Section 124-A of the
Act of 1989 as held in  Union of India  v.  Prabhakaran Vijaya
Kumar  is clearly attracted .”
28. Upon applicability of the above-quoted judgment passed by the
Hon'ble Supreme Court in the present case, it is apparent that the initial
burden has been discharged by the appellants upon production not only
of the affidavit of the appellant no. 1 / Jai Ram (AW-1) but also by
examining Mr. Baijnath (AW-2), who has deposed that the deceased
purchased a second class general journey ticket from Delhi to Sitapur
and boarded the said train, and was duly cross-examined on 12.10.2011.
The learned Tribunal discarded the testimony of AW-2 on the ground
that he had stated nothing about the falling down of the deceased and
had not disclosed the reasons of his presence at Delhi Railway Station
despite being a resident of Sitapur. In the considered opinion of this
Court, AW-2 was produced as a witness to the purchase of the journey
ticket and not as an eye-witness to the fall, and the learned Tribunal has
not recorded any material contradiction as having been elicited from him
in his cross-examination. The non-mention of the reasons of his presence

11
FAFO No. - 167 of 2013
at Delhi cannot, by itself, be a ground to discard his testimony on the
vital fact of purchase of the ticket.
29. Thus, in view of above quoted judgements, mere absence of ticket
will not negative the claim that the deceased was a bonafide passenger.
The respondent has neither produced the relevant ticket sale record of
Delhi Railway Station nor any other material to establish that no journey
ticket had been issued to the deceased or that he was not travelling in the
train in question. Thus, there was no evidence before the learned
Tribunal to rebut the case of the appellants on the point of bonafide
travel. In view of the aforesaid judgment of the Hon'ble Supreme Court,
as applicable to the facts and circumstances of the present case, it is held
that the deceased / Sanjay was a bonafide passenger in the train in
question.
30. To delve into the second question involved in the present case, it
would be apposite to first advert to the relevant provisions of Chapter
XIII of the Railways Act, 1989, which deals with the liability of the
Railway Administration for the death of, and injury to, passengers
arising out of accidents. In particular, Section 123(c) of the Act of 1989
defines the expression 'untoward incident', while Section 124-A of the
same provides for the payment of compensation on account of such
incidents.
31. Section 123(c)(2) of the Railways Act, 1989 defines 'untoward
incident' to include the accidental falling of any passenger from a train
carrying passengers. The relevant provision is extracted here in below:
"123 (c) untoward incident means-
…
(2) the accidental falling of any passenger from a train carrying
passengers."
32. Section 124-A provides that when an untoward incident occurs, 'then
whether or not there has been any wrongful act, neglect or default on the
part of the railway administration' such as would entitle the dependent of
the passenger who has died to maintain an action, the railway
administration shall be liable to pay compensation, subject only to the

12
FAFO No. - 167 of 2013
exceptions enumerated in the proviso thereto. A bare perusal of Section
124-A reveals the beneficial and welfare legislative intention dealing
with situation(s) of strict liability or no fault liability in case of railway
accidents and reflects that if a case comes within the purview of Section
124-A it is wholly irrelevant as to who was at fault. For convenience the
said Section 124-A is quoted herein below:
"124A. Compensation on account of untoward incident . -
When in the course of working a railway an untoward incident
occurs, then whether or not there has been any wrongful act,
neglect or default on the part of the railway administration such
as would entitle a passenger who has been injured or the
dependent of a passenger who has been killed to maintain an
action and recover damages in respect thereof, the railway
administration shall, notwithstanding anything contained in any
other law, be liable to pay compensation to such extent as may
be prescribed and to that extent only for loss occasioned by the
death of, or injury to, a passenger as a result of such untoward
incident:
Provided that no compensation shall be payable under this
section by the railway administration if the passenger dies or
suffers injury due to-
(a) suicide or attempted suicide by him;
(b) self-inflicted injury;
(c) his own criminal act;
(d) any act committed by him in a state of intoxication or
insanity;
(e) any natural cause or disease or medical or surgical treatment
unless such treatment becomes necessary due to injury caused
by the said untoward incident.
Explanation - For the purposes of this section, "passenger"
includes
(i) a railway servant on duty; and
(ii) a person who has purchased a valid ticket for travelling by a
train carrying passengers, on any date or a valid platform ticket
and becomes a victim of an untoward incident."
33. It is relevant to note here that in exercise of power under Section 129
of the Railways Act, 1989, the Central Government framed rules known
as Railway Accidents and Untoward Incidents (Compensation) Rules,
1990. The said Rules provided for a Schedule prescribing the amount of
compensation payable in respect of death and injuries. However, the said
Rules have been amended w.e.f. 01.01.2017 by Notification dated

13
FAFO No. - 167 of 2013
22.12.2016, substituting the Schedule by higher amount of
compensation.
34. With regard to establishment of the alleged accident, the death of the
deceased on the railway track between Sitapur City and Hempur
Railway Station near Gram Ameer Nagar on 06.08.2009 stands
corroborated by the documentary evidence brought on record, such as,
the panchnama and the post-mortem report. However, the case of the
appellants / claimants has been turned down by the learned Tribunal on
the ground that the post-mortem report records crush injuries, the body
of the deceased was found severed into two pieces and, according to the
measurements of the broad gauge track and the coach, a person falling
from the coach cannot come over the rail and get crushed, therefore, the
death is presumed to be a case not covered under Section 123(c)(2) and
Section 124-A of the Railways Act, 1989. In the considered opinion of
this Court, the said finding is based merely on presumption and is not
supported by any independent oral or expert evidence. The respondent
has failed to adduce any evidence to establish that the deceased was not
travelling in the train or that the incident did not constitute an 'untoward
incident' within the meaning of Section 123(c)(2) read with Section 124-
A of the Railways Act, 1989.
35. The Hon'ble the Supreme Court in the case of Solanki Chimanbhai
Ukabhai versus State of Gujarat reported in (1983) 2 Supreme Court
Cases 174 has been pleased to hold as follows:
"13. Ordinarily, the value of medical evidence is only
corroborative. It proves that the injuries could have been caused
in the manner alleged and nothing more. The use which the
defence can make of the medical evidence is to prove that the
injuries could not possibly have been caused in the manner
alleged and thereby discredit the eye witnesses. Unless, however
the medical evidence in its turn goes so far that it completely
rules out all possibilities whatsoever of injuries taking place in
the manner alleged by eye witnesses, the testimony of the eye
witnesses cannot be thrown out on the ground of alleged
inconsistency between it and the medical evidence."
36. The High Court of Delhi in the case of Sh. Prempal Singh and
Another versus Union of India, reported in 2018 SCC OnLine Del
9571 has held as under:

14
FAFO No. - 167 of 2013
"7. The reasoning in the impugned order that because the
deceased was cut into halves: one part found inside the railway
tracks and the other outside, the death could not have been
caused due to accidental falling from a moving train, is flawed.
The impossibility of a passenger being so crushed after a fall
from a moving train has not been conclusively established in
law, so as to obviate all such claims for compensation. It is
possible that the deceased while standing near the overcrowded
passenger compartment door, slipped down while holding on to
the door- railing, and frantically tried to recover and re-board the
train - with his legs flailing violently, and in the valiant and
violent melee his legs or his body could have unfortunately
come under the wheels of the train leading to his being
consumed in the fatal accident. As long as such possibility
exists, the claim cannot be ousted or denied on technical
assumptions. There is not a divine camera which could replay
the actual manner of the fatality, but all factors lead to the
inexorable conclusion that a bonafide passenger died in an
untoward train accident. There is also no reason why the
deceased would be walking the railway tracks in an odd place
en-route his destination - his home. It is not that he lived near
the site of the accident or that he had any regular business
anywhere near the place of the accident. Thus the inference that
he died while crossing the tracks, is unwarranted and
untenable."
(underline supplied by this Court)
37. Similar view has been expressed by this Court in the case of Lali
versus Union of India, reported in 2026 SCC OnLine All 26470,
wherein the Court observed as under:
“33. At this stage, it would not be out of place to observe that in
certain cases where a passenger accidentally loses balance due to
sudden jolting, overcrowding or abrupt movement / braking of a
running train and falls therefrom, the possibility of the passenger
coming into contact with the wheels or other moving parts of the
train, cannot be ruled out. In such a situation, a human body may
sustain grievous injuries, including severance or fragmentation,
depending upon the manner and circumstances of the fall.
Therefore, the mere fact that the body of the deceased was found
in multiple pieces cannot, by itself, lead to a conclusive inference
that the case was one of the circumstances specified in the
proviso to Section 124-A of the Railways Act, 1989. For
attracting the exceptions contained in the proviso to Section 124-
A of the Railways Act, 1989, the Railways is required to establish
the same by leading cogent and substantial evidence.”
(emphasis supplied by this Court)
38. The reliance placed by learned counsel for the respondent upon
Sumitra Mishra and others versus Union of India and others
reported in 2016 SCC OnLine All 3922 and Tara Chand
Mathur v. Union of India, through General Manager Northern

15
FAFO No. - 167 of 2013
Railwa y (F.A.F.O. Defective No. 763 of 2011) is of no avail to the
respondent. As projected by the learned counsel for the respondent
himself, the observation therein is that in case a person falls down from a
train 'ordinarily' the body would not be cut into two pieces, and the
version of the claimants in those cases was not believed. In the present
case, the learned Tribunal has drawn the inference from the condition of
the body and the geometry of the track and the coach alone. Such an
inference, in view of the law discussed herein above is unsustainable in
law since the documents annexed with the DRM report were found by
the learned Tribunal itself to have been prepared in respect of another
person. The circumstance that two persons were found lying cut at Km.
76/6-9 on the same date, which the respondent itself has emphasised,
rather lends support to the contention of the appellants that the record
produced by the respondent pertains to another person, and by itself it
does not establish that the deceased was not a passenger.
39. Insofar as the findings of the learned Tribunal that the inquest report
does not mention a fall from the train, that the appellant no. 1 was a
member of the inquest committee, and that no eye-witness was
produced, this Court finds that in the opinion of panchas records the
expression ‘cut down by the train’ in the inquest report ( panchnama ) at
best describes the injuries sustained by the deceased and does not, by
itself, exclude an accidental fall from the train.
40. Having regard to the law discussed hereinabove and to the facts and
circumstances of the present case, it is evident that the evidence adduced
on behalf of the appellants was not appreciated by the learned Claims
Tribunal in its correct perspective. AW-1 deposed that the deceased had
purchased a valid journey ticket in the presence of AW-2 and had
boarded the Satyagrah Express to travel from Delhi to Sitapur, and that
the ticket could not be recovered since it had, in all probability, been lost
during the incident. This version was duly corroborated by AW-2, Mr.
Baijnath. In such circumstances, there was no justification for the
learned Claims Tribunal to reject the claim merely on account of the
non-recovery of the journey ticket and the condition in which the body

16
FAFO No. - 167 of 2013
of the deceased was found, particularly when the respondent had led no
independent evidence to rebut the case of the appellants.
41. A case of run over is sought to be built on the injuries sustained by
the deceased, whose body was found severed into two parts. The
question that arises is whether, solely by reason of the nature of such
injuries, a conclusion can be drawn that the deceased was run over by a
train. It is true that such injuries are possible where a person is run over
by a train. At the same time, it must be borne in mind that injuries of this
kind can equally result from an accidental fall of a passenger from a
moving train. There is no eyewitness to the incident. In the absence of
any categorical report by the loco pilot that a passenger was run over at
the place and time of the incident, the possibility that the deceased fell
from a moving train and came under its wheels cannot be ruled out.
42. As such, the finding of the learned Tribunal that since the deceased
had received crush injuries, which could occur only if the body came
under the wheels of a running train, and that it is impossible for the body
of a person falling from a running train to be crushed by its wheels is
unacceptable in the facts and circumstances of the case as narrated
herein above. It would not be out of place to observe that it is not a
universal proposition that every crush injury is necessarily caused by
contact with a moving train undoubtedly, an injury can also be sustained
when a person falls from a speeding train. Nor can it be said with
certainty that a leg or any other limb cannot be severed in an accidental
fall from a train. Indeed, there may be several speculative assumptions
as to the cause of death or injuries, but a theory, to be acceptable, must
be consistent with the facts of the case and the evidence on record. In the
instant case, there is nothing on record to indicate that the injuries could
not have been caused by an accidental fall from a running train. On the
contrary, the evidence on record is compatible with the theory of an
accidental fall from a running train. Resultantly, the finding of the
Tribunal, that the death of the deceased was not caused in an untoward
incident, cannot be sustained.

17
FAFO No. - 167 of 2013
43. This Court is of the opinion that the learned Tribunal was required to
exercise due caution in appreciating the evidence. In the facts and
circumstances of the case in hand, this Court is of the view that the
finding of fact arrived at by the learned Tribunal are unsustainable, and
the case set up by the railway is not acceptable. Needless to observed
that, had the deceased been run over by a train at the place and time of
the incident, the loco pilot would have reported the same to the Station
Master. Upon a cumulative consideration of these facts, the case of the
appellants falls within the first part of Section 124-A of the Railways
Act, 1989 (for short, "the Act of 1989"), and does not fall within any of
the clauses of the proviso to Section 124-A of the Act of 1989.
44. It is pertinent to note that Section 124-A is a beneficial piece of
legislation, inserted with the avowed object of awarding compensation to
the injured, or to the dependents of the deceased, in cases of injury or
death in an untoward incident. Having regard to its beneficial object, the
provision deserves a liberal interpretation, and where two views or
constructions are possible, the one which advances the object of the
statute and serves its purpose should be preferred.
45. In view of the foregoing discussion, this Court finds that the learned
Tribunal was not justified in rejecting the claim. The evidence led by the
appellants called for consideration in its entirety, together with the
attendant circumstances. For the reasons aforestated, the findings
returned by the learned Claims Tribunal on Issue Nos. 1 and 2 are
perverse and unsustainable in the eyes of law. The said findings are,
therefore, set aside, and Issue Nos. 1 and 2 are answered in the
affirmative, in favour of the appellants and against the respondent.
46. As regards the third Issue relating to dependency, this Court notes
that the claim petition was preferred by the father and mother of the
deceased, who asserted their status as his legal dependents. Appellant
No. 1 filed an affidavit in evidence reaffirming this status, and a ration
card was filed in support. This evidence stood uncontroverted before the
Tribunal, as the respondent Railway led no rebuttal evidence, and the
said finding of the learned Tribunal has not been assailed by the

18
FAFO No. - 167 of 2013
respondent. In view of the beneficial object of the statute and the
absence of any contrary material on record, the issue of dependency is
affirmed in favour of the appellants, and they are held to be bona fide
dependents of the deceased within the meaning of Section 123(b) of the
Railways Act, 1989.
47. As regards the fourth Issue relating to the quantum of compensation,
the untoward incident occurred on 06.08.2009, when the structured
compensation prescribed for death under the Schedule to the Railway
Accidents and Untoward Incidents (Compensation) Rules, 1990 was Rs.
4,00,000/- (Rupees Four Lakhs only). The Central Government,
however, amended the Schedule with effect from 01.01.2017, enhancing
the basic structured compensation for death to Rs. 8,00,000/- (Rupees
Eight Lakhs only). Since the issue of dependency has already been
decided in favour of the appellants, the evidence on record is complete,
and the compensation payable is a structured sum prescribed by the
Schedule, this Court finds no useful purpose in remitting the matter to
the learned Claims Tribunal for fresh adjudication, which would only
prolong the litigation arising out of the incident of the year 2009. It is,
therefore, considered appropriate to determine the compensation at this
stage.
48. The legal position governing the grant of compensation when an
accident occurs prior to the 2017 amendment but the final adjudication
takes place thereafter is no longer res integra. The Hon'ble Supreme
Court in Rina Devi (supra) subsequently clarified and followed in
Union of India versus Radha Yadav reported in (2019) 3 SCC 410.
The relevant paragraph of the Radha Yadav (supra) reads as under:
"11. The issue raised in the matter does not really require any
elaboration as in our view, the judgment of this Court in Rina
Devi is very clear. What this Court has laid down is that the
amount of compensation payable on the date of accident with
reasonable rate of interest shall first be calculated. If the amount
so calculated is less than the amount prescribed as on the date of
the award, the claimant would be entitled to higher of these two
amounts. Therefore, if the liability had arisen before the
amendment was brought in, the basic figure would be as per the
Schedule as was in existence before the amendment and on such
basic figure reasonable rate of interest would be calculated. If
there be any difference between the amount so calculated and the

19
FAFO No. - 167 of 2013
amount prescribed in the Schedule as on the date of the award, the
higher of two figures would be the measure of compensation. For
instance, in case of a death in an accident which occurred before
amendment, the basic figure would be Rs 4,00,000. If, after
applying reasonable rate of interest, the final figure were to be less
than Rs 8,00,000, which was brought in by way of amendment,
the claimant would be entitled to Rs 8,00,000. If, however, the
amount of original compensation with rate of interest were to
exceed the sum of Rs 8,00,000 the compensation would be in
terms of figure in excess of Rs 8,00,000. The idea is to afford the
benefit of the amendment, to the extent possible. Thus, according
to us, the matter is crystal clear. The issue does not need any
further clarification or elaboration."
49. It is not disputed that the incident took place on 06.08.2009 and that
the impugned order was rendered on 17.01.2013. Applying the aforesaid
principle to the present case, where the claim petition was instituted in
the year 2010 as OA/II/U/511/2010, if interest at a reasonable rate of 6%
per annum is applied to the sum of Rs. 4,00,000/- (Rupees Four Lakhs
only) from the date of the accident till the date of the impugned order of
the learned Claims Tribunal, the total sum falls below the enhanced
statutory limit. Consequently, in line with the mandate in Radha Yadav
( supra ), the appellants are entitled to the higher, revised compensation of
Rs. 8,00,000/- (Rupees Eight Lakhs only) in lump sum.
50. Accordingly, the present appeal is allowed . The impugned judgment
and order dated 17.01.2013, passed by the Railway Claims Tribunal,
Lucknow Bench, in Original Application No. OA/II/U/511/2010, is
hereby set aside. The Original Claim Application consequently stands
allowed in the following operative terms:
(i) The Respondent / Railways is directed to pay a lump-sum
compensation amount of Rs. 8,00,000/- (Rupees Eight Lakhs only) to the
appellants within a period of eight week from the date of production of
the Certified Copy of this Order, along with the required documents.
(ii) In case, if, the Respondent fails to deposit / pay the said amount
within the stipulated period of eight weeks, the awarded sum shall carry
interest at the rate of 9% per annum thereafter, till the actual date of
payment.
51. The lower court records be remitted back to the Railway Claims
Tribunal, Lucknow Bench. No order as to costs.

20
FAFO No. - 167 of 2013
52. Before parting, this Court places on record its sincere appreciation
for the research assistance provided by Mr. Rajat Srivastava, Research
Associate, and Ms. Mizana Kabeer, Law Intern, in finding out the
relevant case laws applicable to the present case.
(Syed Qamar Hasan Rizvi,J.)
November 20, 2026
Virendra
Digitally signed by :-
VIRENDRA KUMAR GUPTA
High Court of Judicature at Allahabad,
Lucknow Bench