THE MANAGER, HDFC ERGO GIC LTD., vs SMT. RATHNAMMA,

Court
Karnataka High Court

- 1 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62503
MFA No. 3068 of 2025
C/W MFA No. 7636 of 2024


CNR: KAHC010272912025






IN THE HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA AT BENGALURU


TH
DATED THIS THE 12 DAY OF NOVEMBER, 2026

BEFORE

THE HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE SHIVASHANKAR AMARANNAVAR

MISCELLANEOUS FIRST APPEAL No. 3068 OF 2025

(MV-D)

C/W

MISCELLANEOUS FIRST APPEAL No. 7636 OF 2024

(MV-D)



IN MFA No. 3068/2025

BETWEEN:

1. SMT. RATHNAMMA
W/O. LATE LAKSHMAIAH
AGED ABOUT 40 YEARS

2.
MASTER MANJESH
S/O. LATE. LAKSHMAIAH
AGED ABOUT 17 YEARS

3. MASTER HARISH. D.L.
S/O. LATE. LAKSHMAIAH
AGED ABOUT 13 YEARS

THE APPELLANT No.2 & 3 ARE
BEING MINORS REPRESENTED BY
THEIR NATURAL GUARDIAN MOTHER
ST
RATHNAMMA I.E., 1 APPELLANT HEREIN.





Digitally Signed By:
SHIVASHANKAR BASAPPA
AMARANNAVAR
JUDGE, HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA

- 2 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62503
MFA No. 3068 of 2025
C/W MFA No. 7636 of 2024


CNR: KAHC010272912025


4. SMT. GANGAMMA
W/O. HANUMANTHAIAH
AGED ABOUT 67 YEARS.

5.
MR. HANUMANTHAIAH
S/O. LATE MURUDAAH
AGED ABOUT 72 YEARS.

DELETED AS PER ORDER DATED 12.11.2026
AMENDMENT CARRIED OUT AS PER ORDER
DATED:12.11.2026.

ALL ARE R/AT DODDAIAHANAKATTE PALYA
HEBBUR HOBLI, TUMKUR TALUK
KEMBALALU, TUMKUR – 572 120.
…APPELLANTS
(BY SRI. VIJAY KUMAR T, ADVOCATE)
AND:

1. MR RENUKA PRASAD N C
S/O. CHANDRAIAH
AGED MAJOR
ND
2 BLOCK, NAGAVALI POST
HEBBUR, TUMKURU-572 120.

2. THE MANAGER,
THE HDFC ERGO GENERAL INSURANCE CO. LTD.,
ND
No.25/1, 2 FLOOR, BUILDING No.2
SHANKARANARAYANA BUILDING
M.G.ROAD, BENGALURU-560 001.
…RESPONDENTS
(BY SRI B PRADEEP, ADVOCATE FOR R2
V/O DTD. 9.9.2025 NOTICE TO R1 IS DISPENSED WITH)
Digitally Signed By:
SHIVASHANKAR BASAPPA
AMARANNAVAR
JUDGE, HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA

- 3 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62503
MFA No. 3068 of 2025
C/W MFA No. 7636 of 2024


CNR: KAHC010272912025


THIS MFA IS FILED UNDER SECTION 173(1) OF MV ACT,
AGAINST THE JUDGMENT AND AWARD DATED:10.09.2024
PASSED IN MVC No.1390/2023 ON THE FILE OF THE XIX
ADDITIONAL JUDGE, COURT OF SMALL CAUSES AND ACMM,
BENGALURU SCCH-17, PARTLY ALLOWING THE CLAIM
PETITION FOR COMPENSATION AND SEEKING ENHANCEMENT
OF COMPENSATION.

IN MFA No. 7636/2024
BETWEEN:
THE MANAGER
HDFC ERGO GIC LTD.,
REGIONAL OFFICE No.25/1
ND
2 FLOOR, BUIDLING No.2
SHANKARANARAYANA BUILDING
MG ROAD, BANGALORE-560 001.
...APPELLANT
(BY SRI. PRADEEP B, ADVOCATE)

AND:

1. SMT. RATHNAMMA
W/O LATE LAKSHMAIAH
AGED ABOUT 39 YEARS.

2. MASTER MANJESH
S/O LATE LAKSHMAIAH
AGED ABOUT 17 YEARS.

3. MASTER HARISH D L
S/O LATE LAKSHMAIAH
AGED ABOUT 12 YEARS.

4. SMT. GANGAMMA
W/O HANUMANTHAIAH
AGED ABOUT 66 YEARS.

5. HANUMANTHAIAH
S/O LATE MURUDAIAH
Digitally Signed By:
SHIVASHANKAR BASAPPA
AMARANNAVAR
JUDGE, HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA

- 4 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62503
MFA No. 3068 of 2025
C/W MFA No. 7636 of 2024


CNR: KAHC010272912025


AGED ABOUT 71 YEARS.

ALL ARE R/AT DODAIAHANAKATTE
PALYA HEBBUR HOBLI
TUMKURU TALUK, KEMBALALU
TUMKUR-572 120.

ND RD
SINCE 2 & 3 RESPONDENTS ARE MINORS
WILL BE REPRESENTED BY THEIR MOTHER
ST
AND NATURAL GUARDIAN i.e., 1 RESPONDENT.

6. RENUKA PRASAD N C
S/O CHANDRAIAH
ND
2 BLOCK, NAGAVALI POST
HEBBUR TUMAKURU-572 120.
...RESPONDENTS

(BY SRI T VIJAYA KUMAR, ADVOCATE FOR R1-R5
R2 & R3 MINOR REP. BY R1
V/O DTD. 06.10.2026, NOTICE TO R6 IS D/W)

THIS MFA IS FILED UNDER SECTION 173(1) OF MV ACT
AGAINST THE JUDGMENT AND AWARD DATED:10.09.2024
PASSED IN MVC No.1390/2023 ON THE FILE OF THE XIX
ADDITIONAL JUDGE , COURT OF SMALL CAUSES AND ACMM,
BENGALURU SCCH-17 AWARDING COMPENSATION OF
Rs.49,24,368/- WITH INTEREST AT 6 PERCENT P.A. FROM THE
DATE OF PETITION TILL REALIZATION.

THESE APPEALS COMING ON FOR ADMISSION THIS DAY,
JUDGMENT WAS DELIVERED THEREIN AS UNDER:

CORAM: HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE SHIVASHANKAR AMARANNAVAR
ORAL JUDGMENT

MFA No.3068/2025 is filed by the claimant
challenging the contributory negligence attributed to the
Digitally Signed By:
SHIVASHANKAR BASAPPA
AMARANNAVAR
JUDGE, HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA

- 5 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62503
MFA No. 3068 of 2025
C/W MFA No. 7636 of 2024


CNR: KAHC010272912025


deceased and MFA No.7636/2024 is filed by the Insurer
challenging the judgment and award dated 10.09.2024
passed in MVC No.1390/2023 by XIX Additional Judge,
Court of Small Causes and MACT, Bangalore (SCCH- 17).
2. Even though both appeals are listed today
for admission, they are taken up for disposal with the
consent of learned counsels appearing for the parties.
3. Claimants made a claim petition praying to
award compensation for the death of Laxmaiah in a road
traffic accident occurred on 16.02.2023 contending that
the accident occurred due to the rash and negligent riding
of motorcycle bearing registration No.KA-06/HK-7510 by
its rider. The Tribunal after recording evidence and
appreciating the evidence on record has assessed the
compensation and awarded the compensation under
various heads as under:
1. Loss of dependency Rs. 46,99,968/-
2. Loss of consortium Rs. 2,20,000/-
3. Loss of future
prospects
Rs. 11,74,992/-
4. Towards loss of love Rs. 27,500/-
Digitally Signed By:
SHIVASHANKAR BASAPPA
AMARANNAVAR
JUDGE, HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA

- 6 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62503
MFA No. 3068 of 2025
C/W MFA No. 7636 of 2024


CNR: KAHC010272912025


and affection
5. Funeral Expenses Rs. 16,500/-
6. Transport of dead
body
Rs. 16,500/-
Total Rs. 61,55,460/-


4. The Tribunal held that the deceased has
contributed to the accident to the extent of 20% and after
deducting 20% in total compensation of Rs.61,55,460/-,
awarded Rs.49,24,368/- with interest at the rate of 6%
per annum from the date of petition till realization and
directed the insurer to deposit the award amount with
interest. The claimant challenging the said contributory
negligence attributed to the deceased filed the appeal. The
insurer challenging the quantum of compensation amount
and also the contributory negligence attributed to the
driver of the insured motor vehicle filed the appeal.
5. Learned counsel for claimant would
contend that the deceased was on the left side of the road
and at that time the rider of the motorcycle came and
dashed to him and therefore, entire negligence is on the
part of the rider of the motorcycle. The Tribunal erred in
Digitally Signed By:
SHIVASHANKAR BASAPPA
AMARANNAVAR
JUDGE, HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA

- 7 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62503
MFA No. 3068 of 2025
C/W MFA No. 7636 of 2024


CNR: KAHC010272912025


attributing contributing negligence on the part of the
deceased.
7. Learned counsel for insurer would contend
that the accident has taken place on the highway and the
deceased was crossing the road where there was no zebra
crossing and considering the same, the contributory
negligence attributed to the deceased at 20% is on the
lower side. He further submits that the average income of
the deceased, as shown in the Income Tax Returns at
Exhibit P10 and Exhibit P11, is to be taken. On that point,
he places reliance on the decision of the Hon'ble Apex
Court in the case of Rashmirekha Tripathy and
Another vs. Branch Manager(Legal Claims,) Sriram
General Insurance Company. Limited and Others
(2026 SCC OnLine SC 1256). He further submits that
since consortium is awarded, claimants are not entitled to
loss of love and affection awarded by the Tribunal in a sum
of Rs.27,500/-. The average of the income stated in the
Income Tax Returns at Exhibit P10 and Exhibit P11 is to be
Digitally Signed By:
SHIVASHANKAR BASAPPA
AMARANNAVAR
JUDGE, HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA

- 8 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62503
MFA No. 3068 of 2025
C/W MFA No. 7636 of 2024


CNR: KAHC010272912025


taken as the income of the deceased. With these, he prays
to allow the appeal filed by him.
8. Having heard learned counsels, the Court
has perused the judgment, award and the trial Court
records.
9. The accident occurred on 16.02.2023 at
09:15 p.m. Ex.P7 is the charge sheet and it is filed against
the rider of the insured motorcycle for rash and negligent
driving for offences under Section 279, 338 and 304A of
IPC. As per column No.17 of the charge sheet, the rider of
the motorcycle bearing registration No.KA-06/HK-7510
was proceeding from Nagavalli towards Hebbur on Tumkur
Kunigal road and at that time, the said motorcycle dashed
to the deceased who was crossing the road. Ex.P3 is the
spot mahazar enclosed with the spot sketch. The accident
occurred on the left side of the road on which the rider of
the motorcycle was proceeding and it is near a cross road.
In the said sketch and mahazar there is mention that
there are tire marks on the road to the extent of 10
Digitally Signed By:
SHIVASHANKAR BASAPPA
AMARANNAVAR
JUDGE, HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA

- 9 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62503
MFA No. 3068 of 2025
C/W MFA No. 7636 of 2024


CNR: KAHC010272912025


meters at the spot. The said tire marks clearly indicate
that the rider of the motorcycle applied brake in order to
avoid accident. In spite of that, he dashed to the deceased
who was crossing the road. Considering the said aspect
and that the accident has taken place near the crossroad,
the Tribunal has rightly held that the deceased has also
contributed to the accident and assessed his contributing
negligence at 20%.
10. The deceased is stated to be a driver and
doing business. Exhibit P10 and Exhibit P11 are the
income tax returns filed by the deceased for the
assessment year 2019-20 and 2020-2021. In view of
decision of Hon’ble Apex Court in the case of
Rashmirekha Tripathy(supra), the average of the
income stated in the Income Tax Returns at Exhibit P10
and Exhibit P11 is to be taken as the income of the
deceased. The income shown in Exhibit P10 is
Rs.2,46,574/- and the income shown in Exhibit P11 is
Rs.4,82,048/-. Therefore, the average yearly income
Digitally Signed By:
SHIVASHANKAR BASAPPA
AMARANNAVAR
JUDGE, HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA

- 10 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62503
MFA No. 3068 of 2025
C/W MFA No. 7636 of 2024


CNR: KAHC010272912025


2,
comes to Rs.3,64,311/- ( 46,574 + 4,82,048=
Rs.7,28,622/2= Rs.3,64,311/-). Accordingly, the loss of
dependency is calculated as under:
Rs.3,64,311×13 = Rs.47,36,043/- (-) 1/4th =
Rs.35,52,032/- + 25% (future prospects) =

Rs.44,40,040/-.
11. The Tribunal has awarded consortium,
funeral expenses and transportation of dead body taking
escalation at 10%. The accident occurred after 06 years of
the decision of Hon’ble Apex Court in the case of National
1
Insurance Co.Ltd., Vs Pranay Sethi and Ors and
therefore, the escalation is to be taken at 20% on
conventional heads. Claimants are wife, two children and
parents of the deceased and all are entitled to consortium
in a sum of Rs.40,000/- each with 20% escalation.
Therefore, the claimants are entitled to loss of consortium
in a sum of Rs.2,40,000/- (Rs.48,000/- x 5) as against

1
In AIR 2017 SC 5157
Digitally Signed By:
SHIVASHANKAR BASAPPA
AMARANNAVAR
JUDGE, HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA

- 11 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62503
MFA No. 3068 of 2025
C/W MFA No. 7636 of 2024


CNR: KAHC010272912025


Rs.2,20,000/- as awarded by the Tribunal. In view of
award of loss of consortium, claimants are not entitled to
loss of love and affection awarded by the Tribunal in a sum
of Rs.27,500/-. Claimants are also entitled to funeral
expenses of Rs.18,000/- and transportation of dead body
of Rs.18,000/-.
12. In view of the above, claimants are
entitled to total compensation as under:

Sl.
No.
Particulars Amount
1. Loss of dependency Rs. 44,40,040/-
2. Loss of consortium Rs. 2,40,000/-
3. Loss of estate Rs. 18,000/-
4. Funeral expenses Rs. 18,000/-
Total Rs. 47,16,040/-

Since the contributory negligence of the deceased is
assessed at 20%, the claimants are entitled to 80% of the
compensation assessed. Therefore, 80% of Rs.47,16,040/-
comes to Rs.37,72,832/-. Thus, the claimants are entitled
to a total compensation of Rs.37,72,832/-, as against
Rs.49,24,368/- awarded by the Tribunal, with interest at
Digitally Signed By:
SHIVASHANKAR BASAPPA
AMARANNAVAR
JUDGE, HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA

- 12 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62503
MFA No. 3068 of 2025
C/W MFA No. 7636 of 2024


CNR: KAHC010272912025


the rate of 6% per annum from the date of petition till
realization.
13. In view of above, the following

ORDER
i) Both appeals are allowed in part.
ii) Claimants are entitled to total compensation of
Rs.37,72,832/- as against Rs.49,24,368/- as
awarded by the Tribunal with interest at the rate
of 6% per annum from the date of petition till
realization.
iii) The Insurer (respondent No.2 before the Tribunal)
shall deposit the said compensation with interest
before the Tribunal within a period of 06 weeks
from this day, including the amount already
deposited.

iv) The share of compensation in the compensation
awarded, order of deposit and release as passed
by the Tribunal remained unaltered.
Digitally Signed By:
SHIVASHANKAR BASAPPA
AMARANNAVAR
JUDGE, HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA

- 13 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62503
MFA No. 3068 of 2025
C/W MFA No. 7636 of 2024


CNR: KAHC010272912025



v) The amount in deposit is ordered to be
transmitted to the Tribunal.
vi) In view of death of appellant No.5/claimant No.5,
his share is to be allotted to the appellant No.
4/claimant No.4.
vii) Appellant Nos.1 to 4 are entitled to share in the
compensation in the ratio of 40:25:25:10.

Digitally Signed By:
SHIVASHANKAR BASAPPA
AMARANNAVAR
JUDGE, HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA


(SHIVASHANKAR AMARANNAVAR)
JUDGE


DSP/KLV
List No.: 1 Sl No.: 37
Ct.sm