SURENDRA DUTT BIJALWAN vs STATE OF UTTARAKHAND
- Court
- Uttarakhand High Court
UKHC010056652025
2026:UHC:10399-DB
HIGH COURT OF UTTARAKHAND AT NAINITAL
Writ Petition Service Bench No. 121 of 2025
HON’BLE SRI MANOJ KUMAR TIWARI
AND
HON’BLE SRI JUSTICE SUBHASH UPADHYAY
16 November, 2026
Surendra Dutt Bijalwan & another … Petitioners
Versus
State Of Uttarakhand & others … Respondents
-------------------------------------------------------------------
Presence:-
Mr. C.D. Bahuguna, learned Senior Counsel assisted by Mr. C.S.
Dalakoti, learned counsel for the petitioners.
Mr. J.C. Pande, learned Standing Counsel for the State of Uttarakhand.
Mr. C.S. Rawat, Advocate with Ms. Rajni Supyal Latwal, learned
counsel for respondent no. 4.
-------------------------------------------------------------------
Hon'ble Manoj Kumar Tiwari, ACJ
Hon'ble Subhash Upadhyay, J.
(Per: Hon’ble Manoj Kumar Tiwari, ACJ.)
JUDGMENT
1. This writ petition is filed challenging
judgment and order dated 06.03.2025 passed by
Uttarakhand Public Services Tribunal Bench at Nainital
in Claim Petition No. 68/NB/DB/2022. Operative portion
of the impugned judgment is reproduced below:-
“13. Based on the pleadings of both the parties and the
documents presented, we are of the opinion that the
petitioner was appointed on ad-hoc basis on 30/8/1989 on
the post of the Junior Clerk. He was reappointed by the
respondents on the order of the Hon’ble High Court, was
treated as on the job from the date of termination (on
30.06.1992) to his rejoining on 23.09.2002 for which he
was paid salary and other consequential benefits also.
14. By the order of the Hon’ble High Court, the ad-hoc
service of the petitioner from date of his initial appointment
on 30/8/1989 till date of regularization on 28.01.2013 has
become continuous. The respondents have considered this
period for grant of ACP also. The order of regularization
mentions that the seniority of the petitioner will count from
the date of his regularization and the respondents did not
accept the representation for granting the seniority from his
date of adhoc appointment.
1
UKHC010056652025
2026:UHC:10399-DB
15. The judgment of this Tribunal in the matter of Mohan
Singh vs State of Uttarakhand is not applicable in this case,
as it deals with seniority of the persons who were appointed
on the different dated but regularized from the same date
by different orders. Here the petitioner and private
respondents were regularized from different dates by
different orders.
16. The judgment as cited by the petitioner in the case of
State of Haryana & Ors vs. Devi Lal (supra) is applicable in
the case of the petitioner, as petitioner has worked
continuously w.e.f. 30/8/1989 till his regularization.
17. On the basis of the above, we hold that the
impugned order dated 06.08.2022 is liable to be modified
treating the seniority of the petitioner from 30.08.1989, the
date of his initial appointment and the seniority list dated
06.08.2022 is liable to be modified to the extent that the
petitioner is placed at Sl. No. 4 above Shri Rajendra Prasad
Pant.
ORDER
The impugned order dated 06.08.2022 is hereby
modified treating the seniority of the petitioner from
30.08.1989, the date of his initial appointment. Accordingly,
the respondents are directed to modify the impugned
seniority list dated 06.08.2022, placing the petitioner at Sl.
No 4 above Sri Rajendra Prasad Pant. No order as to costs.”
2. Learned Senior Counsel appearing for the
petitioners submits that respondent no. 4 was given
ad-hoc appointment as Junior Clerk in the year 1989;
his services were terminated vide order dated
30.06.1992 but he was reinstated in service pursuant
to interim order passed by this Court in WPSS No. 6614
of 2001 ( old number WPSS No. 5996 of 1996 ); his
services were regularized on 28.01.2013 under
Regularisation Rules, 2011 framed by State of
Uttarakhand.
3. Learned Senior Counsel further submits that
respondent no. 4 never challenged his regularization
effective from 28.01.2013 or the stipulation made in
the regularisation order; after more than nine years of
his regularization, he approached Uttarakhand Public
2
UKHC010056652025
2026:UHC:10399-DB
Services Tribunal claiming seniority for the past
services rendered before regularization as ad-hoc
employee and learned Tribunal allowed the claim
petition by ignoring Rule 10 of the Regularisation Rules.
4. Rule 10 of the Regularisation Rules, 2011 is
pari materia to Rule 10 of Regularisation Rules, 2013
which provides that a regularized employee will be
entitled to seniority only from the date he assumes
charge of the post/cadre after regularization and he
shall be placed in the seniority list below the
substantively appointed employees serving in that
post/cadre.
5. Learned Tribunal has held that since benefit
of ad-hoc service was given to respondent no. 4 for
ACP, therefore, he is entitled to seniority for the entire
service period, including those rendered in ad-hoc
capacity.
6. ACP is governed by Executive Instructions,
while seniority is governed by Statutory Rules framed
under proviso to Article 309 of the Constitution. Merely
because the service rendered by respondent no. 4 in
ad-hoc capacity was taken into account for grant of ACP
will not entitle him for seniority, unless the Seniority
Rules so provide.
7. Rule 10 of the Regularisation Rules, 2011
unequivocally provides that upon regularization, a
regularized employee shall be entitled to seniority only
from the date of assuming charge, after regularization.
It further provides that a regularized employee shall be
3
UKHC010056652025
2026:UHC:10399-DB
placed in the seniority list below existing members of
service. This aspect, however, was completely
overlooked by learned Tribunal.
8. Learned Tribunal has not indicated any
reason for modifying the seniority list. In para 12 of the
impugned judgment, contention of learned State
Counsel based on Rule 10 of Regularisation Rules is
noted, however, the same has not been dealt with in
the impugned judgment. Learned Tribunal has relied
upon a judgment rendered by Hon’ble High Court of
Punjab & Haryana rendered in the case of State of
Haryana & others vs Devi Lal , which is distinguishable
on facts.
9. An ad-hoc employee does not automatically
get seniority from the date of initial appointment,
unless the regularization order so provides.
Regularisation Order dated 28.01.2013 provides that
three persons, including respondent no. 4, shall stand
regularized with immediate effect. Respondent no. 4
did not challenge the said stipulation made in the
regularization order before any judicial forum. After
accepting the benefit of regularization, with the
condition attached therewith, respondent no. 4
challenged the seniority list by contending that he was
entitled to seniority from the date of his initial
appointment.
10. Learned Tribunal, by ignoring the stipulation
made in the regularization order that regularization
shall be effective from 28.01.2013, allowed the claim
4
UKHC010056652025
2026:UHC:10399-DB
petition, without adverting to Rule 10(1) of the
Regularisation Rules. Thus, the impugned judgment is
interferable.
11. In the case of Shyam Sunder Oberoi & others
vs. District & Sessions Judge, Tis Hazari Courts,
reported as 2022 (3) SCC 197 , Hon’ble Supreme Court
while dealing with the issue of inter se seniority
between direct recruits vis-à-vis employees, who were
regularized on the post of Lower Division Clerk, held as
under:-
“ 17. We consider it appropriate to observe that the
employees who were appointed on ad hoc basis and qualified
typing test at the later stage, in absence of the scheme of
rules in determining seniority, at least could not have a right
to march over such of the employees who were appointed on
substantive basis after going through the process of selection
for holding regular selection and their right of seniority in no
manner be relegated qua such of the ad hoc employees who
qualified typing test at a later stage and regularised
subsequently from the date of initial appointment like in the
instant case by an Order dated 17-11-2000.”
12. Similarly in the case of Rashi Mani Mishra &
others vs State of Uttar Pradesh & others, reported as
(2021) 17 SCC 399 , Hon’ble Supreme Court held as
under:-
“ 22. As per Rule 21 of the 1993 Rules, the seniority of
persons substantively appointed to a post in the service
shall be determined in accordance with the Uttar Pradesh
Government Servants' Seniority Rules, 1991, as amended
from time to time. Even as per the Service Rules, 1993,
“substantive appointment” means an appointment, not
being an ad hoc appointment, on a post in the cadre of the
service… . As per Seniority Rules, 1991, which also defines
the “substantive appointment” as per Rule 4(h), the
seniority shall be counted only from the date of their
“substantive appointment”. In the present case, Seniority
Rules clearly provide that seniority in any category or cadre
post shall be determined from the date of order of
“substantive appointment”. As observed and held by this
Court in Santosh Kumar [Santosh Kumar v. G.R. Chawla,
(2003) 10 SCC 513 : 2004 SCC (L&S) 329] , ad hoc
appointments cannot be deemed to be substantive
5
UKHC010056652025
2026:UHC:10399-DB
appointments. Even the definition of “substantive
appointment” under the Service Rules, 1993 and the
Seniority Rules, 1991, referred to hereinabove, is very clear
and the service rendered as ad hoc cannot be treated as
“substantive appointment”.
23. The sum and substance of the above discussion would
be that on a fair reading of the 1979 Rules, extended from
time to time; initial appointment orders in the year 1985
and the subsequent order of regularisation in the year 1989
of the ad hoc appointees and on a fair reading of the
relevant Service Rules, namely, Service Rules, 1993 and the
Seniority Rules, 1991, our conclusion would be that the
services rendered by the ad hoc appointees prior to their
regularisation as per the 1979 Rules shall not be counted for
the purpose of seniority, vis-à-vis, the direct recruits who
were appointed prior to 1989 and they are not entitled to
seniority from the date of their initial appointment in the
year 1985. The resultant effect would be that the
subsequent redetermination of the seniority in the year
2016 cannot be sustained which was considering the
services rendered by ad hoc appointees prior to 1989 i.e.
from the date of their initial appointment in 1985. This
cannot be sustained and the same deserves to be quashed
and set aside and the seniority list of 2001 counting the
services rendered by ad hoc appointees from the date of
their regularisation in the year 1989 is to be restored.”
13. In the case of State of Haryana & others vs.
Vijay Singh & others, reported as (2012) 8 SCC 633 ,
Hon’ble Supreme Court, after considering the entire
case law on the point, has held as under:-
“30. None of the aforesaid judgments can be read as laying
down a proposition of law that a person who is appointed on
purely ad hoc basis for a fixed period by an authority other
than the one who is competent to make regular
appointment to the service and such appointment is not
made by the specified recruiting agency is entitled to have
his ad hoc service counted for the purpose of fixation of
seniority. Therefore, the respondents, who were appointed
as Masters in different subjects, Physical Training Instructor
and Hindi Teacher on purely ad hoc basis without following
the procedure prescribed under the 1955 Rules are not
entitled to have their seniority fixed on the basis of total
length of service. As a corollary to this, we hold that the
direction given by the High Court for refixation of the
respondents' seniority by counting the ad hoc service cannot
be approved.”
14. The view taken by learned Tribunal is
6
UKHC010056652025
2026:UHC:10399-DB
contrary to the settled law on the point and is thus
unsustainable.
15. Accordingly, the writ petition is allowed.
Judgment dated 06.03.2025 passed by learned
Uttarakhand Public Services Tribunal in Claim Petition
No. 68/NB/DB/2022 is set aside.
________________________________
MANOJ KUMAR TIWARI, ACJ
____________________________
SUBHASH UPADHYAY, J.
Dt: 16.11.2026
Aswal
NITI RAJ SINGH
ASWAL
Digitally signed by NITI RAJ SINGH ASWAL DN: c=IN, o=HIGH COURT OF UTTARAKHAND, ou=HIGH COURT OF UTTARAKHAND, 2.5.4.20=eacc6757ee7881e933ff8934f07477005aa85f9802a3a08b08d1369512ea30f3, postalCode=263001, st=UTTARAKHAND, serialNumber=44EB54CBF00B7698CB6F10C2CE3D26F5C22DACF4F4610C1FE58A58531726FBB0, cn=NITI RAJ SINGH ASWAL Date: 2026.11.17 20:55:06 -08'00'
7