M/S Brahmacrop Limited Thr Its Director Authorized Signatory And Anr. vs Mr. Vijay Hiraman Wadkar And Ors.
- Court
- Bombay High Court
CNR No : HCBM010311342026
-CRA-356-2026.DOC
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAY
CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION
CIVIL REVISION APPLICATION NO. 356 OF 2026
1. M/s Brahmacorp Limited
a Company incorporated under the
Companies Act, through its director/
Authorized Signatory, having its registered
office at 3 Queens Garden, General
Arunkumar Vaidya Road,
Pune – 411 001.
2. Ajay Ramkumar Agarwal
aged about 50 years,
Occupation: Builder, residing at S. Nos. 7 & 8
Bramha Sun City,
Wadgaonsheri, Pune – 411 014. ...Applicants
Versus
ARUN
RAMCHANDRA
SANKPAL
1. Vijay Hiraman Wadkar
Age – 65 years; Occupation: Agriculture
and Business, Residing at : S. No. 22,
Sainikwadi, Vadgaonsheri, Pune – 411 014.
Digitally signed
by ARUN
RAMCHANDRA
SANKPAL
Date: 2026.11.18
22:50:03 +0530
2. Shobha Dilip Wadkar
Age-65 years; Occupation: Homemaker
Residing at
Vadgaonsheri, Pune – 411 014.
3. Vikram Dilip Wadkar
Age – 46 years; Occupation: Agriculture
and Business, Residing at
Vadgaonsheri, Pune – 411 014.
4. Smita Sudhir Kondhare
Age – 44 years; Occupation – Homemaker,
Residing at – S. No. 44, House No. 355/5,
ARS 1/26
Uploaded on - 18/11/2026 Downloaded on - 18/11/2026 23:07:26
-CRA-356-2026.DOC
Kondhare Galli, Near Chakradhar School,
Dattanagar Ambegaon Budruk,
Pune – 411 046.
5. Sharda Ashok Wadkar,
Age – 60 years, Occupation-Homemaker,
Residing at Sainikwadi,
Vadgaonsheri, Pune – 411 014.
6. Ketan Ashok Wadkar,
Age – 41 years, Occupation: Agriculture And
Business, Residing at Sainikwadi,
Vadgaonsheri, Pune – 411 014.
7. Nilam Mahendra Lonkar,
Age – 40 years, Occupation-Homemaker;
Residing at – Clover Hills Annex Society,
Plot No. 42, Opposite Gold Gym,
NIBM Road, Kondhwa Khurd,
Pune – 411 048.
8. Anuradha Amit Sasar
Age – 33 years, Occupation – Homemaker;
Residing at – c/o Amit Nanasaheb Sasar
Bhagwati Nivas, Near Dattamandir
Susgaon, Pune – 411 021.
9. Balkrishna Dattatray Galande,
Age – 68 years: Occupation: Agriculture
residing at – Survey No. 37/1A,
Wadgaonsheri, Pune – 411 014.
10. Nivrutti Dattatray Galande,
Age – 64 years: Occupation: Agriculture
residing at – Survey No. 37/1A,
Wadgaonsheri, Pune – 411 014.
11. Raosaheb Alias Dhananjay Dattatray
Galande,
Age – 45 years: Occupation: Agriculture
residing at – Survey No. 37/1A,
Wadgaonsheri, Pune – 411 014.
ARS 2/26
Uploaded on - 18/11/2026 Downloaded on - 18/11/2026 23:07:26
-CRA-356-2026.DOC
12. Rahul Balkrishna Galande,
Age – 45 years: Occupation: Agriculture
residing at – Survey No. 37/1A,
Wadgaonsheri, Pune – 411 014.
13. Deepal Balkrishna Galande,
Age – 43 years: Occupation: Agriculture
residing at – Survey No. 37/1A,
Wadgaonsheri, Pune – 411 014.
14. Monal Nivrutti Galande,
Age – 43 years: Occupation: Agriculture
residing at – Survey No. 37/1A,
Wadgaonsheri, Pune – 411 014.
15. Ruchil Dhananjay Galande,
Age – 22 years: Occupation: Agriculture
residing at – Survey No. 37/1A,
Wadgaonsheri, Pune – 411 014.
16. Indumati Balkrishna Galande,
Age – 65 years: Occupation: Agriculture
residing at – Survey No. 37/1A,
Wadgaonsheri, Pune – 411 014.
17. Vijaya Nivrutti Galande,
Age – 62 years: Occupation: Agriculture
residing at – Survey No. 37/1A,
Wadgaonsheri, Pune – 411 014.
18. Shubhangi Dhananjay Galande,
Age – 45 years: Occupation: Agriculture
residing at – Survey No. 37/1A,
Wadgaonsheri, Pune – 411 014.
19. Zawar Sales Pvt Ltd,
A Private Limited Company
duly registered under the Companies
Act 2013; Having its Registered Office
at – B/105, Kalpataru Plaza, 224,
Bhavani Peth, Pune – 411 042.
20. Vijay Badrinath Zawar,
Age – 66 years; Occupation: Business;
ARS 3/26
Uploaded on - 18/11/2026 Downloaded on - 18/11/2026 23:07:26
-CRA-356-2026.DOC
Residing at 473/17C, Gultekdi,
Pune – 411 037.
…Respondents
Mr. Girish Godbole, Senior Advocate, with Rohan Cama, Parth Jain,
Aditi Pareek and Divya Kakkar, i/b Jain Law Partners LLP, for
the Applicants.
Mr. Atul Damle, Senior Advocate, i/b Sujay Gangal, for Respondent
Nos. 1 to 4.
Mr. Surel Shah, Senior Advocate, i/b Umang Mehta, for Respondent
Nos. 5 to 8.
Mr. Shreyas R Zarkar, for Respondent Nos. 9, 11 to 13, 15, 16 and 18.
Mr. Prashant Jadhav, with Shrunkhal Pashte, for Respondent Nos. 10,
14 and 17.
CORAM : N. J. JAMADAR, J.
th
RESERVED ON : 29 SEPTEMBER 2026
th
PRONOUNCED ON : 18 NOVEMBER 2026
JUDGMENT:
nd
1.
This revision application is directed against an order dated 22
May 2026 passed by the learned Civil Judge, Senior Division, Pune on
applications seeking rejection of the plaint, preferred by the defendants,
including the applicants (defendant Nos. 13 and 14), in SCS No. 1903 of
2025, whereby the said applications came to be rejected.
2.
The background facts leading to this application can be stated in
brief as under:
2.1 Late Ramchandra Ganpati Galande had two wives. The first wife
had a son, Dattatray, and a daughter, Satyabhama, by late Ramchandra
ARS 4/26
Uploaded on - 18/11/2026 Downloaded on - 18/11/2026 23:07:26
-CRA-356-2026.DOC
Galande. The first wife passed away in the year 1943. Defendants Nos.
1 to 10 are the successor-in-interest of Dattatray.
2.2 After the demise of the first wife, late Ramchandra Galande
solemnized marriage with Geetabai in the year 1947. At that time,
Geetabai was a widow. Geetabai had a daughter Hirabai by her late first
husband, Ramchandra Sopan Mate. The plaintiffs are the heirs of
Hirabai.
th
2.3 Ramchandra Galande passed away intestate on 13 July 1980
intestate. The plaintiffs claimed, upon death of Ramchandra Galande,
the land admeasuring 5H 35.64 R bearing Survey No. 37/1A situated at
Village Vadgaon Sheri, Pune, (“the suit property”), which was the
ancestral property of late Ramchandra Galande, devolved upon
Geetabai, Dattatray and Satyabhama. The name of Hirabai was not
mutated to the Record of Rights of the suit property as she was the step-
daughter of Ramchandra Galande.
2.4 In the year 2000, Satyabhama, the daughter of Ramchandra,
demanded her share in the joint family property left behind by late
Ramchandra Galande. Pursuant to a compromise arrived at between the
parties, a property bearing Survey No. 50/10 admeasuring 69R situated
at Vadgaon Sheri, came to be separated and allotted to Satyabhama
st
under a registered Partition Deed dated 1 March 2000. Thereafter, the
plaintiffs assert, Geetabai, had one half undivided share in the suit
ARS 5/26
Uploaded on - 18/11/2026 Downloaded on - 18/11/2026 23:07:26
-CRA-356-2026.DOC
st
property. Geetabai passed away on 21 March 2001. During the lifetime
of Geetabai, there was no partition between late Geetabai and Dattatray.
2.5 Upon the death of Geetabai, the plaintiffs assert, Hirabai, being
the only daughter of Geetabai, became the absolute owner of the one
half undivided interest of late Geetabai in the suit property. Hirabai, in
th
turn, passed away on 7 October 2023. The plaintiffs, being the legal
heirs of late Hirabai, are thus entitled to one half undivided share in the
suit property.
2.6 It is the case of the plaintiffs that, during her lifetime, Geetabai
had permitted, late Ashsok Wadkar, the predecessor-in-title of plaintiff
Nos. 5 and 6, and Vijay Wadkar, plaintiff No.1, to run a fabrication
business from an area admeasuring 200 sq ft of the suit property.
Though initially permissive, the plaintiffs claim, their possession over
the said area wherefrom the business of Shivganga Enterprises was
being carried, ripened into ownership as they became co-owners of the
suit property upon the demise of Hirabai. The defendants were fully
cognizant of the right, title and interest of the plaintiffs in the suit
property, including the said portion of 200 sq ft. Yet, in February 2025,
defendant Nos. 2, 6 and 9 alongwith their hirelings threatened the
plaintiffs that they could no longer carry on the fabrication business
from the suit property as they had no right in the suit property or any
portion thereof.
ARS 6/26
Uploaded on - 18/11/2026 Downloaded on - 18/11/2026 23:07:26
-CRA-356-2026.DOC
2.7 In the wake of the aforesaid incident, the plaintiffs claim to have
gathered relevant information and collected documents. It transpired
that, during the lifetime of Geetabai, two false and fabricated registered
th th
Wills dated 8 December 1997 and 16 December 1998 were brought
into existence. The defendants had executed five Sale Deeds alongwith
late Geetabai and others in favour of defendant No.11 in respect of the
portions of the suit property. However, the possession of those portions
of the suit property has continued to remain with the defendants. The
Development Agreements and Power of Attorney were also executed by
the defendants in favour of defendant No.11. The latter executed a
Deed of Assignment and Power of Attorney in favour of defendant
th
No.13 on 11 May 2006. By ascribing multifarious reasons, the
plaintiffs assert that, the aforesaid documents executed by and between
the defendants are illegal, null and void and do not bind the plaintiffs
and those documents are liable to be cancelled.
2.8 The plaintiffs have thus instituted the suit seeking a declaration
that the plaintiffs are entitled to one half share in the suit property, for
partition and separate possession thereof and other consequential reliefs
in regard to the above referred instruments.
2.9 The defendants, including the applicants-defendant Nos. 13 and
14, filed applications seeking rejection of the plaint, primarily on two
counts. First, since late Hirabai was not the daughter born to Geetabai
ARS 7/26
Uploaded on - 18/11/2026 Downloaded on - 18/11/2026 23:07:26
-CRA-356-2026.DOC
by late Ramchandra Galande, she was not entitled to inherit the
property left behind by late Ramchandra Galande. Thus the plaint did
not disclose a cause of action. Second the suit was hopelessly barred by
law of limitation.
2.10 The applications were resisted by the plaintiffs.
2.11 By the impugned order, the learned Civil Judge was persuaded to
reject the application observing, inter alia, that the plaint did disclose a
cause of action as Hirabai, being a biological daughter of Geetabai, was
entitled to succeed to the estate left behind by Geetabai irrespective of
the fact that she was not born to Geetabai by late Ramchandra Galande.
Second, the learned Civil Judge was of the view that the averments in
the plaint, if read as a whole, indicated that the plaintiffs had
knowledge about the various testamentary instruments executed by late
Hirabai and the instruments inter vivos executed by Geetabai and other
defendants, in the year 2025 only. Therefore, the suit instituted in the
year 2026 seeking declaration qua those instruments was ex-facie not
barred by law of limitation. Thus, no case was made out for the
rejection of the plaint at the threshold by invoking the power under
Order VII Rule 11 of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 (“the Code”).
2.12 Being aggrieved, defendant nos. 13 and 14 have preferred this
revision application.
ARS 8/26
Uploaded on - 18/11/2026 Downloaded on - 18/11/2026 23:07:26
-CRA-356-2026.DOC
3.
I have heard Mr. Girish Godbole, the learned Senior Advocate, for
the applicants, Mr. Atul Damle, the learned Senior Advocate, for
respondent Nos. 1 to 4, Mr. Surel Shah, the learned Senior Advocate, for
respondent Nos. 5 to 8, Mr. Shreyas Zarkar, the learned Counsel for
respondent Nos. 9, 11 to 13, 15, 16 and 18 and Mr. Prashant Jadhav, the
learned Counsel for respondent Nos. 10, 14 and 17. With the assistance
of the learned Counsel for the parties, I have perused the material on
record, especially the averments in the plaint.
4.
Mr. Girish Godbole, the learned Senior Advocate for the revision
applicants, submitted that the learned Civil Judge did not properly
appreciate the object of the provisions contained in Order VII Rule 11 of
the Code. A suit of the present nature, where the successor-in-interest of
a step-daughter of the original holder of the suit property, who was
under no circumstances entitled to succeed to the estate of such original
holder, have approached the Civil Court, after the demise of the step-
daughter, the provision contained in Order VII Rule 11 of the Code finds
its practical application. The very object of nipping a frivolous and
abortive proceeding in the bud would be defeated if the plaint of the
present nature is not rejected by exercising power under Order VII Rule
11 of the Code. The learned Civil Judge unjustifiably declined to exercise
the jurisdiction vested in him though a very strong case was made out
from the very averments in the plaint, submitted Mr. Godbole.
ARS 9/26
Uploaded on - 18/11/2026 Downloaded on - 18/11/2026 23:07:26
-CRA-356-2026.DOC
5.
Mr. Godbole laid emphasis on the fact that, Hirabai lived for
almost 23 years of the demise of Geetabai. Yet, during her lifetime,
Hirabai never asserted her right, title and interest in the suit property in
her capacity as the daughter of Geetabai. Nor Hirabai ever questioned
any of the transactions entered into by the defendants during the said
23 long years. What accentuates the situation is the fact that, the
plaintiffs claim to be very much on the suit property, albeit in a small
portion of 200 sq ft for running a business and, yet, the plaintiffs feigned
ignorance about the transactions executed by the defendants and
Geetabai during her lifetime, and by resorting to clever drafting baldly
asserted that the cause of action arose in the year 2025 when they were
allegedly restrained from continuing the fabrication business from the
suit property. The learned Civil Judge thus ought to have read the plaint
in a meaningful and not a formalistic manner. The Courts have frowned
upon such clever drafting which creates an illusion of a cause of action.
To buttress these submissions, Mr. Godbole placed reliance on a
judgment of the learned Single Judge of this Court in Kumar Beharay
Properties LLP, through its Authorized Signatory Vs Rajesh Chandrakant
1
Shinde and Ors.
6.
Mr. Godbole further submitted that, even if the case of the
plaintiffs is taken at par by way of demurer, yet, it becomes evident that
during her life time, Geetabai had divested herself of all the right, title
1
2025 SCC OnLine Bom 5006.
ARS 10/26
Uploaded on - 18/11/2026 Downloaded on - 18/11/2026 23:07:26
-CRA-356-2026.DOC
and interest in the suit property, initially by executing the registered
Wills and, thereafter, by executing various instruments in favour of
defendant No.11. Thus, on the date Geetabai passed away, she had not
left behind any estate and, therefore, the claim of the plaintiffs that
Hirabai became the absolute owner of one half interest in the suit
property is ex-facie untenable.
7.
Emphasis was laid by Mr. Godbole on the fact that all the
instruments in respect of which declarations are sought by the plaintiffs
have been duly registered. This factor singularly demolishes the case of
the plaintiffs that they had no knowledge about the instruments in
question as the registered instruments constitute a constructive notice.
8.
In opposition to this, Mr. Atul Damle, the learned Senior
Advocate, for respondent Nos.1 to 4-plaintiff Nos.1 to 4 stoutly
submitted that the very premise of the applicants that the plaint did not
disclose a cause of action was completely misconceived. It is not the
requirement of law that the son or daughter who succeeds to the estate
of a female Hindu dying intestate under Section 15 of the Hindu
Succession Act, 1956 ought to have been born to the husband whose
property the female Hindu had inherited. The only qualification to
succeed to the property left behind by Hindu female, who dies intestate,
is to be a son or daughter. Therefore, in the case at hand, the fact that
Hirabai was born to Geetabai by her first husband was not determinative
ARS 11/26
Uploaded on - 18/11/2026 Downloaded on - 18/11/2026 23:07:26
-CRA-356-2026.DOC
of Hirabai's entitlement to succeed to the estate left behind by Geetabai.
Hirabai was entitled to succeed to the estate left behind by Geetabai to
the exclusion of the heirs of her husband. To buttress this submission,
Mr. Damle placed reliance on a Division Bench judgment of this Court in
2
the case of Rama Ananda Patil Vs Appa Bhima Redekar and Ors.
9.
Mr. Damle further submitted that, in any event, limitation is a
mixed question of law and fact. In the backdrop of the averments in the
plaint, by no stretch of imagination, could it be said that the suit is ex-
facie barred by law of limitation. At any rate, even if the prayer for
declarations in regard to the instruments in question is considered to be
barred by limitation yet since the plaintiffs are seeking partition and
separate possession of their share in the suit properties, the plaint cannot
be rejected in part. To this end, a strong reliance was placed by Mr.
Damle on the judgment of the Supreme Court in the case of Central
3
Bank of India and Anr Vs Prabha Jain and Ors, wherein it was
enunciated that there cannot be a partial rejection of the plaint under
Order VII Rule 11 of the Code and even if one relief survives, plaint
cannot be rejected under Order VII Rule 11 of the Code.
10.
Mr. Surel Shah, the learned Senior Advocate for respondent-
defendant Nos. 5 to 8 also supplemented the submissions of Mr. Damle.
It was urged that the application for rejection of the plaint proceeded on
2
AIR 1969 Bombay 205.
3
( 2025) 4 SCC 38.
ARS 12/26
Uploaded on - 18/11/2026 Downloaded on - 18/11/2026 23:07:26
-CRA-356-2026.DOC
an erroneous impression of law. The plaintiffs had pleaded a clear cause
of action.
11.
On the aspect of the limitation, Mr. Shah would urge, at the stage
of consideration of an application for rejection of the plaint, the
averments in the plaint in regard to the knowledge of essential facts and
documents which furnish a cause of action, will have to be accepted as
correct. In the case at hand, the plaintiffs have made clear and
unequivocal averments that they came to know about the instruments in
question and the intent of the defendants in the year 2025 only, when
they were tried to be restrained from carrying out the business from the
suit property.
12.
In such a situation the fact that the instruments in question have
been executed prior to certain years, cannot be a sustainable ground for
the rejection of the plaint. In order to lend support to the aforesaid
submission, Mr. Shah placed a very strong reliance on the judgment of
the Supreme Court in the case of Daliben Valjibhai and Ors Vs Prajapati
4
Kodarbhai Kachrabhai and Anr.
13.
The contours of the provisions contained in Order VII Rule 11 of
the Code which empower the Court to reject the Plaint for the causes set
out in clause (a) to (f) of sub-rule (1) are fairly well recognized. The
power under Order VII Rule 11 can be exercised by the Court at any
stage of the suit. The stage of the proceeding does not matter. What is of
4
2024 SCC OnLine SC 4105.
ARS 13/26
Uploaded on - 18/11/2026 Downloaded on - 18/11/2026 23:07:26
-CRA-356-2026.DOC
decisive signifcance is the averments in the Plaint. To arrive at a decision
as to whether a plaint is required to be rejected, for not disclosing a
cause of action or being barred by any law, only the averments in the
Plaint are germane. The pleas in defence are wholly irrelevant. The
Plaint is required to be read as a whole. The averments in the Plaint are
required to be read in a meaningful manner. It is not the formal reading
of the Plaint but a meaningful reading which would serve as the light-
house to find out whether the Plaint discloses a cause of action or by
resorting to clever drafting an illusion of a cause of action is created.
These principles are well settled by a catena of decisions. (T.
5
Arivandandam vs T. V. Satyapal & Another, The Church of Christ
Charitable Trust & Educational Charitable Society, represented by its
Chairman Vs. M/s Ponniamman Educational Trust represented by its
6
Chairperson/Managing Trustee and Dahiben Vs. Arvindbhai Kalyanji
7
Bhanusali (Gajra) (d) Thru L.Rs. & Ors. )
14.
Evidently, the first ground of the plaint not disclosing a cause of
action was premised on late Hirabai not being the daughter of late
Ramchandra Galande. A contention was sought to be advanced before
the trial Court that since Geetabai had succeeded to the estate of late
Ramchandra Galande, even if the plaintiffs case was taken at par,
5 (1977) 4 SCC 467.
6
(2012) 8 SCC 706.
7
(2020) 7 SCC 366.
ARS 14/26
Uploaded on - 18/11/2026 Downloaded on - 18/11/2026 23:07:26
-CRA-356-2026.DOC
Hirabai could never be the heir of late Ramchandra Galande and,
therefore, she was not entitled to succeed to the estate of late
Ramchandra Galande. The said contention was justifiably repelled by the
learned Civil Judge.
15.
From perusal of the averments in the plaint, it becomes explicitly
clear that the plaintiffs case was that after the demise of late
Ramchandra Galande, the suit property devolved on Geetabai; the
widow, Dattatray; the son, and Satyabhama; the daughter of
Ramchandra Galande. Subsequently, there was a partition among
Geetabai, Dattatray and Satyabhama. Only the share of Satyabhama was
carved out and Geetbai and Dattatray continued to remain joint as is
st
evident from the Partition Deed dated 1 March 2000. During the
lifetime of Geetabai, there was no partition between her and Dattatray.
Therefore, after the demise of Geetabai, Hirabai; her daughter, could lay
claim over one half undivided share in the suit property on the premise
that she succeeded to the entire estate left behind by Geetabai.
16.
In the backdrop of these aforesaid facts, it becomes abundantly
clear that the plaintiffs claim does not rest on Hirabai being a heir of
Ramchandra Galande but is premised on Hirabai being the only
daughter of Geetabai and thus having succeeded to the estate left behind
by Geetabai, exclusively. In this situation, the source of the property
becomes inconsequential. What assumes significance is, whether
ARS 15/26
Uploaded on - 18/11/2026 Downloaded on - 18/11/2026 23:07:26
-CRA-356-2026.DOC
Geetabai had left behind any estate intestate and not the source from
which Geetabai had inherited the said estate.
17.
The expression “sons and daughters” under Section 15 (1)(a) of
the Hind Succession Act, 1956, simply means the sons and daughters
born to the female Hindu dying intestate, without any reference to the
husband by whom those sons and daughters, were born to her.
Therefore, the endeavour on the part of the applicants to link the
entitlement of Hirabai to succeed to the estate of Geetabai with the
source from which the property had devolved upon Geetabai, cannot be
countenanced.
18.
The reliance by Mr. Damle on a judgment of the Division Bench of
this Court in the case of Rama Ananda Patil (Supra) is well founded. In
the said case, the Division Bench considered the question, whether a son
by the first husband of a female Hindu is entitled to succeed to the
property on her death inherited by her from her second husband under
Section 15 of the Act, 1956.
19.
After a textual and contextual interpretation of the provisions
contained in Hindu Succession Act, 1956, the Division Bench concluded
that there was no warrant to assume that the legislature intended to
deprive the sons and daughters or their children from inheritance of the
property left by a female Hindu dying intestate merely because they
ARS 16/26
Uploaded on - 18/11/2026 Downloaded on - 18/11/2026 23:07:26
-CRA-356-2026.DOC
were born to her from some other husband than the one from whom the
property in dispute was inherited by the female Hindu.
20.
The Division Bench inter alia observed that the property
contemplated in Sub-Section (1) of Section 15 is all property held by
female Hindu at the time of her death without reference to the source
whether acquired by her either by her own learning and exertions or by
a gift or under a Will or by inheritance from some relatives other than
those referred to in Clauses (a) and (b) of Sub-Section (2) of Section 15.
The sources of the acquisition of the property by a female Hindu could
be diverse and any of her husbands may not have any connection even
directly or indirectly with such acquisitions. The sons and daughters
referred to in Clause (a) of Sub-Section (1) of Section 15, therefore, can
mean her sons and daughters born to her from any of her husband.
21.
The aforesaid being the position in law and in the light of the
clear and categorical avermenrts in the plaint that Hirabai succeeded to
the estate left behind by Geetabai as her daughter, the plaint discloses a
clear cause of action. The learned Civil Judge was, therefore, will within
his rights in observing that the plaint did disclose a cause of action.
22.
On the aspect of the bar of limitation, the fulcrum of the
submission on behalf of the applicants was that the registered
instruments were executed by Geetabai, during her lifetime. Geetbai had
executed two testamentary instruments bequeathing the properties to
ARS 17/26
Uploaded on - 18/11/2026 Downloaded on - 18/11/2026 23:07:26
-CRA-356-2026.DOC
th
Dattatray. Geetbai had also executed five Sale Deeds on 29 December
2000 alongwith late Dattatray and his family members. Subsequently,
registered Development Agreement and Power of Attorney were
th
executed on 13 August 2002, and, thereafter Deed of Assignment and
Power of Attorney were executed by defendant No.11 in favour of
defeated No.13, the applicant herein. Though Hirabai passed away after
23 years of the demise of Geetabai, during her lifetime Hirabai never
challenged any of the aforesaid registered instruments nor sought
partition of the suit properties on the premise that she succeeded to the
one half share of Geetabai. Registered instruments constitute a
constructive and public notice. Therefore, the learned Civil Judge ought
not to have considered the self-serving averments in the plaint that the
plaintiffs became aware of those instruments in the year 2025.
23.
Mr. Godbole would urge that the decision in the case of Kumar
Beharay Properties LLP, through its Authorized Signatory (Supra) is on
all the four with the facts of the case at hand as in that case as well, the
suit was instituted after a decade of the demise of the father of the
plaintiffs therein. In the said case, this Court, after following the decision
8
of the Supreme Court in the case of Uma Devi Vs Anand Kumar and
applying the principle therein to the facts in that case, observed that the
plaintiff was attempting to reignite the case after his father who had
notice of the registered instruments slept over the same during his
nd
8
SLP (C) No. 2137 of 2025 decided on 2 April 2025.
ARS 18/26
Uploaded on - 18/11/2026 Downloaded on - 18/11/2026 23:07:26
-CRA-356-2026.DOC
lifetime for 24 long years. The father of the plaintiffs therein had not
challenged the registered instruments and thus the suit instituted by the
plaintiff after the death of his father was clearly barred by law of
limitation.
24.
There can be no quarrel with the proposition of law that where it
is evident from the averments in the plaint that the suit is hopelessly
barred by law of limitation, plaint can be rejected under Order VII Rule
11 of the Code, irrespective of the fact that the issue of limitation is
generally a mixed question of law and fact and has to be decided after
appraisal of evidence (Shri Mukund Bhavan Trust and Ors. V/s.
Shrimant Chhatrapati Udayan Raje Pratapsinh Maharaj Bhonsle and
9
Anr ). However, to invoke the provisions contained in Clause (d) of
Order VII Rule 11, to reject the plaint at the threshold on the ground
that it is barred by law of limitation, the Court after perusal of the
averments in the plaint and the documents annexed thereto, ought to be
in a position to draw an exonerable inference that the suit is ex-facie
barred by law of limitation. Generally, the question of limitation is a
mixed question of fact and law and warrants adjudication at the trial. It
is equally well-settled that the bar of limitation ought to be self-evident
from the averments in the plaint and the documents annexed thereto
and the defence raised by the defendant, is not at all germane at that
stage.
9
2024 (15) SCC 675.
ARS 19/26
Uploaded on - 18/11/2026 Downloaded on - 18/11/2026 23:07:26
-CRA-356-2026.DOC
25.
The learned Civil Judge was of the view that from the perusal of
the averments in the plaint, it prima facie appeared that the knowledge
about the aforesaid registered instruments was obtained by the plaintiffs
in the year 2025, after they were prohibited from conducting business
from the suit properties. Conversely, it did not became evident from the
averments in the plaint that the plaintiffs had knowledge about the said
instrument at a prior point in time.
26.
The aforesaid view of the learned Civil Judge cannot be said to be
in dissonance with the law. The knowledge about the essential facts
which gives rise to cause of action to seek declaration, actual or
constructive, ought to be discernible from the averments in the plaint
and the documents annexed thereto. In all cases where the challenge is
to the registered instruments, it cannot be laid down an immutable rule
of law that the person challenging those instruments must be deemed to
have knowledge about the same from the date of registration. The
attendant facts and circumstances bear upon the aspect of knowledge.
27.
In the case of Daliben Valjibhai and Ors (Supra), on which
reliance was placed by Mr. Shah, the Supreme Court did not approve
the view of the High Court that in cases where the document was
registered, the knowledge must be presumed from the date of
registration. The Supreme Court, after adverting to the earlier
10
precedents in the cases of P. V. Guru Rai Reddy Vs P. Neeradha Reddy
10
(2015) 8 SCC 331.
ARS 20/26
Uploaded on - 18/11/2026 Downloaded on - 18/11/2026 23:07:26
-CRA-356-2026.DOC
11
and Chhotanben Vs Kirtibhai Jalkrushnabhai Thakkar concluded that
the High Court was not justified in holding that the limitation period
commenced from the date of registration. The observations of the
Supreme Court, in paragraphs 10 to 13 read as under:
“10. The First Appellate Court came to the conclusion that the
defendants made an application for correcting the revenue
records only in the year 2017 and on the said application the
Deputy Collector issued notice to the plaintiffs in March 2017 and
that was the time when the plaintiffs came to know about the
execution of the sale deed. It is under these circumstances that
the suit was instituted in the year 2017. While the High Court
came to the correct conclusion that under Article 59 of the
Limitation Act, a suit can be instituted within 3 years of the
knowledge, it proceeded to return a finding that in cases where
the document is registered, the knowledge must be presumed
from the date of registration.
11. This Court had to deal with a similar situation in P. V. Guru
Rai Reddy (Supra). A suit instituted by the plaintiff in the year
2002 for cancellation of sale deed of year 1979 on the ground
that the knowledge of fraud was acquired only in 1999, was
objected to by the defendant in an application under Order 7 Rule
11 on the ground that it is barred by limitation. This Court held:
“5. Rejection of the plaint under Order 7 Rule 11 of CPC
is a drastic power conferred in the court to terminate a
civil action at the threshold. The conditions precedent to
11
(2018) 6 SCC 422.
ARS 21/26
Uploaded on - 18/11/2026 Downloaded on - 18/11/2026 23:07:26
-CRA-356-2026.DOC
the exercise of power under Order 7 Rule 11, therefore,
are stringent and have been consistently held to be so by
the Court. It is the averments in the plaint that have to
be read as a whole to find out whether it discloses a
cause of action or whether the suit is barred under any
law. At the stage of exercise of power under Order 7
Rule 11, the stand of the defendants in the written
statement or in the application for rejection of the plaint
is wholly immaterial. It is only if the averments in the
plaint ex facie do not disclose a cause of action or on a
reading thereof the suit appears to be barred under any
law the plaint can be rejected. In all other situations, the
claims will have to be adjudicated in the course of the
trial.
6. In the present case, reading the plaint as a
whole and proceeding on the basis that the averments
made therein are correct, which is what the Court is
required to do, it cannot be said that the said pleadings
ex facie disclose that the suit is barred by limitation or is
barred under any other provision of law. The claim of
the plaintiffs with regard to the knowledge of the
essential facts giving rise to the cause of action as
pleaded will have to be accepted as correct. At the stage
of consideration of the application under Order 7 Rule
11 the stand of the defendants in the written statement
would be altogether irrelevant.”
12. Further, in Chhotanben (Supra) where again a suit for
cancellation of sale deed was opposed through an application
under Order 7 Rule 11, on ground of limitation, this Court
ARS 22/26
Uploaded on - 18/11/2026 Downloaded on - 18/11/2026 23:07:26
-CRA-356-2026.DOC
specifically held that limitation in all such cases will arise from
date of knowledge. The relevant portion is as follows:
“15. What is relevant for answering the matter in issue
in the context of the application under Order 7 Rule
11(d) CPC, is to examine the averments in the plaint.
The plaint is required to be read as a whole. The
defence available to the defendants or the plea taken by
them in the written statement or any application filed
by them, cannot be the basis to decide the application
under Order 7 Rule 11(d). Only the averments in the
plaint are germane. It is common ground that the
registered sale deed is dated 18-10- 1996. The
limitation to challenge the registered sale deed
ordinarily would start running from the date on which
the sale deed was registered. However, the specific case
of the appellant- plaintiffs is that until 2013 they had
no knowledge whatsoever regarding execution of such
sale deed by their brothers, original Defendants 1 and
2, in favour of Jaikrishnabhai Prabhudas Thakkar or
Defendants 3 to 6. They acquired that knowledge on
26-12-2012 and immediately took steps to obtain a
certified copy of the registered sale deed and on receipt
thereof they realised the fraud played on them by their
brothers concerning the ancestral property and two
days prior to the filing of the suit, had approached their
brothers (original Defendants 1 and 2) calling upon
them to stop interfering with their possession and to
partition the property and provide exclusive possession
of half (½) portion of the land so designated towards
their share. However, when they realised that the
original Defendants 1 and 2 would not pay any heed to
ARS 23/26
Uploaded on - 18/11/2026 Downloaded on - 18/11/2026 23:07:26
-CRA-356-2026.DOC
their request, they had no other option but to approach
the court of law and filed the subject suit within two
days therefrom. According to the appellants, the suit
has been filed within time after acquiring the
knowledge about the execution of the registered sale
deed. In this context, the trial court opined that it was a
triable issue and declined to accept the application filed
by Respondent 1-Defendant 5 for rejection of the plaint
under Order 7 Rule 11(d). That view commends to us.
… … …
19. In the present case, we find that the appellant-
plaintiffs have asserted that the suit was filed
immediately after getting knowledge about the
fraudulent sale deed executed by original Defendants 1
and 2 by keeping them in the dark about such
execution and within two days from the refusal by the
original Defendants 1 and 2 to refrain from obstructing
the peaceful enjoyment of use and possession of the
ancestral property of the appellants. We affirm the view
taken by the trial court that the issue regarding the suit
being barred by limitation in the facts of the present
case, is a triable issue and for which reason the plaint
cannot be rejected at the threshold in exercise of the
power under Order 7 Rule 11(d)CPC.”
13. In view of the above, there was no justification for the High
Court in allowing the application under Order 7 Rule 11, on
issues that were not evident from the plaint averments itself. The
High Court was also not justified in holding that the limitation
period commences from the date of registration itself. In this view
of the matter the judgment of the High Court is unsustainable.”
ARS 24/26
Uploaded on - 18/11/2026 Downloaded on - 18/11/2026 23:07:26
-CRA-356-2026.DOC
28.
In the case of P. V. Guru Rai Reddy (Supra), the Supreme Court
has enunciated in clear and explicit terms that the claim of the plaintiff
with regard to the knowledge of the essential facts giving rise to the
cause of action as pleaded will have to be accepted as correct.
29.
If the averments in the plaint in regard to the knowledge of the
plaintiffs of the aforesaid registered instruments are appraised in the
light of the aforesaid principles, the view of the trial Court appears
justifiable.
30.
In any event, the plaintiffs are seeking partition and separate
possession of their share in the suit properties. The said relief, cannot be
said to be barred by law of limitation. It is trite, even if one relief
survives, the plaint cannot be rejected as partial rejection of the plaint is
impermissible. Thus, no interference is warranted with the impugned
order.
31.
It is, however, necessary to clarify that the aforesaid observations
or for that matter the observations in the impugned order, were confined
to determine the prayer for rejection of the plaint and the trial Court
shall adjudicate the issue of limitation without being influenced by the
observations in paragraphs 37 and 38 of the impugned order that all the
reliefs in the plaint appeared to have been sought well within the
limitation and were not barred by law of limitation.
ARS 25/26
Uploaded on - 18/11/2026 Downloaded on - 18/11/2026 23:07:26
-CRA-356-2026.DOC
32.
Hence, the following order:
: O R D E R :
Civil Revision Application stands rejected.
No costs.
[N. J. JAMADAR, J.]
ARS 26/26
Uploaded on - 18/11/2026 Downloaded on - 18/11/2026 23:07:26
Powered by TCPDF (www.tcpdf.org)