State Of Haryana And Another vs Ajmer And Another

Court
Punjab and Haryana High Court

-1-

RFA-949-2024 (O&M)
IN THE HIGH COURT OF PUNJAB AND HARYANA
AT CHANDIGARH
*
236 Date of Decision: 19.11.2026

1. RFA-949-2024 (O&M) with XOBJR-53-2025 (O&M)
STATE OF HARYANA AND ANOTHER
…Appellants
Versus

AJMER AND ANOTHER
…Respondents
And

Sr. Case No. Appellant(s) Respondent(s)
No.
2. RFA-951-2024 (O&M) with STATE OF HARYANA RAMPHAL
XOBJR-50-2025 (O&M) AND ANOTHER
3. RFA-952-2024 (O&M) STATE OF HARYANA MEHAR SINGH AND OTHERS
AND ANOTHER
4. RFA-953-2024 (O&M) STATE OF HARYANA RAM SINGH (DECEASED)
AND ANOTHER THROUGH LRS
5. RFA-954-2024 (O&M) STATE OF HARYANA ROHTASH AND OTHERS
AND ANOTHER
6. RFA-955-2024 (O&M) with STATE OF HARYANA PARDEEP KUMAR AND
XOBJR-49-2025 (O&M) AND ANOTHER OTHERS
7. RFA-956-2024 (O&M) STATE OF HARYANA SURAJMAL (DECEASED)
AND ANOTHER THROUGH LRS AND OTHERS
8. RFA-957-2024 (O&M) STATE OF HARYANA KARTAR AND OTHERS
AND ANOTHER
RFA-958-2024 (O&M) with STATE OF HARYANA
9. VEDPAL
XOBJR-52-2025 (O&M) AND ANOTHER
10. RFA-959-2024 (O&M) STATE OF HARYANA SHAKUNTLA AND OTHERS
AND ANOTHER
11. RFA-960-2024 (O&M) STATE OF HARYANA VIDHYA DHAR
AND ANOTHER
12. RFA-961-2024 (O&M) STATE OF HARYANA BALJEET & ANOTHER
AND ANOTHER
13. RFA-962-2024 (O&M) STATE OF HARYANA LAL CHAND (DECEASED)
AND ANOTHER THROUGH LRS
14. RFA-979-2024 (O&M) with STATE OF HARYANA MANGTU (DECEASED)
XOBJR-55-2025 (O&M) AND ANOTHER THROUGH LRS AND OTHERS

CORAM: HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE JAGMOHAN BANSAL

Present:- Mr. Abhinash Jain, Additional Advocate General, Haryana

Mr. Bhupender Ghanghas, Advocate for cross-objectors
(In XOBJR Nos.49, 50, 52, 53 & 55 of 2025 )

*
SUDEEPAK KUMAR
2026.11.20 14:54
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document

-2-

RFA-949-2024 (O&M)

JAGMOHAN BANSAL, J. (ORAL)
1. These appeals and cross-objections under Section 74 of Right
to Fair Compensation and Transparency in Land Acquisition, Rehabilitation
& Resettlement Act, 2013 (for short ‘2013 Act’) are directed against award
dated 04.12.2023 passed by learned Additional District Judge, Bhiwani (for
short ‘Authority’).
2. As common issues are involved in the captioned appeals and
cross-objections, with the consent of both sides, the same are hereby
disposed of by this common order. For the sake of brevity and convenience,
facts are borrowed from RFA No.949 of 2024 .
3. The State Government issued notification dated 14.10.2013
under Section 4 of the Land Acquisition Act, 1894 (for short ‘1894 Act’) for
the acquisition of land situated in Village Mandhana measuring 121 Kanal
17 Marla with intent to construct Siwara Talu Link Drain in Village
Mandhana, Tehsil & District Bhiwani. The said notification was followed by
notification dated 03.06.2014 issued under Section 6 of 1894 Act read with
Section 19 of 2013 Act.
4. The Land Acquisition Collector (for short ‘Collector’) vide
Award dated 28.09.2015 determined compensation payable to the
landowners. Market value of the acquired land was determined. The
landowners were held entitled to solatium and other statutory benefits.
Feeling dis-satisfied from the aforesaid award, landowners preferred
petitions before the Collector which were referred to the Authority under
Section 64 of the 2013 Act. It is apt to notice here that acquisition process
SUDEEPAK KUMAR
2026.11.20 14:54
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document

-3-

RFA-949-2024 (O&M)
was initiated under 1894 Act, however, market value was determined under
2013 Act because award could not be passed prior to 01.01.2014.
5. The State as well as landowners, in support of their contentions,
led their evidence. The State attempted to justify market value determined
by the Collector, however, landowners vehemently pleaded that value of
their land has been assessed on the lower side.
6. The Authority while appreciating evidence led by both sides,
by impugned award adjudicated reference petitions. The Authority by
impugned award dated 04.12.2023 has assessed market value of the acquired
land as assessed by the Collector, however, extended benefit of 1.25
multiplier.
7. Tabulated details of the assessment made till date read as: -
Date of notification under Section 4 14.10.2013
Date of notification under Section 6 03.06.2014
Purpose of acquisition Construction of Siwara Talu Link Drain in
Village Mandhana, Tehsil & District Bhiwani
Location Village - Mandhana
Tehsil & District - Bhiwani
Total Area 121 Kanal 17 Marla
Date of Collector (LAC) Award 28.09.2015
₹
Market value as per LAC ( per acre) 12,00,000/-
Date of Reference Court (RC) Award 04.12.2023
₹
Market value as per RC ( per acre) 12,00,000/-

8. Learned counsel for the parties are ad idem that delay in filing
any appeal which is part of present bunch may be condoned. Accordingly,
SUDEEPAK KUMAR
2026.11.20 14:54
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document

-4-

RFA-949-2024 (O&M)
delay, if any, in any case, stands condoned. It is clarified that appellant shall
not be entitled to interest for the delayed period.
9. All the arguments raised by both sides have been recorded in
the presence of counsel for the parties. They have not raised any other
argument.
10. Heard the arguments and perused the record.
11. From the perusal of record, it is evident that by common
notification, land of Villages Pur and Mandhana was acquired. Purpose of
acquisition was construction of Siwara Talu link drain. It was a linear
acquisition.
12. The Apex Court in ‘HSIIDC Vs. Pran Sukh & Ors.’, 2010(11)
SCC 175 and ‘Ali Mohammad Beigh & Ors. Vs. State of J&K’, 2017(4)
SCC 717 has held that whereby common notification and for common
purpose land of different villages is acquired, the Court may determine one
rate for all the villages. Relevant extracts of Ali Mohammad Beigh (supra)
read as: -
“13. When the lands are more or less situated nearby and
when the acquired lands are identical and similar and the
acquisition is for the same purpose, it would not be proper to
discriminate between the land owners unless there are strong
reasons. In Union of India v. Bal Ram and Another (2010) 5
SCC 747, this Court held that if the purpose of acquisition is
same and when the lands are identical and similar though
lying in different villages, there is no justification to make any
discrimination between the land owners to pay more to some
of the land owners and less compensation to others. The same
SUDEEPAK KUMAR
2026.11.20 14:54
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document

-5-

RFA-949-2024 (O&M)
was the view taken in Union of India v. Harinder Pal Singh
and Others. (2005) 12 SCC 564, where this Court held as
under:-
“15. We have carefully considered the submissions
made on behalf of the respective parties and we see no
justification to interfere with the decision of the
Division Bench of the Punjab and Haryana High
Court which, in our view, took a pragmatic approach
in fixing the market value of the lands forming the
subject-matter of the acquisition proceedings at a
uniform rate. From the sketch plan of the area in
question, it appears to us that while the lands in
question are situated in five different villages, they can
be consolidated into one single unit with little to
choose between one stretch of land and another. The
entire area is in a stage of development and the
different villages are capable of being developed in the
same manner as the lands comprised in Kala Ghanu
Pur where the market value of the acquired lands was
fixed at a uniform rate of Rs. 40,000 per acre. The
Division Bench of the Punjab and Haryana High
Court discarded the belting method of valuation
having regard to the local circumstances and features
and no cogent ground has been made out to interfere
with the same. 16. In our view, in the absence of any
contemporaneous document, the market value of the
acquired lands of Village Kala Ghanu Pur which were
acquired at the same time as the lands in the other five
villages was correctly taken to be a comparative unit
for determination of the market value of the lands
comprising the lands forming the subject-matter of the
acquisition proceedings under consideration.......””

13. By notification dated 14.10.2013, land of different villages
including Mandhana, District Bhiwani was proposed to be acquired for the
SUDEEPAK KUMAR
2026.11.20 14:54
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document

-6-

RFA-949-2024 (O&M)
construction of Siwara Talu link drain. The Collector passed different awards
with respect to different villages. Market value of the land for Village Pur
₹ ₹
was determined @ 7,50,000/- per acre whereas 12,00,000/- per acre was
determined for Village Mandhana. The landowners filed references and the
authority constituted under Section 51 of the 2013 Act passed award dated
09.08.2023 whereby market value was re-determined applying multiplier of
1.25 as per notification dated 23.01.2018. The Reference Court further
awarded severance charges @ 20% to those landowners whose land was
bifurcated into two different parcels due to construction of the drain.
14. Matter with respect to acquisition of land of Village Pur reached
to this Court which vide order dated 19.09.2025 passed in RFA-1837-2023
₹
has determined market price @ 15,19,760/- per acre. The State filed SLP
(Civil) Diary No.44019 of 2026 against order dated 19.09.2025 passed by
this Court which stands dismissed by the Hon’ble Supreme Court vide order
dated 02.09.2026.
15. The Collector and the Authority has assessed market value of
the land in question @ 12,00,000/- per acre whereas for the land of Village
₹
Pur, market value was determined @ 7,50,000/- per acre. This Court has
₹ ₹
increased market price from 7,50,000/- to 15,19,760/- per acre. On being
confronted with aforesaid order dated 19.09.2025 passed by this Court,
learned State counsel expressed his inability to controvert that land of both
the villages was acquired by common notification and for common purpose,
thus, there is no occasion to reduce market price determined by the Reference
SUDEEPAK KUMAR
2026.11.20 14:54
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document

-7-

RFA-949-2024 (O&M)
Court. He submitted that sale deeds produced by the State with respect to
land of Village Mandhana are disclosing lesser price.
16. In view of afore-cited judgments of the Supreme Court, market
price of the land in question needs to be determined as per judgment of this
Court in ‘Bhateri & Ors. Vs. State of Haryana & Anr.’, RFA-1837-2023 . It
is apt to mention here that landowners are not in appeal, however, there are
cross-objections in 5 appeals wherein landowners are seeking enhancement
of the market value. In the backdrop, market value of the land in question is
₹
determined @ 15,19,760/- per acre.
17. The Reference Court has applied multiplier as per notification
dated 23.01.2018 whereas award under Section 11 of 1894 Act read with
Section 19 of 2013 Act was passed on 28.09.2015.
18. This Court vide judgment dated 18.08.2026 passed in a bunch
of appeals including RFA-787-2024 titled as ‘Santosh Rani Vs. State of
Haryana & Anr’ has adjudicated question of multiplier. This Court has held
that notification dated 23.01.2018 is applicable in all these cases.
19. On being confronted with aforesaid judgment, learned State
Counsel expressed his inability to controvert applicability of aforesaid
judgment to the present appeals. He further submits that the State is
contemplating to file appeal against aforesaid judgment before the Apex
Court.
20. The landowners shall be entitled to multiplier (1.25) and other
statutory benefits as granted by the Authority.
SUDEEPAK KUMAR
2026.11.20 14:54
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document

-8-

RFA-949-2024 (O&M)
21. In the wake of above discussion and findings, all the State
appeals are hereby dismissed and cross-objections allowed in above terms.
22. Pending application(s), if any, shall stand disposed of.

(JAGMOHAN BANSAL)
JUDGE
19.11.2026
SDK

Whether speaking/reasoned Yes/No
Whether reportable Yes/No

SUDEEPAK KUMAR
2026.11.20 14:54
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document