ANANDITA SHARMA vs STATE OF HP AND OTHERS
- Court
- High Court of Himachal Pradesh
2026:HHC:50190
High Court of H.P.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF HIMACHAL PRADESH, SHIMLA
C.W.P No.20525 of 2026
Date of Decision: 18.11.2026
_______________________________________________________________
Anandita Sharma ...Petitioner
Versus
State of Himachal Pradesh & others ...Respondents
Coram
Hon’ble Mr. Justice Ajay Mohan Goel, Judge
Hon’ble Mr. Justice Yogesh Jaswal, Judge
Whether approved for reporting? Yes
_________________________________________________________________
For the petitioner: Mr.Sunil Dutt Gautam and Mr. Harmohan
Thakur, Advocates.
For the respondents : Mr. Anup Rattan, Advocate General along
with Mr. Ramakant Sharma, Mr.
Pushpinder Jaswal, Additional Advocates
General and Mr. Rajat Chauhan, Assistant
Advocate General, for respondents No.1 &
2.
Mr. Vishwajeet Singh, Advocate, for
respondents No.3.
None for respondent No.4.
_______________________________________________________________
Ajay Mohan Goel, J. (Oral)
Notice. Mr. Pushpinder Jaswal, learned Additional
Advocate General and Mr. Vishwajeet Singh, learned counsel, accept
notice on behalf of respondents No.1,2 and 3, respectively.
::: Downloaded on - 20/11/2026 14:10:17 :::CIS
2026:HHC:50190
-2-
High Court of H.P.
2. By way of this writ petition, the petitioner has, inter alia
prayed for the following reliefs:-
“A. Issue an appropriate writ, order or direction,
particularly in the nature of Certiorari, quashing and
setting aside the relevant provisions of Paragraph 5 of
the Sub-Scheme contained in the Himachal Pradesh
Government Gazette Notification dated 11.02.2022
(Annexure P-4), insofar as the same prescribe English
as a compulsory subject in B.Ed and require at least
55 % marks in English at the Graduation level for
appointment of the post of English Teacher, as well as
the corresponding eligibility conditions prescribed
under Advertisement No.14/2026 dated 02.11.2026
(Annexure P-3), relating to English Teacher, Post Code
26046, being arbitrary, unreasonable and violative of
Articles 14 and 16 of the Constitution of India.
B. Declare that the aforesaid eligibility conditions,
insofar as they are applied to candidates who have
pursued B.Ed in accordance with the stream-wise
teaching-subject combinations prescribed under the
HPU B.Ed. Regulations, cannot be enforced without
considering the prescribed academic framework and
the subjects available to candidates of the respective
streams.
C. Issue an appropriate writ, order or direction
directing the respondents to reconsider and determine
::: Downloaded on - 20/11/2026 14:10:17 :::CIS
2026:HHC:50190
-3-
High Court of H.P.
the eligibility of the petitioner for the post of English
Teacher by taking into consideration her B.Sc.Non-
Medical qualification, B.Ed.with Mathematics and
Physical Science as teaching subjects, M.A. in English,
HP TET qualification and the applicable HPU B.Ed.
Regulations.
D. Direct the respondents to produce before this
Hon’ble Court the relevant recruitment rules, academic
regulations and the material forming the basis for
prescribing the impugned eligibility conditions
contained in the Gazette Notification dated 11.02.2026
and Advertisement No.14/2026 dated 02.11.2026.
E. During the pendency of the present petition,
direct the respondents to provisionally permit the
petitioner to submit her application and participate in
the recruitment process for the post of English
Teacher, subject to the final outcome of the present
petition.”
3. The petitioner, who claims to be a candidate possessing
the qualifications of B.Sc., B.Ed. and Master of English from Indira
Gandhi National Open University, is aggrieved by the issuance of
nd
Annexures P-3 and P-4. Annexure P-3 is advertisement dated 2
November, 2026, issued by the respondent, the Himachal Pradesh
Rajya Chayan Aayog, Hamirpur, in terms whereof, applications were
invited from eligible candidates for recruitment against the post of
::: Downloaded on - 20/11/2026 14:10:17 :::CIS
2026:HHC:50190
-4-
High Court of H.P.
English Teachers along with Teachers in other streams. Annexure P-4
th
is the Scheme for CBSE. Affiliated Schools of Excellence dated 19
January, 2026, on the basis whereof, the advertisement was issued.
4. Learned counsel for the petitioner submitted that the peti-
tioner has done her graduation in Science and thereafter, she has
done her B.Ed. from the Himachal Pradesh University. Learned
counsel further submitted that the petitioner has also done M.A. in
English from Indira Gandhi National Open University with 63.14%
marks, but on account of the condition which is contained in the
Scheme (Annexure P-4), in terms whereof, the minimum educational
qualification for being considered for appointment as English Teacher
in CBSE Affiliated Schools of Excellence is M.A. English with 50%
marks in graduation with B.Ed. and teaching of English as a
compulsory subject in B.Ed as the petitioner has not done B.Ed. with
English as a compulsory subject, this renders her ineligible for the
post. Learned counsel for the petitioner has argued that in light of
the fact that the Himachal Pradesh University does not impart B.Ed.
education with English as a compulsory subject, the inclusion of this
Clause in Annexure P-4 is arbitrary, as it renders the petitioner and
all other candidates who are similarly situated ineligible to participate
::: Downloaded on - 20/11/2026 14:10:17 :::CIS
2026:HHC:50190
-5-
High Court of H.P.
in the process and on this count, he prayed that the present petition
be allowed as prayed for.
5. On the other hand, learned Advocate General submitted
that a perusal of the relevant Clause of Annexure P-4 would
demonstrate that in terms of the said Scheme, the eligibility criteria
for being eligible to participate in the process for appointment against
the post of English in CBSE-Affiliated Schools of Excellence is M.A.
English with 50% marks in graduation with B.Ed., but with the
condition that English has to be a compulsory subject in B.Ed.
6. Learned Advocate General submitted that this has been
done for the reason that in terms of the Rules, even a candidate, who
has done his graduation in Science is eligible to participate in the
process, provided his post-graduation is in English with minimum
50% marks, but as English is not a subject which a candidate is
taught while undergoing under-graduation in the Science stream,
therefore, to make good this deficiency, the Government in its wisdom,
has introduced the Clause that at least B.Ed. should be with English
as a compulsory subject.
7. Learned Advocate General further submitted that it is not
as if B.Ed. in the concerned subject has been made compulsory only
::: Downloaded on - 20/11/2026 14:10:17 :::CIS
2026:HHC:50190
-6-
High Court of H.P.
in English subject. By referring to Annexure P-4, he has submitted
that this Scheme relates to appointment of teachers in English and
Maths and this Clause has been similarly made applicable for both
the subjects.
8. Learned Advocate General also submitted that as the post
is of English and as the Rule envisages that B.Ed. should be with
English as a compulsory subject, in the act of the respondents, there
is no arbitrariness in the same.
9. Having heard learned counsel for the petitioner as also
learned Advocate General and having perused Annexures P-3 and P-4,
we are of the considered view that there is no merit in the petition.
The post in issue is of English Teacher in CBSE-Affiliated Schools of
Excellence. The educational qualification required to be eligible to
participate in the process is M.A in English with 50% marks in
graduation with B.Ed and teaching of English as a compulsory sub-
ject in B.Ed.
10. In terms of Annexure P-4, candidates like the petitioner,
who have not done their graduation in English or graduation in
Humanities have also been made eligible to participate in the process,
provided they are possessing the qualification of M.A. English with
::: Downloaded on - 20/11/2026 14:10:17 :::CIS
2026:HHC:50190
-7-
High Court of H.P.
50% marks in graduation and B.Ed. and teaching of English as a
compulsory subject in B.Ed. Simply because the University from
which the petitioners have done their B.Ed. does not impart B.Ed.
with teaching of English as a compulsory subject, the same does not
render the educational qualification which has been prescribed in
Annexure P-4 to be per se bad in law.
11. Hon'ble Supreme Court of India in P.U.
Joshi & Others vs The Accountant General Ahmedabad and oth-
ers reported in (2003) 2 SCC 632 has been pleased to hold that
questions relating to constitution, pattern, nomenclature of posts,
cadres, categories, their creation, abolition, prescription of qualifica-
tion and other conditions of service including avenues of promotion
and criteria to be fulfilled for promotion, etc. pertain to the field of pol-
icy and are within the exclusive discretion and jurisdiction of the
State, subject of course to the limitations or restrictions envisaged in
the Constitution of India, and it is not for the Statutory Tribunals, at
any rate, to direct the Government to have a particular method of re-
cruitment or eligibility criteria etc. Hon'ble Supreme Court has further
held that it is well open and within the competency of the State to
::: Downloaded on - 20/11/2026 14:10:17 :::CIS
2026:HHC:50190
-8-
High Court of H.P.
change the Rules relating to service and alter or amend or vary the
same, including the qualification.
12. In the present case, it is not as if for appointment against
the post of English, the educational qualification which the
Department is seeking in terms of Annexure P-4 is alien to the
post which is intended to be filled by way of Annexure P-4. The post
is of an English Teacher and the requirement is M.A. English with
50% marks in graduation with B.Ed. and teaching of English as a
compulsory subject in B.Ed. According to us, teaching of English as a
compulsory subject in B.Ed. for an English Teacher cannot be said to
be an arbitrary qualification provided in the Scheme in issue.
13. As observed hereinabove also, simply because the
petitioner does not fulfill the eligibility criteria, the same does not
render the eligibility criteria to be bad in law.
14. Even otherwise, the scope of interference with regard to the
laying down of Recruitment and Promotion Rules, which as per the
Hon'ble Supreme Court of India pertain to the field of Policy, is very
limited and the Courts can interfere only if they come to the
conclusion that the Rules are beyond the limitations or restrictions
envisaged in the Constitution of India. In the Rule in hand, we do not
::: Downloaded on - 20/11/2026 14:10:17 :::CIS
2026:HHC:50190
-9-
High Court of H.P.
find that the criteria which is prescribed is beyond the restrictions or
limitations as envisaged in the Constitution of India and, therefore, as
we do not find any merit in the present petition, the same is dis-
missed. Pending miscellaneous application(s), if any, shall also stand
disposed of.
(Ajay Mohan Goel)
Judge
(Yogesh Jaswal)
Judge
November 18, 2026 (meera)
::: Downloaded on - 20/11/2026 14:10:17 :::CIS