N K Agarwal vs M/o Railways
- Court
- Central Administrative Tribunal
1
Item No. 27 (C-1)
O.A. No. 3990/2018
Central Administrative Tribunal
Principal Bench, New Delhi
O.A. No. 3990/2018
th
This the 04 day of November, 2026
Hon’ble Shri B. Anand, Member (A)
Shri N.K. Agarwal
S/o Late Shri R.P. Agarwal Aged 69 yrs Group C.
Ex. Senior Section Engineer [Dsl]
Northern Railway Diesel Shed Tughlakabad
R/o FA-218 Lajpat Nagar Sahibabad Ghaziabad
... Applicant
(By Advocate: Mr. BC Nagar)
Versus
Union of India : Through
1. Secretary Railway Board Ministry of Railways Railway
Bhawan, New Delhi
2. General Manager Northern Railway Headquarters Office
Baroda House New Delhi
3. Chief Motive Power Engineer(Diesel) Northern Railway
Headquarters Office Baroda House, New Delhi.
4. Divisional Railway Manager Northern Railway State
Entry Road, New Delhi
... Respondents
(By Advocate: Mr. Ranjan Tyagi)
DEEKSHA 2026.11.13
16:25:58+05'30'
DHINGRA
2
Item No. 27 (C-1)
O.A. No. 3990/2018
O R D E R (ORAL)
Hon’ble Shri B. Anand, Member (A)
1. The brief facts of the case as explained by the learned
counsel for the applicant are that the applicant was
compulsorily retired from the service vide order dated
23.04.2007. Aggrieved by the same, the applicant preferred
an appeal, however, the same was rejected by the appellate
authority vide its order dated 23.08.2007. The applicant
then filed an O.A. No. 3699/2013 before the Tribunal which
was disposed of with a direction to dispose of the pending
appeal of the applicant. Accordingly, his appeal post the
grant of liberty by the Tribunal was disposed of on
31.10.2015. Thereafter, the applicant filed another O.A. No.
2078/2016 which was disposed of on 18.07.2016 with a
direction to the respondents to pass a reasoned and
speaking order on the pending representation of the
applicant within two months. It is submitted that in
compliance of the directions of the Tribunal, the
respondents set aside the suspension period of the applicant
and exonerated him from all the charges levelled against
him and revised his pay and pension vide order dated
22.02.2016. Now, the only issue that remains to be
adjudicated is that the applicant having been compulsorily
DEEKSHA 2026.11.13
16:25:58+05'30'
DHINGRA
3
Item No. 27 (C-1)
O.A. No. 3990/2018
retired on 23.04.2007 ought to have been given all the
retiral dues to which he is entitled as per the rules. It
appears that inasmuch as the applicant was trying to
approach judicial forum to set aside the order of compulsory
retirement, the authorities have also not taken prompt steps
to release the applicant’s retiral benefits from 23.04.2007. It
is also seen that the applicant has also attributed to this
delay by not having immediately furnished all the requisite
pensionary papers to the respondents and in the absence of
any cause of action as the applicant was very busy trying to
change the order of compulsory retirement. Aggrieved by
the above action of the respondents, the applicant has
preferred the present O.A. seeking the following relief(s):-
“8.1 That this Hon'ble' Tribunal may be graciously
pleased to allow this OA and direct the respondents to
pay interest on the delayed payment of retiral
benefits as indicated below: (i) Interest @ 10% per
annum is due to the applicant in the following
delayed payment: (a) Provident Fund:
Rs.2,57,884.00 paid on 23-5-2012 which was due on
30-4-2009. (b) Leave encashment: Rs.54,774.00 paid
on 11-10-2013, which was due on 23-4-2007. (c)
Insurance Amount: Rs.29,342.00 paid on 11-10 2013
which was due on 23-4-2007. (d) DCRG :
Rs.4,69,176.00 paid on 11-10-2013 which was due on
23-4-2007 (the said amount had been calculated by
the respondents on 23-4-2007 when the applicant
was wrongfully retired compulsorily. (e)
Commutation: Rs.5,35,100.00 paid on 11-10-2013,
although it was due on 30-4-2009, but the calculation
made was from 23-4-2007. (f) Salary w.e.f.23-4-
2007 to 30-4-2009 Rs. 4,85,429.00 paid on 31-10-
DEEKSHA 2026.11.13
16:25:58+05'30'
DHINGRA
4
Item No. 27 (C-1)
O.A. No. 3990/2018
2010, although this amount was due on 30-4-2009.
(g) Pension amount: Rs.9,10,472.00 paid on 31-1-
2014, although this amount ought to have been paid
on 30-4-2009.
8.2 That this Hon'ble' Tribunal may be further
pleased to direct the respondents to pay further
interest as per Schedule followed by the Banks.
8.3 That this Hon'ble Tribunal may also be pleased to
grant any other or further relief which this Hon'ble
Tribunal may deem fit and proper in view of the facts
and circumstances of the case.
8.4 That the costs of these proceedings may kindly be
granted in favour of Applicant and against the
Respondents.”
2. Learned counsel for the applicant submits that in view of the
delayed payments made as indicated in para 4.25 of the
O.A., the applicant is now seeking interest at the rate of 10%
on all the delayed payments.
3. In view of the full Bench judgment of the Tribunal, the law
on the aspect of delayed payments of retiral dues and
interest thereon has been indicated in the case of Rajbir
Singh v. Municipal Corporation of Delhi & Ors . in
O.A. No. 2821/2023 dated 30.10.2025. Though the said
order has been challenged before the Hon’ble High Court of
Delhi, however, there is no stay operating.
4. It is seen that there is a delay on the part of the applicant
also as he had not submitted the relevant retirement papers
on time and had submitted the same only on 25.10.2010.
There is also nothing on record to show that during the
DEEKSHA 2026.11.13
16:25:58+05'30'
DHINGRA
5
Item No. 27 (C-1)
O.A. No. 3990/2018
period starting from 23.04.2007 to 25.10.2010, the
respondents have been reminding him to furnish all the
requisite papers required for processing the claim of
pensionary benefits. Thus, both the applicant and the
respondents are equally responsible for the delay in
payment of the retiral dues between 23.04.2007 to
25.10.2010.
5. In view of the above, the O.A. is disposed of with the
following directions:-
a. For the delay caused between 23.04.2007 to
25.10.2010, the interest rate on the delayed payments
for this period will be reduced by 50% and
accordingly, the respondents would calculate the GPF
interest rate and pay interest on the delayed payments
of the retiral dues.
b. For the remaining period starting from 25.10.2010 till
the time the amount due is actually paid, the applicant
would be entitled to the interest on the delayed
payments at the rates applicable on the GPF deposits.
c. The aforesaid directions of paying the interest on all
the delayed payments made to the applicant from the
date it was due till the date it is actually paid would be
initially at half the interest rate of GPF deposits, that
DEEKSHA 2026.11.13
16:25:58+05'30'
DHINGRA
6
Item No. 27 (C-1)
O.A. No. 3990/2018
is, from 23.04.2007 to 25.10.2010 and for the
remaining period starting from 25.10.2010 till the date
the retiral dues were paid, the applicant shall be
entitled for interest on the same at the GPF interest
rate.
d. The aforesaid directions shall be complied with within
a period of six weeks from the date of receipt of a
certified copy of this order.
6. The O.A. stands disposed of in the aforesaid terms. There
shall be no order as to costs.
(B. Anand)
Member (A)
/dd /
DEEKSHA 2026.11.13
16:25:58+05'30'
DHINGRA