M/S Anil Spinner Mills vs State Of Haryana And Ors

Court
Punjab and Haryana High Court

1-
CWP-24203 of 2017 (O&M) -
IN THE HIGH COURT OF PUNJAB & HARYANA AT
CHANDIGARH
(221)
CWP No.24203 of 2017 (O&M)
Date of decision 17.11.2026

M/S ANIL SPINNER MILLS ...Petitioner

Versus

STATE OF HARYANA AND OTHERS ...Respondents



CORAM: HON’BLE MS. JUSTICE KIRTI SINGH


Present: Mr. Saurabh Bajaj, Advocate
for the petitioner.


Mr. Kapil Bansal, DAG, Haryana.


Mr. Himanshu Gupta, Advocate

for respondent No.4. (legal aid counsel)




KIRTI SINGH, J. (ORAL)

1. The present writ petition has been filed under Articles 226/227
of the Constitution of India seeking issuance of a writ in the nature of certiorari
for quashing the order dated 13.01.2017 (Annexure P-1) passed by the
Controlling Authority under the Payment of Gratuity Act, 1972 (for short, ‘the
Act of 1972’), Circle-II, Panipat (respondent No.2), as also the order dated
18.08.2017 (Annexure P-2) passed by the Appellate Authority under the Act
of 1972-cum-Deputy Labour Commissioner, Panipat (respondent No.3),
whereby respondent No.4 has been held entitled to gratuity amounting to
Rs.67,500/- along with interest at the rate of 9% per annum.

2. Briefly stated, as per the pleaded case of the petitioner, the
petitioner is a partnership firm and the present petition has been filed through
its partner. Respondent No.4 filed an application dated 13.05.2013
(Annexure P-5) before the Controlling Authority, which was registered as
SWARNJIT SINGH
2026.11.20 13:57
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document

2-
CWP-24203 of 2017 (O&M) -
Case No.06/PG/2013, claiming gratuity amounting to Rs.1,20,000/- on the
ground that he had served the petitioner-firm as a Peon from 18.01.1987 till
05.04.2013, on last drawn wages of Rs.4,500/- per month, and that he had been
removed from service on 06.04.2013. The petitioner contested the claim, inter
alia, on the ground that respondent No.4 had worked with the petitioner-firm
as per his own wish, that during the said period he had left and joined the
service many times, and that his service could not, therefore, be counted as
continuous service.

3. Respondent No.4 appeared as AW-1 and stated that he had been
engaged in the year 1987 and had worked as a watchman till the year 2013. In
his cross-examination, he stated that he is a resident of Nepal, that he used to
go to his house twice in a year after taking leave of 15-20 days, and that he
had taken an advance of Rs.15,000/- which was deducted from his salary. One
more witness was examined as AW-2. On the other hand, the witness
examined by the petitioner as RW-1 stated that respondent No.4 had worked
for 9-10 years as per record, that he used to go to his house twice a year and
that he had not worked for 240 days, and produced the details of the working
days of respondent No.4. He also stated that the petitioner retained the record
of ten years only. In his cross-examination, RW-1 admitted that
respondent No.4 had been engaged in the year 1985-86 and had worked till
the year 2013.

4. The Controlling Authority, vide order dated 13.01.2017
(Annexure P-1), noticed that the petitioner had neither produced any full and
final account voucher of respondent No.4 nor any order whereby the absence
or leave taken by respondent No.4 had been treated as a break in his service.
Relying upon sub-section (1) read with sub-section (2) of Section 2A of the
SWARNJIT SINGH
2026.11.20 13:57
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document

3-
CWP-24203 of 2017 (O&M) -
Act of 1972, it held that mere absence from duty on account of sickness or
leave could not be treated as an interruption or break in continuous service,
and that the condition of rendering service for 240 days in a year is not
required where the employee remains in continuous service. Taking note of
the admission made by RW-1 in his cross-examination, it held that
respondent No.4 had rendered continuous service from 18.01.1987 to
05.04.2013, i.e. for 26 years. On the basis of the last drawn wages of
Rs.4,500/- per month, which were not rebutted by the petitioner, gratuity was
computed at Rs.67,500/- and interest at the rate of 9% per annum for a fixed
period of three years, amounting to Rs.18,225/-, was also allowed, with a
direction to deposit the amount within 30 days, failing which further simple
interest at the rate of 9% per annum would be payable till realisation.

5. Aggrieved thereby, the petitioner preferred an appeal under
Section 7(7) of the Act of 1972 (Annexure P-4), contending, inter alia, that
respondent No.4 had worked with the petitioner only for about 9-10 years as
per record, that he used to go to his house twice in a year and had not worked
continuously, and that the petitioner was ready to pay the gratuity for 10 years
of service as per its record. The Appellate Authority, vide order dated
18.08.2017 (Annexure P-2), dismissed the appeal, holding that the findings
recorded by the Controlling Authority were based upon appreciation of facts
and evidence and that the order dated 13.01.2017 did not suffer from any error.
Hence, the present petition.

6. Learned counsel for the petitioner submits that the impugned
orders are illegal and have been passed in violation of the provisions of the
Act of 1972. He submits that respondent No.4 is a citizen of Nepal who used
to go to his country twice a year and, therefore, never worked for 240 days in
SWARNJIT SINGH
2026.11.20 13:57
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document

4-
CWP-24203 of 2017 (O&M) -
a year with the petitioner-firm, which fact stands admitted by him in his own
cross-examination. It is further submitted that the attendance record produced
by the petitioner before the Controlling Authority as Ex.RW-1 (Annexure P-
3) also shows that respondent No.4 never completed the requisite days of
service, and that the authorities below have allowed the claim merely on the
oral assertion of respondent No.4, without there being any evidence contrary
to the record produced by the petitioner-firm.

7. Learned counsel further submits that, in terms of Section 4 of the
Act of 1972, gratuity is payable only where the employee has rendered
continuous service for not less than five years, that the petitioner-firm is not a
seasonal establishment and works six days a week, and that respondent No.4
was never in continuous service within the meaning of Section 2A of the Act
of 1972. It is also contended that respondent No.4, in his application
(Annexure P-5), never claimed that he had worked for a continuous period,
and that the Appellate Authority dismissed the appeal by a non-speaking order
without application of mind.

8. Per contra, learned State counsel as well as learned counsel
appearing for respondent No.4 have opposed the prayer made in the petition
and supported the impugned orders. It is submitted that the Controlling
Authority as well as the Appellate Authority have recorded concurrent
findings of fact on the basis of the evidence led by the parties, which do not
warrant any interference.

9. I have heard learned counsel for the parties and perused the
record.

10. At the outset, it deserves to be noticed that the present petition
assails concurrent findings recorded by two statutory authorities functioning
SWARNJIT SINGH
2026.11.20 13:57
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document

5-
CWP-24203 of 2017 (O&M) -
under the Act of 1972, after affording opportunity to both parties to lead
evidence. It is well settled that the jurisdiction of this Court under Articles
226/227 of the Constitution of India, while examining orders of such statutory
authorities, is supervisory and not appellate in character. A writ of certiorari
would lie only where the authority has acted without jurisdiction, in violation
of the principles of natural justice, or where the finding is based on no
evidence or is otherwise perverse. It is not open to this Court to re-appreciate
the evidence as if sitting in appeal merely because another view is possible.

11. Section 2A(1) of the Act of 1972 provides that an employee shall
be said to be in continuous service for a period if he has, for that period, been
in uninterrupted service, including service which may be interrupted on
account of sickness, accident, leave, absence from duty without leave (not
being absence in respect of which an order treating the absence as break in
service has been passed in accordance with the standing orders, rules or
regulations governing the employees of the establishment), lay-off, strike or a
lock-out or cessation of work not due to any fault of the employee. The
deeming provision contained in Section 2A(2) of the Act of 1972, which refers
to an employee having actually worked for 240 days during the preceding
twelve calendar months, comes into play only where the employee is not in
continuous service within the meaning of clause (1) thereof.

12. Tested on this touchstone, the impugned orders do not suffer
from any infirmity. It is neither the pleaded case of the petitioner, nor does the
record bear out, that any order was ever passed treating the absence of
respondent No.4 during his visits to his native place as a break in his service
in terms of any standing orders, rules or regulations governing the petitioner-
firm. The very statement of respondent No.4 on which the petitioner places
SWARNJIT SINGH
2026.11.20 13:57
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document

6-
CWP-24203 of 2017 (O&M) -
reliance is that he used to go to his house after taking leave of 15-20 days, and
service interrupted on account of leave is expressly included within
continuous service under Section 2A(1) of the Act of 1972. Further, the
witness examined by the petitioner as RW-1 himself admitted in his cross-
examination that respondent No.4 had been engaged in the year 1985-86 and
had worked till the year 2013, and the petitioner did not produce any full and
final account voucher of respondent No.4. In these circumstances, the finding
recorded by the Controlling Authority, and affirmed by the Appellate
Authority, that respondent No.4 rendered continuous service from 18.01.1987
to 05.04.2013 is based on the evidence on record and cannot be termed as
perverse. The contention of learned counsel for the petitioner that
respondent No.4 did not work for 240 days in a year is, therefore, of no avail.

13. It is also relevant to notice that, as per the statement of RW-1
himself, the petitioner retained the record of ten years only, and before the
Appellate Authority the petitioner itself took the stand that it was ready to pay
gratuity to respondent No.4 for 10 years of service as per its record. The stand
of the petitioner thus itself acknowledges that respondent No.4 had rendered
service far in excess of five years, and the attendance record (Annexure P-3)
relied upon by the petitioner cannot be read as establishing that the service of
respondent No.4 stood broken at any point of time.

14. The contention that respondent No.4 had not claimed continuous
service in his application (Annexure P-5) is also not borne out from the record.
A perusal of the said application shows that respondent No.4 had specifically
asserted that he had rendered continuous service for a period of not less than
16 years. The said contention, therefore, does not advance the case of the
petitioner.
SWARNJIT SINGH
2026.11.20 13:57
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document

7-
CWP-24203 of 2017 (O&M) -

15. The further contention that the Appellate Authority passed a non-
speaking order also does not merit acceptance. A perusal of the order dated
18.08.2017 (Annexure P-2) shows that the Appellate Authority took note of
the case set up by the parties, the issues framed, the evidence led by both sides
and the findings recorded by the Controlling Authority before concurring with
the same. Learned counsel for the petitioner has not been able to point out any
material aspect which was urged before the Appellate Authority and was not
considered. Merely because the Appellate Authority concurred with the
findings recorded by the Controlling Authority would not, by itself, render its
order non-speaking.

16. For the reasons recorded hereinabove, this Court finds no ground
to interfere with the order dated 13.01.2017 (Annexure P-1) passed by
respondent No.2-Controlling Authority or the order dated 18.08.2017
(Annexure P-2) passed by respondent No.3-Appellate Authority.

17. The present writ petition, being devoid of merit, is accordingly
dismissed.

18. Pending civil miscellaneous application(s), if any, also stand
disposed of.

(KIRTI SINGH)

JUDGE

17.11.2026
SwarnjitS

Whether speaking/reasoned: Yes/No
Whether reportable: Yes/No
SWARNJIT SINGH
2026.11.20 13:57
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document