PR COMMISSIONER OF INCOME TAX-2 vs M/S CGI INFORMATION SYSTEMS AND MANAGEMENT COUNSULTANTS PVT LTD
- Court
- Karnataka High Court
- 1 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:60291-DB
ITA No. 245 of 2021
CNR: KAHC010047542021
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA AT BENGALURU
TH
DATED THIS THE 29 DAY OF OCTOBER, 2026
PRESENT
THE HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE S.G.PANDIT
AND
THE HON'BLE DR. JUSTICE CHILLAKUR SUMALATHA
INCOME TAX APPEAL NO. 245 OF 2021
BETWEEN:
1.
PR COMMISSIONER OF
INCOME TAX-2
BMTC COMPLEX
KORAMANGALA, BANGALORE.
2. THE DEPUTY COMMISSIONER
OF INCOME TAX,
CIRCLE 2 (1)(1), BMTC,
COMPLEX, KORMANGALA,
BENGALURU.
…APPELLANTS
(BY SRI. RAVIRAJ Y.V., ADVOCATE FOR
Digitally signed
by AASEEFA
PARVEEN
Location: HIGH
COURT OF
KARNATAKA
SRI. SANMATHI E. I., ADVOCATE)
AND:
M/S. CGI INFORMATION SYSTEMS
AND MANAGEMENT COUNSULTANTS PVT. LTD.,
(SUCCESSOR IN THE INTEREST
OF M/S LOGICA PVT LTD) E CITY
TOWER-2 ELECTRONIC
CITY PHASE-1 (WEST),
BENGALURU-560100.
PAN-AAACL3330M
…RESPONDENT
(BY MISS. TANMAYEE RAJKUMAR, ADVOCATE)
- 2 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:60291-DB
ITA No. 245 of 2021
CNR: KAHC010047542021
THIS ITA / INCOME TAX APPEAL UNDER SEC.260-A OF
INCOME TAX ACT 1961, ARISING OUT OF ORDER DATED
24/04/2020 PASSED IN IT(TP)A NO. 612/BANG/2013, FOR THE
ASSESSMENT YEAR 2005-2006 PRAYING TO
(1) DECIDE THE FOREGOING QUESTION OF LAW AND / OR
SUCH OTHER QUESTIONS OF LAW AS MAY BE FORMULATED BY
THE HON'BLE COURT AS DEEMED FIT.(2) SET ASIDE THE
APPELLATE ORDER DATED 24/04/2020 PASSED BY THE
INCOME TAX APPELLATE TRIBUNAL, 'B' BENCH, BENGALURU,
AS SOUGHT FOR, IN THE RESPONDENT-ASSESSEE'S CASE, IN
APPEAL PROCEEDINGS NO. IT(TP)A NO. 612/BANG/2013
(ANNEXURE-A) FOR ASSESSMENT YEAR 2005-2006.
THIS APPEAL, COMING ON FOR HEARING, THIS DAY,
JUDGMENT WAS DELIVERED THEREIN AS UNDER:
CORAM: HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE S.G.PANDIT
and
HON'BLE DR. JUSTICE CHILLAKUR SUMALATHA
ORAL JUDGMENT
(PER: HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE S.G.PANDIT)
Heard learned counsel Sri.E.I.Sanmathi, for
appellant-revenue and learned counsel Ms.Tanmayee
Rajkumar, for respondent-assessee. Perused the entire
appeal papers.
- 3 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:60291-DB
ITA No. 245 of 2021
CNR: KAHC010047542021
2. The above appeal is filed under Section 260A of
the Income Tax Act, 1961 questioning the order dated
24.04.2020 passed by the Income Tax Appellate Tribunal,
'B' Bench, Bengaluru, in IT(TP)A.No.612/Bang/2013 for
the Assessment Year 2005-2006.
3. Learned counsel Sri.Sanmathi for appellant-
revenue would submit that the Tribunal committed grave
error in upholding the exclusion of Bodhtree Consulting
Ltd.. Geometric Software Solutions Company Ltd., Tata
Elxsi Ltd., Exensys Software Solutions Ltd. and Thirdware
Solutions Ltd. without properly appreciating the material
on record. Further, learned counsel for appellant-revenue
would submit that the Tribunal also committed an error in
excluding Flextronics Limited, L&T Infotech Limited.,
Infosys Technologies Limited, Satyam Computer Services
Limited., and iGate Global Solutions Limited by applying
turnover filter. Thus, learned counsel would submit that
- 4 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:60291-DB
ITA No. 245 of 2021
CNR: KAHC010047542021
the order passed by the CIT(A) and the Tribunal needs to
be interfered with.
4. On the other hand learned counsel
Ms.Tanmayee, for respondent-assessee would support the
order passed by CIT (A) as well as the Tribunal. Learned
counsel would submit that the issue raised by the
appellant-revenue is answered in ITA No.10/2011 and
connected appeals dated 28.08.2026 in Sap Labs India
Private Limited vs. The Income Tax Officer. Further it
is submitted that the appellant-revenue is in appeal
against the concurrent finding of the CIT (A) as well as the
Tribunal. It is further submitted that the finding of the
CIT(A) as well as Tribunal is on the factual and material on
record. Further, learned counsel would submit that this
Court in Sap Labs India Private Limited , has held that
adoption of an upper turnover filter of Rs.200 crores is
rational and legally sustainable, as turnover, brand value,
economies of scale and bargaining power and ownership of
- 5 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:60291-DB
ITA No. 245 of 2021
CNR: KAHC010047542021
intangibles materially influence comparability and
profitability. Thus, learned counsel would pray for
dismissal of the appeal.
5. Having heard the learned counsels for the
parties and on perusal of the entire materials on record we
are not inclined to interfere with the order under challenge
and accordingly the substantial questions of law raised by
the appellant-revenue are to be answered in favour of the
respondent-assessee and against the appellant-revenue.
6. Co-ordinate Bench of this Court in Sap Labs
India Private Limited (supra) on consideration of
various decisions of Hon'ble Apex Court in the matter of
transfer pricing has arrived at the following conclusion
which reads as follows:
(i) The Court concludes that Chapter X of the Income-
tax Act, 1961 constitutes a self-contained code
governing transfer pricing, providing a complete
statutory framework for determination of the
Arm's Length Price (ALP), maintenance of
documentation, and assessment of international
transactions.
- 6 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:60291-DB
ITA No. 245 of 2021
CNR: KAHC010047542021
(ii) The initial burden of determining the ALP and
maintaining the prescribed documentation rests
upon the taxpayer, while the Transfer Pricing
Officer can interfere with the taxpayer's
determination only upon satisfaction of the
conditions stipulated under Section 92C(3) of the
Act.
(iii) The selection or exclusion of comparables is
essentially a factual and data-driven exercise, and
the TPO cannot reject the taxpayer's comparables
merely to substitute them with a standard
departmental set. Such determination must strictly
conform to the requirements of Rule 10B of the
Rules.
(iv) The Tribunal's adoption of an upper turnover filter
of Rs.200 crores is rational and legally sustainable,
as turnover, brand value, economies of scale,
bargaining power and ownership of intangibles
materially influence comparability and profitability.
(v) An RPT filter of 15% is ordinarily preferable,
though a higher threshold of 20% or 25% may be
adopted only upon recording a specific finding that
sufficient comparable companies satisfying the
lower threshold are unavailable.
(vi) Foreign exchange gain or loss can be treated as an
operating item only when it has a direct nexus
with the international transaction. Where such
nexus is absent, it cannot form part of the
operating revenue or operating cost.
(vii) The burden of proof varies according to the nature
of the dispute. While the taxpayer bears the initial
burden of substantiating the ALP, once the TPO
rejects the taxpayer's determination and
substitutes comparables, the burden shifts to the
TPO to justify such inclusion or exclusion.
(viii) There is no legal prohibition against inclusion or
exclusion of comparables at the appellate stage,
provided the subsequently relied upon data is
reliable and the proposed comparables satisfy the
requirements of the Act and the Rules.
- 7 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:60291-DB
ITA No. 245 of 2021
CNR: KAHC010047542021
(ix) The tolerance of ±5% prescribed under Section
92C of the Act is merely a permissible variation
and not a standard deduction, and transfer pricing
adjustment becomes necessary whenever the
variation exceeds the prescribed statutory limit.
(x) Working Capital Adjustment is a comparability
adjustment and not a selection filter, and its grant
depends entirely upon the facts of each case.
Findings on such adjustment, like the selection of
comparables, ordinarily remain findings of fact and
do not warrant interference unless shown to be
contrary to the Act or vitiated by perversity.
7. It is seen that the respondent-assessee is
engaged in the business of development of computer
software for exports software consultancy. The CIT(A) as
well as the Tribunal concurrently arrived at a conclusion to
exclude the six comparable companies on functionality of
the assessee company as well as the comparable
companies. Both the authorities have concurrently
recorded that the comparable companies as well as
assessee are functionally not similar on examining the
material on record. The Tribunal in its order while directing
exclusion of six companies has discussed with regard to
each company and compared functionality of each
company with the functionality of the assessee company.
- 8 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:60291-DB
ITA No. 245 of 2021
CNR: KAHC010047542021
8. Insofar as exclusion of companies by applying
turn over filter is in-consonance with the conclusion of Co-
ordinate Bench in Sap Labs India Private Limited
(Supra). Further, the Tribunal has also recorded that the
companies which are excluded by applying turnover filter
are also not comparable companies on its functionality.
9. As held by Sap Labs (supra), the inclusion or
exclusion of comparables is essentially a factual and data-
driven exercise. In the instant case, the concurrent
findings recorded by the CIT(A) as well as by the Tribunal
are based on the material on record.
10. We do not find any perversity in the order
passed by the CIT(A) or in the order passed by the
Tribunal. The appellant-revenue has not pointed out taking
of any irrelevant material or excluding relevant material by
the CIT(A) or Tribunal while arriving at the above
conclusion.
- 9 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:60291-DB
ITA No. 245 of 2021
CNR: KAHC010047542021
11. Thus, we do not find any merit in the appeal
and accordingly appeal stands rejected answering the
substantial questions of law in favour of the respondent-
assessee and against the appellant-revenue.
Sd/-
(S.G.PANDIT)
JUDGE
Sd/-
(DR.CHILLAKUR SUMALATHA)
JUDGE
AP
CT:TSM
List No.: 1 Sl No.: 19