DR MANJAPPA N vs THE VICE CHANCELLOR AND CHAIRMAN OF KARNATAKA VETERINARY
- Court
- Karnataka High Court
- 1 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:12505
WP No. 202073 of 2026
CNR: KAHC030049162026
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA
KALABURAGI BENCH
TH
DATED THIS THE 19 DAY OF NOVEMBER, 2026
BEFORE
THE HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE VIJAYKUMAR A. PATIL
WRIT PETITION NO. 202073 OF 2026 (S-PRO)
BETWEEN:
DR. MANJAPPA N S/O NINGAPPA
AGE: 48 YEARS OCC: ASSOCIATE PROFESSOR
R/O C-7 UAS STAFF QUATERS
OPP. VETERINARY COLLEGE
HEBBAL, BANGALORE-560024
…PETITIONER
(BY SRI RAVI BHEEMSINGH CHAWAN, ADVOCATE)
AND:
1. THE VICE CHANCELLOR
AND CHAIRMAN OF KARNATAKA VETERINARY
ANIMAL AND FISHERIES SCIENCES UNIVERSITY
NANDI NAGAR, PB NO.6
BIDAR-585226
2. THE REGISTRAR
KARNATAKA VETERINARY, ANIMAL
AND FISHERIES SCIENCES UNIVERSITY
NANDI NAGAR, PB NO.6, BIDAR-585226
…RESPONDENTS
Digitally signed
by SWETA
KULKARNI
Location: HIGH
COURT OF
KARNATAKA
(BY MISS NILUFARHANAZ, ADVOCATE FOR R1 AND R2)
THIS WRIT PETITION IS FILED UNDER ARTICLES 226
AND 227 OF THE CONSTITUTION OF INDIA, PRAYING TO, A)
ISSUE A WRIT OF CERTIORARI THEREBY QUASHING THE
- 2 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:12505
WP No. 202073 of 2026
CNR: KAHC030049162026
IMPUGNED ORDER BEARING NO.R/KVASU/RECTT./CAS-2016.
TEACHER.PROM.ORDER/ 2026-27 DATED 06.02.2026 VIDE
ANNEXURE-H ISSUED BY THE RESPONDENT NO.2 WHEREIN
THE PETITIONER NAME WAS NOT INCLUDED IN THE FINAL
PROMOTION LIST; B) CONSEQUENTLY, TO QUASH THE
ENDORSEMENT DATED 13.03.2026 ISSUED BY THE
RESPONDENT NO.2 VIDE ANNEXURE-L, THEREBY THE DENIAL
OF THE PROMOTION OF THE PETITIONER; AND C) DIRECT THE
RESPONDENT NO.2 TO CONSIDER THE REPRESENTATION
DATED 23.02.2026 VIDE ANNEXURE-K AND PROMOTE TO THE
PETITIONER WITH EFFECT FROM 16.03.2025 FOR THE POST OF
ASSOCIATE PROFESSOR (ACADEMIC PAY LEVEL 13A) TO
PROFESSOR (ACADEMIC PAY LEVEL 14) UNDER CAREER
ADVANCEMENT SCHEME-2016, ALONG WITH ALL
CONSEQUENTIAL SERVICE AND MONETARY BENEFITS; D)
PASS SUCH OTHER ORDER(S) AS THIS COURT DEEMS FIT IN
THE INTEREST OF JUSTICE AND EQUITY.
THIS PETITION, COMING ON FOR PRELIMINARY HEARING
'B' GROUP, THIS DAY, ORDER WAS MADE THEREIN AS UNDER:
CORAM: HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE VIJAYKUMAR A. PATIL
ORAL ORDER
This writ petition is filed seeking following prayers:
“a) Issue a writ of certiorari thereby quashing the
impugned order bearing No.R/KVASU/Rectt./CAS-
2016. Teacher.Prom.Order/ 2026-27 dated
06.02.2026 vide Annexure-H issued by the
respondent No.2 wherein the petitioner name was
not included in the final promotion list;
b) Consequently, to quash the endorsement dated
13.03.2026 issued by the respondent No.2 vide
Annexure-L, thereby the denial of the promotion of
the petitioner; and
- 3 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:12505
WP No. 202073 of 2026
CNR: KAHC030049162026
c) Direct the respondent No.2 to consider the
representation dated 23.02.2026 vide Annexure-K
and promote to the petitioner with effect from
16.03.2025 for the post of Associate Professor
(Academic Pay Level 13A) to Professor (Academic
Pay Level 14) under Career Advancement Scheme-
2016, along with all consequential service and
monetary benefits;
d) Pass such other order(s) as this court deems fit in
the interest of justice and equity.”
2. Learned counsel appearing for the petitioner
submits that the petitioner is working as an Associate
Professor and is eligible for promotion. It is submitted
that the petitioner was called for interview for the
promotion as he was eligible along with other candidates.
Thereafter he attended the interview. However, his name
was not found in the promotion list. Later he submitted a
representation to the respondents seeking to consider his
request for promotion. It is further submitted that the
respondent - authorities issued the impugned
endorsement stating that the petitioner is not promoted on
the ground that a criminal case is pending against him
which is factually incorrect. It is also submitted that the
- 4 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:12505
WP No. 202073 of 2026
CNR: KAHC030049162026
Bidar Lokayukta Police registered an FIR however, the
petitioner is not named in the FIR. He obtained the
anticipatory bail and till this day no charge sheet is filed
against anyone. Hence, the petitioner’s promotion cannot
be withheld. Hence, he seeks to allow the petition by
directing the respondent - University to promote the
petitioner as a Professor.
3. Per contra , learned counsel appearing for the
respondent - University supports the action of the
University and submits that the University has considered
the petitioner’s candidature in the meeting and on noticing
that a criminal case is pending against him before the
Karnataka Lokayukta, Bidar, the University followed sealed
cover procedure and once the criminal case is concluded,
the University would consider the candidature of the
petitioner for promotion. It is submitted that the
University in its proceedings held on 09.01.2026 assigned
detailed reasons and thereafter followed the sealed cover
- 5 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:12505
WP No. 202073 of 2026
CNR: KAHC030049162026
procedure pending completion of the proceedings against
the petitioner. Hence, she seeks to dismiss the petition.
4. I have heard the arguments of the learned
counsel for the petitioner and learned counsel appearing
for the respondent - University. Meticulously perused the
materials available on record. I have given my anxious
consideration to the submissions advanced.
5. The petitioner averred that he had completed
Ph.D and was appointed as an Associate Professor.
Thereafter he was transferred to different places under the
University and worked without any blemish. It is further
averred that the petitioner being eligible for promotion,
applied for the same on 16.03.2025 seeking promotion
from the cadre of Associate Professor to Professor cadre.
The University found him eligible as per the eligible list of
candidates dated 17.07.2025 at Annexure-F. The material
on record indicate that the respondent No.2 sent an
intimation to all the eligible candidates for their
- 6 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:12505
WP No. 202073 of 2026
CNR: KAHC030049162026
appearance for interview. The petitioner attended the
interview on 08.01.2026. The Committee recommended
eligible candidates for promotion. However, the name of
the petitioner in the list of promotees was not found
despite his eligibility for the post. The material on record
th
indicate that in the 124 meeting of Board of Management
held on 09.01.2026, the petitioner’s candidature was
considered and sealed cover procedure was followed on
the ground that the petitioner is an accused in Crime
No.7/2021 registered by Bidar Lokayukta Police and
decided to consider the case for promotion after conclusion
of the proceedings. The petitioner submitted a
representation dated 23.02.2026 complaining that his
name does not find place in the final list of promotees.
The respondent No.2 – University issued endorsement
dated 13.03.2026 indicating that a criminal case is
pending against the petitioner and after the petitioner gets
acquitted, they would consider his candidature for
promotion to the post of Professor. The University has
- 7 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:12505
WP No. 202073 of 2026
CNR: KAHC030049162026
followed the sealed cover procedure and have not provided
promotion to the petitioner though he was found eligible,
on the ground that criminal case is pending against him.
The material on record indicate that Crime No.7/2021 is
registered by ACB, Bidar on 04.10.2021 based on the
complaint of Dr. K. Venkat Reddy and Sri K.C.
Shankaregowda. In the said FIR the name of the
petitioner does not find place. It is to be noticed that till
this day the investigation is not completed and no charge
sheet is filed against the petitioner.
6. At this stage it would be appropriate to consider
the decision rendered by the Hon’ble Supreme Court and
this court on the subject. The Hon’ble Supreme Court in
the case of UNION OF INDIA & ORS. VS. K.V.
1
JANKIRAMAN & ORS. in paragraphs 16 and 17 held as
under:
“16. On the first question, viz., as to when for the
purposes of the sealed cover procedure the
1
(1991) 4 SCC 109
- 8 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:12505
WP No. 202073 of 2026
CNR: KAHC030049162026
disciplinary/criminal proceedings can be said to have
commenced, the Full Bench of the Tribunal has held
that it is only when a charge-memo in a disciplinary
proceedings or a charge-sheet in a criminal
prosecution is issued to the employee that it can be
said that the departmental proceedings/criminal
prosecution is initiated against the employee. The
sealed cover procedure is to be resorted to only after
the charge-memo/charge-sheet is issued. The
pendency of preliminary investigation prior to that
stage will not be sufficient to enable the authorities
to adopt the sealed cover procedure. We are in
agreement with the Tribunal on this point. The
contention advanced by the learned counsel for the
appellant-authorities that when there are serious
allegations and it takes time to collect necessary
evidence to prepare and issue charge-memo/charge-
sheet, it would not be in the interest of the purity of
administration to reward the employee with a
promotion, increment etc. does not impress us. The
acceptance of this contention would result in injustice
to the employees in many cases. As has been the
experience so far, the preliminary investigations take
an inordinately long time and particularly when they
are initiated at the instance of the interested
persons, they are kept pending deliberately. Many
times they never result in the issue of any charge-
memo/charge-sheet. If the allegations are serious
and the authorities are keen in investigating them,
ordinarily it should not take much time to collect the
relevant evidence and finalise the charges. What is
further, if the charges are that serious, the
authorities have the power to suspend the employee
under the relevant rules, and the suspension by itself
permits a resort to the sealed cover procedure. The
authorities thus are not without a remedy. It was
then contended on behalf of the authorities that
conclusions Nos. 1 and 4 of the Full Bench of the
Tribunal are inconsistent with each other. Those
conclusions are as follows: (ATC p. 196, para 39)
- 9 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:12505
WP No. 202073 of 2026
CNR: KAHC030049162026
“(1) consideration for promotion, selection grade,
crossing the efficiency bar or higher scale of pay
cannot be withheld merely on the ground of
pendency of a disciplinary or criminal proceedings
against an official;
(2) *
(3) *
(4) the sealed cover procedure can be resorted to
only after a charge memo is served on the concerned
official or the charge-sheet filed before the criminal
court and not before;”
17. There is no doubt that there is a seeming
contradiction between the two conclusions. But read
harmoniously, and that is what the Full Bench has
intended, the two conclusions can be reconciled with
each other. The conclusion No. 1 should be read to
mean that the promotion etc. cannot be withheld
merely because some disciplinary/criminal
proceedings are pending against the employee. To
deny the said benefit, they must be at the relevant
time pending at the stage when charge-
memo/charge-sheet has already been issued to the
employee. Thus read, there is no inconsistency in the
two conclusions.”
7. The Hon’ble Supreme Court in the case of
2
UNION OF INDIA & ORS. VS. ANIL KUMAR SARKAR
at para 13 to 17 held as under:
“13. Aggrieved by the said decision of the Tribunal,
the respondent herein filed a petition before the High
Court, wherein, the said memorandum, particularly
Para 2, was pressed into service. The High Court,
taking note of the conditions prescribed in Para 2 and
2
Civil Appeal No.2537/2023 disposed of on 15.03.2013
- 10 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:12505
WP No. 202073 of 2026
CNR: KAHC030049162026
in the absence of any such condition as on the
relevant date i.e. 21-4-2003, set aside the order of
the Tribunal and directed the Railways to consider
the case of the respondent for promotion.
14. As per Para 2 of the said memorandum, at the
time of consideration of the government servants for
promotion, the following details of government
servants in the consideration zone for promotion
falling in the categories mentioned should be
specifically brought to the notice of the DPC viz. (i)
Government servant is under suspension; (ii)
Government servant has been served with a charge-
sheet and the disciplinary proceedings are pending;
and (iii) Government servant is facing prosecution for
a criminal charge and the said proceedings are
pending. As rightly observed by the High Court, if the
above conditions are available, even one of them,
then the DPC has to apply the “sealed cover
process”. In the case on hand, it is not in dispute
that the relevant date is 21-4-2003, when the
respondent's batchmates were promoted, admittedly
on that date the respondent was not under
suspension, no charge-sheet was served upon him
nor was he facing any criminal prosecution. In such
circumstances, in terms of Para 2 referred to above,
the recommendation of the DPC has to be honoured
and there is no question of applying “sealed cover
process”.
15. Mr Mohan Jain, learned ASG submitted that Para
2 has to be read along with Para 7 of the Office
Memorandum dated 14-9-1992. We have already
extracted Para 7 of the memorandum which makes it
clear that a government servant, who is
recommended for promotion by the DPC if any of the
circumstances mentioned in Para 2 of the said
memorandum arises after the recommendations of
the DPC are received, but before he is actually
promoted, will be considered as if his case has been
placed in a sealed cover by the DPC. After extracting
Para 2, we also highlighted the three conditions
- 11 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:12505
WP No. 202073 of 2026
CNR: KAHC030049162026
prescribed therein. Though, the learned ASG has
mentioned that four charge-sheets were issued to
the respondent, enquires were completed and show-
cause notices had already been served on the
respondent, on the relevant date, namely, 21-4-
2003, when his batchmates were promoted, none of
the conditions was in existence in the case of the
respondent. Admittedly, the respondent was not
placed under suspension, charge-sheet had been
issued only on 13-8-2003 i.e. nearly after 4 months,
no disciplinary proceedings were initiated or were
pending as on 21-4-2003. In such circumstances, we
are of the view that the High Court is fully justified in
issuing the direction based on Para 2 of the
memorandum. No doubt, the learned ASG heavily
relied on the later part of Para 7 of the memorandum
which reads as under:
“He shall not be promoted until the conclusion of
disciplinary case/criminal proceedings and the
provisions contained in this letter will be applicable in
his case also.”
Inasmuch as none of the circumstances was in
existence as on 21-4-2003, reliance placed on the
later part of Para 7 cannot be accepted or even not
be applicable.
17. Inasmuch as we are concerned about the first
question, the dictum laid down by this Court relating
to the said issue is as follows: (K.V. Jankiraman case
[(1991) 4 SCC 109 : 1993 SCC (L&S) 387 : (1993)
23 ATC 322] , SCC p. 118, para 16)
“16. On the first question viz. as to when for the
purposes of the sealed cover procedure the
disciplinary/criminal proceedings can be said to have
commenced, the Full Bench of the Tribunal has held
that it is only when a charge memo in a disciplinary
proceedings or a charge-sheet in a criminal
prosecution is issued to the employee that it can be
said that the departmental proceedings/criminal
prosecution is initiated against the employee. The
sealed cover procedure is to be resorted to only after
- 12 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:12505
WP No. 202073 of 2026
CNR: KAHC030049162026
the charge memo/charge-sheet is issued. The
pendency of preliminary investigation prior to that
stage will not be sufficient to enable the authorities
to adopt the sealed cover procedure. We are in
agreement with the Tribunal on this point. The
contention advanced by the learned counsel for the
appellant authorities that when there are serious
allegations and it takes time to collect necessary
evidence to prepare and issue charge memo/charge-
sheet, it would not be in the interest of the purity of
administration to reward the employee with a
promotion, increment, etc. does not impress us. The
acceptance of this contention would result in injustice
to the employees in many cases. As has been the
experience so far, the preliminary investigations take
an inordinately long time and particularly when they
are initiated at the instance of the interested
persons, they are kept pending deliberately. Many
times they never result in the issue of any charge
memo/charge-sheet. If the allegations are serious
and the authorities are keen in investigating them,
ordinarily it should not take much time to collect the
relevant evidence and finalise the charges. What is
further, if the charges are that serious, the
authorities have the power to suspend the employee
under the relevant rules, and the suspension by itself
permits a resort to the sealed cover procedure. The
authorities thus are not without a remedy.”
In para 17, this Court further held: (K.V. Jankiraman
case [(1991) 4 SCC 109 : 1993 SCC (L&S) 387 :
(1993) 23 ATC 322] , SCC p. 119)
“17. … Conclusion 1 should be read to mean that the
promotion, etc. cannot be withheld merely because
some disciplinary/criminal proceedings are pending
against the employee. To deny the said benefit, they
must be at the relevant time pending at the stage
when charge memo/charge-sheet has already been
issued to the employee.”
After finding so, in the light of the fact that no
charge-sheet was served on the respondent
- 13 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:12505
WP No. 202073 of 2026
CNR: KAHC030049162026
employee when the DPC met to consider his
promotion, yet the sealed cover procedure was
adopted. In such circumstances, this Court held that:
(K.V. Jankiraman case [(1991) 4 SCC 109 : 1993
SCC (L&S) 387 : (1993) 23 ATC 322] , SCC p. 124,
para 32)
“32. … The Tribunal has rightly directed the
authorities to open the sealed cover and if the
respondent was found fit for promotion by the DPC,
to give him the promotion from the date his
immediate junior Shri M. Raja Rao was promoted
pursuant to the order dated 30-4-1986. The Tribunal
has also directed the authorities to grant to the
respondent all the consequential benefits. … We see
no reason to interfere with this order. The appeal,
therefore, stands dismissed.”
(emphasis supplied)”
8. The Hon’ble Supreme Court in the case of
3
UNION OF INDIA & ORS. VS. DOLY LOYI at para 20
to 24 has held as under:
“ 20. The core issue for consideration before this
Court is:“Whether by the mere grant of prosecution
sanction, it could be said that the prosecution for a
criminal charge is pending against the respondent
Government Servant and whether grant of sanction
for prosecution could be a valid ground for putting
the DPC recommendations in a sealed cover”?
th
21. On a bare perusal of OM dated 14 September,
1992, which covers the issue, it is clear that it
prescribes the conditions under which the
assessment done by the DPC is to be kept in the
sealed cover. According to this OM, the sealed cover
procedure can be resorted to in respect of three
3
2024 SCC OnLine SC 2613
- 14 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:12505
WP No. 202073 of 2026
CNR: KAHC030049162026
categories of Government servants i.e. Government
servants under suspension, Government servants in
respect of whom a charge sheet has been issued and
the disciplinary proceedings are pending, and
Government servants in respect of whom prosecution
for criminal charge is pending.
22. Learned counsel for appellant made a pertinent
submission that the case of the respondent falls
under the third clause of the above OM, i.e.
Government servants in respect of whom prosecution
for criminal charges is pending. Thus, the question
requiring consideration is as to whether a mere grant
of prosecution sanction would be sufficient to infer
that the prosecution for a criminal charge was
pending against the respondent. Similar issue came
up for consideration before this Court in the case of
1
Union of India v. K.V. Jankiraman , wherein it was
held that sealed cover procedure is to be resorted to
only after the charge memo/charge sheet is issued.
The relevant extract is reproduced hereinbelow:
“16. On the first question, viz., as to when for
the purposes of the sealed cover procedure the
disciplinary/criminal proceedings can be said to
have commenced, the Full Bench of the Tribunal
has held that it is only when a charge-memo in
a disciplinary proceedings or a charge-sheet in
a criminal prosecution is issued to the
employee that it can be said that the
departmental proceedings/criminal prosecution
is initiated against the employee. The sealed
cover procedure is to be resorted to only after
the charge-memo/charge-sheet is issued. The
pendency of preliminary investigation prior to
that stage will not be sufficient to enable the
authorities to adopt the sealed cover
procedure. We are in agreement with the
Tribunal on this point . The contention advanced by
the learned counsel for the appellant-authorities that
when there are serious allegations and it takes time
to collect necessary evidence to prepare and issue
- 15 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:12505
WP No. 202073 of 2026
CNR: KAHC030049162026
charge-memo/charge-sheet, it would not be in the
interest of the purity of administration to reward the
employee with a promotion, increment etc. does not
impress us. The acceptance of this contention would
result in injustice to the employees in many cases.
As has been the experience so far, the preliminary
investigations take an inordinately long time and
particularly when they are initiated at the instance of
the interested persons, they are kept pending
deliberately. Many times they never result in the
issue of any charge-memo/charge-sheet. If the
allegations are serious and the authorities are keen
in investigating them, ordinarily it should not take
much time to collect the relevant evidence and
finalise the charges. What is further, if the charges
are that serious, the authorities have the power to
suspend the employee under the relevant rules, and
the suspension by itself permits a resort to the
sealed cover procedure. The authorities thus are not
without a remedy.”
(emphasis supplied)
23. At this stage, it is pertinent to note that the
Ministry of Personnel, Government of India vide OM
nd
dated 2 November, 2012 issued certain
clarifications regarding the stage when a prosecution
for criminal charge can be said to be pending,
keeping in view the dicta laid down in K.V.
Jankiraman (supra). Para Nos. 6 and 8 of OM dated
nd
2 November, 2012 states as under:
“ 6. When a government servant comes under a
cloud, he may pass through three stages, namely,
investigation for a criminal charge in departmental
proceedings and or prosecution of criminal charges
followed by either penal/conviction or
exoneration/acquittal. During the stage of
investigation prior to issue of charge-sheet in
disciplinary proceedings or prosecution, if the
Government is of the view that the charges are
serious and the officer should not be promoted, it is
open to the Government to suspend the officer which
- 16 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:12505
WP No. 202073 of 2026
CNR: KAHC030049162026
will lead to DPC recommendation to be kept in sealed
cover. The sealed cover procedure is to be
resorted to only after the charge
memo/charge-sheet is issued or the officer is
placed under suspension. The pendency of
preliminary investigation prior to that stage is
not adopt the sealed cover procedure .”
(emphasis supplied)
24. Considering the above position, the
disciplinary/criminal proceedings can be said to be
initiated against the employee only when a charge
memo is issued to the employee in a disciplinary
proceeding or a charge-sheet for a criminal
prosecution is filed in the competent Court. The
sealed cover procedure is to be resorted to only after
issuance of the charge-memo/charge-sheet is issued.
The pendency of investigation and grant of
prosecution sanction will not be sufficient to enable
the authorities to adopt the sealed cover procedure.”
9. Admittedly, the DPC was held on 09.01.2026
by the University and on the said date no charge sheet
was filed against the petitioner, much less, the name of
the petitioner does not find place in the FIR. Hence, the
University has committed an error in following the sealed
cover procedure. The enunciation of law laid down by the
Hon’ble Supreme Court supra makes it clear that the
disciplinary proceedings or criminal proceedings would
commence only from the date of filing of the charge sheet.
- 17 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:12505
WP No. 202073 of 2026
CNR: KAHC030049162026
In the case on hand, no proceedings have commenced
against the petitioner. Hence, the University is required to
open the sealed cover and consider the candidature of the
petitioner for promotion.
10. For the preceding analysis, I proceed to pass
the following:
ORDER
i) The petition is hereby allowed .
ii) The impugned endorsement dated 13.03.2026
issued by respondent No.2 at Annexure-L is
quashed.
iii) The respondents are hereby directed to open
the sealed cover procedure followed in respect
of petitioner in the matter of promotion.
Further, the respondents are directed to give
effect to the promotion to the petitioner with
all consequential benefits.
- 18 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:12505
WP No. 202073 of 2026
CNR: KAHC030049162026
iv) The aforesaid direction shall be complied
within a period of two months from the date
of receipt of a copy of this order.
No order as to costs.
Sd/-
(VIJAYKUMAR A. PATIL)
JUDGE
SWK
List No.: 1 Sl No.: 4