Santosh Kumar Verma vs State Of U.P. Through Prin. Secy. Deptt. Of Medical Edu. Lko

Court
Allahabad High Court

HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT ALLAHABAD
A.F.R.
LUCKNOW
WRIT - A No. - 7386 of 2014
Santosh Kumar Verma
.....Petitioner(s)
Versus
State Of U.P. Through Prin. Secy. Deptt. Of
Medical Edu. Lko
.....Respondent(s)
Counsel for Petitioner(s) : Rajeev Singh, Kartikay Singh, Raj
Kumar Singh, Vijay Kumar
Counsel for Respondent(s) : C.S.C.

Court No. - 4
HON'BLE IRSHAD ALI, J.
1. Heard Ms. Bulbul Godiyal, learned Senior Advocate assisted by Sri
Kartikey Singh, learned counsel for the petitioner and learned Standing
Counsel for the State-respondent.
2. By means of present writ petition, the petitioner has prayed for
quashing the order dated 07.11.2014 passed by respondent No.2 contained
as Anneuxre-1 to the writ petition with a further prayer to issue writ of
mandamus commanding the respondent No.2 to allow the petitioner all
service benefits given to juniors namely Irfan Mohammad Siddiqui and
Satya Narayan Gupta.
3. Factual matrix of the case is that the petitioner was initially appointed
as a Junior Clerk on daily-wage basis on 20.04.1992 by respondent No.2.
He continuously discharged his duties under the control and supervision
of the respondent authorities and his work and conduct remained
satisfactory. However, without assigning any reason, the petitioner was
orally terminated from service by respondent No.2 in August, 1992.
Aggrieved by the said oral termination, the petitioner instituted Writ
Petition No.6940 (S/S) of 1992 before this Court. The said writ petition
was allowed vide judgment and order dated 14.07.1995, whereby
respondent No.2 was directed to permit the petitioner to continue to work
as a Clerk on daily-wage basis, subject to the condition that persons junior
to the petitioner were still working.

WRIA No. 7386 of 2014
2
4. In compliance with the judgment and order dated 14.07.1995, the
petitioner was permitted to resume and continue his duties as a daily-
wage Clerk at the State Pharmacy, Lucknow. Subsequently, vide order
dated 03.02.2005, the petitioner was permitted to work at the Directorate
on the post of Clerk on daily-wage basis.
5. The petitioner, thereafter, requested the respondent authorities for his
absorption in service and for payment of the minimum of the regular pay
scale, particularly as similar benefits were being extended to his juniors,
namely, Satya Narayan Gupta, who had initially been engaged as a daily
wager on 27.05.1992 and Irfan Mohammad Siddiqui, who had initially
been engaged as a daily wager on 31.05.1992. Irfan Mohammad Siddiqui
was absorbed by respondent No.2 vide order dated 05.03.2005. However,
subsequently, the then respondent No.2 cancelled the petitioner's
engagement vide order dated 05.12.2007. Aggrieved thereby, the
petitioner filed Writ Petition No.984 (S/S) of 2008, in which this Court,
vide interim order dated 22.02.2008, stayed the operation of the order
dated 05.12.2007.
6. Pursuant to the interim protection granted by this Hon'ble Court, the
petitioner resumed his duties. Thereafter, the State Government, vide
letter dated 02.06.2009, directed respondent No.2 to extend the minimum
pay scale applicable to the post of Junior Clerk to the petitioner forthwith.
In compliance thereof, respondent No.2 passed order dated 18.01.2011
granting the petitioner the minimum pay scale with effect from
07.02.2005.
7. The petitioner subsequently came to know that respondent No.2 was
attempting to absorb daily-wage employees Junior to the petitioner by
adopting a pick-and-choose method. Aggrieved by the proposed arbitrary
action, the petitioner filed Writ Petition No.2600 (S/S) of 2010 seeking a
direction to the respondents to absorb him against a substantive vacancy
on the post of Junior Clerk. This Court, vide interim order dated
03.05.2010, directed that no action be taken by the respondents unless and
until a seniority list of the daily-wage employees was prepared.
8. During the aforesaid period, Satya Narayan Gupta, who had initially

WRIA No. 7386 of 2014
3
been engaged as a daily wager on 27.05.1992 and was thus junior to the
petitioner, was absorbed by the respondent authorities vide order dated
01.11.2012. Satya Narayan Gupta had been working at Rajkiya Takmil
Tibbi College and was subsequently transferred to Government
Ayurvedic College vide order dated 28.02.2011. Both the said institutions
were under the control of the Director, Ayurvedic Services and were
governed by the U.P. Ayurvedic and Unani Department Ministerial Cadre
Service Rules, 1991. Thereafter, the State Government, vide letter dated
03.06.2013, directed respondent No.2 to absorb Satya Narayan Gupta
from the date of availability of the vacancy, i.e. 03.04.1997. In pursuance
thereof, respondent No.2 issued a formal order dated 17.06.2013, whereby
Satya Narayan Gupta was absorbed with effect from 03.04.1997 along
with the consequential benefits, including pay-scale benefits.
9. The petitioner also placed on record the relevant orders and documents
concerning the interim order dated 03.05.2010 passed in Writ Petition
No.2602 (S/S) of 2010, the absorption order dated 01.11.2012 of Satya
Narayan Gupta, his transfer order dated 28.02.2011, the applicable
Service Rules, the Government letter dated 03.06.2013 and the formal
absorption order dated 17.06.2013 as Annexures No. 8 to 13 to the writ
petition.
10. Likewise, Irfan Mohammad Siddiqui, who was also junior to the
petitioner and had initially been engaged as a daily wager on 31.05.1992,
was absorbed by the respondent authorities vide order dated 29.06.2012
with retrospective effect from 03.04.1997. In view of the absorption of his
juniors, the petitioner submitted a representation dated 18.01.2013 before
the State Government, pointing out that his juniors were being absorbed
against substantive vacancies in an arbitrary and discriminatory manner.
The petitioner requested that he and other similarly situated daily-wage
employees also be absorbed against the available substantive vacancies.
Upon receipt of the representation, the State Government called for a
report from respondent No.2 vide its letters dated 06.03.2013 and
15.07.2013.
11. Thereafter, respondent No.2 issued letter dated 05.09.2013 calling for
the current status and particulars of daily-wage employees from the

WRIA No. 7386 of 2014
4
Principal, Government Ayurvedic College, Lucknow and the Regional
Ayurvedic and Unani Officers. In response, the particulars of the
petitioner and other similarly situated employees were furnished by the
competent/supervising authorities. The matter was thereafter placed
before the duly constituted Absorption Committee, which considered the
cases of the concerned employees in the first week of January, 2014. On
the recommendation of the Committee, respondent No.2, being the
appointing authority, passed the absorption order dated 10.01.2014,
whereby the petitioner, namely Shri Dhirendra Singh, was adjusted
against a vacant post of Junior Assistant in the pay scale of Rs.5200-
20200 with Grade Pay of Rs.2000 at Government Ayurvedic and Unani
Medicine Manufacturing Unit, Lucknow, with immediate effect.
12. The relevant absorption order dated 10.01.2014 recorded that the
petitioner was being adjusted against the vacant post of Junior Assistant
on the basis of the recommendation of the Committee constituted for
regularization/absorption of clerical employees working on fixed
remuneration. The said order was issued by the Director, Ayurvedic
Services, Uttar Pradesh, Lucknow.
13. Subsequently, under the Right to Information Act, an application
dated 07.03.2014 was submitted by Sri Jitendra Kumar Jha, Junior Clerk,
seeking information regarding the sanctioned substantive posts of Senior
Assistant and Junior Assistant/Junior Clerk. In response, the Public
Information Officer, vide letter dated 12.05.2014, informed that there
were 62 substantive posts of Senior Assistant, out of which 26 posts were
vacant and 258 substantive posts of Junior Clerk/Junior Assistant, out of
which 24 posts were still vacant. Thus, the information obtained under the
Right to Information Act demonstrated the availability of substantive
vacancies in the cadre of Junior Clerk/Junior Assistant even after the
petitioner's absorption.
14. The State Government, thereafter, promulgated fresh service rules
governing the Ministerial Cadre vide notification dated 22.09.2014,
namely, the U.P. Government Servant Department Ministerial Cadre
Service Rules, 2014. The petitioner had initially been engaged as a Junior
Clerk/Junior Assistant on daily-wage basis on 20.04.1992 and had

WRIA No. 7386 of 2014
5
continuously rendered satisfactory service. He was granted the minimum
of the pay scale applicable to the post with effect from 07.02.2005. In the
meantime, his juniors, namely, Irfan Mohammad Siddiqui, initially
engaged on 31.05.1992 and Satya Narayan Gupta, initially engaged on
27.05.1992, had been absorbed by the respondents with retrospective
effect from 03.04.1997 pursuant to the orders dated 29.06.2012 and
17.06.2013 respectively. The petitioner and other similarly situated
employees thereafter approached the State Government seeking
absorption. Upon consideration of their cases, the requisite particulars
were obtained, an Absorption Committee was constituted and, on the
recommendation of the Committee, the petitioner and other similarly
situated employees were absorbed vide order dated 10.01.2014.
15. However, despite the petitioner's absorption having been made
pursuant to the recommendation of the duly constituted Committee and
against an available substantive vacancy and despite the information
furnished under the Right to Information Act disclosing that 24
substantive posts of Junior Clerk/Junior Assistant were still vacant, the
respondents, in an arbitrary and illegal manner, cancelled the petitioner's
absorption order along with the absorption orders of other similarly
situated employees vide order dated 07.11.2014. The said cancellation
was effected without affording the petitioner any opportunity of hearing
and in violation of the principles of natural justice.
16. The order dated 07.11.2014 was not an isolated action. Identical
orders were passed against other similarly situated employees, wherein
only the names of the employees and dispatch numbers were different.
The affected employees, namely Manoj Kumar Dwivedi, Awadhesh
Kumar Verma and Rajesh Kumar Srivastava, challenged the respective
cancellation orders before this Hon'ble Court in Writ Petition Nos.7021
(S/S) of 2014, 6976 (S/S) of 2014 and 6955 (S/S) of 2014.
17. This Hon'ble Court, upon consideration of the cases of the aforesaid
similarly situated employees, granted interim protection against the
operation of the identical cancellation orders vide orders dated
04.12.2014, 03.12.2014 and 02.12.2014 respectively. In particular, in
Writ Petition No.7021 (S/S) of 2014, Manoj Kumar Dwivedi Vs. State of

WRIA No. 7386 of 2014
6
U.P. and others, this Hon'ble Court, vide order dated 04.12.2014, noticed
that the petitioner's services had earlier been adjusted against a vacant
post of Junior Clerk and that the said adjustment order had subsequently
been cancelled without affording any opportunity to the petitioner.
Finding a prima facie case for interim relief, this Hon'ble Court stayed the
operation and implementation of the impugned order dated 07.11.2014
until further orders.
18. The petitioner contends that his case stands on the same footing as
that of the aforesaid similarly situated employees and that the cancellation
of his absorption, without notice or opportunity of hearing, is arbitrary,
discriminatory and contrary to the principles of natural justice. The
petitioner accordingly seeks appropriate protection from this Hon'ble
Court in view of the interim orders already granted in the cases of
similarly situated employees.
19. Submission of learned Senior Counsel for the petitioner is that the
order impugned has been passed without issuing notice to the petitioner
and without affording opportunity of hearing, therefore, the order
impugned suffer from vices of principles of natural justice. She further
submitted that the order impugned has been passed without assigning
reasons by arriving at conclusion that due to non fulfillment of absorption
rules, the absorption has been cancelled but no provision whatsoever has
been pointed out in regard to non applicability of absorption rules,
therefore, her submission is that the order impugned is per se illegal and
liable to be set aside by this Court.
20. Her next submission is that the order impugned suffers from apparent
illegality and is not sustainable in law. She submitted that the petitioner
was absorbed in service in accordance with provisions of absorption rules
and other similarly situated junior candidates have also been absorbed,
who were continuing on the post of Junior Clerk and deliberately the
order of cancellation of absorption has been passed in the case of the
petitioner.
21. She lastly submitted that violation of principles of natural justice has
been explained in paragraph 13 of the writ petition and reply to the same

WRIA No. 7386 of 2014
7
has been given in paragraph 17 of the counter affidavit, wherein there is
no denial of the facts narrated in paragraph 13 of the writ petition.
22. On the other hand, learned Standing Counsel submitted that the
petitioner's case was not covered under absorption rules, therefore, his
claim was cancelled on the ground of non fulfillment of prescribed
provisions under absorption rules. He submitted that the impugned order
does not suffer from any infirmity or illegality and is just and valid.
23. I have considered the submissions advanced by learned counsel for
the parties and perused the material on record.
24. On perusal of impugned order, which is annexure-1 to the writ
petition, it transpires that no reasons have been recorded in the impugned
order that which provision of Uttar Pradesh Regularisation of Persons
Working on Daily Wages or On Work Charge or On Contract in
Government Departments on Group "C" and Group "D" Posts (Outside
the Purview of the Uttar Pradesh Public Service Commission) Rules,
2016 has not been applied to the petitioner, therefore, the order impugned
is unreasoned.
25. Reasons are heart beat of conclusion and in case no reasons have been
recorded, the order suffers from apparent illegality and is liable to be set
aside. In view of fact narrated in paragraph 13 of the writ petition, it is
also apparent on the face of record that no notice nor opportunity of
hearing was afforded to the petitioner prior to passing of impugned order
dated 07.11.2014, therefore, the order being violative of principles of
natural justice is liable to be set aside.
26. It is also relevant to point out that averment made in paragraph 13 of
the writ petition in regard to violation of principles of natural justice has
not been denied in paragraph 17 of the counter affidavit, therefore, the
order impugned being violative of principles of natural jusitce is liable to
be set aside.
27. In view of reasons recorded above, this Court is of the considered
opinion that the order impugned dated 07.11.2014 being unreasoned and
violative of principles of natural justice is not sustainable in law and is

WRIA No. 7386 of 2014
8
hereby set aside.
28. The writ petition succeeds and is allowed .
29. No order as to costs.
(Irshad Ali,J.)
November 12, 2026
Gautam
Digitally signed by :-
GAUTAM TECKCHANDANI
High Court of Judicature at Allahabad,
Lucknow Bench